diff --git a/.github/workflows/update_space.yml b/.github/workflows/update_space.yml new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..67dbc84e4e59320a7c98b94460eb976e5cd2984f --- /dev/null +++ b/.github/workflows/update_space.yml @@ -0,0 +1,28 @@ +name: Run Python script + +on: + push: + branches: + - main + +jobs: + build: + runs-on: ubuntu-latest + + steps: + - name: Checkout + uses: actions/checkout@v2 + + - name: Set up Python + uses: actions/setup-python@v2 + with: + python-version: '3.9' + + - name: Install Gradio + run: python -m pip install gradio + + - name: Log in to Hugging Face + run: python -c 'import huggingface_hub; huggingface_hub.login(token="${{ secrets.hf_token }}")' + + - name: Deploy to Spaces + run: gradio deploy diff --git a/.gitignore b/.gitignore new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..64370f3285b7edd39224b7d53b13adaf54b4be78 --- /dev/null +++ b/.gitignore @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +# created by virtualenv automatically +.venv +.env + diff --git a/.gradio/certificate.pem b/.gradio/certificate.pem new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b85c8037f6b60976b2546fdbae88312c5246d9a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/.gradio/certificate.pem @@ -0,0 +1,31 @@ +-----BEGIN CERTIFICATE----- +MIIFazCCA1OgAwIBAgIRAIIQz7DSQONZRGPgu2OCiwAwDQYJKoZIhvcNAQELBQAw +TzELMAkGA1UEBhMCVVMxKTAnBgNVBAoTIEludGVybmV0IFNlY3VyaXR5IFJlc2Vh +cmNoIEdyb3VwMRUwEwYDVQQDEwxJU1JHIFJvb3QgWDEwHhcNMTUwNjA0MTEwNDM4 +WhcNMzUwNjA0MTEwNDM4WjBPMQswCQYDVQQGEwJVUzEpMCcGA1UEChMgSW50ZXJu +ZXQgU2VjdXJpdHkgUmVzZWFyY2ggR3JvdXAxFTATBgNVBAMTDElTUkcgUm9vdCBY +MTCCAiIwDQYJKoZIhvcNAQEBBQADggIPADCCAgoCggIBAK3oJHP0FDfzm54rVygc +h77ct984kIxuPOZXoHj3dcKi/vVqbvYATyjb3miGbESTtrFj/RQSa78f0uoxmyF+ +0TM8ukj13Xnfs7j/EvEhmkvBioZxaUpmZmyPfjxwv60pIgbz5MDmgK7iS4+3mX6U +A5/TR5d8mUgjU+g4rk8Kb4Mu0UlXjIB0ttov0DiNewNwIRt18jA8+o+u3dpjq+sW +T8KOEUt+zwvo/7V3LvSye0rgTBIlDHCNAymg4VMk7BPZ7hm/ELNKjD+Jo2FR3qyH +B5T0Y3HsLuJvW5iB4YlcNHlsdu87kGJ55tukmi8mxdAQ4Q7e2RCOFvu396j3x+UC +B5iPNgiV5+I3lg02dZ77DnKxHZu8A/lJBdiB3QW0KtZB6awBdpUKD9jf1b0SHzUv +KBds0pjBqAlkd25HN7rOrFleaJ1/ctaJxQZBKT5ZPt0m9STJEadao0xAH0ahmbWn +OlFuhjuefXKnEgV4We0+UXgVCwOPjdAvBbI+e0ocS3MFEvzG6uBQE3xDk3SzynTn +jh8BCNAw1FtxNrQHusEwMFxIt4I7mKZ9YIqioymCzLq9gwQbooMDQaHWBfEbwrbw +qHyGO0aoSCqI3Haadr8faqU9GY/rOPNk3sgrDQoo//fb4hVC1CLQJ13hef4Y53CI +rU7m2Ys6xt0nUW7/vGT1M0NPAgMBAAGjQjBAMA4GA1UdDwEB/wQEAwIBBjAPBgNV +HRMBAf8EBTADAQH/MB0GA1UdDgQWBBR5tFnme7bl5AFzgAiIyBpY9umbbjANBgkq +hkiG9w0BAQsFAAOCAgEAVR9YqbyyqFDQDLHYGmkgJykIrGF1XIpu+ILlaS/V9lZL +ubhzEFnTIZd+50xx+7LSYK05qAvqFyFWhfFQDlnrzuBZ6brJFe+GnY+EgPbk6ZGQ +3BebYhtF8GaV0nxvwuo77x/Py9auJ/GpsMiu/X1+mvoiBOv/2X/qkSsisRcOj/KK +NFtY2PwByVS5uCbMiogziUwthDyC3+6WVwW6LLv3xLfHTjuCvjHIInNzktHCgKQ5 +ORAzI4JMPJ+GslWYHb4phowim57iaztXOoJwTdwJx4nLCgdNbOhdjsnvzqvHu7Ur +TkXWStAmzOVyyghqpZXjFaH3pO3JLF+l+/+sKAIuvtd7u+Nxe5AW0wdeRlN8NwdC +jNPElpzVmbUq4JUagEiuTDkHzsxHpFKVK7q4+63SM1N95R1NbdWhscdCb+ZAJzVc +oyi3B43njTOQ5yOf+1CceWxG1bQVs5ZufpsMljq4Ui0/1lvh+wjChP4kqKOJ2qxq +4RgqsahDYVvTH9w7jXbyLeiNdd8XM2w9U/t7y0Ff/9yi0GE44Za4rF2LN9d11TPA +mRGunUHBcnWEvgJBQl9nJEiU0Zsnvgc/ubhPgXRR4Xq37Z0j4r7g1SgEEzwxA57d +emyPxgcYxn/eR44/KJ4EBs+lVDR3veyJm+kXQ99b21/+jh5Xos1AnX5iItreGCc= +-----END CERTIFICATE----- diff --git a/.idea/.gitignore b/.idea/.gitignore new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..13566b81b018ad684f3a35fee301741b2734c8f4 --- /dev/null +++ b/.idea/.gitignore @@ -0,0 +1,8 @@ +# Default ignored files +/shelf/ +/workspace.xml +# Editor-based HTTP Client requests +/httpRequests/ +# Datasource local storage ignored files +/dataSources/ +/dataSources.local.xml diff --git a/.idea/ibfs_project.iml b/.idea/ibfs_project.iml new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2c80e1269497d12e018fd6afa29982e56b0fb70d --- /dev/null +++ b/.idea/ibfs_project.iml @@ -0,0 +1,10 @@ + + + + + + + + + + \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.idea/inspectionProfiles/Project_Default.xml b/.idea/inspectionProfiles/Project_Default.xml new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a0c1d180c50de4a6a65068ccfd4970bd16a85dc1 --- /dev/null +++ b/.idea/inspectionProfiles/Project_Default.xml @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ + + + + \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.idea/inspectionProfiles/profiles_settings.xml b/.idea/inspectionProfiles/profiles_settings.xml new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..105ce2da2d6447d11dfe32bfb846c3d5b199fc99 --- /dev/null +++ b/.idea/inspectionProfiles/profiles_settings.xml @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ + + + + \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.idea/misc.xml b/.idea/misc.xml new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7c7bbecf4eeb1a6cb40556734a5e6389f0e8ef2d --- /dev/null +++ b/.idea/misc.xml @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ + + + + + + \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.idea/modules.xml b/.idea/modules.xml new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8a77611eefff9d784b2ca0c2bc9f89784fe62d6c --- /dev/null +++ b/.idea/modules.xml @@ -0,0 +1,8 @@ + + + + + + + + \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.idea/vcs.xml b/.idea/vcs.xml new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..94a25f7f4cb416c083d265558da75d457237d671 --- /dev/null +++ b/.idea/vcs.xml @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ + + + + + + \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.idea/workspace.xml b/.idea/workspace.xml new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..042aded0532bfebe02e5b9c44bb553e77ec33b35 --- /dev/null +++ b/.idea/workspace.xml @@ -0,0 +1,284 @@ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + { + "lastFilter": { + "state": "OPEN", + "assignee": "josh-ashkinaze" + } +} + { + "selectedUrlAndAccountId": { + "url": "https://github.com/josh-ashkinaze/ibfs_project.git", + "accountId": "67c5aa1d-9f62-44e5-af08-3ca11051ec38" + } +} + { + "associatedIndex": 4 +} + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + 1741892070040 + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/.ipynb_checkpoints/Untitled-checkpoint.ipynb b/.ipynb_checkpoints/Untitled-checkpoint.ipynb new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..363fcab7ed6e9634e198cf5555ceb88932c9a245 --- /dev/null +++ b/.ipynb_checkpoints/Untitled-checkpoint.ipynb @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +{ + "cells": [], + "metadata": {}, + "nbformat": 4, + "nbformat_minor": 5 +} diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index ab7161d94c1116f34895f5d64f443c30a3719ece..e6f45481358d5ac0eadeda56b9de9534b9186d14 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -1,12 +1,6 @@ --- -title: Ibfs Demo -emoji: 🐢 -colorFrom: pink -colorTo: pink -sdk: gradio -sdk_version: 5.22.0 +title: ibfs_demo app_file: app.py -pinned: false +sdk: gradio +sdk_version: 5.20.1 --- - -Check out the configuration reference at https://huggingface.co/docs/hub/spaces-config-reference diff --git a/Untitled.ipynb b/Untitled.ipynb new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..733d0e566db29aa501fa19827d9e9e30c686280e --- /dev/null +++ b/Untitled.ipynb @@ -0,0 +1,1799 @@ +{ + "cells": [ + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": 4, + "id": "84aba5f9-77d5-4638-9121-f85a21c0f6c4", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [ + { + "name": "stdout", + "output_type": "stream", + "text": [ + "Loading data from experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_all_results.json...\n", + "Loaded 16 valid results\n", + "Analysis results will be saved to analysis_output_exp_20250319_141119\n" + ] + }, + { + "ename": "TypeError", + "evalue": "Object of type int64 is not JSON serializable", + "output_type": "error", + "traceback": [ + "\u001b[31m---------------------------------------------------------------------------\u001b[39m", + "\u001b[31mTypeError\u001b[39m Traceback (most recent call last)", + "\u001b[36mCell\u001b[39m\u001b[36m \u001b[39m\u001b[32mIn[4]\u001b[39m\u001b[32m, line 468\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 464\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28mprint\u001b[39m(\u001b[33mf\u001b[39m\u001b[33m\"\u001b[39m\u001b[33mAnalysis complete. Results saved to \u001b[39m\u001b[38;5;132;01m{\u001b[39;00moutput_dir\u001b[38;5;132;01m}\u001b[39;00m\u001b[33m\"\u001b[39m)\n\u001b[32m 465\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mreturn\u001b[39;00m output_dir\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m468\u001b[39m \u001b[43mperform_full_analysis\u001b[49m\u001b[43m(\u001b[49m\u001b[33;43m\"\u001b[39;49m\u001b[33;43mexperiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_all_results.json\u001b[39;49m\u001b[33;43m\"\u001b[39;49m\u001b[43m)\u001b[49m\n", + "\u001b[36mCell\u001b[39m\u001b[36m \u001b[39m\u001b[32mIn[4]\u001b[39m\u001b[32m, line 426\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36mperform_full_analysis\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(input_file)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 408\u001b[39m basic_stats = {\n\u001b[32m 409\u001b[39m \u001b[33m'\u001b[39m\u001b[33mtotal_simulations\u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m: \u001b[38;5;28mlen\u001b[39m(df),\n\u001b[32m 410\u001b[39m \u001b[33m'\u001b[39m\u001b[33mparameter_ranges\u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m: {\n\u001b[32m (...)\u001b[39m\u001b[32m 422\u001b[39m }\n\u001b[32m 423\u001b[39m }\n\u001b[32m 425\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mwith\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;28mopen\u001b[39m(os.path.join(output_dir, \u001b[33m'\u001b[39m\u001b[33mbasic_stats.json\u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m), \u001b[33m'\u001b[39m\u001b[33mw\u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m) \u001b[38;5;28;01mas\u001b[39;00m f:\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m426\u001b[39m \u001b[43mjson\u001b[49m\u001b[43m.\u001b[49m\u001b[43mdump\u001b[49m\u001b[43m(\u001b[49m\u001b[43mbasic_stats\u001b[49m\u001b[43m,\u001b[49m\u001b[43m \u001b[49m\u001b[43mf\u001b[49m\u001b[43m,\u001b[49m\u001b[43m \u001b[49m\u001b[43mindent\u001b[49m\u001b[43m=\u001b[49m\u001b[32;43m2\u001b[39;49m\u001b[43m)\u001b[49m\n\u001b[32m 428\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;66;03m# Create visualizations\u001b[39;00m\n\u001b[32m 429\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28mprint\u001b[39m(\u001b[33m\"\u001b[39m\u001b[33mGenerating visualizations...\u001b[39m\u001b[33m\"\u001b[39m)\n", + "\u001b[36mFile \u001b[39m\u001b[32m/Library/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.12/lib/python3.12/json/__init__.py:179\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36mdump\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(obj, fp, skipkeys, ensure_ascii, check_circular, allow_nan, cls, indent, separators, default, sort_keys, **kw)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 173\u001b[39m iterable = \u001b[38;5;28mcls\u001b[39m(skipkeys=skipkeys, ensure_ascii=ensure_ascii,\n\u001b[32m 174\u001b[39m check_circular=check_circular, allow_nan=allow_nan, indent=indent,\n\u001b[32m 175\u001b[39m separators=separators,\n\u001b[32m 176\u001b[39m default=default, sort_keys=sort_keys, **kw).iterencode(obj)\n\u001b[32m 177\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;66;03m# could accelerate with writelines in some versions of Python, at\u001b[39;00m\n\u001b[32m 178\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;66;03m# a debuggability cost\u001b[39;00m\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m179\u001b[39m \u001b[43m\u001b[49m\u001b[38;5;28;43;01mfor\u001b[39;49;00m\u001b[43m \u001b[49m\u001b[43mchunk\u001b[49m\u001b[43m \u001b[49m\u001b[38;5;129;43;01min\u001b[39;49;00m\u001b[43m \u001b[49m\u001b[43miterable\u001b[49m\u001b[43m:\u001b[49m\n\u001b[32m 180\u001b[39m \u001b[43m \u001b[49m\u001b[43mfp\u001b[49m\u001b[43m.\u001b[49m\u001b[43mwrite\u001b[49m\u001b[43m(\u001b[49m\u001b[43mchunk\u001b[49m\u001b[43m)\u001b[49m\n", + "\u001b[36mFile \u001b[39m\u001b[32m/Library/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.12/lib/python3.12/json/encoder.py:432\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36m_make_iterencode.._iterencode\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(o, _current_indent_level)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 430\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01myield from\u001b[39;00m _iterencode_list(o, _current_indent_level)\n\u001b[32m 431\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01melif\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;28misinstance\u001b[39m(o, \u001b[38;5;28mdict\u001b[39m):\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m432\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01myield from\u001b[39;00m _iterencode_dict(o, _current_indent_level)\n\u001b[32m 433\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01melse\u001b[39;00m:\n\u001b[32m 434\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mif\u001b[39;00m markers \u001b[38;5;129;01mis\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;129;01mnot\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;28;01mNone\u001b[39;00m:\n", + "\u001b[36mFile \u001b[39m\u001b[32m/Library/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.12/lib/python3.12/json/encoder.py:406\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36m_make_iterencode.._iterencode_dict\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(dct, _current_indent_level)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 404\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01melse\u001b[39;00m:\n\u001b[32m 405\u001b[39m chunks = _iterencode(value, _current_indent_level)\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m406\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01myield from\u001b[39;00m chunks\n\u001b[32m 407\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mif\u001b[39;00m newline_indent \u001b[38;5;129;01mis\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;129;01mnot\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;28;01mNone\u001b[39;00m:\n\u001b[32m 408\u001b[39m _current_indent_level -= \u001b[32m1\u001b[39m\n", + "\u001b[36mFile \u001b[39m\u001b[32m/Library/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.12/lib/python3.12/json/encoder.py:406\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36m_make_iterencode.._iterencode_dict\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(dct, _current_indent_level)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 404\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01melse\u001b[39;00m:\n\u001b[32m 405\u001b[39m chunks = _iterencode(value, _current_indent_level)\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m406\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01myield from\u001b[39;00m chunks\n\u001b[32m 407\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mif\u001b[39;00m newline_indent \u001b[38;5;129;01mis\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;129;01mnot\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;28;01mNone\u001b[39;00m:\n\u001b[32m 408\u001b[39m _current_indent_level -= \u001b[32m1\u001b[39m\n", + "\u001b[36mFile \u001b[39m\u001b[32m/Library/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.12/lib/python3.12/json/encoder.py:326\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36m_make_iterencode.._iterencode_list\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(lst, _current_indent_level)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 324\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01melse\u001b[39;00m:\n\u001b[32m 325\u001b[39m chunks = _iterencode(value, _current_indent_level)\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m326\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01myield from\u001b[39;00m chunks\n\u001b[32m 327\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mif\u001b[39;00m newline_indent \u001b[38;5;129;01mis\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;129;01mnot\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;28;01mNone\u001b[39;00m:\n\u001b[32m 328\u001b[39m _current_indent_level -= \u001b[32m1\u001b[39m\n", + "\u001b[36mFile \u001b[39m\u001b[32m/Library/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.12/lib/python3.12/json/encoder.py:439\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36m_make_iterencode.._iterencode\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(o, _current_indent_level)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 437\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mraise\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;167;01mValueError\u001b[39;00m(\u001b[33m\"\u001b[39m\u001b[33mCircular reference detected\u001b[39m\u001b[33m\"\u001b[39m)\n\u001b[32m 438\u001b[39m markers[markerid] = o\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m439\u001b[39m o = \u001b[43m_default\u001b[49m\u001b[43m(\u001b[49m\u001b[43mo\u001b[49m\u001b[43m)\u001b[49m\n\u001b[32m 440\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01myield from\u001b[39;00m _iterencode(o, _current_indent_level)\n\u001b[32m 441\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mif\u001b[39;00m markers \u001b[38;5;129;01mis\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;129;01mnot\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;28;01mNone\u001b[39;00m:\n", + "\u001b[36mFile \u001b[39m\u001b[32m/Library/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.12/lib/python3.12/json/encoder.py:180\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36mJSONEncoder.default\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(self, o)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 161\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mdef\u001b[39;00m\u001b[38;5;250m \u001b[39m\u001b[34mdefault\u001b[39m(\u001b[38;5;28mself\u001b[39m, o):\n\u001b[32m 162\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;250m \u001b[39m\u001b[33;03m\"\"\"Implement this method in a subclass such that it returns\u001b[39;00m\n\u001b[32m 163\u001b[39m \u001b[33;03m a serializable object for ``o``, or calls the base implementation\u001b[39;00m\n\u001b[32m 164\u001b[39m \u001b[33;03m (to raise a ``TypeError``).\u001b[39;00m\n\u001b[32m (...)\u001b[39m\u001b[32m 178\u001b[39m \n\u001b[32m 179\u001b[39m \u001b[33;03m \"\"\"\u001b[39;00m\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m180\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mraise\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;167;01mTypeError\u001b[39;00m(\u001b[33mf\u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m\u001b[33mObject of type \u001b[39m\u001b[38;5;132;01m{\u001b[39;00mo.\u001b[34m__class__\u001b[39m.\u001b[34m__name__\u001b[39m\u001b[38;5;132;01m}\u001b[39;00m\u001b[33m \u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 181\u001b[39m \u001b[33mf\u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m\u001b[33mis not JSON serializable\u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m)\n", + "\u001b[31mTypeError\u001b[39m: Object of type int64 is not JSON serializable" + ] + } + ], + "source": [ + "import os\n", + "import json\n", + "import argparse\n", + "import numpy as np\n", + "import pandas as pd\n", + "import matplotlib.pyplot as plt\n", + "import seaborn as sns\n", + "from scipy import stats\n", + "from pathlib import Path\n", + "\n", + "def load_experiment_data(filename):\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " Load the experiment results from a JSON file.\n", + " \n", + " Args:\n", + " filename: Path to the results JSON file\n", + " \n", + " Returns:\n", + " Pandas DataFrame with the experiment results\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " print(f\"Loading data from {filename}...\")\n", + " \n", + " with open(filename, 'r') as f:\n", + " data = json.load(f)\n", + " \n", + " # Check if this is the all_results file directly\n", + " if isinstance(data, list) and len(data) > 0 and 'ibfs_config' in data[0]:\n", + " results = data\n", + " # Check if this is the experiment_id_analysis.json file\n", + " elif 'summary' in data:\n", + " # We need to find and load the corresponding all_results file\n", + " experiment_id = data.get('experiment_id')\n", + " base_dir = os.path.dirname(filename)\n", + " all_results_file = os.path.join(base_dir, f\"{experiment_id}_all_results.json\")\n", + " \n", + " if os.path.exists(all_results_file):\n", + " print(f\"Found associated all_results file: {all_results_file}\")\n", + " with open(all_results_file, 'r') as f:\n", + " results = json.load(f)\n", + " else:\n", + " # Need to reconstruct from individual simulation files\n", + " print(f\"No all_results file found. Reconstructing from individual simulation files...\")\n", + " results = []\n", + " for file in os.listdir(base_dir):\n", + " if file.startswith(experiment_id) and file.endswith(\".json\") and \"_sim_\" in file:\n", + " with open(os.path.join(base_dir, file), 'r') as f:\n", + " try:\n", + " sim_data = json.load(f)\n", + " results.append(sim_data)\n", + " except json.JSONDecodeError:\n", + " print(f\"Error loading {file} - skipping\")\n", + " else:\n", + " raise ValueError(\"Unrecognized file format. Please provide an experiment results file.\")\n", + " \n", + " # Filter out any results with errors\n", + " valid_results = [r for r in results if 'error' not in r]\n", + " \n", + " # Convert to DataFrame for easier analysis\n", + " rows = []\n", + " for result in valid_results:\n", + " # Extract the core configuration\n", + " row = {\n", + " 'query': result.get('query', ''),\n", + " 'similarity_score': result.get('similarity_score', 0),\n", + " 'diversity_level': result.get('ibfs_config', {}).get('diversity_level', ''),\n", + " 'branching_factor': result.get('ibfs_config', {}).get('branching_factor', 0),\n", + " 'max_depth': result.get('ibfs_config', {}).get('max_depth', 0),\n", + " 'epsilon': result.get('user_config', {}).get('epsilon', 0),\n", + " 'strategy_path': result.get('strategy_path', []),\n", + " 'path_length': len(result.get('strategy_path', [])),\n", + " 'experiment_id': result.get('experiment_id', '')\n", + " }\n", + " rows.append(row)\n", + " \n", + " df = pd.DataFrame(rows)\n", + " print(f\"Loaded {len(df)} valid results\")\n", + " return df\n", + "\n", + "def create_output_directory(experiment_id):\n", + " \"\"\"Create an output directory for analysis artifacts.\"\"\"\n", + " output_dir = f\"analysis_output_{experiment_id}\"\n", + " os.makedirs(output_dir, exist_ok=True)\n", + " return output_dir\n", + "\n", + "def plot_similarity_by_parameter(df, parameter, output_dir):\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " Create a box plot showing similarity scores grouped by a parameter.\n", + " \n", + " Args:\n", + " df: DataFrame with experiment results\n", + " parameter: The parameter to group by (e.g., 'diversity_level')\n", + " output_dir: Directory to save the plot\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(10, 6))\n", + " sns.boxplot(x=parameter, y='similarity_score', data=df)\n", + " plt.title(f'Similarity Scores by {parameter}')\n", + " plt.ylabel('Similarity Score')\n", + " plt.xlabel(parameter.replace('_', ' ').title())\n", + " plt.grid(axis='y', linestyle='--', alpha=0.7)\n", + " \n", + " # Save the figure\n", + " filename = os.path.join(output_dir, f'similarity_by_{parameter}.png')\n", + " plt.savefig(filename, dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight')\n", + " plt.close()\n", + " print(f\"Saved plot to {filename}\")\n", + "\n", + "def plot_parameter_interaction(df, param1, param2, output_dir):\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " Create a heatmap showing the interaction between two parameters.\n", + " \n", + " Args:\n", + " df: DataFrame with experiment results\n", + " param1: First parameter (e.g., 'branching_factor')\n", + " param2: Second parameter (e.g., 'max_depth')\n", + " output_dir: Directory to save the plot\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " # Group by both parameters and calculate mean similarity score\n", + " grouped = df.groupby([param1, param2])['similarity_score'].mean().reset_index()\n", + " pivot_table = grouped.pivot(index=param1, columns=param2, values='similarity_score')\n", + " \n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(10, 8))\n", + " sns.heatmap(pivot_table, annot=True, cmap='viridis', fmt='.3f', cbar_kws={'label': 'Avg Similarity Score'})\n", + " plt.title(f'Interaction between {param1} and {param2}')\n", + " plt.xlabel(param2.replace('_', ' ').title())\n", + " plt.ylabel(param1.replace('_', ' ').title())\n", + " \n", + " # Save the figure\n", + " filename = os.path.join(output_dir, f'interaction_{param1}_{param2}.png')\n", + " plt.savefig(filename, dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight')\n", + " plt.close()\n", + " print(f\"Saved plot to {filename}\")\n", + "\n", + "def run_statistical_tests(df, output_dir):\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " Run statistical tests to determine significant effects.\n", + " \n", + " Args:\n", + " df: DataFrame with experiment results\n", + " output_dir: Directory to save the results\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " test_results = {}\n", + " \n", + " # Test for effect of diversity level\n", + " if 'diversity_level' in df.columns and len(df['diversity_level'].unique()) > 1:\n", + " groups = [df[df['diversity_level'] == level]['similarity_score'].values \n", + " for level in df['diversity_level'].unique()]\n", + " \n", + " # ANOVA test if we have more than 2 groups\n", + " if len(groups) > 2:\n", + " f_stat, p_value = stats.f_oneway(*groups)\n", + " test_results['diversity_level_anova'] = {\n", + " 'test': 'ANOVA',\n", + " 'F_statistic': float(f_stat),\n", + " 'p_value': float(p_value),\n", + " 'significant': p_value < 0.05\n", + " }\n", + " # T-test if we have exactly 2 groups\n", + " elif len(groups) == 2:\n", + " t_stat, p_value = stats.ttest_ind(groups[0], groups[1], equal_var=False)\n", + " test_results['diversity_level_ttest'] = {\n", + " 'test': 't-test',\n", + " 'groups': list(df['diversity_level'].unique()),\n", + " 't_statistic': float(t_stat),\n", + " 'p_value': float(p_value),\n", + " 'significant': p_value < 0.05\n", + " }\n", + " \n", + " # Test for effect of branching factor\n", + " if 'branching_factor' in df.columns and len(df['branching_factor'].unique()) > 1:\n", + " groups = [df[df['branching_factor'] == b]['similarity_score'].values \n", + " for b in sorted(df['branching_factor'].unique())]\n", + " \n", + " if len(groups) > 2:\n", + " f_stat, p_value = stats.f_oneway(*groups)\n", + " test_results['branching_factor_anova'] = {\n", + " 'test': 'ANOVA',\n", + " 'F_statistic': float(f_stat),\n", + " 'p_value': float(p_value),\n", + " 'significant': p_value < 0.05\n", + " }\n", + " elif len(groups) == 2:\n", + " t_stat, p_value = stats.ttest_ind(groups[0], groups[1], equal_var=False)\n", + " test_results['branching_factor_ttest'] = {\n", + " 'test': 't-test',\n", + " 'groups': list(sorted(df['branching_factor'].unique())),\n", + " 't_statistic': float(t_stat),\n", + " 'p_value': float(p_value),\n", + " 'significant': p_value < 0.05\n", + " }\n", + " \n", + " # Test for effect of max depth\n", + " if 'max_depth' in df.columns and len(df['max_depth'].unique()) > 1:\n", + " groups = [df[df['max_depth'] == d]['similarity_score'].values \n", + " for d in sorted(df['max_depth'].unique())]\n", + " \n", + " if len(groups) > 2:\n", + " f_stat, p_value = stats.f_oneway(*groups)\n", + " test_results['max_depth_anova'] = {\n", + " 'test': 'ANOVA',\n", + " 'F_statistic': float(f_stat),\n", + " 'p_value': float(p_value),\n", + " 'significant': p_value < 0.05\n", + " }\n", + " elif len(groups) == 2:\n", + " t_stat, p_value = stats.ttest_ind(groups[0], groups[1], equal_var=False)\n", + " test_results['max_depth_ttest'] = {\n", + " 'test': 't-test',\n", + " 'groups': list(sorted(df['max_depth'].unique())),\n", + " 't_statistic': float(t_stat),\n", + " 'p_value': float(p_value),\n", + " 'significant': p_value < 0.05\n", + " }\n", + " \n", + " # Test for effect of epsilon\n", + " if 'epsilon' in df.columns and len(df['epsilon'].unique()) > 1:\n", + " groups = [df[df['epsilon'] == e]['similarity_score'].values \n", + " for e in sorted(df['epsilon'].unique())]\n", + " \n", + " if len(groups) > 2:\n", + " f_stat, p_value = stats.f_oneway(*groups)\n", + " test_results['epsilon_anova'] = {\n", + " 'test': 'ANOVA',\n", + " 'F_statistic': float(f_stat),\n", + " 'p_value': float(p_value),\n", + " 'significant': p_value < 0.05\n", + " }\n", + " elif len(groups) == 2:\n", + " t_stat, p_value = stats.ttest_ind(groups[0], groups[1], equal_var=False)\n", + " test_results['epsilon_ttest'] = {\n", + " 'test': 't-test',\n", + " 'groups': list(sorted(df['epsilon'].unique())),\n", + " 't_statistic': float(t_stat),\n", + " 'p_value': float(p_value),\n", + " 'significant': p_value < 0.05\n", + " }\n", + " \n", + " # Save the test results\n", + " with open(os.path.join(output_dir, 'statistical_tests.json'), 'w') as f:\n", + " json.dump(test_results, f, indent=2)\n", + " \n", + " # Also save a human-readable summary\n", + " with open(os.path.join(output_dir, 'statistical_tests_summary.txt'), 'w') as f:\n", + " f.write(\"Statistical Test Results Summary\\n\")\n", + " f.write(\"===============================\\n\\n\")\n", + " \n", + " for test_name, result in test_results.items():\n", + " f.write(f\"Test: {test_name}\\n\")\n", + " f.write(f\"Type: {result['test']}\\n\")\n", + " if 'groups' in result:\n", + " f.write(f\"Groups: {result['groups']}\\n\")\n", + " \n", + " if result['test'] == 'ANOVA':\n", + " f.write(f\"F-statistic: {result['F_statistic']:.4f}\\n\")\n", + " elif result['test'] == 't-test':\n", + " f.write(f\"t-statistic: {result['t_statistic']:.4f}\\n\")\n", + " \n", + " f.write(f\"p-value: {result['p_value']:.4f}\\n\")\n", + " f.write(f\"Significant: {result['significant']}\\n\\n\")\n", + " \n", + " print(f\"Saved statistical test results to {output_dir}\")\n", + " return test_results\n", + "\n", + "def plot_final_configs(df, output_dir):\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " Create visualizations of the best-performing configurations.\n", + " \n", + " Args:\n", + " df: DataFrame with experiment results\n", + " output_dir: Directory to save the plots\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " # Group by configuration and calculate mean similarity score\n", + " grouped = df.groupby(['diversity_level', 'branching_factor', 'max_depth', 'epsilon'])['similarity_score'].agg(['mean', 'std', 'count']).reset_index()\n", + " \n", + " # Sort by mean similarity score (descending)\n", + " grouped = grouped.sort_values('mean', ascending=False)\n", + " \n", + " # Plot top configurations\n", + " top_n = min(10, len(grouped))\n", + " top_configs = grouped.head(top_n)\n", + " \n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(12, 8))\n", + " \n", + " # Create labels for x-axis\n", + " config_labels = [f\"D:{row['diversity_level']}, B:{row['branching_factor']}, M:{row['max_depth']}, E:{row['epsilon']}\" \n", + " for _, row in top_configs.iterrows()]\n", + " \n", + " # Plot with error bars\n", + " plt.bar(range(top_n), top_configs['mean'], yerr=top_configs['std'], capsize=5, color='skyblue')\n", + " plt.xticks(range(top_n), config_labels, rotation=45, ha='right')\n", + " plt.ylabel('Mean Similarity Score')\n", + " plt.title(f'Top {top_n} Configurations by Mean Similarity Score')\n", + " plt.grid(axis='y', linestyle='--', alpha=0.7)\n", + " plt.tight_layout()\n", + " \n", + " # Save the figure\n", + " filename = os.path.join(output_dir, 'top_configurations.png')\n", + " plt.savefig(filename, dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight')\n", + " plt.close()\n", + " print(f\"Saved plot to {filename}\")\n", + "\n", + "def plot_query_performance(df, output_dir):\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " Create visualizations of performance across different queries.\n", + " \n", + " Args:\n", + " df: DataFrame with experiment results\n", + " output_dir: Directory to save the plots\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " # Check if we have multiple queries\n", + " if len(df['query'].unique()) <= 1:\n", + " print(\"Only one query found - skipping query performance analysis\")\n", + " return\n", + " \n", + " # For each query, find the best-performing configuration\n", + " query_results = []\n", + " \n", + " for query in df['query'].unique():\n", + " query_df = df[df['query'] == query]\n", + " \n", + " # Group by configuration\n", + " grouped = query_df.groupby(['diversity_level', 'branching_factor', 'max_depth', 'epsilon'])['similarity_score'].mean().reset_index()\n", + " \n", + " # Get the best configuration\n", + " best_config = grouped.loc[grouped['similarity_score'].idxmax()]\n", + " \n", + " query_results.append({\n", + " 'query': query,\n", + " 'best_config': {\n", + " 'diversity_level': best_config['diversity_level'],\n", + " 'branching_factor': best_config['branching_factor'],\n", + " 'max_depth': best_config['max_depth'],\n", + " 'epsilon': best_config['epsilon']\n", + " },\n", + " 'best_score': best_config['similarity_score'],\n", + " 'avg_score': query_df['similarity_score'].mean(),\n", + " 'min_score': query_df['similarity_score'].min(),\n", + " 'max_score': query_df['similarity_score'].max()\n", + " })\n", + " \n", + " # Create a plot of best scores by query\n", + " query_df = pd.DataFrame(query_results)\n", + " \n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(10, 6))\n", + " plt.bar(range(len(query_df)), query_df['best_score'], color='darkgreen')\n", + " plt.xticks(range(len(query_df)), [q[:30] + '...' if len(q) > 30 else q for q in query_df['query']], rotation=45, ha='right')\n", + " plt.ylabel('Best Similarity Score')\n", + " plt.title('Best Performance by Query')\n", + " plt.grid(axis='y', linestyle='--', alpha=0.7)\n", + " plt.tight_layout()\n", + " \n", + " # Save the figure\n", + " filename = os.path.join(output_dir, 'best_scores_by_query.png')\n", + " plt.savefig(filename, dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight')\n", + " plt.close()\n", + " print(f\"Saved plot to {filename}\")\n", + " \n", + " # Save the query analysis results\n", + " with open(os.path.join(output_dir, 'query_analysis.json'), 'w') as f:\n", + " json.dump(query_results, f, indent=2)\n", + "\n", + "def analyze_path_length_effect(df, output_dir):\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " Analyze the effect of actual path length on performance.\n", + " \n", + " Args:\n", + " df: DataFrame with experiment results\n", + " output_dir: Directory to save the plots\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " if 'path_length' not in df.columns:\n", + " print(\"Path length information not available - skipping path length analysis\")\n", + " return\n", + " \n", + " # Group by path length\n", + " grouped = df.groupby('path_length')['similarity_score'].agg(['mean', 'std', 'count']).reset_index()\n", + " \n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(10, 6))\n", + " plt.bar(grouped['path_length'], grouped['mean'], yerr=grouped['std'], capsize=5, color='purple')\n", + " plt.xticks(grouped['path_length'])\n", + " plt.xlabel('Path Length')\n", + " plt.ylabel('Mean Similarity Score')\n", + " plt.title('Effect of Strategy Path Length on Performance')\n", + " plt.grid(axis='y', linestyle='--', alpha=0.7)\n", + " \n", + " # Save the figure\n", + " filename = os.path.join(output_dir, 'path_length_effect.png')\n", + " plt.savefig(filename, dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight')\n", + " plt.close()\n", + " print(f\"Saved plot to {filename}\")\n", + "\n", + "def perform_full_analysis(input_file):\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " Perform a full analysis of the experiment results.\n", + " \n", + " Args:\n", + " input_file: Path to the experiment results file\n", + " \"\"\"\n", + " # Load the data\n", + " df = load_experiment_data(input_file)\n", + " \n", + " # Get the experiment ID\n", + " experiment_id = df['experiment_id'].iloc[0] if 'experiment_id' in df.columns and not df.empty else \"unknown_experiment\"\n", + " \n", + " # Create output directory\n", + " output_dir = create_output_directory(experiment_id)\n", + " print(f\"Analysis results will be saved to {output_dir}\")\n", + " \n", + " # Save some basic statistics\n", + " basic_stats = {\n", + " 'total_simulations': len(df),\n", + " 'parameter_ranges': {\n", + " 'diversity_levels': list(df['diversity_level'].unique()) if 'diversity_level' in df.columns else [],\n", + " 'branching_factors': list(sorted(df['branching_factor'].unique())) if 'branching_factor' in df.columns else [],\n", + " 'max_depths': list(sorted(df['max_depth'].unique())) if 'max_depth' in df.columns else [],\n", + " 'epsilon_values': list(sorted(df['epsilon'].unique())) if 'epsilon' in df.columns else []\n", + " },\n", + " 'similarity_stats': {\n", + " 'mean': float(df['similarity_score'].mean()),\n", + " 'median': float(df['similarity_score'].median()),\n", + " 'min': float(df['similarity_score'].min()),\n", + " 'max': float(df['similarity_score'].max()),\n", + " 'std': float(df['similarity_score'].std())\n", + " }\n", + " }\n", + " \n", + " with open(os.path.join(output_dir, 'basic_stats.json'), 'w') as f:\n", + " json.dump(basic_stats, f, indent=2)\n", + " \n", + " # Create visualizations\n", + " print(\"Generating visualizations...\")\n", + " \n", + " # Individual parameter effects\n", + " for param in ['diversity_level', 'branching_factor', 'max_depth', 'epsilon']:\n", + " if param in df.columns and len(df[param].unique()) > 1:\n", + " plot_similarity_by_parameter(df, param, output_dir)\n", + " \n", + " # Parameter interactions\n", + " interaction_pairs = [\n", + " ('diversity_level', 'branching_factor'),\n", + " ('diversity_level', 'max_depth'),\n", + " ('branching_factor', 'max_depth'),\n", + " ('epsilon', 'diversity_level')\n", + " ]\n", + " \n", + " for param1, param2 in interaction_pairs:\n", + " if param1 in df.columns and param2 in df.columns and len(df[param1].unique()) > 1 and len(df[param2].unique()) > 1:\n", + " plot_parameter_interaction(df, param1, param2, output_dir)\n", + " \n", + " # Run statistical tests\n", + " print(\"Running statistical tests...\")\n", + " test_results = run_statistical_tests(df, output_dir)\n", + " \n", + " # Plot top configurations\n", + " print(\"Analyzing top configurations...\")\n", + " plot_final_configs(df, output_dir)\n", + " \n", + " # Query-specific analysis\n", + " print(\"Analyzing performance by query...\")\n", + " plot_query_performance(df, output_dir)\n", + " \n", + " # Path length analysis\n", + " print(\"Analyzing path length effects...\")\n", + " analyze_path_length_effect(df, output_dir)\n", + " \n", + " print(f\"Analysis complete. Results saved to {output_dir}\")\n", + " return output_dir\n", + "\n", + "\n", + "perform_full_analysis(\"experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_all_results.json\")\n" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": 2, + "id": "0b51f8cf-6f33-46dc-9209-3c08dc64944e", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [ + { + "name": "stdout", + "output_type": "stream", + "text": [ + "Collecting seaborn\n", + " Obtaining dependency information for seaborn from https://files.pythonhosted.org/packages/83/11/00d3c3dfc25ad54e731d91449895a79e4bf2384dc3ac01809010ba88f6d5/seaborn-0.13.2-py3-none-any.whl.metadata\n", + " Using cached seaborn-0.13.2-py3-none-any.whl.metadata (5.4 kB)\n", + "Collecting scipy\n", + " Obtaining dependency information for scipy from https://files.pythonhosted.org/packages/a4/98/e5c964526c929ef1f795d4c343b2ff98634ad2051bd2bbadfef9e772e413/scipy-1.15.2-cp312-cp312-macosx_14_0_arm64.whl.metadata\n", + " Using cached scipy-1.15.2-cp312-cp312-macosx_14_0_arm64.whl.metadata (61 kB)\n", + "Requirement already satisfied: numpy!=1.24.0,>=1.20 in ./.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages (from seaborn) (2.2.3)\n", + "Requirement already satisfied: pandas>=1.2 in ./.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages (from seaborn) (2.2.3)\n", + "Requirement already satisfied: matplotlib!=3.6.1,>=3.4 in ./.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages (from seaborn) (3.10.1)\n", + "Requirement already satisfied: contourpy>=1.0.1 in ./.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages (from matplotlib!=3.6.1,>=3.4->seaborn) (1.3.1)\n", + "Requirement already satisfied: cycler>=0.10 in ./.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages (from matplotlib!=3.6.1,>=3.4->seaborn) (0.12.1)\n", + "Requirement already satisfied: fonttools>=4.22.0 in ./.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages (from matplotlib!=3.6.1,>=3.4->seaborn) (4.56.0)\n", + "Requirement already satisfied: kiwisolver>=1.3.1 in ./.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages (from matplotlib!=3.6.1,>=3.4->seaborn) (1.4.8)\n", + "Requirement already satisfied: packaging>=20.0 in ./.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages (from matplotlib!=3.6.1,>=3.4->seaborn) (24.2)\n", + "Requirement already satisfied: pillow>=8 in ./.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages (from matplotlib!=3.6.1,>=3.4->seaborn) (11.1.0)\n", + "Requirement already satisfied: pyparsing>=2.3.1 in ./.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages (from matplotlib!=3.6.1,>=3.4->seaborn) (3.2.1)\n", + "Requirement already satisfied: python-dateutil>=2.7 in ./.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages (from matplotlib!=3.6.1,>=3.4->seaborn) (2.9.0.post0)\n", + "Requirement already satisfied: pytz>=2020.1 in ./.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages (from pandas>=1.2->seaborn) (2025.1)\n", + "Requirement already satisfied: tzdata>=2022.7 in ./.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages (from pandas>=1.2->seaborn) (2025.1)\n", + "Requirement already satisfied: six>=1.5 in ./.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages (from python-dateutil>=2.7->matplotlib!=3.6.1,>=3.4->seaborn) (1.17.0)\n", + "Using cached seaborn-0.13.2-py3-none-any.whl (294 kB)\n", + "Using cached scipy-1.15.2-cp312-cp312-macosx_14_0_arm64.whl (22.4 MB)\n", + "Installing collected packages: scipy, seaborn\n", + "Successfully installed scipy-1.15.2 seaborn-0.13.2\n", + "\n", + "\u001b[1m[\u001b[0m\u001b[34;49mnotice\u001b[0m\u001b[1;39;49m]\u001b[0m\u001b[39;49m A new release of pip is available: \u001b[0m\u001b[31;49m23.2.1\u001b[0m\u001b[39;49m -> \u001b[0m\u001b[32;49m25.0.1\u001b[0m\n", + "\u001b[1m[\u001b[0m\u001b[34;49mnotice\u001b[0m\u001b[1;39;49m]\u001b[0m\u001b[39;49m To update, run: \u001b[0m\u001b[32;49mpip install --upgrade pip\u001b[0m\n" + ] + } + ], + "source": [ + "!pip install seaborn scipy " + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": 7, + "id": "f7c32e9c-fbc7-415e-b484-526d079dd9b2", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [ + { + "name": "stdout", + "output_type": "stream", + "text": [ + "Loading data from experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_all_results.json...\n", + "Loaded 16 valid results\n" + ] + }, + { + "ename": "TypeError", + "evalue": "Object of type int64 is not JSON serializable", + "output_type": "error", + "traceback": [ + "\u001b[31m---------------------------------------------------------------------------\u001b[39m", + "\u001b[31mTypeError\u001b[39m Traceback (most recent call last)", + "\u001b[36mCell\u001b[39m\u001b[36m \u001b[39m\u001b[32mIn[7]\u001b[39m\u001b[32m, line 522\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 517\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mreturn\u001b[39;00m output_dir\n\u001b[32m 519\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mif\u001b[39;00m \u001b[34m__name__\u001b[39m == \u001b[33m\"\u001b[39m\u001b[33m__main__\u001b[39m\u001b[33m\"\u001b[39m:\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m522\u001b[39m \u001b[43mperform_full_analysis\u001b[49m\u001b[43m(\u001b[49m\u001b[33;43m\"\u001b[39;49m\u001b[33;43mexperiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_all_results.json\u001b[39;49m\u001b[33;43m\"\u001b[39;49m\u001b[43m)\u001b[49m\n", + "\u001b[36mCell\u001b[39m\u001b[36m \u001b[39m\u001b[32mIn[7]\u001b[39m\u001b[32m, line 489\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36mperform_full_analysis\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(input_file)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 471\u001b[39m basic_stats = {\n\u001b[32m 472\u001b[39m \u001b[33m'\u001b[39m\u001b[33mtotal_simulations\u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m: \u001b[38;5;28mlen\u001b[39m(df),\n\u001b[32m 473\u001b[39m \u001b[33m'\u001b[39m\u001b[33mparameter_ranges\u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m: {\n\u001b[32m (...)\u001b[39m\u001b[32m 485\u001b[39m }\n\u001b[32m 486\u001b[39m }\n\u001b[32m 488\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mwith\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;28mopen\u001b[39m(os.path.join(output_dir, \u001b[33m'\u001b[39m\u001b[33mbasic_stats.json\u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m), \u001b[33m'\u001b[39m\u001b[33mw\u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m) \u001b[38;5;28;01mas\u001b[39;00m f:\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m489\u001b[39m \u001b[43mjson\u001b[49m\u001b[43m.\u001b[49m\u001b[43mdump\u001b[49m\u001b[43m(\u001b[49m\u001b[43mbasic_stats\u001b[49m\u001b[43m,\u001b[49m\u001b[43m \u001b[49m\u001b[43mf\u001b[49m\u001b[43m,\u001b[49m\u001b[43m \u001b[49m\u001b[43mindent\u001b[49m\u001b[43m=\u001b[49m\u001b[32;43m2\u001b[39;49m\u001b[43m)\u001b[49m\n\u001b[32m 491\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;66;03m# Print basic statistics\u001b[39;00m\n\u001b[32m 492\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28mprint\u001b[39m(\u001b[33m\"\u001b[39m\u001b[38;5;130;01m\\n\u001b[39;00m\u001b[33m============= EXPERIMENT ANALYSIS =============\u001b[39m\u001b[33m\"\u001b[39m)\n", + "\u001b[36mFile \u001b[39m\u001b[32m/Library/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.12/lib/python3.12/json/__init__.py:179\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36mdump\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(obj, fp, skipkeys, ensure_ascii, check_circular, allow_nan, cls, indent, separators, default, sort_keys, **kw)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 173\u001b[39m iterable = \u001b[38;5;28mcls\u001b[39m(skipkeys=skipkeys, ensure_ascii=ensure_ascii,\n\u001b[32m 174\u001b[39m check_circular=check_circular, allow_nan=allow_nan, indent=indent,\n\u001b[32m 175\u001b[39m separators=separators,\n\u001b[32m 176\u001b[39m default=default, sort_keys=sort_keys, **kw).iterencode(obj)\n\u001b[32m 177\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;66;03m# could accelerate with writelines in some versions of Python, at\u001b[39;00m\n\u001b[32m 178\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;66;03m# a debuggability cost\u001b[39;00m\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m179\u001b[39m \u001b[43m\u001b[49m\u001b[38;5;28;43;01mfor\u001b[39;49;00m\u001b[43m \u001b[49m\u001b[43mchunk\u001b[49m\u001b[43m \u001b[49m\u001b[38;5;129;43;01min\u001b[39;49;00m\u001b[43m \u001b[49m\u001b[43miterable\u001b[49m\u001b[43m:\u001b[49m\n\u001b[32m 180\u001b[39m \u001b[43m \u001b[49m\u001b[43mfp\u001b[49m\u001b[43m.\u001b[49m\u001b[43mwrite\u001b[49m\u001b[43m(\u001b[49m\u001b[43mchunk\u001b[49m\u001b[43m)\u001b[49m\n", + "\u001b[36mFile \u001b[39m\u001b[32m/Library/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.12/lib/python3.12/json/encoder.py:432\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36m_make_iterencode.._iterencode\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(o, _current_indent_level)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 430\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01myield from\u001b[39;00m _iterencode_list(o, _current_indent_level)\n\u001b[32m 431\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01melif\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;28misinstance\u001b[39m(o, \u001b[38;5;28mdict\u001b[39m):\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m432\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01myield from\u001b[39;00m _iterencode_dict(o, _current_indent_level)\n\u001b[32m 433\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01melse\u001b[39;00m:\n\u001b[32m 434\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mif\u001b[39;00m markers \u001b[38;5;129;01mis\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;129;01mnot\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;28;01mNone\u001b[39;00m:\n", + "\u001b[36mFile \u001b[39m\u001b[32m/Library/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.12/lib/python3.12/json/encoder.py:406\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36m_make_iterencode.._iterencode_dict\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(dct, _current_indent_level)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 404\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01melse\u001b[39;00m:\n\u001b[32m 405\u001b[39m chunks = _iterencode(value, _current_indent_level)\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m406\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01myield from\u001b[39;00m chunks\n\u001b[32m 407\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mif\u001b[39;00m newline_indent \u001b[38;5;129;01mis\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;129;01mnot\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;28;01mNone\u001b[39;00m:\n\u001b[32m 408\u001b[39m _current_indent_level -= \u001b[32m1\u001b[39m\n", + "\u001b[36mFile \u001b[39m\u001b[32m/Library/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.12/lib/python3.12/json/encoder.py:406\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36m_make_iterencode.._iterencode_dict\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(dct, _current_indent_level)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 404\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01melse\u001b[39;00m:\n\u001b[32m 405\u001b[39m chunks = _iterencode(value, _current_indent_level)\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m406\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01myield from\u001b[39;00m chunks\n\u001b[32m 407\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mif\u001b[39;00m newline_indent \u001b[38;5;129;01mis\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;129;01mnot\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;28;01mNone\u001b[39;00m:\n\u001b[32m 408\u001b[39m _current_indent_level -= \u001b[32m1\u001b[39m\n", + "\u001b[36mFile \u001b[39m\u001b[32m/Library/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.12/lib/python3.12/json/encoder.py:326\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36m_make_iterencode.._iterencode_list\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(lst, _current_indent_level)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 324\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01melse\u001b[39;00m:\n\u001b[32m 325\u001b[39m chunks = _iterencode(value, _current_indent_level)\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m326\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01myield from\u001b[39;00m chunks\n\u001b[32m 327\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mif\u001b[39;00m newline_indent \u001b[38;5;129;01mis\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;129;01mnot\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;28;01mNone\u001b[39;00m:\n\u001b[32m 328\u001b[39m _current_indent_level -= \u001b[32m1\u001b[39m\n", + "\u001b[36mFile \u001b[39m\u001b[32m/Library/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.12/lib/python3.12/json/encoder.py:439\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36m_make_iterencode.._iterencode\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(o, _current_indent_level)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 437\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mraise\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;167;01mValueError\u001b[39;00m(\u001b[33m\"\u001b[39m\u001b[33mCircular reference detected\u001b[39m\u001b[33m\"\u001b[39m)\n\u001b[32m 438\u001b[39m markers[markerid] = o\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m439\u001b[39m o = \u001b[43m_default\u001b[49m\u001b[43m(\u001b[49m\u001b[43mo\u001b[49m\u001b[43m)\u001b[49m\n\u001b[32m 440\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01myield from\u001b[39;00m _iterencode(o, _current_indent_level)\n\u001b[32m 441\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mif\u001b[39;00m markers \u001b[38;5;129;01mis\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;129;01mnot\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;28;01mNone\u001b[39;00m:\n", + "\u001b[36mFile \u001b[39m\u001b[32m/Library/Frameworks/Python.framework/Versions/3.12/lib/python3.12/json/encoder.py:180\u001b[39m, in \u001b[36mJSONEncoder.default\u001b[39m\u001b[34m(self, o)\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 161\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mdef\u001b[39;00m\u001b[38;5;250m \u001b[39m\u001b[34mdefault\u001b[39m(\u001b[38;5;28mself\u001b[39m, o):\n\u001b[32m 162\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;250m \u001b[39m\u001b[33;03m\"\"\"Implement this method in a subclass such that it returns\u001b[39;00m\n\u001b[32m 163\u001b[39m \u001b[33;03m a serializable object for ``o``, or calls the base implementation\u001b[39;00m\n\u001b[32m 164\u001b[39m \u001b[33;03m (to raise a ``TypeError``).\u001b[39;00m\n\u001b[32m (...)\u001b[39m\u001b[32m 178\u001b[39m \n\u001b[32m 179\u001b[39m \u001b[33;03m \"\"\"\u001b[39;00m\n\u001b[32m--> \u001b[39m\u001b[32m180\u001b[39m \u001b[38;5;28;01mraise\u001b[39;00m \u001b[38;5;167;01mTypeError\u001b[39;00m(\u001b[33mf\u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m\u001b[33mObject of type \u001b[39m\u001b[38;5;132;01m{\u001b[39;00mo.\u001b[34m__class__\u001b[39m.\u001b[34m__name__\u001b[39m\u001b[38;5;132;01m}\u001b[39;00m\u001b[33m \u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m\n\u001b[32m 181\u001b[39m \u001b[33mf\u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m\u001b[33mis not JSON serializable\u001b[39m\u001b[33m'\u001b[39m)\n", + "\u001b[31mTypeError\u001b[39m: Object of type int64 is not JSON serializable" + ] + } + ], + "source": [ + "import os\n", + "import json\n", + "import argparse\n", + "import numpy as np\n", + "import pandas as pd\n", + "import matplotlib.pyplot as plt\n", + "import seaborn as sns\n", + "from scipy import stats\n", + "\n", + "def load_experiment_data(filename):\n", + " \"\"\"Load experiment results from a JSON file.\"\"\"\n", + " print(f\"Loading data from {filename}...\")\n", + " \n", + " with open(filename, 'r') as f:\n", + " data = json.load(f)\n", + " \n", + " # Handle all_results file format\n", + " if isinstance(data, list):\n", + " results = data\n", + " # Handle analysis file format\n", + " elif 'summary' in data:\n", + " experiment_id = data.get('experiment_id')\n", + " all_results_file = os.path.join(os.path.dirname(filename), f\"{experiment_id}_all_results.json\")\n", + " \n", + " if os.path.exists(all_results_file):\n", + " with open(all_results_file, 'r') as f:\n", + " results = json.load(f)\n", + " else:\n", + " print(\"Error: Could not find all_results file\")\n", + " return None\n", + " else:\n", + " print(\"Error: Unrecognized file format\")\n", + " return None\n", + " \n", + " # Create DataFrame\n", + " rows = []\n", + " for result in results:\n", + " # Skip results with errors\n", + " if 'error' in result:\n", + " continue\n", + " \n", + " row = {\n", + " 'query': result.get('query', ''),\n", + " 'similarity_score': result.get('similarity_score', 0),\n", + " 'diversity_level': result.get('ibfs_config', {}).get('diversity_level', ''),\n", + " 'branching_factor': result.get('ibfs_config', {}).get('branching_factor', 0),\n", + " 'max_depth': result.get('ibfs_config', {}).get('max_depth', 0),\n", + " 'epsilon': result.get('user_config', {}).get('epsilon', 0),\n", + " 'experiment_id': result.get('experiment_id', '')\n", + " }\n", + " \n", + " # Add strategy path information if available\n", + " if 'strategy_path' in result:\n", + " row['path_length'] = len(result.get('strategy_path', []))\n", + " \n", + " rows.append(row)\n", + " \n", + " df = pd.DataFrame(rows)\n", + " print(f\"Loaded {len(df)} valid results\")\n", + " return df\n", + "\n", + "def create_parameter_plots(df, output_dir):\n", + " \"\"\"Create plots showing the effects of different parameters.\"\"\"\n", + " os.makedirs(output_dir, exist_ok=True)\n", + " \n", + " # Set seaborn style for better visualization\n", + " sns.set(style=\"whitegrid\")\n", + " \n", + " # Plot 1: Similarity scores by diversity level\n", + " if 'diversity_level' in df.columns and len(df['diversity_level'].unique()) > 1:\n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(10, 6))\n", + " ax = sns.boxplot(x='diversity_level', y='similarity_score', data=df, palette=\"Set3\")\n", + " ax.set_title('Similarity Scores by Diversity Level', fontsize=16)\n", + " ax.set_xlabel('Diversity Level', fontsize=14)\n", + " ax.set_ylabel('Similarity Score', fontsize=14)\n", + " \n", + " # Add mean values as text above each box\n", + " for i, level in enumerate(sorted(df['diversity_level'].unique())):\n", + " mean_val = df[df['diversity_level'] == level]['similarity_score'].mean()\n", + " ax.text(i, df['similarity_score'].max() + 0.01, f'Mean: {mean_val:.3f}', \n", + " horizontalalignment='center', fontsize=12)\n", + " \n", + " plt.tight_layout()\n", + " plt.savefig(os.path.join(output_dir, 'diversity_effect.png'), dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight')\n", + " plt.show()\n", + " \n", + " # Plot 2: Similarity scores by branching factor\n", + " if 'branching_factor' in df.columns and len(df['branching_factor'].unique()) > 1:\n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(10, 6))\n", + " ax = sns.boxplot(x='branching_factor', y='similarity_score', data=df, palette=\"Blues\")\n", + " ax.set_title('Similarity Scores by Branching Factor', fontsize=16)\n", + " ax.set_xlabel('Branching Factor', fontsize=14)\n", + " ax.set_ylabel('Similarity Score', fontsize=14)\n", + " \n", + " # Add mean values as text above each box\n", + " for i, factor in enumerate(sorted(df['branching_factor'].unique())):\n", + " mean_val = df[df['branching_factor'] == factor]['similarity_score'].mean()\n", + " ax.text(i, df['similarity_score'].max() + 0.01, f'Mean: {mean_val:.3f}', \n", + " horizontalalignment='center', fontsize=12)\n", + " \n", + " plt.tight_layout()\n", + " plt.savefig(os.path.join(output_dir, 'branching_effect.png'), dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight')\n", + " plt.show()\n", + " \n", + " # Plot 3: Similarity scores by max depth\n", + " if 'max_depth' in df.columns and len(df['max_depth'].unique()) > 1:\n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(10, 6))\n", + " ax = sns.boxplot(x='max_depth', y='similarity_score', data=df, palette=\"Greens\")\n", + " ax.set_title('Similarity Scores by Max Depth', fontsize=16)\n", + " ax.set_xlabel('Max Depth', fontsize=14)\n", + " ax.set_ylabel('Similarity Score', fontsize=14)\n", + " \n", + " # Add mean values as text above each box\n", + " for i, depth in enumerate(sorted(df['max_depth'].unique())):\n", + " mean_val = df[df['max_depth'] == depth]['similarity_score'].mean()\n", + " ax.text(i, df['similarity_score'].max() + 0.01, f'Mean: {mean_val:.3f}', \n", + " horizontalalignment='center', fontsize=12)\n", + " \n", + " plt.tight_layout()\n", + " plt.savefig(os.path.join(output_dir, 'depth_effect.png'), dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight')\n", + " plt.show()\n", + " \n", + " # Plot 4: Similarity scores by epsilon\n", + " if 'epsilon' in df.columns and len(df['epsilon'].unique()) > 1:\n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(10, 6))\n", + " ax = sns.boxplot(x='epsilon', y='similarity_score', data=df, palette=\"Oranges\")\n", + " ax.set_title('Similarity Scores by Epsilon (Noise Parameter)', fontsize=16)\n", + " ax.set_xlabel('Epsilon', fontsize=14)\n", + " ax.set_ylabel('Similarity Score', fontsize=14)\n", + " \n", + " # Add mean values as text above each box\n", + " for i, eps in enumerate(sorted(df['epsilon'].unique())):\n", + " mean_val = df[df['epsilon'] == eps]['similarity_score'].mean()\n", + " ax.text(i, df['similarity_score'].max() + 0.01, f'Mean: {mean_val:.3f}', \n", + " horizontalalignment='center', fontsize=12)\n", + " \n", + " plt.tight_layout()\n", + " plt.savefig(os.path.join(output_dir, 'epsilon_effect.png'), dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight')\n", + " plt.show()\n", + " \n", + " # Plot 5: Heatmap of diversity level and branching factor\n", + " if ('diversity_level' in df.columns and 'branching_factor' in df.columns and \n", + " len(df['diversity_level'].unique()) > 1 and len(df['branching_factor'].unique()) > 1):\n", + " \n", + " pivot_table = df.pivot_table(\n", + " values='similarity_score', \n", + " index='diversity_level', \n", + " columns='branching_factor',\n", + " aggfunc='mean'\n", + " )\n", + " \n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(10, 8))\n", + " ax = sns.heatmap(pivot_table, annot=True, cmap=\"YlGnBu\", fmt=\".3f\", linewidths=.5)\n", + " ax.set_title('Interaction: Diversity Level × Branching Factor', fontsize=16)\n", + " ax.set_xlabel('Branching Factor', fontsize=14)\n", + " ax.set_ylabel('Diversity Level', fontsize=14)\n", + " \n", + " plt.tight_layout()\n", + " plt.savefig(os.path.join(output_dir, 'diversity_branching_interaction.png'), dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight')\n", + " plt.show()\n", + " \n", + " # Plot 6: Heatmap of diversity level and max depth\n", + " if ('diversity_level' in df.columns and 'max_depth' in df.columns and \n", + " len(df['diversity_level'].unique()) > 1 and len(df['max_depth'].unique()) > 1):\n", + " \n", + " pivot_table = df.pivot_table(\n", + " values='similarity_score', \n", + " index='diversity_level', \n", + " columns='max_depth',\n", + " aggfunc='mean'\n", + " )\n", + " \n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(10, 8))\n", + " ax = sns.heatmap(pivot_table, annot=True, cmap=\"YlOrRd\", fmt=\".3f\", linewidths=.5)\n", + " ax.set_title('Interaction: Diversity Level × Max Depth', fontsize=16)\n", + " ax.set_xlabel('Max Depth', fontsize=14)\n", + " ax.set_ylabel('Diversity Level', fontsize=14)\n", + " \n", + " plt.tight_layout()\n", + " plt.savefig(os.path.join(output_dir, 'diversity_depth_interaction.png'), dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight')\n", + " plt.show()\n", + " \n", + " # Plot 7: Heatmap of branching factor and max depth\n", + " if ('branching_factor' in df.columns and 'max_depth' in df.columns and \n", + " len(df['branching_factor'].unique()) > 1 and len(df['max_depth'].unique()) > 1):\n", + " \n", + " pivot_table = df.pivot_table(\n", + " values='similarity_score', \n", + " index='branching_factor', \n", + " columns='max_depth',\n", + " aggfunc='mean'\n", + " )\n", + " \n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(10, 8))\n", + " ax = sns.heatmap(pivot_table, annot=True, cmap=\"PuBuGn\", fmt=\".3f\", linewidths=.5)\n", + " ax.set_title('Interaction: Branching Factor × Max Depth', fontsize=16)\n", + " ax.set_xlabel('Max Depth', fontsize=14)\n", + " ax.set_ylabel('Branching Factor', fontsize=14)\n", + " \n", + " plt.tight_layout()\n", + " plt.savefig(os.path.join(output_dir, 'branching_depth_interaction.png'), dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight')\n", + " plt.show()\n", + "\n", + "def plot_top_configurations(df, output_dir):\n", + " \"\"\"Create plots showing top configurations.\"\"\"\n", + " # Group by all key parameters\n", + " grouped = df.groupby(['diversity_level', 'branching_factor', 'max_depth'])['similarity_score'].agg(\n", + " ['mean', 'std', 'count']).reset_index()\n", + " \n", + " # Sort by mean similarity score (descending)\n", + " grouped = grouped.sort_values('mean', ascending=False)\n", + " \n", + " # Plot top 10 configurations (or all if less than 10)\n", + " top_n = min(10, len(grouped))\n", + " top_configs = grouped.head(top_n)\n", + " \n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(12, 8))\n", + " \n", + " # Create labels for x-axis\n", + " config_labels = [f\"D:{row['diversity_level']}, B:{row['branching_factor']}, M:{row['max_depth']}\" \n", + " for _, row in top_configs.iterrows()]\n", + " \n", + " # Plot with error bars\n", + " ax = plt.bar(range(top_n), top_configs['mean'], yerr=top_configs['std'], \n", + " capsize=5, color='skyblue', alpha=0.7)\n", + " plt.xticks(range(top_n), config_labels, rotation=45, ha='right', fontsize=12)\n", + " plt.ylabel('Mean Similarity Score', fontsize=14)\n", + " plt.title('Top Configurations by Mean Similarity Score', fontsize=16)\n", + " plt.ylim(0, 1.0) # Assuming similarity scores are between 0 and 1\n", + " plt.grid(axis='y', linestyle='--', alpha=0.7)\n", + " \n", + " # Add value labels on top of bars\n", + " for i, value in enumerate(top_configs['mean']):\n", + " plt.text(i, value + 0.02, f\"{value:.3f}\", ha='center', fontsize=11)\n", + " \n", + " plt.tight_layout()\n", + " plt.savefig(os.path.join(output_dir, 'top_configurations.png'), dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight')\n", + " plt.show()\n", + " \n", + " # Output the top configurations as text\n", + " with open(os.path.join(output_dir, 'top_configurations.txt'), 'w') as f:\n", + " f.write(\"Top Configurations by Mean Similarity Score\\n\")\n", + " f.write(\"=========================================\\n\\n\")\n", + " \n", + " for i, (_, row) in enumerate(top_configs.iterrows(), 1):\n", + " f.write(f\"{i}. Diversity: {row['diversity_level']}, Branching: {row['branching_factor']}, \")\n", + " f.write(f\"Max Depth: {row['max_depth']}, Score: {row['mean']:.4f}\")\n", + " f.write(f\" (std: {row['std']:.3f}, n: {row['count']})\\n\")\n", + " \n", + " # Print top configurations\n", + " print(\"\\nTop configurations by mean similarity score:\")\n", + " for i, (_, row) in enumerate(top_configs.iterrows(), 1):\n", + " print(f\"{i}. Diversity: {row['diversity_level']}, Branching: {row['branching_factor']}, \"\n", + " f\"Max Depth: {row['max_depth']}, Score: {row['mean']:.4f}\")\n", + "\n", + "def run_statistical_tests(df, output_dir):\n", + " \"\"\"Run statistical tests to check for significant effects.\"\"\"\n", + " results = {}\n", + " \n", + " # Function to run and format test results\n", + " def run_test_for_param(param):\n", + " param_values = sorted(df[param].unique())\n", + " \n", + " if len(param_values) == 2:\n", + " # T-test for two groups\n", + " group1 = df[df[param] == param_values[0]]['similarity_score']\n", + " group2 = df[df[param] == param_values[1]]['similarity_score']\n", + " \n", + " t_stat, p_val = stats.ttest_ind(group1, group2, equal_var=False)\n", + " \n", + " # Calculate effect size (Cohen's d)\n", + " mean1, mean2 = group1.mean(), group2.mean()\n", + " sd1, sd2 = group1.std(), group2.std()\n", + " n1, n2 = len(group1), len(group2)\n", + " \n", + " # Pooled standard deviation\n", + " sd_pooled = np.sqrt(((n1 - 1) * sd1**2 + (n2 - 1) * sd2**2) / (n1 + n2 - 2))\n", + " \n", + " # Cohen's d\n", + " d = abs(mean1 - mean2) / sd_pooled\n", + " \n", + " return {\n", + " 'test': 't-test',\n", + " 'parameter': param,\n", + " 'groups': param_values,\n", + " 'statistic': float(t_stat),\n", + " 'p_value': float(p_val),\n", + " 'significant': p_val < 0.05,\n", + " 'effect_size': float(d),\n", + " 'effect_size_type': \"Cohen's d\",\n", + " 'mean_values': {str(param_values[0]): float(mean1), str(param_values[1]): float(mean2)}\n", + " }\n", + " \n", + " elif len(param_values) > 2:\n", + " # ANOVA for more than two groups\n", + " groups = [df[df[param] == val]['similarity_score'] for val in param_values]\n", + " f_stat, p_val = stats.f_oneway(*groups)\n", + " \n", + " # Calculate mean for each group\n", + " mean_values = {str(val): float(df[df[param] == val]['similarity_score'].mean()) for val in param_values}\n", + " \n", + " # Calculate effect size (Eta squared)\n", + " ss_between = sum(len(group) * ((group.mean() - df['similarity_score'].mean()) ** 2) for group in groups)\n", + " ss_total = sum((df['similarity_score'] - df['similarity_score'].mean()) ** 2)\n", + " eta_squared = ss_between / ss_total if ss_total > 0 else 0\n", + " \n", + " return {\n", + " 'test': 'ANOVA',\n", + " 'parameter': param,\n", + " 'groups': list(map(str, param_values)),\n", + " 'statistic': float(f_stat),\n", + " 'p_value': float(p_val),\n", + " 'significant': p_val < 0.05,\n", + " 'effect_size': float(eta_squared),\n", + " 'effect_size_type': \"Eta squared\",\n", + " 'mean_values': mean_values\n", + " }\n", + " \n", + " # Test all available parameters\n", + " for param in ['diversity_level', 'branching_factor', 'max_depth', 'epsilon']:\n", + " if param in df.columns and len(df[param].unique()) > 1:\n", + " results[f'{param}_test'] = run_test_for_param(param)\n", + " \n", + " # Write results to a detailed text file\n", + " with open(os.path.join(output_dir, 'statistical_results.txt'), 'w') as f:\n", + " f.write(\"Statistical Test Results\\n\")\n", + " f.write(\"=======================\\n\\n\")\n", + " \n", + " for test_name, result in results.items():\n", + " f.write(f\"Test: {test_name}\\n\")\n", + " f.write(f\"Parameter: {result['parameter']}\\n\")\n", + " f.write(f\"Type: {result['test']}\\n\")\n", + " f.write(f\"Groups: {result['groups']}\\n\")\n", + " \n", + " if result['test'] == 'ANOVA':\n", + " f.write(f\"F-statistic: {result['statistic']:.4f}\\n\")\n", + " elif result['test'] == 't-test':\n", + " f.write(f\"t-statistic: {result['statistic']:.4f}\\n\")\n", + " \n", + " f.write(f\"p-value: {result['p_value']:.4f}\\n\")\n", + " f.write(f\"Significant: {result['significant']}\\n\")\n", + " f.write(f\"Effect size ({result['effect_size_type']}): {result['effect_size']:.4f}\\n\")\n", + " f.write(\"Mean values by group:\\n\")\n", + " \n", + " for group, mean in result['mean_values'].items():\n", + " f.write(f\" - {group}: {mean:.4f}\\n\")\n", + " \n", + " f.write(\"\\n\")\n", + " \n", + " # Save results as JSON for potential further analysis\n", + " with open(os.path.join(output_dir, 'statistical_results.json'), 'w') as f:\n", + " json.dump(results, f, indent=2)\n", + " \n", + " # Print significant findings\n", + " significant_results = [r for r in results.values() if r['significant']]\n", + " \n", + " if significant_results:\n", + " print(\"\\nSignificant effects found:\")\n", + " for result in significant_results:\n", + " effect_size_interp = \"\"\n", + " if result['effect_size_type'] == \"Cohen's d\":\n", + " if result['effect_size'] < 0.2:\n", + " effect_size_interp = \"negligible effect\"\n", + " elif result['effect_size'] < 0.5:\n", + " effect_size_interp = \"small effect\"\n", + " elif result['effect_size'] < 0.8:\n", + " effect_size_interp = \"medium effect\"\n", + " else:\n", + " effect_size_interp = \"large effect\"\n", + " elif result['effect_size_type'] == \"Eta squared\":\n", + " if result['effect_size'] < 0.01:\n", + " effect_size_interp = \"negligible effect\"\n", + " elif result['effect_size'] < 0.06:\n", + " effect_size_interp = \"small effect\"\n", + " elif result['effect_size'] < 0.14:\n", + " effect_size_interp = \"medium effect\"\n", + " else:\n", + " effect_size_interp = \"large effect\"\n", + " \n", + " print(f\"- {result['parameter']}: p={result['p_value']:.4f}, {result['effect_size_type']}={result['effect_size']:.3f} ({effect_size_interp})\")\n", + " # Print mean differences to understand direction\n", + " means = result['mean_values']\n", + " print(f\" Mean values: {', '.join([f'{k}={v:.3f}' for k, v in means.items()])}\")\n", + " else:\n", + " print(\"\\nNo significant effects found in the parameters tested.\")\n", + " \n", + " return results\n", + "\n", + "def analyze_query_performance(df, output_dir):\n", + " \"\"\"Analyze performance across different queries.\"\"\"\n", + " if 'query' not in df.columns or len(df['query'].unique()) <= 1:\n", + " print(\"Query analysis skipped - insufficient query variation\")\n", + " return\n", + " \n", + " # Get performance by query\n", + " query_performance = df.groupby('query')['similarity_score'].agg(['mean', 'std', 'min', 'max', 'count']).reset_index()\n", + " query_performance = query_performance.sort_values('mean', ascending=False)\n", + " \n", + " # Plot query performance\n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(12, 6))\n", + " \n", + " # Truncate long query text for display\n", + " query_labels = [q[:30] + '...' if len(q) > 30 else q for q in query_performance['query']]\n", + " \n", + " # Plot with error bars\n", + " plt.bar(range(len(query_performance)), query_performance['mean'], \n", + " yerr=query_performance['std'], capsize=5, color='lightgreen', alpha=0.7)\n", + " plt.xticks(range(len(query_performance)), query_labels, rotation=45, ha='right')\n", + " plt.ylabel('Mean Similarity Score')\n", + " plt.title('Performance by Query')\n", + " plt.ylim(0, 1.0)\n", + " plt.grid(axis='y', linestyle='--', alpha=0.7)\n", + " \n", + " # Add value labels on top of bars\n", + " for i, value in enumerate(query_performance['mean']):\n", + " plt.text(i, value + 0.02, f\"{value:.3f}\", ha='center')\n", + " \n", + " plt.tight_layout()\n", + " plt.savefig(os.path.join(output_dir, 'query_performance.png'), dpi=300, bbox_inches='tight')\n", + " plt.show()\n", + " \n", + " # For each query, find best configuration\n", + " query_best_configs = []\n", + " \n", + " for query in df['query'].unique():\n", + " query_df = df[df['query'] == query]\n", + " \n", + " # Group by configuration\n", + " grouped = query_df.groupby(['diversity_level', 'branching_factor', 'max_depth'])['similarity_score'].mean().reset_index()\n", + " \n", + " # Get the best configuration\n", + " best_config = grouped.loc[grouped['similarity_score'].idxmax()]\n", + " \n", + " query_best_configs.append({\n", + " 'query': query,\n", + " 'best_config': {\n", + " 'diversity_level': best_config['diversity_level'],\n", + " 'branching_factor': int(best_config['branching_factor']),\n", + " 'max_depth': int(best_config['max_depth']),\n", + " },\n", + " 'best_score': float(best_config['similarity_score']),\n", + " 'mean_score': float(query_df['similarity_score'].mean()),\n", + " })\n", + " \n", + " # Save query analysis to file\n", + " with open(os.path.join(output_dir, 'query_analysis.json'), 'w') as f:\n", + " json.dump(query_best_configs, f, indent=2)\n", + " \n", + " # Print best configurations for each query\n", + " print(\"\\nBest configuration for each query:\")\n", + " for result in query_best_configs:\n", + " query_display = result['query'] if len(result['query']) < 50 else result['query'][:47] + \"...\"\n", + " config = result['best_config']\n", + " print(f\"- {query_display}\")\n", + " print(f\" Best config: D:{config['diversity_level']}, B:{config['branching_factor']}, M:{config['max_depth']}\")\n", + " print(f\" Score: {result['best_score']:.4f} (mean across all configs: {result['mean_score']:.4f})\")\n", + "\n", + "def perform_full_analysis(input_file):\n", + " \"\"\"Perform a comprehensive analysis of the experiment results.\"\"\"\n", + " # Load the data\n", + " df = load_experiment_data(input_file)\n", + " if df is None:\n", + " return\n", + " \n", + " # Create output directory\n", + " experiment_id = df['experiment_id'].iloc[0] if not df.empty and 'experiment_id' in df.columns else \"unknown\"\n", + " output_dir = f\"analysis_{experiment_id}\"\n", + " os.makedirs(output_dir, exist_ok=True)\n", + " \n", + " # Save basic statistics\n", + " basic_stats = {\n", + " 'total_simulations': len(df),\n", + " 'parameter_ranges': {\n", + " 'diversity_levels': list(df['diversity_level'].unique()) if 'diversity_level' in df.columns else [],\n", + " 'branching_factors': list(sorted(df['branching_factor'].unique())) if 'branching_factor' in df.columns else [],\n", + " 'max_depths': list(sorted(df['max_depth'].unique())) if 'max_depth' in df.columns else [],\n", + " 'epsilon_values': list(sorted(df['epsilon'].unique())) if 'epsilon' in df.columns else []\n", + " },\n", + " 'similarity_stats': {\n", + " 'mean': float(df['similarity_score'].mean()),\n", + " 'median': float(df['similarity_score'].median()),\n", + " 'min': float(df['similarity_score'].min()),\n", + " 'max': float(df['similarity_score'].max()),\n", + " 'std': float(df['similarity_score'].std())\n", + " }\n", + " }\n", + " \n", + " with open(os.path.join(output_dir, 'basic_stats.json'), 'w') as f:\n", + " json.dump(basic_stats, f, indent=2)\n", + " \n", + " # Print basic statistics\n", + " print(\"\\n============= EXPERIMENT ANALYSIS =============\")\n", + " print(f\"Total simulations: {basic_stats['total_simulations']}\")\n", + " print(f\"Overall similarity score: mean={basic_stats['similarity_stats']['mean']:.4f}, \"\n", + " f\"median={basic_stats['similarity_stats']['median']:.4f}, \"\n", + " f\"min={basic_stats['similarity_stats']['min']:.4f}, \"\n", + " f\"max={basic_stats['similarity_stats']['max']:.4f}, \"\n", + " f\"std={basic_stats['similarity_stats']['std']:.4f}\")\n", + " \n", + " # Create parameter plots\n", + " print(\"\\nGenerating parameter effect plots...\")\n", + " create_parameter_plots(df, output_dir)\n", + " \n", + " # Plot top configurations\n", + " print(\"\\nAnalyzing top configurations...\")\n", + " plot_top_configurations(df, output_dir)\n", + " \n", + " # Run statistical tests\n", + " print(\"\\nRunning statistical tests...\")\n", + " run_statistical_tests(df, output_dir)\n", + " \n", + " # Analyze query performance\n", + " print(\"\\nAnalyzing query performance...\")\n", + " analyze_query_performance(df, output_dir)\n", + " \n", + " print(f\"\\nAnalysis complete. Results saved to {output_dir}\")\n", + " return output_dir\n", + "\n", + "if __name__ == \"__main__\":\n", + "\n", + " \n", + " perform_full_analysis(\"experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_all_results.json\")" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": 16, + "id": "435a0d02-9262-4467-878f-191ffe679521", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [ + { + "name": "stdout", + "output_type": "stream", + "text": [ + "Loading data from experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_all_results.json...\n", + "Loaded 80 valid results\n" + ] + } + ], + "source": [ + "fn = \"experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_all_results.json\"\n", + "df = load_experiment_data(fn)" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": 17, + "id": "2a140217-f62d-4cce-8786-7b5d44cf4aee", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [ + { + "data": { + "text/html": [ + "
\n", + "\n", + "\n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + " \n", + "
querysimilarity_scorediversity_levelbranching_factormax_depthepsilonexperiment_idpath_length
0What are the environmental impacts of electric...0.6low210.2exp_20250319_1606271
1What are the environmental impacts of electric...0.5low210.2exp_20250319_1606271
2What are the environmental impacts of electric...0.5low210.2exp_20250319_1606271
3What are the environmental impacts of electric...0.6low210.2exp_20250319_1606271
4What are the environmental impacts of electric...0.3low210.2exp_20250319_1606271
...........................
75What are the environmental impacts of electric...0.3medium420.2exp_20250319_1606272
76What are the environmental impacts of electric...0.4medium420.2exp_20250319_1606272
77What are the environmental impacts of electric...0.6medium420.2exp_20250319_1606272
78What are the environmental impacts of electric...0.5medium420.2exp_20250319_1606272
79What are the environmental impacts of electric...0.3medium420.2exp_20250319_1606272
\n", + "

80 rows × 8 columns

\n", + "
" + ], + "text/plain": [ + " query similarity_score \\\n", + "0 What are the environmental impacts of electric... 0.6 \n", + "1 What are the environmental impacts of electric... 0.5 \n", + "2 What are the environmental impacts of electric... 0.5 \n", + "3 What are the environmental impacts of electric... 0.6 \n", + "4 What are the environmental impacts of electric... 0.3 \n", + ".. ... ... \n", + "75 What are the environmental impacts of electric... 0.3 \n", + "76 What are the environmental impacts of electric... 0.4 \n", + "77 What are the environmental impacts of electric... 0.6 \n", + "78 What are the environmental impacts of electric... 0.5 \n", + "79 What are the environmental impacts of electric... 0.3 \n", + "\n", + " diversity_level branching_factor max_depth epsilon experiment_id \\\n", + "0 low 2 1 0.2 exp_20250319_160627 \n", + "1 low 2 1 0.2 exp_20250319_160627 \n", + "2 low 2 1 0.2 exp_20250319_160627 \n", + "3 low 2 1 0.2 exp_20250319_160627 \n", + "4 low 2 1 0.2 exp_20250319_160627 \n", + ".. ... ... ... ... ... \n", + "75 medium 4 2 0.2 exp_20250319_160627 \n", + "76 medium 4 2 0.2 exp_20250319_160627 \n", + "77 medium 4 2 0.2 exp_20250319_160627 \n", + "78 medium 4 2 0.2 exp_20250319_160627 \n", + "79 medium 4 2 0.2 exp_20250319_160627 \n", + "\n", + " path_length \n", + "0 1 \n", + "1 1 \n", + "2 1 \n", + "3 1 \n", + "4 1 \n", + ".. ... \n", + "75 2 \n", + "76 2 \n", + "77 2 \n", + "78 2 \n", + "79 2 \n", + "\n", + "[80 rows x 8 columns]" + ] + }, + "execution_count": 17, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "execute_result" + } + ], + "source": [ + "df" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": 22, + "id": "64b8ccc4-3db0-4cfa-a64b-1bef41e63601", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [ + { + "data": { + "text/plain": [ + "" + ] + }, + "execution_count": 22, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "execute_result" + }, + { + "data": { + "image/png": "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", + "text/plain": [ + "
" + ] + }, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "display_data" + } + ], + "source": [ + "sns.catplot(data=df, x='diversity_level', y='similarity_score', \n", + " col='branching_factor', \n", + " row = \"max_depth\",\n", + " kind='bar') " + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": 23, + "id": "1fefb07c-d5a4-472c-845f-fb4909895b7e", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [ + { + "name": "stdout", + "output_type": "stream", + "text": [ + "Loading data from experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_all_results.json...\n", + "Loaded 80 valid results\n" + ] + } + ], + "source": [ + "def load_experiment_data(filename):\n", + " \"\"\"Load experiment results from a JSON file.\"\"\"\n", + " print(f\"Loading data from {filename}...\")\n", + " \n", + " with open(filename, 'r') as f:\n", + " data = json.load(f)\n", + " \n", + " # Handle all_results file format\n", + " if isinstance(data, list):\n", + " results = data\n", + " # Handle analysis file format\n", + " elif 'summary' in data:\n", + " experiment_id = data.get('experiment_id')\n", + " all_results_file = os.path.join(os.path.dirname(filename), f\"{experiment_id}_all_results.json\")\n", + " \n", + " if os.path.exists(all_results_file):\n", + " with open(all_results_file, 'r') as f:\n", + " results = json.load(f)\n", + " else:\n", + " print(\"Error: Could not find all_results file\")\n", + " return None\n", + " else:\n", + " print(\"Error: Unrecognized file format\")\n", + " return None\n", + " \n", + " # Create DataFrame\n", + " rows = []\n", + " for result in results:\n", + " # Skip results with errors\n", + " if 'error' in result:\n", + " continue\n", + " \n", + " row = {\n", + " 'query': result.get('query', ''),\n", + " 'similarity_score': result.get('similarity_score', 0),\n", + " 'diversity_level': result.get('ibfs_config', {}).get('diversity_level', ''),\n", + " 'branching_factor': result.get('ibfs_config', {}).get('branching_factor', 0),\n", + " 'max_depth': result.get('ibfs_config', {}).get('max_depth', 0),\n", + " 'epsilon': result.get('user_config', {}).get('epsilon', 0),\n", + " 'experiment_id': result.get('experiment_id', ''), \n", + " 'pref_answer':result.get('user_preferred_answer', ''), \n", + " 'final_answer':result.get('final_answer', '')\n", + " }\n", + " \n", + " # Add strategy path information if available\n", + " if 'strategy_path' in result:\n", + " row['path_length'] = len(result.get('strategy_path', []))\n", + " \n", + " rows.append(row)\n", + " \n", + " df = pd.DataFrame(rows)\n", + " print(f\"Loaded {len(df)} valid results\")\n", + " return df\n", + "\n", + "fn = \"experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_all_results.json\"\n", + "df = load_experiment_data(fn)" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": 28, + "id": "e352fcd2-b49b-4a30-8d3c-dd1e14bfcb67", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [ + { + "name": "stderr", + "output_type": "stream", + "text": [ + "[nltk_data] Downloading package punkt to /Users/jashkina/nltk_data...\n", + "[nltk_data] Package punkt is already up-to-date!\n", + "/Users/jashkina/Documents/LocResearch/ibfs/ibfs_project/.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/nltk/translate/bleu_score.py:577: UserWarning: \n", + "The hypothesis contains 0 counts of 4-gram overlaps.\n", + "Therefore the BLEU score evaluates to 0, independently of\n", + "how many N-gram overlaps of lower order it contains.\n", + "Consider using lower n-gram order or use SmoothingFunction()\n", + " warnings.warn(_msg)\n", + "/Users/jashkina/Documents/LocResearch/ibfs/ibfs_project/.venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/nltk/translate/bleu_score.py:577: UserWarning: \n", + "The hypothesis contains 0 counts of 3-gram overlaps.\n", + "Therefore the BLEU score evaluates to 0, independently of\n", + "how many N-gram overlaps of lower order it contains.\n", + "Consider using lower n-gram order or use SmoothingFunction()\n", + " warnings.warn(_msg)\n" + ] + } + ], + "source": [ + "import pandas as pd\n", + "import numpy as np\n", + "import json\n", + "import os\n", + "import nltk\n", + "from sklearn.feature_extraction.text import TfidfVectorizer\n", + "from sklearn.metrics.pairwise import cosine_similarity\n", + "from nltk.translate.bleu_score import sentence_bleu\n", + "from rouge import Rouge\n", + "from rapidfuzz.distance import Levenshtein\n", + "\n", + "# Ensure NLTK data is available\n", + "nltk.download('punkt')\n", + "\n", + "# Load experiment data function\n", + "def load_experiment_data(filename):\n", + " \"\"\"Load experiment results from a JSON file.\"\"\"\n", + " \n", + " with open(filename, 'r') as f:\n", + " data = json.load(f)\n", + " \n", + " # Handle all_results file format\n", + " if isinstance(data, list):\n", + " results = data\n", + " # Handle analysis file format\n", + " elif 'summary' in data:\n", + " experiment_id = data.get('experiment_id')\n", + " all_results_file = os.path.join(os.path.dirname(filename), f\"{experiment_id}_all_results.json\")\n", + " \n", + " if os.path.exists(all_results_file):\n", + " with open(all_results_file, 'r') as f:\n", + " results = json.load(f)\n", + " else:\n", + " return None\n", + " else:\n", + " return None\n", + " \n", + " # Create DataFrame\n", + " rows = []\n", + " for result in results:\n", + " if 'error' in result:\n", + " continue\n", + " \n", + " row = {\n", + " 'query': result.get('query', ''),\n", + " 'similarity_score': result.get('similarity_score', 0),\n", + " 'diversity_level': result.get('ibfs_config', {}).get('diversity_level', ''),\n", + " 'branching_factor': result.get('ibfs_config', {}).get('branching_factor', 0),\n", + " 'max_depth': result.get('ibfs_config', {}).get('max_depth', 0),\n", + " 'epsilon': result.get('user_config', {}).get('epsilon', 0),\n", + " 'experiment_id': result.get('experiment_id', ''), \n", + " 'pref_answer': result.get('user_preferred_answer', ''), \n", + " 'final_answer': result.get('final_answer', '')\n", + " }\n", + " \n", + " if 'strategy_path' in result:\n", + " row['path_length'] = len(result.get('strategy_path', []))\n", + " \n", + " rows.append(row)\n", + " \n", + " df = pd.DataFrame(rows)\n", + " return df\n", + "\n", + "# Load dataset\n", + "fn = \"experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_all_results.json\"\n", + "df = load_experiment_data(fn)\n", + "\n", + "# Ensure pref_answer and final_answer exist\n", + "df = df.dropna(subset=['pref_answer', 'final_answer'])\n", + "\n", + "# Cosine similarity using TF-IDF\n", + "vectorizer = TfidfVectorizer()\n", + "tfidf_matrix = vectorizer.fit_transform(df['pref_answer'].tolist() + df['final_answer'].tolist())\n", + "tfidf_pref = tfidf_matrix[:len(df)]\n", + "tfidf_final = tfidf_matrix[len(df):]\n", + "df['cosine_similarity'] = [cosine_similarity(tfidf_pref[i], tfidf_final[i])[0, 0] for i in range(len(df))]\n", + "\n", + "# Levenshtein Distance (normalized)\n", + "df['levenshtein_distance'] = df.apply(lambda row: Levenshtein.distance(row['pref_answer'], row['final_answer']), axis=1)\n", + "df['levenshtein_ratio'] = df.apply(lambda row: Levenshtein.normalized_similarity(row['pref_answer'], row['final_answer']), axis=1)\n", + "\n", + "# Jaccard Similarity\n", + "def jaccard_similarity(str1, str2):\n", + " set1, set2 = set(str1.split()), set(str2.split())\n", + " intersection = len(set1 & set2)\n", + " union = len(set1 | set2)\n", + " return intersection / union if union != 0 else 0\n", + "\n", + "df['jaccard_similarity'] = df.apply(lambda row: jaccard_similarity(row['pref_answer'], row['final_answer']), axis=1)\n", + "\n", + "# BLEU Score\n", + "df['bleu_score'] = df.apply(lambda row: sentence_bleu(\n", + " [nltk.word_tokenize(row['pref_answer'])], \n", + " nltk.word_tokenize(row['final_answer']),\n", + " weights=(0.5, 0.5, 0, 0)), axis=1) # Bi-gram BLEU score\n", + "\n", + "# ROUGE Score\n", + "rouge = Rouge()\n", + "df['rouge_score'] = df.apply(lambda row: rouge.get_scores(row['final_answer'], row['pref_answer'])[0]['rouge-l']['f'], axis=1)\n" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": 30, + "id": "fcce9a85-ad0b-4865-a3fa-d8a95b7d2c53", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [ + { + "data": { + "image/png": "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", + "text/plain": [ + "
" + ] + }, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "display_data" + }, + { + "data": { + "image/png": "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", + "text/plain": [ + "
" + ] + }, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "display_data" + }, + { + "data": { + "image/png": "iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAArwAAAHYCAYAAACvNzuSAAAAOnRFWHRTb2Z0d2FyZQBNYXRwbG90bGliIHZlcnNpb24zLjEwLjEsIGh0dHBzOi8vbWF0cGxvdGxpYi5vcmcvc2/+5QAAAAlwSFlzAAAPYQAAD2EBqD+naQAAQRxJREFUeJzt3Qd8VMXe//HfJiFUSTBAKAECiFKkN1EEC1eKDZQrYAGRxy7KnyYoBBAeAUVFHlAUC3YR5NoQRBBQegmKXEEQgoj0LkUgyfm/fnPvLrubTUjCJrsZPu/X62h29uzZmbPnLN+dnTPrchzHEQAAAMBSEaGuAAAAAJCXCLwAAACwGoEXAAAAViPwAgAAwGoEXgAAAFiNwAsAAACrEXgBAABgNQIvAAAArEbgBQAAgNUIvACCburUqeJyuWTbtm0S7hITE+Xee+8N6ja17cOHD8/z/XHNNdeYJa/p/ilRokSeP48tQn3883oBGRF4AcASO3fuNEH7xx9/DHVVkMdOnDhhXuuFCxeGuipAgRAV6goAsM8999wjXbt2lcKFC0u4+/XXXyUiIrif/U+ePClRUXn/9jp37twMgXfEiBGm17pBgwZ5/vwIbeDV11rlRy8/UNAReAEEXWRkpFkKgrwI5UWKFJG8DjvFihWT6OjoPH0eALAFQxqAC8Sff/4pvXr1kgoVKpiQV7VqVXn44Yfl9OnTnnW2bt0q//znP+Xiiy82geqKK66QWbNmZdjW//3f/0mdOnXMOqVKlZImTZrIhx9+mOUYRu11vOmmm2Tx4sXSrFkzEwqrVasm7777bobtHz58WPr06SOVKlUydb3kkktk7Nixkp6enqM2b968WW6//XYpV66ceb6EhATT83zkyJFMx/C66671fPzxx6VMmTISGxsrDz74oNlXWrfu3bubdusycOBAcRwnyzG8gXz++edy4403el6P6tWry8iRIyUtLc1nPe29u/zyy2XNmjXSqlUrs8+feuopz33u3j39artp06bm7549e5o66KLtGTZsmBQqVEj27duXoR4PPPCAad/ff/99zv2px0fbtm2lePHipt7PPPOMp+36f92Xt956a4bH6bZjYmLMPsyK1vexxx6T6dOnS+3ataVo0aLSokUL+fnnn839r732mjkW9LXUdvuPkf3hhx/M8Vu5cmWzT/X4+X//7/+ZHne3vXv3mtdUH+/9uv3222+mXV26dJGc+Pe//y3XXXedqaseX6NGjcr0OJ09e7ZcffXV5nkuuugi8/rr4wONv81qX2u7tQ1Ke3ndr7X/MafnfMeOHc32dP3+/ftnOL6ACwU9vMAFQL/q1pCpYU0DTs2aNc0/hjNmzDC9hdpTuGfPHrnyyivNbQ16cXFx8s4778gtt9xi1uvUqZPZ1pQpU8z9nTt3lieeeMKEmXXr1smKFSvkzjvvzLIeGir0cRq8e/ToIW+99Zb5B75x48YmQCt9/tatW5v6aUDS8LJ06VIZPHiw7Nq1S8aPH5+tNms41cBw6tQp6d27twm9us2vvvrK7AcNYFlxP0YDxfLly+X11183wVDronV69tln5euvv5bnn3/eBFINwTmhQVSDSN++fc3/v/vuO0lKSpKjR4+abXo7cOCAtG/f3oT1u+++W+Lj4zNsr1atWiYU6Tb0NdZgpfQ1bdmypblv2rRpJlB67yN9bfVDwbl6pTUotWvXznwIeu6552TOnDkmSKempppta+DSuul9Bw8eNB+a3L788kvTLr3/XDS0fvHFF/Loo4+a26NHjzYflPSDxSuvvCKPPPKIHDp0yDzPfffdZ/abmwZlPX70g5wevytXrjQfznbs2GHuU2XLlpVXX33VBGO9T49lDah6HGoI1efIrt27d8u1115r9sGgQYNMONXjRMOvv/fee88c83pM6oc3rafWQ1+btWvXmg8L2d3XGl71sdpOPS9vu+0287h69er5bEOfq3nz5jJu3DiZN2+evPDCC+aDlT4OuOA4AKzXvXt3JyIiwlm1alWG+9LT083/+/Tpo91Hzg8//OC576+//nKqVq3qJCYmOmlpaabs1ltvderUqZPl87399ttmWykpKZ6yKlWqmLLvv//eU7Z3716ncOHCTr9+/TxlI0eOdIoXL+5s2rTJZ5uDBg1yIiMjne3bt2erzWvXrjXPN3369CzX03r16NEjQ93btm3r2TeqRYsWjsvlch566CFPWWpqqpOQkOC0bt3aZ5v6+GHDhmW5P06cOJGhLg8++KBTrFgx5++///aU6bb1sZMnT86wvt7n/dz6+uq6+nz+tP7Nmzf3KZs5c6ZZf8GCBVnsIcfsH12vd+/enjLdNzfeeKMTHR3t7Nu3z5T9+uuvZr1XX33V5/G33HKLOYa892cg+lg9Hrz302uvvWbKy5Ur5xw9etRTPnjw4Gzt09GjR5vX7ffff/cp79atm9nXepw9//zzZlufffaZkxPuc2bFihU+x3RMTIxP3fQ8io2Nde6//36fx+/evdus612e3X2t//c/zvy38cwzz/iUN2zY0GncuHGO2gjYgiENgOW09+qzzz6Tm2++2Qw98Kc9c0p7K7UXWHuc3LTnUXsL9SvUX375xZRpL6f2mK1atSrHddGvqd09j0p7qi677DLz9a2b9sTpOjpcYP/+/Z6lTZs2ptfq+++/z9ZzuXtwv/nmG9ObllPaC+3eN0p7yjSTabmbjlPWfepd/+zy7gX866+/TBu13VrXjRs3+qyrX8/rMIXzoT3Q2gu/ZcsWT9kHH3xgvvbXHvXs8O4ddg8/0F5i7T1Ul156qdlPul037e3Vr/Lvuusun/2Zmeuvv96nt1O3p7QXWntg/cu99733Pj1+/LjZp9rDra+b9qJ6mzhxojlG9BuHoUOHmgstAw3HyIqeM9oLq+eN9zGtbfX27bffmm8VunXr5nNM6/Gj7ViwYEGO93V2PPTQQz639fjKzbEK2IDAC1hOx23q18n6tXtWfv/9dxM+A31V7r5fPfnkkyYI6z/yNWrUMF89L1myJFt10aEA/jTY6lfU3uNu9StcDQ7eiwZe9xjM7NAxyjpc4I033pDSpUubr3cnTZrkM343J3V1B2gNiP7l3vXPLh27qV9H6+NLlixp2uj+yt+/jhUrVjzvC9R0bKoGZ3cY1efQ4R3ZDaI6k4WOufamAVd5j6XVYK3Hg/t40Q8wZ86cMYEy2Ptdee/77du3m6EJOpzCPW7VHeb996muM2HCBDMcR7elf+eUtlHPAX/+55Ee00rH+vof1zrThv8xnd19nRUdouIe55vZuQZcSBjDCyBHNADrVF4aljSYfvrpp2bco44ddU+TlJnMZm7wvnhIe6T/8Y9/mDGbgbj/4c8OHbOoAUgvENNgoeM1dUyojsnVC4xyU9dA5f4XrZ2L9vZpENOgq2MydVylBpTk5GTzgcL/oqdAY0JzSsOOjoXVwKuvlY7d1fHN2RlXmxM6zlgvFNPn0Yvr3n//fdMLHujD1Pnud+99r73/etxoj7LuQx2nrmNqddy2HgOBLiTT3n+lIVC/tdBvL/KC+7l1HK+OC/eXF1PYFZRZUoD8QuAFLKe9PBqs1q9fn+V6VapUMUHWn/vrdb3fzX01uy76NateNPO///u/5sKy852SS8PfsWPHPD2656tu3bpmGTJkiLng7KqrrpLJkyebq+lDRWdU0AvRZs6caWZecEtJSTmv7Z6rp1Z7X/Vrex2OooG0YcOGnosFsxPa9Otw7w8cmzZtMv/3HoKgPac6+4BuX3uPtbc3uxcang+dyUHroxdael9AqMMJAtEPa9r7rx+stK56QZkO+chJ+NRzwt17683/PNJj2n3BXHaO6+zs6+z0ygM4iyENgOX061GdmkivlF+9enWmPWQdOnQwV7UvW7bMZxykXnWu/8jq+FulQc2bftWu9+l29Kvr83XHHXeYOrh73/x7RvVK9ezQYRz+62rw1f2hPZuh5O598+4Z1g8OOZkhIBD9IOLeT4HoTA86vENnCVi0aFGOe3d13Kub1l1v63RnOu7Wmw5f0DHfAwYMMG3VXt9Q7FP9++WXX86wru6f//mf/zHDcnS2DQ2+2ruuf+eEnjP6bYGeN95DiLzHMCsdTqMfOnX7gc6RQNPFnWtf6/R07rYAODd6eIELgP5Dq1/p69foehGaDkvQKb50fKXON6tf5eq0Sh999JEJRfrVv/bUaW+Z9jrqsAX3r5HdcMMN5mtZ7SnV6bE2bNhg/jHWXj3vi4pyS0OSTkulX7+7pyzT4K09ePo1vI5h1NB2LjpdlV7oo9NPaU+Zhl/9SlmDkV4AFUp6IZUOMdBeRd3X2lundcvp0Ah/2pOor6X2YOtroQFYL4rS8cxKA5OGT329dD/oRVTZpT332iuqddZt6oVoOkezDlvwHyuqx4JOC6bHlx5P2rOZ13QIg7Zf55rVYQwaMPW4DTRmVafT0w9uegGY7gedAkwDsPb6aw94/fr1s/Wc2jusr5s+XrfpnpZMe351bLCb1kWnEdMPAo0aNTKvge4zHXOs+1DPJe+Am519rcNc9IOmTjWnx7eerzpO/1xj9YELVqiniQCQP3RaJp2erEyZMmbqp2rVqjmPPvqoc+rUKc86W7ZscTp37mymUCpSpIjTrFkz56uvvvLZjk4T1apVKycuLs5sp3r16s6AAQOcI0eOnHNaMp1a6VxTa7mncdJppy655BIzFVPp0qWdK6+80hk3bpxz+vTpbLV369atzn333Wfqp225+OKLnWuvvdaZN29etqYl85/CTad/0nL3tFBu+lidRi2n05ItWbLEueKKK5yiRYs6FSpUcAYOHOh88803GaYJ032T2TRwgfbd559/7tSuXduJiooKOEXZypUrTfkNN9yQ5f4L1EY9PvRxOp1XfHy8aaN7ujp/jzzyiHmeDz/8MNvPo+vrMelN95mW69Rh3nQf+U8798svvzht2rRxSpQoYY4Zne7rp59+8tkPun/09gsvvOCzPZ3yTI+F+vXrZ/sYU+vWrTOvgR5jFStWNNPqvfnmmxleb3eddbo7nYpM19dj895773VWr16dq329dOlSM82YniPex1ygY9L7GAYuRC79T6hDNwAgf/z000/SoEED8wt32Z05ITf0wrU333zT/DiD++t3nJt+q6HfZOg4dgDBwxheALiA6C/l6ZRd7l/nygv663s6O4MOHSHsAggHjOEFUODo1FN6kVdmdFym/7jSC51etKgXkukYUx3b7L7ALZh0PlkdF6s9lDpGVse1FkQnT54853zNOmb2fOdGBpB/CLwAChztndRZBjKjFw1ld4L+C0Xv3r1lz549ZmaBc82XnFsaqHUqMr1ITX/IQYdOFER6Idi5ftlOfx3tmmuuybc6ATg/jOEFUOCsWbMmy1+M0ivY9cp3IDd0BhP9Jbys6OwhOtMGgIKBwAsAAACrMaQhk1+52blzp5nHkl+zAQAACD/aZ/vXX39JhQoVPHPFZ4bAG4CG3UqVKoW6GgAAADiHP/74QxISErJch8AbgPvXonQH6i/kAAAAILzoT8hrB2V2fuWTwBuAexiDhl0CLwAAQPjKzvBTfngCAAAAViPwAgAAwGoEXgAAAFiNwAsAAACrEXgBAABgNQIvAAAArEbgBQAAgNUIvAAAALAagRcAAABWI/ACAADAagReAAAAWI3ACwAAAKsReAEAAGA1Ai8AAACsRuAFAACA1Qi8AAAAsFpUqCsAuyQOmhXqKuACsW3MjaGuAgCggKCHFwAAAFYj8AIAAMBqBF4AAABYjcALAAAAqxF4AQAAYDUCLwAAAKxG4AUAAIDVCLwAAACwGoEXAAAAViPwAgAAwGoEXgAAAFiNwAsAAACrEXgBAABgNQIvAAAArEbgBQAAgNUIvAAAALAagRcAAABWI/ACAADAagReAAAAWI3ACwAAAKuFReCdNGmSJCYmSpEiRaR58+aycuXKTNedMmWKXH311VKqVCmztGnTJsP6juNIUlKSlC9fXooWLWrW2bx5cz60BAAAAOEm5IF32rRp0rdvXxk2bJgkJydL/fr1pW3btrJ3796A6y9cuFC6desmCxYskGXLlkmlSpXkhhtukD///NOzznPPPScTJkyQyZMny4oVK6R48eJmm3///Xc+tgwAAADhwOVod2gIaY9u06ZNZeLEieZ2enq6CbG9e/eWQYMGnfPxaWlppqdXH9+9e3fTu1uhQgXp16+f9O/f36xz5MgRiY+Pl6lTp0rXrl3Puc2jR49KTEyMeVzJkiWD0MoLR+KgWaGuAi4Q28bcGOoqAABCKCd5LUpC6PTp07JmzRoZPHiwpywiIsIMQdDe2+w4ceKEnDlzRi6++GJzOyUlRXbv3m224aY7Q4O1bjNQ4D116pRZvHegSk1NNYu7XrpoINfFu766aPD2/uyQWXlkZKS4XC7Pdr3Lla6fnfKoqCizXe9y3a6u71/HzMrzok2FIs6Wp6aL6K1Cft8jnEkXcWkbMpS7xCWOT7k+TarjkghxJDJQucuRSN3Yf6U7ImmOSyJdjkR4lac5ep9LolyOuLzL00XSJWP5f+ru8mkPbQqvNunxZvv5RJtoE22iTbRJMm2T//phG3j3799vGqG9r9709saNG7O1jSeffNL06LoDroZd9zb8t+m+z9/o0aNlxIgRGcrXrl1rhkOoMmXKSPXq1U2g3rdvn2edhIQEs2zatMl8wnCrVq2alC1bVtavXy8nT570lNesWVNiY2PNtr1fwHr16kl0dLSsXr3apw5NmjQxHwzWrVvn80Jrr7g+n/d+0vHKOiRE9+vWrVt9An+tWrVk586dsmPHDk95XrTp3hpnD/gZKRFyLFV8ytTUzRFSIkqkc9V0n3A1dXOkVCwu0j7hbPnh0yLTUyKlRowjrcqdPTl2nBCZ/UekNIxzpFHc2fJfj7jk+90uuSrekctizpYnH3DJmv0u+UdCuiQUO1sXXVcf0ykxXWKjz5bP3hEhO46L3FU93ScI0qbwaZOeK7afT7SJNtEm2kSbojNtk65fIIY06I6rWLGiLF26VFq0aOEpHzhwoCxatMiMv83KmDFjzHhdHderO0Xptq666iqzbb1oze2OO+4wnx50zHB2enh1WMWBAwc8XeSh/hRTUD6Z1UqaU+B7Dm3sDbWxTRueaWf9+USbaBNtok20STJt06FDhyQuLi78hzSULl3aVHrPnj0+5Xq7XLlyWT523LhxJvDOmzfPE3aV+3G6De/Aq7cbNGgQcFuFCxc2iz89GHTx5n6x/Ll3fnbL/bebm3I9OAKVZ1bHnJbnpk0ahvxpcPLnZFruCliuYSc9ULnjMuHJn4YpDU/+NHxJDsoDtUcyrTttys82eR/7tp5P51tOm2hTVnWnTbTJZWGbwnKWBu2mbty4scyfP99Tpp8Q9LZ3j68/7dUdOXKkzJkzx3Rre6tataoJvd7b1B5b7S3OapsAAACwU0h7eJVOSdajRw8TXJs1aybjx4+X48ePS8+ePc39OvOCDnvQcbZq7NixZo7dDz/80Mzd6x6XW6JECbPop5U+ffrIqFGjpEaNGiYADx061Izz7dixY0jbCgAAgAsw8Hbp0sUMdNYQq+FVhx1oz637orPt27f7dJO/+uqrZqBy586dfbaj8/gOHz7cMwZYQ/MDDzwghw8flpYtW5pt6g9bAAAA4MIS8nl4wxHz8OYe8/AivzAPLwBc2I7mIK+F/JfWAAAAgLxE4AUAAIDVCLwAAACwGoEXAAAAViPwAgAAwGoEXgAAAFiNwAsAAACrhfyHJwAACGfML478wvzieYceXgAAAFiNwAsAAACrEXgBAABgNQIvAAAArEbgBQAAgNUIvAAAALAagRcAAABWI/ACAADAagReAAAAWI3ACwAAAKsReAEAAGA1Ai8AAACsRuAFAACA1Qi8AAAAsBqBFwAAAFYj8AIAAMBqBF4AAABYjcALAAAAqxF4AQAAYDUCLwAAAKxG4AUAAIDVCLwAAACwGoEXAAAAViPwAgAAwGoEXgAAAFiNwAsAAACrEXgBAABgNQIvAAAArEbgBQAAgNUIvAAAALAagRcAAABWI/ACAADAagReAAAAWI3ACwAAAKsReAEAAGA1Ai8AAACsRuAFAACA1Qi8AAAAsBqBFwAAAFYj8AIAAMBqBF4AAABYjcALAAAAqxF4AQAAYDUCLwAAAKxG4AUAAIDVCLwAAACwGoEXAAAAViPwAgAAwGoEXgAAAFiNwAsAAACrEXgBAABgNQIvAAAArEbgBQAAgNUIvAAAALAagRcAAABWI/ACAADAagReAAAAWI3ACwAAAKsReAEAAGA1Ai8AAACsRuAFAACA1Qi8AAAAsBqBFwAAAFYj8AIAAMBqBF4AAABYjcALAAAAqxF4AQAAYLWwCLyTJk2SxMREKVKkiDRv3lxWrlyZ6br//ve/5fbbbzfru1wuGT9+fIZ1hg8fbu7zXmrWrJnHrQAAAEA4CnngnTZtmvTt21eGDRsmycnJUr9+fWnbtq3s3bs34PonTpyQatWqyZgxY6RcuXKZbrdOnTqya9cuz7J48eI8bAUAAADCVVSoK/Diiy/K/fffLz179jS3J0+eLLNmzZK33npLBg0alGH9pk2bmkUFut8tKioqy0Ds7dSpU2ZxO3r0qPl/amqqWVRERIRZ0tPTzeLmLk9LSxPHcc5ZHhkZaXqc3dv1Lle6fnbKtX26Xe9y3a6u71/HzMrzok2FIs6Wp6aL6K1Cfh+rzqSLuLQNGcpd4hLHp1yfJtVxSYQ4Ehmo3OVIpG7sv9IdkTTHJZEuRyK8ytMcvc8lUS5HXN7l6SLpkrH8P3V3+bSHNoVXm/R4s/18ok3h0Sbz3JafT7QpPNrkfY7Yej5FBLFN/uuHbeA9ffq0rFmzRgYPHuwp0x3Rpk0bWbZs2Xlte/PmzVKhQgUzTKJFixYyevRoqVy5csB19b4RI0ZkKF+7dq0UL17c/F2mTBmpXr26pKSkyL59+zzrJCQkmGXTpk1y5MgRT7n2QpctW1bWr18vJ0+e9JTr0IrY2Fizbe8XsF69ehIdHS2rV6/2qUOTJk3Mflq3bp3PC62hX59v48aNnvKiRYuaHvL9+/fL1q1bPeUxMTFSq1Yt2blzp+zYscNTnhdturfG2QN+RkqEHEsVnzI1dXOElIgS6Vw13edNZurmSKlYXKR9wtnyw6dFpqdESo0YR1qVO3ty7DghMvuPSGkY50ijuLPlvx5xyfe7XXJVvCOXxZwtTz7gkjX7XfKPhHRJKHa2LrquPqZTYrrERp8tn70jQnYcF7mrerrPGyJtCp826bli+/lEm8KjTcr284k2hUebvM8FW8+nskFsk66fXS7HO2LnM91xFStWlKVLl5pQ6jZw4EBZtGiRrFixIsvH6zjePn36mMXb7Nmz5dixY3LZZZeZ4QwaZv/880+zgy+66KJs9fBWqlRJDhw4ICVLlgyLTzEF5ZNZraQ5Yf8J2sZegQuxTRueaWf9+USbwqNN1Z6abf35RJvCo00bR7az/nyKCGKbDh06JHFxcSZUu/Na2A5pyAvt27f3+XSgF8JVqVJFPvnkE+nVq1eG9QsXLmwWf3ow6OLN/WL5c+/87Jb7bzc35XpwBCrPrI45Lc9Nm/RNwZ++gfhzMi13BSzXN7L0QOWOy7yJ+NM3FX0T8advQpKD8kDtkUzrTpvys03ex76t59P5ltOm4LXJ9vPJt+60KVRtCnRs23g+ReZhm8LyorXSpUubRu/Zs8enXG9nd/xtdmg3+aWXXiq//fZb0LYJAACAgiGkgVfHZTRu3Fjmz5/vKdMucb3tPcThfOnwhi1btkj58uWDtk0AAAAUDCEf0qBTkvXo0cMMQG7WrJmZV/f48eOeWRu6d+9uxvnqhWVKByn/8ssvnr91bO6PP/4oJUqUkEsuucSU9+/fX26++WYzjEHHCeuUZ9qT3K1btxC2FAAAABdk4O3SpYu5si8pKUl2794tDRo0kDlz5kh8fLy5f/v27T7jQjTANmzY0HN73LhxZmndurUsXLjQlOkVhBpu9aIzvYKwZcuWsnz5cvM3AAAALiwhD7zqscceM0sg7hDrPTPDuSaW+Pjjj4NaPwAAABRcIf+lNQAAACDsAq+OsQUAAACsDbw6vva+++6TxYsXB79GAAAAQKgD7/vvvy8HDx6U6667zsxvO2bMGHMxGQAAAGBF4O3YsaN89tlnZkqwhx56SD788EMzBdhNN90kM2fOzPDTcAAAAECBvGhNp/nSeXTXrVsnL774osybN086d+4sFSpUMNOMnThxIng1BQAAAPJ7WjL9CeB33nlHpk6dKr///rsJu7169TLz4I4dO9bMfTt37tzzeQoAAAAg/wOvDlt4++235ZtvvpHatWvLI488InfffbfExsZ61rnyyiulVq1a51c7AAAAIBSBV3/2t2vXrrJkyRJp2rRpwHV0WMPTTz99vvUDAAAA8j/w7tq1S4oVK5blOkWLFpVhw4bltl4AAABA6C5au+iii2Tv3r0Zyg8cOCCRkZHBqBcAAAAQusDrOE7A8lOnTkl0dPT51gkAAAAIzZCGCRMmmP+7XC554403pESJEp770tLS5Pvvv5eaNWsGr3YAAABAfgbel156ydPDO3nyZJ/hC9qzm5iYaMoBAACAAhl4U1JSzP+vvfZaMzVZqVKl8qpeAAAAQOhmaViwYEFwnh0AAAAIl8CrPyE8cuRIKV68uPk7K/ozwwAAAECBCrxr166VM2fOmL+Tk5PNhWuBZFYOAAAAhHXg9R7GsHDhwryqDwAAABDaeXi1lzcqKkrWr18f3JoAAAAA4RB4CxUqJJUrVzbz7gIAAABW/tLa008/LU899ZQcPHgw+DUCAAAAQj0t2cSJE+W3336TChUqSJUqVczMDd70ojYAAACgwAbejh07Br8mAAAAQLgE3mHDhgW/JgAAAEC4jOEFAAAArO7h1RkaXnrpJfnkk09k+/btcvr0aZ/7uZgNAAAABbqHd8SIEebng7t06SJHjhwxPzV82223SUREhAwfPjz4tQQAAADyM/B+8MEHMmXKFOnXr5/5EYpu3brJG2+8IUlJSbJ8+fLc1gUAAAAIj8C7e/duqVu3rvm7RIkSppdX3XTTTTJr1qzg1hAAAADI78CbkJAgu3btMn9Xr15d5s6da/5etWqVFC5c+HzqAwAAAIQ+8Hbq1Enmz59v/u7du7cMHTpUatSoId27d5f77rsvuDUEAAAA8nuWhjFjxnj+1gvXKleuLMuWLTOh9+abbz6f+gAAAAChD7z+WrRoYRYAAACgwAbeL774ItsbveWWW3JbHwAAACA0gbdjx47ZWs/lcpkfpgAAAAAKVOBNT0/P25oAAAAA4TJLAwAAAGBdD++ECRPkgQcekCJFipi/s/L4448Ho24AAABA/gXel156Se666y4TePXvrMbwEngBAABQ4AJvSkpKwL8BAACAcMYYXgAAAFgtVz884TiOzJgxQxYsWCB79+7NMIPDzJkzg1U/AAAAIP8Db58+feS1116Ta6+9VuLj4824XQAAAMCawPvee++ZXtwOHToEv0YAAABAqMfwxsTESLVq1YJZDwAAACB8Au/w4cNlxIgRcvLkyeDXCAAAAAj1kIY77rhDPvroIylbtqwkJiZKoUKFfO5PTk4OVv0AAACA/A+8PXr0kDVr1sjdd9/NRWsAAACwL/DOmjVLvvnmG2nZsmXwawQAAACEegxvpUqVpGTJksGsBwAAABA+gfeFF16QgQMHyrZt24JfIwAAACDUQxp07O6JEyekevXqUqxYsQwXrR08eDBY9QMAAADyP/COHz/+/J4VAAAACPdZGgAAAACrAu/Ro0c9F6rp31nhgjYAAAAUuMBbqlQp2bVrl/mxidjY2IBz7zqOY8rT0tKCXU8AAAAgbwPvd999JxdffLH5e8GCBbl7NgAAACBcA2/r1q0D/g0AAABYNw/vnDlzZPHixZ7bkyZNkgYNGsidd94phw4dCmb9AAAAgPwPvAMGDPBcuPbzzz9L3759pUOHDpKSkmL+BgAAAAr0tGQabGvXrm3+/vTTT+Xmm2+WZ599VpKTk03wBQAAAAp0D290dLT5pTU1b948ueGGG8zfelHbuaYsAwAAAMK+h7dly5Zm6MJVV10lK1eulGnTppnyTZs2SUJCQrDrCAAAAORvD+/EiRMlKipKZsyYIa+++qpUrFjRlM+ePVvatWuX+9oAAAAA4dDDW7lyZfnqq68ylL/00ks+t8eMGSMPPfSQ+aEKAAAAoMD08GaXXsh28ODBvHwKAAAAIHSBV39qGAAAALA28AIAAAChRuAFAACA1Qi8AAAAsBqBFwAAAFbL08B79dVXS9GiRfPyKQAAAIC8CbxbtmyRIUOGSLdu3WTv3r2eH57497//7Vnn66+/lvLly+f2KQAAAIDQBN5FixZJ3bp1ZcWKFTJz5kw5duyYKf/pp59k2LBhOd7epEmTJDExUYoUKSLNmzc3P1ecGQ3Ut99+u1nf5XLJ+PHjz3ubAAAAsFeuAu+gQYNk1KhR8u2330p0dLSn/LrrrpPly5fnaFvTpk2Tvn37mqCcnJws9evXl7Zt23p6jf2dOHFCqlWrZn7FrVy5ckHZJgAAAOyVq8D7888/S6dOnTKUly1bVvbv35+jbb344oty//33S8+ePaV27doyefJkKVasmLz11lsB12/atKk8//zz0rVrVylcuHBQtgkAAAB7ReXmQbGxsbJr1y6pWrWqT/natWulYsWK2d7O6dOnZc2aNTJ48GBPWUREhLRp00aWLVuWm6rlapunTp0yi9vRo0fN/1NTU83i3oYu6enpZvHeti5paWk+vyyXWXlkZKQZiuHerne50vWzUx4VFWW2612u29X1/euYWXletKlQxNny1HQRvVXI72PVmXQRl7YhQ7lLXOL4lOvTpDouiRBHIgOVuxyJ1I39V7ojkua4JNLlSIRXeZqj97kkyuWIy7s8XSRdMpb/p+4un/bQpvBqkx5vtp9PtCk82mSe2/LziTaFR5u8zxFbz6eIILbJf/2gB17tXX3yySdl+vTppoLayCVLlkj//v2le/fu2d6O9gZrI+Lj433K9fbGjRtzU7VcbXP06NEyYsSIDOUa4IsXL27+LlOmjFSvXl1SUlJk3759nnUSEhLMsmnTJjly5IinXIddaI/3+vXr5eTJk57ymjVrmg8Mum3vF7BevXpmeMjq1at96tCkSRMT4tetW+fzQmtPtz6fd5t0RgwdvqH7YOvWrZ7ymJgYqVWrluzcuVN27NjhKc+LNt1b4+wBPyMlQo6lik+Zmro5QkpEiXSumu7zJjN1c6RULC7SPuFs+eHTItNTIqVGjCOtyp09OXacEJn9R6Q0jHOkUdzZ8l+PuOT73S65Kt6Ry2LOlicfcMma/S75R0K6JBQ7WxddVx/TKTFdYs+OzpHZOyJkx3GRu6qn+7wh0qbwaZOeK7afT7QpPNqkbD+faFN4tMn7XLD1fCobxDbp+tnlcrwjdjbpkzz66KMydepUUzH9lKD/v/POO02ZO3mfi+447RFeunSptGjRwlM+cOBAc2GcXhSXFb0orU+fPmY5n20G6uGtVKmSHDhwQEqWLBkWn2IKyiezWklzwv4TtI29AhdimzY8087684k2hUebqj012/rziTaFR5s2jmxn/fkUEcQ2HTp0SOLi4kyodue1oPbwatqeMmWKDB061KR0naWhYcOGUqNGjRxtp3Tp0qbSe/bs8SnX25ldkJYX29SxwIHGA+vBoIs394vlL7OQn1m5/3ZzU64HR6DyzOqY0/LctEnfFPzpG4g/J9NyV8ByfSNLD1TuuMybiD99U9E3EX/6JiQ5KA/UHsm07rQpP9vkfezbej6dbzltCl6bbD+ffOtOm0LVpkDHto3nU2QetilPfniicuXK0qFDB7njjjtyHHbdwblx48Yyf/58T5l+QtDb3r2zod4mAAAACq5c9fBq17IOXdAQqVN9eXdjq++++y7b29Lpw3r06GHGYzRr1szMq3v8+HEzw4LSMcE6REHH2bqHU/zyyy+ev//880/58ccfpUSJEnLJJZdka5sAAAC4cOQq8D7xxBMm8N54441y+eWXmy7x3OrSpYsZ6JyUlCS7d++WBg0ayJw5czwXnW3fvt2nm1zH6OrwCbdx48aZpXXr1rJw4cJsbRMAAAAXjlxdtKbjZN99910znMFGetGaXpGYnUHQ8JU4aFaoq4ALxLYxN4a6CrhA8L6G/ML7Wt7ltYjcjpN1Dx8AAAAAwlmuAm+/fv3k5Zdf9plSAgAAALBmDO/ixYtlwYIFMnv2bKlTp44UKlTI5/6ZM2cGq34AAABAaH5auFOnTuf3zAAAAEC4Bt633347+DUBAAAA8sB5/fAEAAAAYE0Pb6NGjcwPTZQqVcrMg5vV3LvJycnBqh8AAACQP4H31ltvlcKFC5u/O3bseH7PCgAAAIRb4B02bFjAvwEAAADrxvD+8ccfsmPHDs/tlStXSp8+feT1118PZt0AAACA0ATeO++808zDq3bv3i1t2rQxoffpp5+WZ5555vxrBQAAAIQy8K5fv16aNWtm/v7kk0+kbt26snTpUvnggw9k6tSpwaobAAAAEJrAe+bMGc8FbPPmzZNbbrnF/F2zZk3ZtWvX+dcKAAAACGXg1Z8Tnjx5svzwww/y7bffSrt27Uz5zp07JS4uLlh1AwAAAEITeMeOHSuvvfaaXHPNNdKtWzepX7++Kf/iiy88Qx0AAACAAvvTwhp09+/fL0ePHjU/ROH2wAMPSLFixYJZPwAAACD/A6+KjIyU1NRUWbx4sbl92WWXSWJiYjDrBgAAAIRmSMPx48flvvvuk/Lly0urVq3MUqFCBenVq5ecOHHi/GsFAAAAhDLw9u3bVxYtWiRffvmlHD582Cyff/65KevXr1+w6gYAAACEZkjDp59+KjNmzDBjed06dOggRYsWlTvuuENeffXV868ZAAAAEKoeXh22EB8fn6G8bNmyDGkAAABAwQ+8LVq0kGHDhsnff//tKTt58qSMGDHC3AcAAAAU6CEN48ePNz82kZCQ4JmD96effjK/vjZ37txg1xEAAADI38Bbt25d2bx5s3zwwQeyceNGU6Y/QHHXXXeZcbwAAABAgQ68o0ePNmN477//fp/yt956S/bt2ydPPvlksOoHAAAA5P8YXv1Z4Zo1a2Yor1OnjkyePPn8agQAAACEOvDu3r3b/OiEvzJlysiuXbuCUS8AAAAgdIG3UqVKsmTJkgzlWqa/uAYAAAAU6DG8Ona3T58+cubMGbnuuutM2fz582XgwIH80hoAAAAKfuAdMGCAHDhwQB555BE5ffq0KStSpIi5WG3w4MHBriMAAACQv4HX5XLJ2LFjZejQobJhwwYzFVmNGjXMPLwAAABAgQ+8biVKlJCmTZsGrzYAAABAOFy0BgAAABQUBF4AAABYjcALAAAAqxF4AQAAYDUCLwAAAKxG4AUAAIDVCLwAAACwGoEXAAAAViPwAgAAwGoEXgAAAFiNwAsAAACrEXgBAABgNQIvAAAArEbgBQAAgNUIvAAAALAagRcAAABWI/ACAADAagReAAAAWI3ACwAAAKsReAEAAGA1Ai8AAACsRuAFAACA1Qi8AAAAsBqBFwAAAFYj8AIAAMBqBF4AAABYjcALAAAAqxF4AQAAYDUCLwAAAKxG4AUAAIDVCLwAAACwGoEXAAAAViPwAgAAwGoEXgAAAFiNwAsAAACrEXgBAABgNQIvAAAArEbgBQAAgNUIvAAAALAagRcAAABWI/ACAADAagReAAAAWC0sAu+kSZMkMTFRihQpIs2bN5eVK1dmuf706dOlZs2aZv26devK119/7XP/vffeKy6Xy2dp165dHrcCAAAA4SjkgXfatGnSt29fGTZsmCQnJ0v9+vWlbdu2snfv3oDrL126VLp16ya9evWStWvXSseOHc2yfv16n/U04O7atcuzfPTRR/nUIgAAAISTkAfeF198Ue6//37p2bOn1K5dWyZPnizFihWTt956K+D6L7/8sgmzAwYMkFq1asnIkSOlUaNGMnHiRJ/1ChcuLOXKlfMspUqVyqcWAQAAIJxEhfLJT58+LWvWrJHBgwd7yiIiIqRNmzaybNmygI/Rcu0R9qY9wp999plP2cKFC6Vs2bIm6F533XUyatQoiYuLC7jNU6dOmcXt6NGj5v+pqalmcddLl/T0dLN411eXtLQ0cRznnOWRkZFmiIV7u97lStfPTnlUVJTZrne5blfX969jZuV50aZCEWfLU9NF9FYhv49VZ9JFXNqGDOUucYnjU65Pk+q4JEIciQxU7nIkUjf2X+mOSJrjkkiXIxFe5WmO3ueSKJcjLu/ydJF0yVj+n7q7fNpDm8KrTXq82X4+0abwaJN5bsvPJ9oUHm3yPkdsPZ8igtgm//XDNvDu37/fNCI+Pt6nXG9v3Lgx4GN2794dcH0td9Me4Ntuu02qVq0qW7Zskaeeekrat29vwrJ7J3kbPXq0jBgxIkO5DpkoXry4+btMmTJSvXp1SUlJkX379nnWSUhIMMumTZvkyJEjnvJq1aqZwK1DLU6ePOkp17HHsbGxZtveL2C9evUkOjpaVq9e7VOHJk2amA8G69at85RpG5o2bWqez3s/FS1a1AwJ0f26detWT3lMTIzpDd+5c6fs2LHDU54Xbbq3xtkDfkZKhBxLFZ8yNXVzhJSIEulcNd3nTWbq5kipWFykfcLZ8sOnRaanREqNGEdalTt7cuw4ITL7j0hpGOdIo7iz5b8eccn3u11yVbwjl8WcLU8+4JI1+13yj4R0SSh2ti66rj6mU2K6xEafLZ+9I0J2HBe5q3q6zxsibQqfNum5Yvv5RJvCo03K9vOJNoVHm7zPBVvPp7JBbJOun10uxzti5zPdcRUrVjTjclu0aOEpHzhwoCxatEhWrFiR4THa8HfeeceM43V75ZVXTGDds2dPwOfRF01fkHnz5sn111+frR7eSpUqyYEDB6RkyZJh8SmmoHwyq5U0J+w/QdvYK3AhtmnDM+2sP59oU3i0qdpTs60/n2hTeLRp48h21p9PEUFs06FDh8y39xqq3XktLHt4S5cubSrtH1T1to67DUTLc7K++xOFPtdvv/0WMPDqeF9d/OnBoIs394vlL1DPcVbl/tvNTbkeHIHKM6tjTstz0yZ9U/CnbyD+nEzLXQHL9Y0sPVC54zJvIv70TUXfRPzpm5DkoDxQeyTTutOm/GyT97Fv6/l0vuW0KXhtsv188q07bQpVmwId2zaeT5F52KawvGhNe2sbN24s8+fP95TpJwS97d3j603LvddX3377babrK+1+197a8uXLB7H2AAAAKAhCPkuDXoA2ZcoUM0xhw4YN8vDDD8vx48fNrA2qe/fuPhe1PfHEEzJnzhx54YUXzLiT4cOHm7Edjz32mLn/2LFjZgaH5cuXy7Zt20w4vvXWW+WSSy4xF7cBAADgwhLSIQ2qS5cuZqBzUlKSufCsQYMGJtC6L0zbvn27Tzf5lVdeKR9++KEMGTLEXIxWo0YNM0PD5Zdf7ukm14HZGqAPHz4sFSpUkBtuuMFMXxZo2AIAAADsFtKL1sKVXrSmVyRmZxA0fCUOmhXqKuACsW3MjaGuAi4QvK8hv/C+lnd5LeRDGgAAAIC8ROAFAACA1Qi8AAAAsBqBFwAAAFYj8AIAAMBqBF4AAABYjcALAAAAqxF4AQAAYDUCLwAAAKxG4AUAAIDVCLwAAACwGoEXAAAAViPwAgAAwGoEXgAAAFiNwAsAAACrEXgBAABgNQIvAAAArEbgBQAAgNUIvAAAALAagRcAAABWI/ACAADAagReAAAAWI3ACwAAAKsReAEAAGA1Ai8AAACsRuAFAACA1Qi8AAAAsBqBFwAAAFYj8AIAAMBqBF4AAABYjcALAAAAqxF4AQAAYDUCLwAAAKxG4AUAAIDVCLwAAACwGoEXAAAAViPwAgAAwGoEXgAAAFiNwAsAAACrEXgBAABgNQIvAAAArEbgBQAAgNUIvAAAALAagRcAAABWI/ACAADAagReAAAAWI3ACwAAAKsReAEAAGA1Ai8AAACsRuAFAACA1Qi8AAAAsBqBFwAAAFYj8AIAAMBqBF4AAABYjcALAAAAqxF4AQAAYDUCLwAAAKxG4AUAAIDVCLwAAACwGoEXAAAAViPwAgAAwGoEXgAAAFiNwAsAAACrEXgBAABgNQIvAAAArEbgBQAAgNUIvAAAALAagRcAAABWI/ACAADAagReAAAAWI3ACwAAAKsReAEAAGA1Ai8AAACsRuAFAACA1Qi8AAAAsFpYBN5JkyZJYmKiFClSRJo3by4rV67Mcv3p06dLzZo1zfp169aVr7/+2ud+x3EkKSlJypcvL0WLFpU2bdrI5s2b87gVAAAACEchD7zTpk2Tvn37yrBhwyQ5OVnq168vbdu2lb179wZcf+nSpdKtWzfp1auXrF27Vjp27GiW9evXe9Z57rnnZMKECTJ58mRZsWKFFC9e3Gzz77//zseWAQAAIBy4HO0ODSHt0W3atKlMnDjR3E5PT5dKlSpJ7969ZdCgQRnW79Klixw/fly++uorT9kVV1whDRo0MAFXm1OhQgXp16+f9O/f39x/5MgRiY+Pl6lTp0rXrl0zbPPUqVNmcdP1K1euLCkpKVKyZElTFhERYRatny5u7vK0tDTz3Ocqj4yMFJfLJampqT510HKl62enPCoqymzXu1y3q+v71zGz8rxoU9P/necpT00X0bUK+X2sOpMu4tI2ZCh3iUscn3J9mlTHJRHiSGSgcpcjkbqx/0p3RNIcl0S6HInwKk9z9D6XRLkccXmXp4ukS8by/9TdJYUifE8P2hQ+bVr1dBvrzyfaFB5tqjfiW+vPJ9oUHm1aPaSN9edTRBDbdOjQIalataocPnxYYmJiJEtOCJ06dcqJjIx0/vWvf/mUd+/e3bnlllsCPqZSpUrOSy+95FOWlJTk1KtXz/y9ZcsW3YPO2rVrfdZp1aqV8/jjjwfc5rBhw8xjWFhYWFhYWFhYpEAtf/zxxzkzZ5SE0P79+01q195Xb3p748aNAR+ze/fugOtruft+d1lm6/gbPHiwGVbhpp9SDh48KHFxceYTB5BXjh49ar7R+OOPPzzfJgBAQcb7GvKL9hL/9ddf5pv9cwlp4A0XhQsXNou32NjYkNUHFx79R4F/GADYhPc15IdzDmUIh4vWSpcubcZh7Nmzx6dcb5crVy7gY7Q8q/Xd/8/JNgEAAGCvkAbe6Ohoady4scyfP99nOIHebtGiRcDHaLn3+urbb7/1rK+DlzXYeq+jX6/obA2ZbRMAAAD2CvmQBh0726NHD2nSpIk0a9ZMxo8fb2Zh6Nmzp7m/e/fuUrFiRRk9erS5/cQTT0jr1q3lhRdekBtvvFE+/vhjWb16tbz++uvmfh1z26dPHxk1apTUqFHDBOChQ4ea8R06fRkQTnQojU7J5z+kBgAKKt7XEI5CPi2Z0inJnn/+eXNRmU4vpnPo6nRl6pprrjE/SqFTinn/8MSQIUNk27ZtJtTqvLsdOnTw3K9N0pNNQ7BOVdGyZUt55ZVX5NJLLw1J+wAAAHCBB14AAADA2l9aAwAAAPISgRcAAABWI/ACAADAagReAAAAWI3ACwAAAKsReAEAQNAw+RPCUch/eAK40KSlpZmf1AYAW+gPRukvpWrYLVmyZKirA2RADy+QjzZt2mR+TXDXrl2hrgoABMUvv/wit912m/kV1Fq1askHH3xgyunpRTihhxfIJ7/99pu0aNFCDh06JAcOHDA/q126dOlQVwsAzivstmrVSrp37y5NmjSRNWvWSM+ePaVOnTrml1OBcMEvrQH59HXf448/br7ya9q0qTz22GPSv39/GThwIKEXQIF08OBB6datm9SsWVNefvllT/m1114rdevWlQkTJpheXpfLFdJ6AooeXiAfRERESOPGjSUuLk66dOliQm7Xrl3NfYReAAXRmTNn5PDhw9K5c2dzWz/Q63td1apVTRhWhF2ECwIvkA+KFi0qPXr0kOLFi5vbd9xxh+n50N4R/f+gQYNMGNZ/MH7//XfzDwYAhLP4+Hh5//33pUaNGp4LcjXwVqxY0byPeTt27JiUKFEiRDUFCLxAvnGHXfc/CtrTq2H3zjvvNL0gffr0kXHjxpl/KN577z0pVqxYqKsMAFlyh139sF6oUCHzt76v7d2717PO6NGjpXDhwmZYV1QUsQOhwZEH5DOdkkz/QdB/IHRYg4bde+65R7744gvZsmWLrFq1irALoEDRD/He43X1tkpKSpJRo0bJ2rVrCbsIKaYlA0JA/1HQRf+B0J7eq6++Wvbt2yfJyclc2QygQHJfA6/BtlKlSuYbq+eee05Wr14t9evXD3X1cIHj4xYQIhp4dXjDgAEDZMGCBfLjjz+aK5sBoCBy9+rq0IYpU6aYH6BYvHixNGrUKNRVA+jhBUJN56vUnt169eqFuioAcN7atm1r/r906VIzNy8QDpiHFwgx5qkEYOPc4+4LdYFwQOAFAACA1RjSAAAAAKsReAEAAGA1Ai8AAACsRuAFAACA1Qi8AAAAsBqBFwAAAFYj8ALABWjq1KkSGxubL8917733SseOHfPluQAgEAIvACAotm3bZn5ERX8mGwDCCYEXAAAAViPwAkCQXXPNNdK7d2/p06ePlCpVSuLj42XKlCnm51Z79uwpF110kVxyySUye/Zss35aWpr06tVLqlatKkWLFpXLLrtMXn75Zc/2/v77b6lTp4488MADnrItW7aY7bz11lvZHsJQuXJlKVasmHTq1EkOHDiQYZ3PP/9cGjVqJEWKFJFq1arJiBEjJDU11XO/9t6++uqr0r59e1NPXWfGjBme+7X+qmHDhmZd3Q/exo0bJ+XLl5e4uDh59NFH5cyZMznarwCQa/rTwgCA4GndurVz0UUXOSNHjnQ2bdpk/h8ZGem0b9/eef31103Zww8/7MTFxTnHjx93Tp8+7SQlJTmrVq1ytm7d6rz//vtOsWLFnGnTpnm2uXbtWic6Otr57LPPnNTUVOeKK65wOnXqlK36LF++3ImIiHDGjh3r/Prrr87LL7/sxMbGOjExMZ51vv/+e6dkyZLO1KlTnS1btjhz5851EhMTneHDh3vW0X8ytM5Tpkwx2xkyZIhp1y+//GLuX7lypVln3rx5zq5du5wDBw6Y8h49ephtP/TQQ86GDRucL7/80rRP9wUA5AcCLwDkQeBt2bKl57YG1OLFizv33HOPp0wDoYbDZcuWBdzGo48+6tx+++0+Zc8995xTunRp57HHHnPKly/v7N+/P1v16datm9OhQwefsi5duvgE3uuvv9559tlnfdZ57733zPO4aX01tHpr3ry5Ce8qJSXFrKPh3JsG3ipVqpj94PbPf/7T1AEA8gNDGgAgD9SrV8/zd2RkpPkav27dup4yHeag9u7da/4/adIkady4sZQpU0ZKlCghr7/+umzfvt1nm/369ZNLL71UJk6caIYy6DazY8OGDdK8eXOfshYtWvjc/umnn+SZZ54xz+1e7r//ftm1a5ecOHEi08fpbd3+ueiQDN0Pbjq0wd12AMhrUXn+DABwASpUqJDPbR3T6l2mt1V6erp8/PHH0r9/f3nhhRdMgNSxuc8//7ysWLHCZxsaEDdt2mSC4+bNm6Vdu3ZBq++xY8fMmN3bbrstw306pjcv9oe2HQDyA4EXAEJsyZIlcuWVV8ojjzzic1Gav/vuu8/0EusFbtr72qZNG6lVq9Y5t6/r+Ifn5cuX+9zWi9V+/fVXczFdVvRx3bt397mtF6mp6Ohoz0V4ABBOCLwAEGI1atSQd999V7755hsz08F7770nq1at8sx64B7ysGzZMlm3bp1UqlRJZs2aJXfddZcJnO6gmZnHH39crrrqKjNLwq233mqeZ86cOT7rJCUlyU033WRmcujcubNERESYYQ7r16+XUaNGedabPn26NGnSRFq2bCkffPCBrFy5Ut58801zX9myZc3sDbrthIQE0zMcExMT9P0FADnFGF4ACLEHH3zQDCXo0qWLGWurU4Z59/Zu3LhRBgwYIK+88ooJu0r/3r9/vwwdOvSc27/iiivMtGg61Vn9+vVl7ty5MmTIEJ912rZtK1999ZW5r2nTpuYxL730klSpUsVnPR32oEMwdIyyhvSPPvpIateube6LioqSCRMmyGuvvSYVKlQw4RoAwoFLr1wLdSUAAOFPx93+61//4meCARQ49PACAADAagReACjg9JfPvKcT816effbZUFcPAEKOIQ0AUMD9+eefcvLkyYD3XXzxxWYBgAsZgRcAAABWY0gDAAAArEbgBQAAgNUIvAAAALAagRcAAABWI/ACAADAagReAAAAWI3ACwAAALHZ/wdHvq9yLFC/GgAAAABJRU5ErkJggg==", + "text/plain": [ + "
" + ] + }, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "display_data" + }, + { + "data": { + "image/png": "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", + "text/plain": [ + "
" + ] + }, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "display_data" + }, + { + "data": { + "image/png": "iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAsQAAAHYCAYAAABKqf7+AAAAOnRFWHRTb2Z0d2FyZQBNYXRwbG90bGliIHZlcnNpb24zLjEwLjEsIGh0dHBzOi8vbWF0cGxvdGxpYi5vcmcvc2/+5QAAAAlwSFlzAAAPYQAAD2EBqD+naQAAXbtJREFUeJzt3QmcU9X1wPGTzAIIMoPDzoADOAjKJjuooBUFpVUQKiAKIn+wVpBFRaDIKoK2KFqgFKsFrRSKRYoIWEALKMhOEWQrDOKA7PvOTN7/c277MkkmAzMYSCbv9/18opOTl5d7X94LJzfn3eeyLMsSAAAAwKHc4W4AAAAAEE4kxAAAAHA0EmIAAAA4GgkxAAAAHI2EGAAAAI5GQgwAAABHIyEGAACAo5EQAwAAwNFIiAEAAOBoJMRAhJsyZYq4XC7ZvXu3RJN//etfpl8ff/zxdXm9lJQUeeqppyQ/CnXbdbv37NlTrsd+u2bNGonmfVPfF31/IsGHH34oVatWlbi4OElMTAx3c4B8hYQYQMSbNm2ajBs3TqLZ8uXLZdiwYXL8+PFwNwX50NatW01yXrlyZXn33Xdl8uTJIX+NefPmmX0UiEax4W4AAOQmId60aZP06dPnqtexbds2cbvdEZ0QDx8+3CQ1gaN7kd52J9Pk0+PxRMSotrbj7bfflltuueWavIYmxBMmTCApRlTiExaAIxQoUMD8lHy9nDlzJt+2Pdwsy5Jz585JfqDvi74/4Xbw4EHz//xWKqFJ/Pnz58PdDICEGMiv5s+fL3fffbcULlxYbrzxRmnVqpVs3rzZ+/jvfvc7Uwf5/fffZ3vuwIEDJT4+Xo4dO+aNrVy5Ulq2bCkJCQlyww03SLNmzeTrr7/2e56ODOk6//Of/3hHMnX5rl27ytmzZ/2WXbhwodx1111mmSJFisitt94qgwYNCvoP4qhRoyQ5OVkKFiwo9913n1m/7Z577pHPPvvM9ENfW2++NZsXLlyQoUOHmlExTUzKly8v/fv3N/HL1eHaNa7ax379+kmJEiXMtmzTpo0cOnQoD+9E1nb57rvv5PHHH5dixYqZvquNGzea161UqZLpX+nSpeXpp5+WI0eO+D3/pZdeMn9XrFjR20+7bjxYDfGuXbvkl7/8pdx0003m/WrUqJHZTnnx0UcfmfdF21W3bl1ZunSp97Evv/zStOGTTz4JOmKvj61YseKKr6H7xTPPPCNJSUlStGhR6dy5s99+Z/fv5z//uXz++edSr149KVSokPzxj380j/35z3+Wn/3sZ1KyZEnz/t52223yhz/8Idvr2Ov46quvpEGDBqZPus0/+OCDbMtqWUrfvn3Nc3Sduu9puw4fPpynfTNYDbG+Z7pt9PjTsgUtYdDXqF+/vqxevTpbW2bOnGn6pOuvXr262d55rUvWZfUYULof6+vbo7j/+Mc/zGdD2bJlTTu0PSNHjpTMzMxs69HPgIceesjsv3os1KxZ04w42/3U0WFl75968/0C+MILL5jjT19H9yvdBvrlJlj9uu57t99+u1l2wYIFue4rcK1QMgHkQ3ryTJcuXaRFixby+uuvm6RDkwRNwtavX2/+gXzsscdMYvi3v/3Nm2zZNPbAAw+Yf/jUF198IQ8++KBJivQfVv153k5Eli1bZhIMX7puTdxGjx4t69atkz/96U8mYdG2KE3MNTnRf1BHjBhh/tHTRCIwwVZjxowxr/fiiy/KiRMn5I033pBOnTqZf5zVb37zGxNPT0+Xt956y8Q0wbYTlocfftgkQT169JBq1arJt99+a5bbvn27zJ49+4rbslevXmY7aL81mdFaZf0He8aMGXl+XzRBTU1Nlddee82bCOgXA01e9UuDJsO6bTRR0v9/8803JkF49NFHTXv/+te/mrYXL17cm9wEc+DAAWnSpIl5359//nmTbE6dOtVsCz0RTJP6K1myZInpoz5f35+JEyeaL0SrVq0yiZl+EdHkRhOXwPVpTBOrxo0bX/F1dFvqlyJN0LT0Q/dT/XJjn7hm08c6duxokufu3bubhErp8po4ad9iY2Pl008/lV//+tfmvX/uuef8Xkv3sXbt2km3bt3M8fH++++bRE73a12HOn36tPkiuWXLFvPFpE6dOiYRnjNnjtnH7G2fm33zcvRLw6lTp0x/tJ/6XH2fdV+wR/v1C0z79u2lRo0a5ljSLwra9nLlykle6D6rib8m07q99PjQY8/+4qf39Uuf/l+P9SFDhsjJkyflt7/9rXcdup/qMVumTBnp3bu32Vd1G82dO9fc137s27fPLKefP750X9f3R79Eaftr165tvtzo587evXu9x61N26CfQbpv6PaOlJMS4XAWgIj25z//WTMrKy0tzdw/deqUlZiYaHXv3t1vuf3791sJCQl+8caNG1t169b1W27VqlVmfR988IG57/F4rNTUVKtFixbmb9vZs2etihUrWvfff783NnToUPPcp59+2m+dbdq0sZKSkrz333rrLbPcoUOHcuzXl19+aZapVq2adeHCBW/87bffNvFvv/3WG2vVqpV18803Z1vHhx9+aLndbmvZsmV+8UmTJpl1fP31196YPr9Lly7Ztmvz5s39+t23b18rJibGOn78uJVb9nbp2LFjtsd0Owb661//apZfunSpN/bb3/7W7332Fdj2Pn36mGV9+637hb5fKSkpVmZm5mXbq8/V25o1a7yx77//3ipYsKB5L20DBw60ChQo4LctDh48aMXGxpo+X469fXX/u3jxojf+xhtvmPg//vEPv/5pbMGCBbnafrqvVqpUyS9mr8N3m2pbtf0vvPCCNzZkyBCz3KxZs7Kt194P8rJv6vviu2/q+6fL6PFw9OhRb1z7q/FPP/3UG6tRo4aVnJxs3jvbv/71L7NcsP09N/tg4DEXbPs988wz1g033GCdP3/e3M/IyDD7jr7msWPHgm4T9dxzz5nXCDR79mwTf/XVV/3i7dq1s1wul/Wf//zHG9Pl9JjdvHlznvoHXGuUTAD5jI7Q6E++OpqmI1v2LSYmRho2bGhGaWw6+rR27VrZuXOnN6ajgjoi+Mgjj5j7GzZskB07dpif+vVnfHt9+hOo/kSsP6MHnjT0q1/9yu++jrjpc3XUybeOUX+uvdIJRzpyquUbvutSOpJ2Jfpzs44K61RTvttCR7aV77bIiY4s+45U6uvrz8nBSk2uJHC7KP3536a1kto+LW9QOrp+tSc36ai9XZahdPRP+6Kj3Fq6cSU6uqsjp7YKFSqYfUJH9uyf07WMQEtPfKcf0/0nIyNDnnjiiVy1VdvkW//87LPPmpFe7YMv/cVBf/G43PbTUVrdflrOo/uH3velpQf2/mOPsOtIs+++9Pe//11q1aoVdBTddz/4qfumHnv2LzDBnqujrfprhm5j+xcPpX3TEeNQ8d1+OmKt20/bor8u6MwUSn9VSktLMyetBtYgB26TYPS91M8f/bXBl5ZQaA6s5V2+tI/6XgGRhIQYyGc0eVWa9Ok/+L63f/7zn96Ta+yf8PUnX/vnf/3HSZNILY/Qek7f9elPzIHr01IITYgCEw9NnnzZ//DbtaGaDNx5553yf//3f1KqVCnp0KGD+Yk0WHJ8pXVdaVto6UFgu6tUqWIe990WOfkprx9Ik7pAR48eNT8563bQ5ETbZy8XuF1zS5N1u6TAl345sB+/Ei3tCKTbTRMlu4Zav2ho7auWSNj0b03oczuTQeDraPKnP8sHzqsdbNspLbNp3ry5qWnVZE23n12LfqX90n4/fd9L/XKoJSG58VP2jSs9136Pgm3HUM4SoceHJv9a66/HvG4/+8uMvf3sL8y53S6BtC9ao6znMuRmf8zpvQbCiRpiIJ+xk0qt49M6v0A6+mbTf6R0NEiTUU0itGZ1z5493lpf3/VpPaHW/gXjO4KldDQoGLtuVhM/HVnWEVqtk9STZjQp1yRek3bf519pXZejbdfRtDfffDPo41oDeyU/5fUvNxrnW2+tU6ppPaVuX92W2m6t142E6bquREcwNaHX+lr9cqT70Pjx40P+OsG2nSZq+iuFJub6Huv7qSO2OiKpdamB2y+U7+VPXV+o23I19JckHY3VRFhr+bXuW0/e018mXn755bDtf8HeayDcSIiBfEb/UVN6EpuOnF2JjtbqSUh60pImpTojwS9+8Yts69N/NHOzvtzSkWlNZvSmyYyeaKYnyGmSnNfXyelnW237v//9b/Mauflp93rT0cDFixeb+YX1RCabPSrvKy/tv/nmm837Gcj+CVwfv5JgbdAT+3T/8D2ZT0f39YQsPeFPp0LT8gfdp3JLX+fee+/13teT2n788Uczm8GV6Al0moTrCW++I665KYXJie4zOqd1uNnvUeCsFTnFroaeuKilTLNmzZKmTZt641oe4cv+DNDtcrljM6d9VPuyaNEiU5LhO0qcl/0RCDdKJoB8RussNXnVBPPSpUvZHg+cMqxt27ZmtEoTGi2X0DPJ9ednm9aR6j+IOkWSJitXWl9uaJlAIHv0OXA6tNzQ9gYrL9DRVz2LXS+OEEiTt1DOBXw17FHCwFHBYFfds9+T3FypTpNJnQ3Cd9oz7avOXqFn7OemPlOf61vD/MMPP5iab519xHd0U2cB0BKbv/zlL6ZcQke2fWdiuBJtk+9+qrMgaA2yrvNqtp/uBzoDytXS40G/RAWbTu56jt7qrzdaoqCzQ/gedzr7h9YWh0Kw7Xfx4kUzo4gvnWlDyxh0vwzc/3yfm9M+qvuj1p0H/nKgo/iaROfmvQbCjRFiIJ/RZFiTiieffNL8Q6YjeDqip6UQWp6gtbu+/zDpSLKO0OkorY7gBI7u6Uiu1grrP1o6NZWeSKTTPmmiqSNx+no6UpcX+vOslkzo/Kc6OqS1vPqPsM7n6nsiWG5p0q6j2zpSqTWtWnago9y6DbQcRE9m07Zq3/UfZh2Z0rg9r2246LbTkTmdckuTQt2uWjISOEKn7BPcdBRd31MdidU++n55sQ0YMMB8wdH3TE9k0rmIddo1Xa+eNJabq9ppMqZfrnynXVM6mh2sbEKnM1M6h21eaAKmI/j65UVHtfV1dB/QabquRJNzLZHQ7aDTfmniqF9+dJ/WUearoaUrepKg1tfrtGu63fULnI5CT5o0yZxwd73ol1o9kVH3Wz3u9BcFPXb1vQn25TSvdGo+rV3W8wP0fdbkVEutAhN/3V/0M0W3s35x1bZonbceR1qDrMeR7z6q69J9RxNu3Vf1efoZo/uu1obrNtT9XL9g6Yl69gg0ENGu+TwWAEI67ZpNp4bS6ad0qjWdLqty5crWU0895TeVlu3dd98167jxxhutc+fOBX2d9evXW48++qiZLkqnqtIpmB577DFr8eLFV5zaKbCN+pxHHnnEKlu2rBUfH2/+r1OSbd++3a/9+pyZM2f6rcuetkrXaTt9+rT1+OOPm+nmAqek0im9Xn/9dev222837S5WrJiZ6mv48OHWiRMnrjjt2urVq7NtV43r/3Mrp+2i0tPTzVRm2nZ9r375y19a+/btM8sHTl02cuRIq1y5cmZaKt/tGdh2tXPnTjOtla5X3/8GDRpYc+fOzVV7dd06hdZf/vIXM+Webrc77rgjxz7r1GO6XbX9Oe0/geztu2TJEqtHjx7m+UWKFLE6depkHTlyxG9Z7Z9OrRfMnDlzrJo1a5o+6pRy+l6///772Y6JnNbRrFkzc/Olr9+zZ0+zrXX/1KnPdPsePnw4z/tmTtOu6TR6gYK959OnT7eqVq1q3oPq1aub/rZt29bE8iKnfVCnHmzUqJFVqFAhcxz279/f+vzzz4Pu41999ZWZZlE/JwoXLmy2++9//3vv4zo9W69evawSJUqY6dR8UwidOk6nLNTXiIuLM/uVbgPfadt89z0g0rj0P+FOygEAkUtLHPQnfh0JfO+998LdnKino7T6q49OsQjg+qCGGABwWXrFP60l19IJhI6W0eiXjcAT4bTGWa8UCOD6YYQYAHKgdZxXquXUkbycptjK7/QSxRs3bjR1w3oi3dVeSATBab2tzuqg8wLrCLzW7Gods84ZrDM+6CW5tb5Z67BzovteTpf4BpB7nFQHADnQmTeCnWTmS09k05kdopGeaKWzS+hP+FOmTAl3c6KOnvCmJ6rpSa06Aq8nUOqJqGPGjDHJsHr00UfNzBM50ZNWAy9yAiDvGCEGgBzoZXavdJlenTFBL3YAXAt66fXLXRlPL3Khs1QA+GlIiAEAAOBolExcJb3k5b59+8xVeSLxClkAAABOZ1mWmYNf6/QvN0c7CfFV0mS4fPny4W4GAAAArkCvxqkXh8oJCfFVsq/XrhtYr0YFAACAyHLy5EkzgGnnbTkhIb5KdpmEJsMkxAAAAJHrSuWtXJgDAAAAjkZCDAAAAEcjIQYAAICjkRADAADA0UiIAQAA4GgkxAAAAHA0EmIAAAA4GgkxAAAAHI2EGAAAAI5GQgwAAABHIyEGAACAo5EQAwAAwNFIiAEAAOBoJMQAAABwNBJiAAAAOBoJMQAAABwtNtwNAAAgP0sZ8Fm4mwCH2D2mVbibELUYIQYAAICjkRADAADA0SIiIZ4wYYKkpKRIwYIFpWHDhrJq1arLLj9z5kypWrWqWb5GjRoyb968HJf91a9+JS6XS8aNG+cXP3r0qHTq1EmKFi0qiYmJ0q1bNzl9+nTI+gQAAID8IewJ8YwZM6Rfv34ydOhQWbdundSqVUtatGghBw8eDLr88uXLpWPHjiaBXb9+vbRu3drcNm3alG3ZTz75RL755hspW7Zstsc0Gd68ebMsXLhQ5s6dK0uXLpUePXpckz4CAAAgcrksy7LC2QAdEa5fv76MHz/e3Pd4PFK+fHnp1auXDBgwINvy7du3lzNnzpgk1taoUSOpXbu2TJo0yRvbu3evWffnn38urVq1kj59+pib2rJli9x2222yevVqqVevnoktWLBAHnroIUlPTw+aQF+4cMHcbCdPnjTtPHLkiBllVm6329y0D3qz2fHMzEzx3dw5xWNiYsyodkZGhl8bNK50+dzEY2NjzXp947peXT6wjTnF6RN9ok/0iT5dvu1VBi8Qj7gk1mWJy5XVlgyPiCUuiXP7/zP737hIXMCQ1CWPiD49NlvcJS6x/OL68hmWS9xiSUywuMuSGJ+2eCyRTMslMS5L3D7xTEsfy972TI/Qpwjs085RLaP+eHKHuE/Hjh2TpKQkOXHihDdfi7hZJi5evChr166VgQMHemO6EZo3by4rVqwI+hyN64iyLx1Rnj17tve+bvAnn3xSXnrpJbn99tuDrkPLJOxkWOlr6muvXLlS2rRpk+05o0ePluHDh2eL6yh14cKFzd8lSpSQypUrS1pamhw6dMi7THJysrlt377dvCG2SpUqScmSJc3o9rlz57xxLQfR9um6fd/gmjVrSnx8vKxZs8avDdoP3ZYbN2702xH0i4a+3tatW73xQoUKmVH4w4cPy65du7zxhIQEqVatmuzbt898KbDRJ/pEn+gTfbp8n1ITLNl2wiVtUjySGJ/Vxvnpbkk/I9Kpsscvqfo4zS2nM0SeSs1KDtSUHW4pEivSrqLHL/masiNGyhUWeTA5K378osjMtBjz2k1LZyUN6WdF5v8QI3ckWVInKSuu7Vu63yV3lrLk1oSs+LojLll72CX3J3sk+Yastuiy9Cny+uSE46lSiPuky0f8CLFutHLlypkyiMaNG3vj/fv3lyVLlpjkNJB2eurUqaZswjZx4kSTrB44cMCbvH755ZdmdFi/TWh9su8I8WuvvWbWsW3bNr916xug63n22WezvS4jxPSJPtEn+kSfGCGmT4wQu/LVZ0S+GCG+FnTE+e233zb1yLrhQqVAgQLmFkh3Fr35st/MQPabk9t44HqvJq7bIFg8pzbmNU6f6FNOcfpEn5zSJ02ylCY4JoOS7IlSMJpYBbJyjLuCxvW1PcHilsskV4E02dLkKlBObadPkdUnJxxP16NPEXdSXfHixU2H7ZFdm94vXbp00Odo/HLLL1u2zJyQV6FCBW+y+v3338sLL7xgRortdQSetKffOHTmiZxeFwAAANEprAmxlj/UrVtXFi9e7I3pcLre9y2h8KVx3+WVzhRhL6+1w1oDs2HDBu9NT5LTemItobDXcfz4cTOabPviiy/Ma+uJeAAAAHCOsJdM6AlyXbp0McXPDRo0MPMF6ywSXbt2NY937tzZ1BlrXbDq3bu3NGvWTMaOHWtmj5g+fboppJ48ebJ5XOtE9OYrLi7OjPzeeuut5r4Wfbds2VK6d+9uZqa4dOmS9OzZUzp06BB0hgkAAABEr7AnxDqNmp51OGTIENm/f7+ZPk2nQCtVqpR5fM+ePX41J02aNJFp06bJ4MGDZdCgQZKammpmmKhevXqeXvejjz4ySfB9991n1t+2bVt55513Qt4/AAAARLawz0OcX+ksEzrFyJXOWgQARLeUAZ+FuwlwiN1jWoW7CVGbr4X9SnUAAABAOJEQAwAAwNFIiAEAAOBoJMQAAABwtLDPMgFn4eQTXC+cfAIAyC1GiAEAAOBoJMQAAABwNBJiAAAAOBoJMQAAAByNhBgAAACORkIMAAAARyMhBgAAgKOREAMAAMDRSIgBAADgaCTEAAAAcDQSYgAAADgaCTEAAAAcjYQYAAAAjkZCDAAAAEcjIQYAAICjkRADAADA0UiIAQAA4GgkxAAAAHA0EmIAAAA4GgkxAAAAHI2EGAAAAI5GQgwAAABHIyEGAACAo5EQAwAAwNFIiAEAAOBoJMQAAABwNBJiAAAAOBoJMQAAAByNhBgAAACOFhEJ8YQJEyQlJUUKFiwoDRs2lFWrVl12+ZkzZ0rVqlXN8jVq1JB58+b5PT5s2DDzeOHChaVYsWLSvHlzWblypd8y+noul8vvNmbMmGvSPwAAAESusCfEM2bMkH79+snQoUNl3bp1UqtWLWnRooUcPHgw6PLLly+Xjh07Srdu3WT9+vXSunVrc9u0aZN3mSpVqsj48ePl22+/la+++sokvw888IAcOnTIb10jRoyQH3/80Xvr1avXNe8vAAAAIovLsiwrnA3QEeH69eubBFZ5PB4pX768SU4HDBiQbfn27dvLmTNnZO7cud5Yo0aNpHbt2jJp0qSgr3Hy5ElJSEiQRYsWyX333WdimiT36dPH3HLjwoUL5ua7Tm3nkSNHpGjRoibmdrvNTfugN5sdz8zMFN/NnVM8JibGjFhnZGT4tUHjSpfPTTw2Ntas1zeu69XlA9uYUzzUfUodlPW+qQyPiC4VF/DV7JJHxKV9yBZ3iUssv7i+TIblErdYEhMs7rIkRlf2Px5LJNNySYzLErdPPNPSx1wS67LE5Rv3iHgke/y/bXdJnNv/EKJPkdGnLSNaRv3xRJ8io09VBi+I+uOJPkVGn3aOahn1x5M7xH06duyYJCUlyYkTJ7z5WjCxEkYXL16UtWvXysCBA70x3Qha4rBixYqgz9G4jij70hHl2bNn5/gakydPNgmxjj770hKJkSNHSoUKFeTxxx+Xvn37mjc/mNGjR8vw4cOzxXWUWkszVIkSJaRy5cqSlpbmNxqdnJxsbtu3bzdviK1SpUpSsmRJM7p97tw5b1zLPRITE826fd/gmjVrSnx8vKxZs8avDfXq1TP93Lhxo9+OoF809PW2bt3qjRcqVMhsh8OHD8uuXbu8cd0+1apVk3379kl6ero3Huo+dars8ftw+TjNLaczRJ5KzTpI1JQdbikSK9KuosfvQ2jKjhgpV1jkweSs+PGLIjPTYiQ1wZKmpbMOnvSzIvN/iJE7kiypk5QV33bCJUv3u+TOUpbcmpAVX3fEJWsPu+T+ZI8k35DVFl1Wn9MmxSOJ8Vnx+eluST8j9ClC+2QfJ9F8PNGnyOiT7tPRfjzRp8jokxOOp0oh7pMuH/EjxLrRypUrZ8ogGjdu7I33799flixZkq3uV2mnp06dasombBMnTjTJ6oEDB7wxHUHu0KGDnD17VsqUKWMSZn1jbW+++abUqVNHbrrpJvP6mpR37drVxINhhJgR4vw8quDEPjFCTJ+uV58YIaZP16tPjBC7onOE+Fq69957ZcOGDeYbzLvvviuPPfaYSbD1W4fyHWW2v10888wzZiS4QIEC2dansWBx3VkCR5XtNzOQ/ebkNp7TaHVe4rrzBIvn1Ma8xvPaJ/3ACB7PHrNyjLuCxvWDzhMsbrnMh0wg/dDRD5lA+iEleYjTp8jsU+B+H43HE32KjD7pPh3tx1P2ttOncPTJCcfT9ehTxJ1UV7x4cdNh35FdpfdLly4d9Dkaz83yWsZwyy23mPri9957z2wQ/f/lapn1W8fu3bt/Up8AAACQv4Q1IdZR2bp168rixYu9MR1O1/u+JRS+NO67vFq4cGGOy/uu17fkIZCOJus3F3sEGQAAAM4Q9pIJLV3o0qWLKX5u0KCBjBs3zswiofW8qnPnzqbOWEsZVO/evaVZs2YyduxYadWqlUyfPt0UUuuJc0qfO2rUKHn44YdN7bCWTOg8x3v37pVf/vKX3hPztHxCyypuvPFGc19PqHviiSfMvMUAAABwjrAnxDqNmp51OGTIENm/f7+ZPm3BggVSqlQp8/iePXv8ak6aNGki06ZNk8GDB8ugQYMkNTXVnDBXvXp187iWYOjZkHrinSbDWkitJ9MtW7ZMbr/9drOM1gJrIq0X8NBR44oVK5qEOHD2CgAAAES/sM9DnF/Zcxtf6axF+EsZ8Fm4mwCH2D2mVbibAIfgcw3XC59r1y5fC/uV6gAAAIBwIiEGAACAo5EQAwAAwNFIiAEAAOBoJMQAAABwNBJiAAAAOBoJMQAAAByNhBgAAACORkIMAAAARyMhBgAAgKOREAMAAMDRSIgBAADgaCTEAAAAcDQSYgAAADgaCTEAAAAcjYQYAAAAjkZCDAAAAEcjIQYAAICjkRADAADA0UiIAQAA4GgkxAAAAHA0EmIAAAA4GgkxAAAAHI2EGAAAAI5GQgwAAABHIyEGAACAo5EQAwAAwNFIiAEAAOBoJMQAAABwNBJiAAAAOBoJMQAAAByNhBgAAACORkIMAAAARyMhBgAAgKNFREI8YcIESUlJkYIFC0rDhg1l1apVl11+5syZUrVqVbN8jRo1ZN68eX6PDxs2zDxeuHBhKVasmDRv3lxWrlzpt8zRo0elU6dOUrRoUUlMTJRu3brJ6dOnr0n/AAAAELnCnhDPmDFD+vXrJ0OHDpV169ZJrVq1pEWLFnLw4MGgyy9fvlw6duxoEtj169dL69atzW3Tpk3eZapUqSLjx4+Xb7/9Vr766iuTbD/wwANy6NAh7zKaDG/evFkWLlwoc+fOlaVLl0qPHj2uS58BAAAQOVyWZVnhbICOCNevX98ksMrj8Uj58uWlV69eMmDAgGzLt2/fXs6cOWOSWFujRo2kdu3aMmnSpKCvcfLkSUlISJBFixbJfffdJ1u2bJHbbrtNVq9eLfXq1TPLLFiwQB566CFJT0+XsmXLZlvHhQsXzM13ndrOI0eOmFFm5Xa7zU37oDebHc/MzBTfzZ1TPCYmRlwul2RkZPi1QeNKl89NPDY21qzXN67r1eUD25hTPNR9Sh2U9b6pDI+ILhUX8NXskkfEpX3IFneJSyy/uL5MhuUSt1gSEyzusiRGV/Y/Hksk03JJjMsSt08809LHXBLrssTlG/eIeCR7/L9td0mc2/8Qok+R0actI1pG/fFEnyKjT1UGL4j644k+RUafdo5qGfXHkzvEfTp27JgkJSXJiRMnvPlaMLESRhcvXpS1a9fKwIEDvTHdCFrisGLFiqDP0biOKPvSEeXZs2fn+BqTJ082CbGOPtvr0DIJOxlW+pr62lpa0aZNm2zrGT16tAwfPjxbXEeptTRDlShRQipXrixpaWl+o9HJycnmtn37dvOG2CpVqiQlS5Y0o9vnzp3zxrXcQ9un6/Z9g2vWrCnx8fGyZs0avzZoP7SfGzdu9NsR9IuGvt7WrVu98UKFCpntcPjwYdm1a5c3rtunWrVqsm/fPvOlwBbqPnWq7PH7cPk4zS2nM0SeSs06SNSUHW4pEivSrqLH70Noyo4YKVdY5MHkrPjxiyIz02IkNcGSpqWzDp70syLzf4iRO5IsqZOUFd92wiVL97vkzlKW3JqQFV93xCVrD7vk/mSPJN+Q1RZdVp/TJsUjifFZ8fnpbkk/I/QpQvtkHyfRfDzRp8jok+7T0X480afI6JMTjqdKIe6TLh/xI8S60cqVK2fKIBo3buyN9+/fX5YsWZKt7ldpp6dOnWrKJmwTJ040yeqBAwe8MR1B7tChg5w9e1bKlCljEmZ9Y9Vrr71m1rFt2za/desboOt59tlns70uI8SMEOfnUQUn9okRYvp0vfrECDF9ul59YoTYFZ0jxNfSvffeKxs2bDDfYN5991157LHHTIKtSe/VKFCggLkF0p1Fb77sNzOQ/ebkNh643quJ684TLJ5TG/Maz2uf9AMjeDx7zMox7goa1w86T7C45TIfMoH0Q0c/ZALph5TkIU6fIrNPgft9NB5P9Cky+qT7dLQfT9nbTp/C0ScnHE/Xo08Rd1Jd8eLFTYd9R3aV3i9dunTQ52g8N8trGcMtt9xi6ovfe+89s0H0//Y6Ak/a028cOvNETq8LAACA6BTWhFjLH+rWrSuLFy/2xnQ4Xe/7llD40rjv8kpnishped/12iUPuuzx48dN/bLtiy++MMvoSX4AAABwjrCXTOgJcl26dDHFzw0aNJBx48aZWSS6du1qHu/cubOpM9aT2lTv3r2lWbNmMnbsWGnVqpVMnz7dFFLriXNKnztq1Ch5+OGHTe2wlkzoPMd79+6VX/7yl2YZLfpu2bKldO/e3cxMcenSJenZs6epOQ42wwQAAACiV9gTYp1GTc86HDJkiOzfv99Mn6ZToJUqVco8vmfPHr+akyZNmsi0adNk8ODBMmjQIElNTTUnzFWvXt08riUYejaknjSnybAWUuvJdMuWLZPbb7/du56PPvrIJME6DZuuv23btvLOO++EYQsAAADA0fMQ51f23MZXOmsR/lIGfBbuJsAhdo9pFe4mwCH4XMP1wufatcvXwn6lOgAAACCcSIgBAADgaCTEAAAAcDQSYgAAADgaCTEAAAAcjYQYAAAAjkZCDAAAAEcjIQYAAICjkRADAADA0UiIAQAA4GgkxAAAAHA0EmIAAAA4GgkxAAAAHI2EGAAAAI5GQgwAAABHi73aJ+7cuVPGjRsnW7ZsMfdvu+026d27t1SuXDmU7QMAAAAib4T4888/NwnwqlWrpGbNmua2cuVKuf3222XhwoWhbyUAAAAQSSPEAwYMkL59+8qYMWOyxV9++WW5//77Q9U+AAAAIPJGiLVMolu3btniTz/9tHz33XehaBcAAAAQuQlxiRIlZMOGDdniGitZsmQo2gUAAABEbslE9+7dpUePHrJr1y5p0qSJiX399dfy+uuvS79+/ULdRgAAACCyEuJXXnlFbrzxRhk7dqwMHDjQxMqWLSvDhg2T559/PtRtBAAAACIrIXa5XOakOr2dOnXKxDRBBgAAABwzD7GNRBgAAACOSIjr1KkjixcvlmLFiskdd9xhRolzsm7dulC1DwAAAIiMhPiRRx6RAgUKeP++XEIMAAAARF1CPHToUO/fevIcAAAA4Nh5iCtVqiRHjhzJFj9+/Lh5DAAAAIjqhHj37t2SmZmZLX7hwgVJT08PRbsAAACAyJtlYs6cOd6/P//8c0lISPDe1wRZT7qrWLFiaFsIAAAAREpC3Lp1a/N/PaGuS5cufo/FxcVJSkqKuVgHAAAAkF/kKSH2eDzm/zoKvHr1ailevPi1ahcAAAAQuRfmSEtLC31LAAAAgPx0pbozZ87IkiVLZM+ePXLx4kW/x55//vlQtA0AAACIzFkm1q9fL7fccot07NhRevbsKa+++qr06dNHBg0aJOPGjcvz+iZMmGDqjwsWLCgNGzaUVatWXXb5mTNnStWqVc3yNWrUkHnz5nkfu3Tpkrz88ssmXrhwYSlbtqx07txZ9u3b57cOfT2thfa9jRkzJs9tBwAAgAMT4r59+8ovfvELOXbsmBQqVEi++eYb+f7776Vu3bryu9/9Lk/rmjFjhvTr189c+EMv+VyrVi1p0aKFHDx4MOjyy5cvN4l4t27dTGKuJ/rpbdOmTebxs2fPmvW88sor5v+zZs2Sbdu2ycMPP5xtXSNGjJAff/zRe+vVq9fVbA4AAADkYy7Lsqy8PikxMVFWrlwpt956q/l7xYoVUq1aNRPT2Se2bt2a63XpiHD9+vVl/Pjx3hP3ypcvb5LTAQMGZFu+ffv2plxj7ty53lijRo2kdu3aMmnSpKCvoScANmjQwCTtFSpU8I4Q66i23nJD51jWm+3kyZOmnXqBkqJFi5qY2+02N+2DfQKib1ynpvPd3DnFY2JizIh1RkaGXxs0rgLngM4pHhsba9brG9f16vKBbcwpHuo+pQ7Ket9UhkdEl4oL+Gp2ySOiFwePzRZ3iUssv7i+TIblErdYEhMs7rIkxudK4x5LJNNySYzLErdPPNPSx1wS67LE98rkmR4Rj2SP/7ftLolz+x9C9Cky+rRlRMuoP57oU2T0qcrgBVF/PNGnyOjTzlEto/54coe4Tzp4m5SUJCdOnPDmayGrIdYp1rSxqmTJkqaOWBNinZf4hx9+yPV6tPZ47dq1MnDgQG9M19u8eXOTZAejcR1R9qUjyrNnz87xdXQj6EbU5N2XlkiMHDnSJMmPP/64GfnWNz+Y0aNHy/Dhw7PFdZRaSzNUiRIlpHLlyuakw0OHDnmXSU5ONrft27ebttj0qn66/XR0+9y5c964loNoW3Xdvm9wzZo1JT4+XtasWePXhnr16pltuXHjRr8dQb9o6Ov5fkHREX0dhT98+LDs2rXLG9f3Tt9DLS3xvbhKqPvUqbLH78Pl4zS3nM4QeSo16yBRU3a4pUisSLuKHr8PoSk7YqRcYZEHk7Pixy+KzEyLkdQES5qWzjp40s+KzP8hRu5IsqROUlZ82wmXLN3vkjtLWXJrQlZ83RGXrD3skvuTPZJ8Q1ZbdFl9TpsUjyTGZ8Xnp7sl/YzQpwjtk32cRPPxRJ8io0+6T0f78USfIqNPTjieKoW4T7r8NRshfuCBB+Spp54ySWT37t3NBtQT6T788EOTietIcW7oRitXrpwpg2jcuLE33r9/f3PCXrD1aKenTp1qyiZsEydONMnqgQMHsi1//vx5ufPOO82G/Oijj7zxN998U+rUqSM33XSTeX1Nyrt27WriwTBCzAhxfh5VcGKfGCGmT9erT4wQ06fr1SdGiF2RNUL82muvyalTp8zfo0aNMietPfvss5Kamirvv/++RAo9we6xxx4zG/QPf/iD32O+o8z2t4tnnnnGjAQXKFAg27o0FiyuO0vgqLL9Zgay35zcxnMarc5LXHeeYPGc2pjXeF77pB8YwePZY1aOcVfQuH7QeYLFLZf5kAmkHzr6IRNIP6QkD3H6FJl9Ctzvo/F4ok+R0Sfdp6P9eMredvoUjj454Xi6Hn0KupzkkSaXOpRdvXp1c1//XrBggVwNvbCHdjhwZFfvly5dOuhzNJ6b5e1kWOuGv/jii8t+K7BrmfVbx+7du01tNAAAAJzBfTUJsU65lpda4ZzoqKzOTLF48WJvTIfT9b5vCYUvjfsurxYuXOi3vJ0M79ixQxYtWmSGyq9kw4YN5puLJvgAAABwjjyPEGvSqKURWjur//+ptHRBZ6bQ4medCULnMdZZJLSeV2k5htYZaymD6t27tzRr1kzGjh0rrVq1kunTp5tC6smTJ3uT4Xbt2pkp13QmCq0p2b9/v3lM64U1CdcT87Q++d5775Ubb7zR3NcT6p544gkpVqzYT+4TAAAA8o+rqiHW2RleeuklU5drl05cLZ1GTc86HDJkiElcdfo0LcEoVaqUeVxnsPCtOWnSpIlMmzZNBg8ebC4Eokm5zjBht2Pv3r0yZ84c87euy9eXX34p99xzj6kF1kR62LBh5kS5ihUrmoQ4cPYKAAAARL+rmmVCR1H1Ahhac6sjrjoFh6+jR49KtNNZJnSKkSudtQh/KQM+C3cT4BC7x7QKdxPgEHyu4Xrhc+3a5WtXNUJ8NZdnBgAAACLRVSXEWvOb29KKX/3qV9kuiAEAAADk21km8jpfsRPKJwAAAJB/XdOE+CrKkwEAAIDoSYgBAACASEdCDAAAAEcjIQYAAICjkRADAADA0a5pQnz33Xdnu2gHAAAAkO/nIVYej0f+85//yMGDB83fvpo2bWr+P2/evJ/eQgAAACDSEuJvvvlGHn/8cfn++++zTa3mcrkkMzMzVO0DAAAAIi8h1qvP1atXTz777DMpU6aMSYIBAAAAxyTEO3bskI8//lhuueWW0LcIAAAAiPST6ho2bGjqhwEAAABHjhD36tVLXnjhBdm/f7/UqFFD4uLi/B6vWbNmqNoHAAAARF5C3LZtW/P/p59+2hvTOmI9wY6T6gAAABD1CXFaWlroWwIAAADkl4T45ptvDn1LAAAAgEhOiOfMmSMPPvigqRfWvy/n4YcfDkXbAAAAgMhJiFu3bm1OoitZsqT5OyfUEAMAACAqE2LfyzMHXqoZAAAAcNQ8xL7Onz8fmpYAAAAA+SUh1pKIkSNHSrly5aRIkSKya9cuE3/llVfkvffeC3UbAQAAgMhKiEeNGiVTpkyRN954Q+Lj473x6tWry5/+9KdQtg8AAACIvIT4gw8+kMmTJ0unTp0kJibGG69Vq5Zs3bo1lO0DAAAAIi8h3rt3r9xyyy3Z4nqy3aVLl0LRLgAAACByE+LbbrtNli1bli3+8ccfyx133BGKdgEAAACRe6W6IUOGSJcuXcxIsY4Kz5o1S7Zt22ZKKebOnRv6VgIAAACRNEL8yCOPyKeffiqLFi2SwoULmwR5y5YtJnb//feHvpUAAABAJI0Qq7vvvlsWLlwY2tYAAAAA+WGEuFKlSnLkyJFs8ePHj5vHAAAAgKhOiHfv3m0uzhHowoULpq4YAAAAiMqSiTlz5nj//vzzzyUhIcF7XxPkxYsXS0pKSmhbCAAAAERKQty6dWvzf5fLZWaZ8BUXF2eS4bFjx4a2hQAAAECklEzoFGt6q1Chghw8eNB7X29aLqFTr/385z/PcyMmTJhgkumCBQtKw4YNZdWqVZddfubMmVK1alWzfI0aNWTevHnex/TCIC+//LKJ6wwYZcuWlc6dO8u+ffv81nH06FFzpb2iRYtKYmKidOvWTU6fPp3ntgMAAMCBNcRpaWlSvHjxkDRgxowZ0q9fPxk6dKisW7fOXP65RYsWJuEOZvny5dKxY0eTwK5fv96MWutt06ZN5vGzZ8+a9bzyyivm//YcyQ8//LDfejQZ3rx5s5kpQ+dOXrp0qfTo0SMkfQIAAED+4bIsy7qaJ2q9sN7skWJf77//fq7XoyPC9evXl/Hjx5v7uq7y5ctLr169ZMCAAdmWb9++vZw5c8bvAiCNGjWS2rVry6RJk4K+xurVq6VBgwby/fffm9FtnTNZr7an8Xr16pllFixYIA899JCkp6ebUeVAOgKuN9vJkydNO3W2DR1lVm6329zsUXObHdc6a9/NnVM8JibGlKVkZGT4tUHjKvCExpzisbGxZr2+cV2vLh/Yxpzioe5T6iD/C7dkeER0qbiAr2aXPCIu7UO2uEtcYvnF9WUyLJe4xZKYYHGXJTG6sv/xWCKZlktiXJa4feKZlj7mkliXJS7fuEfEI9nj/227S+Lc/ocQfYqMPm0Z0TLqjyf6FBl9qjJ4QdQfT/QpMvq0c1TLqD+e3CHu07FjxyQpKUlOnDjhzddCNg/x8OHDZcSIESaZLFOmjGng1bh48aKsXbtWBg4c6I3pRmjevLmsWLEi6HM0riPKvnREefbs2Tm+jm4EbaOWRtjr0L/tZFjpa+prr1y5Utq0aZNtHaNHjzb9DqSj1FqaoUqUKCGVK1c2I+iHDh3yLpOcnGxu27dvN22x6RR1JUuWNKPb586d88a1HETbp+v2fYNr1qwp8fHxsmbNGr82aD90W27cuNFvR9AvGvp6W7du9cYLFSpkRuEPHz4su3bt8sb1BMlq1aqZ0hL9UmALdZ86Vfb4fbh8nOaW0xkiT6X6f6massMtRWJF2lX0+H0ITdkRI+UKizyYnBU/flFkZlqMpCZY0rR01sGTflZk/g8xckeSJXWSsuLbTrhk6X6X3FnKklsTsuLrjrhk7WGX3J/skeQbstqiy+pz2qR4JDE+Kz4/3S3pZ4Q+RWif7OMkmo8n+hQZfdJ9OtqPJ/oUGX1ywvFUKcR90uWv2QixJsFvvPGGPPnkk/JT6EYrV66cKYNo3LixN96/f39ZsmSJSU4DaaenTp1qyiZsEydONMnqgQMHsi1//vx5ufPOO82G/Oijj0zstddeM+vQUgpf+gboep599tls62GEmBHi/Dyq4MQ+MUJMn65Xnxghpk/Xq0+MELsia4RYM+4mTZpIpNMT7B577DGzQf/whz/8pHUVKFDA3ALpzqI3X/abGch+c3IbD1zv1cR15wkWz6mNeY3ntU/6gRE8nj1m5Rh3BY3rB50nWNxymQ+ZQPqhox8ygfRDSvIQp0+R2afA/T4ajyf6FBl90n062o+n7G2nT+HokxOOp+vRp5CdVPd///d/Mm3aNPmp9MQ87XDgyK7eL126dNDnaDw3y9vJsNYN64lzvt8KdNnAk/b0G4fOPJHT6wIAACA65XqE2LduV4e8J0+eLIsWLTK1GzoHsa8333wzV+vU8oe6deuak/PsOY513Xq/Z8+eQZ+jpRX6eJ8+fbwxTXh9Sy7sZHjHjh3y5ZdfmqHywHXoZaa1fllfX33xxRfmtfUkPwAAADhHrhPiwKJkndVB2dOd2fJ6gp0m2nqRDy1+1pkgxo0bZ2aR6Nq1q3lc5xDWOmM9qU317t1bmjVrZi4A0qpVK5k+fboppNYE3U6G27VrZ6Zc05kotKZk//795rGbbrrJJOFa9N2yZUvp3r27mZlCn6MJeIcOHYLOMAEAAIDoleuEWEdarwWdRk3POhwyZIhJXDXR1inQSpUqZR7fs2ePX82J1i5rucbgwYNl0KBBkpqaamaYqF69unl879693ktM20m7bx/uuece87eeYKdJ8H333WfW37ZtW3nnnXeuSR8BAAAQhfMQ+9IZF7TkQGdy0JsTaJ91ipErnbUIfykDPgt3E+AQu8e0CncT4BB8ruF64XPt2uVrV3VSndbn2hfS0DnitNxBY3q55L///e9Xs0oAAAAgLK4qIdbLHN99993m708++cRMa6YnqWnJwauvvhrqNgIAAACRlRDrsLOeoKa03lfrb2+44QZzkpvO7AAAAABEdUKsV2jTyx/rbBCaED/wwAPeq4EULFgw1G0EAAAArpmrulKdzgHcqVMnKVKkiNx8883emRu0lELriAEAAICoToh//etfmzmDf/jhB7n//vu906JVqlSJGmIAAABEf0KsdGYJvfnSGmIAAAAg6hNivfrblClTzCWUDx48aC557EvnJAYAAACiNiHWyydrQqwjwnqFuLxerhkAAADI1wnx9OnT5W9/+5s89NBDoW8RAAAAEOnTrsXHx8stt9wS+tYAAAAA+SEhfuGFF+Ttt982V6gDAAAAHFcy8dVXX8mXX34p8+fPl9tvv13i4uL8Hp81a1ao2gcAAABEXkKcmJgobdq0CX1rAAAAgPyQEP/5z38OfUsAAACA/FJDrDIyMmTRokXyxz/+UU6dOmVi+/btk9OnT4eyfQAAAEDkjRB///330rJlS9mzZ49cuHDBXL75xhtvlNdff93cnzRpUuhbCgAAAETKCLFemEMv23zs2DEpVKiQN651xXr1OgAAACCqR4iXLVsmy5cvN/MR+0pJSZG9e/eGqm0AAABAZI4QezweyczMzBZPT083pRMAAABAVCfEDzzwgIwbN8573+VymZPphg4dyuWcAQAAEP0lE2PHjpUWLVrIbbfdJufPn5fHH39cduzYIcWLF5e//vWvoW8lAAAAEEkJcXJysvz73/+W6dOny8aNG83ocLdu3aRTp05+J9kBAAAAUZkQ66hwwYIF5Yknngh9iwAAAIBIryEuWbKkdOnSRRYuXGhOsAMAAAAclRBPnTpVzp49K4888oiUK1dO+vTpI2vWrAl96wAAAIBITIj1AhwzZ86UAwcOyGuvvSbfffedNGrUSKpUqSIjRowIfSsBAACASEqIbTrncNeuXeWf//ynObmucOHCMnz48NC1DgAAAIjkhFhPrvvb3/4mrVu3ljp16sjRo0flpZdeCl3rAAAAgEicZeLzzz+XadOmyezZsyU2NlbatWtnRombNm0a+hYCAAAAkZYQaw3xz3/+c/nggw/Mleni4uJC3zIAAAAgUhNiPZlO64cBAAAAR9YQazK8c+dOGTx4sHTs2FEOHjxo4vPnz5fNmzeHuo0AAABAZCXES5YskRo1asjKlStl1qxZ5tLNSi/nPHTo0FC3EQAAAIishHjAgAHy6quvmivVxcfHe+M/+9nP5Jtvvsnz+iZMmCApKSnmctANGzaUVatWXXZ5nQO5atWqZnlNzOfNm+f3uCbpDzzwgCQlJYnL5ZINGzZkW8c999xjHvO9/epXv8pz2wEAAODAhPjbb781J9YFu6Tz4cOH87SuGTNmSL9+/czI8rp166RWrVrSokULbxlGoOXLl5syjW7dusn69evNlG9627Rpk3eZM2fOyF133SWvv/76ZV+7e/fu8uOPP3pvb7zxRp7aDgAAAIeeVJeYmGgSyIoVK/rFNUHVSznnxZtvvmkSU73Ah5o0aZJ89tln8v7775uR6EBvv/22tGzZ0jvf8ciRI81I9fjx481z1ZNPPmn+v3v37su+9g033CClS5fOVTsvXLhgbraTJ0+a/2dkZJibcrvd5ubxeMzNZsczMzPFsqwrxmNiYsyItb1e37jS5XMT1ynxdL2+cV2vLh/Yxpzioe5TnDsrZrafR0QjcQFfzS55RFzah2xxl7jE8ovry2RYLnGLJTHB4i5LYnRl/+OxRDItl8S4LHH7xDMtfcwlsS5LXL5xj4hHssf/23b6FKl9so+faD6e6FOE9EmsqD+e6FNk9MkRx5M7tH0KXD6kCXGHDh3k5ZdfNqUL2jjt4Ndffy0vvviidO7cOdfruXjxoqxdu1YGDhzojelGaN68uaxYsSLoczSuI8q+dERZ50TOq48++kj+8pe/mKT4F7/4hbzyyismSQ5m9OjRQa/Cp18C9Ap9qkSJElK5cmVJS0uTQ4cOeZdJTk42t+3bt8uJEye88UqVKplRdR3dPnfunDeu5SD6pUPX7fsG16xZ05SorFmzxq8N9erVM9tSrxbouyPUr1/fvN7WrVu98UKFCplReB3J37VrlzeekJAg1apVk3379kl6ero3Huo+dars8ftw+TjNLaczRJ5KzTpI1JQdbikSK9KuosfvQ2jKjhgpV1jkweSs+PGLIjPTYiQ1wZKmpbMOnvSzIvN/iJE7kiypk5QV33bCJUv3u+TOUpbcmpAVX3fEJWsPu+T+ZI8k++wGuqw+p02KRxKzKoRkfrpb0s8IfYrQPtnHSTQfT/QpMvqk+3S0H0/0KTL65ITjqVKI+6TL54bL8k2/c0lf4LnnnpMpU6aYRuk3CM3AO3XqZGJ2Vn4lutF0RFnLIBo3buyN9+/f35y4pyftBdJOT5061ZRN2CZOnGiSVZ0OzpeOEOsotm6M2rVr+z02efJkufnmm6Vs2bJmB9AEv0GDBqb+OLcjxOXLl5cjR45I0aJFI+JbUH74Zpc6aG7EfwOPxlEFJ/Zpy4iWUX880afI6FOVwQui/niiT5HRp52jWkb98eQOcZ+OHTtmzinTpNvO10I2QqxJ6bvvvitDhgwx9cQ6y8Qdd9whqampkl/06NHD+7eemFemTBm57777zHRy+k0mUIECBcwtkO4sevNlv5mBcvqikFM8cL1XE9edJ1g8pzbmNZ7XPukHRvB49piVY9wVNK4fdJ5gcctlPmQC6YeOfsgE0g8pyUOcPkVmnwL3+2g8nuhTZPRJ9+loP56yt50+haNPTjierkefgi6Xq6VEspUpBPKdXULrgnOjePHipsOBI7t6P6faXo3nZfnc0tkt1H/+85+gCTEAAACiU64T4lzXYPj+DpGLkea6devK4sWLzUwRSofT9X7Pnj2DPkdLK/TxPn36eGN6Up1vycXVsKdm05FiAAAAOEeuE+Ivv/zymjRAR567dOliip+1hnfcuHFm2jR71gk9SU/rjPWkNtW7d29p1qyZjB07Vlq1aiXTp083hdRaE2w7evSo7Nmzx9Qoq23btpn/6yiy3rQsYtq0afLQQw+ZuhKtIe7bt680bdrUFGcDAADAOa6qhjiU2rdvb8461Hrk/fv3m5PfFixYIKVKlTKPa2LrW3PSpEkTk8zqZaMHDRpk6pZ1honq1at7l5kzZ443obZnxVA61/GwYcPMyPSiRYu8ybeeHNe2bVuzTgAAADjLVc0ygf/OMqFTjFzprEX4SxnwWbibAIfYPaZVuJsAh+BzDdcLn2vXLl+7qivVAQAAANGChBgAAACORkIMAAAARyMhBgAAgKOREAMAAMDRSIgBAADgaCTEAAAAcDQSYgAAADgaCTEAAAAcjYQYAAAAjkZCDAAAAEcjIQYAAICjkRADAADA0UiIAQAA4GgkxAAAAHA0EmIAAAA4GgkxAAAAHI2EGAAAAI5GQgwAAABHIyEGAACAo5EQAwAAwNFIiAEAAOBoJMQAAABwNBJiAAAAOBoJMQAAAByNhBgAAACORkIMAAAARyMhBgAAgKOREAMAAMDRSIgBAADgaCTEAAAAcDQSYgAAADgaCTEAAAAcjYQYAAAAjhYRCfGECRMkJSVFChYsKA0bNpRVq1ZddvmZM2dK1apVzfI1atSQefPm+T0+a9YseeCBByQpKUlcLpds2LAh2zrOnz8vzz33nFmmSJEi0rZtWzlw4EDI+wYAAIDIFvaEeMaMGdKvXz8ZOnSorFu3TmrVqiUtWrSQgwcPBl1++fLl0rFjR+nWrZusX79eWrdubW6bNm3yLnPmzBm566675PXXX8/xdfv27SuffvqpSa6XLFki+/btk0cfffSa9BEAAACRy2VZlhXOBuiIcP369WX8+PHmvsfjkfLly0uvXr1kwIAB2ZZv3769SXjnzp3rjTVq1Ehq164tkyZN8lt29+7dUrFiRZM46+O2EydOSIkSJWTatGnSrl07E9u6datUq1ZNVqxYYdYX6MKFC+ZmO3nypGnnkSNHpGjRoibmdrvNTfugN5sdz8zMFN/NnVM8JibGjGxnZGT4tUHjSpfPTTw2Ntas1zeu69XlA9uYUzzUfUodlPW+qQyPiC4VF/DV7JJHxKV9yBZ3iUssv7i+TIblErdYEhMs7rIkRlf2Px5LJNNySYzLErdPPNPSx1wS67LE5Rv3iHgke/y/bXdJnNv/EKJPkdGnLSNaRv3xRJ8io09VBi+I+uOJPkVGn3aOahn1x5M7xH06duyYqQbQ3M/O14KJlTC6ePGirF27VgYOHOiN6UZo3ry5SUyD0biOKPvSEeXZs2fn+nX1NS9dumRex6YlGBUqVMgxIR49erQMHz48W1yT7cKFC5u/NcmuXLmypKWlyaFDh7zLJCcnm9v27dvNG2KrVKmSlCxZ0oxunzt3zq8tiYmJZt2+b3DNmjUlPj5e1qxZ49eGevXqmW25ceNGvx1Bv2jo62mybytUqJAZhT98+LDs2rXLG09ISDBfCHSkPD093RsPdZ86Vfb4fbh8nOaW0xkiT6VmHSRqyg63FIkVaVfR4/chNGVHjJQrLPJgclb8+EWRmWkxkppgSdPSWQdP+lmR+T/EyB1JltRJyopvO+GSpftdcmcpS25NyIqvO+KStYddcn+yR5JvyGqLLqvPaZPikcT4rPj8dLeknxH6FKF9so+TaD6e6FNk9En36Wg/nuhTZPTJCcdTpRD3SZeP+BFi3WjlypUzZRCNGzf2xvv372/KGFauXJntOdrpqVOnmrIJ28SJE02yGlgDnNMIsY4Md+3a1W/EVzVo0EDuvffeoKUWjBAzQpyfRxWc2CdGiOnT9eoTI8T06Xr1iRFiV3SOEOcnBQoUMLdAurPozZf9Zgay35zcxgPXezVx3XmCxXNqY17jee2TfmAEj2ePWTnGXUHj+kHnCRa3XOZDJpB+6OiHTCD9kJI8xOlTZPYpcL+PxuOJPkVGn3SfjvbjKXvb6VM4+uSE4+l69CniTqorXry46XDgyK7eL126dNDnaDwvy+e0Dh1GP378+E9aDwAAAPK/sCbEWv5Qt25dWbx4sTemw+l637eEwpfGfZdXCxcuzHH5YPQ14+Li/Nazbds22bNnT57WAwAAgPwv7CUTeoJcly5dTPGz1vCOGzfOzCKhNb6qc+fOps5YT2pTvXv3lmbNmsnYsWOlVatWMn36dFNIPXnyZO86jx49apJbrVG2k12lo79608JvnbZNX/umm24yNSU6q4Umw8FOqAMAAED0CntCrNOo6VmHQ4YMkf3795uT3xYsWCClSpUyj2ti61tz0qRJE3NS3ODBg2XQoEGSmppqZpioXr26d5k5c+Z4E2rVoUMH83+d63jYsGHm77feesusVy/IoSfL6UwVenIeAAAAnCXs8xDnVzrLhI40X+msRfhLGfBZuJsAh9g9plW4mwCH4HMN1wufa9cuXwv7leoAAACAcCIhBgAAgKOREAMAAMDRSIgBAADgaCTEAAAAcDQSYgAAADgaCTEAAAAcjYQYAAAAjkZCDAAAAEcjIQYAAICjkRADAADA0UiIAQAA4GgkxAAAAHA0EmIAAAA4GgkxAAAAHI2EGAAAAI5GQgwAAABHIyEGAACAo5EQAwAAwNFIiAEAAOBoJMQAAABwNBJiAAAAOBoJMQAAAByNhBgAAACORkIMAAAARyMhBgAAgKOREAMAAMDRSIgBAADgaCTEAAAAcDQSYgAAADgaCTEAAAAcjYQYAAAAjkZCDAAAAEcjIQYAAICjRURCPGHCBElJSZGCBQtKw4YNZdWqVZddfubMmVK1alWzfI0aNWTevHl+j1uWJUOGDJEyZcpIoUKFpHnz5rJjxw6/ZfT1XC6X323MmDHXpH8AAACIXGFPiGfMmCH9+vWToUOHyrp166RWrVrSokULOXjwYNDlly9fLh07dpRu3brJ+vXrpXXr1ua2adMm7zJvvPGGvPPOOzJp0iRZuXKlFC5c2Kzz/PnzfusaMWKE/Pjjj95br169rnl/AQAAEFlclg6nhpGOCNevX1/Gjx9v7ns8HilfvrxJTgcMGJBt+fbt28uZM2dk7ty53lijRo2kdu3aJgHW7pQtW1ZeeOEFefHFF83jJ06ckFKlSsmUKVOkQ4cO3hHiPn36mFtuXLhwwdxsJ0+eNO08cuSIFC1a1MTcbre5aR/0ZrPjmZmZpn1XisfExJgR64yMDL82aFzp8rmJx8bGmvX6xnW9unxgG3OKh7pPqYOy3jeV4RHRpeICvppd8oi4tA/Z4i5xieUX15fJsFziFktigsVdlsToyv7HY4lkWi6JcVni9olnWvqYS2Jdlrh84x4Rj2SP/7ftLolz+x9C9Cky+rRlRMuoP57oU2T0qcrgBVF/PNGnyOjTzlEto/54coe4T8eOHZOkpCSTC9r5WjCxEkYXL16UtWvXysCBA70x3Qha4rBixYqgz9G4jij70tHf2bNnm7/T0tJk//79Zh22hIQEk3jrc+2EWGmJxMiRI6VChQry+OOPS9++fc2bH8zo0aNl+PDh2eI6Sq0j0KpEiRJSuXJl04ZDhw55l0lOTja37du3mzfEVqlSJSlZsqQZ3T537pw3ruUgiYmJZt2+b3DNmjUlPj5e1qxZ49eGevXqmW25ceNGvx1Bv2jo623dutUb1xISHYU/fPiw7Nq1y28bVatWTfbt2yfp6eneeKj71Kmyx+/D5eM0t5zOEHkqNesgUVN2uKVIrEi7ih6/D6EpO2KkXGGRB5Oz4scvisxMi5HUBEuals46eNLPisz/IUbuSLKkTlJWfNsJlyzd75I7S1lya0JWfN0Rl6w97JL7kz2SfENWW3RZfU6bFI8kxmfF56e7Jf2M0KcI7ZN9nETz8USfIqNPuk9H+/FEnyKjT044niqFuE+6fMSPEOtGK1eunCmDaNy4sTfev39/WbJkiSl3CKSdnjp1qimbsE2cONEkqwcOHDDruvPOO826tYbY9thjj5lvFlqiod58802pU6eO3HTTTeY5mpR37drVxINhhJgR4vw8quDEPjFCTJ+uV58YIaZP16tPjBC7onOEOJx8R5ntbxfPPPOMGQkuUKBAtuU1FiyuO0vgqLL9Zgay35zcxnMarc5LXHeeYPGc2pjXeF77pB8YwePZY1aOcVfQuH7QeYLFLZf5kAmkHzr6IRNIP6QkD3H6FJl9Ctzvo/F4ok+R0Sfdp6P9eMredvoUjj454Xi6Hn2KuJPqihcvbjqsI7u+9H7p0qWDPkfjl1ve/n9e1qm0pEK/dezevfuq+wMAAID8J6wJsY7K1q1bVxYvXuyN6XC63vctofClcd/l1cKFC73LV6xY0SS+vstoeYOWX+S0TrVhwwbzzUXrVgAAAOAcsZFQutClSxdT/NygQQMZN26cmUVC63lV586dTZ2xljKo3r17S7NmzWTs2LHSqlUrmT59uimknjx5sndoX2eOePXVVyU1NdUkyK+88oqZeUKnZ1N6cp0myPfee6/ceOON5r6eUPfEE09IsWLFwrg1AAAA4LiEWKdR07MO9UIaOjuETp+2YMECM02a2rNnj1/NSZMmTWTatGkyePBgGTRokEl6dYaJ6tWr+52Up0l1jx495Pjx43LXXXeZdeqFPJTWAmsiPWzYMHOinCbNmhAHzl4BAACA6Bf2eYjzKy3D0ClGrnTWIvylDPgs3E2AQ+we0yrcTYBD8LmG64XPtWuXr4X9SnUAAABAOJEQAwAAwNFIiAEAAOBoJMQAAABwNBJiAAAAOBoJMQAAAByNhBgAAACORkIMAAAARyMhBgAAgKOREAMAAMDRSIgBAADgaCTEAAAAcDQSYgAAADgaCTEAAAAcjYQYAAAAjkZCDAAAAEcjIQYAAICjkRADAADA0UiIAQAA4GgkxAAAAHA0EmIAAAA4GgkxAAAAHI2EGAAAAI5GQgwAAABHIyEGAACAo5EQAwAAwNFIiAEAAOBoJMQAAABwNBJiAAAAOBoJMQAAAByNhBgAAACORkIMAAAARyMhBgAAgKOREAMAAMDRIiIhnjBhgqSkpEjBggWlYcOGsmrVqssuP3PmTKlatapZvkaNGjJv3jy/xy3LkiFDhkiZMmWkUKFC0rx5c9mxY4ffMkePHpVOnTpJ0aJFJTExUbp16yanT5++Jv0DAABA5Ap7Qjxjxgzp16+fDB06VNatWye1atWSFi1ayMGDB4Muv3z5cunYsaNJYNevXy+tW7c2t02bNnmXeeONN+Sdd96RSZMmycqVK6Vw4cJmnefPn/cuo8nw5s2bZeHChTJ37lxZunSp9OjR47r0GQAAAJHDZelwahjpiHD9+vVl/Pjx5r7H45Hy5ctLr169ZMCAAdmWb9++vZw5c8YksbZGjRpJ7dq1TQKs3Slbtqy88MIL8uKLL5rHT5w4IaVKlZIpU6ZIhw4dZMuWLXLbbbfJ6tWrpV69emaZBQsWyEMPPSTp6enm+YEuXLhgbjZdZ4UKFSQtLc2MMiu3221u2ge92ex4Zmamad+V4jExMeJyuSQjI8OvDRpXunxu4rGxsWa9vnFdry4f2Mac4qHu0x3DF/i1McMjokvFBXw1u+QRcWkfssVd4hLLL64vk2G5xC2WxASLuyyJ0ZX9j8cSybRcEuOyxO0Tz7T0MZfEuixx+cY9Ih7JHv9v210S5/Y/hOhTZPRp9W+aR/3xRJ8io091Ri6K+uOJPkVGn/49pHnUH0/uEPfp2LFjUrFiRTl+/LgkJCRIjqwwunDhghUTE2N98sknfvHOnTtbDz/8cNDnlC9f3nrrrbf8YkOGDLFq1qxp/t65c6duPWv9+vV+yzRt2tR6/vnnzd/vvfeelZiY6Pf4pUuXTFtmzZoV9HWHDh1q1suNGzdu3Lhx48ZN8tXthx9+uGxOGithdPjwYZPR6+itL72/devWoM/Zv39/0OU1bj9uxy63TMmSJbN9C7rpppu8ywQaOHCgKe2w6bccrUNOSkoy31iAa+XkyZPmV5MffvjB+2sEAORnfK7hetFR5lOnTgX99d9XWBPi/KRAgQLm5ktPxgOuF/1Hg384AEQTPtdwPVy2VCISTqorXry4qfE4cOCAX1zvly5dOuhzNH655e3/X2mZwJP2tCZFR3xzel0AAABEp7AmxPHx8VK3bl1ZvHixXymC3m/cuHHQ52jcd3mlM0XYy2vhtCa1vsvoTzM624S9jP5fi6vXrl3rXeaLL74wr60n+QEAAMA5wl4yoXW5Xbp0MbM9NGjQQMaNG2dmkejatat5vHPnzlKuXDkZPXq0ud+7d29p1qyZjB07Vlq1aiXTp0+XNWvWyOTJk83jWs/bp08fefXVVyU1NdUkyK+88oqpHdHp2VS1atWkZcuW0r17dzMzxaVLl6Rnz55mBoor1ZgA15uW6ui0hIElOwCQX/G5hkgT9mnXlE659tvf/tac0KbTp+kcwvZI7T333GMu2qFTpvlemGPw4MGye/duk/TqvMM6ZZpNu6QHmibJOhJ81113ycSJE6VKlSreZbQ8QpPgTz/91Ezv0bZtW/O6RYoUuc69BwAAgDg9IQYAAAAce6U6AAAAIJxIiAEAAOBoJMQAAABwNBJiAAAAOBoJMQAAAByNhBiIcEwEAyAa/Pjjj/Ldd9+FuxlAUCTEQATSi9OcOnXKXGVRLzYDAPnZ3r17pUaNGuYaAnoxLSDSkBADEUZHUB599FFzRUa9quJHH31k4owUA8ivduzYISdOnDC33//+97Ju3TrvY3y2IRKQEAMRlgw3bdpUbr/9dnnxxRfN5cT1MuYbNmxgpBhAvlWzZk1zRdn27dvLpk2b5M0335TNmzebx0iIEQm4Uh0QIfRy4h07dpSqVavK22+/7Y3fe++95qdGvbS4Hq4kxgDyk8zMTPP5dtddd8kXX3whq1atktGjR0vt2rVNUlymTBn5+OOPw91MOFxsuBsA4L8uXbokx48fl3bt2pn7Ho9H3G63VKxY0fxjokiGAeQ3+jlWokQJqV+/vhkdbtOmjRQoUEC6dOkiFy5ckO7du4e7iQAlE0CkKFWqlPzlL3+Ru+++2zuqosqVK2f+QfF1+vTpsLQRAPLK/iIfExMj//rXv8zfs2bNMp9x5cuXl2XLlplRYyCcGCEGIkhqaqp3dDguLs78rWUSBw8e9C6jPzXq6Mrzzz8vsbEcwgAim13q9bOf/UzS0tLk17/+tcybN0/Wrl1rzo946aWXJD4+3tQZFyxYMNzNhUPxrykQgXRE2Lde2B4hHjJkiLz66quyfv16kmEA+YL9OablX3qSsP4aNnfuXHNfb/p4rVq1SIYRVpxUB0Qou4Z42LBhZkJ7HT3WOTyXL18uderUCXfzACDP50l8+OGHUq9ePTMazEnCiCQMMQERyh4V1tKJd999V4oWLSpfffUVyTCAfEk/y5566invZxvJMCIJJ9UBEa5Fixbm/zoyrCMrAJBfBZ4gDEQKSiaAfHIp58KFC4e7GQAARCUSYgAAADgav10AAADA0UiIAQAA4GgkxAAAAHA0EmIAAAA4GgkxAAAAHI2EGAAAAI5GQgwAuXDPPfdInz59JNLs3r3bXPFrw4YNOS4zZcoUSUxMvK7tOnv2rLRt29ZcYVHbd/z48ev6+gCQFyTEABDl2rdvL9u3b7+urzl16lRZtmyZucLijz/+KAkJCT95nXrZ39atW4ekfQDgK9bvHgAgJC5evCjx8fESCQoVKmRu19POnTulWrVqUr16dYk0kfTeAIgMjBADQC5lZGRIz549zWhn8eLF5ZVXXhH7Yp8pKSkycuRI6dy5sykT6NGjh4m//PLLUqVKFbnhhhukUqVK5jmXLl3yrnPYsGFSu3Zt+fDDD806dN0dOnSQU6dOeZfxeDzyxhtvyC233CIFChSQChUqyKhRo/zatmvXLrn33nvN69SqVUtWrFiRY8lEbl5T/+7UqZO5ZHiZMmXkrbfeynXZiC43duxYWbp0qSmX0PtKX69evXpy4403SunSpeXxxx+XgwcP+j138+bN8vOf/9xsQ13u7rvvNsm1tllHnf/xj3+YdertX//6l3nOt99+Kz/72c9M0p+UlGS2/enTp7ONLOs2K1u2rNx66625er8BOAcJMQDkkiZksbGxsmrVKnn77bflzTfflD/96U/ex3/3u9+ZZHT9+vUm8VWa1GlC+t1335nnvPvuuya59KUJ3+zZs2Xu3LnmtmTJEhkzZoz38YEDB5r7uk5dz7Rp06RUqVJ+6/jNb34jL774oqkl1gS8Y8eOJoHPyZVes1+/fvL111/LnDlzZOHChab8Yd26dbnaTrNmzZLu3btL48aNTbmE3lf6RUC/NPz73/82r631z5qs2vbu3StNmzY1Sf8XX3wha9eulaefftr0Q/v22GOPScuWLc069dakSRM5c+aMtGjRQooVKyarV6+WmTNnyqJFi8wXF1+LFy+Wbdu2mb5ofwHAjwUAuKJmzZpZ1apVszwejzf28ssvm5i6+eabrdatW19xPb/97W+tunXreu8PHTrUuuGGG6yTJ096Yy+99JLVsGFD87fGCxQoYL377rtB15eWlqZD1Naf/vQnb2zz5s0mtmXLFnP/z3/+s5WQkJCn14yLi7Nmzpzpffz48ePmOb1797ZyQ5fTbXY5q1evNu08deqUuT9w4ECrYsWK1sWLF4Mu36VLF+uRRx7xi02ePNkqVqyYdfr0aW/ss88+s9xut7V//37v80qVKmVduHAhV20H4DyMEANALjVq1Mj8VG/TEdAdO3ZIZmamua/lAIFmzJghd955pykRKFKkiAwePFj27Nnjt4yWLehIsk1LFOxSgi1btsiFCxfkvvvuu2zbatas6fd8FViOkNvX1PILHc1t0KCB93Etq/ippQY64vuLX/zClHzoazdr1szE7e2ho9taIhEXF5frder20VF5Le2w6fbWMhMdEbbVqFGDumEAOSIhBoAQ8U3KlNbxah3uQw89ZH6m11IKLW3Qk7p8BSaAmnRrQqdyezKc7zrspN1ex5WWD3zNa8EubdDa4I8++siUN3zyySfmMXt7XMsT/wLfGwDwRUIMALm0cuVKv/vffPONpKamSkxMTNDldcqxm2++2STBOnqsy37//fd5ek19jiaKWgN7vejJf5owa9JqO3HixE+aum3r1q1y5MgRU6eso8BVq1bNNoKto9xaq+x70qEvHeG1R+NtOpOF1iRrwm3T2me3283JcwByjYQYAHJJf9rXk830p/i//vWv8vvf/1569+592WRWnzN9+nRzEts777zjHRXNrYIFC5qZKvr37y8ffPCBWY8m4u+9955cK1rO0KVLF3nppZfkyy+/NDM/dOvWzSSZviUjeaFlEprQ6jbTkgw9WU9PsPOlJ8KdPHnSzHixZs0aU46iM1PYpQ9a5rFx40Zz//DhwyZx1hF43Uba3k2bNpn29urVS5588slsJx4CQE5IiAEgl3RKtXPnzpna2ueee84kw/b0asE8/PDD0rdvX5Po6TRnOmJszz6RF/qcF154QYYMGWJGRPVCG5erDw4FnUFDa6R1CrTmzZubulx9bU0+r0aJEiXMbBs6C8Rtt91mRop1Vg5fOmWazi6hU6ZpfXHdunXNrBx2eYfOXKGjvjraruvTkWCdZu7zzz+Xo0ePSv369aVdu3am3nr8+PEh2Q4AnMGlZ9aFuxEAgMimJQnlypUz8wvraDEARBOuVAcAyEZPANS6Xx0N1/rhESNGmPgjjzwS7qYBQMiREAMAgtKSBq3X1dpfLV/QE970Cn36/wcffDDH5/leJQ4A8gNKJgAAeaJ11HpVuZzoJaYBID8hIQYAAICjMcsEAAAAHI2EGAAAAI5GQgwAAABHIyEGAACAo5EQAwAAwNFIiAEAAOBoJMQAAAAQJ/t/wVkd6eXNsGwAAAAASUVORK5CYII=", + "text/plain": [ + "
" + ] + }, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "display_data" + }, + { + "data": { + "image/png": "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", + "text/plain": [ + "
" + ] + }, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "display_data" + }, + { + "data": { + "image/png": "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", + "text/plain": [ + "
" + ] + }, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "display_data" + }, + { + "data": { + "image/png": "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", + "text/plain": [ + "
" + ] + }, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "display_data" + }, + { + "data": { + "image/png": "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", + "text/plain": [ + "
" + ] + }, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "display_data" + }, + { + "data": { + "image/png": "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", + "text/plain": [ + "
" + ] + }, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "display_data" + }, + { + "data": { + "image/png": "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", + "text/plain": [ + "
" + ] + }, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "display_data" + }, + { + "data": { + "image/png": "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", + "text/plain": [ + "
" + ] + }, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "display_data" + } + ], + "source": [ + "import matplotlib.pyplot as plt\n", + "\n", + "# Define similarity metrics\n", + "metrics = ['cosine_similarity', 'levenshtein_ratio', 'jaccard_similarity', 'bleu_score']\n", + "\n", + "# Define parameters to analyze\n", + "parameters = ['diversity_level', 'branching_factor', 'max_depth']\n", + "\n", + "# Convert categorical columns to strings for proper grouping\n", + "df['diversity_level'] = df['diversity_level'].astype(str)\n", + "df['branching_factor'] = df['branching_factor'].astype(str)\n", + "df['max_depth'] = df['max_depth'].astype(str)\n", + "\n", + "# Create bar charts for each metric across parameters\n", + "for metric in metrics:\n", + " for param in parameters:\n", + " plt.figure(figsize=(8, 5))\n", + " df.groupby(param)[metric].mean().plot(kind='bar', title=f'{metric} by {param}')\n", + " plt.ylabel(metric)\n", + " plt.xlabel(param)\n", + " plt.xticks(rotation=45)\n", + " plt.grid(axis='y', linestyle='--', alpha=0.7)\n", + " plt.show()\n" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": 33, + "id": "75efaa29-f478-437a-9a25-32b52261351f", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [ + { + "data": { + "text/plain": [ + "" + ] + }, + "execution_count": 33, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "execute_result" + }, + { + "data": { + "image/png": "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", + "text/plain": [ + "
" + ] + }, + "metadata": {}, + "output_type": "display_data" + } + ], + "source": [ + "sns.heatmap(df.corr(numeric_only=True), annot=True)" + ] + }, + { + "cell_type": "code", + "execution_count": null, + "id": "e73f649d-7b83-4932-b91e-24d283696342", + "metadata": {}, + "outputs": [], + "source": [] + } + ], + "metadata": { + "kernelspec": { + "display_name": "Python 3 (ipykernel)", + "language": "python", + "name": "python3" + }, + "language_info": { + "codemirror_mode": { + "name": "ipython", + "version": 3 + }, + "file_extension": ".py", + "mimetype": "text/x-python", + "name": "python", + "nbconvert_exporter": "python", + "pygments_lexer": "ipython3", + "version": "3.12.7" + } + }, + "nbformat": 4, + "nbformat_minor": 5 +} diff --git a/__pycache__/ibfs.cpython-312.pyc b/__pycache__/ibfs.cpython-312.pyc new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2b66fbd19bc5b9e13a513f23c8e78e7cfd9e5f5b Binary files /dev/null and b/__pycache__/ibfs.cpython-312.pyc differ diff --git a/__pycache__/prompts.cpython-312.pyc b/__pycache__/prompts.cpython-312.pyc new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f34dd4d7131fe157a087560873d5bc042cf89756 Binary files /dev/null and b/__pycache__/prompts.cpython-312.pyc differ diff --git a/__pycache__/utils.cpython-312.pyc b/__pycache__/utils.cpython-312.pyc new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1e2c22598871041e08583e25cccceb748eebff31 Binary files /dev/null and b/__pycache__/utils.cpython-312.pyc differ diff --git a/__pycache__/zero_shot.cpython-312.pyc b/__pycache__/zero_shot.cpython-312.pyc new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e78d3531cc93e48416e3515e744a4d14c466206d Binary files /dev/null and b/__pycache__/zero_shot.cpython-312.pyc differ diff --git a/agent_studies.py b/agent_studies.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9183ea22f53b056c619c7cbc58a8734feffd1740 --- /dev/null +++ b/agent_studies.py @@ -0,0 +1,820 @@ +import os +import json +import uuid +import random +import yaml +import litellm +import tqdm +import concurrent.futures +from typing import List, Dict, Any, Optional, Tuple +from datetime import datetime +from pathlib import Path + +# Reuse components from the existing codebase +from prompts import PROMPTS, format_prompt, load_prompts +from utils import save_results, generate_user_id +from ibfs import generate_strategies, answer_query +from zero_shot import zero_shot_answer + +# Load environment variables and prompts +load_prompts() + + +class UserAgent: + """Simulates a user with a preferred answer and decision-making behavior.""" + + def __init__(self, llm_model: str = "gpt-4o", epsilon: float = 0.2): + """ + Initialize the UserAgent with properties. + + Args: + llm_model: The LLM model to use for agent decisions + epsilon: Probability of making a random choice instead of optimal + """ + self.llm_model = llm_model + self.epsilon = epsilon + self.preferred_answer = None + self.query = None + self.id = generate_user_id() + + def set_preferences(self, query: str): + """ + Set a query and generate the preferred answer for this user. + + Args: + query: The question the user wants answered + """ + self.query = query + + # Generate the user's preferred answer using the LLM + messages = [ + {"role": "system", + "content": "You are generating a preferred answer that a user has in mind for their query. This represents what the user is hoping to learn or the perspective they're hoping to see."}, + {"role": "user", + "content": f"For the query: '{query}', generate a detailed, thoughtful answer that will serve as the user's preferred answer. This is the information or perspective they are hoping to find. Make it 20 words."} + ] + + response = litellm.completion( + model=self.llm_model, + messages=messages, + max_tokens=1000 + ) + + self.preferred_answer = response.choices[0].message.content + return self.preferred_answer + + def choose_strategy(self, strategies: List[str]) -> int: + """ + Choose a strategy from the provided options. + + Args: + strategies: List of strategy descriptions + + Returns: + Index of the chosen strategy (0-based) + """ + # With probability epsilon, make a random choice + if random.random() < self.epsilon: + return random.randint(0, len(strategies) - 1) + + # Otherwise, evaluate which strategy gets closest to preferred answer + if not self.preferred_answer or not strategies: + return 0 # Default to first option if no preference or strategies + + # Prompt the LLM to rank the strategies based on similarity to preferred answer + strategy_list = "\n".join([f"{i + 1}. {s}" for i, s in enumerate(strategies)]) + + messages = [ + {"role": "system", + "content": "You are helping a user select the strategy that would most likely lead to their preferred answer."}, + {"role": "user", "content": f""" +Query: {self.query} + +User's preferred answer: {self.preferred_answer} + +Available strategies: +{strategy_list} + +Which strategy (provide the number only) would most likely lead to an answer that matches the user's preferred answer? Respond with only a single number representing your choice. +"""} + ] + + try: + response = litellm.completion( + model=self.llm_model, + messages=messages, + temperature=0.2, + max_tokens=10 + ) + + # Extract the chosen strategy number + content = response.choices[0].message.content.strip() + # Find the first number in the response + import re + match = re.search(r'\d+', content) + if match: + choice = int(match.group()) - 1 # Convert to 0-based index + # Ensure it's within bounds + if 0 <= choice < len(strategies): + return choice + + # If we couldn't parse the response or it's out of bounds, make a random choice + return random.randint(0, len(strategies) - 1) + + except Exception as e: + print(f"Error in choosing strategy: {e}") + # Fall back to random choice + return random.randint(0, len(strategies) - 1) + + +class IBFSAgent: + """Implements the Interactive Best-First Search process.""" + + def __init__(self, + llm_model: str = "gpt-4o", + diversity_level: str = "medium", + branching_factor: int = 4, + max_depth: int = 2): + """ + Initialize the IBFSAgent with properties. + + Args: + llm_model: The LLM model to use for generating candidates + diversity_level: How diverse the generated candidates should be (low, medium, high) + branching_factor: Number of candidates to generate at each step + max_depth: Maximum depth/iterations of the IBFS process + """ + self.llm_model = llm_model + self.diversity_level = diversity_level + self.branching_factor = branching_factor + self.max_depth = max_depth + self.id = generate_user_id() + + # Set up diversity-specific prompts + self._setup_prompts() + + def _setup_prompts(self): + """Set up the candidate generation and refinement prompts based on diversity level.""" + # Load the base prompts from PROMPTS dictionary + self.base_system_prompt = PROMPTS["ibfs"]["initial_strategies"]["system"] + self.base_user_prompt = PROMPTS["ibfs"]["initial_strategies"]["user"] + self.refinement_system_prompt = PROMPTS["ibfs"]["continuation_strategies"]["system"] + self.refinement_user_prompt = PROMPTS["ibfs"]["continuation_strategies"]["user"] + + # Augment with diversity-specific instructions + diversity_instructions = { + "low": """ +The strategies you generate can be similar to each other and explore related approaches. +There's no need to make them very different from each other. +""", + "medium": """ +Each strategy should represent a somewhat different approach to answering the question. +Try to include some variety in the approaches. +""", + "high": """ +Each strategy should represent a substantially different approach to answering the question. +Make sure the strategies are maximally diverse from each other - consider entirely different angles, +methodologies, perspectives, and areas of knowledge. +""" + } + + # Add diversity instructions to the prompts + self.diversity_instructions = diversity_instructions[self.diversity_level] + + def generate_strategies(self, query: str, current_path: List[str] = None) -> List[str]: + """ + Generate strategy options for the current step. + + Args: + query: The user's query + current_path: List of previously selected strategies + + Returns: + List of strategy descriptions + """ + if not current_path or len(current_path) == 0: + # Initial generation + system_prompt = self.base_system_prompt + "\n" + self.diversity_instructions + user_prompt = self.base_user_prompt + + # Format the prompts + format_args = { + "query": query, + "k": self.branching_factor + } + else: + # Refinement of previously selected strategy + system_prompt = self.refinement_system_prompt + "\n" + self.diversity_instructions + user_prompt = self.refinement_user_prompt + + # Format the prompts + format_args = { + "query": query, + "selected_strategy": current_path[-1], + "k": self.branching_factor + } + + # Format the prompts + system_message = format_prompt(system_prompt, **format_args) + user_message = format_prompt(user_prompt, **format_args) + + messages = [ + {"role": "system", "content": system_message}, + {"role": "user", "content": user_message} + ] + + try: + response = litellm.completion( + model=self.llm_model, + messages=messages, + temperature=0.7, + max_tokens=1000 + ) + + content = response.choices[0].message.content + + # Use the strategy parsing from ibfs.py + # Parse strategies using regex + import re + strategies = re.findall(r'\d+\.\s*(I can answer by[^\n\d]*(?:\n(?!\d+\.)[^\n]*)*)', content, re.IGNORECASE) + + # If we didn't find enough strategies with that format, try alternative parsing + if len(strategies) < self.branching_factor: + strategies = re.findall(r'(?:^|\n)(I can answer by[^\n]*(?:\n(?!I can answer by)[^\n]*)*)', content, + re.IGNORECASE) + + # Clean up the strategies + strategies = [s.strip() for s in strategies] + + # Ensure we have exactly b strategies + if len(strategies) > self.branching_factor: + strategies = strategies[:self.branching_factor] + + # If we still don't have enough strategies, create generic ones + while len(strategies) < self.branching_factor: + strategies.append( + f"I can answer by using approach #{len(strategies) + 1} (Note: Strategy generation incomplete)") + + return strategies + + except Exception as e: + print(f"Error generating strategies: {e}") + # Return fallback strategies + return [f"I can answer by approach #{i + 1} (Error: Could not generate strategies)" for i in + range(self.branching_factor)] + + def generate_final_answer(self, query: str, strategy_path: List[str]) -> str: + """ + Generate the final answer based on the selected strategy path. + + Args: + query: The original user query + strategy_path: List of selected strategies + + Returns: + Final answer to the query + """ + if not strategy_path: + return "No strategy was selected to generate an answer." + + final_strategy = strategy_path[-1] + + # Use the answer_query function from ibfs.py + return answer_query(query, final_strategy) + + +def run_simulation(query: str, + user_agent: UserAgent, + ibfs_agent: IBFSAgent) -> Dict[str, Any]: + """ + Run a full simulation of a user interacting with the IBFS system. + + Args: + query: The question to be answered + user_agent: The UserAgent instance + ibfs_agent: The IBFSAgent instance + + Returns: + Dictionary containing the simulation results + """ + # Set up the user's preferred answer + user_agent.set_preferences(query) + + # Initialize the strategy path + strategy_path = [] + + # Record all strategies presented and choices made + history = [] + + # Run through the IBFS process up to max_depth + for depth in range(ibfs_agent.max_depth): + # Generate strategies at this step + strategies = ibfs_agent.generate_strategies(query, strategy_path) + + # Have the user agent choose a strategy + choice_idx = user_agent.choose_strategy(strategies) + chosen_strategy = strategies[choice_idx] + + # Record this step + history.append({ + "depth": depth, + "strategies": strategies, + "choice_idx": choice_idx, + "chosen_strategy": chosen_strategy + }) + + # Update the strategy path + strategy_path.append(chosen_strategy) + + # Generate the final answer + final_answer = ibfs_agent.generate_final_answer(query, strategy_path) + + # Create the simulation result + result = { + "query": query, + "user_id": user_agent.id, + "ibfs_id": ibfs_agent.id, + "user_preferred_answer": user_agent.preferred_answer, + "final_answer": final_answer, + "strategy_path": strategy_path, + "history": history, + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": ibfs_agent.diversity_level, + "branching_factor": ibfs_agent.branching_factor, + "max_depth": ibfs_agent.max_depth + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": user_agent.epsilon + }, + "timestamp": datetime.now().isoformat() + } + + return result + + +def evaluate_answer_similarity(answer1: str, answer2: str) -> float: + """ + Evaluate the similarity between two answers using the LLM. + + Args: + answer1: First answer + answer2: Second answer + + Returns: + Similarity score (0-1) + """ + messages = [ + {"role": "system", + "content": "You are evaluating the similarity between a user's preferred answer and a generated answer. Provide a similarity score from 0 to 1, where 1 means identical in content and perspective, and 0 means completely different."}, + {"role": "user", "content": f""" +Answer 1: +{answer1} + +Answer 2: +{answer2} + +On a scale from 0 to 1, how similar are these answers in terms of content, perspective, and key information? +Provide only a single number as your response. +"""} + ] + + try: + response = litellm.completion( + model="gpt-4o", + messages=messages, + temperature=0.1, + max_tokens=10 + ) + + content = response.choices[0].message.content.strip() + # Extract the score from the response + import re + match = re.search(r'(\d+(\.\d+)?)', content) + if match: + score = float(match.group(1)) + # Ensure it's in the range [0, 1] + return max(0, min(score, 1)) + else: + # Default score if parsing fails + return 0.5 + + except Exception as e: + print(f"Error evaluating similarity: {e}") + return 0.5 + + +def process_simulation(args): + """ + Process a single simulation for parallel execution. + + Args: + args: Tuple containing (query, user_config, ibfs_config, experiment_id, sim_count) + + Returns: + Simulation result + """ + query, user_config, ibfs_config, experiment_id, sim_count = args + + try: + # Create agents with the current configuration + user_agent = UserAgent(epsilon=user_config["epsilon"]) + ibfs_agent = IBFSAgent( + diversity_level=ibfs_config["diversity_level"], + branching_factor=ibfs_config["branching_factor"], + max_depth=ibfs_config["max_depth"] + ) + + # Run the simulation + result = run_simulation(query, user_agent, ibfs_agent) + + # Add evaluation of similarity between preferred and final answers + similarity = evaluate_answer_similarity( + user_agent.preferred_answer, + result["final_answer"] + ) + result["similarity_score"] = similarity + + # Add metadata + result["experiment_id"] = experiment_id + result["simulation_id"] = sim_count + + # Save individual result + os.makedirs("experiment_results", exist_ok=True) + simulation_id = f"{experiment_id}_sim_{sim_count}" + with open(f"experiment_results/{simulation_id}.json", "w") as f: + json.dump(result, f, indent=2) + + return result + + except Exception as e: + print(f"Error in simulation {sim_count}: {e}") + return { + "error": str(e), + "experiment_id": experiment_id, + "simulation_id": sim_count, + "query": query + } + + +def run_experiment(queries: List[str], + diversity_levels: List[str], + branching_factors: List[int], + max_depths: List[int], + epsilon_values: List[float], + repetitions: int = 3, + max_workers: int = 4) -> List[Dict[str, Any]]: + """ + Run a full experiment with different configurations using parallel processing. + + Args: + queries: List of queries to test + diversity_levels: List of diversity levels to test + branching_factors: List of branching factors to test + max_depths: List of max depths to test + epsilon_values: List of epsilon values to test + repetitions: Number of repetitions for each configuration + max_workers: Maximum number of parallel workers + + Returns: + List of results for all simulations + """ + # Create the results directory if it doesn't exist + os.makedirs("experiment_results", exist_ok=True) + + # Generate a unique experiment ID + experiment_id = f"exp_{datetime.now().strftime('%Y%m%d_%H%M%S')}" + + # Create a config log for this experiment + config = { + "experiment_id": experiment_id, + "queries": queries, + "diversity_levels": diversity_levels, + "branching_factors": branching_factors, + "max_depths": max_depths, + "epsilon_values": epsilon_values, + "repetitions": repetitions, + "timestamp": datetime.now().isoformat() + } + + # Save the configuration + with open(f"experiment_results/{experiment_id}_config.json", "w") as f: + json.dump(config, f, indent=2) + + # Prepare all simulation configurations + simulation_args = [] + sim_count = 0 + + for query in queries: + for diversity in diversity_levels: + for branching in branching_factors: + for depth in max_depths: + for epsilon in epsilon_values: + for rep in range(repetitions): + # Create configuration for this simulation + user_config = {"epsilon": epsilon} + ibfs_config = { + "diversity_level": diversity, + "branching_factor": branching, + "max_depth": depth + } + + # Add to arguments list + simulation_args.append((query, user_config, ibfs_config, experiment_id, sim_count)) + sim_count += 1 + + # Calculate total simulations + total_simulations = len(simulation_args) + + # Run simulations in parallel with progress bar + results = [] + with tqdm.tqdm(total=total_simulations, desc="Running simulations") as pbar: + with concurrent.futures.ProcessPoolExecutor(max_workers=max_workers) as executor: + # Submit all simulations and process as they complete + future_to_sim = {executor.submit(process_simulation, args): args for args in simulation_args} + + for future in concurrent.futures.as_completed(future_to_sim): + result = future.result() + results.append(result) + pbar.update(1) + + # Save aggregated results + with open(f"experiment_results/{experiment_id}_all_results.json", "w") as f: + json.dump(results, f, indent=2) + + return results + + +def analyze_results(experiment_id: str) -> Dict[str, Any]: + """ + Analyze the results of an experiment. + + Args: + experiment_id: ID of the experiment to analyze + + Returns: + Dictionary with analysis results + """ + # Load all simulation results for this experiment + results = [] + for filename in os.listdir("experiment_results"): + if filename.startswith(experiment_id) and not filename.endswith("config.json") and not filename.endswith( + "all_results.json") and not filename.endswith("analysis.json"): + with open(f"experiment_results/{filename}", "r") as f: + try: + results.append(json.load(f)) + except json.JSONDecodeError: + print(f"Error loading {filename}") + + # Aggregate metrics by configuration + aggregated = {} + + for result in results: + if "error" in result: + continue # Skip failed simulations + + # Create a key for this configuration + config_key = ( + result["ibfs_config"]["diversity_level"], + result["ibfs_config"]["branching_factor"], + result["ibfs_config"]["max_depth"], + result["user_config"]["epsilon"] + ) + + # Initialize if this is the first result with this config + if config_key not in aggregated: + aggregated[config_key] = { + "similarity_scores": [], + "config": { + "diversity_level": result["ibfs_config"]["diversity_level"], + "branching_factor": result["ibfs_config"]["branching_factor"], + "max_depth": result["ibfs_config"]["max_depth"], + "epsilon": result["user_config"]["epsilon"] + }, + "queries": [] + } + + # Add the similarity score + aggregated[config_key]["similarity_scores"].append(result["similarity_score"]) + + # Track queries for this configuration + if result["query"] not in aggregated[config_key]["queries"]: + aggregated[config_key]["queries"].append(result["query"]) + + # Calculate summary statistics + summary = [] + for config_key, data in aggregated.items(): + scores = data["similarity_scores"] + summary.append({ + "config": data["config"], + "avg_similarity": sum(scores) / len(scores) if scores else 0, + "min_similarity": min(scores) if scores else 0, + "max_similarity": max(scores) if scores else 0, + "std_deviation": (sum((x - (sum(scores) / len(scores))) ** 2 for x in scores) / len( + scores)) ** 0.5 if scores else 0, + "num_samples": len(scores), + "queries_tested": len(data["queries"]) + }) + + # Sort by average similarity (descending) + summary.sort(key=lambda x: x["avg_similarity"], reverse=True) + + # Add query-specific analysis + query_analysis = {} + for result in results: + if "error" in result: + continue + + query = result["query"] + if query not in query_analysis: + query_analysis[query] = { + "best_config": None, + "best_similarity": -1, + "configs_tested": 0, + "avg_similarity": 0, + "all_scores": [] + } + + # Track all scores for this query + query_analysis[query]["all_scores"].append(result["similarity_score"]) + + # Update best configuration for this query + if result["similarity_score"] > query_analysis[query]["best_similarity"]: + query_analysis[query]["best_similarity"] = result["similarity_score"] + query_analysis[query]["best_config"] = { + "diversity_level": result["ibfs_config"]["diversity_level"], + "branching_factor": result["ibfs_config"]["branching_factor"], + "max_depth": result["ibfs_config"]["max_depth"], + "epsilon": result["user_config"]["epsilon"] + } + + # Calculate query statistics + for query, data in query_analysis.items(): + scores = data["all_scores"] + data["avg_similarity"] = sum(scores) / len(scores) if scores else 0 + data["configs_tested"] = len(scores) + # Remove the raw scores to keep the analysis file smaller + del data["all_scores"] + + # Save the analysis + analysis = { + "experiment_id": experiment_id, + "total_simulations": len(results), + "summary": summary, + "query_analysis": query_analysis, + "timestamp": datetime.now().isoformat() + } + + with open(f"experiment_results/{experiment_id}_analysis.json", "w") as f: + json.dump(analysis, f, indent=2) + + return analysis + + +def compare_to_zero_shot(experiment_id: str, queries: List[str]) -> Dict[str, Any]: + """ + Compare IBFS results to zero-shot answers. + + Args: + experiment_id: ID of the experiment to compare + queries: List of queries to test with zero-shot + + Returns: + Comparison results + """ + # First, get zero-shot answers for all queries + zero_shot_results = [] + + print("Generating zero-shot answers...") + for query in tqdm.tqdm(queries): + try: + # Generate zero-shot answer using function from ibfs.py + answer = zero_shot_answer(query) + + # Save the result + zero_shot_results.append({ + "query": query, + "zero_shot_answer": answer + }) + except Exception as e: + print(f"Error generating zero-shot answer for '{query}': {e}") + zero_shot_results.append({ + "query": query, + "zero_shot_answer": f"Error: {str(e)}", + "error": True + }) + + # Load the IBFS experiment results + analysis = analyze_results(experiment_id) + + # Load the best configurations from the analysis + best_config = analysis["summary"][0]["config"] if analysis["summary"] else None + + # For each query, compare the best IBFS result to the zero-shot answer + comparison = [] + + print("Comparing zero-shot to IBFS results...") + for zero_shot_result in tqdm.tqdm(zero_shot_results): + query = zero_shot_result["query"] + zero_shot_answer = zero_shot_result["zero_shot_answer"] + + # Find the best IBFS result for this query + query_data = analysis.get("query_analysis", {}).get(query, {}) + best_config_for_query = query_data.get("best_config", best_config) + + if best_config_for_query: + # Find a simulation with this configuration and query + matching_results = [] + for filename in os.listdir("experiment_results"): + if filename.startswith(experiment_id) and not filename.endswith( + "config.json") and not filename.endswith("all_results.json") and not filename.endswith( + "analysis.json"): + try: + with open(f"experiment_results/{filename}", "r") as f: + result = json.load(f) + if (result.get("query") == query and + result.get("ibfs_config", {}).get("diversity_level") == best_config_for_query.get( + "diversity_level") and + result.get("ibfs_config", {}).get("branching_factor") == best_config_for_query.get( + "branching_factor") and + result.get("ibfs_config", {}).get("max_depth") == best_config_for_query.get( + "max_depth") and + result.get("user_config", {}).get("epsilon") == best_config_for_query.get( + "epsilon")): + matching_results.append(result) + except: + continue + + # Use the best matching result (if any) + if matching_results: + # Sort by similarity score (descending) + matching_results.sort(key=lambda x: x.get("similarity_score", 0), reverse=True) + best_ibfs_result = matching_results[0] + + # Compare zero-shot to user's preferred answer + preferred_answer = best_ibfs_result.get("user_preferred_answer", "") + zero_shot_similarity = evaluate_answer_similarity(preferred_answer, zero_shot_answer) + + # Get the IBFS similarity (already calculated) + ibfs_similarity = best_ibfs_result.get("similarity_score", 0) + + comparison.append({ + "query": query, + "zero_shot_similarity": zero_shot_similarity, + "ibfs_similarity": ibfs_similarity, + "difference": ibfs_similarity - zero_shot_similarity, + "ibfs_config": best_config_for_query + }) + else: + print(f"No valid configuration found for query: {query}") + + # Calculate overall metrics + zero_shot_avg = sum(item["zero_shot_similarity"] for item in comparison) / len(comparison) if comparison else 0 + ibfs_avg = sum(item["ibfs_similarity"] for item in comparison) / len(comparison) if comparison else 0 + avg_difference = sum(item["difference"] for item in comparison) / len(comparison) if comparison else 0 + + # Save the comparison results + comparison_results = { + "experiment_id": experiment_id, + "zero_shot_avg_similarity": zero_shot_avg, + "ibfs_avg_similarity": ibfs_avg, + "avg_difference": avg_difference, + "query_comparisons": comparison, + "timestamp": datetime.now().isoformat() + } + + with open(f"experiment_results/{experiment_id}_zero_shot_comparison.json", "w") as f: + json.dump(comparison_results, f, indent=2) + + return comparison_results + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + # Ensure the prompts from YAML file are loaded + if not PROMPTS: + load_prompts() + + # Sample queries to test + queries = [ + "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "How has artificial intelligence changed the job market in the past decade?", + "What are the most effective strategies for reducing stress and anxiety?", + "What are the arguments for and against universal basic income?", + ] + + # Experiment parameters + diversity_levels = ["low", "medium", "high"] + branching_factors = [2, 4, 8] + max_depths = [1, 2, 4] + epsilon_values = [0.1, 0.3] + + # Run a smaller test experiment + print("Running test experiment...") + test_results = run_experiment( + queries=queries[:1], # Just use the first query for testing + diversity_levels=diversity_levels[:2], # Test low and medium diversity + branching_factors=[2, 4], # Test b=2 and b=4 + max_depths=[1, 2], # Test m=1 and m=2 + epsilon_values=[0.2], # Test epsilon=0.2 + repetitions=10, # Just 2 repetitions for testing + max_workers=7 # Use 2 parallel workers for testing + ) diff --git a/analysis.py b/analysis.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e69de29bb2d1d6434b8b29ae775ad8c2e48c5391 diff --git a/analysis_exp_20250319_141119/basic_stats.json b/analysis_exp_20250319_141119/basic_stats.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..561442cd9f4caa9694016a17483bfc2e06dba6db --- /dev/null +++ b/analysis_exp_20250319_141119/basic_stats.json @@ -0,0 +1,9 @@ +{ + "total_simulations": 16, + "parameter_ranges": { + "diversity_levels": [ + "low", + "medium" + ], + "branching_factors": [ + \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/analysis_output_exp_20250319_141119/basic_stats.json b/analysis_output_exp_20250319_141119/basic_stats.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..561442cd9f4caa9694016a17483bfc2e06dba6db --- /dev/null +++ b/analysis_output_exp_20250319_141119/basic_stats.json @@ -0,0 +1,9 @@ +{ + "total_simulations": 16, + "parameter_ranges": { + "diversity_levels": [ + "low", + "medium" + ], + "branching_factors": [ + \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/app.py b/app.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..539ef81c02bfb76793ded426793b657ca21f08d4 --- /dev/null +++ b/app.py @@ -0,0 +1,299 @@ +import gradio as gr +from dotenv import load_dotenv + +# Import from other modules +from ibfs import start_ibfs, handle_choice +from zero_shot import start_zero_shot + +# Load environment variables +load_dotenv() + + + +# Define dependent variables for user evaluation +DV_QUESTIONS = [ + "How satisfied are you with the answer? (1-5)", + "How clear was the explanation? (1-5)", + "How relevant was the answer to your query? (1-5)", + "How confident are you in the accuracy of the answer? (1-5)", + "Would you use this method again for similar questions? (Yes/No)" +] + + +def save_dv_responses(user_id, method, responses): + """Save user's responses to dependent variable questions.""" + from utils import save_results + import json + from datetime import datetime + + timestamp = datetime.now().strftime("%Y%m%d_%H%M%S") + filename = f"ibfs_results/{user_id}_{method}_dv_{timestamp}.json" + + with open(filename, "w") as f: + json.dump(responses, f, indent=2) + + return filename + + +def process_dv_responses(state, *responses): + """Process and save the user's responses to dependent variables.""" + if not state: + return "No active session" + + user_id = state.get("user_id", "unknown") + method = state.get("method", "unknown") + + # Create a dictionary of responses + response_dict = { + "user_id": user_id, + "method": method, + "responses": {} + } + + for i, response in enumerate(responses): + response_dict["responses"][f"question_{i + 1}"] = { + "question": DV_QUESTIONS[i], + "response": response + } + + # Save responses + save_path = save_dv_responses(user_id, method, response_dict) + + return f"Thank you for your feedback! Responses saved to {save_path}" + + +def create_ibfs_interface(): + """Create the IBFS tab interface.""" + with gr.Column(): + gr.Markdown("# IBFS") + gr.Markdown("Enter your query and set parameters to explore different strategies.") + + with gr.Row(): + with gr.Column(scale=3): + ibfs_query_input = gr.Textbox( + label="Query", + placeholder="Enter your question here...", + lines=3 + ) + + with gr.Column(scale=1): + k_slider = gr.Slider( + minimum=2, + maximum=5, + step=1, + value=3, + label="k (Branching Factor - options per step)" + ) + m_slider = gr.Slider( + minimum=1, + maximum=3, + step=1, + value=2, + label="m (Depth - number of iterations)" + ) + + ibfs_start_btn = gr.Button("Start IBFS Process", variant="primary") + + # State for maintaining context between steps + ibfs_state = gr.State(None) + + # Chat display + ibfs_chatbot = gr.Chatbot( + label="Interactive Search Process", + height=600, + type="messages" + ) + + # User choice input for selecting strategies + ibfs_choice_input = gr.Textbox( + label="Enter the number of your choice (e.g., 1, 2, 3...)", + placeholder="Type a number and press Enter", + lines=1 + ) + + # Event handlers for IBFS + ibfs_start_btn.click( + fn=start_ibfs, + inputs=[ibfs_query_input, k_slider, m_slider], + outputs=[ibfs_state, ibfs_chatbot], + show_progress="minimal" + ) + + ibfs_choice_input.submit( + fn=handle_choice, + inputs=[ibfs_state, ibfs_choice_input], + outputs=[ibfs_state, ibfs_chatbot], + show_progress="minimal" + ) + + ibfs_choice_input.submit( + fn=lambda: "", + inputs=[], + outputs=[ibfs_choice_input] + ) + + # Dependent Variables Section (initially hidden) + with gr.Accordion("Evaluation Questions", open=False, visible=False) as ibfs_dv_accordion: + ibfs_dv_inputs = [] + for i, question in enumerate(DV_QUESTIONS): + if "1-5" in question: + dv_input = gr.Slider( + minimum=1, + maximum=5, + step=1, + value=3, + label=question + ) + elif "Yes/No" in question: + dv_input = gr.Radio( + choices=["Yes", "No"], + label=question + ) + else: + dv_input = gr.Textbox( + label=question + ) + ibfs_dv_inputs.append(dv_input) + + ibfs_submit_dv_btn = gr.Button("Submit Evaluation", variant="primary") + ibfs_dv_result = gr.Markdown("") + + # Function to show DV accordion after final answer is generated + def show_dv_section(state): + if state and state.get("current_step", 0) == 0 and state.get("strategy_path", []): + # This means we've completed a cycle and have a final answer + state["method"] = "ibfs" # Add method to state for DV processing + return gr.update(visible=True, open=True) + return gr.update(visible=False, open=False) + + # Update visibility of DV section when state changes + ibfs_state.change( + fn=show_dv_section, + inputs=[ibfs_state], + outputs=[ibfs_dv_accordion] + ) + + # Handle DV submission + ibfs_submit_dv_btn.click( + fn=process_dv_responses, + inputs=[ibfs_state] + ibfs_dv_inputs, + outputs=ibfs_dv_result + ) + + return (ibfs_query_input, k_slider, m_slider, ibfs_start_btn, + ibfs_state, ibfs_chatbot, ibfs_choice_input) + + +def create_zero_shot_interface(): + """Create the Zero-Shot tab interface.""" + with gr.Column(): + gr.Markdown("# Zero-Shot Direct Answer") + gr.Markdown("Enter your query to get a direct answer without interactive exploration.") + + zero_query_input = gr.Textbox( + label="Query", + placeholder="Enter your question here...", + lines=3 + ) + + zero_shot_btn = gr.Button("Get Direct Answer", variant="primary") + + # State for maintaining context for zero-shot + zero_state = gr.State(None) + + # Chat display + zero_chatbot = gr.Chatbot( + label="Direct Answer", + height=600, + type="messages" + ) + + # Modified zero-shot function to return state + def zero_shot_with_state(query): + """Wrapper for zero_shot to also return state""" + from utils import generate_user_id + chat_history = start_zero_shot(query) + # Create state with user_id and method for DV processing + state = { + "user_id": generate_user_id(), + "method": "zero_shot", + "has_answer": True # Flag to indicate answer is ready + } + return state, chat_history + + # Event handler for zero-shot + zero_shot_btn.click( + fn=zero_shot_with_state, + inputs=zero_query_input, + outputs=[zero_state, zero_chatbot], + show_progress="minimal" + ) + + # Dependent Variables Section (initially hidden) + with gr.Accordion("Evaluation Questions", open=False, visible=False) as zero_dv_accordion: + zero_dv_inputs = [] + for i, question in enumerate(DV_QUESTIONS): + if "1-5" in question: + dv_input = gr.Slider( + minimum=1, + maximum=5, + step=1, + value=3, + label=question + ) + elif "Yes/No" in question: + dv_input = gr.Radio( + choices=["Yes", "No"], + label=question + ) + else: + dv_input = gr.Textbox( + label=question + ) + zero_dv_inputs.append(dv_input) + + zero_submit_dv_btn = gr.Button("Submit Evaluation", variant="primary") + zero_dv_result = gr.Markdown("") + + # Function to show DV accordion after answer is generated + def show_zero_dv_section(state): + if state and state.get("has_answer", False): + return gr.update(visible=True, open=True) + return gr.update(visible=False, open=False) + + # Update visibility of DV section when state changes + zero_state.change( + fn=show_zero_dv_section, + inputs=[zero_state], + outputs=[zero_dv_accordion] + ) + + # Handle DV submission + zero_submit_dv_btn.click( + fn=process_dv_responses, + inputs=[zero_state] + zero_dv_inputs, + outputs=zero_dv_result + ) + + return zero_query_input, zero_shot_btn, zero_chatbot + + +def create_gradio_app(): + """Create the main Gradio application with tabs.""" + with gr.Blocks() as app: + with gr.Tabs() as tabs: + # IBFS Tab + with gr.Tab("IBFS"): + create_ibfs_interface() + + # Zero-Shot Tab + with gr.Tab("Zero-Shot"): + create_zero_shot_interface() + + return app + + +# Create and launch the app +if __name__ == "__main__": + ibfs_app = create_gradio_app() + ibfs_app.launch(share=True) \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_all_results.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_all_results.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0ed86156d7bc148d81b6badc9585514661c1ce47 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_all_results.json @@ -0,0 +1,634 @@ +[ + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "ec487b84-f421-4825-925e-6811623122df", + "ibfs_id": "1f13d1b0-313f-4112-8ec3-4b366183261f", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles have distinct environmental impacts, and understanding these differences is crucial for assessing their roles in sustainable transportation.\n\n1. **Emissions During Use**: One of the most significant environmental advantages of EVs over gasoline vehicles is their lack of tailpipe emissions. While gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change, EVs run on electricity and produce no direct emissions. This shift can significantly improve air quality, especially in urban areas.\n\n2. **Lifecycle Emissions**: When evaluating the overall environmental impact, it's essential to consider the entire lifecycle of the vehicles, from production to disposal. EVs generally have higher emissions during the manufacturing phase, primarily due to the battery production, which requires mining and processing of minerals like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. However, these initial emissions are often offset by the reduced emissions during the vehicle's operational phase.\n\n3. **Energy Source for Electricity**: The environmental benefits of EVs are closely tied to the energy sources used for electricity generation. In regions where the grid is predominantly powered by coal or other fossil fuels, the emissions benefits of EVs are reduced. However, as the grid becomes greener with more renewable energy sources like wind, solar, and hydroelectric power, the environmental advantage of EVs increases.\n\n4. **Resource Extraction and Battery Production**: The production of EV batteries involves resource-intensive processes. Mining for battery materials can lead to habitat destruction, water pollution, and significant energy use. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling processes are continually being developed to mitigate these impacts.\n\n5. **End-of-Life and Recycling**: The disposal and recycling of both EVs and gasoline vehicles present environmental challenges. EV batteries, in particular, require careful handling due to their chemical components. Recycling programs are crucial to reclaim valuable materials and reduce environmental harm. The automotive industry is investing in improving battery recycling technologies to enhance sustainability.\n\n6. **Efficiency and Energy Use**: EVs are generally more efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 60% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, while conventional gasoline engines convert only about 20% of the energy stored in gasoline. This higher efficiency translates to less energy use and lower overall emissions, assuming a clean energy source.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles present certain environmental challenges, particularly in terms of battery production and resource extraction, they offer significant benefits in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and air pollutants during operation. The net environmental impact of EVs is highly dependent on the electricity grid's cleanliness, advancements in battery technology, and effective recycling systems. As clean energy sources and technologies continue to evolve, the environmental benefits of EVs are expected to increase, making them a key component in reducing the transportation sector's carbon footprint.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we will conduct a comparative lifecycle analysis. This analysis examines the entire lifecycle of both vehicle types, including raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. We will evaluate each stage in terms of greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use copper and rare earth elements for motors and electronics, which require additional mining activities.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Fuel Extraction:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can cause oil spills, habitat disruption, and significant land and water pollution.\n- **Material Use:** Gasoline vehicles primarily use steel, aluminum, and plastics, which also require energy-intensive extraction processes but generally have a less complex supply chain than EV batteries.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** The manufacturing of EVs, particularly their batteries, is energy-intensive. The production process emits more greenhouse gases compared to gasoline vehicles due to the energy required for battery production.\n- **Manufacturing Emissions:** Overall, EVs have higher emissions during the manufacturing phase because of the complex battery systems.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Conventional Manufacturing:** The production of gasoline vehicles is well-established and generally less energy-intensive than EVs, resulting in lower emissions during the manufacturing phase.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, significantly reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during the usage phase depends on the electricity source. If the electricity comes from renewable sources, the emissions are minimal. However, if it is from coal or natural gas, the emissions can be substantial.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Combustion Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and particulate matter during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Improvements in fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, but they still remain higher than those of EVs, especially when EVs are powered by clean energy.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries are critical. Improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination. However, advances in battery recycling technologies are improving the recovery of valuable materials.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, the rest of the EV can be recycled, but the battery poses unique challenges.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles have a well-established recycling process for metals and other materials, which mitigates some environmental impacts.\n- **Waste Products:** End-of-life gasoline vehicles do not have the same battery disposal issues as EVs, but they still contribute to waste and pollution.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles generally have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases due to the energy-intensive processes involved in battery production. However, during the usage phase, EVs offer significant environmental benefits over gasoline vehicles, especially when powered by renewable energy, as they produce zero tailpipe emissions. The end-of-life disposal of EVs presents challenges, particularly with battery recycling, but advancements in this area are ongoing. Overall, while EVs have a larger initial environmental footprint, their long-term benefits in reducing emissions and pollution make them a more sustainable option compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining the entire lifecycle of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal. I would assess the environmental impacts at each stage, considering factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution. This comprehensive analysis would provide a detailed view of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining the entire lifecycle of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal. I would assess the environmental impacts at each stage, considering factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution. This comprehensive analysis would provide a detailed view of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational emissions and energy sources associated with electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would emphasize the emissions produced during the use phase of the vehicles. For gasoline vehicles, I would calculate the emissions from burning fossil fuels. For electric vehicles, I would analyze the emissions based on the electricity mix used for charging, considering how the energy grid's reliance on renewable or non-renewable sources affects the overall environmental impact. This strategy highlights the differences in emissions during the vehicles' operational life." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining the entire lifecycle of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal. I would assess the environmental impacts at each stage, considering factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution. This comprehensive analysis would provide a detailed view of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:11:52.163671", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 0 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c2791648-8420-4b9d-8353-1576e0896024", + "ibfs_id": "36233969-2c31-413c-9d61-d4a40a06f31b", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) offer a promising solution to many of the environmental challenges posed by traditional gasoline vehicles, but they also come with their own set of environmental impacts. A comprehensive comparison between EVs and gasoline vehicles reveals several key aspects:\n\n1. **Greenhouse Gas Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs produce zero emissions at the tailpipe, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas. However, the production of electricity used to charge EVs can contribute to greenhouse gas emissions, depending on the energy sources. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the overall emissions are much lower.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2) and other harmful pollutants directly from their exhausts. Combustion of gasoline releases significant amounts of CO2, contributing to global warming, and other pollutants that degrade air quality, such as nitrogen oxides and particulate matter.\n\n2. **Lifecycle Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: Manufacturing EVs, especially the batteries, can be more resource-intensive compared to conventional vehicles, leading to higher emissions upfront. However, over their lifetime, EVs generally have lower emissions when accounting for the electricity used for charging. Improvements in battery technology and recycling, along with cleaner electricity grids, are further reducing the lifecycle emissions of EVs.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: While their manufacturing process involves fewer emissions compared to EVs, the continuous burning of fuel over the vehicle's lifespan results in higher cumulative emissions. Gasoline production, including extraction, refining, and distribution, also contributes to significant emissions.\n\n3. **Resource Use and Environmental Impact**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The production of EV batteries requires minerals such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel. Mining these minerals can have environmental and social impacts, including habitat destruction and pollution. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling are helping mitigate these issues.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The extraction and processing of crude oil have substantial environmental impacts, including oil spills, habitat destruction, and pollution. The infrastructure required for oil extraction and transportation also impacts ecosystems.\n\n4. **Energy Efficiency**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert a higher percentage of electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, compared to the lower efficiency of internal combustion engines.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Internal combustion engines typically have lower efficiency rates, with much of the energy from gasoline lost as heat. This inefficiency contributes to higher fuel consumption and emissions.\n\n5. **End-of-Life Considerations**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose challenges but also opportunities. Effective recycling can recover valuable materials and reduce environmental impact. Policies and technologies are evolving to improve battery recycling processes.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Conventional vehicles also require end-of-life processing, but they lack the complex battery disposal issues of EVs. However, they contribute to environmental pollution through the disposal of used oil and other fluids.\n\nIn summary, while EVs are not entirely free of environmental impacts, they generally offer significant benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving air quality. Their environmental footprint is expected to further decrease as technology advances and energy grids become greener. Transitioning to electric vehicles, coupled with renewable energy adoption and sustainable practices, plays a crucial role in achieving a more sustainable transportation system.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will conduct a comprehensive lifecycle analysis (LCA) that examines each stage of their lifecycle: raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other minerals. Mining these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Materials:** EVs also use aluminum and steel, similar to gasoline vehicles, but the production of lightweight materials like aluminum can be energy-intensive.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Extraction:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Material Use:** Gasoline vehicles are primarily made of steel and aluminum, with less reliance on rare minerals compared to EVs.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy Use:** The manufacturing process for EVs, particularly battery production, is energy-intensive and results in higher initial emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Emissions:** The production of EVs generally results in higher greenhouse gas emissions upfront due to the energy required for battery production.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Use:** Manufacturing processes for gasoline vehicles are less energy-intensive than for EVs, resulting in lower initial emissions.\n- **Emissions:** The emissions from manufacturing gasoline vehicles are typically lower than those for EVs, primarily due to the absence of battery production.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy Source:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions. However, their overall emissions depend on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources (solar, wind) significantly reduce emissions, while coal-based electricity increases them.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Gasoline vehicles are less efficient, with internal combustion engines losing a significant amount of energy as heat.\n\n### 4. Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal of EVs involves challenges related to battery recycling. While recycling technologies are improving, improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination.\n- **Material Recovery:** Many components of EVs can be recycled, but the process is complex and energy-intensive.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recyclability:** Gasoline vehicles are relatively straightforward to recycle, with established processes for recovering metals and other materials.\n- **End-of-Life Emissions:** The disposal process for gasoline vehicles is less complex than for EVs, but still involves emissions and energy use.\n\n### Overall Environmental Impact\n\n- **EVs:** While EVs have higher initial environmental impacts due to battery production, they generally have lower emissions during the usage phase, especially when powered by renewable energy. Over their lifetime, EVs tend to have a smaller carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles, particularly in regions with clean electricity grids.\n \n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** Gasoline vehicles have lower initial manufacturing emissions but contribute significantly to greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution during their operational phase. Over their lifetime, they typically have a larger environmental footprint compared to EVs.\n\nIn conclusion, while both vehicle types have environmental impacts, EVs offer a more sustainable option in the long term, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive lifecycle analysis for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the entire lifespan of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction and manufacturing processes to usage and eventual disposal. By comparing the energy consumption, emissions, and environmental impact at each stage, I can provide a detailed comparison of their overall environmental footprints." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive lifecycle analysis for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the entire lifespan of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction and manufacturing processes to usage and eventual disposal. By comparing the energy consumption, emissions, and environmental impact at each stage, I can provide a detailed comparison of their overall environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the specific types of emissions and pollutants generated by each vehicle type during operation. This approach would involve analyzing the direct air pollutants and greenhouse gases emitted by gasoline vehicles, while considering the indirect emissions associated with electricity production for EVs. By comparing the emissions profiles and considering factors like the energy sources used to generate electricity, I can offer insights into the operational environmental impacts of each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive lifecycle analysis for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the entire lifespan of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction and manufacturing processes to usage and eventual disposal. By comparing the energy consumption, emissions, and environmental impact at each stage, I can provide a detailed comparison of their overall environmental footprints." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:11:53.833862", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 1 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "fdb54149-1cf7-4023-b8e5-dcc46f7029a9", + "ibfs_id": "8474042e-348a-4a4e-b7a6-6c6542757b7e", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) are often touted as a more environmentally friendly alternative to traditional gasoline vehicles. The environmental impacts of each can be examined across several dimensions, including emissions, resource extraction, manufacturing, and end-of-life processes.\n\n**1. Emissions:**\n\n- **Operational Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas. This is a stark contrast to gasoline vehicles, which emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n \n- **Lifecycle Emissions:** While EVs are cleaner during operation, their overall environmental impact also depends on the source of electricity used to charge them. In regions where the grid relies heavily on coal or other fossil fuels, the carbon footprint of EVs can be higher. However, as the grid becomes greener, the lifecycle emissions of EVs decrease significantly.\n\n**2. Resource Extraction and Manufacturing:**\n\n- **Materials and Batteries:** EVs require lithium, cobalt, and other rare earth elements for their batteries, which can have significant environmental and ethical implications due to mining practices. The extraction processes can lead to habitat destruction, water pollution, and human rights concerns. However, the automotive industry is increasingly focusing on sustainable sourcing and recycling initiatives.\n\n- **Manufacturing Emissions:** The production of EVs, particularly their batteries, tends to be more energy-intensive compared to traditional vehicles, leading to higher initial emissions. However, these emissions are offset over the vehicle's lifespan due to their lower operational emissions.\n\n**3. Energy Efficiency:**\n\n- EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. They convert a higher percentage of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, whereas internal combustion engines lose a significant amount of energy as heat.\n\n**4. End-of-Life and Recycling:**\n\n- **Recycling Batteries:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries remain a challenge, but advances are being made in battery recycling technologies to recover and reuse valuable materials, thus reducing the environmental impact.\n\n- **Decommissioning:** Both EVs and gasoline vehicles face environmental impacts at the end of their life cycles. However, the recycling of metal and other components is more established for traditional vehicles.\n\n**5. Broader Environmental Benefits:**\n\n- **Noise Pollution:** EVs operate more quietly than gasoline vehicles, contributing to reduced noise pollution, particularly in urban areas.\n\n- **Contribution to Renewable Energy Transition:** As the integration of renewable energy sources into the grid increases, EVs can play a crucial role in energy storage and management, further supporting the transition to a low-carbon future.\n\nOverall, while EVs have certain environmental challenges, particularly related to battery production and resource extraction, they offer significant advantages in reducing emissions and improving air quality. As technology advances and renewable energy becomes more prevalent, the environmental benefits of EVs are expected to increase, making them a critical component of sustainable transportation strategies.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a localized lifecycle analysis comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to consider several factors that vary by region: the energy mix of the local electricity grid, the availability and efficiency of recycling infrastructure, and the typical driving conditions and distances. Here, we will examine three distinct regions: the United States, Germany, and China, each with different energy profiles and recycling capabilities.\n\n### United States\n\n**Energy Mix:**\n- The U.S. electricity grid is diverse, with significant contributions from natural gas, coal, nuclear, and renewables (wind, solar, hydro).\n- The carbon intensity of electricity varies by state. For example, California has a higher proportion of renewable energy compared to states like West Virginia, which relies heavily on coal.\n\n**Lifecycle Analysis:**\n- **Production:** EVs generally have higher emissions during production due to battery manufacturing. However, this is offset over time by lower operational emissions.\n- **Use Phase:** In states with cleaner grids (e.g., California), EVs have significantly lower emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. In coal-reliant states, the benefits are reduced but still present.\n- **End-of-Life:** The U.S. has a developing infrastructure for battery recycling, which is crucial for minimizing the environmental impact of EVs.\n\n### Germany\n\n**Energy Mix:**\n- Germany has made significant strides in renewable energy, with wind and solar playing a major role, although coal and natural gas are still part of the mix.\n- The Energiewende policy aims to further reduce reliance on fossil fuels.\n\n**Lifecycle Analysis:**\n- **Production:** Similar to the U.S., the initial production of EVs is more carbon-intensive due to battery manufacturing.\n- **Use Phase:** Due to a relatively clean grid, EVs in Germany generally have a lower carbon footprint during the use phase compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **End-of-Life:** Germany has robust recycling programs, including for EV batteries, which helps mitigate environmental impacts.\n\n### China\n\n**Energy Mix:**\n- China's electricity grid is heavily reliant on coal, although there is a growing investment in renewable energy.\n- The regional disparity is significant, with some areas having more access to cleaner energy sources.\n\n**Lifecycle Analysis:**\n- **Production:** China is a major producer of EVs, and the initial carbon footprint is high due to coal-based electricity used in manufacturing.\n- **Use Phase:** In regions with cleaner energy, such as those with hydroelectric power, EVs perform better environmentally. However, in coal-dominated areas, the benefits are less pronounced.\n- **End-of-Life:** China is rapidly developing its recycling infrastructure, but it still lags behind Western countries in terms of efficiency and coverage.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe environmental impact of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles varies significantly by region due to differences in energy sources and recycling infrastructure. In regions with a cleaner energy mix and robust recycling systems, such as Germany and certain U.S. states, EVs offer substantial environmental benefits over gasoline vehicles. In contrast, in areas with a coal-heavy grid, like parts of China, the benefits are reduced, though still present. The development of recycling infrastructure and a shift towards renewable energy are critical to maximizing the environmental advantages of electric vehicles globally.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach involves evaluating factors such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By comparing these aspects, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of each vehicle type over their entire lifespans.", + "I can answer by conducting a localized lifecycle analysis that accounts for regional differences in energy sources and recycling infrastructure. This approach will compare the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles in different geographical areas, taking into consideration the local electricity grid's energy mix (e.g., coal vs. renewable energy) and the availability of recycling facilities for batteries and automotive components. By examining the lifecycle impacts in various regions, I can highlight how the environmental footprints of these vehicles can vary significantly based on location." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach involves evaluating factors such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By comparing these aspects, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of each vehicle type over their entire lifespans.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both vehicle types, specifically analyzing emissions and energy efficiency during their use. This approach includes evaluating the greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during combustion and comparing them to the emissions associated with electricity generation for electric vehicles, considering the energy mix of different regions. Additionally, I can analyze how advancements in renewable energy and battery technologies influence the overall environmental impact during the operational phase." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach involves evaluating factors such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By comparing these aspects, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of each vehicle type over their entire lifespans." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a detailed lifecycle assessment of the manufacturing phase, specifically analyzing the environmental impacts of producing batteries for electric vehicles compared to the engines of gasoline vehicles. This approach will delve into the sourcing and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries and compare these with the materials and energy required for internal combustion engines. By isolating the manufacturing phase, I can provide insights into the specific environmental challenges and benefits associated with each vehicle type's production.", + "I can answer by conducting a localized lifecycle analysis that accounts for regional differences in energy sources and recycling infrastructure. This approach will compare the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles in different geographical areas, taking into consideration the local electricity grid's energy mix (e.g., coal vs. renewable energy) and the availability of recycling facilities for batteries and automotive components. By examining the lifecycle impacts in various regions, I can highlight how the environmental footprints of these vehicles can vary significantly based on location." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a localized lifecycle analysis that accounts for regional differences in energy sources and recycling infrastructure. This approach will compare the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles in different geographical areas, taking into consideration the local electricity grid's energy mix (e.g., coal vs. renewable energy) and the availability of recycling facilities for batteries and automotive components. By examining the lifecycle impacts in various regions, I can highlight how the environmental footprints of these vehicles can vary significantly based on location." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:12:27.242514", + "similarity_score": 0.7, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 2 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "e7dfef36-6ad0-4692-b928-3b1e2811fc1f", + "ibfs_id": "f1af943d-adfe-4c1d-a4ba-b792c30321fd", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) are often touted as a more environmentally friendly alternative to traditional gasoline vehicles, and there are several aspects where they offer significant environmental benefits. However, they also present some challenges that need to be considered for a comprehensive understanding.\n\n1. **Emissions During Operation**: \n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which means they do not emit harmful pollutants such as nitrogen oxides, particulate matter, or carbon dioxide while being driven. This leads to improved air quality, especially in urban areas where vehicle emissions are a major contributor to pollution.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Traditional vehicles emit a significant amount of greenhouse gases (GHGs) and pollutants during operation. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change.\n\n2. **Energy Source and Production**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The environmental impact of EVs largely depends on the energy mix used to generate the electricity that powers them. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the overall emissions are much lower. However, in regions where coal or natural gas dominate the energy mix, the carbon footprint of electricity generation can be significant.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The production and refining of gasoline involve substantial energy use and emissions. Moreover, the extraction of oil can lead to environmental degradation, spills, and habitat disruption.\n\n3. **Manufacturing Impact**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The production of EVs, particularly their batteries, is energy-intensive and can result in considerable emissions. Mining for lithium, cobalt, and other materials used in batteries can have negative environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and pollution.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: While the manufacturing of conventional vehicles also involves emissions, they are generally less than those associated with EV batteries. However, the emissions from gasoline vehicle production are compounded by their operational emissions over their lifespan.\n\n4. **Lifecycle Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: Studies suggest that, over their entire lifecycle, EVs typically have lower total emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, even when considering battery production and electricity generation. This is because the higher emissions from manufacturing are offset by the lower operational emissions.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The lifecycle emissions of gasoline vehicles remain high due to the continuous emissions from fuel combustion.\n\n5. **End-of-Life Considerations**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The recycling and disposal of EV batteries pose environmental challenges. Advancements in battery recycling technology are critical to reducing these impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Conventional vehicles also require recycling and disposal, but the environmental concerns are generally less pronounced compared to EV battery disposal.\n\nIn summary, while electric vehicles offer significant environmental benefits, particularly in terms of reducing air pollutants and greenhouse gas emissions during operation, their overall environmental impact is influenced by factors such as the energy source for electricity, battery production, and end-of-life management. Transitioning to cleaner energy sources and improving battery technologies and recycling processes are crucial steps in maximizing the environmental benefits of electric vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles during their use phase, we will conduct a life cycle analysis (LCA) focusing on energy consumption and emissions produced while the vehicles are in operation.\n\n### Electric Vehicles (EVs)\n\n1. **Energy Consumption:**\n - EVs are powered by electricity stored in batteries. The energy efficiency of EVs is generally higher than that of gasoline vehicles because electric motors convert a larger percentage of electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n - The efficiency of EVs can be measured in miles per kilowatt-hour (mi/kWh). On average, EVs achieve about 3 to 4 mi/kWh.\n\n2. **Emissions:**\n - The emissions from EVs during the use phase are primarily indirect and depend on the electricity generation mix used to charge the batteries.\n - If the electricity comes from renewable sources (e.g., wind, solar, hydro), the emissions are minimal. However, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels (e.g., coal, natural gas), the emissions can be significant.\n - On average, EVs produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions per mile compared to gasoline vehicles, even when charged from a grid with a substantial fossil fuel component. This is due to the higher efficiency of power plants compared to internal combustion engines and the potential for cleaner energy sources.\n\n### Gasoline Vehicles\n\n1. **Energy Consumption:**\n - Gasoline vehicles are powered by internal combustion engines that convert the chemical energy in gasoline into mechanical energy.\n - The energy efficiency of gasoline vehicles is typically lower than that of EVs. Fuel economy is often measured in miles per gallon (mpg). A typical gasoline vehicle might achieve around 25 to 30 mpg.\n\n2. **Emissions:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO), and particulate matter directly from the tailpipe as a result of burning gasoline.\n - The emissions are directly proportional to fuel consumption, with higher fuel consumption leading to higher emissions.\n - On average, gasoline vehicles emit more greenhouse gases per mile than EVs, primarily due to the combustion of fossil fuels in the engine.\n\n### Comparison\n\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** EVs generally produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions during the use phase compared to gasoline vehicles, especially when charged with electricity from low-carbon sources.\n- **Energy Efficiency:** EVs are more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to motion.\n- **Local Emissions:** EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, improving local air quality, whereas gasoline vehicles emit pollutants directly into the atmosphere.\n\nIn summary, during the use phase, electric vehicles tend to have a lower environmental impact in terms of greenhouse gas emissions and energy efficiency compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly when charged with electricity from renewable sources. However, the overall environmental benefits of EVs can vary significantly based on the electricity generation mix of the region where they are used.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the entire life cycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase, to disposal and recycling. I would compare factors such as energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource depletion at each stage to provide a comprehensive view of their environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis (LCA) focused on the use phase of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the environmental impacts related to the energy consumption and emissions produced while the vehicles are in operation. For EVs, this would include analyzing the electricity sources used for charging, while for gasoline vehicles, it would involve assessing the emissions from burning fuel. By comparing the operational impacts of both vehicle types, I can identify how they differ in terms of energy efficiency and greenhouse gas emissions throughout their usage life." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the entire life cycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase, to disposal and recycling. I would compare factors such as energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource depletion at each stage to provide a comprehensive view of their environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase comparison of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would specifically look at the emissions and energy consumption during the use of the vehicles. I would analyze the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles and compare them to the emissions associated with electricity production for EVs, considering different electricity grid mixes. This would highlight the direct environmental impacts during the vehicle's operational life." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the entire life cycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase, to disposal and recycling. I would compare factors such as energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource depletion at each stage to provide a comprehensive view of their environmental impacts." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis (LCA) that focuses specifically on the manufacturing phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts associated with the production processes, including the extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium for batteries, steel, and aluminum. It would also consider the energy and resources used in assembling the vehicles. By comparing the manufacturing impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles, I can provide insights into which type of vehicle has a greater environmental footprint during this critical phase.", + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis (LCA) focused on the use phase of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the environmental impacts related to the energy consumption and emissions produced while the vehicles are in operation. For EVs, this would include analyzing the electricity sources used for charging, while for gasoline vehicles, it would involve assessing the emissions from burning fuel. By comparing the operational impacts of both vehicle types, I can identify how they differ in terms of energy efficiency and greenhouse gas emissions throughout their usage life." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis (LCA) focused on the use phase of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the environmental impacts related to the energy consumption and emissions produced while the vehicles are in operation. For EVs, this would include analyzing the electricity sources used for charging, while for gasoline vehicles, it would involve assessing the emissions from burning fuel. By comparing the operational impacts of both vehicle types, I can identify how they differ in terms of energy efficiency and greenhouse gas emissions throughout their usage life." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:12:31.658637", + "similarity_score": 0.8, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 3 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "0a20bae1-3f62-4587-ba53-e17c1be5a870", + "ibfs_id": "49792305-a0fa-4f26-a672-2868236c8be8", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) are often touted as a cleaner alternative to traditional gasoline vehicles, but it's essential to consider the environmental impacts throughout their entire lifecycle to get a complete picture.\n\n**Manufacturing Impact:**\nThe production of EVs, particularly the batteries, typically results in higher emissions compared to manufacturing traditional gasoline vehicles. The extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel used in EV batteries are energy-intensive and can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and pollution. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling processes are continually improving this aspect.\n\n**Operation Emissions:**\nOnce on the road, EVs have a clear advantage. They produce zero tailpipe emissions, meaning no carbon dioxide or harmful pollutants like nitrogen oxides and particulate matter are emitted during operation. This contributes to improved air quality, especially in urban areas. In contrast, gasoline vehicles emit significant amounts of greenhouse gases and pollutants that contribute to climate change and respiratory diseases.\n\n**Energy Source:**\nA critical factor in determining the environmental impact of EVs is the source of the electricity used to charge them. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the overall carbon footprint of EVs is substantially lower. Conversely, if the electricity comes primarily from coal or other fossil fuels, the environmental benefits are reduced but still generally better than traditional vehicles due to the higher efficiency of electric motors.\n\n**End-of-Life and Recycling:**\nEVs offer potential benefits in terms of recyclability. While the recycling of EV batteries is still developing, it presents opportunities for recovering valuable materials and reducing the need for new raw material extraction. Innovations are underway to improve battery recycling processes, making them more efficient and environmentally friendly. Traditional vehicles also have recyclable components, but the energy-intensive nature of fossil fuel production and the emissions from tailpipes are ongoing environmental concerns.\n\n**Long-Term Benefits:**\nOver their lifespan, EVs typically result in lower overall emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener. Their potential to integrate with renewable energy systems and advancements in technology promise to further reduce their environmental impact.\n\n**Conclusion:**\nWhile both electric and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts, EVs generally have a lower carbon footprint over their entire lifecycle. Their benefits are most pronounced when supported by clean energy grids and robust recycling programs. As technology and infrastructure improve, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to increase, making them a crucial component in the transition to a more sustainable transportation system.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will conduct a lifecycle analysis (LCA) that examines each stage: raw material extraction, manufacturing, use, and disposal.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Materials:** EVs require lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals for their batteries. Mining these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy use. Cobalt mining, in particular, has raised concerns over environmental degradation and human rights issues.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use aluminum and copper, which require energy-intensive extraction and processing.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fossil Fuels:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Metals and Plastics:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and plastics, which also involve energy-intensive extraction and processing.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** The production of lithium-ion batteries is energy-intensive and contributes significantly to the carbon footprint of EVs. Manufacturing processes involve high energy use and emissions.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** EVs generally have fewer moving parts than gasoline vehicles, which can reduce some manufacturing impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Transmission:** The manufacturing of internal combustion engines and transmissions is complex and energy-intensive.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to EVs, the assembly of gasoline vehicles involves energy use and emissions, but the complexity of the engine and transmission adds to the environmental burden.\n\n### 3. Use Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy Consumption:** EVs are generally more efficient than gasoline vehicles. They produce zero tailpipe emissions, but the environmental impact depends on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the impact is significantly lower than if it comes from coal or natural gas.\n- **Maintenance:** EVs typically require less maintenance due to fewer moving parts, reducing the environmental impact over the vehicle's lifetime.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Consumption:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Maintenance:** Regular maintenance, including oil changes and engine repairs, contributes to environmental impacts through the production and disposal of parts and fluids.\n\n### 4. Disposal and Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Disposal/Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries are challenging. Improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination, but recycling can recover valuable materials. Efforts are underway to improve battery recycling technologies.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** EVs can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, but the battery remains a significant challenge.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **End-of-Life Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically recycled for their metal content. The recycling process is well-established, but it still involves energy use and emissions.\n- **Fluid Disposal:** Disposal of engine oil and other fluids can pose environmental risks if not managed properly.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, electric vehicles tend to have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases, primarily due to battery production. However, they offer significant advantages during the use phase, especially when powered by renewable energy, due to their higher efficiency and lack of tailpipe emissions. The end-of-life phase presents challenges for both types of vehicles, but advancements in battery recycling could improve the sustainability of EVs. In contrast, gasoline vehicles have a more consistent environmental impact across all phases, with significant emissions during the use phase.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles, examining every stage from production, use, to disposal. This would involve comparing the raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life disposal or recycling impacts for each type of vehicle." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles, examining every stage from production, use, to disposal. This would involve comparing the raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life disposal or recycling impacts for each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the operational phase, comparing the emissions and energy efficiency of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their use. This approach involves analyzing the greenhouse gas emissions and fuel efficiency when the vehicles are driven, considering factors like the energy source for electricity generation and the fuel type used in gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring the impact of the supply chain for each vehicle type, looking at the environmental effects of sourcing materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries compared to oil extraction and refining for gasoline vehicles. This strategy assesses the ecological and social impacts associated with the procurement of these critical resources.", + "I can answer by reviewing existing research and reports from credible organizations and studies that have analyzed the environmental impacts of both vehicle types. This would involve synthesizing findings from scientific papers, government publications, and industry analyses to provide a comprehensive overview of how electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles differ in their environmental footprints." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles, examining every stage from production, use, to disposal. This would involve comparing the raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life disposal or recycling impacts for each type of vehicle." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:12:59.137988", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 4 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "380c1f19-5969-45ca-abda-f31c4bf5c06c", + "ibfs_id": "0df81a50-a904-487a-b314-f6251c5d45bd", + "user_preferred_answer": "When considering the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, it's important to evaluate several aspects, including emissions, resource use, and lifecycle impacts.\n\n1. **Emissions Reduction**: \n - **Tailpipe Emissions**: Electric vehicles have a significant advantage over gasoline vehicles because they produce zero tailpipe emissions. This means they do not emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), or particulate matter while driving, which are major contributors to air pollution and climate change.\n - **Power Generation**: The overall environmental benefit of EVs depends on the energy mix used to generate electricity. In regions where electricity is primarily generated from renewable sources like wind, solar, and hydro, EVs have a much lower carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. However, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, the emissions benefits are reduced, though still generally better than gasoline vehicles.\n\n2. **Resource Use and Manufacturing**:\n - **Battery Production**: The production of EV batteries involves mining and processing materials such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which can have significant environmental impacts. This includes habitat destruction, water use, and pollution from mining activities. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling processes are helping to mitigate these impacts.\n - **Lifecycle Assessment**: When considering the entire lifecycle, from manufacturing to disposal, EVs generally have a lower environmental impact than gasoline vehicles. The energy-intensive battery production is offset over time by the cleaner operation of EVs, especially as the grid becomes greener.\n\n3. **End-of-Life and Recycling**:\n - **Battery Recycling**: Effective recycling of EV batteries can recover valuable materials and reduce the need for new resource extraction. This is an area of active research and development, with improvements expected to increase the sustainability of EVs.\n - **Vehicle Disposal**: Both EVs and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts at the end of their lifecycles, but the potential for recycling and reuse of EV components is increasing, which can mitigate these impacts.\n\n4. **Overall Environmental Impact**:\n - **Reduction in Greenhouse Gas Emissions**: Overall, EVs contribute to a significant reduction in greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, particularly as the energy grid shifts towards renewable sources.\n - **Improved Air Quality**: By reducing tailpipe emissions, EVs contribute to improved urban air quality, which has direct health benefits for populations.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles have some environmental challenges, particularly related to battery production and resource use, their overall impact is significantly lower than that of traditional gasoline vehicles. As technology and infrastructure continue to advance, the environmental benefits of EVs are expected to increase, making them a crucial component of sustainable transportation solutions.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, a lifecycle analysis (LCA) is conducted. This analysis considers the environmental effects from the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and disposal stages for both types of vehicles.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve mining for lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. This mining process can lead to significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Materials:** EVs also use aluminum and other lightweight materials to offset the weight of the battery, which involves additional mining and processing impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fossil Fuels:** The extraction of oil for gasoline involves drilling and refining, which can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and significant greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Metals and Plastics:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and plastics, similar to EVs, but generally in smaller quantities than the materials needed for EV batteries.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy-Intensive Battery Production:** The production of EV batteries is energy-intensive, often resulting in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Assembly:** The assembly of EVs is similar to gasoline vehicles but includes additional processes for battery integration.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine Production:** Manufacturing internal combustion engines is complex and energy-intensive, but generally less so than battery production.\n- **Assembly:** Similar to EVs, the assembly process involves significant energy use but is well-optimized over decades of production.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, reducing urban air pollution and greenhouse gases during operation.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during usage largely depends on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources significantly reduce the carbon footprint, while coal-based electricity can offset some of the benefits.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, particulate matter, and other pollutants, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Advances in fuel efficiency have reduced emissions per mile, but they still remain higher than those of EVs powered by clean electricity.\n\n### 4. Disposal and Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal of EV batteries poses challenges due to hazardous materials. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable metals.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, the rest of the EV can be recycled, though the processes are still being optimized for EV-specific components.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **End-of-Life Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles have established recycling processes for metals and other materials, but the disposal of fluids and certain plastics remains a challenge.\n- **Environmental Impact:** The disposal phase has a smaller relative impact compared to the usage phase, but still contributes to the overall environmental footprint.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles generally have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases due to battery production. However, they offer significant environmental benefits during the usage phase, especially when powered by renewable energy. Gasoline vehicles, while having lower initial production impacts, contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational life. The disposal and recycling phase presents challenges for both types of vehicles, but advancements in technology and recycling processes continue to improve the sustainability of both. Overall, the lifecycle analysis suggests that EVs have the potential for a lower overall environmental impact, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery technologies advance.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would encompass the environmental impacts from raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal stages. By examining each phase, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their respective carbon footprints and resource utilizations." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would encompass the environmental impacts from raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal stages. By examining each phase, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their respective carbon footprints and resource utilizations.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the operation of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing tailpipe emissions, electricity generation sources for EVs, and the resultant greenhouse gas outputs. This approach highlights the direct and indirect emissions associated with both vehicle types during their use phase.", + "I can answer by evaluating the resource extraction and supply chain impacts for electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would explore the environmental consequences of mining for battery materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EVs, as well as oil extraction and refining for gasoline vehicles. It would provide insight into how resource demands affect ecosystems and communities.", + "I can answer by assessing the policy and infrastructure implications on environmental impacts. This would involve examining how government policies, incentives, and charging infrastructure developments influence the adoption of electric vehicles and their environmental benefits. This approach considers how regulatory frameworks can mitigate or exacerbate environmental impacts through strategic planning and investment." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would encompass the environmental impacts from raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal stages. By examining each phase, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their respective carbon footprints and resource utilizations." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:13:05.418370", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 5 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "a871da43-2d15-478c-87fe-d769ca9bb1eb", + "ibfs_id": "80d22b70-3d63-42dd-95be-4450cb6938fd", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) are often touted as a sustainable alternative to traditional gasoline vehicles, and understanding their environmental impacts is crucial in evaluating this claim. Here's a comprehensive comparison of the two:\n\n1. **Emissions During Operation:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which means they do not emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, or particulate matter during operation. This can lead to significant improvements in air quality, especially in urban areas with high traffic congestion.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Traditional vehicles burn fossil fuels and emit a considerable amount of greenhouse gases (GHGs) like CO2, as well as other pollutants that contribute to air pollution and health problems.\n\n2. **Lifecycle Emissions:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The production of EVs can result in higher initial emissions, primarily due to battery manufacturing, which involves energy-intensive processes and the extraction of metals like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. However, over their lifespan, EVs typically have lower overall emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, especially when charged with renewable energy sources.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** While gasoline vehicles may have lower manufacturing emissions, their lifetime emissions are significantly higher due to the continuous burning of fossil fuels.\n\n3. **Energy Source and Efficiency:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. The efficiency of an EV can be influenced by the electricity mix used for charging. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources, the environmental benefits of EVs are maximized.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles are less efficient, as a significant portion of the energy in gasoline is lost as heat. Additionally, the extraction, refining, and transportation of oil further add to their environmental impact.\n\n4. **Resource Extraction:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The need for battery materials involves mining activities that can lead to habitat destruction, water pollution, and other environmental concerns. However, advancements in battery recycling and sustainable mining practices are being developed to mitigate these impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** The oil industry\u2019s extraction and production processes can result in significant environmental degradation, including oil spills, habitat destruction, and water pollution.\n\n5. **End-of-Life and Recycling:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** Battery disposal and recycling are critical challenges. However, the development of effective recycling techniques is underway, which can help recover valuable materials and reduce environmental harm.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Traditional vehicles are easier to recycle, but the environmental damage from oil and fuel leaks during their lifespan can be significant.\n\n6. **Impact on Ecosystems:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** While the transition to EVs can reduce air and noise pollution, the extraction of raw materials for batteries can impact ecosystems if not managed sustainably.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Their emissions contribute to air pollution, acid rain, and climate change, which can have widespread effects on ecosystems.\n\nIn summary, while electric vehicles have some environmental challenges, particularly related to battery production and resource extraction, their overall impact is generally less harmful than that of traditional gasoline vehicles, especially when considering the long-term benefits of reduced operational emissions and the potential for greener electricity sources. As technology advances and the energy grid becomes cleaner, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to grow.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, a cradle-to-grave life cycle assessment (LCA) provides a comprehensive analysis. This approach considers all phases of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction to end-of-life disposal or recycling.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Materials**: EVs require lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other rare earth metals for their batteries. The extraction of these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components**: EVs also use aluminum and copper, which require energy-intensive mining processes.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Fossil Fuels**: The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling and refining, which can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Metals**: Gasoline vehicles also require steel and aluminum, but generally in smaller quantities than the metals needed for EV batteries.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Processes\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Production**: Manufacturing EV batteries is energy-intensive and contributes significantly to the vehicle's initial carbon footprint. However, advancements in battery technology and production efficiency are reducing these impacts.\n- **Vehicle Assembly**: Similar to gasoline vehicles, but with additional processes for integrating electric drivetrains and battery systems.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Engine Production**: Manufacturing internal combustion engines involves complex processes that also consume energy and resources.\n- **Vehicle Assembly**: Generally less complex than EVs due to the absence of large battery systems.\n\n### 3. Transportation Logistics\n\nBoth EVs and gasoline vehicles require transportation from manufacturing sites to dealerships. This phase contributes to emissions through the use of ships, trains, and trucks. The impact is relatively similar for both vehicle types, although the heavier weight of EVs due to batteries can slightly increase transportation emissions.\n\n### 4. Operational Lifespan\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Energy Source**: The environmental impact during the use phase largely depends on the electricity mix. In regions with renewable energy, EVs have significantly lower emissions. However, in areas reliant on coal, the benefits are reduced.\n- **Efficiency**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting more energy from the grid into miles driven.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Fuel Combustion**: Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency**: Improvements in fuel efficiency have reduced emissions over time, but they still lag behind the potential emissions reductions from EVs.\n\n### 5. End-of-Life Recycling or Disposal\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Recycling**: The recycling of EV batteries is crucial to reduce environmental impacts. Current technologies allow for the recovery of some materials, but the process is still developing.\n- **Vehicle Recycling**: Similar to gasoline vehicles, with additional challenges related to battery disposal.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Recycling**: Established processes exist for recycling metals and other materials from gasoline vehicles. However, the disposal of engine fluids and other hazardous materials remains a concern.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, electric vehicles tend to have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases, primarily due to battery production. However, they generally offer significant environmental benefits during the operational phase, especially when powered by renewable energy sources. The end-of-life phase presents challenges for both vehicle types, but advancements in recycling technologies are helping to mitigate these impacts. While both vehicle types have environmental impacts, the potential for EVs to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution during their use phase makes them a more sustainable option in the long term, particularly as the energy grid becomes greener.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts from the production phase, the operational phase, and the disposal/recycling phase of each type of vehicle to provide a comprehensive comparison.", + "I can answer by focusing on a cradle-to-grave life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles, which includes detailed analysis of raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, transportation logistics, the full operational lifespan with real-world driving data, and end-of-life recycling or disposal processes. This comprehensive approach ensures all phases of the vehicle's life are examined for environmental impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts from the production phase, the operational phase, and the disposal/recycling phase of each type of vehicle to provide a comprehensive comparison.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions during the use phase of the vehicles. This approach would compare the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles with the emissions related to electricity generation for EVs, considering factors like the energy mix of the grid and advancements in battery technology.", + "I can answer by analyzing the resource extraction and material sourcing for both types of vehicles. This would involve looking into the mining and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries, as well as the extraction and refining of oil for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring the infrastructure and energy supply chains required for each vehicle type. This approach would examine the environmental impacts of building and maintaining charging stations and electricity grids for EVs, compared to the impacts associated with refining and distributing gasoline." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts from the production phase, the operational phase, and the disposal/recycling phase of each type of vehicle to provide a comprehensive comparison." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a cradle-to-grave life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles, which includes detailed analysis of raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, transportation logistics, the full operational lifespan with real-world driving data, and end-of-life recycling or disposal processes. This comprehensive approach ensures all phases of the vehicle's life are examined for environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative LCA that emphasizes regional variations in electricity generation for EVs, such as coal-based vs. renewable energy grids, and how these sources affect the overall environmental footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. By tailoring the assessment to specific geographic areas, we can better understand the localized environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by performing a time-based LCA, where I evaluate the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles over different time horizons. This would involve assessing short-term impacts, such as initial manufacturing emissions, and long-term impacts, like battery degradation and fuel efficiency changes, to provide a dynamic view of their environmental implications over time.", + "I can answer by integrating a social and economic dimension into the LCA, where I assess not only the environmental impacts but also the societal benefits or drawbacks, such as job creation in manufacturing sectors and potential health benefits from reduced emissions. This holistic approach can offer a broader perspective on the trade-offs between electric and gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on a cradle-to-grave life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles, which includes detailed analysis of raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, transportation logistics, the full operational lifespan with real-world driving data, and end-of-life recycling or disposal processes. This comprehensive approach ensures all phases of the vehicle's life are examined for environmental impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:13:35.903125", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 6 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "8fdbe0d1-ab98-4d89-a2dc-3f2a20a01566", + "ibfs_id": "69b76df7-b531-43b8-ae1a-0a9a5054ae7f", + "user_preferred_answer": "When comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) to traditional gasoline vehicles, several key factors need to be considered, including emissions during operation, the production process, and end-of-life disposal.\n\n1. **Operational Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces local air pollution, particularly in urban areas. This is a major advantage over gasoline vehicles, which emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles rely on internal combustion engines that burn fossil fuels, directly emitting CO2 and other pollutants. This contributes to global warming and has adverse health effects on humans due to air quality degradation.\n\n2. **Lifecycle Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: While EVs have higher emissions during the manufacturing phase, primarily due to battery production, they generally have a smaller carbon footprint over their lifetime. This is because electricity generation, even when accounting for fossil fuels, tends to be cleaner than burning gasoline. As the energy grid becomes greener, the lifecycle emissions of EVs are expected to decrease further.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: They typically have lower emissions during manufacturing compared to EVs but higher lifetime emissions due to fuel combustion. The continuous use of gasoline results in higher cumulative emissions, making them less environmentally friendly over the vehicle's lifespan.\n\n3. **Energy Source**:\n - The environmental benefit of EVs heavily depends on the energy mix used for electricity generation. In regions where renewable energy sources (such as wind, solar, or hydropower) are prevalent, the environmental benefits of EVs are maximized. However, in areas reliant on coal or other fossil fuels, the advantage diminishes but still generally remains better than gasoline vehicles.\n\n4. **Resource Extraction and Battery Production**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The production of lithium-ion batteries requires mining of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which can have significant environmental and social impacts. Sustainable sourcing and advancements in battery technology are critical to reducing these impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The extraction and refining of oil for gasoline also have substantial environmental effects, including habitat destruction, water contamination, and oil spills, which are detrimental to ecosystems.\n\n5. **End-of-Life Management**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EV batteries present a unique challenge due to their size and chemical complexity. However, advancements in battery recycling and second-life applications (such as energy storage) are improving the sustainability of EVs.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles can be more straightforward to recycle, but the continuous need for fossil fuels remains an ongoing environmental concern.\n\nIn conclusion, while both vehicle types have environmental impacts, electric vehicles offer significant advantages in reducing emissions and improving air quality, especially as electricity grids become cleaner. Efforts to enhance battery technology, recycling, and sustainable mining practices are crucial to maximizing the environmental benefits of EVs.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles using a time-based life cycle assessment (LCA), we need to consider several stages of the vehicle lifecycle: production, use, and end-of-life, while also accounting for projected technological advancements and changes in energy sources over time.\n\n### 1. Production Phase\n\n- **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Current Impact:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery manufacturing, is more energy-intensive than that of gasoline vehicles. This is primarily due to the extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel.\n - **Future Projections:** Over time, advancements in battery technology, such as solid-state batteries, and improvements in manufacturing processes are expected to reduce the energy intensity and environmental impact of battery production. Additionally, increased recycling of battery materials will further mitigate these impacts.\n\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Current Impact:** The production of gasoline vehicles is less energy-intensive compared to EVs, mainly due to the absence of large battery packs.\n - **Future Projections:** While improvements in manufacturing efficiency are expected, the fundamental materials and processes involved in gasoline vehicle production are not projected to change significantly.\n\n### 2. Use Phase\n\n- **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Current Impact:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, leading to significant reductions in local air pollutants compared to gasoline vehicles. However, the environmental impact during the use phase is influenced by the electricity grid's energy mix.\n - **Future Projections:** As the grid becomes increasingly decarbonized with more renewable energy sources like wind and solar, the carbon footprint of operating EVs will decrease substantially. This shift is expected to make EVs significantly cleaner over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Current Impact:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other pollutants during operation. The environmental impact is directly related to fuel efficiency and the carbon content of the fuel.\n - **Future Projections:** While improvements in fuel efficiency and the development of cleaner fuels can reduce emissions, gasoline vehicles will continue to produce direct emissions as long as they rely on internal combustion engines.\n\n### 3. End-of-Life Phase\n\n- **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Current Impact:** The recycling of EV batteries is still developing, but it is crucial for minimizing environmental impacts. Current processes are energy-intensive and not yet widely implemented.\n - **Future Projections:** Advances in battery recycling technologies and increased infrastructure for recycling are expected to reduce the environmental impacts associated with the disposal of EV batteries. This will also help recover valuable materials, reducing the need for new raw material extraction.\n\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Current Impact:** The end-of-life phase for gasoline vehicles is relatively well-established, with many components being recyclable.\n - **Future Projections:** While recycling processes may become more efficient, the overall impact is not expected to change dramatically, as the materials and components involved remain largely the same.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOver time, the environmental impacts of electric vehicles are projected to decrease significantly due to advancements in battery technology, increased reliance on renewable energy sources, and improved recycling processes. In contrast, while gasoline vehicles may see some improvements in efficiency and emissions, their fundamental reliance on fossil fuels limits their potential for significant environmental impact reduction. Therefore, from a long-term perspective, EVs are expected to offer substantial environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include evaluating aspects such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation emissions, and end-of-life recycling or disposal, providing a comprehensive overview of their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by performing a time-based life cycle assessment (LCA), which assesses how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles evolve over time. This approach examines the projected changes in technology, energy sources, and recycling processes over the lifespan of the vehicles, offering a dynamic perspective on their long-term environmental impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include evaluating aspects such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation emissions, and end-of-life recycling or disposal, providing a comprehensive overview of their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase only, comparing the emissions and energy efficiency of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles when in use. This would involve analyzing data on greenhouse gas emissions, air pollutants, and the energy sources used for electricity generation, providing insight into their impacts during the vehicle's lifetime.", + "I can answer by exploring the supply chain and resource availability impacts, particularly the mining and processing of key materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for electric vehicle batteries versus the extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline. This approach would highlight the environmental and social impacts associated with obtaining essential resources for each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by examining policy and infrastructure factors that influence the environmental impacts of both vehicle types, such as government incentives for electric vehicles, availability and development of charging stations, and the impact of electricity grid composition on overall emissions. This would provide a perspective on how external factors can alter the environmental outcomes of electric versus gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include evaluating aspects such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation emissions, and end-of-life recycling or disposal, providing a comprehensive overview of their environmental footprints." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a hotspot analysis within the life cycle assessment (LCA), which focuses on identifying the most significant environmental impacts in the life cycle stages of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach zeroes in on critical points such as battery production for electric vehicles and fuel extraction for gasoline vehicles, providing insights into which aspects contribute most to their overall environmental impact.", + "I can answer by implementing a sensitivity analysis as part of the life cycle assessment (LCA), which involves varying key assumptions and parameters such as electricity grid composition and fuel efficiency. This approach evaluates how changes in these factors can influence the comparative environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles, helping to understand the robustness of the LCA outcomes.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison, which examines how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles differ across various geographic locations. This approach considers regional differences in electricity generation sources, manufacturing practices, and waste management infrastructures, providing tailored insights into their environmental footprints in different contexts.", + "I can answer by performing a time-based life cycle assessment (LCA), which assesses how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles evolve over time. This approach examines the projected changes in technology, energy sources, and recycling processes over the lifespan of the vehicles, offering a dynamic perspective on their long-term environmental impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 3, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by performing a time-based life cycle assessment (LCA), which assesses how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles evolve over time. This approach examines the projected changes in technology, energy sources, and recycling processes over the lifespan of the vehicles, offering a dynamic perspective on their long-term environmental impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:13:45.547891", + "similarity_score": 0.8, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 7 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "f5ca8dd3-6754-4582-8da6-89aaa03a680e", + "ibfs_id": "e730baa9-8a4c-47be-a7c9-6cf1904c89e8", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles each have distinct environmental impacts that are important to consider when evaluating their overall sustainability.\n\n**1. Greenhouse Gas Emissions:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which is a significant advantage in reducing local air pollution and greenhouse gases in urban areas. However, the overall environmental impact of EVs depends on the source of the electricity used to charge them. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the greenhouse gas emissions of EVs are significantly lower compared to gasoline vehicles. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal-fired power plants, the emissions can be higher, although still generally less than those from gasoline vehicles.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2) and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe. The emissions are a direct result of burning fossil fuels, contributing significantly to global warming and air quality issues.\n\n**2. Energy Efficiency:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** EVs are typically more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. They convert over 77% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, whereas gasoline vehicles only convert about 12%\u201330% of the energy stored in gasoline to power at the wheels.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles lose a significant amount of energy through engine heat and exhaust, making them less efficient compared to EVs.\n\n**3. Resource Extraction and Manufacturing:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** The production of EVs, particularly their batteries, requires significant amounts of raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel. Mining and processing these materials can have substantial environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and pollution. Advancements in battery recycling and sustainable mining practices are crucial for minimizing these impacts.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The environmental impact of traditional vehicles largely stems from oil extraction, refining, and transportation. These processes can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and pollution.\n\n**4. End-of-Life and Recycling:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** The disposal of EV batteries poses environmental challenges. However, advancements in recycling technologies are being developed to mitigate these issues by recovering valuable materials and reducing landfill waste.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** While traditional vehicles don\u2019t have the same battery disposal issue, they do require the disposal of various fluids and components that can be environmentally harmful if not properly managed.\n\n**5. Long-Term Sustainability:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** As the grid becomes greener and battery technologies improve, the environmental benefits of EVs are expected to increase. The shift towards renewable energy sources further enhances the long-term sustainability of EVs.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The reliance on fossil fuels is a major limitation for traditional vehicles, as it is unsustainable in the long term due to finite resources and the need to reduce carbon emissions to combat climate change.\n\nIn conclusion, while both electric and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts, EVs generally offer a more sustainable option, particularly as the energy grid becomes cleaner and battery technologies advance. The transition to renewable energy and improvements in battery recycling will further enhance the environmental benefits of electric vehicles over time.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine the emissions and environmental degradation associated with the energy sources used to power each type of vehicle. This involves looking at the electricity generation process for EVs and the gasoline production and combustion process for traditional vehicles.\n\n### Electric Vehicles (EVs)\n\n1. **Electricity Generation:**\n - The environmental impact of EVs largely depends on the energy mix used to generate electricity. In regions where electricity is primarily generated from renewable sources such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the emissions associated with EVs are significantly lower.\n - In contrast, if the electricity comes from fossil fuels like coal or natural gas, the emissions can be higher. Coal-fired power plants, in particular, produce substantial greenhouse gas emissions and other pollutants.\n - The regional variation in energy sources is crucial. For example, in countries like Norway, where a large portion of electricity comes from hydropower, EVs have a much lower carbon footprint compared to regions heavily reliant on coal.\n\n2. **Lifecycle Emissions:**\n - While EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, the production of their batteries can be resource-intensive, involving mining and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. This can lead to environmental degradation if not managed sustainably.\n - However, over the lifespan of the vehicle, the reduced operational emissions often offset the initial environmental costs of battery production, especially as battery recycling and production processes improve.\n\n### Traditional Gasoline Vehicles\n\n1. **Gasoline Production:**\n - The extraction, refining, and transportation of crude oil to produce gasoline are energy-intensive processes that contribute to greenhouse gas emissions and environmental degradation. Oil drilling can lead to habitat destruction, oil spills, and water contamination.\n - Refining crude oil into gasoline involves significant energy use and emissions of pollutants such as sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides.\n\n2. **Combustion Emissions:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), a major greenhouse gas, directly from the tailpipe during combustion. They also produce other pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which contribute to air pollution and health issues.\n - Unlike EVs, the emissions from gasoline vehicles are consistent regardless of the region, as they are directly tied to the combustion of gasoline.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe environmental impact of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles is heavily influenced by the source of the electricity used to charge them. In regions with a clean energy grid, EVs offer significant environmental benefits over gasoline vehicles due to lower lifecycle emissions. However, in areas dependent on fossil fuels for electricity, the benefits may be reduced, though EVs still avoid the direct tailpipe emissions associated with gasoline vehicles. As the global energy mix shifts towards more renewable sources, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to increase.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impacts associated with the energy sources used to power each type of vehicle. This approach would compare the emissions and environmental degradation linked to the electricity generation process for EVs against those associated with gasoline production and combustion, considering factors such as the energy mix (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and regional variations in energy sources." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive lifecycle analysis of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, including raw material extraction, manufacturing, use, and end-of-life disposal or recycling, to provide a detailed comparison of their overall ecological footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impacts associated with the energy sources used to power each type of vehicle. This approach would compare the emissions and environmental degradation linked to the electricity generation process for EVs against those associated with gasoline production and combustion, considering factors such as the energy mix (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and regional variations in energy sources." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impacts associated with the energy sources used to power each type of vehicle. This approach would compare the emissions and environmental degradation linked to the electricity generation process for EVs against those associated with gasoline production and combustion, considering factors such as the energy mix (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and regional variations in energy sources." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:14:03.424808", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 8 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "b94d3f42-145c-4f98-b6eb-3cc3df41aa8e", + "ibfs_id": "d808e45e-5574-40e9-9f79-45dee86d1ff7", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles each have distinct environmental impacts, and understanding these differences is crucial for evaluating their roles in sustainable transportation.\n\n**1. Emissions:**\n\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas, leading to improvements in public health and local air quality. Gasoline vehicles, on the other hand, emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter, and other pollutants that contribute to smog and respiratory problems.\n\n- **Lifecycle Emissions:** While EVs have higher emissions during production, primarily due to battery manufacturing, they tend to have lower overall lifecycle emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. This is because they compensate for these initial emissions through cleaner operation over time, especially if powered by renewable energy sources. As the grid becomes greener, the lifecycle emissions of EVs continue to decrease.\n\n**2. Energy Source:**\n\n- **Electricity vs. Fossil Fuels:** EVs are as clean as the electricity that powers them. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydro, EVs have a significantly lower carbon footprint. Conversely, gasoline vehicles rely on fossil fuels, which are major contributors to greenhouse gas emissions and climate change.\n\n- **Energy Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 77% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, whereas gasoline vehicles convert only about 12%\u201330% of the energy stored in gasoline.\n\n**3. Resource Extraction and Production:**\n\n- **Battery Production:** The production of EV batteries involves mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which can have significant environmental and social impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and human rights concerns. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling are helping mitigate these issues over time.\n\n- **Oil Extraction and Refining:** Gasoline production involves oil extraction, which can lead to oil spills and environmental degradation. The refining process also emits pollutants and requires substantial energy, often sourced from fossil fuels.\n\n**4. End-of-Life Considerations:**\n\n- **Recycling and Disposal:** EVs, especially their batteries, present challenges and opportunities in terms of recycling and disposal. Efforts are underway to improve recycling technologies to reclaim valuable materials and reduce environmental impact. Gasoline vehicles, consisting of metal and other materials, are also recyclable, but the disposal of used oil and other fluids can pose environmental risks.\n\n**5. Infrastructure and Land Use:**\n\n- **Charging Infrastructure:** Expanding EV infrastructure requires investment and land use considerations, but it can lead to a cleaner, more sustainable transportation system over time. Gasoline infrastructure is well-established but contributes to ongoing environmental issues related to fuel transport and storage.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs are not without environmental challenges, especially concerning battery production and resource extraction, they offer significant long-term benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles. These benefits include reduced emissions, improved air quality, and better alignment with renewable energy pathways. As technology and infrastructure continue to evolve, the environmental advantages of EVs are likely to increase, making them a crucial component of a sustainable transportation future.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will examine specific environmental impact categories: air pollution, resource depletion, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n### Air Pollution\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Gasoline vehicles emit pollutants directly from their tailpipes, including nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO), particulate matter (PM), and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). These emissions contribute to smog, respiratory problems, and other health issues.\n- The combustion of gasoline also releases carbon dioxide (CO2), a greenhouse gas, although this is more relevant to the greenhouse gas emissions category.\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- EVs have no tailpipe emissions, which means they do not directly emit NOx, CO, PM, or VOCs during operation.\n- However, the electricity used to charge EVs can lead to air pollution, depending on the energy mix of the grid. If the electricity is generated from fossil fuels like coal or natural gas, there are emissions associated with power generation, including NOx, SO2, and PM.\n- The extent of air pollution from EVs depends on the cleanliness of the electricity grid. In regions with a high percentage of renewable energy, the air pollution impact is significantly lower.\n\n### Resource Depletion\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Resource depletion for gasoline vehicles primarily involves the extraction and refining of crude oil. This process requires significant energy and water resources and can lead to environmental degradation, such as oil spills and habitat destruction.\n- The infrastructure for oil extraction and refining is extensive and has long-term environmental impacts.\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- EVs rely on batteries, typically lithium-ion, which require raw materials like lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. The extraction and processing of these materials can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy use.\n- Mining for these materials can also have social and ethical implications, particularly in regions with poor labor practices.\n- The recycling and disposal of batteries pose additional challenges, although advancements in battery recycling technology are ongoing.\n\n### Greenhouse Gas Emissions\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The production of gasoline vehicles involves emissions from manufacturing processes, but the most significant emissions occur during the operational phase due to the combustion of gasoline.\n- On average, gasoline vehicles emit about 2.3 kg of CO2 per liter of gasoline burned, contributing significantly to climate change over their lifetime.\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher initial greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- However, during the operational phase, EVs typically have lower emissions, especially if charged with low-carbon electricity. Over time, the total lifecycle emissions of EVs can be lower than those of gasoline vehicles, depending on the energy mix used for electricity generation.\n- As the electricity grid becomes greener, the greenhouse gas emissions associated with EVs will continue to decrease.\n\nIn summary, while electric vehicles offer significant advantages in terms of reducing tailpipe emissions and potentially lowering greenhouse gas emissions over their lifetime, they also present challenges related to resource depletion and initial production emissions. The overall environmental impact of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles depends heavily on the energy sources used for electricity generation and advancements in battery technology and recycling.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by examining specific environmental impact categories separately, such as air pollution, resource depletion, and greenhouse gas emissions. For air pollution, I would compare emissions from the tailpipe of gasoline vehicles with the emissions from electricity generation for EVs. For resource depletion, I would focus on the extraction and processing of raw materials needed for battery production in EVs, compared to oil extraction and refining for gasoline. Additionally, I would analyze the greenhouse gas emissions from both the production and operational phases of each vehicle type, providing a detailed comparison of their contributions to climate change." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal or recycling. By comparing the energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource use across these stages, I can provide a comprehensive analysis of the overall environmental footprint of both types of vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining specific environmental impact categories separately, such as air pollution, resource depletion, and greenhouse gas emissions. For air pollution, I would compare emissions from the tailpipe of gasoline vehicles with the emissions from electricity generation for EVs. For resource depletion, I would focus on the extraction and processing of raw materials needed for battery production in EVs, compared to oil extraction and refining for gasoline. Additionally, I would analyze the greenhouse gas emissions from both the production and operational phases of each vehicle type, providing a detailed comparison of their contributions to climate change." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by examining specific environmental impact categories separately, such as air pollution, resource depletion, and greenhouse gas emissions. For air pollution, I would compare emissions from the tailpipe of gasoline vehicles with the emissions from electricity generation for EVs. For resource depletion, I would focus on the extraction and processing of raw materials needed for battery production in EVs, compared to oil extraction and refining for gasoline. Additionally, I would analyze the greenhouse gas emissions from both the production and operational phases of each vehicle type, providing a detailed comparison of their contributions to climate change." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:14:13.689224", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 9 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "5a032899-3a4f-47eb-9a31-ae205f4d31d3", + "ibfs_id": "e1cc7551-6647-43fd-b175-21afe42c589a", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles have distinct environmental impacts across their life cycles, from manufacturing to operation and eventual disposal. Here's a detailed comparison:\n\n1. **Manufacturing Impact**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The production of EVs, particularly the battery manufacturing process, tends to have a significant environmental footprint. Mining and processing the raw materials needed for lithium-ion batteries, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, can result in habitat destruction, water pollution, and carbon emissions. However, advancements in battery recycling and the development of more sustainable mining practices are ongoing to mitigate these effects.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Traditional vehicles also have environmental costs during manufacturing, mainly due to steel and aluminum production. However, they generally require fewer rare metals compared to EVs. The overall carbon footprint during manufacturing is usually lower than that of EVs, but the difference diminishes over the vehicle's lifetime.\n\n2. **Operational Impact**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs are far cleaner during operation, producing zero tailpipe emissions. This significantly reduces urban air pollution, which is linked to health issues such as respiratory and cardiovascular diseases. The overall environmental benefit of EVs largely depends on the electricity source used for charging. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind or solar, the carbon footprint is dramatically reduced compared to fossil fuels.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants during operation, contributing substantially to air pollution and climate change. The combustion of gasoline leads to significant greenhouse gas emissions, which are a major driver of global warming.\n\n3. **Energy Efficiency**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. Internal combustion engines lose a lot of energy as heat, while electric motors convert a higher percentage of electrical energy from the grid to power the wheels.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Less efficient in converting stored energy into movement, leading to higher fuel consumption and emissions per mile traveled.\n\n4. **Lifecycle Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: Over their entire lifecycle, EVs typically have lower greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, even when accounting for battery production. As the electricity grid becomes greener, the lifecycle emissions of EVs will continue to decline.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The lifecycle emissions remain high due to continued reliance on fossil fuels during operation.\n\n5. **Waste and Recycling**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose environmental challenges. However, the industry is making strides in battery recycling technologies, which can recover valuable materials and reduce waste.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: While traditional vehicles are also recycled, they do not face the same challenges associated with battery disposal.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles are not without their environmental impacts, particularly in manufacturing, they offer significant advantages over gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of reducing operational emissions and improving urban air quality. As the renewable energy sector grows and battery technologies advance, the environmental benefits of EVs are expected to increase further, making them a more sustainable choice for the future.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a regional lifecycle analysis comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to consider several factors that vary by geographic area. These include the energy grid mix, climate conditions, and regional policies, all of which significantly influence the environmental performance of each vehicle type. Below, I will provide a comparison for three distinct regions: California (USA), Germany, and China, highlighting how these factors affect the lifecycle emissions and overall environmental impact of EVs versus gasoline vehicles.\n\n### California, USA\n\n**Energy Grid Mix:**\n- California's energy grid is relatively clean, with a significant portion of electricity coming from renewable sources such as solar, wind, and hydroelectric power. In 2022, about 33% of California's electricity was generated from renewable sources, with natural gas also playing a role.\n\n**Climate Conditions:**\n- The mild climate in California reduces the energy needed for heating and cooling, which can affect the energy efficiency of both EVs and gasoline vehicles.\n\n**Regional Policies:**\n- California has stringent emissions regulations and incentives for EV adoption, including rebates and access to carpool lanes.\n\n**Lifecycle Analysis:**\n- **EVs:** In California, the cleaner energy grid means that the lifecycle emissions of EVs are significantly lower than in regions with a coal-heavy grid. The production phase of EVs, particularly battery manufacturing, still has a high environmental impact, but this is offset by the low emissions during the use phase.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles produce higher emissions during the use phase due to the combustion of fossil fuels. California's strict emissions standards help reduce the impact somewhat, but gasoline vehicles still have a higher overall lifecycle emissions profile compared to EVs in this region.\n\n### Germany\n\n**Energy Grid Mix:**\n- Germany's energy grid is in transition, with a mix of renewable energy (wind and solar), coal, and natural gas. In 2022, approximately 42% of the electricity came from renewables, but coal still plays a significant role.\n\n**Climate Conditions:**\n- Germany experiences a temperate climate, which can influence vehicle efficiency, especially in winter months when heating is required.\n\n**Regional Policies:**\n- Germany has strong policies promoting EVs, including subsidies and a robust charging infrastructure.\n\n**Lifecycle Analysis:**\n- **EVs:** The environmental impact of EVs in Germany is moderate due to the mixed energy grid. While the use phase emissions are lower than gasoline vehicles, the reliance on coal for electricity generation increases the lifecycle emissions compared to regions with cleaner grids.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles have higher emissions during the use phase. Germany's policies aim to reduce reliance on gasoline vehicles, but their lifecycle emissions remain higher than those of EVs, especially as the grid continues to decarbonize.\n\n### China\n\n**Energy Grid Mix:**\n- China's energy grid is heavily reliant on coal, although there is a growing share of renewables. As of 2022, coal accounted for about 57% of electricity generation, with renewables making up around 28%.\n\n**Climate Conditions:**\n- China has diverse climate conditions, from cold northern regions to tropical southern areas, affecting vehicle efficiency and energy use.\n\n**Regional Policies:**\n- China is aggressively promoting EV adoption through subsidies, mandates, and investments in charging infrastructure.\n\n**Lifecycle Analysis:**\n- **EVs:** In China, the high reliance on coal for electricity generation means that the lifecycle emissions of EVs are higher than in regions with cleaner grids. However, the rapid expansion of renewable energy is expected to improve this over time.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles have high emissions during the use phase, and given the size of the market, their overall environmental impact is substantial. EVs still offer a reduction in urban air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, despite the coal-heavy grid.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe environmental impacts of EVs compared to traditional gasoline vehicles vary significantly by region due to differences in energy grid composition, climate conditions, and regional policies. In regions like California with a cleaner energy grid, EVs offer substantial environmental benefits over gasoline vehicles. In contrast, in regions like China with a coal-heavy grid, the benefits are less pronounced but still present, especially as the grid becomes cleaner. Germany represents a transitional case where the benefits of EVs are growing as the energy grid shifts towards renewables. Overall, regional lifecycle analysis highlights the importance of local context in assessing the environmental impacts of vehicle types.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that compares the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining each stage of a vehicle's lifecycle, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal. I would gather data on emissions, energy consumption, and resource use for both types of vehicles, and then provide a comprehensive comparison to highlight the differences in their overall environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle analysis that focuses on the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles within specific geographic areas. This approach would examine how factors like the local energy grid mix, climate conditions, and regional policies influence the environmental performance of each vehicle type. By analyzing data on emissions, energy consumption, and resource use specific to various regions, I can provide a nuanced comparison that highlights how the environmental impacts of these vehicles vary depending on the geographic context." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that compares the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining each stage of a vehicle's lifecycle, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal. I would gather data on emissions, energy consumption, and resource use for both types of vehicles, and then provide a comprehensive comparison to highlight the differences in their overall environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by summarizing existing scientific research and reports on the topic, focusing on key areas such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource depletion. I would look at studies conducted by environmental organizations, universities, and governmental agencies that have directly compared the impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles. This approach would allow me to present a synthesis of expert opinions and findings, providing a balanced view of the environmental pros and cons associated with each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that compares the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining each stage of a vehicle's lifecycle, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal. I would gather data on emissions, energy consumption, and resource use for both types of vehicles, and then provide a comprehensive comparison to highlight the differences in their overall environmental footprints." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle analysis that focuses on the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles within specific geographic areas. This approach would examine how factors like the local energy grid mix, climate conditions, and regional policies influence the environmental performance of each vehicle type. By analyzing data on emissions, energy consumption, and resource use specific to various regions, I can provide a nuanced comparison that highlights how the environmental impacts of these vehicles vary depending on the geographic context.", + "I can answer by conducting a temporal lifecycle analysis that looks at how the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles evolve over time. This approach would involve examining changes in technology, energy sources, and regulatory landscapes that affect each stage of a vehicle's lifecycle, from manufacturing to disposal. By gathering data on historical and projected trends in emissions, energy consumption, and resource use, I can provide a dynamic comparison that illustrates how the environmental footprints of these vehicles might change in the future." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle analysis that focuses on the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles within specific geographic areas. This approach would examine how factors like the local energy grid mix, climate conditions, and regional policies influence the environmental performance of each vehicle type. By analyzing data on emissions, energy consumption, and resource use specific to various regions, I can provide a nuanced comparison that highlights how the environmental impacts of these vehicles vary depending on the geographic context." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:14:42.131102", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 10 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "9992ba20-254a-49bd-b21e-5d633c25a8bc", + "ibfs_id": "040bf6f6-e505-44ef-a7b9-846fc8e3fb60", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) are often promoted as a more environmentally friendly alternative to traditional gasoline vehicles, and there is substantial evidence to support this claim, particularly when considering long-term impacts. However, the environmental impacts of EVs can be complex and multifaceted. Here\u2019s a detailed comparison of the environmental impacts of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles:\n\n1. **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:**\n - **EVs:** Over their lifecycle, EVs generally produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline vehicles. While the manufacturing process, particularly battery production, is energy-intensive and can result in higher initial emissions, these are offset by the reduced emissions during operation. EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, and when powered by renewable energy sources, their overall emissions can be significantly lower.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases directly from the tailpipe, contributing significantly to climate change. Even with advancements in fuel efficiency, the emissions from gasoline combustion are a major environmental concern.\n\n2. **Air Quality:**\n - **EVs:** By eliminating tailpipe emissions, EVs help improve air quality, particularly in urban areas. They significantly reduce pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter, which are harmful to human health and contribute to smog and acid rain.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles emit a variety of harmful pollutants, including NOx, hydrocarbons, and particulate matter, which can degrade air quality and pose health risks.\n\n3. **Resource Extraction and Manufacturing:**\n - **EVs:** The production of EVs, especially their batteries, requires the extraction of minerals like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. This can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and water pollution. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling are helping to mitigate these issues.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** The extraction and refinement of oil for gasoline is also resource-intensive and environmentally damaging. Oil drilling and spills can cause significant ecological harm, and refining processes emit pollutants.\n\n4. **Energy Efficiency:**\n - **EVs:** Electric motors are more energy-efficient than internal combustion engines. EVs convert a higher percentage of electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Internal combustion engines are less efficient, with much of the energy from gasoline lost as heat. This inherent inefficiency means higher fuel consumption and increased emissions per mile driven.\n\n5. **End-of-Life Considerations:**\n - **EVs:** Battery disposal and recycling are critical issues. However, as EV adoption grows, so does the development of battery recycling technologies, which aim to recover valuable materials and mitigate environmental impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Conventional vehicles also require disposal of hazardous materials like motor oil and coolant. The recycling process for traditional vehicles is well-established, but it does not negate the environmental impact of their operation.\n\n6. **Infrastructure and Energy Source:**\n - **EVs:** The environmental benefits of EVs can vary depending on the energy mix of the grid. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources, the benefits are maximized. However, in areas relying heavily on coal, the benefits are reduced but still tend to be better than gasoline vehicles.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** These rely on a vast infrastructure for fuel extraction, refinement, and distribution, which has its own environmental footprint.\n\nIn summary, while both EVs and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts, EVs generally offer significant advantages in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving air quality, especially as the energy grid becomes cleaner. Continued advancements in technology and infrastructure are likely to further enhance the environmental benefits of electric vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles using a geographically-tailored life cycle assessment (LCA), we need to consider several regional factors that influence the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type. These factors include the composition of the electricity grid used for charging EVs, the local availability and sourcing of raw materials, and regional end-of-life processing capabilities. Let's examine these aspects across three different regions: the United States, Europe, and China.\n\n### United States\n\n1. **Electricity Grid Composition:**\n - The U.S. grid is diverse, with significant regional variation. Some states like California and New York have a higher proportion of renewable energy (solar, wind), while others rely more on coal and natural gas.\n - In states with cleaner grids, EVs have a lower carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles due to reduced emissions from electricity generation.\n\n2. **Raw Materials:**\n - The U.S. has some domestic lithium and cobalt resources, but much of the raw materials for batteries are imported, affecting the environmental impact due to transportation emissions.\n - Recycling facilities are developing, but the infrastructure is not yet widespread.\n\n3. **End-of-Life Processing:**\n - The U.S. has established recycling programs for traditional vehicles, but EV battery recycling is still emerging, which can lead to higher environmental impacts if not managed properly.\n\n### Europe\n\n1. **Electricity Grid Composition:**\n - Europe has a relatively clean grid, with a significant share of renewable energy sources like wind, hydro, and solar, especially in countries like Germany and Denmark.\n - This results in a lower carbon footprint for EVs compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n2. **Raw Materials:**\n - Europe relies heavily on imports for battery materials, but there is a strong focus on developing sustainable supply chains and recycling initiatives.\n - The European Union has stringent regulations on sourcing and recycling, which can mitigate some environmental impacts.\n\n3. **End-of-Life Processing:**\n - Europe has advanced recycling capabilities and strict regulations for vehicle disposal, including EV batteries, which helps reduce the environmental impact.\n\n### China\n\n1. **Electricity Grid Composition:**\n - China's grid is heavily reliant on coal, although there is a growing investment in renewables.\n - The high coal dependency means that the carbon footprint of EVs can be higher compared to regions with cleaner grids, although still generally lower than gasoline vehicles due to efficiency gains.\n\n2. **Raw Materials:**\n - China is a major producer of lithium and other battery materials, reducing transportation emissions and environmental impact associated with imports.\n - Local sourcing helps lower the overall environmental footprint of EV production.\n\n3. **End-of-Life Processing:**\n - China is rapidly developing its recycling infrastructure, with government policies encouraging the recycling of EV batteries.\n - However, the current capabilities may not fully mitigate the environmental impacts yet.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles vary significantly by region due to differences in electricity grid composition, raw material sourcing, and end-of-life processing capabilities. In regions with cleaner electricity grids and advanced recycling infrastructure, such as Europe, EVs tend to have a significantly lower environmental impact than gasoline vehicles. In contrast, regions with coal-dependent grids, like parts of China, may see less pronounced benefits, although EVs generally still offer some environmental advantages. The U.S. presents a mixed scenario, with regional differences playing a crucial role in determining the overall environmental benefits of EVs.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation to end-of-life disposal. This method provides a comprehensive view of the overall environmental footprint, including CO", + "I can answer by conducting a geographically-tailored life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines how the environmental impacts of electric and traditional gasoline vehicles vary depending on the region. This approach would consider regional differences in electricity grid composition for EV charging, local availability of raw materials, and regional end-of-life processing capabilities, offering insights into how location influences the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation to end-of-life disposal. This method provides a comprehensive view of the overall environmental footprint, including CO", + "I can answer by analyzing the operational impact differences between electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach focuses on the emissions and environmental effects during the vehicle's use phase, particularly comparing the greenhouse gas emissions and energy efficiency. It also considers the source of electricity used to charge EVs, as this can significantly influence their environmental impact. This method provides insights into the direct environmental benefits or drawbacks of each vehicle type during their active use." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation to end-of-life disposal. This method provides a comprehensive view of the overall environmental footprint, including CO" + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing the life cycle assessment (LCA) specifically on the manufacturing phase of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would delve deeply into the extraction and processing of raw materials, such as lithium for EV batteries and steel for gasoline engines, considering energy usage, emissions, and waste generated during this stage to reveal which type of vehicle has a more sustainable production process.", + "I can answer by conducting a geographically-tailored life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines how the environmental impacts of electric and traditional gasoline vehicles vary depending on the region. This approach would consider regional differences in electricity grid composition for EV charging, local availability of raw materials, and regional end-of-life processing capabilities, offering insights into how location influences the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a geographically-tailored life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines how the environmental impacts of electric and traditional gasoline vehicles vary depending on the region. This approach would consider regional differences in electricity grid composition for EV charging, local availability of raw materials, and regional end-of-life processing capabilities, offering insights into how location influences the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:14:55.057551", + "similarity_score": 0.7, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 11 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "11e76d50-bc2e-42e9-8d28-d68f76ef4719", + "ibfs_id": "b6d36c94-b9d0-4490-9cdd-2215801e9973", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) are often heralded as a more environmentally-friendly alternative to traditional gasoline vehicles, and for good reasons. However, the environmental impacts of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles are nuanced and depend on several factors, including the source of electricity, battery production, and overall lifecycle emissions.\n\n1. **Emissions During Operation**: \n EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas. This is a stark contrast to gasoline vehicles, which emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulates that contribute to air pollution and climate change. The reduction in local air pollutants from EVs can lead to improved public health outcomes and a decrease in smog and respiratory problems.\n\n2. **Energy Source for Electricity**:\n The environmental benefits of EVs largely depend on the energy mix used to generate electricity. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the overall emissions from EVs can be significantly lower than gasoline vehicles. However, if the electricity is primarily generated from coal or other fossil fuels, the environmental advantage diminishes, although EVs are still generally cleaner overall due to higher efficiency in energy use.\n\n3. **Lifecycle Emissions**:\n When considering the full lifecycle, including manufacturing, operation, and disposal, EVs typically have a lower carbon footprint than gasoline vehicles. The production of EVs, particularly the batteries, is energy-intensive and can result in higher upfront emissions. However, these emissions are often offset by the efficiency and cleaner operation of EVs over their lifespan.\n\n4. **Battery Production and Recycling**:\n The production of lithium-ion batteries used in EVs involves mining lithium, cobalt, and other metals, which can have significant environmental impacts, such as habitat destruction and water pollution. Nonetheless, advancements in battery technology and recycling processes are helping to mitigate these impacts. Effective recycling can recover valuable materials and reduce the demand for new raw materials.\n\n5. **Resource Use and Sustainability**:\n As EV adoption grows, there is an increasing focus on sustainable sourcing of materials and improving battery technologies to reduce reliance on scarce resources. Efforts are underway to develop more sustainable battery chemistries and to enhance the efficiency of resource use.\n\n6. **Long-Term Environmental Benefits**:\n Over the long term, the transition to EVs is expected to significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions and reliance on fossil fuels, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener. This shift is essential for meeting global climate targets and reducing the impacts of climate change.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs are not without environmental challenges, they offer a more sustainable alternative to gasoline vehicles, particularly as the energy grid becomes cleaner and battery technologies improve. The shift to electric mobility is a key component of reducing transportation-related emissions and achieving a more sustainable future.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a lifecycle analysis that examines each stage of their lifecycle: extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal.\n\n### 1. Extraction of Raw Materials\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Rare Earth Elements:** EVs often use rare earth elements in their motors, which are also environmentally intensive to extract.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Oil Extraction:** The primary raw material is crude oil, which must be extracted, transported, and refined. Oil extraction can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and significant greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Metals and Plastics:** Gasoline vehicles also require steel, aluminum, and plastics, which involve mining and refining processes that have environmental impacts.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Material Processing:** The processing of battery materials contributes to air and water pollution.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Traditional Manufacturing:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is well-established and generally less energy-intensive than EVs, but still involves significant emissions from steel and aluminum production.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during usage depends on the electricity source. If powered by renewable energy, EVs have a much lower carbon footprint. However, if the electricity comes from coal or natural gas, the benefits are reduced.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Combustion Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Improvements in fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, but gasoline vehicles inherently produce more emissions than EVs during operation.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries pose environmental challenges. While recycling can recover valuable materials, improper disposal can lead to toxic pollution.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, the rest of the EV can be recycled, but the process is complicated by the presence of electronic components.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are largely recyclable, with established systems for recycling metals and other materials.\n- **Waste Oil and Fluids:** Disposal of engine oil and other fluids can pose environmental risks if not managed properly.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nElectric vehicles generally offer environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during the usage phase. However, they also present unique environmental challenges, especially in the extraction of raw materials and battery disposal. The overall environmental impact of EVs can be significantly reduced if the electricity used for charging comes from renewable sources and if effective recycling systems for batteries are developed. On the other hand, gasoline vehicles have a more straightforward lifecycle but contribute more directly to air pollution and climate change during their operational phase.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles at each stage of their lifecycle. This includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. This approach will help highlight the various environmental costs associated with both types of vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles at each stage of their lifecycle. This includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. This approach will help highlight the various environmental costs associated with both types of vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining the emissions and pollutants associated with both vehicle types. This involves comparing the tailpipe emissions of traditional gasoline vehicles with the emissions generated from electricity production for EVs, considering different energy sources like coal, natural gas, and renewables. This will provide insight into the air quality impacts and greenhouse gas contributions from each vehicle.", + "I can answer by analyzing the resource and energy consumption required to produce electric and gasoline vehicles. This includes a focus on the mining and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries, and the energy-intensive processes involved in refining gasoline. This approach will consider the environmental footprint of resource extraction and manufacturing processes.", + "I can answer by evaluating the potential for each vehicle type to support a sustainable transportation system in the future. This involves looking at the scalability of electric vehicle infrastructure, such as charging stations and grid capacity, versus the sustainability challenges faced by continued reliance on fossil fuels. This future-oriented analysis will consider long-term environmental resilience and adaptability." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles at each stage of their lifecycle. This includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. This approach will help highlight the various environmental costs associated with both types of vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:15:10.194143", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 12 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "ca79664e-1541-4288-826f-a5724923a301", + "ibfs_id": "3e2382bb-81e5-44c7-a5ef-2aa97030f528", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles impact the environment in distinct ways, and understanding these differences is crucial for assessing their overall sustainability and environmental footprint.\n\n**1. Emissions During Use:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which is a significant advantage over gasoline vehicles. This means they do not emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), or particulate matter during operation, contributing to improved air quality, especially in urban areas.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** In contrast, traditional gasoline vehicles emit significant amounts of CO2, a greenhouse gas that contributes to climate change, along with NOx and particulates that can harm human health and the environment.\n\n**2. Energy Source and Lifecycle Emissions:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** The environmental impact of EVs largely depends on the energy mix used for electricity generation. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the overall emissions are much lower compared to when electricity is generated from fossil fuels. However, even with a less green energy mix, EVs often have a smaller carbon footprint over their entire lifecycle compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The emissions from gasoline vehicles are directly linked to fossil fuel combustion. This not only contributes to air pollution but also involves significant CO2 emissions during fuel extraction, refining, and transportation.\n\n**3. Manufacturing and Raw Materials:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve mining for lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other materials. This mining process can have significant environmental and social impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and ethical concerns regarding labor practices. However, advances in battery recycling and second-life applications are helping mitigate these impacts.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** While gasoline vehicles do not require large batteries, their production still involves substantial resource extraction and energy use, but the environmental impacts in terms of raw material extraction are generally less compared to the battery production for EVs.\n\n**4. End-of-Life Considerations:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** Battery disposal and recycling are critical issues. Developing effective recycling technology is essential to minimize toxic waste and recover valuable materials, thereby reducing the environmental impact of EVs.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles also require proper disposal and recycling, but they do not have the same battery-specific issues as EVs. However, the engines and other components still need to be managed to prevent environmental harm.\n\n**5. Overall Environmental Impact:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** Generally, EVs are considered to have a lower environmental impact over their lifecycle compared to gasoline vehicles, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery technology improves.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles remain a significant source of greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, and their environmental impact is more challenging to mitigate given the reliance on fossil fuels.\n\nIn conclusion, while both EVs and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts, EVs offer a pathway to significantly reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions, particularly as renewable energy sources become more prevalent and battery technologies advance. Policymakers, industry stakeholders, and consumers are increasingly recognizing these advantages, driving the global shift towards electrification in transportation.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we can analyze their lifecycle emissions, which encompass the manufacturing, operation, and disposal stages. This comprehensive approach provides a clearer picture of the total carbon footprint associated with each type of vehicle.\n\n### 1. Manufacturing Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** The production of EVs, particularly the lithium-ion batteries, is energy-intensive and contributes significantly to the initial carbon footprint. The extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel are resource-intensive and can have substantial environmental impacts.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** The assembly of EVs is similar to that of gasoline vehicles, but the additional complexity of battery integration can increase emissions slightly.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Fuel System Production:** Manufacturing internal combustion engines and fuel systems also involves significant emissions, but generally less than the battery production for EVs.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to EVs, the assembly process contributes to the carbon footprint, but without the added impact of battery production.\n\n### 2. Operation Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Electricity Generation:** The emissions during the operation of EVs depend heavily on the energy mix used to generate electricity. In regions where coal is a major energy source, the operational emissions can be higher. However, as the grid becomes greener with more renewable energy, the operational emissions of EVs decrease significantly.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid into vehicle movement.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Combustion:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe. These emissions are consistent regardless of the energy grid and are a significant source of greenhouse gases.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** While improvements in fuel efficiency have been made, gasoline vehicles are inherently less efficient than EVs due to energy losses in combustion.\n\n### 3. Disposal Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries present environmental challenges. However, advancements in recycling technologies are improving the recovery of valuable materials, reducing the environmental impact.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, the recycling of the vehicle body and components is standard, though the presence of batteries adds complexity.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** The recycling process is well-established, with most materials being recoverable. However, the environmental impact of disposing of engine components and fluids is notable.\n\n### Lifecycle Emissions Comparison\n\nSeveral studies have conducted lifecycle assessments (LCAs) to compare the total carbon footprint of EVs and gasoline vehicles. These studies generally find that:\n\n- **Initial Emissions:** EVs have higher emissions during the manufacturing stage, primarily due to battery production.\n- **Operational Emissions:** EVs typically have lower emissions during the operational stage, especially as the grid becomes cleaner.\n- **Overall Lifecycle Emissions:** Over the vehicle's lifetime, EVs tend to have lower total emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, particularly in regions with a significant share of renewable energy in the electricity mix.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs have a higher initial carbon footprint due to battery production, their lower operational emissions often result in a smaller overall carbon footprint over their lifecycle compared to traditional gasoline vehicles. This advantage is expected to grow as battery technologies improve and the electricity grid becomes increasingly powered by renewable sources.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by comparing the lifecycle emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles, which includes manufacturing, operation, and disposal stages. This approach will involve analyzing studies that assess the total carbon footprint from the production of the vehicles, the extraction and processing of raw materials, the emissions during vehicle use, and the environmental costs of vehicle disposal or recycling." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by comparing the lifecycle emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles, which includes manufacturing, operation, and disposal stages. This approach will involve analyzing studies that assess the total carbon footprint from the production of the vehicles, the extraction and processing of raw materials, the emissions during vehicle use, and the environmental costs of vehicle disposal or recycling.", + "I can answer by examining the energy sources used to power electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impact of generating electricity (considering coal, natural gas, renewables, etc.) compared to the extraction, refining, and burning of gasoline. This comparison can highlight how the source of electricity influences the overall environmental benefits of electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by considering the ecological impact of resource extraction for both types of vehicles. For electric vehicles, this means focusing on the mining of lithium, cobalt, and other materials used in batteries, while for gasoline vehicles, it involves looking at the extraction and refining of crude oil. Evaluating the effects of these processes on ecosystems, biodiversity, and human communities can offer insights into their environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by exploring policy and infrastructure impacts, such as government incentives for electric vehicles, the development of charging infrastructure, and the role of public transportation integration. This approach assesses how these factors influence the environmental footprint of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles, including potential reductions in emissions due to shifts in transportation habits and energy grid improvements." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by comparing the lifecycle emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles, which includes manufacturing, operation, and disposal stages. This approach will involve analyzing studies that assess the total carbon footprint from the production of the vehicles, the extraction and processing of raw materials, the emissions during vehicle use, and the environmental costs of vehicle disposal or recycling." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:15:29.255223", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 13 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "23d4bc09-b1f9-4ffe-afc0-40525c1c502a", + "ibfs_id": "7f60bb0c-59d6-45ea-8191-9aba2e6de262", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles each have distinct environmental impacts that can be evaluated across various stages of their lifecycle, from production to end-of-life. Here is a detailed comparison:\n\n1. **Production Impact**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The production of EVs, particularly the manufacturing of lithium-ion batteries, tends to have a higher environmental footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. Mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel\u2014key components of these batteries\u2014can lead to habitat destruction, water pollution, and significant energy consumption. However, as technology advances, the efficiency of battery production is improving, and efforts are being made to recycle battery materials to mitigate these impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The production of traditional vehicles is less energy-intensive due to the mature nature of the industry, but it still involves considerable resource extraction and energy use. The environmental impact is spread more evenly across the vehicle's lifecycle compared to EVs, which have a higher initial production impact.\n\n2. **Operational Impact**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: During operation, EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas. The overall environmental benefit depends on the electricity source used to charge them. If the electricity comes from renewable sources, the emissions are greatly reduced. However, if the grid is heavily reliant on fossil fuels, this advantage diminishes. As the global energy grid becomes cleaner, the operational benefits of EVs will continue to increase.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Traditional vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants that contribute to air pollution and climate change. These emissions are a significant environmental concern, especially in densely populated regions.\n\n3. **Lifecycle Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: Despite the higher initial production emissions, studies show that EVs typically have a lower overall carbon footprint over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles, especially when charged from a clean energy grid. The reduction in emissions during the operational phase helps offset the initial production impact.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Over their lifecycle, these vehicles contribute significantly to greenhouse gas emissions, primarily due to the combustion of fossil fuels during operation. This impact is consistent regardless of the region, as long as they rely on gasoline.\n\n4. **End-of-Life Impact**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: Battery disposal and recycling are critical issues. Improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination. However, advancements in battery recycling technologies are promising, aiming to recover valuable materials and reduce waste.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles have well-established recycling processes for metals and other components, though the disposal of certain materials can still pose environmental challenges.\n\n5. **Resource Dependency**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The dependency on specific materials for batteries (like lithium, cobalt, and nickel) can lead to geopolitical and ethical concerns, including labor practices in mining operations. However, there is a growing focus on developing alternative battery technologies that use more abundant and sustainable resources.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The reliance on petroleum not only has environmental implications but also involves geopolitical tensions and price volatility. Oil extraction and transportation can lead to spills and environmental degradation.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles have a higher environmental impact during the production phase, they generally offer significant advantages in terms of reduced emissions and air pollution during their operational life, especially as energy grids transition to renewable sources. The long-term environmental benefits of EVs make them a crucial component of global strategies to combat climate change and reduce urban pollution. As technology and infrastructure continue to improve, the environmental impacts of EVs are expected to further decline, enhancing their sustainability compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through a component-specific life cycle assessment (LCA), we will focus on key components: the battery in EVs and the internal combustion engine in gasoline vehicles. This analysis will consider the production, use, and disposal stages of these components.\n\n### Electric Vehicles: Battery\n\n#### Production Stage\n- **Materials Extraction and Processing**: The production of EV batteries, particularly lithium-ion batteries, involves the extraction and processing of raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. These processes are energy-intensive and can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high carbon emissions due to mining activities.\n- **Manufacturing**: Battery manufacturing requires substantial energy, often sourced from fossil fuels, contributing to greenhouse gas emissions. The production of cathodes, anodes, and electrolytes involves chemical processes that can release pollutants.\n\n#### Use Stage\n- **Energy Efficiency**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. They convert a higher percentage of electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels. This efficiency translates into lower operational emissions, especially when charged using renewable energy sources.\n- **Emissions**: During use, EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, reducing urban air pollution and associated health impacts.\n\n#### Disposal Stage\n- **Recycling and Disposal**: End-of-life battery management is crucial. Recycling can recover valuable materials, reducing the need for new raw material extraction. However, improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination due to hazardous materials in batteries.\n\n### Gasoline Vehicles: Internal Combustion Engine\n\n#### Production Stage\n- **Materials and Manufacturing**: The production of internal combustion engines involves the extraction and processing of metals like steel and aluminum. The manufacturing process is energy-intensive and contributes to greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Complexity and Components**: Engines are complex with many moving parts, requiring precision manufacturing and assembly, which further increases energy use and emissions.\n\n#### Use Stage\n- **Fuel Consumption**: Gasoline vehicles rely on fossil fuels, which release carbon dioxide and other pollutants during combustion. This contributes significantly to greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution.\n- **Efficiency**: Internal combustion engines are less efficient compared to electric motors, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n\n#### Disposal Stage\n- **End-of-Life Management**: Engines and associated components can be recycled, but the process is energy-intensive. Metals can be recovered, but other materials may end up in landfills.\n\n### Comparative Summary\n\n- **Production**: EV batteries have a higher initial environmental impact due to material extraction and energy-intensive manufacturing. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling can mitigate these impacts over time.\n- **Use**: EVs offer significant environmental benefits during the use phase, with higher energy efficiency and zero tailpipe emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, which emit greenhouse gases and pollutants.\n- **Disposal**: Both EV batteries and gasoline engines require careful end-of-life management to minimize environmental impacts. Recycling processes are improving, particularly for EV batteries, which can reduce the need for new raw materials.\n\nOverall, while the production of EV batteries currently has a higher environmental footprint than gasoline engines, the benefits during the use phase and potential for recycling make EVs a more sustainable choice in the long term, especially as the energy grid becomes greener.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the environmental impact of each vehicle type from production through disposal, considering factors such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle use phase, and end-of-life recycling or disposal.", + "I can answer by conducting a component-specific life cycle assessment (LCA) that isolates the environmental impacts of key vehicle components, such as batteries in electric vehicles and engines in gasoline vehicles. This approach would delve into the specific environmental footprints of these components, including their production, use, and disposal stages, to understand their individual contributions to the overall vehicle impact." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the environmental impact of each vehicle type from production through disposal, considering factors such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle use phase, and end-of-life recycling or disposal.", + "I can answer by comparing the greenhouse gas emissions of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their operational phase. This strategy would focus on the emissions produced by each vehicle type while they are being driven, including the emissions from electricity generation for EVs and the combustion of gasoline for traditional vehicles.", + "I can answer by analyzing the supply chain and resource dependencies of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts related to mining and processing raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries versus those related to oil extraction and refinement for gasoline.", + "I can answer by reviewing and synthesizing existing scientific literature and reports from environmental organizations on the topic. This method would involve gathering data from various studies and reports to provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts associated with both vehicle types, highlighting areas of consensus and debate within the research community." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the environmental impact of each vehicle type from production through disposal, considering factors such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle use phase, and end-of-life recycling or disposal." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) that emphasizes the differences in energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions between electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would detail the energy used and emissions produced at each life cycle stage, from manufacturing and operational energy consumption to final disposal, providing specific insights into how each stage contributes to the overall environmental impact.", + "I can answer by performing a regional life cycle assessment (LCA) that considers the geographical variations in electricity generation sources and raw material availability. This approach would highlight how the environmental impacts of electric vehicles might differ significantly depending on the region, due to varying energy grids, local manufacturing practices, and recycling capabilities, compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by conducting a component-specific life cycle assessment (LCA) that isolates the environmental impacts of key vehicle components, such as batteries in electric vehicles and engines in gasoline vehicles. This approach would delve into the specific environmental footprints of these components, including their production, use, and disposal stages, to understand their individual contributions to the overall vehicle impact.", + "I can answer by integrating a temporal life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles change over time. This approach would assess factors such as potential improvements in battery technology, changes in electricity generation, and advancements in fuel efficiency, projecting how these dynamic elements could alter the comparative environmental impacts of the two vehicle types over the next decades." + ], + "choice_idx": 2, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a component-specific life cycle assessment (LCA) that isolates the environmental impacts of key vehicle components, such as batteries in electric vehicles and engines in gasoline vehicles. This approach would delve into the specific environmental footprints of these components, including their production, use, and disposal stages, to understand their individual contributions to the overall vehicle impact." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:15:53.853918", + "similarity_score": 0.8, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 14 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "4300457a-91ea-45de-a95d-5d425507e6a6", + "ibfs_id": "73df6d95-3eff-47bc-9dc0-4c8dcb26c6e9", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) are often touted as a more environmentally friendly alternative to traditional gasoline vehicles, and for good reason. However, their environmental impacts are multifaceted and can vary depending on several factors, including the source of the electricity used to charge them and the materials used in their batteries.\n\n**1. Emissions During Use:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollutants like nitrogen oxides and particulate matter in urban areas. This can lead to improved air quality and public health benefits.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** In contrast, traditional gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2) and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n\n**2. Lifecycle Emissions:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The total environmental impact of EVs includes emissions from electricity generation and battery production. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind or solar, the overall emissions are much lower. However, if the grid relies heavily on fossil fuels, the environmental benefits are reduced.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Gasoline vehicles produce emissions throughout their lifecycle, from fuel extraction, refining, and transportation, to combustion. These emissions are generally higher than those associated with EVs, especially as the grid becomes cleaner.\n\n**3. Battery Production and Disposal:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The production of lithium-ion batteries used in EVs can have significant environmental impacts, including resource extraction, water usage, and habitat disruption. The mining of lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which are crucial for these batteries, can lead to environmental degradation and human rights concerns. However, advances in recycling technologies and battery chemistry are helping to mitigate these impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** While gasoline vehicles do not rely on large batteries, the environmental costs of oil extraction and refining are substantial, including risks of oil spills and habitat destruction.\n\n**4. Energy Efficiency:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. They convert a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels, whereas internal combustion engines waste a significant portion of energy as heat.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Even the most advanced gasoline engines are less efficient, leading to higher fuel consumption and more emissions per mile.\n\n**5. Infrastructure and Long-Term Impacts:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The shift to EVs requires substantial changes to infrastructure, including charging stations and grid upgrades. In the long term, widespread adoption of EVs can support a transition to renewable energy and a more sustainable transportation system.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Continued reliance on gasoline vehicles perpetuates the demand for fossil fuels and the infrastructure that supports them, which is less sustainable in the context of climate change goals.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles offer significant environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, especially in terms of emissions during use, their overall impact depends on how they are manufactured, the source of their electricity, and how effectively their batteries are recycled. As technology advances and the electricity grid becomes greener, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to increase further.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles using a longitudinal life cycle analysis (LCA), we need to consider the entire lifecycle of each vehicle type, from production through use to end-of-life, while factoring in technological advancements, changes in energy sources, and improvements in recycling methods over time.\n\n### Production Phase\n\n1. **Material Extraction and Manufacturing:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, involves significant environmental impacts due to the extraction and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. However, advancements in battery technology, such as the development of solid-state batteries and alternative chemistries, are expected to reduce these impacts over time by increasing energy density and reducing reliance on scarce materials.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** The manufacturing of gasoline vehicles involves less intensive material extraction compared to EVs, but the production of internal combustion engines (ICEs) and associated components still contributes to environmental impacts. Over time, improvements in manufacturing efficiency and material recycling can mitigate some of these impacts.\n\n### Use Phase\n\n2. **Energy Consumption and Emissions:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The environmental impact during the use phase of EVs is largely dependent on the electricity mix used for charging. As the grid becomes greener with increased integration of renewable energy sources like wind and solar, the carbon footprint of EVs during their use phase is expected to decrease significantly. Technological advancements in battery efficiency and vehicle design also contribute to reduced energy consumption per mile.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Gasoline vehicles emit greenhouse gases and pollutants directly from the tailpipe. While advancements in engine technology and fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, the inherent reliance on fossil fuels limits the potential for significant long-term reductions in environmental impact.\n\n### End-of-Life Phase\n\n3. **Recycling and Disposal:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The recycling of EV batteries is a critical factor in their environmental impact. Current recycling methods are improving, with advancements in recovering valuable materials and reducing waste. Future developments in battery design that facilitate easier recycling and the establishment of efficient recycling infrastructure are expected to further mitigate environmental impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** The recycling of gasoline vehicles is relatively well-established, with many components being recyclable. However, the disposal of engine oils and other fluids presents environmental challenges. Improvements in vehicle design for easier disassembly and recycling can enhance sustainability.\n\n### Longitudinal Considerations\n\n- **Technological Advancements:** Over time, both EVs and gasoline vehicles benefit from technological improvements. For EVs, this includes better battery technologies, more efficient electric drivetrains, and lighter materials. For gasoline vehicles, advancements focus on increasing fuel efficiency and reducing emissions.\n- **Energy Source Changes:** The shift towards renewable energy sources significantly benefits EVs, as their environmental impact during the use phase is closely tied to the electricity grid's carbon intensity. Gasoline vehicles remain dependent on fossil fuels, limiting their potential for similar improvements.\n- **Recycling Improvements:** As recycling technologies advance, both vehicle types can see reduced environmental impacts at the end of their lifecycle. However, the complexity of EV battery recycling presents unique challenges and opportunities for innovation.\n\nIn conclusion, while both electric and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts, the longitudinal life cycle analysis suggests that EVs have the potential for greater reductions in environmental impact over time due to technological advancements, cleaner energy sources, and improved recycling methods. Gasoline vehicles, constrained by their reliance on fossil fuels, face more significant challenges in achieving similar long-term environmental benefits.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive life cycle analysis (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal. By comparing the LCAs, I can provide a detailed overview of how each vehicle type impacts the environment throughout its entire lifespan.", + "I can answer by integrating a longitudinal life cycle analysis (LCA) that examines how the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles evolve over time. This involves considering technological advancements, changes in energy sources, and improvements in recycling methods, providing a dynamic view of how each vehicle type's environmental impacts may change in the future." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive life cycle analysis (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal. By comparing the LCAs, I can provide a detailed overview of how each vehicle type impacts the environment throughout its entire lifespan.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions comparison during the usage phase of the vehicles. This involves analyzing the greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion compared to the emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs, considering the energy mix of different regions. This approach would highlight the environmental impact while the vehicles are in use.", + "I can answer by examining the resource consumption and waste generation associated with each vehicle type. This includes assessing the demand for rare earth metals in EV batteries and their recyclability, versus the oil extraction and refining processes required for gasoline vehicles. By comparing the sustainability of resource usage, I can provide insights into the broader environmental implications.", + "I can answer by exploring the potential impact on ecosystems and local environments. This could involve looking at the land use changes, habitat disruption, and pollution resulting from mining activities for battery materials in EVs, compared to the impact of oil drilling and infrastructure development for gasoline vehicles. This strategy would provide an ecological perspective on the environmental impacts of both vehicle types." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive life cycle analysis (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal. By comparing the LCAs, I can provide a detailed overview of how each vehicle type impacts the environment throughout its entire lifespan." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a specific LCA phase for both electric and gasoline vehicles, such as the manufacturing process. In this approach, I will conduct a detailed comparison of the environmental impacts related specifically to the production of EV batteries versus gasoline engines. This targeted analysis will highlight the differences in resource use and emissions during the manufacturing stage.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional life cycle analysis (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles, taking into account the specific energy sources and infrastructure available in different geographic areas. This approach will assess how the environmental impacts vary depending on whether the electricity for EVs is generated from renewable sources or fossil fuels, and how this compares to regional gasoline production and consumption.", + "I can answer by undertaking a component-specific life cycle analysis (LCA), where I assess and compare the environmental impacts of individual components such as the battery pack for EVs and the internal combustion engine for gasoline vehicles. This granular approach will provide insights into which specific parts contribute most to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type throughout their lifecycle.", + "I can answer by integrating a longitudinal life cycle analysis (LCA) that examines how the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles evolve over time. This involves considering technological advancements, changes in energy sources, and improvements in recycling methods, providing a dynamic view of how each vehicle type's environmental impacts may change in the future." + ], + "choice_idx": 3, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by integrating a longitudinal life cycle analysis (LCA) that examines how the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles evolve over time. This involves considering technological advancements, changes in energy sources, and improvements in recycling methods, providing a dynamic view of how each vehicle type's environmental impacts may change in the future." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:16:09.338244", + "similarity_score": 0.8, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 15 + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_config.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_config.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ae9cccc3d2b2e95c2b242023cd338625b72a97f4 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_config.json @@ -0,0 +1,23 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "queries": [ + "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?" + ], + "diversity_levels": [ + "low", + "medium" + ], + "branching_factors": [ + 2, + 4 + ], + "max_depths": [ + 1, + 2 + ], + "epsilon_values": [ + 0.2 + ], + "repetitions": 2, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:11:19.463061" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_0.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_0.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..12401d03232dbaed14ba7bd4cd9429c3220aff9d --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_0.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "ec487b84-f421-4825-925e-6811623122df", + "ibfs_id": "1f13d1b0-313f-4112-8ec3-4b366183261f", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles have distinct environmental impacts, and understanding these differences is crucial for assessing their roles in sustainable transportation.\n\n1. **Emissions During Use**: One of the most significant environmental advantages of EVs over gasoline vehicles is their lack of tailpipe emissions. While gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change, EVs run on electricity and produce no direct emissions. This shift can significantly improve air quality, especially in urban areas.\n\n2. **Lifecycle Emissions**: When evaluating the overall environmental impact, it's essential to consider the entire lifecycle of the vehicles, from production to disposal. EVs generally have higher emissions during the manufacturing phase, primarily due to the battery production, which requires mining and processing of minerals like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. However, these initial emissions are often offset by the reduced emissions during the vehicle's operational phase.\n\n3. **Energy Source for Electricity**: The environmental benefits of EVs are closely tied to the energy sources used for electricity generation. In regions where the grid is predominantly powered by coal or other fossil fuels, the emissions benefits of EVs are reduced. However, as the grid becomes greener with more renewable energy sources like wind, solar, and hydroelectric power, the environmental advantage of EVs increases.\n\n4. **Resource Extraction and Battery Production**: The production of EV batteries involves resource-intensive processes. Mining for battery materials can lead to habitat destruction, water pollution, and significant energy use. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling processes are continually being developed to mitigate these impacts.\n\n5. **End-of-Life and Recycling**: The disposal and recycling of both EVs and gasoline vehicles present environmental challenges. EV batteries, in particular, require careful handling due to their chemical components. Recycling programs are crucial to reclaim valuable materials and reduce environmental harm. The automotive industry is investing in improving battery recycling technologies to enhance sustainability.\n\n6. **Efficiency and Energy Use**: EVs are generally more efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 60% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, while conventional gasoline engines convert only about 20% of the energy stored in gasoline. This higher efficiency translates to less energy use and lower overall emissions, assuming a clean energy source.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles present certain environmental challenges, particularly in terms of battery production and resource extraction, they offer significant benefits in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and air pollutants during operation. The net environmental impact of EVs is highly dependent on the electricity grid's cleanliness, advancements in battery technology, and effective recycling systems. As clean energy sources and technologies continue to evolve, the environmental benefits of EVs are expected to increase, making them a key component in reducing the transportation sector's carbon footprint.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we will conduct a comparative lifecycle analysis. This analysis examines the entire lifecycle of both vehicle types, including raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. We will evaluate each stage in terms of greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use copper and rare earth elements for motors and electronics, which require additional mining activities.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Fuel Extraction:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can cause oil spills, habitat disruption, and significant land and water pollution.\n- **Material Use:** Gasoline vehicles primarily use steel, aluminum, and plastics, which also require energy-intensive extraction processes but generally have a less complex supply chain than EV batteries.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** The manufacturing of EVs, particularly their batteries, is energy-intensive. The production process emits more greenhouse gases compared to gasoline vehicles due to the energy required for battery production.\n- **Manufacturing Emissions:** Overall, EVs have higher emissions during the manufacturing phase because of the complex battery systems.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Conventional Manufacturing:** The production of gasoline vehicles is well-established and generally less energy-intensive than EVs, resulting in lower emissions during the manufacturing phase.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, significantly reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during the usage phase depends on the electricity source. If the electricity comes from renewable sources, the emissions are minimal. However, if it is from coal or natural gas, the emissions can be substantial.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Combustion Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and particulate matter during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Improvements in fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, but they still remain higher than those of EVs, especially when EVs are powered by clean energy.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries are critical. Improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination. However, advances in battery recycling technologies are improving the recovery of valuable materials.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, the rest of the EV can be recycled, but the battery poses unique challenges.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles have a well-established recycling process for metals and other materials, which mitigates some environmental impacts.\n- **Waste Products:** End-of-life gasoline vehicles do not have the same battery disposal issues as EVs, but they still contribute to waste and pollution.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles generally have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases due to the energy-intensive processes involved in battery production. However, during the usage phase, EVs offer significant environmental benefits over gasoline vehicles, especially when powered by renewable energy, as they produce zero tailpipe emissions. The end-of-life disposal of EVs presents challenges, particularly with battery recycling, but advancements in this area are ongoing. Overall, while EVs have a larger initial environmental footprint, their long-term benefits in reducing emissions and pollution make them a more sustainable option compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining the entire lifecycle of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal. I would assess the environmental impacts at each stage, considering factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution. This comprehensive analysis would provide a detailed view of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining the entire lifecycle of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal. I would assess the environmental impacts at each stage, considering factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution. This comprehensive analysis would provide a detailed view of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational emissions and energy sources associated with electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would emphasize the emissions produced during the use phase of the vehicles. For gasoline vehicles, I would calculate the emissions from burning fossil fuels. For electric vehicles, I would analyze the emissions based on the electricity mix used for charging, considering how the energy grid's reliance on renewable or non-renewable sources affects the overall environmental impact. This strategy highlights the differences in emissions during the vehicles' operational life." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining the entire lifecycle of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal. I would assess the environmental impacts at each stage, considering factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution. This comprehensive analysis would provide a detailed view of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:11:52.163671", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 0 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_1.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_1.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..23cb37dff39d90af5a7d5f6b24889ade3d2d6879 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_1.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c2791648-8420-4b9d-8353-1576e0896024", + "ibfs_id": "36233969-2c31-413c-9d61-d4a40a06f31b", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) offer a promising solution to many of the environmental challenges posed by traditional gasoline vehicles, but they also come with their own set of environmental impacts. A comprehensive comparison between EVs and gasoline vehicles reveals several key aspects:\n\n1. **Greenhouse Gas Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs produce zero emissions at the tailpipe, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas. However, the production of electricity used to charge EVs can contribute to greenhouse gas emissions, depending on the energy sources. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the overall emissions are much lower.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2) and other harmful pollutants directly from their exhausts. Combustion of gasoline releases significant amounts of CO2, contributing to global warming, and other pollutants that degrade air quality, such as nitrogen oxides and particulate matter.\n\n2. **Lifecycle Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: Manufacturing EVs, especially the batteries, can be more resource-intensive compared to conventional vehicles, leading to higher emissions upfront. However, over their lifetime, EVs generally have lower emissions when accounting for the electricity used for charging. Improvements in battery technology and recycling, along with cleaner electricity grids, are further reducing the lifecycle emissions of EVs.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: While their manufacturing process involves fewer emissions compared to EVs, the continuous burning of fuel over the vehicle's lifespan results in higher cumulative emissions. Gasoline production, including extraction, refining, and distribution, also contributes to significant emissions.\n\n3. **Resource Use and Environmental Impact**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The production of EV batteries requires minerals such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel. Mining these minerals can have environmental and social impacts, including habitat destruction and pollution. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling are helping mitigate these issues.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The extraction and processing of crude oil have substantial environmental impacts, including oil spills, habitat destruction, and pollution. The infrastructure required for oil extraction and transportation also impacts ecosystems.\n\n4. **Energy Efficiency**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert a higher percentage of electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, compared to the lower efficiency of internal combustion engines.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Internal combustion engines typically have lower efficiency rates, with much of the energy from gasoline lost as heat. This inefficiency contributes to higher fuel consumption and emissions.\n\n5. **End-of-Life Considerations**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose challenges but also opportunities. Effective recycling can recover valuable materials and reduce environmental impact. Policies and technologies are evolving to improve battery recycling processes.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Conventional vehicles also require end-of-life processing, but they lack the complex battery disposal issues of EVs. However, they contribute to environmental pollution through the disposal of used oil and other fluids.\n\nIn summary, while EVs are not entirely free of environmental impacts, they generally offer significant benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving air quality. Their environmental footprint is expected to further decrease as technology advances and energy grids become greener. Transitioning to electric vehicles, coupled with renewable energy adoption and sustainable practices, plays a crucial role in achieving a more sustainable transportation system.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will conduct a comprehensive lifecycle analysis (LCA) that examines each stage of their lifecycle: raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other minerals. Mining these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Materials:** EVs also use aluminum and steel, similar to gasoline vehicles, but the production of lightweight materials like aluminum can be energy-intensive.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Extraction:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Material Use:** Gasoline vehicles are primarily made of steel and aluminum, with less reliance on rare minerals compared to EVs.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy Use:** The manufacturing process for EVs, particularly battery production, is energy-intensive and results in higher initial emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Emissions:** The production of EVs generally results in higher greenhouse gas emissions upfront due to the energy required for battery production.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Use:** Manufacturing processes for gasoline vehicles are less energy-intensive than for EVs, resulting in lower initial emissions.\n- **Emissions:** The emissions from manufacturing gasoline vehicles are typically lower than those for EVs, primarily due to the absence of battery production.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy Source:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions. However, their overall emissions depend on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources (solar, wind) significantly reduce emissions, while coal-based electricity increases them.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Gasoline vehicles are less efficient, with internal combustion engines losing a significant amount of energy as heat.\n\n### 4. Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal of EVs involves challenges related to battery recycling. While recycling technologies are improving, improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination.\n- **Material Recovery:** Many components of EVs can be recycled, but the process is complex and energy-intensive.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recyclability:** Gasoline vehicles are relatively straightforward to recycle, with established processes for recovering metals and other materials.\n- **End-of-Life Emissions:** The disposal process for gasoline vehicles is less complex than for EVs, but still involves emissions and energy use.\n\n### Overall Environmental Impact\n\n- **EVs:** While EVs have higher initial environmental impacts due to battery production, they generally have lower emissions during the usage phase, especially when powered by renewable energy. Over their lifetime, EVs tend to have a smaller carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles, particularly in regions with clean electricity grids.\n \n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** Gasoline vehicles have lower initial manufacturing emissions but contribute significantly to greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution during their operational phase. Over their lifetime, they typically have a larger environmental footprint compared to EVs.\n\nIn conclusion, while both vehicle types have environmental impacts, EVs offer a more sustainable option in the long term, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive lifecycle analysis for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the entire lifespan of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction and manufacturing processes to usage and eventual disposal. By comparing the energy consumption, emissions, and environmental impact at each stage, I can provide a detailed comparison of their overall environmental footprints." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive lifecycle analysis for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the entire lifespan of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction and manufacturing processes to usage and eventual disposal. By comparing the energy consumption, emissions, and environmental impact at each stage, I can provide a detailed comparison of their overall environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the specific types of emissions and pollutants generated by each vehicle type during operation. This approach would involve analyzing the direct air pollutants and greenhouse gases emitted by gasoline vehicles, while considering the indirect emissions associated with electricity production for EVs. By comparing the emissions profiles and considering factors like the energy sources used to generate electricity, I can offer insights into the operational environmental impacts of each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive lifecycle analysis for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the entire lifespan of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction and manufacturing processes to usage and eventual disposal. By comparing the energy consumption, emissions, and environmental impact at each stage, I can provide a detailed comparison of their overall environmental footprints." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:11:53.833862", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 1 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_10.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_10.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..98929cfd74eab918c0af5f952176a9239c424628 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_10.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "5a032899-3a4f-47eb-9a31-ae205f4d31d3", + "ibfs_id": "e1cc7551-6647-43fd-b175-21afe42c589a", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles have distinct environmental impacts across their life cycles, from manufacturing to operation and eventual disposal. Here's a detailed comparison:\n\n1. **Manufacturing Impact**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The production of EVs, particularly the battery manufacturing process, tends to have a significant environmental footprint. Mining and processing the raw materials needed for lithium-ion batteries, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, can result in habitat destruction, water pollution, and carbon emissions. However, advancements in battery recycling and the development of more sustainable mining practices are ongoing to mitigate these effects.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Traditional vehicles also have environmental costs during manufacturing, mainly due to steel and aluminum production. However, they generally require fewer rare metals compared to EVs. The overall carbon footprint during manufacturing is usually lower than that of EVs, but the difference diminishes over the vehicle's lifetime.\n\n2. **Operational Impact**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs are far cleaner during operation, producing zero tailpipe emissions. This significantly reduces urban air pollution, which is linked to health issues such as respiratory and cardiovascular diseases. The overall environmental benefit of EVs largely depends on the electricity source used for charging. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind or solar, the carbon footprint is dramatically reduced compared to fossil fuels.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants during operation, contributing substantially to air pollution and climate change. The combustion of gasoline leads to significant greenhouse gas emissions, which are a major driver of global warming.\n\n3. **Energy Efficiency**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. Internal combustion engines lose a lot of energy as heat, while electric motors convert a higher percentage of electrical energy from the grid to power the wheels.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Less efficient in converting stored energy into movement, leading to higher fuel consumption and emissions per mile traveled.\n\n4. **Lifecycle Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: Over their entire lifecycle, EVs typically have lower greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, even when accounting for battery production. As the electricity grid becomes greener, the lifecycle emissions of EVs will continue to decline.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The lifecycle emissions remain high due to continued reliance on fossil fuels during operation.\n\n5. **Waste and Recycling**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose environmental challenges. However, the industry is making strides in battery recycling technologies, which can recover valuable materials and reduce waste.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: While traditional vehicles are also recycled, they do not face the same challenges associated with battery disposal.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles are not without their environmental impacts, particularly in manufacturing, they offer significant advantages over gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of reducing operational emissions and improving urban air quality. As the renewable energy sector grows and battery technologies advance, the environmental benefits of EVs are expected to increase further, making them a more sustainable choice for the future.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a regional lifecycle analysis comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to consider several factors that vary by geographic area. These include the energy grid mix, climate conditions, and regional policies, all of which significantly influence the environmental performance of each vehicle type. Below, I will provide a comparison for three distinct regions: California (USA), Germany, and China, highlighting how these factors affect the lifecycle emissions and overall environmental impact of EVs versus gasoline vehicles.\n\n### California, USA\n\n**Energy Grid Mix:**\n- California's energy grid is relatively clean, with a significant portion of electricity coming from renewable sources such as solar, wind, and hydroelectric power. In 2022, about 33% of California's electricity was generated from renewable sources, with natural gas also playing a role.\n\n**Climate Conditions:**\n- The mild climate in California reduces the energy needed for heating and cooling, which can affect the energy efficiency of both EVs and gasoline vehicles.\n\n**Regional Policies:**\n- California has stringent emissions regulations and incentives for EV adoption, including rebates and access to carpool lanes.\n\n**Lifecycle Analysis:**\n- **EVs:** In California, the cleaner energy grid means that the lifecycle emissions of EVs are significantly lower than in regions with a coal-heavy grid. The production phase of EVs, particularly battery manufacturing, still has a high environmental impact, but this is offset by the low emissions during the use phase.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles produce higher emissions during the use phase due to the combustion of fossil fuels. California's strict emissions standards help reduce the impact somewhat, but gasoline vehicles still have a higher overall lifecycle emissions profile compared to EVs in this region.\n\n### Germany\n\n**Energy Grid Mix:**\n- Germany's energy grid is in transition, with a mix of renewable energy (wind and solar), coal, and natural gas. In 2022, approximately 42% of the electricity came from renewables, but coal still plays a significant role.\n\n**Climate Conditions:**\n- Germany experiences a temperate climate, which can influence vehicle efficiency, especially in winter months when heating is required.\n\n**Regional Policies:**\n- Germany has strong policies promoting EVs, including subsidies and a robust charging infrastructure.\n\n**Lifecycle Analysis:**\n- **EVs:** The environmental impact of EVs in Germany is moderate due to the mixed energy grid. While the use phase emissions are lower than gasoline vehicles, the reliance on coal for electricity generation increases the lifecycle emissions compared to regions with cleaner grids.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles have higher emissions during the use phase. Germany's policies aim to reduce reliance on gasoline vehicles, but their lifecycle emissions remain higher than those of EVs, especially as the grid continues to decarbonize.\n\n### China\n\n**Energy Grid Mix:**\n- China's energy grid is heavily reliant on coal, although there is a growing share of renewables. As of 2022, coal accounted for about 57% of electricity generation, with renewables making up around 28%.\n\n**Climate Conditions:**\n- China has diverse climate conditions, from cold northern regions to tropical southern areas, affecting vehicle efficiency and energy use.\n\n**Regional Policies:**\n- China is aggressively promoting EV adoption through subsidies, mandates, and investments in charging infrastructure.\n\n**Lifecycle Analysis:**\n- **EVs:** In China, the high reliance on coal for electricity generation means that the lifecycle emissions of EVs are higher than in regions with cleaner grids. However, the rapid expansion of renewable energy is expected to improve this over time.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles have high emissions during the use phase, and given the size of the market, their overall environmental impact is substantial. EVs still offer a reduction in urban air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, despite the coal-heavy grid.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe environmental impacts of EVs compared to traditional gasoline vehicles vary significantly by region due to differences in energy grid composition, climate conditions, and regional policies. In regions like California with a cleaner energy grid, EVs offer substantial environmental benefits over gasoline vehicles. In contrast, in regions like China with a coal-heavy grid, the benefits are less pronounced but still present, especially as the grid becomes cleaner. Germany represents a transitional case where the benefits of EVs are growing as the energy grid shifts towards renewables. Overall, regional lifecycle analysis highlights the importance of local context in assessing the environmental impacts of vehicle types.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that compares the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining each stage of a vehicle's lifecycle, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal. I would gather data on emissions, energy consumption, and resource use for both types of vehicles, and then provide a comprehensive comparison to highlight the differences in their overall environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle analysis that focuses on the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles within specific geographic areas. This approach would examine how factors like the local energy grid mix, climate conditions, and regional policies influence the environmental performance of each vehicle type. By analyzing data on emissions, energy consumption, and resource use specific to various regions, I can provide a nuanced comparison that highlights how the environmental impacts of these vehicles vary depending on the geographic context." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that compares the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining each stage of a vehicle's lifecycle, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal. I would gather data on emissions, energy consumption, and resource use for both types of vehicles, and then provide a comprehensive comparison to highlight the differences in their overall environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by summarizing existing scientific research and reports on the topic, focusing on key areas such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource depletion. I would look at studies conducted by environmental organizations, universities, and governmental agencies that have directly compared the impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles. This approach would allow me to present a synthesis of expert opinions and findings, providing a balanced view of the environmental pros and cons associated with each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that compares the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining each stage of a vehicle's lifecycle, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal. I would gather data on emissions, energy consumption, and resource use for both types of vehicles, and then provide a comprehensive comparison to highlight the differences in their overall environmental footprints." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle analysis that focuses on the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles within specific geographic areas. This approach would examine how factors like the local energy grid mix, climate conditions, and regional policies influence the environmental performance of each vehicle type. By analyzing data on emissions, energy consumption, and resource use specific to various regions, I can provide a nuanced comparison that highlights how the environmental impacts of these vehicles vary depending on the geographic context.", + "I can answer by conducting a temporal lifecycle analysis that looks at how the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles evolve over time. This approach would involve examining changes in technology, energy sources, and regulatory landscapes that affect each stage of a vehicle's lifecycle, from manufacturing to disposal. By gathering data on historical and projected trends in emissions, energy consumption, and resource use, I can provide a dynamic comparison that illustrates how the environmental footprints of these vehicles might change in the future." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle analysis that focuses on the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles within specific geographic areas. This approach would examine how factors like the local energy grid mix, climate conditions, and regional policies influence the environmental performance of each vehicle type. By analyzing data on emissions, energy consumption, and resource use specific to various regions, I can provide a nuanced comparison that highlights how the environmental impacts of these vehicles vary depending on the geographic context." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:14:42.131102", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 10 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_11.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_11.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7599a974d3a8a611baafb4402855973d5fc17eb3 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_11.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "9992ba20-254a-49bd-b21e-5d633c25a8bc", + "ibfs_id": "040bf6f6-e505-44ef-a7b9-846fc8e3fb60", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) are often promoted as a more environmentally friendly alternative to traditional gasoline vehicles, and there is substantial evidence to support this claim, particularly when considering long-term impacts. However, the environmental impacts of EVs can be complex and multifaceted. Here\u2019s a detailed comparison of the environmental impacts of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles:\n\n1. **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:**\n - **EVs:** Over their lifecycle, EVs generally produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline vehicles. While the manufacturing process, particularly battery production, is energy-intensive and can result in higher initial emissions, these are offset by the reduced emissions during operation. EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, and when powered by renewable energy sources, their overall emissions can be significantly lower.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases directly from the tailpipe, contributing significantly to climate change. Even with advancements in fuel efficiency, the emissions from gasoline combustion are a major environmental concern.\n\n2. **Air Quality:**\n - **EVs:** By eliminating tailpipe emissions, EVs help improve air quality, particularly in urban areas. They significantly reduce pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter, which are harmful to human health and contribute to smog and acid rain.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles emit a variety of harmful pollutants, including NOx, hydrocarbons, and particulate matter, which can degrade air quality and pose health risks.\n\n3. **Resource Extraction and Manufacturing:**\n - **EVs:** The production of EVs, especially their batteries, requires the extraction of minerals like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. This can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and water pollution. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling are helping to mitigate these issues.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** The extraction and refinement of oil for gasoline is also resource-intensive and environmentally damaging. Oil drilling and spills can cause significant ecological harm, and refining processes emit pollutants.\n\n4. **Energy Efficiency:**\n - **EVs:** Electric motors are more energy-efficient than internal combustion engines. EVs convert a higher percentage of electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Internal combustion engines are less efficient, with much of the energy from gasoline lost as heat. This inherent inefficiency means higher fuel consumption and increased emissions per mile driven.\n\n5. **End-of-Life Considerations:**\n - **EVs:** Battery disposal and recycling are critical issues. However, as EV adoption grows, so does the development of battery recycling technologies, which aim to recover valuable materials and mitigate environmental impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Conventional vehicles also require disposal of hazardous materials like motor oil and coolant. The recycling process for traditional vehicles is well-established, but it does not negate the environmental impact of their operation.\n\n6. **Infrastructure and Energy Source:**\n - **EVs:** The environmental benefits of EVs can vary depending on the energy mix of the grid. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources, the benefits are maximized. However, in areas relying heavily on coal, the benefits are reduced but still tend to be better than gasoline vehicles.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** These rely on a vast infrastructure for fuel extraction, refinement, and distribution, which has its own environmental footprint.\n\nIn summary, while both EVs and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts, EVs generally offer significant advantages in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving air quality, especially as the energy grid becomes cleaner. Continued advancements in technology and infrastructure are likely to further enhance the environmental benefits of electric vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles using a geographically-tailored life cycle assessment (LCA), we need to consider several regional factors that influence the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type. These factors include the composition of the electricity grid used for charging EVs, the local availability and sourcing of raw materials, and regional end-of-life processing capabilities. Let's examine these aspects across three different regions: the United States, Europe, and China.\n\n### United States\n\n1. **Electricity Grid Composition:**\n - The U.S. grid is diverse, with significant regional variation. Some states like California and New York have a higher proportion of renewable energy (solar, wind), while others rely more on coal and natural gas.\n - In states with cleaner grids, EVs have a lower carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles due to reduced emissions from electricity generation.\n\n2. **Raw Materials:**\n - The U.S. has some domestic lithium and cobalt resources, but much of the raw materials for batteries are imported, affecting the environmental impact due to transportation emissions.\n - Recycling facilities are developing, but the infrastructure is not yet widespread.\n\n3. **End-of-Life Processing:**\n - The U.S. has established recycling programs for traditional vehicles, but EV battery recycling is still emerging, which can lead to higher environmental impacts if not managed properly.\n\n### Europe\n\n1. **Electricity Grid Composition:**\n - Europe has a relatively clean grid, with a significant share of renewable energy sources like wind, hydro, and solar, especially in countries like Germany and Denmark.\n - This results in a lower carbon footprint for EVs compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n2. **Raw Materials:**\n - Europe relies heavily on imports for battery materials, but there is a strong focus on developing sustainable supply chains and recycling initiatives.\n - The European Union has stringent regulations on sourcing and recycling, which can mitigate some environmental impacts.\n\n3. **End-of-Life Processing:**\n - Europe has advanced recycling capabilities and strict regulations for vehicle disposal, including EV batteries, which helps reduce the environmental impact.\n\n### China\n\n1. **Electricity Grid Composition:**\n - China's grid is heavily reliant on coal, although there is a growing investment in renewables.\n - The high coal dependency means that the carbon footprint of EVs can be higher compared to regions with cleaner grids, although still generally lower than gasoline vehicles due to efficiency gains.\n\n2. **Raw Materials:**\n - China is a major producer of lithium and other battery materials, reducing transportation emissions and environmental impact associated with imports.\n - Local sourcing helps lower the overall environmental footprint of EV production.\n\n3. **End-of-Life Processing:**\n - China is rapidly developing its recycling infrastructure, with government policies encouraging the recycling of EV batteries.\n - However, the current capabilities may not fully mitigate the environmental impacts yet.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles vary significantly by region due to differences in electricity grid composition, raw material sourcing, and end-of-life processing capabilities. In regions with cleaner electricity grids and advanced recycling infrastructure, such as Europe, EVs tend to have a significantly lower environmental impact than gasoline vehicles. In contrast, regions with coal-dependent grids, like parts of China, may see less pronounced benefits, although EVs generally still offer some environmental advantages. The U.S. presents a mixed scenario, with regional differences playing a crucial role in determining the overall environmental benefits of EVs.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation to end-of-life disposal. This method provides a comprehensive view of the overall environmental footprint, including CO", + "I can answer by conducting a geographically-tailored life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines how the environmental impacts of electric and traditional gasoline vehicles vary depending on the region. This approach would consider regional differences in electricity grid composition for EV charging, local availability of raw materials, and regional end-of-life processing capabilities, offering insights into how location influences the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation to end-of-life disposal. This method provides a comprehensive view of the overall environmental footprint, including CO", + "I can answer by analyzing the operational impact differences between electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach focuses on the emissions and environmental effects during the vehicle's use phase, particularly comparing the greenhouse gas emissions and energy efficiency. It also considers the source of electricity used to charge EVs, as this can significantly influence their environmental impact. This method provides insights into the direct environmental benefits or drawbacks of each vehicle type during their active use." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation to end-of-life disposal. This method provides a comprehensive view of the overall environmental footprint, including CO" + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing the life cycle assessment (LCA) specifically on the manufacturing phase of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would delve deeply into the extraction and processing of raw materials, such as lithium for EV batteries and steel for gasoline engines, considering energy usage, emissions, and waste generated during this stage to reveal which type of vehicle has a more sustainable production process.", + "I can answer by conducting a geographically-tailored life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines how the environmental impacts of electric and traditional gasoline vehicles vary depending on the region. This approach would consider regional differences in electricity grid composition for EV charging, local availability of raw materials, and regional end-of-life processing capabilities, offering insights into how location influences the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a geographically-tailored life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines how the environmental impacts of electric and traditional gasoline vehicles vary depending on the region. This approach would consider regional differences in electricity grid composition for EV charging, local availability of raw materials, and regional end-of-life processing capabilities, offering insights into how location influences the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:14:55.057551", + "similarity_score": 0.7, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 11 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_12.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_12.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..def1e980e220009ed1c3c9210dab4c30f3581091 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_12.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "11e76d50-bc2e-42e9-8d28-d68f76ef4719", + "ibfs_id": "b6d36c94-b9d0-4490-9cdd-2215801e9973", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) are often heralded as a more environmentally-friendly alternative to traditional gasoline vehicles, and for good reasons. However, the environmental impacts of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles are nuanced and depend on several factors, including the source of electricity, battery production, and overall lifecycle emissions.\n\n1. **Emissions During Operation**: \n EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas. This is a stark contrast to gasoline vehicles, which emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulates that contribute to air pollution and climate change. The reduction in local air pollutants from EVs can lead to improved public health outcomes and a decrease in smog and respiratory problems.\n\n2. **Energy Source for Electricity**:\n The environmental benefits of EVs largely depend on the energy mix used to generate electricity. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the overall emissions from EVs can be significantly lower than gasoline vehicles. However, if the electricity is primarily generated from coal or other fossil fuels, the environmental advantage diminishes, although EVs are still generally cleaner overall due to higher efficiency in energy use.\n\n3. **Lifecycle Emissions**:\n When considering the full lifecycle, including manufacturing, operation, and disposal, EVs typically have a lower carbon footprint than gasoline vehicles. The production of EVs, particularly the batteries, is energy-intensive and can result in higher upfront emissions. However, these emissions are often offset by the efficiency and cleaner operation of EVs over their lifespan.\n\n4. **Battery Production and Recycling**:\n The production of lithium-ion batteries used in EVs involves mining lithium, cobalt, and other metals, which can have significant environmental impacts, such as habitat destruction and water pollution. Nonetheless, advancements in battery technology and recycling processes are helping to mitigate these impacts. Effective recycling can recover valuable materials and reduce the demand for new raw materials.\n\n5. **Resource Use and Sustainability**:\n As EV adoption grows, there is an increasing focus on sustainable sourcing of materials and improving battery technologies to reduce reliance on scarce resources. Efforts are underway to develop more sustainable battery chemistries and to enhance the efficiency of resource use.\n\n6. **Long-Term Environmental Benefits**:\n Over the long term, the transition to EVs is expected to significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions and reliance on fossil fuels, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener. This shift is essential for meeting global climate targets and reducing the impacts of climate change.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs are not without environmental challenges, they offer a more sustainable alternative to gasoline vehicles, particularly as the energy grid becomes cleaner and battery technologies improve. The shift to electric mobility is a key component of reducing transportation-related emissions and achieving a more sustainable future.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a lifecycle analysis that examines each stage of their lifecycle: extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal.\n\n### 1. Extraction of Raw Materials\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Rare Earth Elements:** EVs often use rare earth elements in their motors, which are also environmentally intensive to extract.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Oil Extraction:** The primary raw material is crude oil, which must be extracted, transported, and refined. Oil extraction can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and significant greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Metals and Plastics:** Gasoline vehicles also require steel, aluminum, and plastics, which involve mining and refining processes that have environmental impacts.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Material Processing:** The processing of battery materials contributes to air and water pollution.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Traditional Manufacturing:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is well-established and generally less energy-intensive than EVs, but still involves significant emissions from steel and aluminum production.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during usage depends on the electricity source. If powered by renewable energy, EVs have a much lower carbon footprint. However, if the electricity comes from coal or natural gas, the benefits are reduced.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Combustion Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Improvements in fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, but gasoline vehicles inherently produce more emissions than EVs during operation.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries pose environmental challenges. While recycling can recover valuable materials, improper disposal can lead to toxic pollution.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, the rest of the EV can be recycled, but the process is complicated by the presence of electronic components.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are largely recyclable, with established systems for recycling metals and other materials.\n- **Waste Oil and Fluids:** Disposal of engine oil and other fluids can pose environmental risks if not managed properly.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nElectric vehicles generally offer environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during the usage phase. However, they also present unique environmental challenges, especially in the extraction of raw materials and battery disposal. The overall environmental impact of EVs can be significantly reduced if the electricity used for charging comes from renewable sources and if effective recycling systems for batteries are developed. On the other hand, gasoline vehicles have a more straightforward lifecycle but contribute more directly to air pollution and climate change during their operational phase.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles at each stage of their lifecycle. This includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. This approach will help highlight the various environmental costs associated with both types of vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles at each stage of their lifecycle. This includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. This approach will help highlight the various environmental costs associated with both types of vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining the emissions and pollutants associated with both vehicle types. This involves comparing the tailpipe emissions of traditional gasoline vehicles with the emissions generated from electricity production for EVs, considering different energy sources like coal, natural gas, and renewables. This will provide insight into the air quality impacts and greenhouse gas contributions from each vehicle.", + "I can answer by analyzing the resource and energy consumption required to produce electric and gasoline vehicles. This includes a focus on the mining and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries, and the energy-intensive processes involved in refining gasoline. This approach will consider the environmental footprint of resource extraction and manufacturing processes.", + "I can answer by evaluating the potential for each vehicle type to support a sustainable transportation system in the future. This involves looking at the scalability of electric vehicle infrastructure, such as charging stations and grid capacity, versus the sustainability challenges faced by continued reliance on fossil fuels. This future-oriented analysis will consider long-term environmental resilience and adaptability." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles at each stage of their lifecycle. This includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. This approach will help highlight the various environmental costs associated with both types of vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:15:10.194143", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 12 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_13.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_13.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..37e44849b848b15c7110bc4e79864e39f4af74d1 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_13.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "ca79664e-1541-4288-826f-a5724923a301", + "ibfs_id": "3e2382bb-81e5-44c7-a5ef-2aa97030f528", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles impact the environment in distinct ways, and understanding these differences is crucial for assessing their overall sustainability and environmental footprint.\n\n**1. Emissions During Use:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which is a significant advantage over gasoline vehicles. This means they do not emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), or particulate matter during operation, contributing to improved air quality, especially in urban areas.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** In contrast, traditional gasoline vehicles emit significant amounts of CO2, a greenhouse gas that contributes to climate change, along with NOx and particulates that can harm human health and the environment.\n\n**2. Energy Source and Lifecycle Emissions:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** The environmental impact of EVs largely depends on the energy mix used for electricity generation. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the overall emissions are much lower compared to when electricity is generated from fossil fuels. However, even with a less green energy mix, EVs often have a smaller carbon footprint over their entire lifecycle compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The emissions from gasoline vehicles are directly linked to fossil fuel combustion. This not only contributes to air pollution but also involves significant CO2 emissions during fuel extraction, refining, and transportation.\n\n**3. Manufacturing and Raw Materials:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve mining for lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other materials. This mining process can have significant environmental and social impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and ethical concerns regarding labor practices. However, advances in battery recycling and second-life applications are helping mitigate these impacts.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** While gasoline vehicles do not require large batteries, their production still involves substantial resource extraction and energy use, but the environmental impacts in terms of raw material extraction are generally less compared to the battery production for EVs.\n\n**4. End-of-Life Considerations:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** Battery disposal and recycling are critical issues. Developing effective recycling technology is essential to minimize toxic waste and recover valuable materials, thereby reducing the environmental impact of EVs.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles also require proper disposal and recycling, but they do not have the same battery-specific issues as EVs. However, the engines and other components still need to be managed to prevent environmental harm.\n\n**5. Overall Environmental Impact:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** Generally, EVs are considered to have a lower environmental impact over their lifecycle compared to gasoline vehicles, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery technology improves.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles remain a significant source of greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, and their environmental impact is more challenging to mitigate given the reliance on fossil fuels.\n\nIn conclusion, while both EVs and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts, EVs offer a pathway to significantly reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions, particularly as renewable energy sources become more prevalent and battery technologies advance. Policymakers, industry stakeholders, and consumers are increasingly recognizing these advantages, driving the global shift towards electrification in transportation.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we can analyze their lifecycle emissions, which encompass the manufacturing, operation, and disposal stages. This comprehensive approach provides a clearer picture of the total carbon footprint associated with each type of vehicle.\n\n### 1. Manufacturing Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** The production of EVs, particularly the lithium-ion batteries, is energy-intensive and contributes significantly to the initial carbon footprint. The extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel are resource-intensive and can have substantial environmental impacts.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** The assembly of EVs is similar to that of gasoline vehicles, but the additional complexity of battery integration can increase emissions slightly.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Fuel System Production:** Manufacturing internal combustion engines and fuel systems also involves significant emissions, but generally less than the battery production for EVs.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to EVs, the assembly process contributes to the carbon footprint, but without the added impact of battery production.\n\n### 2. Operation Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Electricity Generation:** The emissions during the operation of EVs depend heavily on the energy mix used to generate electricity. In regions where coal is a major energy source, the operational emissions can be higher. However, as the grid becomes greener with more renewable energy, the operational emissions of EVs decrease significantly.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid into vehicle movement.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Combustion:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe. These emissions are consistent regardless of the energy grid and are a significant source of greenhouse gases.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** While improvements in fuel efficiency have been made, gasoline vehicles are inherently less efficient than EVs due to energy losses in combustion.\n\n### 3. Disposal Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries present environmental challenges. However, advancements in recycling technologies are improving the recovery of valuable materials, reducing the environmental impact.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, the recycling of the vehicle body and components is standard, though the presence of batteries adds complexity.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** The recycling process is well-established, with most materials being recoverable. However, the environmental impact of disposing of engine components and fluids is notable.\n\n### Lifecycle Emissions Comparison\n\nSeveral studies have conducted lifecycle assessments (LCAs) to compare the total carbon footprint of EVs and gasoline vehicles. These studies generally find that:\n\n- **Initial Emissions:** EVs have higher emissions during the manufacturing stage, primarily due to battery production.\n- **Operational Emissions:** EVs typically have lower emissions during the operational stage, especially as the grid becomes cleaner.\n- **Overall Lifecycle Emissions:** Over the vehicle's lifetime, EVs tend to have lower total emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, particularly in regions with a significant share of renewable energy in the electricity mix.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs have a higher initial carbon footprint due to battery production, their lower operational emissions often result in a smaller overall carbon footprint over their lifecycle compared to traditional gasoline vehicles. This advantage is expected to grow as battery technologies improve and the electricity grid becomes increasingly powered by renewable sources.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by comparing the lifecycle emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles, which includes manufacturing, operation, and disposal stages. This approach will involve analyzing studies that assess the total carbon footprint from the production of the vehicles, the extraction and processing of raw materials, the emissions during vehicle use, and the environmental costs of vehicle disposal or recycling." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by comparing the lifecycle emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles, which includes manufacturing, operation, and disposal stages. This approach will involve analyzing studies that assess the total carbon footprint from the production of the vehicles, the extraction and processing of raw materials, the emissions during vehicle use, and the environmental costs of vehicle disposal or recycling.", + "I can answer by examining the energy sources used to power electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impact of generating electricity (considering coal, natural gas, renewables, etc.) compared to the extraction, refining, and burning of gasoline. This comparison can highlight how the source of electricity influences the overall environmental benefits of electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by considering the ecological impact of resource extraction for both types of vehicles. For electric vehicles, this means focusing on the mining of lithium, cobalt, and other materials used in batteries, while for gasoline vehicles, it involves looking at the extraction and refining of crude oil. Evaluating the effects of these processes on ecosystems, biodiversity, and human communities can offer insights into their environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by exploring policy and infrastructure impacts, such as government incentives for electric vehicles, the development of charging infrastructure, and the role of public transportation integration. This approach assesses how these factors influence the environmental footprint of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles, including potential reductions in emissions due to shifts in transportation habits and energy grid improvements." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by comparing the lifecycle emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles, which includes manufacturing, operation, and disposal stages. This approach will involve analyzing studies that assess the total carbon footprint from the production of the vehicles, the extraction and processing of raw materials, the emissions during vehicle use, and the environmental costs of vehicle disposal or recycling." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:15:29.255223", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 13 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_14.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_14.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..84fe9f2fcbbb18bd46367a812c9f528456a5badf --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_14.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "23d4bc09-b1f9-4ffe-afc0-40525c1c502a", + "ibfs_id": "7f60bb0c-59d6-45ea-8191-9aba2e6de262", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles each have distinct environmental impacts that can be evaluated across various stages of their lifecycle, from production to end-of-life. Here is a detailed comparison:\n\n1. **Production Impact**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The production of EVs, particularly the manufacturing of lithium-ion batteries, tends to have a higher environmental footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. Mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel\u2014key components of these batteries\u2014can lead to habitat destruction, water pollution, and significant energy consumption. However, as technology advances, the efficiency of battery production is improving, and efforts are being made to recycle battery materials to mitigate these impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The production of traditional vehicles is less energy-intensive due to the mature nature of the industry, but it still involves considerable resource extraction and energy use. The environmental impact is spread more evenly across the vehicle's lifecycle compared to EVs, which have a higher initial production impact.\n\n2. **Operational Impact**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: During operation, EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas. The overall environmental benefit depends on the electricity source used to charge them. If the electricity comes from renewable sources, the emissions are greatly reduced. However, if the grid is heavily reliant on fossil fuels, this advantage diminishes. As the global energy grid becomes cleaner, the operational benefits of EVs will continue to increase.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Traditional vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants that contribute to air pollution and climate change. These emissions are a significant environmental concern, especially in densely populated regions.\n\n3. **Lifecycle Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: Despite the higher initial production emissions, studies show that EVs typically have a lower overall carbon footprint over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles, especially when charged from a clean energy grid. The reduction in emissions during the operational phase helps offset the initial production impact.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Over their lifecycle, these vehicles contribute significantly to greenhouse gas emissions, primarily due to the combustion of fossil fuels during operation. This impact is consistent regardless of the region, as long as they rely on gasoline.\n\n4. **End-of-Life Impact**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: Battery disposal and recycling are critical issues. Improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination. However, advancements in battery recycling technologies are promising, aiming to recover valuable materials and reduce waste.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles have well-established recycling processes for metals and other components, though the disposal of certain materials can still pose environmental challenges.\n\n5. **Resource Dependency**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The dependency on specific materials for batteries (like lithium, cobalt, and nickel) can lead to geopolitical and ethical concerns, including labor practices in mining operations. However, there is a growing focus on developing alternative battery technologies that use more abundant and sustainable resources.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The reliance on petroleum not only has environmental implications but also involves geopolitical tensions and price volatility. Oil extraction and transportation can lead to spills and environmental degradation.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles have a higher environmental impact during the production phase, they generally offer significant advantages in terms of reduced emissions and air pollution during their operational life, especially as energy grids transition to renewable sources. The long-term environmental benefits of EVs make them a crucial component of global strategies to combat climate change and reduce urban pollution. As technology and infrastructure continue to improve, the environmental impacts of EVs are expected to further decline, enhancing their sustainability compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through a component-specific life cycle assessment (LCA), we will focus on key components: the battery in EVs and the internal combustion engine in gasoline vehicles. This analysis will consider the production, use, and disposal stages of these components.\n\n### Electric Vehicles: Battery\n\n#### Production Stage\n- **Materials Extraction and Processing**: The production of EV batteries, particularly lithium-ion batteries, involves the extraction and processing of raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. These processes are energy-intensive and can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high carbon emissions due to mining activities.\n- **Manufacturing**: Battery manufacturing requires substantial energy, often sourced from fossil fuels, contributing to greenhouse gas emissions. The production of cathodes, anodes, and electrolytes involves chemical processes that can release pollutants.\n\n#### Use Stage\n- **Energy Efficiency**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. They convert a higher percentage of electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels. This efficiency translates into lower operational emissions, especially when charged using renewable energy sources.\n- **Emissions**: During use, EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, reducing urban air pollution and associated health impacts.\n\n#### Disposal Stage\n- **Recycling and Disposal**: End-of-life battery management is crucial. Recycling can recover valuable materials, reducing the need for new raw material extraction. However, improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination due to hazardous materials in batteries.\n\n### Gasoline Vehicles: Internal Combustion Engine\n\n#### Production Stage\n- **Materials and Manufacturing**: The production of internal combustion engines involves the extraction and processing of metals like steel and aluminum. The manufacturing process is energy-intensive and contributes to greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Complexity and Components**: Engines are complex with many moving parts, requiring precision manufacturing and assembly, which further increases energy use and emissions.\n\n#### Use Stage\n- **Fuel Consumption**: Gasoline vehicles rely on fossil fuels, which release carbon dioxide and other pollutants during combustion. This contributes significantly to greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution.\n- **Efficiency**: Internal combustion engines are less efficient compared to electric motors, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n\n#### Disposal Stage\n- **End-of-Life Management**: Engines and associated components can be recycled, but the process is energy-intensive. Metals can be recovered, but other materials may end up in landfills.\n\n### Comparative Summary\n\n- **Production**: EV batteries have a higher initial environmental impact due to material extraction and energy-intensive manufacturing. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling can mitigate these impacts over time.\n- **Use**: EVs offer significant environmental benefits during the use phase, with higher energy efficiency and zero tailpipe emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, which emit greenhouse gases and pollutants.\n- **Disposal**: Both EV batteries and gasoline engines require careful end-of-life management to minimize environmental impacts. Recycling processes are improving, particularly for EV batteries, which can reduce the need for new raw materials.\n\nOverall, while the production of EV batteries currently has a higher environmental footprint than gasoline engines, the benefits during the use phase and potential for recycling make EVs a more sustainable choice in the long term, especially as the energy grid becomes greener.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the environmental impact of each vehicle type from production through disposal, considering factors such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle use phase, and end-of-life recycling or disposal.", + "I can answer by conducting a component-specific life cycle assessment (LCA) that isolates the environmental impacts of key vehicle components, such as batteries in electric vehicles and engines in gasoline vehicles. This approach would delve into the specific environmental footprints of these components, including their production, use, and disposal stages, to understand their individual contributions to the overall vehicle impact." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the environmental impact of each vehicle type from production through disposal, considering factors such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle use phase, and end-of-life recycling or disposal.", + "I can answer by comparing the greenhouse gas emissions of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their operational phase. This strategy would focus on the emissions produced by each vehicle type while they are being driven, including the emissions from electricity generation for EVs and the combustion of gasoline for traditional vehicles.", + "I can answer by analyzing the supply chain and resource dependencies of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts related to mining and processing raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries versus those related to oil extraction and refinement for gasoline.", + "I can answer by reviewing and synthesizing existing scientific literature and reports from environmental organizations on the topic. This method would involve gathering data from various studies and reports to provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts associated with both vehicle types, highlighting areas of consensus and debate within the research community." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the environmental impact of each vehicle type from production through disposal, considering factors such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle use phase, and end-of-life recycling or disposal." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) that emphasizes the differences in energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions between electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would detail the energy used and emissions produced at each life cycle stage, from manufacturing and operational energy consumption to final disposal, providing specific insights into how each stage contributes to the overall environmental impact.", + "I can answer by performing a regional life cycle assessment (LCA) that considers the geographical variations in electricity generation sources and raw material availability. This approach would highlight how the environmental impacts of electric vehicles might differ significantly depending on the region, due to varying energy grids, local manufacturing practices, and recycling capabilities, compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by conducting a component-specific life cycle assessment (LCA) that isolates the environmental impacts of key vehicle components, such as batteries in electric vehicles and engines in gasoline vehicles. This approach would delve into the specific environmental footprints of these components, including their production, use, and disposal stages, to understand their individual contributions to the overall vehicle impact.", + "I can answer by integrating a temporal life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles change over time. This approach would assess factors such as potential improvements in battery technology, changes in electricity generation, and advancements in fuel efficiency, projecting how these dynamic elements could alter the comparative environmental impacts of the two vehicle types over the next decades." + ], + "choice_idx": 2, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a component-specific life cycle assessment (LCA) that isolates the environmental impacts of key vehicle components, such as batteries in electric vehicles and engines in gasoline vehicles. This approach would delve into the specific environmental footprints of these components, including their production, use, and disposal stages, to understand their individual contributions to the overall vehicle impact." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:15:53.853918", + "similarity_score": 0.8, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 14 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_15.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_15.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..34e0493655cb2e11534792c007547040bdb18b6a --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_15.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "4300457a-91ea-45de-a95d-5d425507e6a6", + "ibfs_id": "73df6d95-3eff-47bc-9dc0-4c8dcb26c6e9", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) are often touted as a more environmentally friendly alternative to traditional gasoline vehicles, and for good reason. However, their environmental impacts are multifaceted and can vary depending on several factors, including the source of the electricity used to charge them and the materials used in their batteries.\n\n**1. Emissions During Use:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollutants like nitrogen oxides and particulate matter in urban areas. This can lead to improved air quality and public health benefits.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** In contrast, traditional gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2) and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n\n**2. Lifecycle Emissions:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The total environmental impact of EVs includes emissions from electricity generation and battery production. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind or solar, the overall emissions are much lower. However, if the grid relies heavily on fossil fuels, the environmental benefits are reduced.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Gasoline vehicles produce emissions throughout their lifecycle, from fuel extraction, refining, and transportation, to combustion. These emissions are generally higher than those associated with EVs, especially as the grid becomes cleaner.\n\n**3. Battery Production and Disposal:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The production of lithium-ion batteries used in EVs can have significant environmental impacts, including resource extraction, water usage, and habitat disruption. The mining of lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which are crucial for these batteries, can lead to environmental degradation and human rights concerns. However, advances in recycling technologies and battery chemistry are helping to mitigate these impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** While gasoline vehicles do not rely on large batteries, the environmental costs of oil extraction and refining are substantial, including risks of oil spills and habitat destruction.\n\n**4. Energy Efficiency:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. They convert a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels, whereas internal combustion engines waste a significant portion of energy as heat.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Even the most advanced gasoline engines are less efficient, leading to higher fuel consumption and more emissions per mile.\n\n**5. Infrastructure and Long-Term Impacts:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The shift to EVs requires substantial changes to infrastructure, including charging stations and grid upgrades. In the long term, widespread adoption of EVs can support a transition to renewable energy and a more sustainable transportation system.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Continued reliance on gasoline vehicles perpetuates the demand for fossil fuels and the infrastructure that supports them, which is less sustainable in the context of climate change goals.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles offer significant environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, especially in terms of emissions during use, their overall impact depends on how they are manufactured, the source of their electricity, and how effectively their batteries are recycled. As technology advances and the electricity grid becomes greener, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to increase further.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles using a longitudinal life cycle analysis (LCA), we need to consider the entire lifecycle of each vehicle type, from production through use to end-of-life, while factoring in technological advancements, changes in energy sources, and improvements in recycling methods over time.\n\n### Production Phase\n\n1. **Material Extraction and Manufacturing:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, involves significant environmental impacts due to the extraction and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. However, advancements in battery technology, such as the development of solid-state batteries and alternative chemistries, are expected to reduce these impacts over time by increasing energy density and reducing reliance on scarce materials.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** The manufacturing of gasoline vehicles involves less intensive material extraction compared to EVs, but the production of internal combustion engines (ICEs) and associated components still contributes to environmental impacts. Over time, improvements in manufacturing efficiency and material recycling can mitigate some of these impacts.\n\n### Use Phase\n\n2. **Energy Consumption and Emissions:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The environmental impact during the use phase of EVs is largely dependent on the electricity mix used for charging. As the grid becomes greener with increased integration of renewable energy sources like wind and solar, the carbon footprint of EVs during their use phase is expected to decrease significantly. Technological advancements in battery efficiency and vehicle design also contribute to reduced energy consumption per mile.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Gasoline vehicles emit greenhouse gases and pollutants directly from the tailpipe. While advancements in engine technology and fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, the inherent reliance on fossil fuels limits the potential for significant long-term reductions in environmental impact.\n\n### End-of-Life Phase\n\n3. **Recycling and Disposal:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The recycling of EV batteries is a critical factor in their environmental impact. Current recycling methods are improving, with advancements in recovering valuable materials and reducing waste. Future developments in battery design that facilitate easier recycling and the establishment of efficient recycling infrastructure are expected to further mitigate environmental impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** The recycling of gasoline vehicles is relatively well-established, with many components being recyclable. However, the disposal of engine oils and other fluids presents environmental challenges. Improvements in vehicle design for easier disassembly and recycling can enhance sustainability.\n\n### Longitudinal Considerations\n\n- **Technological Advancements:** Over time, both EVs and gasoline vehicles benefit from technological improvements. For EVs, this includes better battery technologies, more efficient electric drivetrains, and lighter materials. For gasoline vehicles, advancements focus on increasing fuel efficiency and reducing emissions.\n- **Energy Source Changes:** The shift towards renewable energy sources significantly benefits EVs, as their environmental impact during the use phase is closely tied to the electricity grid's carbon intensity. Gasoline vehicles remain dependent on fossil fuels, limiting their potential for similar improvements.\n- **Recycling Improvements:** As recycling technologies advance, both vehicle types can see reduced environmental impacts at the end of their lifecycle. However, the complexity of EV battery recycling presents unique challenges and opportunities for innovation.\n\nIn conclusion, while both electric and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts, the longitudinal life cycle analysis suggests that EVs have the potential for greater reductions in environmental impact over time due to technological advancements, cleaner energy sources, and improved recycling methods. Gasoline vehicles, constrained by their reliance on fossil fuels, face more significant challenges in achieving similar long-term environmental benefits.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive life cycle analysis (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal. By comparing the LCAs, I can provide a detailed overview of how each vehicle type impacts the environment throughout its entire lifespan.", + "I can answer by integrating a longitudinal life cycle analysis (LCA) that examines how the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles evolve over time. This involves considering technological advancements, changes in energy sources, and improvements in recycling methods, providing a dynamic view of how each vehicle type's environmental impacts may change in the future." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive life cycle analysis (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal. By comparing the LCAs, I can provide a detailed overview of how each vehicle type impacts the environment throughout its entire lifespan.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions comparison during the usage phase of the vehicles. This involves analyzing the greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion compared to the emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs, considering the energy mix of different regions. This approach would highlight the environmental impact while the vehicles are in use.", + "I can answer by examining the resource consumption and waste generation associated with each vehicle type. This includes assessing the demand for rare earth metals in EV batteries and their recyclability, versus the oil extraction and refining processes required for gasoline vehicles. By comparing the sustainability of resource usage, I can provide insights into the broader environmental implications.", + "I can answer by exploring the potential impact on ecosystems and local environments. This could involve looking at the land use changes, habitat disruption, and pollution resulting from mining activities for battery materials in EVs, compared to the impact of oil drilling and infrastructure development for gasoline vehicles. This strategy would provide an ecological perspective on the environmental impacts of both vehicle types." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive life cycle analysis (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal. By comparing the LCAs, I can provide a detailed overview of how each vehicle type impacts the environment throughout its entire lifespan." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a specific LCA phase for both electric and gasoline vehicles, such as the manufacturing process. In this approach, I will conduct a detailed comparison of the environmental impacts related specifically to the production of EV batteries versus gasoline engines. This targeted analysis will highlight the differences in resource use and emissions during the manufacturing stage.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional life cycle analysis (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles, taking into account the specific energy sources and infrastructure available in different geographic areas. This approach will assess how the environmental impacts vary depending on whether the electricity for EVs is generated from renewable sources or fossil fuels, and how this compares to regional gasoline production and consumption.", + "I can answer by undertaking a component-specific life cycle analysis (LCA), where I assess and compare the environmental impacts of individual components such as the battery pack for EVs and the internal combustion engine for gasoline vehicles. This granular approach will provide insights into which specific parts contribute most to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type throughout their lifecycle.", + "I can answer by integrating a longitudinal life cycle analysis (LCA) that examines how the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles evolve over time. This involves considering technological advancements, changes in energy sources, and improvements in recycling methods, providing a dynamic view of how each vehicle type's environmental impacts may change in the future." + ], + "choice_idx": 3, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by integrating a longitudinal life cycle analysis (LCA) that examines how the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles evolve over time. This involves considering technological advancements, changes in energy sources, and improvements in recycling methods, providing a dynamic view of how each vehicle type's environmental impacts may change in the future." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:16:09.338244", + "similarity_score": 0.8, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 15 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_2.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_2.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..673a5b36a960e5181657913738d3c3c15d4b0cc2 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_2.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "fdb54149-1cf7-4023-b8e5-dcc46f7029a9", + "ibfs_id": "8474042e-348a-4a4e-b7a6-6c6542757b7e", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) are often touted as a more environmentally friendly alternative to traditional gasoline vehicles. The environmental impacts of each can be examined across several dimensions, including emissions, resource extraction, manufacturing, and end-of-life processes.\n\n**1. Emissions:**\n\n- **Operational Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas. This is a stark contrast to gasoline vehicles, which emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n \n- **Lifecycle Emissions:** While EVs are cleaner during operation, their overall environmental impact also depends on the source of electricity used to charge them. In regions where the grid relies heavily on coal or other fossil fuels, the carbon footprint of EVs can be higher. However, as the grid becomes greener, the lifecycle emissions of EVs decrease significantly.\n\n**2. Resource Extraction and Manufacturing:**\n\n- **Materials and Batteries:** EVs require lithium, cobalt, and other rare earth elements for their batteries, which can have significant environmental and ethical implications due to mining practices. The extraction processes can lead to habitat destruction, water pollution, and human rights concerns. However, the automotive industry is increasingly focusing on sustainable sourcing and recycling initiatives.\n\n- **Manufacturing Emissions:** The production of EVs, particularly their batteries, tends to be more energy-intensive compared to traditional vehicles, leading to higher initial emissions. However, these emissions are offset over the vehicle's lifespan due to their lower operational emissions.\n\n**3. Energy Efficiency:**\n\n- EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. They convert a higher percentage of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, whereas internal combustion engines lose a significant amount of energy as heat.\n\n**4. End-of-Life and Recycling:**\n\n- **Recycling Batteries:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries remain a challenge, but advances are being made in battery recycling technologies to recover and reuse valuable materials, thus reducing the environmental impact.\n\n- **Decommissioning:** Both EVs and gasoline vehicles face environmental impacts at the end of their life cycles. However, the recycling of metal and other components is more established for traditional vehicles.\n\n**5. Broader Environmental Benefits:**\n\n- **Noise Pollution:** EVs operate more quietly than gasoline vehicles, contributing to reduced noise pollution, particularly in urban areas.\n\n- **Contribution to Renewable Energy Transition:** As the integration of renewable energy sources into the grid increases, EVs can play a crucial role in energy storage and management, further supporting the transition to a low-carbon future.\n\nOverall, while EVs have certain environmental challenges, particularly related to battery production and resource extraction, they offer significant advantages in reducing emissions and improving air quality. As technology advances and renewable energy becomes more prevalent, the environmental benefits of EVs are expected to increase, making them a critical component of sustainable transportation strategies.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a localized lifecycle analysis comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to consider several factors that vary by region: the energy mix of the local electricity grid, the availability and efficiency of recycling infrastructure, and the typical driving conditions and distances. Here, we will examine three distinct regions: the United States, Germany, and China, each with different energy profiles and recycling capabilities.\n\n### United States\n\n**Energy Mix:**\n- The U.S. electricity grid is diverse, with significant contributions from natural gas, coal, nuclear, and renewables (wind, solar, hydro).\n- The carbon intensity of electricity varies by state. For example, California has a higher proportion of renewable energy compared to states like West Virginia, which relies heavily on coal.\n\n**Lifecycle Analysis:**\n- **Production:** EVs generally have higher emissions during production due to battery manufacturing. However, this is offset over time by lower operational emissions.\n- **Use Phase:** In states with cleaner grids (e.g., California), EVs have significantly lower emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. In coal-reliant states, the benefits are reduced but still present.\n- **End-of-Life:** The U.S. has a developing infrastructure for battery recycling, which is crucial for minimizing the environmental impact of EVs.\n\n### Germany\n\n**Energy Mix:**\n- Germany has made significant strides in renewable energy, with wind and solar playing a major role, although coal and natural gas are still part of the mix.\n- The Energiewende policy aims to further reduce reliance on fossil fuels.\n\n**Lifecycle Analysis:**\n- **Production:** Similar to the U.S., the initial production of EVs is more carbon-intensive due to battery manufacturing.\n- **Use Phase:** Due to a relatively clean grid, EVs in Germany generally have a lower carbon footprint during the use phase compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **End-of-Life:** Germany has robust recycling programs, including for EV batteries, which helps mitigate environmental impacts.\n\n### China\n\n**Energy Mix:**\n- China's electricity grid is heavily reliant on coal, although there is a growing investment in renewable energy.\n- The regional disparity is significant, with some areas having more access to cleaner energy sources.\n\n**Lifecycle Analysis:**\n- **Production:** China is a major producer of EVs, and the initial carbon footprint is high due to coal-based electricity used in manufacturing.\n- **Use Phase:** In regions with cleaner energy, such as those with hydroelectric power, EVs perform better environmentally. However, in coal-dominated areas, the benefits are less pronounced.\n- **End-of-Life:** China is rapidly developing its recycling infrastructure, but it still lags behind Western countries in terms of efficiency and coverage.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe environmental impact of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles varies significantly by region due to differences in energy sources and recycling infrastructure. In regions with a cleaner energy mix and robust recycling systems, such as Germany and certain U.S. states, EVs offer substantial environmental benefits over gasoline vehicles. In contrast, in areas with a coal-heavy grid, like parts of China, the benefits are reduced, though still present. The development of recycling infrastructure and a shift towards renewable energy are critical to maximizing the environmental advantages of electric vehicles globally.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach involves evaluating factors such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By comparing these aspects, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of each vehicle type over their entire lifespans.", + "I can answer by conducting a localized lifecycle analysis that accounts for regional differences in energy sources and recycling infrastructure. This approach will compare the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles in different geographical areas, taking into consideration the local electricity grid's energy mix (e.g., coal vs. renewable energy) and the availability of recycling facilities for batteries and automotive components. By examining the lifecycle impacts in various regions, I can highlight how the environmental footprints of these vehicles can vary significantly based on location." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach involves evaluating factors such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By comparing these aspects, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of each vehicle type over their entire lifespans.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both vehicle types, specifically analyzing emissions and energy efficiency during their use. This approach includes evaluating the greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during combustion and comparing them to the emissions associated with electricity generation for electric vehicles, considering the energy mix of different regions. Additionally, I can analyze how advancements in renewable energy and battery technologies influence the overall environmental impact during the operational phase." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach involves evaluating factors such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By comparing these aspects, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of each vehicle type over their entire lifespans." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a detailed lifecycle assessment of the manufacturing phase, specifically analyzing the environmental impacts of producing batteries for electric vehicles compared to the engines of gasoline vehicles. This approach will delve into the sourcing and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries and compare these with the materials and energy required for internal combustion engines. By isolating the manufacturing phase, I can provide insights into the specific environmental challenges and benefits associated with each vehicle type's production.", + "I can answer by conducting a localized lifecycle analysis that accounts for regional differences in energy sources and recycling infrastructure. This approach will compare the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles in different geographical areas, taking into consideration the local electricity grid's energy mix (e.g., coal vs. renewable energy) and the availability of recycling facilities for batteries and automotive components. By examining the lifecycle impacts in various regions, I can highlight how the environmental footprints of these vehicles can vary significantly based on location." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a localized lifecycle analysis that accounts for regional differences in energy sources and recycling infrastructure. This approach will compare the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles in different geographical areas, taking into consideration the local electricity grid's energy mix (e.g., coal vs. renewable energy) and the availability of recycling facilities for batteries and automotive components. By examining the lifecycle impacts in various regions, I can highlight how the environmental footprints of these vehicles can vary significantly based on location." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:12:27.242514", + "similarity_score": 0.7, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 2 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_3.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_3.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c577a6ec01db6f0dcd67b7de61675905aabb363c --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_3.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "e7dfef36-6ad0-4692-b928-3b1e2811fc1f", + "ibfs_id": "f1af943d-adfe-4c1d-a4ba-b792c30321fd", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) are often touted as a more environmentally friendly alternative to traditional gasoline vehicles, and there are several aspects where they offer significant environmental benefits. However, they also present some challenges that need to be considered for a comprehensive understanding.\n\n1. **Emissions During Operation**: \n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which means they do not emit harmful pollutants such as nitrogen oxides, particulate matter, or carbon dioxide while being driven. This leads to improved air quality, especially in urban areas where vehicle emissions are a major contributor to pollution.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Traditional vehicles emit a significant amount of greenhouse gases (GHGs) and pollutants during operation. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change.\n\n2. **Energy Source and Production**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The environmental impact of EVs largely depends on the energy mix used to generate the electricity that powers them. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the overall emissions are much lower. However, in regions where coal or natural gas dominate the energy mix, the carbon footprint of electricity generation can be significant.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The production and refining of gasoline involve substantial energy use and emissions. Moreover, the extraction of oil can lead to environmental degradation, spills, and habitat disruption.\n\n3. **Manufacturing Impact**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The production of EVs, particularly their batteries, is energy-intensive and can result in considerable emissions. Mining for lithium, cobalt, and other materials used in batteries can have negative environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and pollution.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: While the manufacturing of conventional vehicles also involves emissions, they are generally less than those associated with EV batteries. However, the emissions from gasoline vehicle production are compounded by their operational emissions over their lifespan.\n\n4. **Lifecycle Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: Studies suggest that, over their entire lifecycle, EVs typically have lower total emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, even when considering battery production and electricity generation. This is because the higher emissions from manufacturing are offset by the lower operational emissions.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The lifecycle emissions of gasoline vehicles remain high due to the continuous emissions from fuel combustion.\n\n5. **End-of-Life Considerations**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The recycling and disposal of EV batteries pose environmental challenges. Advancements in battery recycling technology are critical to reducing these impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: Conventional vehicles also require recycling and disposal, but the environmental concerns are generally less pronounced compared to EV battery disposal.\n\nIn summary, while electric vehicles offer significant environmental benefits, particularly in terms of reducing air pollutants and greenhouse gas emissions during operation, their overall environmental impact is influenced by factors such as the energy source for electricity, battery production, and end-of-life management. Transitioning to cleaner energy sources and improving battery technologies and recycling processes are crucial steps in maximizing the environmental benefits of electric vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles during their use phase, we will conduct a life cycle analysis (LCA) focusing on energy consumption and emissions produced while the vehicles are in operation.\n\n### Electric Vehicles (EVs)\n\n1. **Energy Consumption:**\n - EVs are powered by electricity stored in batteries. The energy efficiency of EVs is generally higher than that of gasoline vehicles because electric motors convert a larger percentage of electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n - The efficiency of EVs can be measured in miles per kilowatt-hour (mi/kWh). On average, EVs achieve about 3 to 4 mi/kWh.\n\n2. **Emissions:**\n - The emissions from EVs during the use phase are primarily indirect and depend on the electricity generation mix used to charge the batteries.\n - If the electricity comes from renewable sources (e.g., wind, solar, hydro), the emissions are minimal. However, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels (e.g., coal, natural gas), the emissions can be significant.\n - On average, EVs produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions per mile compared to gasoline vehicles, even when charged from a grid with a substantial fossil fuel component. This is due to the higher efficiency of power plants compared to internal combustion engines and the potential for cleaner energy sources.\n\n### Gasoline Vehicles\n\n1. **Energy Consumption:**\n - Gasoline vehicles are powered by internal combustion engines that convert the chemical energy in gasoline into mechanical energy.\n - The energy efficiency of gasoline vehicles is typically lower than that of EVs. Fuel economy is often measured in miles per gallon (mpg). A typical gasoline vehicle might achieve around 25 to 30 mpg.\n\n2. **Emissions:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO), and particulate matter directly from the tailpipe as a result of burning gasoline.\n - The emissions are directly proportional to fuel consumption, with higher fuel consumption leading to higher emissions.\n - On average, gasoline vehicles emit more greenhouse gases per mile than EVs, primarily due to the combustion of fossil fuels in the engine.\n\n### Comparison\n\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** EVs generally produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions during the use phase compared to gasoline vehicles, especially when charged with electricity from low-carbon sources.\n- **Energy Efficiency:** EVs are more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to motion.\n- **Local Emissions:** EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, improving local air quality, whereas gasoline vehicles emit pollutants directly into the atmosphere.\n\nIn summary, during the use phase, electric vehicles tend to have a lower environmental impact in terms of greenhouse gas emissions and energy efficiency compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly when charged with electricity from renewable sources. However, the overall environmental benefits of EVs can vary significantly based on the electricity generation mix of the region where they are used.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the entire life cycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase, to disposal and recycling. I would compare factors such as energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource depletion at each stage to provide a comprehensive view of their environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis (LCA) focused on the use phase of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the environmental impacts related to the energy consumption and emissions produced while the vehicles are in operation. For EVs, this would include analyzing the electricity sources used for charging, while for gasoline vehicles, it would involve assessing the emissions from burning fuel. By comparing the operational impacts of both vehicle types, I can identify how they differ in terms of energy efficiency and greenhouse gas emissions throughout their usage life." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the entire life cycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase, to disposal and recycling. I would compare factors such as energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource depletion at each stage to provide a comprehensive view of their environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase comparison of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would specifically look at the emissions and energy consumption during the use of the vehicles. I would analyze the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles and compare them to the emissions associated with electricity production for EVs, considering different electricity grid mixes. This would highlight the direct environmental impacts during the vehicle's operational life." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the entire life cycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase, to disposal and recycling. I would compare factors such as energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource depletion at each stage to provide a comprehensive view of their environmental impacts." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis (LCA) that focuses specifically on the manufacturing phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts associated with the production processes, including the extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium for batteries, steel, and aluminum. It would also consider the energy and resources used in assembling the vehicles. By comparing the manufacturing impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles, I can provide insights into which type of vehicle has a greater environmental footprint during this critical phase.", + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis (LCA) focused on the use phase of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the environmental impacts related to the energy consumption and emissions produced while the vehicles are in operation. For EVs, this would include analyzing the electricity sources used for charging, while for gasoline vehicles, it would involve assessing the emissions from burning fuel. By comparing the operational impacts of both vehicle types, I can identify how they differ in terms of energy efficiency and greenhouse gas emissions throughout their usage life." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis (LCA) focused on the use phase of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve evaluating the environmental impacts related to the energy consumption and emissions produced while the vehicles are in operation. For EVs, this would include analyzing the electricity sources used for charging, while for gasoline vehicles, it would involve assessing the emissions from burning fuel. By comparing the operational impacts of both vehicle types, I can identify how they differ in terms of energy efficiency and greenhouse gas emissions throughout their usage life." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:12:31.658637", + "similarity_score": 0.8, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 3 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_4.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_4.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6435ef6eae2bef3543d8aa3be32da57b722dc521 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_4.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "0a20bae1-3f62-4587-ba53-e17c1be5a870", + "ibfs_id": "49792305-a0fa-4f26-a672-2868236c8be8", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) are often touted as a cleaner alternative to traditional gasoline vehicles, but it's essential to consider the environmental impacts throughout their entire lifecycle to get a complete picture.\n\n**Manufacturing Impact:**\nThe production of EVs, particularly the batteries, typically results in higher emissions compared to manufacturing traditional gasoline vehicles. The extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel used in EV batteries are energy-intensive and can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and pollution. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling processes are continually improving this aspect.\n\n**Operation Emissions:**\nOnce on the road, EVs have a clear advantage. They produce zero tailpipe emissions, meaning no carbon dioxide or harmful pollutants like nitrogen oxides and particulate matter are emitted during operation. This contributes to improved air quality, especially in urban areas. In contrast, gasoline vehicles emit significant amounts of greenhouse gases and pollutants that contribute to climate change and respiratory diseases.\n\n**Energy Source:**\nA critical factor in determining the environmental impact of EVs is the source of the electricity used to charge them. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the overall carbon footprint of EVs is substantially lower. Conversely, if the electricity comes primarily from coal or other fossil fuels, the environmental benefits are reduced but still generally better than traditional vehicles due to the higher efficiency of electric motors.\n\n**End-of-Life and Recycling:**\nEVs offer potential benefits in terms of recyclability. While the recycling of EV batteries is still developing, it presents opportunities for recovering valuable materials and reducing the need for new raw material extraction. Innovations are underway to improve battery recycling processes, making them more efficient and environmentally friendly. Traditional vehicles also have recyclable components, but the energy-intensive nature of fossil fuel production and the emissions from tailpipes are ongoing environmental concerns.\n\n**Long-Term Benefits:**\nOver their lifespan, EVs typically result in lower overall emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener. Their potential to integrate with renewable energy systems and advancements in technology promise to further reduce their environmental impact.\n\n**Conclusion:**\nWhile both electric and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts, EVs generally have a lower carbon footprint over their entire lifecycle. Their benefits are most pronounced when supported by clean energy grids and robust recycling programs. As technology and infrastructure improve, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to increase, making them a crucial component in the transition to a more sustainable transportation system.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will conduct a lifecycle analysis (LCA) that examines each stage: raw material extraction, manufacturing, use, and disposal.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Materials:** EVs require lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals for their batteries. Mining these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy use. Cobalt mining, in particular, has raised concerns over environmental degradation and human rights issues.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use aluminum and copper, which require energy-intensive extraction and processing.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fossil Fuels:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Metals and Plastics:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and plastics, which also involve energy-intensive extraction and processing.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** The production of lithium-ion batteries is energy-intensive and contributes significantly to the carbon footprint of EVs. Manufacturing processes involve high energy use and emissions.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** EVs generally have fewer moving parts than gasoline vehicles, which can reduce some manufacturing impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Transmission:** The manufacturing of internal combustion engines and transmissions is complex and energy-intensive.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to EVs, the assembly of gasoline vehicles involves energy use and emissions, but the complexity of the engine and transmission adds to the environmental burden.\n\n### 3. Use Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy Consumption:** EVs are generally more efficient than gasoline vehicles. They produce zero tailpipe emissions, but the environmental impact depends on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the impact is significantly lower than if it comes from coal or natural gas.\n- **Maintenance:** EVs typically require less maintenance due to fewer moving parts, reducing the environmental impact over the vehicle's lifetime.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Consumption:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Maintenance:** Regular maintenance, including oil changes and engine repairs, contributes to environmental impacts through the production and disposal of parts and fluids.\n\n### 4. Disposal and Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Disposal/Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries are challenging. Improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination, but recycling can recover valuable materials. Efforts are underway to improve battery recycling technologies.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** EVs can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, but the battery remains a significant challenge.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **End-of-Life Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically recycled for their metal content. The recycling process is well-established, but it still involves energy use and emissions.\n- **Fluid Disposal:** Disposal of engine oil and other fluids can pose environmental risks if not managed properly.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, electric vehicles tend to have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases, primarily due to battery production. However, they offer significant advantages during the use phase, especially when powered by renewable energy, due to their higher efficiency and lack of tailpipe emissions. The end-of-life phase presents challenges for both types of vehicles, but advancements in battery recycling could improve the sustainability of EVs. In contrast, gasoline vehicles have a more consistent environmental impact across all phases, with significant emissions during the use phase.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles, examining every stage from production, use, to disposal. This would involve comparing the raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life disposal or recycling impacts for each type of vehicle." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles, examining every stage from production, use, to disposal. This would involve comparing the raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life disposal or recycling impacts for each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the operational phase, comparing the emissions and energy efficiency of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their use. This approach involves analyzing the greenhouse gas emissions and fuel efficiency when the vehicles are driven, considering factors like the energy source for electricity generation and the fuel type used in gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring the impact of the supply chain for each vehicle type, looking at the environmental effects of sourcing materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries compared to oil extraction and refining for gasoline vehicles. This strategy assesses the ecological and social impacts associated with the procurement of these critical resources.", + "I can answer by reviewing existing research and reports from credible organizations and studies that have analyzed the environmental impacts of both vehicle types. This would involve synthesizing findings from scientific papers, government publications, and industry analyses to provide a comprehensive overview of how electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles differ in their environmental footprints." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles, examining every stage from production, use, to disposal. This would involve comparing the raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life disposal or recycling impacts for each type of vehicle." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:12:59.137988", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 4 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_5.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_5.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..12a77f98094df2d49d1a627891e40e378163c77b --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_5.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "380c1f19-5969-45ca-abda-f31c4bf5c06c", + "ibfs_id": "0df81a50-a904-487a-b314-f6251c5d45bd", + "user_preferred_answer": "When considering the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, it's important to evaluate several aspects, including emissions, resource use, and lifecycle impacts.\n\n1. **Emissions Reduction**: \n - **Tailpipe Emissions**: Electric vehicles have a significant advantage over gasoline vehicles because they produce zero tailpipe emissions. This means they do not emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), or particulate matter while driving, which are major contributors to air pollution and climate change.\n - **Power Generation**: The overall environmental benefit of EVs depends on the energy mix used to generate electricity. In regions where electricity is primarily generated from renewable sources like wind, solar, and hydro, EVs have a much lower carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. However, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, the emissions benefits are reduced, though still generally better than gasoline vehicles.\n\n2. **Resource Use and Manufacturing**:\n - **Battery Production**: The production of EV batteries involves mining and processing materials such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which can have significant environmental impacts. This includes habitat destruction, water use, and pollution from mining activities. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling processes are helping to mitigate these impacts.\n - **Lifecycle Assessment**: When considering the entire lifecycle, from manufacturing to disposal, EVs generally have a lower environmental impact than gasoline vehicles. The energy-intensive battery production is offset over time by the cleaner operation of EVs, especially as the grid becomes greener.\n\n3. **End-of-Life and Recycling**:\n - **Battery Recycling**: Effective recycling of EV batteries can recover valuable materials and reduce the need for new resource extraction. This is an area of active research and development, with improvements expected to increase the sustainability of EVs.\n - **Vehicle Disposal**: Both EVs and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts at the end of their lifecycles, but the potential for recycling and reuse of EV components is increasing, which can mitigate these impacts.\n\n4. **Overall Environmental Impact**:\n - **Reduction in Greenhouse Gas Emissions**: Overall, EVs contribute to a significant reduction in greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, particularly as the energy grid shifts towards renewable sources.\n - **Improved Air Quality**: By reducing tailpipe emissions, EVs contribute to improved urban air quality, which has direct health benefits for populations.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles have some environmental challenges, particularly related to battery production and resource use, their overall impact is significantly lower than that of traditional gasoline vehicles. As technology and infrastructure continue to advance, the environmental benefits of EVs are expected to increase, making them a crucial component of sustainable transportation solutions.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, a lifecycle analysis (LCA) is conducted. This analysis considers the environmental effects from the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and disposal stages for both types of vehicles.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve mining for lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. This mining process can lead to significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Materials:** EVs also use aluminum and other lightweight materials to offset the weight of the battery, which involves additional mining and processing impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fossil Fuels:** The extraction of oil for gasoline involves drilling and refining, which can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and significant greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Metals and Plastics:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and plastics, similar to EVs, but generally in smaller quantities than the materials needed for EV batteries.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy-Intensive Battery Production:** The production of EV batteries is energy-intensive, often resulting in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Assembly:** The assembly of EVs is similar to gasoline vehicles but includes additional processes for battery integration.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine Production:** Manufacturing internal combustion engines is complex and energy-intensive, but generally less so than battery production.\n- **Assembly:** Similar to EVs, the assembly process involves significant energy use but is well-optimized over decades of production.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, reducing urban air pollution and greenhouse gases during operation.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during usage largely depends on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources significantly reduce the carbon footprint, while coal-based electricity can offset some of the benefits.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, particulate matter, and other pollutants, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Advances in fuel efficiency have reduced emissions per mile, but they still remain higher than those of EVs powered by clean electricity.\n\n### 4. Disposal and Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal of EV batteries poses challenges due to hazardous materials. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable metals.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, the rest of the EV can be recycled, though the processes are still being optimized for EV-specific components.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **End-of-Life Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles have established recycling processes for metals and other materials, but the disposal of fluids and certain plastics remains a challenge.\n- **Environmental Impact:** The disposal phase has a smaller relative impact compared to the usage phase, but still contributes to the overall environmental footprint.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles generally have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases due to battery production. However, they offer significant environmental benefits during the usage phase, especially when powered by renewable energy. Gasoline vehicles, while having lower initial production impacts, contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational life. The disposal and recycling phase presents challenges for both types of vehicles, but advancements in technology and recycling processes continue to improve the sustainability of both. Overall, the lifecycle analysis suggests that EVs have the potential for a lower overall environmental impact, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery technologies advance.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would encompass the environmental impacts from raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal stages. By examining each phase, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their respective carbon footprints and resource utilizations." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would encompass the environmental impacts from raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal stages. By examining each phase, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their respective carbon footprints and resource utilizations.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the operation of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing tailpipe emissions, electricity generation sources for EVs, and the resultant greenhouse gas outputs. This approach highlights the direct and indirect emissions associated with both vehicle types during their use phase.", + "I can answer by evaluating the resource extraction and supply chain impacts for electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would explore the environmental consequences of mining for battery materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EVs, as well as oil extraction and refining for gasoline vehicles. It would provide insight into how resource demands affect ecosystems and communities.", + "I can answer by assessing the policy and infrastructure implications on environmental impacts. This would involve examining how government policies, incentives, and charging infrastructure developments influence the adoption of electric vehicles and their environmental benefits. This approach considers how regulatory frameworks can mitigate or exacerbate environmental impacts through strategic planning and investment." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would encompass the environmental impacts from raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal stages. By examining each phase, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their respective carbon footprints and resource utilizations." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:13:05.418370", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 5 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_6.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_6.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..06062dc091335bc0babd8eb43168ac0231990ac2 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_6.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "a871da43-2d15-478c-87fe-d769ca9bb1eb", + "ibfs_id": "80d22b70-3d63-42dd-95be-4450cb6938fd", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) are often touted as a sustainable alternative to traditional gasoline vehicles, and understanding their environmental impacts is crucial in evaluating this claim. Here's a comprehensive comparison of the two:\n\n1. **Emissions During Operation:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which means they do not emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, or particulate matter during operation. This can lead to significant improvements in air quality, especially in urban areas with high traffic congestion.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Traditional vehicles burn fossil fuels and emit a considerable amount of greenhouse gases (GHGs) like CO2, as well as other pollutants that contribute to air pollution and health problems.\n\n2. **Lifecycle Emissions:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The production of EVs can result in higher initial emissions, primarily due to battery manufacturing, which involves energy-intensive processes and the extraction of metals like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. However, over their lifespan, EVs typically have lower overall emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, especially when charged with renewable energy sources.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** While gasoline vehicles may have lower manufacturing emissions, their lifetime emissions are significantly higher due to the continuous burning of fossil fuels.\n\n3. **Energy Source and Efficiency:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. The efficiency of an EV can be influenced by the electricity mix used for charging. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources, the environmental benefits of EVs are maximized.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles are less efficient, as a significant portion of the energy in gasoline is lost as heat. Additionally, the extraction, refining, and transportation of oil further add to their environmental impact.\n\n4. **Resource Extraction:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The need for battery materials involves mining activities that can lead to habitat destruction, water pollution, and other environmental concerns. However, advancements in battery recycling and sustainable mining practices are being developed to mitigate these impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** The oil industry\u2019s extraction and production processes can result in significant environmental degradation, including oil spills, habitat destruction, and water pollution.\n\n5. **End-of-Life and Recycling:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** Battery disposal and recycling are critical challenges. However, the development of effective recycling techniques is underway, which can help recover valuable materials and reduce environmental harm.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Traditional vehicles are easier to recycle, but the environmental damage from oil and fuel leaks during their lifespan can be significant.\n\n6. **Impact on Ecosystems:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** While the transition to EVs can reduce air and noise pollution, the extraction of raw materials for batteries can impact ecosystems if not managed sustainably.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Their emissions contribute to air pollution, acid rain, and climate change, which can have widespread effects on ecosystems.\n\nIn summary, while electric vehicles have some environmental challenges, particularly related to battery production and resource extraction, their overall impact is generally less harmful than that of traditional gasoline vehicles, especially when considering the long-term benefits of reduced operational emissions and the potential for greener electricity sources. As technology advances and the energy grid becomes cleaner, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to grow.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, a cradle-to-grave life cycle assessment (LCA) provides a comprehensive analysis. This approach considers all phases of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction to end-of-life disposal or recycling.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Materials**: EVs require lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other rare earth metals for their batteries. The extraction of these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components**: EVs also use aluminum and copper, which require energy-intensive mining processes.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Fossil Fuels**: The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling and refining, which can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Metals**: Gasoline vehicles also require steel and aluminum, but generally in smaller quantities than the metals needed for EV batteries.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Processes\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Production**: Manufacturing EV batteries is energy-intensive and contributes significantly to the vehicle's initial carbon footprint. However, advancements in battery technology and production efficiency are reducing these impacts.\n- **Vehicle Assembly**: Similar to gasoline vehicles, but with additional processes for integrating electric drivetrains and battery systems.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Engine Production**: Manufacturing internal combustion engines involves complex processes that also consume energy and resources.\n- **Vehicle Assembly**: Generally less complex than EVs due to the absence of large battery systems.\n\n### 3. Transportation Logistics\n\nBoth EVs and gasoline vehicles require transportation from manufacturing sites to dealerships. This phase contributes to emissions through the use of ships, trains, and trucks. The impact is relatively similar for both vehicle types, although the heavier weight of EVs due to batteries can slightly increase transportation emissions.\n\n### 4. Operational Lifespan\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Energy Source**: The environmental impact during the use phase largely depends on the electricity mix. In regions with renewable energy, EVs have significantly lower emissions. However, in areas reliant on coal, the benefits are reduced.\n- **Efficiency**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting more energy from the grid into miles driven.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Fuel Combustion**: Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency**: Improvements in fuel efficiency have reduced emissions over time, but they still lag behind the potential emissions reductions from EVs.\n\n### 5. End-of-Life Recycling or Disposal\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Recycling**: The recycling of EV batteries is crucial to reduce environmental impacts. Current technologies allow for the recovery of some materials, but the process is still developing.\n- **Vehicle Recycling**: Similar to gasoline vehicles, with additional challenges related to battery disposal.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Recycling**: Established processes exist for recycling metals and other materials from gasoline vehicles. However, the disposal of engine fluids and other hazardous materials remains a concern.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, electric vehicles tend to have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases, primarily due to battery production. However, they generally offer significant environmental benefits during the operational phase, especially when powered by renewable energy sources. The end-of-life phase presents challenges for both vehicle types, but advancements in recycling technologies are helping to mitigate these impacts. While both vehicle types have environmental impacts, the potential for EVs to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution during their use phase makes them a more sustainable option in the long term, particularly as the energy grid becomes greener.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts from the production phase, the operational phase, and the disposal/recycling phase of each type of vehicle to provide a comprehensive comparison.", + "I can answer by focusing on a cradle-to-grave life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles, which includes detailed analysis of raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, transportation logistics, the full operational lifespan with real-world driving data, and end-of-life recycling or disposal processes. This comprehensive approach ensures all phases of the vehicle's life are examined for environmental impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts from the production phase, the operational phase, and the disposal/recycling phase of each type of vehicle to provide a comprehensive comparison.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions during the use phase of the vehicles. This approach would compare the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles with the emissions related to electricity generation for EVs, considering factors like the energy mix of the grid and advancements in battery technology.", + "I can answer by analyzing the resource extraction and material sourcing for both types of vehicles. This would involve looking into the mining and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries, as well as the extraction and refining of oil for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring the infrastructure and energy supply chains required for each vehicle type. This approach would examine the environmental impacts of building and maintaining charging stations and electricity grids for EVs, compared to the impacts associated with refining and distributing gasoline." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts from the production phase, the operational phase, and the disposal/recycling phase of each type of vehicle to provide a comprehensive comparison." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a cradle-to-grave life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles, which includes detailed analysis of raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, transportation logistics, the full operational lifespan with real-world driving data, and end-of-life recycling or disposal processes. This comprehensive approach ensures all phases of the vehicle's life are examined for environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative LCA that emphasizes regional variations in electricity generation for EVs, such as coal-based vs. renewable energy grids, and how these sources affect the overall environmental footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. By tailoring the assessment to specific geographic areas, we can better understand the localized environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by performing a time-based LCA, where I evaluate the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles over different time horizons. This would involve assessing short-term impacts, such as initial manufacturing emissions, and long-term impacts, like battery degradation and fuel efficiency changes, to provide a dynamic view of their environmental implications over time.", + "I can answer by integrating a social and economic dimension into the LCA, where I assess not only the environmental impacts but also the societal benefits or drawbacks, such as job creation in manufacturing sectors and potential health benefits from reduced emissions. This holistic approach can offer a broader perspective on the trade-offs between electric and gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on a cradle-to-grave life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles, which includes detailed analysis of raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, transportation logistics, the full operational lifespan with real-world driving data, and end-of-life recycling or disposal processes. This comprehensive approach ensures all phases of the vehicle's life are examined for environmental impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:13:35.903125", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 6 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_7.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_7.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..496da87e261856150ac32a5373ca4f844f8656a4 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_7.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "8fdbe0d1-ab98-4d89-a2dc-3f2a20a01566", + "ibfs_id": "69b76df7-b531-43b8-ae1a-0a9a5054ae7f", + "user_preferred_answer": "When comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) to traditional gasoline vehicles, several key factors need to be considered, including emissions during operation, the production process, and end-of-life disposal.\n\n1. **Operational Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces local air pollution, particularly in urban areas. This is a major advantage over gasoline vehicles, which emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles rely on internal combustion engines that burn fossil fuels, directly emitting CO2 and other pollutants. This contributes to global warming and has adverse health effects on humans due to air quality degradation.\n\n2. **Lifecycle Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: While EVs have higher emissions during the manufacturing phase, primarily due to battery production, they generally have a smaller carbon footprint over their lifetime. This is because electricity generation, even when accounting for fossil fuels, tends to be cleaner than burning gasoline. As the energy grid becomes greener, the lifecycle emissions of EVs are expected to decrease further.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: They typically have lower emissions during manufacturing compared to EVs but higher lifetime emissions due to fuel combustion. The continuous use of gasoline results in higher cumulative emissions, making them less environmentally friendly over the vehicle's lifespan.\n\n3. **Energy Source**:\n - The environmental benefit of EVs heavily depends on the energy mix used for electricity generation. In regions where renewable energy sources (such as wind, solar, or hydropower) are prevalent, the environmental benefits of EVs are maximized. However, in areas reliant on coal or other fossil fuels, the advantage diminishes but still generally remains better than gasoline vehicles.\n\n4. **Resource Extraction and Battery Production**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The production of lithium-ion batteries requires mining of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which can have significant environmental and social impacts. Sustainable sourcing and advancements in battery technology are critical to reducing these impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The extraction and refining of oil for gasoline also have substantial environmental effects, including habitat destruction, water contamination, and oil spills, which are detrimental to ecosystems.\n\n5. **End-of-Life Management**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EV batteries present a unique challenge due to their size and chemical complexity. However, advancements in battery recycling and second-life applications (such as energy storage) are improving the sustainability of EVs.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles can be more straightforward to recycle, but the continuous need for fossil fuels remains an ongoing environmental concern.\n\nIn conclusion, while both vehicle types have environmental impacts, electric vehicles offer significant advantages in reducing emissions and improving air quality, especially as electricity grids become cleaner. Efforts to enhance battery technology, recycling, and sustainable mining practices are crucial to maximizing the environmental benefits of EVs.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles using a time-based life cycle assessment (LCA), we need to consider several stages of the vehicle lifecycle: production, use, and end-of-life, while also accounting for projected technological advancements and changes in energy sources over time.\n\n### 1. Production Phase\n\n- **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Current Impact:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery manufacturing, is more energy-intensive than that of gasoline vehicles. This is primarily due to the extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel.\n - **Future Projections:** Over time, advancements in battery technology, such as solid-state batteries, and improvements in manufacturing processes are expected to reduce the energy intensity and environmental impact of battery production. Additionally, increased recycling of battery materials will further mitigate these impacts.\n\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Current Impact:** The production of gasoline vehicles is less energy-intensive compared to EVs, mainly due to the absence of large battery packs.\n - **Future Projections:** While improvements in manufacturing efficiency are expected, the fundamental materials and processes involved in gasoline vehicle production are not projected to change significantly.\n\n### 2. Use Phase\n\n- **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Current Impact:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, leading to significant reductions in local air pollutants compared to gasoline vehicles. However, the environmental impact during the use phase is influenced by the electricity grid's energy mix.\n - **Future Projections:** As the grid becomes increasingly decarbonized with more renewable energy sources like wind and solar, the carbon footprint of operating EVs will decrease substantially. This shift is expected to make EVs significantly cleaner over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Current Impact:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other pollutants during operation. The environmental impact is directly related to fuel efficiency and the carbon content of the fuel.\n - **Future Projections:** While improvements in fuel efficiency and the development of cleaner fuels can reduce emissions, gasoline vehicles will continue to produce direct emissions as long as they rely on internal combustion engines.\n\n### 3. End-of-Life Phase\n\n- **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Current Impact:** The recycling of EV batteries is still developing, but it is crucial for minimizing environmental impacts. Current processes are energy-intensive and not yet widely implemented.\n - **Future Projections:** Advances in battery recycling technologies and increased infrastructure for recycling are expected to reduce the environmental impacts associated with the disposal of EV batteries. This will also help recover valuable materials, reducing the need for new raw material extraction.\n\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Current Impact:** The end-of-life phase for gasoline vehicles is relatively well-established, with many components being recyclable.\n - **Future Projections:** While recycling processes may become more efficient, the overall impact is not expected to change dramatically, as the materials and components involved remain largely the same.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOver time, the environmental impacts of electric vehicles are projected to decrease significantly due to advancements in battery technology, increased reliance on renewable energy sources, and improved recycling processes. In contrast, while gasoline vehicles may see some improvements in efficiency and emissions, their fundamental reliance on fossil fuels limits their potential for significant environmental impact reduction. Therefore, from a long-term perspective, EVs are expected to offer substantial environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include evaluating aspects such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation emissions, and end-of-life recycling or disposal, providing a comprehensive overview of their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by performing a time-based life cycle assessment (LCA), which assesses how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles evolve over time. This approach examines the projected changes in technology, energy sources, and recycling processes over the lifespan of the vehicles, offering a dynamic perspective on their long-term environmental impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include evaluating aspects such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation emissions, and end-of-life recycling or disposal, providing a comprehensive overview of their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase only, comparing the emissions and energy efficiency of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles when in use. This would involve analyzing data on greenhouse gas emissions, air pollutants, and the energy sources used for electricity generation, providing insight into their impacts during the vehicle's lifetime.", + "I can answer by exploring the supply chain and resource availability impacts, particularly the mining and processing of key materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for electric vehicle batteries versus the extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline. This approach would highlight the environmental and social impacts associated with obtaining essential resources for each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by examining policy and infrastructure factors that influence the environmental impacts of both vehicle types, such as government incentives for electric vehicles, availability and development of charging stations, and the impact of electricity grid composition on overall emissions. This would provide a perspective on how external factors can alter the environmental outcomes of electric versus gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include evaluating aspects such as raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation emissions, and end-of-life recycling or disposal, providing a comprehensive overview of their environmental footprints." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a hotspot analysis within the life cycle assessment (LCA), which focuses on identifying the most significant environmental impacts in the life cycle stages of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach zeroes in on critical points such as battery production for electric vehicles and fuel extraction for gasoline vehicles, providing insights into which aspects contribute most to their overall environmental impact.", + "I can answer by implementing a sensitivity analysis as part of the life cycle assessment (LCA), which involves varying key assumptions and parameters such as electricity grid composition and fuel efficiency. This approach evaluates how changes in these factors can influence the comparative environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles, helping to understand the robustness of the LCA outcomes.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison, which examines how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles differ across various geographic locations. This approach considers regional differences in electricity generation sources, manufacturing practices, and waste management infrastructures, providing tailored insights into their environmental footprints in different contexts.", + "I can answer by performing a time-based life cycle assessment (LCA), which assesses how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles evolve over time. This approach examines the projected changes in technology, energy sources, and recycling processes over the lifespan of the vehicles, offering a dynamic perspective on their long-term environmental impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 3, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by performing a time-based life cycle assessment (LCA), which assesses how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles evolve over time. This approach examines the projected changes in technology, energy sources, and recycling processes over the lifespan of the vehicles, offering a dynamic perspective on their long-term environmental impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:13:45.547891", + "similarity_score": 0.8, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 7 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_8.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_8.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f4fd60a5519e831acde348cf36ca7faf7c4d3c12 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_8.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "f5ca8dd3-6754-4582-8da6-89aaa03a680e", + "ibfs_id": "e730baa9-8a4c-47be-a7c9-6cf1904c89e8", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles each have distinct environmental impacts that are important to consider when evaluating their overall sustainability.\n\n**1. Greenhouse Gas Emissions:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which is a significant advantage in reducing local air pollution and greenhouse gases in urban areas. However, the overall environmental impact of EVs depends on the source of the electricity used to charge them. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the greenhouse gas emissions of EVs are significantly lower compared to gasoline vehicles. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal-fired power plants, the emissions can be higher, although still generally less than those from gasoline vehicles.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2) and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe. The emissions are a direct result of burning fossil fuels, contributing significantly to global warming and air quality issues.\n\n**2. Energy Efficiency:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** EVs are typically more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. They convert over 77% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, whereas gasoline vehicles only convert about 12%\u201330% of the energy stored in gasoline to power at the wheels.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles lose a significant amount of energy through engine heat and exhaust, making them less efficient compared to EVs.\n\n**3. Resource Extraction and Manufacturing:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** The production of EVs, particularly their batteries, requires significant amounts of raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel. Mining and processing these materials can have substantial environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and pollution. Advancements in battery recycling and sustainable mining practices are crucial for minimizing these impacts.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The environmental impact of traditional vehicles largely stems from oil extraction, refining, and transportation. These processes can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and pollution.\n\n**4. End-of-Life and Recycling:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** The disposal of EV batteries poses environmental challenges. However, advancements in recycling technologies are being developed to mitigate these issues by recovering valuable materials and reducing landfill waste.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** While traditional vehicles don\u2019t have the same battery disposal issue, they do require the disposal of various fluids and components that can be environmentally harmful if not properly managed.\n\n**5. Long-Term Sustainability:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** As the grid becomes greener and battery technologies improve, the environmental benefits of EVs are expected to increase. The shift towards renewable energy sources further enhances the long-term sustainability of EVs.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The reliance on fossil fuels is a major limitation for traditional vehicles, as it is unsustainable in the long term due to finite resources and the need to reduce carbon emissions to combat climate change.\n\nIn conclusion, while both electric and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts, EVs generally offer a more sustainable option, particularly as the energy grid becomes cleaner and battery technologies advance. The transition to renewable energy and improvements in battery recycling will further enhance the environmental benefits of electric vehicles over time.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine the emissions and environmental degradation associated with the energy sources used to power each type of vehicle. This involves looking at the electricity generation process for EVs and the gasoline production and combustion process for traditional vehicles.\n\n### Electric Vehicles (EVs)\n\n1. **Electricity Generation:**\n - The environmental impact of EVs largely depends on the energy mix used to generate electricity. In regions where electricity is primarily generated from renewable sources such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the emissions associated with EVs are significantly lower.\n - In contrast, if the electricity comes from fossil fuels like coal or natural gas, the emissions can be higher. Coal-fired power plants, in particular, produce substantial greenhouse gas emissions and other pollutants.\n - The regional variation in energy sources is crucial. For example, in countries like Norway, where a large portion of electricity comes from hydropower, EVs have a much lower carbon footprint compared to regions heavily reliant on coal.\n\n2. **Lifecycle Emissions:**\n - While EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, the production of their batteries can be resource-intensive, involving mining and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. This can lead to environmental degradation if not managed sustainably.\n - However, over the lifespan of the vehicle, the reduced operational emissions often offset the initial environmental costs of battery production, especially as battery recycling and production processes improve.\n\n### Traditional Gasoline Vehicles\n\n1. **Gasoline Production:**\n - The extraction, refining, and transportation of crude oil to produce gasoline are energy-intensive processes that contribute to greenhouse gas emissions and environmental degradation. Oil drilling can lead to habitat destruction, oil spills, and water contamination.\n - Refining crude oil into gasoline involves significant energy use and emissions of pollutants such as sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides.\n\n2. **Combustion Emissions:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), a major greenhouse gas, directly from the tailpipe during combustion. They also produce other pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which contribute to air pollution and health issues.\n - Unlike EVs, the emissions from gasoline vehicles are consistent regardless of the region, as they are directly tied to the combustion of gasoline.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe environmental impact of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles is heavily influenced by the source of the electricity used to charge them. In regions with a clean energy grid, EVs offer significant environmental benefits over gasoline vehicles due to lower lifecycle emissions. However, in areas dependent on fossil fuels for electricity, the benefits may be reduced, though EVs still avoid the direct tailpipe emissions associated with gasoline vehicles. As the global energy mix shifts towards more renewable sources, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to increase.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impacts associated with the energy sources used to power each type of vehicle. This approach would compare the emissions and environmental degradation linked to the electricity generation process for EVs against those associated with gasoline production and combustion, considering factors such as the energy mix (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and regional variations in energy sources." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive lifecycle analysis of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, including raw material extraction, manufacturing, use, and end-of-life disposal or recycling, to provide a detailed comparison of their overall ecological footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impacts associated with the energy sources used to power each type of vehicle. This approach would compare the emissions and environmental degradation linked to the electricity generation process for EVs against those associated with gasoline production and combustion, considering factors such as the energy mix (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and regional variations in energy sources." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impacts associated with the energy sources used to power each type of vehicle. This approach would compare the emissions and environmental degradation linked to the electricity generation process for EVs against those associated with gasoline production and combustion, considering factors such as the energy mix (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and regional variations in energy sources." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:14:03.424808", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 8 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_9.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_9.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e80142316d19a17a4197e6691696bbfafd64db41 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_141119_sim_9.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "b94d3f42-145c-4f98-b6eb-3cc3df41aa8e", + "ibfs_id": "d808e45e-5574-40e9-9f79-45dee86d1ff7", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles each have distinct environmental impacts, and understanding these differences is crucial for evaluating their roles in sustainable transportation.\n\n**1. Emissions:**\n\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas, leading to improvements in public health and local air quality. Gasoline vehicles, on the other hand, emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter, and other pollutants that contribute to smog and respiratory problems.\n\n- **Lifecycle Emissions:** While EVs have higher emissions during production, primarily due to battery manufacturing, they tend to have lower overall lifecycle emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. This is because they compensate for these initial emissions through cleaner operation over time, especially if powered by renewable energy sources. As the grid becomes greener, the lifecycle emissions of EVs continue to decrease.\n\n**2. Energy Source:**\n\n- **Electricity vs. Fossil Fuels:** EVs are as clean as the electricity that powers them. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydro, EVs have a significantly lower carbon footprint. Conversely, gasoline vehicles rely on fossil fuels, which are major contributors to greenhouse gas emissions and climate change.\n\n- **Energy Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 77% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, whereas gasoline vehicles convert only about 12%\u201330% of the energy stored in gasoline.\n\n**3. Resource Extraction and Production:**\n\n- **Battery Production:** The production of EV batteries involves mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which can have significant environmental and social impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and human rights concerns. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling are helping mitigate these issues over time.\n\n- **Oil Extraction and Refining:** Gasoline production involves oil extraction, which can lead to oil spills and environmental degradation. The refining process also emits pollutants and requires substantial energy, often sourced from fossil fuels.\n\n**4. End-of-Life Considerations:**\n\n- **Recycling and Disposal:** EVs, especially their batteries, present challenges and opportunities in terms of recycling and disposal. Efforts are underway to improve recycling technologies to reclaim valuable materials and reduce environmental impact. Gasoline vehicles, consisting of metal and other materials, are also recyclable, but the disposal of used oil and other fluids can pose environmental risks.\n\n**5. Infrastructure and Land Use:**\n\n- **Charging Infrastructure:** Expanding EV infrastructure requires investment and land use considerations, but it can lead to a cleaner, more sustainable transportation system over time. Gasoline infrastructure is well-established but contributes to ongoing environmental issues related to fuel transport and storage.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs are not without environmental challenges, especially concerning battery production and resource extraction, they offer significant long-term benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles. These benefits include reduced emissions, improved air quality, and better alignment with renewable energy pathways. As technology and infrastructure continue to evolve, the environmental advantages of EVs are likely to increase, making them a crucial component of a sustainable transportation future.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will examine specific environmental impact categories: air pollution, resource depletion, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n### Air Pollution\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Gasoline vehicles emit pollutants directly from their tailpipes, including nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO), particulate matter (PM), and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). These emissions contribute to smog, respiratory problems, and other health issues.\n- The combustion of gasoline also releases carbon dioxide (CO2), a greenhouse gas, although this is more relevant to the greenhouse gas emissions category.\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- EVs have no tailpipe emissions, which means they do not directly emit NOx, CO, PM, or VOCs during operation.\n- However, the electricity used to charge EVs can lead to air pollution, depending on the energy mix of the grid. If the electricity is generated from fossil fuels like coal or natural gas, there are emissions associated with power generation, including NOx, SO2, and PM.\n- The extent of air pollution from EVs depends on the cleanliness of the electricity grid. In regions with a high percentage of renewable energy, the air pollution impact is significantly lower.\n\n### Resource Depletion\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Resource depletion for gasoline vehicles primarily involves the extraction and refining of crude oil. This process requires significant energy and water resources and can lead to environmental degradation, such as oil spills and habitat destruction.\n- The infrastructure for oil extraction and refining is extensive and has long-term environmental impacts.\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- EVs rely on batteries, typically lithium-ion, which require raw materials like lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. The extraction and processing of these materials can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy use.\n- Mining for these materials can also have social and ethical implications, particularly in regions with poor labor practices.\n- The recycling and disposal of batteries pose additional challenges, although advancements in battery recycling technology are ongoing.\n\n### Greenhouse Gas Emissions\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The production of gasoline vehicles involves emissions from manufacturing processes, but the most significant emissions occur during the operational phase due to the combustion of gasoline.\n- On average, gasoline vehicles emit about 2.3 kg of CO2 per liter of gasoline burned, contributing significantly to climate change over their lifetime.\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher initial greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- However, during the operational phase, EVs typically have lower emissions, especially if charged with low-carbon electricity. Over time, the total lifecycle emissions of EVs can be lower than those of gasoline vehicles, depending on the energy mix used for electricity generation.\n- As the electricity grid becomes greener, the greenhouse gas emissions associated with EVs will continue to decrease.\n\nIn summary, while electric vehicles offer significant advantages in terms of reducing tailpipe emissions and potentially lowering greenhouse gas emissions over their lifetime, they also present challenges related to resource depletion and initial production emissions. The overall environmental impact of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles depends heavily on the energy sources used for electricity generation and advancements in battery technology and recycling.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by examining specific environmental impact categories separately, such as air pollution, resource depletion, and greenhouse gas emissions. For air pollution, I would compare emissions from the tailpipe of gasoline vehicles with the emissions from electricity generation for EVs. For resource depletion, I would focus on the extraction and processing of raw materials needed for battery production in EVs, compared to oil extraction and refining for gasoline. Additionally, I would analyze the greenhouse gas emissions from both the production and operational phases of each vehicle type, providing a detailed comparison of their contributions to climate change." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal or recycling. By comparing the energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource use across these stages, I can provide a comprehensive analysis of the overall environmental footprint of both types of vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining specific environmental impact categories separately, such as air pollution, resource depletion, and greenhouse gas emissions. For air pollution, I would compare emissions from the tailpipe of gasoline vehicles with the emissions from electricity generation for EVs. For resource depletion, I would focus on the extraction and processing of raw materials needed for battery production in EVs, compared to oil extraction and refining for gasoline. Additionally, I would analyze the greenhouse gas emissions from both the production and operational phases of each vehicle type, providing a detailed comparison of their contributions to climate change." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by examining specific environmental impact categories separately, such as air pollution, resource depletion, and greenhouse gas emissions. For air pollution, I would compare emissions from the tailpipe of gasoline vehicles with the emissions from electricity generation for EVs. For resource depletion, I would focus on the extraction and processing of raw materials needed for battery production in EVs, compared to oil extraction and refining for gasoline. Additionally, I would analyze the greenhouse gas emissions from both the production and operational phases of each vehicle type, providing a detailed comparison of their contributions to climate change." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T14:14:13.689224", + "similarity_score": 0.9, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_141119", + "simulation_id": 9 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160620_config.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160620_config.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ca7793776573d0004d0b960cbc2a1f7e03fd03b4 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160620_config.json @@ -0,0 +1,23 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160620", + "queries": [ + "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?" + ], + "diversity_levels": [ + "low", + "medium" + ], + "branching_factors": [ + 2, + 4 + ], + "max_depths": [ + 1, + 2 + ], + "epsilon_values": [ + 0.2 + ], + "repetitions": 10, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:20.391323" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_all_results.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_all_results.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..15b2d2e19a6a4e38902c144700443268c5e61703 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_all_results.json @@ -0,0 +1,3162 @@ +[ + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "e111650a-da51-4ab2-8237-d29e52bf64f2", + "ibfs_id": "d312e392-257c-4107-81ba-5bd440c80c12", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles generally have lower emissions and reduced environmental impact compared to gasoline vehicles, benefiting air quality and climate change.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, we need to examine two main aspects: emissions and energy efficiency.\n\n**1. Emissions:**\n\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:**\n - **Electric Vehicles (EVs):** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions during their operation. This means they do not emit pollutants such as carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), or particulate matter (PM) while being driven. This is a significant advantage over gasoline vehicles, especially in urban areas where air quality is a concern.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Gasoline vehicles emit various pollutants through their tailpipes, including CO2, NOx, carbon monoxide (CO), and hydrocarbons. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change.\n\n- **Source of Electricity:**\n - The environmental impact of EVs during their operational phase also depends on the source of the electricity used to charge them. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the overall emissions associated with driving an EV are significantly reduced. However, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels such as coal or natural gas, the emissions associated with electricity production can offset some of the benefits of zero tailpipe emissions.\n - The energy mix varies by region, so the environmental impact of EVs can differ depending on where they are charged. In areas with a high percentage of renewable energy in the grid, EVs have a much lower overall environmental impact compared to regions that rely heavily on fossil fuels.\n\n**2. Energy Efficiency:**\n\n- **Electric Vehicles:**\n - EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 85-90% of electrical energy from the battery to power the wheels. This high efficiency means that a greater proportion of the energy stored in the battery is used for propulsion, resulting in less energy waste.\n \n- **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Internal combustion engines (ICEs) in gasoline vehicles are less efficient, typically converting only about 20-30% of the energy stored in gasoline into motion. The rest is lost as heat and through other inefficiencies in the engine and drivetrain.\n\nThe higher energy efficiency of EVs means that even when accounting for the emissions from electricity generation, they often have a lower overall environmental impact during their operational phase compared to gasoline vehicles. This efficiency advantage, combined with the potential for using renewable energy sources, makes EVs a more environmentally friendly option during their use phase.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, specifically analyzing their emissions and energy efficiency. This approach would delve into the differences in tailpipe emissions, where electric vehicles typically produce none, and the source of electricity for EVs, which can vary in its environmental impact depending on the energy mix (renewable vs. fossil fuels). Additionally, I would compare the energy efficiency of electric motors versus internal combustion engines, highlighting how these differences contribute to the overall environmental footprint during the vehicle's use phase." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, examining each stage from production to disposal. This would include the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage, such as greenhouse gas emissions, water usage, and resource depletion, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how the two types of vehicles differ environmentally.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, specifically analyzing their emissions and energy efficiency. This approach would delve into the differences in tailpipe emissions, where electric vehicles typically produce none, and the source of electricity for EVs, which can vary in its environmental impact depending on the energy mix (renewable vs. fossil fuels). Additionally, I would compare the energy efficiency of electric motors versus internal combustion engines, highlighting how these differences contribute to the overall environmental footprint during the vehicle's use phase." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, specifically analyzing their emissions and energy efficiency. This approach would delve into the differences in tailpipe emissions, where electric vehicles typically produce none, and the source of electricity for EVs, which can vary in its environmental impact depending on the energy mix (renewable vs. fossil fuels). Additionally, I would compare the energy efficiency of electric motors versus internal combustion engines, highlighting how these differences contribute to the overall environmental footprint during the vehicle's use phase." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:42.543692", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 4 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "eb3f4598-4f8c-4d28-9004-2bafc54459a9", + "ibfs_id": "e4427e40-0f46-4491-a578-3e899870aaf1", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce zero tailpipe emissions, reduce greenhouse gases, but have environmental costs in battery production and electricity sources.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can review existing studies and reports from credible sources. These studies typically evaluate the entire lifecycle of vehicles, including manufacturing, operation, and disposal, to provide a comprehensive understanding of their environmental impacts.\n\n1. **Lifecycle Greenhouse Gas Emissions**:\n - A study by the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS) found that electric vehicles produce significantly lower greenhouse gas emissions over their lifetimes compared to gasoline vehicles. This is primarily due to the higher efficiency of electric motors and the potential for electricity to be generated from renewable sources. According to their 2020 report, even when accounting for the emissions from electricity generation, EVs in the U.S. produce less than half the emissions of comparable gasoline vehicles.\n - The International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT) also supports these findings, indicating that EVs have lower lifecycle emissions, especially as the grid becomes cleaner with more renewable energy sources.\n\n2. **Manufacturing Impact**:\n - The production of electric vehicles, particularly the batteries, is more energy-intensive than that of gasoline vehicles. A report from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) highlights that battery production is a significant source of emissions. However, these emissions are offset during the vehicle's operational phase due to the higher efficiency and lower emissions of EVs.\n - The European Environment Agency (EEA) notes that while battery production has a higher environmental footprint, advancements in battery technology and recycling can mitigate these impacts.\n\n3. **Air Quality**:\n - EVs contribute to improved air quality by eliminating tailpipe emissions, which are a significant source of urban air pollution. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) emphasizes that reducing emissions from transportation is crucial for improving air quality and public health, particularly in urban areas.\n - A study published in the journal *Nature Sustainability* found that widespread adoption of EVs could lead to substantial reductions in air pollutants like nitrogen oxides and particulate matter, which are harmful to human health.\n\n4. **Resource Use and Recycling**:\n - The extraction and processing of materials for EV batteries, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, have environmental and social implications. Reports from organizations like Amnesty International highlight concerns about mining practices and their environmental and human rights impacts.\n - However, the industry is moving towards more sustainable practices, and research from the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) suggests that recycling and second-life applications for batteries can reduce the demand for raw materials and lower the environmental impact.\n\n5. **Energy Source Variability**:\n - The environmental benefits of EVs are closely tied to the energy sources used for electricity generation. A report from the International Energy Agency (IEA) indicates that in regions where coal is the dominant energy source, the benefits of EVs are reduced. However, as grids incorporate more renewable energy, the advantages of EVs increase significantly.\n\nIn summary, existing studies and reports generally agree that electric vehicles offer substantial environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving air quality. While there are challenges related to battery production and resource use, advancements in technology and energy sourcing are expected to enhance the environmental performance of EVs further.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by reviewing existing studies and reports from credible sources such as environmental organizations, governmental agencies, and academic research that have analyzed the environmental impacts of electric versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve summarizing key findings from these studies, highlighting the consensus and any differing opinions on the environmental benefits and drawbacks of each vehicle type. This method relies on existing research to provide a synthesized overview of the current understanding in this field." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would consider the raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, usage phase, and end-of-life management for both types of vehicles. By examining the entire lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive analysis of how each type of vehicle impacts the environment over its lifespan.", + "I can answer by reviewing existing studies and reports from credible sources such as environmental organizations, governmental agencies, and academic research that have analyzed the environmental impacts of electric versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve summarizing key findings from these studies, highlighting the consensus and any differing opinions on the environmental benefits and drawbacks of each vehicle type. This method relies on existing research to provide a synthesized overview of the current understanding in this field." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by reviewing existing studies and reports from credible sources such as environmental organizations, governmental agencies, and academic research that have analyzed the environmental impacts of electric versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve summarizing key findings from these studies, highlighting the consensus and any differing opinions on the environmental benefits and drawbacks of each vehicle type. This method relies on existing research to provide a synthesized overview of the current understanding in this field." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:45.380396", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 2 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "ab712ce7-f55d-4326-981b-0acb6540a7c4", + "ibfs_id": "5c22a326-8a7b-4c02-a647-efc6238ce84c", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles offer lower emissions, reduced air pollution, and decreased reliance on fossil fuels compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To address the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, I will review recent scientific studies and reports from credible sources, focusing on emissions, resource consumption, and potential benefits or drawbacks.\n\n1. **Emissions**:\n - A study published in *Nature Sustainability* (2020) analyzed the life cycle emissions of EVs and found that, on average, EVs produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles. This is primarily due to the higher efficiency of electric motors and the increasing share of renewable energy in electricity grids.\n - The International Energy Agency (IEA) in its 2021 Global EV Outlook report highlighted that EVs have the potential to significantly reduce CO2 emissions, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener. The report noted that in regions with a high share of coal in electricity generation, the emissions benefits are less pronounced but still positive.\n\n2. **Resource Consumption**:\n - A report by the European Environment Agency (EEA) in 2020 discussed the resource implications of EVs, noting that while EVs require critical raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for their batteries, advancements in battery technology and recycling processes are helping to mitigate these impacts. The shift towards less resource-intensive battery chemistries, such as lithium iron phosphate (LFP), is also reducing the environmental footprint.\n - The Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS) in a 2021 analysis emphasized that the extraction and processing of materials for EV batteries have environmental impacts, but these are offset by the lower emissions during the vehicle's operational phase.\n\n3. **Potential Benefits**:\n - EVs contribute to improved air quality in urban areas by eliminating tailpipe emissions of pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM). A study by the American Lung Association (2020) estimated that widespread adoption of EVs could prevent thousands of premature deaths and save billions in health costs annually in the United States alone.\n - According to a 2021 report by BloombergNEF, the total cost of ownership for EVs is becoming competitive with gasoline vehicles, which could accelerate their adoption and amplify environmental benefits.\n\n4. **Drawbacks and Challenges**:\n - The environmental impact of EVs is heavily dependent on the energy mix used for electricity generation. In regions where coal is a major energy source, the benefits are reduced. However, as renewable energy sources like wind and solar become more prevalent, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to increase.\n - The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose environmental challenges. Research from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) in 2021 highlighted the need for improved recycling technologies and policies to manage battery waste sustainably.\n\nIn conclusion, recent studies and reports indicate that electric vehicles generally offer significant environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of emissions and air quality. However, challenges related to resource consumption and battery disposal remain, necessitating continued advancements in technology and policy to maximize the environmental benefits of EVs.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by reviewing recent scientific studies and reports from credible sources like environmental agencies, universities, and research institutions. This would include summarizing findings on emissions, resource consumption, and potential benefits or drawbacks of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, taking into account advancements in technology and changes in energy production methods." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles, focusing on key stages such as production, operation, and disposal. This would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage, such as the extraction of raw materials, emissions during vehicle operation, and the handling of end-of-life components, to provide a comprehensive comparison.", + "I can answer by reviewing recent scientific studies and reports from credible sources like environmental agencies, universities, and research institutions. This would include summarizing findings on emissions, resource consumption, and potential benefits or drawbacks of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, taking into account advancements in technology and changes in energy production methods." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by reviewing recent scientific studies and reports from credible sources like environmental agencies, universities, and research institutions. This would include summarizing findings on emissions, resource consumption, and potential benefits or drawbacks of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, taking into account advancements in technology and changes in energy production methods." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:45.248199", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 5 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "46d99c5a-7575-42c7-a908-2e6c04ca7d80", + "ibfs_id": "9c4f5dbc-73c9-477c-8104-55130a0b0401", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution over their lifecycle, despite requiring resource-intensive production compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative analysis of the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine the entire lifecycle of both types of vehicles. This includes the production, operation, and disposal phases.\n\n### Production Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Raw Material Extraction:** The production of EVs, particularly their batteries, requires significant amounts of raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. The extraction and processing of these materials can have substantial environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Manufacturing:** The manufacturing process for EVs generally requires more energy compared to gasoline vehicles due to the complexity and energy-intensity of battery production. However, advancements in technology and recycling processes are helping to reduce these impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Raw Material Extraction:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and other materials, which also involve mining and processing. However, the environmental impact is generally lower than that of battery production for EVs.\n- **Manufacturing:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is well-established and typically less energy-intensive than that for EVs, primarily because it does not involve battery production.\n\n### Operation Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Electricity Generation:** The environmental impact of operating EVs largely depends on the source of electricity used for charging. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind or solar, the emissions are minimal. However, if the electricity is generated from coal or natural gas, the emissions can be significant.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Combustion:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter, and other pollutants during fuel combustion. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Efficiency:** Internal combustion engines are less efficient than electric motors, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n\n### Disposal Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Disposal/Recycling:** The disposal of EV batteries poses environmental challenges due to the toxic materials they contain. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable materials and reducing environmental harm.\n- **Vehicle Disposal:** The rest of the EV can be recycled similarly to traditional vehicles, but the focus remains on improving battery recycling.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Vehicle Disposal:** Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle, as they do not contain large batteries. However, the disposal of engine fluids and other hazardous materials must be managed carefully.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, both electric and gasoline vehicles have distinct environmental impacts across their lifecycles. Electric vehicles tend to have higher environmental impacts during the production phase due to battery manufacturing but offer significant advantages during the operation phase, especially when charged with renewable energy. Gasoline vehicles have lower production impacts but contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation. The disposal phase presents challenges for both types, with a particular focus on battery recycling for EVs. Overall, the shift towards renewable energy sources and improved recycling technologies can enhance the environmental benefits of electric vehicles over their lifecycle.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the entire lifecycle of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve looking at the environmental impacts from production, operation, and disposal phases. For electric vehicles, I would consider the extraction and processing of raw materials for batteries, the electricity sources used for charging, and battery disposal or recycling. For gasoline vehicles, I would focus on the extraction, refining, and combustion of fossil fuels. This comprehensive lifecycle assessment would provide a broad view of the environmental impacts across different stages." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the entire lifecycle of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve looking at the environmental impacts from production, operation, and disposal phases. For electric vehicles, I would consider the extraction and processing of raw materials for batteries, the electricity sources used for charging, and battery disposal or recycling. For gasoline vehicles, I would focus on the extraction, refining, and combustion of fossil fuels. This comprehensive lifecycle assessment would provide a broad view of the environmental impacts across different stages.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational emissions of electric versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would analyze the emissions produced during the use phase of the vehicles. For electric vehicles, I would examine the emissions related to electricity generation based on different energy mixes (renewable versus non-renewable sources). For gasoline vehicles, I would discuss the direct emissions from burning gasoline. This strategy allows for an evaluation of the immediate environmental impacts related to vehicle use and highlights the differences in carbon footprints during their operation." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the entire lifecycle of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve looking at the environmental impacts from production, operation, and disposal phases. For electric vehicles, I would consider the extraction and processing of raw materials for batteries, the electricity sources used for charging, and battery disposal or recycling. For gasoline vehicles, I would focus on the extraction, refining, and combustion of fossil fuels. This comprehensive lifecycle assessment would provide a broad view of the environmental impacts across different stages." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:50.671724", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 1 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "a00f9058-2cf5-4e3b-9c12-434c54c8db3a", + "ibfs_id": "80f9f3ed-49da-4e30-807e-6ea515abe5a9", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and reliance on fossil fuels but require energy-intensive battery production, impacting environmental sustainability.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative lifecycle analysis of the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine several stages: production, operation, and end-of-life disposal. Each stage has distinct environmental implications for both types of vehicles.\n\n### 1. Production\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Production**: The production of EVs, particularly the lithium-ion batteries, is resource-intensive. Key materials include lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. Mining and processing these materials can have significant environmental impacts, such as habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Manufacturing Emissions**: EVs generally require more energy to produce than gasoline vehicles, primarily due to the battery. This results in higher initial carbon emissions during manufacturing.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Oil Extraction and Refining**: The production of gasoline vehicles involves the extraction and refining of oil, which can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and significant greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing**: The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is less energy-intensive compared to EVs, resulting in lower initial carbon emissions.\n\n### 2. Operation\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Energy Source**: The environmental impact during the operation of EVs largely depends on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the operational emissions are minimal. However, if it comes from coal or natural gas, the emissions can be significant.\n- **Efficiency**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Fuel Combustion**: Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants during operation. The emissions are directly related to fuel consumption and are a major source of urban air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Efficiency**: Internal combustion engines are less efficient than electric motors, leading to higher energy consumption and emissions per mile driven.\n\n### 3. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Recycling**: The disposal of EV batteries poses environmental challenges. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable materials like lithium and cobalt. Proper recycling can mitigate some environmental impacts.\n- **Vehicle Recycling**: The rest of the vehicle can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, with metals and other materials being reused.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Vehicle Recycling**: Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle, as they do not have large batteries. The metals and other materials can be efficiently recovered and reused.\n- **Waste Oil**: Used oil and other fluids need to be disposed of properly to prevent environmental contamination.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles have a higher environmental impact during the production phase due to battery manufacturing. However, they offer significant benefits during the operation phase, especially if powered by renewable energy, due to their higher efficiency and lower emissions. The end-of-life disposal of EVs, particularly battery recycling, presents challenges but also opportunities for material recovery. Gasoline vehicles have lower initial production emissions but contribute significantly to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation. Their end-of-life disposal is more straightforward but still requires careful handling of waste fluids. Overall, the environmental benefits of EVs become more pronounced as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies advance.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles from production through disposal. This would include analyzing the emissions produced during manufacturing, the resources used (such as lithium for batteries in electric vehicles versus oil for gasoline vehicles), the energy consumption during operation, and the end-of-life recycling or disposal processes. This comprehensive approach would provide a detailed picture of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles from production through disposal. This would include analyzing the emissions produced during manufacturing, the resources used (such as lithium for batteries in electric vehicles versus oil for gasoline vehicles), the energy consumption during operation, and the end-of-life recycling or disposal processes. This comprehensive approach would provide a detailed picture of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both vehicle types, specifically analyzing the emissions during usage and the source of the energy (electricity versus gasoline). I would look into how the electricity for electric vehicles is generated (renewable sources versus fossil fuels) and compare it to the emissions from burning gasoline. This approach highlights the differences in carbon emissions and pollution during the actual use of the vehicles, offering insight into their environmental impact while they are being driven." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles from production through disposal. This would include analyzing the emissions produced during manufacturing, the resources used (such as lithium for batteries in electric vehicles versus oil for gasoline vehicles), the energy consumption during operation, and the end-of-life recycling or disposal processes. This comprehensive approach would provide a detailed picture of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:52.591843", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 0 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "8ac5ec5e-2b64-451e-af70-29e9ed08f127", + "ibfs_id": "a98443f7-ef1a-4882-917e-a383b08211c7", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and reliance on fossil fuels, but battery production and disposal have environmental impacts.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, I reviewed and synthesized findings from current scientific literature and reports from credible sources, including environmental agencies, research institutions, and industry analyses. Here are the key insights:\n\n1. **Greenhouse Gas Emissions**:\n - **Lifecycle Emissions**: According to a report by the International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT), electric vehicles generally produce fewer greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles. This includes emissions from vehicle manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life disposal. The reduction in emissions is more pronounced when the electricity used to charge EVs comes from renewable sources.\n - **Operational Emissions**: EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces GHG emissions during the operational phase compared to gasoline vehicles that emit CO2 and other pollutants directly from combustion.\n\n2. **Air Pollution**:\n - **Local Air Quality**: EVs contribute to improved local air quality because they do not emit nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM) from tailpipes, which are common pollutants from gasoline vehicles. Studies, such as those by the European Environment Agency (EEA), highlight the potential for EVs to reduce urban air pollution significantly.\n - **Upstream Emissions**: While EVs do not emit pollutants during operation, the electricity generation process can contribute to air pollution if fossil fuels are used. However, the shift towards renewable energy sources is mitigating these upstream emissions.\n\n3. **Resource Depletion**:\n - **Battery Production**: The production of lithium-ion batteries for EVs involves mining for materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and water pollution. Reports from the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS) emphasize the need for sustainable mining practices and recycling to minimize these impacts.\n - **Oil Extraction**: Gasoline vehicles rely on oil extraction and refining, which also have substantial environmental impacts, including oil spills and habitat disruption.\n\n4. **Energy Consumption**:\n - **Efficiency**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. The U.S. Department of Energy reports that electric drivetrains convert over 60% of electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, compared to about 20% for gasoline vehicles.\n - **Renewable Energy Integration**: The increasing integration of renewable energy into the grid enhances the environmental benefits of EVs. As more electricity is generated from wind, solar, and other renewable sources, the overall carbon footprint of EVs continues to decrease.\n\n5. **Technological Advancements**:\n - **Battery Technology**: Advances in battery technology, such as increased energy density and reduced reliance on rare materials, are improving the environmental performance of EVs. Research from institutions like the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) suggests that these advancements will further reduce the environmental impact of battery production and disposal.\n - **Renewable Energy**: The transition to renewable energy sources for electricity generation is crucial for maximizing the environmental benefits of EVs. Reports from the International Energy Agency (IEA) indicate that policies promoting renewable energy adoption are key to reducing the carbon footprint of EVs.\n\n**Consensus and Differences**:\nThere is a broad consensus among researchers that EVs offer significant environmental benefits over gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of reducing GHG emissions and improving air quality. However, the extent of these benefits can vary depending on factors such as the energy mix of the electricity grid and the lifecycle management of batteries. Differences in regional energy policies and infrastructure also influence the overall environmental impact of EVs.\n\n**Implications**:\nThe continued development of cleaner energy sources and battery technologies will enhance the environmental advantages of EVs. Policymakers and industry stakeholders are encouraged to support these advancements to ensure that the transition to electric mobility contributes positively to environmental sustainability.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by reviewing and synthesizing current scientific literature and reports from credible sources such as environmental agencies, research institutions, and automotive industry analyses. This approach would involve gathering data and findings from various studies that have evaluated the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles. I would focus on summarizing key insights related to greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, resource depletion, and energy consumption. Additionally, I would highlight any consensus or significant differences among researchers, and discuss the implications of technological advancements, such as improvements in battery technology or the increased use of renewable energy for electricity generation, on the environmental performance of electric vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a detailed comparative analysis of the life cycle assessments (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life cycle\u2014manufacturing, usage, and disposal. I would look into the raw material extraction, especially the mining of lithium for EV batteries, and compare it to the extraction and refining processes for gasoline. Additionally, I would assess the emissions during the vehicle's operation, including tailpipe emissions for gasoline vehicles and the emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs. Finally, I would explore the end-of-life disposal or recycling processes for both types of vehicles and their components.", + "I can answer by reviewing and synthesizing current scientific literature and reports from credible sources such as environmental agencies, research institutions, and automotive industry analyses. This approach would involve gathering data and findings from various studies that have evaluated the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles. I would focus on summarizing key insights related to greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, resource depletion, and energy consumption. Additionally, I would highlight any consensus or significant differences among researchers, and discuss the implications of technological advancements, such as improvements in battery technology or the increased use of renewable energy for electricity generation, on the environmental performance of electric vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by reviewing and synthesizing current scientific literature and reports from credible sources such as environmental agencies, research institutions, and automotive industry analyses. This approach would involve gathering data and findings from various studies that have evaluated the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles. I would focus on summarizing key insights related to greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, resource depletion, and energy consumption. Additionally, I would highlight any consensus or significant differences among researchers, and discuss the implications of technological advancements, such as improvements in battery technology or the increased use of renewable energy for electricity generation, on the environmental performance of electric vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:52.495929", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 3 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "86eb172c-f1f6-469b-a9b1-1c9d38e657b3", + "ibfs_id": "d0a18dcd-b9e3-46ac-ba7e-a95b5f32d4b5", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, but concern remains about battery production and electricity sourcing impact.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we can examine specific environmental metrics such as tailpipe emissions and the energy sources used to power EVs.\n\n### Tailpipe Emissions\n\n1. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Traditional gasoline vehicles emit pollutants directly from their tailpipes. These emissions include carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO), particulate matter (PM), and hydrocarbons (HC). CO2 is a significant greenhouse gas contributing to global warming, while NOx and PM contribute to air pollution and have adverse health effects.\n\n2. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - EVs have zero tailpipe emissions since they do not burn fuel. This means they do not emit CO2, NOx, CO, PM, or HC during operation. This is a significant advantage in terms of reducing urban air pollution and improving air quality.\n\n### Energy Sources\n\n1. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - The environmental impact of gasoline vehicles is primarily linked to the combustion of fossil fuels (gasoline or diesel) derived from crude oil. The extraction, refining, and transportation of these fuels also contribute to environmental degradation and greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n2. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - The environmental impact of EVs depends significantly on the energy mix used to generate electricity. If the electricity comes from renewable sources such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the overall emissions associated with EVs are much lower. However, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels like coal or natural gas, the emissions can be higher.\n - The global energy mix is gradually shifting towards more renewable sources, which enhances the environmental benefits of EVs over time. In regions where the grid is predominantly powered by renewables, EVs have a much smaller carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n### Contribution to Air Pollution and Global Warming\n\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Directly contribute to air pollution through tailpipe emissions. They are a significant source of urban air pollution and greenhouse gases, contributing to global warming.\n\n- **Electric Vehicles:**\n - Indirectly contribute to emissions based on the electricity generation mix. In areas with a high percentage of renewable energy, EVs contribute minimally to air pollution and global warming. In contrast, in regions reliant on coal or natural gas, the benefits are reduced but still generally favorable compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, electric vehicles offer substantial environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in reducing tailpipe emissions and improving air quality. The extent of their advantage in terms of global warming potential depends on the energy sources used to generate electricity. As the energy grid becomes greener with more renewable energy integration, the environmental footprint of electric vehicles will continue to decrease, enhancing their role in mitigating climate change.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by comparing specific environmental metrics such as tailpipe emissions and energy sources. This approach would focus on direct emissions during the operation of both vehicle types and consider the energy mix used to power electric vehicles. By contrasting these factors, we can determine their contribution to air pollution and global warming, and assess how the energy grid's reliance on renewable versus fossil fuels impacts the overall environmental footprint of electric vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the entire lifecycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal. This would provide a comprehensive view of the environmental impacts associated with each stage, including greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution.", + "I can answer by comparing specific environmental metrics such as tailpipe emissions and energy sources. This approach would focus on direct emissions during the operation of both vehicle types and consider the energy mix used to power electric vehicles. By contrasting these factors, we can determine their contribution to air pollution and global warming, and assess how the energy grid's reliance on renewable versus fossil fuels impacts the overall environmental footprint of electric vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by comparing specific environmental metrics such as tailpipe emissions and energy sources. This approach would focus on direct emissions during the operation of both vehicle types and consider the energy mix used to power electric vehicles. By contrasting these factors, we can determine their contribution to air pollution and global warming, and assess how the energy grid's reliance on renewable versus fossil fuels impacts the overall environmental footprint of electric vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:59.120475", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 9 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "00ce6ed7-ce43-495f-891b-687f00418058", + "ibfs_id": "2372cec6-35e1-48a7-a2c6-66748e9d0c8e", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles generally produce fewer emissions over their lifecycle compared to gasoline vehicles, benefiting air quality and reducing greenhouse gases.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a lifecycle assessment (LCA) that encompasses the production, usage, and disposal stages of each vehicle type. This approach allows us to understand the comprehensive environmental footprint of both vehicle types.\n\n### 1. Production Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Raw Material Extraction:** EVs require significant amounts of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other rare earth metals for their batteries. The mining and processing of these materials can lead to habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Manufacturing:** The production of EVs, particularly their batteries, is energy-intensive. This stage often results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in battery technology and manufacturing efficiencies are gradually reducing these emissions.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Raw Material Extraction:** Gasoline vehicles primarily use steel, aluminum, and plastics. While these materials also require energy to extract and process, the environmental impact is generally lower than that of battery materials.\n- **Manufacturing:** The production process for gasoline vehicles is well-established and typically results in lower initial carbon emissions compared to EVs. However, the overall energy consumption is still significant.\n\n### 2. Usage Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Consumption:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions. Their environmental impact during the usage stage depends on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the impact is minimal. However, if it comes from fossil fuels, the emissions can be significant.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Consumption:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants during operation. The combustion of gasoline is less efficient, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n- **Emissions:** The usage stage is where gasoline vehicles have the most significant environmental impact, contributing to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n### 3. Disposal Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal of EVs poses challenges, particularly with battery recycling. While recycling technologies are improving, the process is complex and energy-intensive. Proper recycling can mitigate some environmental impacts by recovering valuable materials.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** The rest of the vehicle can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, with metals and plastics being reclaimed.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle, with established processes for reclaiming metals and other materials. However, the disposal of fluids and other hazardous materials remains a concern.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, the lifecycle assessment reveals that electric vehicles have a higher environmental impact during the production stage due to battery manufacturing. However, they offer significant benefits during the usage stage, especially when powered by renewable energy, due to their higher efficiency and zero tailpipe emissions. Gasoline vehicles, while having lower production emissions, contribute more significantly to environmental degradation during their operational life due to fossil fuel combustion. The disposal stage presents challenges for both vehicle types, particularly in battery recycling for EVs. Overall, the transition to electric vehicles can lead to reduced environmental impacts, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery technologies advance.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by analyzing lifecycle assessments (LCAs) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts from production, usage, and disposal stages of each vehicle type. By breaking down these stages, I can highlight specific areas where EVs and gasoline vehicles differ in their environmental footprints, such as the sourcing of raw materials, energy consumption during operation, and end-of-life recycling processes." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive literature review of scientific studies and reports that compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve summarizing findings on various metrics such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource extraction impacts, and potential pollution from both vehicle types, providing a balanced view based on current research.", + "I can answer by analyzing lifecycle assessments (LCAs) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts from production, usage, and disposal stages of each vehicle type. By breaking down these stages, I can highlight specific areas where EVs and gasoline vehicles differ in their environmental footprints, such as the sourcing of raw materials, energy consumption during operation, and end-of-life recycling processes." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by analyzing lifecycle assessments (LCAs) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts from production, usage, and disposal stages of each vehicle type. By breaking down these stages, I can highlight specific areas where EVs and gasoline vehicles differ in their environmental footprints, such as the sourcing of raw materials, energy consumption during operation, and end-of-life recycling processes." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:59.518719", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 6 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "394e92d2-d34e-4cb1-861d-08bed5b5fb48", + "ibfs_id": "a0427723-887b-49c3-b7de-c44a23e8b29c", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce lower emissions, use sustainable energy, decrease air pollution but involve battery-related environmental challenges in mining and recycling.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine the emissions and energy sources associated with each during their operational phase.\n\n### Emissions from Gasoline Vehicles\n\nGasoline vehicles rely on internal combustion engines that burn fossil fuels, primarily gasoline, to operate. This combustion process directly emits several pollutants and greenhouse gases (GHGs) into the atmosphere, including:\n\n1. **Carbon Dioxide (CO2):** A significant greenhouse gas contributing to climate change. Gasoline vehicles emit CO2 as a byproduct of burning fossil fuels.\n2. **Nitrogen Oxides (NOx):** These contribute to smog and respiratory problems.\n3. **Particulate Matter (PM):** Tiny particles that can penetrate deep into the lungs and cause health issues.\n4. **Carbon Monoxide (CO):** A toxic gas that can be harmful in high concentrations.\n5. **Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs):** Contribute to the formation of ground-level ozone and smog.\n\nThe emissions from gasoline vehicles are directly released into the environment during operation, contributing significantly to air pollution and climate change.\n\n### Emissions from Electric Vehicles\n\nElectric vehicles, on the other hand, do not have tailpipe emissions. However, their environmental impact depends largely on the source of the electricity used to charge them:\n\n1. **Renewable Energy Sources (e.g., wind, solar, hydroelectric):** If the electricity used to charge EVs comes from renewable sources, the emissions associated with their operation are minimal. This scenario significantly reduces the carbon footprint of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles.\n \n2. **Fossil Fuel-Based Electricity (e.g., coal, natural gas):** If the electricity is generated from fossil fuels, EVs indirectly contribute to emissions. The extent of these emissions depends on the energy mix of the grid. For example, coal-fired power plants emit high levels of CO2, NOx, and other pollutants, whereas natural gas plants have a lower emissions profile.\n\n### Comparative Analysis\n\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** On average, EVs tend to have lower GHG emissions than gasoline vehicles, especially in regions where the electricity grid is cleaner or transitioning towards renewable energy. Even in areas with a significant portion of electricity from fossil fuels, EVs often still result in lower overall emissions due to the higher efficiency of electric motors compared to internal combustion engines.\n\n- **Air Pollutants:** EVs contribute to reduced air pollution in urban areas since they do not emit NOx, PM, or VOCs during operation. This can lead to improved air quality and public health benefits.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe environmental impact of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles is largely contingent upon the energy sources used for electricity generation. While EVs have the potential to significantly reduce emissions and improve air quality, maximizing these benefits requires a shift towards cleaner, renewable energy sources for electricity production. In contrast, gasoline vehicles consistently emit pollutants and GHGs directly during their operation, contributing to environmental degradation and climate change.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy source differences between electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would involve comparing the greenhouse gas emissions and air pollutants produced by each type of vehicle during operation. For electric vehicles, I would consider the source of the electricity, whether it's from renewable sources or fossil fuels, to evaluate their true emissions impact. For gasoline vehicles, I would analyze the direct emissions from combustion engines. This approach highlights the operational phase and energy sourcing as key factors in the environmental impact comparison." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis for both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts of each type of vehicle from production to disposal. I would assess factors such as the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. This comprehensive analysis would provide a detailed comparison of the overall environmental footprint of electric versus gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy source differences between electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would involve comparing the greenhouse gas emissions and air pollutants produced by each type of vehicle during operation. For electric vehicles, I would consider the source of the electricity, whether it's from renewable sources or fossil fuels, to evaluate their true emissions impact. For gasoline vehicles, I would analyze the direct emissions from combustion engines. This approach highlights the operational phase and energy sourcing as key factors in the environmental impact comparison." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy source differences between electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would involve comparing the greenhouse gas emissions and air pollutants produced by each type of vehicle during operation. For electric vehicles, I would consider the source of the electricity, whether it's from renewable sources or fossil fuels, to evaluate their true emissions impact. For gasoline vehicles, I would analyze the direct emissions from combustion engines. This approach highlights the operational phase and energy sourcing as key factors in the environmental impact comparison." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:04.102044", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 7 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "de405556-9935-4e7b-9761-2a2d1f6d3e31", + "ibfs_id": "1dccd8e5-c222-45d1-833a-e02ba7fb3ccc", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce fewer emissions, reduce dependency on fossil fuels, and contribute less pollution compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative analysis of the lifecycle emissions of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will examine the emissions produced during the manufacturing, operation, and disposal phases of each vehicle type. This analysis draws from various studies and reports that provide insights into the carbon footprint and energy consumption associated with both types of vehicles.\n\n### Manufacturing Phase\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - The manufacturing of EVs generally results in higher emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to the production of lithium-ion batteries. The extraction and processing of raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel are energy-intensive and contribute significantly to the carbon footprint.\n - According to a study by the Union of Concerned Scientists, the production emissions of an EV can be about 15% to 68% higher than those of a gasoline vehicle, depending on the size of the battery.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles involves emissions from the production of steel, aluminum, and other materials, but these are typically lower than the emissions associated with EV battery production.\n - Overall, the manufacturing emissions for gasoline vehicles are relatively lower compared to EVs, but this advantage diminishes over the vehicle's lifecycle.\n\n### Operation Phase\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces their operational carbon footprint. However, the total emissions depend on the electricity source used for charging.\n - In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources, the operational emissions of EVs are minimal. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, the emissions can be higher.\n - The International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT) reports that even in regions with a high percentage of fossil fuel-based electricity, EVs still have lower operational emissions than gasoline vehicles.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe during operation.\n - The operational emissions are consistent and depend on fuel efficiency and driving habits. On average, gasoline vehicles emit about 4.6 metric tons of CO2 per year, according to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).\n\n### Disposal Phase\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - The disposal phase of EVs involves recycling or disposing of batteries, which can be environmentally challenging. However, advancements in battery recycling technologies are reducing the environmental impact.\n - Proper recycling can recover valuable materials and reduce the need for new raw material extraction, thus lowering the lifecycle emissions.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - The disposal of gasoline vehicles involves recycling metals and other materials, which is a well-established process with a relatively lower environmental impact compared to battery disposal.\n - However, the end-of-life emissions are generally lower than those of EVs due to the absence of large batteries.\n\n### Overall Lifecycle Emissions\n\n- **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - Despite higher manufacturing emissions, EVs tend to have lower overall lifecycle emissions due to their cleaner operation phase. The reduction in emissions is more pronounced over time as the electricity grid becomes greener.\n - Studies, such as those by the European Environment Agency, indicate that EVs can reduce lifecycle emissions by about 30% to 50% compared to gasoline vehicles, depending on the electricity mix.\n\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Gasoline vehicles have lower manufacturing emissions but higher operational emissions, leading to a higher overall carbon footprint over their lifecycle.\n - The lack of tailpipe emissions reduction technology means that gasoline vehicles will continue to have a significant environmental impact unless offset by other means.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs have higher emissions during the manufacturing phase, their overall lifecycle emissions are generally lower than those of traditional gasoline vehicles, especially as the energy grid becomes more reliant on renewable sources. This makes EVs a more environmentally friendly option in the long term.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the lifecycle emissions of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the emissions produced during the manufacturing, operation, and disposal phases of each vehicle type. I would gather data from studies and reports that provide insights into the carbon footprint and energy consumption associated with both EVs and gasoline vehicles, highlighting key differences and similarities in their environmental impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the lifecycle emissions of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the emissions produced during the manufacturing, operation, and disposal phases of each vehicle type. I would gather data from studies and reports that provide insights into the carbon footprint and energy consumption associated with both EVs and gasoline vehicles, highlighting key differences and similarities in their environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by evaluating the broader ecological effects of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles beyond just emissions. This strategy would look at factors such as the environmental impact of raw material extraction (like lithium for EV batteries), the energy sources used for electricity generation, and the potential for pollution from battery disposal. Additionally, I would consider the impacts on ecosystems, such as habitat disruption from mining activities, and compare these to the effects of oil extraction and refining for gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the lifecycle emissions of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the emissions produced during the manufacturing, operation, and disposal phases of each vehicle type. I would gather data from studies and reports that provide insights into the carbon footprint and energy consumption associated with both EVs and gasoline vehicles, highlighting key differences and similarities in their environmental impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:10.805611", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 8 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c5d4f863-7530-4534-a9ee-640fc803cf2d", + "ibfs_id": "76036b0c-d83c-434c-8715-b7e107d106b0", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles greatly reduce emissions during operation but entail environmental concerns from battery production and electricity generation impacts.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles using a regional lifecycle assessment, we need to consider several factors that vary by location, including the energy grid composition, resource availability, and recycling capabilities. This analysis will focus on three distinct regions: a coal-heavy grid, a renewable-heavy grid, and a region with moderate renewable integration.\n\n### Region 1: Coal-Heavy Grid (e.g., parts of the Midwest, USA)\n\n**Energy Production:**\n- **Electric Vehicles (EVs):** In regions where the electricity grid is predominantly powered by coal, the environmental benefits of EVs are reduced. The high carbon emissions associated with coal-fired power plants mean that charging EVs can result in significant greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, potentially offsetting the benefits of zero tailpipe emissions.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles emit GHGs directly through combustion. In a coal-heavy region, the lifecycle emissions of gasoline vehicles might be comparable to or even lower than those of EVs, depending on the specific grid mix.\n\n**Resource Availability and Recycling:**\n- **EVs:** The production of EV batteries requires significant mineral resources, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel. If the region lacks robust recycling facilities, the environmental impact of mining and processing these materials can be substantial.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The extraction and refining of oil also have environmental impacts, but these are more established processes with existing infrastructure.\n\n### Region 2: Renewable-Heavy Grid (e.g., parts of Scandinavia)\n\n**Energy Production:**\n- **Electric Vehicles (EVs):** In regions where the grid is powered largely by renewables like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, EVs have a clear environmental advantage. The low-carbon electricity significantly reduces the lifecycle GHG emissions of EVs, making them a much cleaner option compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** Despite improvements in fuel efficiency, gasoline vehicles continue to emit GHGs and other pollutants directly, making them less environmentally friendly in regions with clean energy grids.\n\n**Resource Availability and Recycling:**\n- **EVs:** Regions with advanced recycling technologies can mitigate the environmental impact of battery production by recovering valuable materials, reducing the need for new mining operations.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The environmental impact remains relatively constant, as the primary emissions are from fuel combustion.\n\n### Region 3: Moderate Renewable Integration (e.g., parts of California, USA)\n\n**Energy Production:**\n- **Electric Vehicles (EVs):** In regions with a balanced mix of renewables and fossil fuels, the environmental impact of EVs is moderate. The cleaner the grid, the more beneficial EVs become in terms of reducing GHG emissions.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** While still emitting GHGs, the impact is less severe compared to a coal-heavy region but remains higher than EVs in a renewable-heavy region.\n\n**Resource Availability and Recycling:**\n- **EVs:** With moderate recycling capabilities, the region can partially offset the environmental impact of battery production by reusing materials.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The environmental impact is primarily dependent on fuel efficiency and emissions standards.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles vary significantly by region due to differences in energy grid composition and resource management capabilities. In regions with renewable-heavy grids, EVs offer substantial environmental benefits over gasoline vehicles. Conversely, in coal-heavy regions, the benefits of EVs are diminished, and their lifecycle emissions may be comparable to those of gasoline vehicles. Regions with moderate renewable integration see a mixed impact, with EVs generally offering a cleaner alternative, especially as grid decarbonization progresses. Additionally, local recycling capabilities play a crucial role in mitigating the environmental impacts associated with the production and disposal of EV batteries.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach will consider factors such as the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By evaluating the entire lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each vehicle type affects the environment in terms of carbon emissions, resource consumption, and pollution.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle assessment that takes into account the geographical variations in energy production and resource availability. This approach will analyze how the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles differ depending on the regional energy grid composition (e.g., coal-heavy versus renewable-heavy) and local recycling capabilities. By tailoring the lifecycle analysis to specific regions, I can provide insights into how location influences the environmental benefits or drawbacks of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach will consider factors such as the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By evaluating the entire lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each vehicle type affects the environment in terms of carbon emissions, resource consumption, and pollution.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase and analyzing the direct emissions and energy consumption of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This strategy involves examining the emissions produced during vehicle use, particularly the greenhouse gases emitted from gasoline combustion compared to the emissions from electricity generation that powers EVs. Additionally, I will consider the energy efficiency of each vehicle type and how the energy source mix (renewables versus fossil fuels) influences the overall environmental impact during the operational phase." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach will consider factors such as the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By evaluating the entire lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each vehicle type affects the environment in terms of carbon emissions, resource consumption, and pollution." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a detailed cradle-to-grave analysis, which delves into each stage of the vehicle's life separately. This approach will start with the extraction of raw materials, move through the manufacturing and assembly processes, continue with the energy use and emissions during the vehicle's operational phase, and conclude with disposal or recycling processes. By breaking down each phase, I can identify specific areas where electric vehicles outperform or fall short compared to gasoline vehicles in terms of environmental impact.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle assessment that takes into account the geographical variations in energy production and resource availability. This approach will analyze how the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles differ depending on the regional energy grid composition (e.g., coal-heavy versus renewable-heavy) and local recycling capabilities. By tailoring the lifecycle analysis to specific regions, I can provide insights into how location influences the environmental benefits or drawbacks of each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle assessment that takes into account the geographical variations in energy production and resource availability. This approach will analyze how the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles differ depending on the regional energy grid composition (e.g., coal-heavy versus renewable-heavy) and local recycling capabilities. By tailoring the lifecycle analysis to specific regions, I can provide insights into how location influences the environmental benefits or drawbacks of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:15.022897", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 10 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "4eb26326-ee83-48c1-b059-98bb13ce5496", + "ibfs_id": "6910ba0c-178c-4a41-90cc-6c3c065eb400", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and reliance on fossil fuels but involve battery production and recycling challenges impacting the environment.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles during the production phase, we need to examine the sourcing and processing of raw materials, as well as the energy consumption and emissions associated with manufacturing each type of vehicle.\n\n### Electric Vehicles (EVs)\n\n#### Raw Materials and Production\n\n1. **Lithium-ion Batteries**: \n - **Lithium**: The production of lithium-ion batteries, which are crucial for EVs, requires significant amounts of lithium. Lithium is primarily extracted from brine pools or hard rock mining. Both methods have environmental impacts. Brine extraction, common in South America, involves pumping water into underground reservoirs to bring lithium to the surface, which can lead to water depletion and contamination. Hard rock mining, prevalent in Australia, involves more energy-intensive processes and can result in habitat destruction.\n - **Cobalt and Nickel**: These metals are also critical for battery production. Cobalt mining, often concentrated in the Democratic Republic of Congo, has been associated with severe environmental degradation, including soil and water pollution. Nickel mining can lead to deforestation and soil erosion.\n - **Graphite**: Used as an anode material, graphite mining can result in air and water pollution due to the release of fine particles and chemicals.\n\n2. **Energy Consumption and Emissions**:\n - The production of EV batteries is energy-intensive, often relying on electricity from fossil fuels, which contributes to greenhouse gas emissions. The carbon footprint of battery production can be significant, depending on the energy mix of the manufacturing location.\n - Manufacturing the rest of the EV (body, electronics, etc.) is similar to traditional vehicles in terms of energy use and emissions.\n\n### Traditional Gasoline Vehicles\n\n#### Raw Materials and Production\n\n1. **Steel and Aluminum**:\n - **Steel**: The production of steel, a primary material in gasoline vehicles, involves mining iron ore and using coal in blast furnaces. This process is energy-intensive and emits significant amounts of CO2. Steel production is one of the largest industrial sources of greenhouse gases.\n - **Aluminum**: Used for lighter vehicle components, aluminum production involves bauxite mining and electrolysis, which is also energy-intensive and can result in significant emissions and environmental degradation.\n\n2. **Plastics and Other Materials**:\n - Derived from petroleum, the production of plastics used in vehicles involves chemical processes that emit greenhouse gases and other pollutants.\n\n3. **Energy Consumption and Emissions**:\n - The overall energy consumption for manufacturing a gasoline vehicle is generally lower than that for an EV, primarily due to the absence of a large battery pack. However, the emissions from steel and aluminum production contribute significantly to the vehicle's initial carbon footprint.\n\n### Comparative Analysis\n\n- **Emissions**: The production of EVs, particularly the battery, tends to result in higher initial emissions compared to traditional gasoline vehicles. However, this is often offset over the vehicle's lifetime due to the lower emissions during operation.\n- **Resource Extraction**: EV production involves more intensive mining activities for battery materials, which can have localized environmental impacts. In contrast, gasoline vehicles rely more heavily on steel and aluminum, with significant emissions from their production processes.\n- **Energy Use**: The energy required for producing EVs is generally higher, largely due to battery manufacturing. The environmental impact of this energy use depends on the energy sources of the manufacturing region.\n\nIn conclusion, while the production phase of EVs has a higher environmental impact in terms of emissions and resource extraction compared to gasoline vehicles, the overall environmental benefits of EVs can become apparent when considering their entire lifecycle, including the operational phase.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts from the production, use, and disposal phases of both types of vehicles. I would look into the materials used in manufacturing, the energy sources for vehicle operation, and the recycling processes at the end of a vehicle's life. This analysis would provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of both vehicle types throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the production phase of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy involves a deep dive into the environmental impacts associated with sourcing and processing raw materials, such as lithium for EV batteries and steel for gasoline vehicles. By analyzing the energy consumption and emissions during the manufacturing process, I can provide insights into how the initial production stage contributes to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts from the production, use, and disposal phases of both types of vehicles. I would look into the materials used in manufacturing, the energy sources for vehicle operation, and the recycling processes at the end of a vehicle's life. This analysis would provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of both vehicle types throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by evaluating the emissions and pollution differences between electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would focus on the operational phase, analyzing the direct emissions produced by gasoline vehicles compared to the indirect emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs. I would consider factors such as the carbon intensity of the electricity grid, advancements in battery technology, and the potential for renewable energy integration, providing insights into how these factors influence the overall environmental impact of each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts from the production, use, and disposal phases of both types of vehicles. I would look into the materials used in manufacturing, the energy sources for vehicle operation, and the recycling processes at the end of a vehicle's life. This analysis would provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of both vehicle types throughout their entire lifecycles." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the production phase of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy involves a deep dive into the environmental impacts associated with sourcing and processing raw materials, such as lithium for EV batteries and steel for gasoline vehicles. By analyzing the energy consumption and emissions during the manufacturing process, I can provide insights into how the initial production stage contributes to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by emphasizing the use phase of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the differences in emissions and energy consumption when these vehicles are in operation. For EVs, I would explore how the source of electricity (renewable vs. non-renewable) impacts their environmental benefits, while for gasoline vehicles, I would assess the emissions from fuel combustion and their efficiency. This analysis would highlight how the operational phase contributes to the total environmental impact over the vehicles' lifetimes." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing specifically on the production phase of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy involves a deep dive into the environmental impacts associated with sourcing and processing raw materials, such as lithium for EV batteries and steel for gasoline vehicles. By analyzing the energy consumption and emissions during the manufacturing process, I can provide insights into how the initial production stage contributes to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:18.607942", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 12 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "66366a9f-3fdf-4ca1-ab83-5b1c43b1a4df", + "ibfs_id": "e44ba9ee-a410-4b94-9795-15927e74c9cc", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but battery production and disposal have environmental impacts compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through a stakeholder-focused lifecycle analysis, we will consider the perspectives of three main stakeholders: manufacturers, consumers, and policymakers. This analysis will cover the stages of material sourcing, production, use, and disposal.\n\n### Manufacturers\n\n**Material Sourcing:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** Manufacturers of EVs face significant environmental challenges in sourcing materials, particularly for batteries. The extraction of lithium, cobalt, and nickel can lead to habitat destruction, water pollution, and high carbon emissions. These impacts are critical for manufacturers to manage, as sustainable sourcing becomes a competitive advantage and a regulatory requirement.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The primary environmental concern is the extraction and refining of oil for fuel. While the materials for vehicle construction (steel, aluminum) are similar to EVs, the ongoing demand for oil has significant environmental impacts, including oil spills and greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n**Production:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** The production of EVs, especially battery manufacturing, is energy-intensive and can result in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. Manufacturers must invest in cleaner production technologies and renewable energy sources to mitigate these impacts.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The production process is relatively mature and optimized, but still involves significant energy use and emissions. Manufacturers are pressured to improve efficiency and reduce emissions in line with environmental standards.\n\n### Consumers\n\n**Energy Consumption During Use:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** Consumers benefit from lower emissions during the use phase, as EVs produce no tailpipe emissions. The environmental impact largely depends on the electricity source; renewable energy significantly reduces the carbon footprint. Consumers are increasingly aware of this and may choose EVs based on the availability of clean energy.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles emit CO2 and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change. Consumers face increasing fuel costs and potential restrictions in urban areas due to emissions.\n\n**Cost and Maintenance:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** While EVs often have higher upfront costs, they generally have lower operating and maintenance costs due to fewer moving parts and the absence of oil changes. Consumers are attracted to these long-term savings and the environmental benefits.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** Typically cheaper upfront, but with higher fuel and maintenance costs over time. Consumers may prioritize short-term affordability over long-term environmental impact.\n\n### Policymakers\n\n**Regulatory and Environmental Impact:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** Policymakers are focused on promoting EV adoption to reduce urban air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. Incentives such as tax credits, rebates, and infrastructure investments (charging stations) are common strategies to encourage EV use.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** Policymakers are increasingly imposing stricter emissions standards and fuel efficiency requirements. There is a push for transitioning to cleaner alternatives to meet climate goals.\n\n**End-of-Life and Disposal:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** The disposal and recycling of batteries present significant environmental challenges. Policymakers are concerned with developing effective recycling programs and regulations to manage battery waste and recover valuable materials.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** End-of-life disposal involves recycling metals and managing hazardous materials like oil and coolants. While established, these processes still have environmental impacts that require oversight.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nFrom a stakeholder-focused lifecycle analysis, electric vehicles present both challenges and opportunities across their lifecycle stages. Manufacturers must address the environmental impacts of material sourcing and production, consumers benefit from lower emissions and operating costs, and policymakers see EVs as a critical component of reducing transportation-related emissions. Conversely, gasoline vehicles have a more established lifecycle with significant emissions during use, presenting ongoing environmental challenges for all stakeholders. This nuanced understanding highlights the importance of collaboration among stakeholders to maximize the environmental benefits of transitioning to electric vehicles.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which includes examining the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach will involve looking at the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By assessing these stages, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each type of vehicle affects the environment throughout its entire lifecycle.", + "I can answer by performing a stakeholder-focused lifecycle analysis, which considers the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles from the perspectives of various stakeholders such as manufacturers, consumers, and policymakers. This approach will involve evaluating how each stage of the vehicle lifecycle affects these stakeholders differently, including the sourcing of materials, energy consumption during vehicle use, and disposal practices. By addressing the concerns and priorities of each stakeholder group, I can deliver a nuanced understanding of the environmental implications for each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which includes examining the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach will involve looking at the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By assessing these stages, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each type of vehicle affects the environment throughout its entire lifecycle.", + "I can answer by investigating the specific environmental impacts of the energy sources used to power electric vehicles compared to the emissions from gasoline vehicles. This approach will focus on analyzing the carbon footprint and pollution associated with electricity generation (e.g., coal, natural gas, renewables) versus the emissions resulting directly from burning gasoline. Additionally, I can consider how regional energy grids and their reliance on different energy sources can influence the overall environmental benefits or drawbacks of using EVs in various locations." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which includes examining the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach will involve looking at the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By assessing these stages, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each type of vehicle affects the environment throughout its entire lifecycle." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle analysis, focusing on how geographic factors influence the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach will involve examining the variations in raw material availability, energy sources for manufacturing and charging, and local recycling infrastructure in different regions. By assessing these regional differences, I can provide insights into how the environmental impacts of vehicles may vary depending on where they are produced, operated, and disposed of.", + "I can answer by performing a stakeholder-focused lifecycle analysis, which considers the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles from the perspectives of various stakeholders such as manufacturers, consumers, and policymakers. This approach will involve evaluating how each stage of the vehicle lifecycle affects these stakeholders differently, including the sourcing of materials, energy consumption during vehicle use, and disposal practices. By addressing the concerns and priorities of each stakeholder group, I can deliver a nuanced understanding of the environmental implications for each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by performing a stakeholder-focused lifecycle analysis, which considers the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles from the perspectives of various stakeholders such as manufacturers, consumers, and policymakers. This approach will involve evaluating how each stage of the vehicle lifecycle affects these stakeholders differently, including the sourcing of materials, energy consumption during vehicle use, and disposal practices. By addressing the concerns and priorities of each stakeholder group, I can deliver a nuanced understanding of the environmental implications for each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:19.572955", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 11 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "41bd84ff-7932-4064-9d28-8263bd354890", + "ibfs_id": "6625dfcc-ed3b-496c-8cf5-fc06e1fd95de", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles generally reduce emissions long-term, but battery production has significant environmental impacts compared to gasoline vehicle manufacturing.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we must consider the entire life cycle of each vehicle type, focusing on the energy sources used at each stage. This includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Lithium Mining:** EVs rely heavily on lithium-ion batteries, which require the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other materials. Lithium is primarily extracted through mining or evaporation from brine pools, processes that can lead to significant environmental impacts. Mining can result in habitat destruction, water pollution, and high water usage, particularly in arid regions like the Atacama Desert in Chile.\n- **Cobalt and Nickel:** These materials are often mined in regions with less stringent environmental regulations, leading to deforestation, soil erosion, and pollution. Cobalt mining, particularly in the Democratic Republic of Congo, has raised concerns about human rights and environmental degradation.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Crude Oil Extraction:** The extraction of crude oil involves drilling, which can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and pollution. Offshore drilling poses risks to marine ecosystems, while onshore drilling can impact local wildlife and water resources. The refining process also generates significant emissions and waste.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in battery technology and manufacturing efficiency are gradually reducing this impact.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Traditional vehicles have a less energy-intensive manufacturing process compared to EVs, primarily due to the absence of large battery packs. However, the production of internal combustion engines and associated components still contributes to environmental pollution.\n\n### 3. Operation\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Electricity Generation:** The carbon footprint of operating an EV largely depends on the energy mix used to generate electricity. In regions where electricity is primarily generated from renewable sources (e.g., wind, solar, hydro), EVs have a significantly lower carbon footprint. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, the benefits are reduced but still generally favorable compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Combustion Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change. The efficiency of gasoline engines is lower than that of electric motors, leading to higher emissions per mile driven.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose environmental challenges. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, reducing the need for new mining.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like traditional vehicles, EVs can be recycled for their metal components, though the battery remains a key focus for environmental impact.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Traditional vehicles are generally recycled for their metal content, but the disposal of fluids and other components can lead to environmental issues if not managed properly.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, while electric vehicles have a higher environmental impact during the manufacturing phase due to battery production, they offer significant advantages during the operational phase, especially in regions with clean electricity grids. The reduction in tailpipe emissions and improved energy efficiency contribute to a lower overall carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. However, the environmental benefits of EVs are contingent on responsible sourcing of raw materials and advancements in battery recycling technologies.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the full life cycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would include assessing the environmental impacts during the manufacturing process, the source and type of energy used for operation (electricity vs. gasoline), and the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes. By evaluating each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by focusing on a detailed breakdown of the energy sources used throughout the life cycle of electric and gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the environmental impacts of extracting raw materials, especially the mining of lithium for electric vehicle batteries versus crude oil extraction for gasoline. Additionally, I would assess the carbon footprint of electricity generation for electric vehicles compared to gasoline combustion in traditional vehicles, considering regional variations in energy sources." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the full life cycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would include assessing the environmental impacts during the manufacturing process, the source and type of energy used for operation (electricity vs. gasoline), and the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes. By evaluating each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, specifically analyzing their emissions and energy efficiency during use. For electric vehicles, this would involve examining the carbon intensity of electricity grids in different regions, while for gasoline vehicles, it would involve assessing tailpipe emissions and fuel consumption. This approach would help highlight the differences in emissions and energy use once the vehicles are on the road." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the full life cycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would include assessing the environmental impacts during the manufacturing process, the source and type of energy used for operation (electricity vs. gasoline), and the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes. By evaluating each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of both vehicle types." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a detailed breakdown of the energy sources used throughout the life cycle of electric and gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the environmental impacts of extracting raw materials, especially the mining of lithium for electric vehicle batteries versus crude oil extraction for gasoline. Additionally, I would assess the carbon footprint of electricity generation for electric vehicles compared to gasoline combustion in traditional vehicles, considering regional variations in energy sources.", + "I can answer by conducting a sector-specific impact assessment, where I evaluate the environmental effects of electric and gasoline vehicles within different sectors, such as urban versus rural environments. In this approach, I would examine how the manufacturing, operational, and disposal stages of vehicles differently affect air quality, noise pollution, and waste management in these areas. This strategy would highlight how the environmental impacts vary based on the context in which the vehicles are used." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on a detailed breakdown of the energy sources used throughout the life cycle of electric and gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the environmental impacts of extracting raw materials, especially the mining of lithium for electric vehicle batteries versus crude oil extraction for gasoline. Additionally, I would assess the carbon footprint of electricity generation for electric vehicles compared to gasoline combustion in traditional vehicles, considering regional variations in energy sources." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:22.827542", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 13 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "5a2eab31-8be5-431f-bae7-6618ece85f34", + "ibfs_id": "f4866d16-c3e0-477b-9bd3-0ca8ef592a4d", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution over their lifecycle, but battery production creates significant environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative analysis of the environmental impacts of the manufacturing processes of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to focus on several key aspects: energy consumption, emissions, and waste generation during the production of their respective components, particularly batteries for EVs and engines for gasoline vehicles.\n\n### Energy Consumption\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- The manufacturing of EVs, particularly the battery production, is energy-intensive. Lithium-ion batteries, which are commonly used in EVs, require significant amounts of energy to extract and process raw materials like lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite.\n- The energy consumption for producing these batteries is substantial, often resulting in higher initial energy use compared to the manufacturing of internal combustion engines (ICEs) for gasoline vehicles.\n- However, advancements in battery technology and manufacturing processes are gradually reducing the energy intensity of battery production.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The production of traditional gasoline vehicles involves the manufacturing of internal combustion engines, which is less energy-intensive compared to the production of EV batteries.\n- The energy required to produce steel and aluminum for engine components is significant, but generally less than the energy required for battery production in EVs.\n\n### Emissions\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- The production of EV batteries is associated with higher greenhouse gas emissions compared to the production of gasoline engines. This is primarily due to the energy-intensive processes involved in mining and refining the raw materials.\n- Emissions from battery production can vary significantly depending on the energy sources used in the manufacturing process. For instance, if the electricity used comes from renewable sources, the emissions can be considerably lower.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The emissions from manufacturing gasoline vehicles are generally lower than those from EVs, primarily because engine production is less energy-intensive.\n- However, the overall emissions from gasoline vehicles during their lifecycle are higher due to the combustion of fossil fuels during operation, which is not a factor in the manufacturing phase but is relevant for the vehicle's total environmental impact.\n\n### Waste Generation\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- The production of EV batteries generates waste, including chemical byproducts and spent materials from mining operations.\n- Proper disposal and recycling of batteries are critical to minimizing waste and environmental harm. The development of efficient recycling processes is essential to manage the waste associated with EV battery production.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The manufacturing of gasoline engines produces waste in the form of metal shavings, used lubricants, and other byproducts of metalworking processes.\n- The waste generated is generally less hazardous compared to the chemical waste from battery production, but it still requires proper management and disposal.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, the manufacturing phase of electric vehicles, particularly the production of lithium-ion batteries, is more energy-intensive and generates higher emissions compared to the production of traditional gasoline engines. However, the environmental impact of EVs can be mitigated by using cleaner energy sources for manufacturing and improving battery recycling processes. On the other hand, while gasoline vehicle production has a lower environmental impact during manufacturing, the overall lifecycle emissions from these vehicles are higher due to fuel combustion. As battery technology improves and manufacturing processes become more efficient, the environmental footprint of EV production is expected to decrease, potentially making them a more sustainable option in the long term.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the entire lifecycle of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include evaluating the environmental impacts of raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By considering the full lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each type of vehicle affects the environment across its lifespan.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that focuses specifically on the environmental impacts of the manufacturing processes of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include a detailed examination of the energy consumption, emissions, and waste generation associated with the production of components like batteries for EVs and engines for gasoline vehicles. By concentrating on the manufacturing phase, I can provide insights into how the production of each type of vehicle contributes to its overall environmental footprint." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the entire lifecycle of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include evaluating the environmental impacts of raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By considering the full lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each type of vehicle affects the environment across its lifespan.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, specifically analyzing emissions and energy consumption during use. This approach would involve comparing the carbon footprint and pollutant emissions of electric vehicles, which rely on electricity (potentially from renewable sources), to the emissions produced by burning gasoline in traditional vehicles. This strategy highlights the immediate environmental benefits of reduced emissions from using electric vehicles on the road." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the entire lifecycle of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include evaluating the environmental impacts of raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By considering the full lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each type of vehicle affects the environment across its lifespan." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that focuses specifically on the environmental impacts of the manufacturing processes of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include a detailed examination of the energy consumption, emissions, and waste generation associated with the production of components like batteries for EVs and engines for gasoline vehicles. By concentrating on the manufacturing phase, I can provide insights into how the production of each type of vehicle contributes to its overall environmental footprint.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that emphasizes the environmental impacts during the operational phase of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the emissions produced during vehicle operation, the energy sources and efficiency of EVs compared to gasoline consumption, and the long-term effects of these factors on air quality and climate change. By focusing on the use phase, I can illuminate how the day-to-day operation of each vehicle type affects the environment." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that focuses specifically on the environmental impacts of the manufacturing processes of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include a detailed examination of the energy consumption, emissions, and waste generation associated with the production of components like batteries for EVs and engines for gasoline vehicles. By concentrating on the manufacturing phase, I can provide insights into how the production of each type of vehicle contributes to its overall environmental footprint." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:28.585785", + "similarity_score": 0.7, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 15 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "7eef3907-d175-4235-a824-4a938c18414f", + "ibfs_id": "b51d7188-912e-4abc-b76d-785c40ba9cf5", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and dependence on fossil fuels but require resource-intensive battery production and electricity generation improvements.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a time-sensitive life-cycle analysis comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to consider several key factors that have evolved over time and will continue to change in the future. These factors include technological advancements, shifts in energy sources, and improvements in recycling methods. By analyzing historical data and projecting future trends, we can gain insights into how the sustainability of both vehicle types is likely to evolve.\n\n### Historical Context and Technological Advancements\n\n1. **Manufacturing and Materials:**\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Traditionally, gasoline vehicles have relied on internal combustion engines (ICEs) with a focus on improving fuel efficiency and reducing emissions through catalytic converters and better engine designs.\n - **Electric Vehicles:** Initially, EVs faced challenges with battery technology, particularly in terms of energy density and cost. However, over the past decade, there have been significant advancements in lithium-ion battery technology, leading to increased range, reduced costs, and improved energy efficiency.\n\n2. **Energy Sources:**\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** The environmental impact of gasoline vehicles is heavily influenced by the extraction, refining, and combustion of fossil fuels, which contribute to greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution.\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The environmental impact of EVs depends on the electricity mix used for charging. Historically, this mix included a significant proportion of coal and natural gas. However, there has been a shift towards renewable energy sources such as wind, solar, and hydroelectric power, reducing the carbon footprint of EVs over time.\n\n3. **Recycling and End-of-Life:**\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Recycling efforts have focused on metal recovery and reusing parts, but the environmental benefits are limited by the ongoing need for fossil fuels.\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The recycling of EV batteries is a critical area of development. Recent advancements in recycling technologies aim to recover valuable materials such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, reducing the need for new mining and minimizing environmental impacts.\n\n### Current Trends and Future Projections\n\n1. **Battery Technology:**\n - Continued improvements in battery technology are expected, with solid-state batteries and other innovations promising higher energy densities, faster charging, and longer lifespans. These advancements will reduce the environmental impact associated with battery production and disposal.\n\n2. **Energy Transition:**\n - The global energy transition towards renewables is expected to accelerate. As the grid becomes greener, the lifecycle emissions of EVs will decrease further, making them increasingly sustainable compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n3. **Recycling Innovations:**\n - Emerging recycling methods, such as direct recycling and closed-loop systems, are projected to enhance the recovery of battery materials, reducing the environmental footprint of EVs. These methods will also lower the demand for new raw materials, mitigating the environmental impacts of mining.\n\n### Comparative Environmental Impacts Over Time\n\n- **Short-Term (Next 5-10 Years):** In the short term, EVs are likely to continue benefiting from improvements in battery technology and a cleaner electricity grid. Gasoline vehicles will remain reliant on fossil fuels, with limited potential for significant environmental impact reduction.\n \n- **Medium-Term (10-20 Years):** As renewable energy becomes more dominant and recycling technologies mature, the environmental advantages of EVs will become more pronounced. Gasoline vehicles will face increasing regulatory pressures and potential obsolescence due to stricter emissions standards.\n\n- **Long-Term (20+ Years):** In the long term, EVs are expected to achieve near-zero lifecycle emissions as the grid becomes fully renewable and battery recycling reaches high efficiency. Gasoline vehicles, on the other hand, will likely be phased out or relegated to niche markets due to their unsustainable environmental impact.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOver the next few decades, electric vehicles are projected to become significantly more sustainable than traditional gasoline vehicles due to advancements in technology, shifts in energy sources, and improvements in recycling methods. While gasoline vehicles will continue to have a substantial environmental impact due to their reliance on fossil fuels, EVs will benefit from a cleaner energy grid and more efficient recycling processes, making them the more environmentally friendly option in the long run.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life-cycle analysis that examines the entire lifespan of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By evaluating each stage, I can provide a detailed comparison of the environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution.", + "I can answer by conducting a time-sensitive life-cycle analysis that evaluates how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles change over time. This would involve analyzing historical data on technological advancements, shifts in energy sources, and emerging recycling methods. By projecting future trends, I can compare the potential environmental impacts of both vehicle types over the next few decades, offering insights into their evolving sustainability." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life-cycle analysis that examines the entire lifespan of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By evaluating each stage, I can provide a detailed comparison of the environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution.", + "I can answer by focusing on specific environmental factors, such as greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, during the operation phase of the vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing emissions data and energy efficiency for both electric and gasoline vehicles, considering the source of electricity for electric vehicles, and discussing how regional variations in energy production can affect their environmental impact compared to gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life-cycle analysis that examines the entire lifespan of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By evaluating each stage, I can provide a detailed comparison of the environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a geographic-specific life-cycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles in different regions. By considering variations in electricity generation sources, local vehicle manufacturing practices, and regional recycling capabilities, I can provide a nuanced comparison that reflects the diverse environmental impacts unique to each geographic area.", + "I can answer by conducting a time-sensitive life-cycle analysis that evaluates how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles change over time. This would involve analyzing historical data on technological advancements, shifts in energy sources, and emerging recycling methods. By projecting future trends, I can compare the potential environmental impacts of both vehicle types over the next few decades, offering insights into their evolving sustainability." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a time-sensitive life-cycle analysis that evaluates how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles change over time. This would involve analyzing historical data on technological advancements, shifts in energy sources, and emerging recycling methods. By projecting future trends, I can compare the potential environmental impacts of both vehicle types over the next few decades, offering insights into their evolving sustainability." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:31.759457", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 14 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c841f652-3ae8-482c-8ce8-cd564687f2df", + "ibfs_id": "3d4dce46-0dab-43ff-8dcb-c49d4f0b42b7", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and fossil fuel dependency but involve significant resource use and pollution during battery production and disposal.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through a lifecycle analysis focusing on resource consumption and material sustainability, we need to examine several key stages: raw material extraction, production, usage, and end-of-life management.\n\n### Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n1. **Batteries:** EVs primarily rely on lithium-ion batteries, which require significant amounts of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and manganese. These materials are often sourced from regions with limited environmental regulations, leading to concerns about ecological damage and human rights issues. For instance, cobalt mining in the Democratic Republic of Congo has been associated with environmental degradation and unethical labor practices.\n2. **Rare Earth Metals:** EV motors often use rare earth elements like neodymium and dysprosium. The extraction of these metals is energy-intensive and can result in substantial environmental harm, including habitat destruction and pollution from tailings and chemical processing.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n1. **Fossil Fuels:** The primary raw material for gasoline vehicles is crude oil, which is extracted through drilling. This process can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and significant greenhouse gas emissions.\n2. **Metals and Materials:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and other metals for construction, similar to EVs. However, they do not require the same quantity of rare earth metals as EVs.\n\n### Production\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in manufacturing processes and increased use of renewable energy in production are helping to mitigate these impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The production of gasoline vehicles is less energy-intensive than EVs, primarily due to the absence of large battery systems. However, the manufacturing process still involves significant emissions and resource use.\n\n### Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, leading to reduced air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation. The environmental benefits are contingent on the electricity source; renewable energy sources enhance sustainability, while coal-based electricity can diminish these benefits.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change. The efficiency of the engine and fuel quality can affect the level of emissions.\n\n### End-of-Life Management\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- Battery recycling is a significant challenge and opportunity. While recycling technologies are improving, the current rate of battery recycling is low. Effective recycling can recover valuable materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, reducing the need for new raw material extraction and minimizing waste.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- End-of-life gasoline vehicles are typically dismantled, with metals being recycled. However, the disposal of fluids and other non-metal components can pose environmental risks.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, both electric and gasoline vehicles have distinct environmental impacts throughout their lifecycles. EVs offer significant advantages in reducing operational emissions, especially when powered by renewable energy. However, they present challenges in terms of raw material extraction and battery recycling. Gasoline vehicles have a more established recycling infrastructure but contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during use. Addressing the sustainability of EVs requires advancements in battery technology, improved recycling processes, and a shift towards cleaner energy sources.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and disposal. This approach will highlight differences in resource consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and pollution associated with electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles. I would gather data from existing studies and reports to provide a comprehensive assessment of their environmental impacts throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis that emphasizes resource consumption and material sustainability. This approach would delve into the types and quantities of raw materials required for the production of electric versus gasoline vehicles, including rare earth metals for batteries and fossil fuels for combustion engines. By examining the sourcing, usage, and recyclability of these materials, I can highlight the sustainability challenges and opportunities associated with each vehicle type. Data would be collected from recent industry reports and sustainability assessments to ensure a comprehensive evaluation of material impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and disposal. This approach will highlight differences in resource consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and pollution associated with electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles. I would gather data from existing studies and reports to provide a comprehensive assessment of their environmental impacts throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both vehicle types, specifically analyzing their emissions during use. This approach will involve comparing tailpipe emissions from gasoline vehicles with the emissions related to electricity generation for EVs, taking into account the energy mix in different regions. I would also consider the potential for renewable energy sources to power EVs and how that could further reduce their environmental footprint compared to gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and disposal. This approach will highlight differences in resource consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and pollution associated with electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles. I would gather data from existing studies and reports to provide a comprehensive assessment of their environmental impacts throughout their entire lifecycles." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis focused specifically on the carbon footprint of electric and gasoline vehicles. This variation would involve quantifying the total greenhouse gas emissions produced at each stage of a vehicle's lifecycle, such as the energy used in manufacturing, the emissions during operation, and the environmental costs of disposal. I would utilize carbon accounting methodologies and gather data from peer-reviewed studies to determine the net carbon impact of each vehicle type over its expected lifespan.", + "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis that emphasizes resource consumption and material sustainability. This approach would delve into the types and quantities of raw materials required for the production of electric versus gasoline vehicles, including rare earth metals for batteries and fossil fuels for combustion engines. By examining the sourcing, usage, and recyclability of these materials, I can highlight the sustainability challenges and opportunities associated with each vehicle type. Data would be collected from recent industry reports and sustainability assessments to ensure a comprehensive evaluation of material impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis that emphasizes resource consumption and material sustainability. This approach would delve into the types and quantities of raw materials required for the production of electric versus gasoline vehicles, including rare earth metals for batteries and fossil fuels for combustion engines. By examining the sourcing, usage, and recyclability of these materials, I can highlight the sustainability challenges and opportunities associated with each vehicle type. Data would be collected from recent industry reports and sustainability assessments to ensure a comprehensive evaluation of material impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:32.558214", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 16 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "b066ac05-51fe-400f-aa0d-67186b4f8d01", + "ibfs_id": "222ed71e-347d-42c0-a979-ab78de7ebaff", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but battery production and disposal pose environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through a lifecycle analysis with a focus on end-of-life disposal and recycling processes, we must consider several key aspects: battery recycling, vehicle dismantling, and waste management strategies.\n\n### 1. Battery Recycling in Electric Vehicles\n\n**Environmental Implications:**\n- **Resource Recovery:** EVs primarily rely on lithium-ion batteries, which contain valuable materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and manganese. The recycling of these batteries is crucial for recovering these materials, reducing the need for new mining operations, and minimizing environmental degradation.\n- **Recycling Processes:** Current recycling methods include pyrometallurgical, hydrometallurgical, and direct recycling processes. Each has its environmental footprint, with hydrometallurgical processes generally offering a better environmental profile due to lower energy consumption and emissions.\n- **Challenges:** The recycling infrastructure for EV batteries is still developing. Efficient collection systems, standardized battery designs, and improved recycling technologies are needed to enhance material recovery rates and reduce environmental impacts.\n\n**Opportunities:**\n- **Circular Economy:** Effective battery recycling can contribute to a circular economy by reintroducing recovered materials into the production cycle, thus reducing the environmental impact of raw material extraction.\n- **Innovation in Recycling Technologies:** Advances in recycling technologies can improve the efficiency and environmental performance of battery recycling processes.\n\n### 2. Vehicle Dismantling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Complexity:** EVs have fewer moving parts than gasoline vehicles, but their dismantling can be more complex due to the presence of high-voltage systems and the need for specialized handling of batteries.\n- **Material Recovery:** EVs offer opportunities for recovering high-value materials from components such as electric motors and electronic systems.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Established Processes:** The dismantling and recycling processes for gasoline vehicles are well-established, with mature markets for scrap metal recovery.\n- **Environmental Concerns:** Gasoline vehicles contain fluids and components that require careful handling to prevent environmental contamination, such as oils, coolants, and lead-acid batteries.\n\n### 3. Waste Management Strategies\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Waste:** The management of battery waste is a significant concern. Improper disposal can lead to environmental hazards due to the release of toxic substances.\n- **Regulatory Frameworks:** Many regions are developing regulations and extended producer responsibility (EPR) schemes to ensure proper battery disposal and recycling.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Hazardous Materials:** Gasoline vehicles contain hazardous materials that must be managed carefully to prevent soil and water contamination.\n- **Recycling Rates:** The recycling rates for materials like steel and aluminum are high, but there is room for improvement in recycling plastics and other non-metal components.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe end-of-life disposal and recycling processes of electric and gasoline vehicles present distinct environmental challenges and opportunities. EVs offer significant potential for resource recovery through battery recycling, contributing to a more sustainable lifecycle. However, the current recycling infrastructure and technologies need further development to maximize these benefits. Gasoline vehicles, while benefiting from established recycling processes, pose environmental risks due to hazardous materials. Both vehicle types require robust waste management strategies to mitigate their environmental impacts at the end of their lifecycle.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to operation and end-of-life disposal. This approach would provide a comprehensive overview of the emissions and resource use associated with both types of vehicles, highlighting key differences in their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that emphasizes the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would delve into the environmental implications of battery recycling, vehicle dismantling, and waste management strategies. By highlighting the differences in how these vehicles are disposed of and the potential for material recovery, I can shed light on the sustainability challenges and opportunities associated with decommissioning each type of vehicle." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to operation and end-of-life disposal. This approach would provide a comprehensive overview of the emissions and resource use associated with both types of vehicles, highlighting key differences in their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, specifically analyzing emissions and energy consumption during their use. This approach would compare the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles with the indirect emissions from electricity generation for electric vehicles. It would also consider the impact of different energy sources used to generate electricity, such as coal, natural gas, or renewables, and how these affect the overall environmental impact of electric vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to operation and end-of-life disposal. This approach would provide a comprehensive overview of the emissions and resource use associated with both types of vehicles, highlighting key differences in their environmental footprints." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing the lifecycle analysis specifically on the manufacturing processes of electric vehicles versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve a detailed examination of the environmental impacts associated with the extraction and processing of raw materials, such as lithium for batteries and steel for engines, as well as the energy consumption and emissions during the assembly processes. By isolating the manufacturing stage, I can provide insights into how production methods contribute to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that emphasizes the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would delve into the environmental implications of battery recycling, vehicle dismantling, and waste management strategies. By highlighting the differences in how these vehicles are disposed of and the potential for material recovery, I can shed light on the sustainability challenges and opportunities associated with decommissioning each type of vehicle." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that emphasizes the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would delve into the environmental implications of battery recycling, vehicle dismantling, and waste management strategies. By highlighting the differences in how these vehicles are disposed of and the potential for material recovery, I can shed light on the sustainability challenges and opportunities associated with decommissioning each type of vehicle." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:40.317142", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 19 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "f8912601-b5d5-46b5-8fbf-70d9ca4fa7aa", + "ibfs_id": "736eac86-411e-4ed1-a1fc-e8658527821d", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce fewer emissions overall, reduce dependence on fossil fuels, and offer cleaner energy options compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, we need to examine the carbon emissions produced by each type of vehicle when they are in use. This involves looking at the emissions from burning gasoline in internal combustion engines and the emissions associated with generating the electricity used to charge EVs.\n\n### Gasoline Vehicles\n\nGasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2) directly from their tailpipes as a result of burning gasoline. The amount of CO2 emitted depends on the fuel efficiency of the vehicle, which is typically measured in miles per gallon (mpg). On average, a gasoline vehicle emits about 8,887 grams of CO2 per gallon of gasoline burned. For a vehicle with a fuel efficiency of 25 mpg, this translates to approximately 355 grams of CO2 per mile driven.\n\n### Electric Vehicles\n\nElectric vehicles do not emit CO2 directly when driven, as they use electric motors powered by batteries. However, the carbon emissions associated with EVs depend on the source of the electricity used to charge them. The carbon intensity of electricity generation varies significantly based on the energy mix of the grid.\n\n1. **Coal-Powered Electricity**: If the electricity used to charge an EV comes primarily from coal-fired power plants, the emissions can be relatively high. Coal-fired plants emit about 2.21 pounds of CO2 per kWh. An EV that consumes 0.3 kWh per mile would thus be responsible for approximately 0.663 pounds (or about 300 grams) of CO2 per mile.\n\n2. **Natural Gas-Powered Electricity**: Natural gas plants emit less CO2 than coal plants, approximately 0.91 pounds of CO2 per kWh. Using the same EV consumption rate, this would result in about 0.273 pounds (or about 124 grams) of CO2 per mile.\n\n3. **Renewable Energy**: If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the associated CO2 emissions are negligible. In this case, the operational phase of an EV can be nearly carbon-free.\n\n### Comparison\n\n- **High Carbon Intensity Grid (Coal)**: In regions where coal is the dominant energy source, the carbon emissions of EVs can approach those of gasoline vehicles, though they are often still slightly lower.\n \n- **Moderate Carbon Intensity Grid (Natural Gas)**: In areas where natural gas is prevalent, EVs generally have significantly lower carbon emissions per mile compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n- **Low Carbon Intensity Grid (Renewables)**: In regions with a high penetration of renewable energy, EVs can have near-zero operational carbon emissions, offering a substantial environmental advantage over gasoline vehicles.\n\nOverall, the carbon emissions of electric vehicles during their operational phase can vary widely based on the energy mix of the electricity grid. However, as the grid becomes increasingly decarbonized with more renewable energy, the environmental benefits of EVs over gasoline vehicles become more pronounced.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by comparing the carbon emissions of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their operational phase. This approach would focus on the emissions produced by each type of vehicle during use, taking into account the energy source for EVs (e.g., coal vs. renewable energy) and the fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to end-of-life. This would include assessing the raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during operation, and disposal or recycling of the vehicles.", + "I can answer by comparing the carbon emissions of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their operational phase. This approach would focus on the emissions produced by each type of vehicle during use, taking into account the energy source for EVs (e.g., coal vs. renewable energy) and the fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by reviewing scientific studies and reports that have evaluated the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This would involve summarizing key findings from credible research papers and expert analyses, highlighting the consensus and any ongoing debates within the scientific community.", + "I can answer by investigating the environmental impacts of the supply chain for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include examining the extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium for EV batteries and the environmental costs of drilling and refining petroleum for gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by comparing the carbon emissions of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their operational phase. This approach would focus on the emissions produced by each type of vehicle during use, taking into account the energy source for EVs (e.g., coal vs. renewable energy) and the fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:41.857698", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 20 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "017d99cb-3072-4a6c-9072-e6389466431f", + "ibfs_id": "91a4288c-dfb5-43a7-9f96-b910ff2c24a4", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce greenhouse gases and pollution but have battery production and disposal impacts compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through a comparative lifecycle analysis, we must consider several key stages: raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. This analysis will also emphasize technological advancements over time, particularly in battery technology, vehicle efficiency, and manufacturing processes.\n\n### Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Batteries:** The production of lithium-ion batteries, which power most EVs, requires mining of raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel. Historically, this process has had significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and water pollution.\n- **Technological Advancements:** Over time, there have been improvements in battery chemistry and recycling processes. For example, newer battery technologies are reducing reliance on cobalt, which is more environmentally damaging to extract. Companies are also investing in more sustainable mining practices and recycling programs to recover valuable materials from used batteries.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Extraction:** The extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline have long been associated with environmental issues, including oil spills, greenhouse gas emissions, and ecosystem disruption.\n- **Technological Advancements:** While there have been improvements in drilling and refining efficiency, the fundamental environmental impacts of oil extraction remain significant.\n\n### Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Use:** Manufacturing EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and initially results in higher emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Technological Advancements:** Over time, manufacturing processes have become more energy-efficient. The use of renewable energy in production facilities has also increased, reducing the carbon footprint of EV manufacturing.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Manufacturing Processes:** The production of gasoline vehicles is less energy-intensive than EVs, primarily due to the absence of large battery packs.\n- **Technological Advancements:** Incremental improvements in manufacturing efficiency have occurred, but they have not significantly altered the environmental impact compared to the advancements seen in EV production.\n\n### Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, significantly reducing air pollution in urban areas.\n- **Energy Source:** The environmental impact during the usage phase depends on the electricity source. As the grid becomes greener with more renewable energy, the lifecycle emissions of EVs decrease.\n- **Technological Advancements:** Improvements in battery efficiency and vehicle aerodynamics have extended the range of EVs, making them more competitive with gasoline vehicles in terms of energy consumption.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other pollutants during operation, contributing to climate change and air quality issues.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Technological advancements have led to more fuel-efficient engines, but these improvements are often offset by increased vehicle size and power.\n\n### End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal of EV batteries poses a challenge due to hazardous materials. However, advancements in recycling technologies are improving the recovery of materials, reducing environmental impacts.\n- **Technological Advancements:** Companies are developing second-life applications for EV batteries, such as energy storage systems, extending their useful life and reducing waste.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Traditional vehicles are largely recyclable, with established processes for metal recovery. However, the environmental impact of end-of-life disposal is generally lower than that of EVs due to the absence of large battery packs.\n\n### Timeline Perspective and Future Scenarios\n\n- **Past:** Initially, the environmental impact of EVs was higher due to less efficient manufacturing and reliance on fossil fuel-based electricity.\n- **Present:** With advancements in battery technology, increased use of renewable energy, and more efficient manufacturing, the lifecycle emissions of EVs have decreased significantly.\n- **Future:** Continued technological innovations, such as solid-state batteries and further decarbonization of the electricity grid, are expected to further reduce the environmental impact of EVs. As these technologies mature, EVs are likely to become even more environmentally friendly compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\nIn conclusion, while both electric and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts, technological advancements have increasingly tipped the balance in favor of EVs. As these innovations continue, the environmental benefits of electric vehicles are expected to grow, potentially leading to a more sustainable transportation future.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, focusing on key stages such as production, use, and disposal. This approach would assess energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource use at each stage, providing a detailed understanding of the environmental impacts associated with both types of vehicles throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis with an emphasis on technological advancements over time. This strategy would involve examining how improvements in battery technology, vehicle efficiency, and manufacturing processes have changed the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles. By including a timeline perspective, this approach would reveal trends and potential future scenarios, illustrating how ongoing innovations could alter the environmental balance between these two types of vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, focusing on key stages such as production, use, and disposal. This approach would assess energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource use at each stage, providing a detailed understanding of the environmental impacts associated with both types of vehicles throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by examining the environmental policies and technological advancements that influence the sustainability of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would analyze how government regulations, incentives, and innovations in battery technology and fuel efficiency contribute to reducing or exacerbating the environmental impacts of each vehicle type, offering a perspective on how future developments might alter their comparative impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, focusing on key stages such as production, use, and disposal. This approach would assess energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource use at each stage, providing a detailed understanding of the environmental impacts associated with both types of vehicles throughout their entire lifecycles." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that incorporates geographical variations in production and use. This approach would involve evaluating how the environmental impacts of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles differ based on factors such as the source of electricity (renewable vs. non-renewable) in different regions, the local availability of materials for battery production, and regional recycling capabilities. By considering these geographical factors, this analysis would provide insights into how location-specific elements influence the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis with an emphasis on technological advancements over time. This strategy would involve examining how improvements in battery technology, vehicle efficiency, and manufacturing processes have changed the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles. By including a timeline perspective, this approach would reveal trends and potential future scenarios, illustrating how ongoing innovations could alter the environmental balance between these two types of vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis with an emphasis on technological advancements over time. This strategy would involve examining how improvements in battery technology, vehicle efficiency, and manufacturing processes have changed the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles. By including a timeline perspective, this approach would reveal trends and potential future scenarios, illustrating how ongoing innovations could alter the environmental balance between these two types of vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:41.828829", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 17 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "99fb7dc6-27ce-4728-9d3f-4188c2560708", + "ibfs_id": "d8a31d7c-e78f-4b0b-89d9-4cf94b6ecdaa", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles offer lower emissions, reduced pollution, and decreased dependency on fossil fuels compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will focus on lifecycle emissions, particularly emphasizing the operational phase. This involves calculating the average emissions per mile driven for both types of vehicles and considering variations in electricity generation sources.\n\n### Gasoline Vehicles\n\n1. **Lifecycle Emissions**: For gasoline vehicles, emissions are primarily generated during the operational phase, where combustion of gasoline releases carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and other pollutants. \n\n2. **Average Emissions**: On average, gasoline vehicles emit about 411 grams of CO2 per mile. This figure can vary based on vehicle efficiency, with more fuel-efficient cars emitting less CO2.\n\n### Electric Vehicles\n\n1. **Lifecycle Emissions**: For EVs, emissions are mainly associated with electricity generation during the operational phase. The emissions depend heavily on the energy mix of the grid from which the electricity is sourced.\n\n2. **Average Emissions**: The emissions per mile for EVs vary significantly based on the grid's energy sources:\n - **Coal-Dominated Grid**: In regions where coal is a major source of electricity, EVs might emit around 200-300 grams of CO2 per mile. This is still generally lower than gasoline vehicles but not as low as in cleaner grids.\n - **Natural Gas-Dominated Grid**: In areas where natural gas is predominant, emissions can be around 150-200 grams of CO2 per mile.\n - **Renewable Energy-Dominated Grid**: In regions with a high percentage of renewable energy (e.g., wind, solar, hydro), EV emissions can be as low as 0-50 grams of CO2 per mile.\n\n### Comparative Analysis\n\n- **Regions with High Renewable Energy**: In areas where the grid is predominantly powered by renewable sources, EVs have a clear advantage over gasoline vehicles, with significantly lower emissions per mile.\n \n- **Regions with Fossil Fuel-Heavy Grids**: Even in regions where the grid relies heavily on fossil fuels, EVs tend to have lower emissions than gasoline vehicles, although the margin is smaller.\n\n- **Grid Decarbonization**: As grids become greener over time, the emissions associated with EVs will continue to decrease, enhancing their environmental benefits compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, electric vehicles generally have lower operational emissions compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, especially as the electricity grid becomes cleaner. The extent of the environmental benefit varies by region, depending on the local energy mix used for electricity generation. As renewable energy adoption increases, the emissions advantage of EVs over gasoline vehicles is expected to grow further.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impacts related to the energy sources and emissions during the use phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the emissions produced during the operation of gasoline vehicles and comparing them to the emissions associated with generating the electricity used to power electric vehicles. Additionally, I can consider the geographical variations in energy production, such as the use of coal versus renewable energy sources, to provide a nuanced comparison of their environmental impacts during the operational phase.", + "I can answer by examining the lifecycle emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles, with an emphasis on the operational phase. This approach would involve calculating the average emissions per mile driven for gasoline vehicles and comparing them to the emissions resulting from electricity generation for electric vehicles. To ensure a comprehensive analysis, I would include variations in grid energy sources, such as regions predominantly using renewable energy versus those using fossil fuels, to highlight how these differences affect the overall environmental impact." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the environmental impacts from the production phase, including the extraction and processing of raw materials, through the operational phase, where the vehicles are used, and finally to the end-of-life phase, where they are disposed of or recycled. By comparing the complete life cycle of both vehicle types, I can provide a detailed comparison of their environmental impacts, such as carbon emissions, resource depletion, and pollution.", + "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impacts related to the energy sources and emissions during the use phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the emissions produced during the operation of gasoline vehicles and comparing them to the emissions associated with generating the electricity used to power electric vehicles. Additionally, I can consider the geographical variations in energy production, such as the use of coal versus renewable energy sources, to provide a nuanced comparison of their environmental impacts during the operational phase." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impacts related to the energy sources and emissions during the use phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the emissions produced during the operation of gasoline vehicles and comparing them to the emissions associated with generating the electricity used to power electric vehicles. Additionally, I can consider the geographical variations in energy production, such as the use of coal versus renewable energy sources, to provide a nuanced comparison of their environmental impacts during the operational phase." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by examining the lifecycle emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles, with an emphasis on the operational phase. This approach would involve calculating the average emissions per mile driven for gasoline vehicles and comparing them to the emissions resulting from electricity generation for electric vehicles. To ensure a comprehensive analysis, I would include variations in grid energy sources, such as regions predominantly using renewable energy versus those using fossil fuels, to highlight how these differences affect the overall environmental impact.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional case study analysis that compares the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles specifically in areas with contrasting energy profiles. This approach would involve selecting two or more regions with distinct energy mixes\u2014such as one reliant on coal and another on hydropower\u2014and analyzing the emissions produced during the operational phase of vehicles in these areas. By focusing on regional differences, I can provide a more detailed understanding of how local energy production influences the environmental benefits or drawbacks of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by examining the lifecycle emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles, with an emphasis on the operational phase. This approach would involve calculating the average emissions per mile driven for gasoline vehicles and comparing them to the emissions resulting from electricity generation for electric vehicles. To ensure a comprehensive analysis, I would include variations in grid energy sources, such as regions predominantly using renewable energy versus those using fossil fuels, to highlight how these differences affect the overall environmental impact." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:44.266118", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 18 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "a9f84eac-c57e-4a94-a508-9075dfe8523a", + "ibfs_id": "efad1fe0-2fcd-4d2a-8b9d-a1fce2d8726d", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions, use renewable energy, but involve mining impacts; gasoline vehicles release more CO2 and pollutants.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine each stage of the vehicle's lifecycle: raw material extraction, manufacturing, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. This analysis will help us understand the environmental impacts of both types of vehicles.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Batteries:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can result in significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use copper and rare earth elements for electric motors and other components, which have their own environmental impacts due to mining.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fossil Fuels:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling and can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Metals and Materials:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and other materials, which also involve mining and processing with associated environmental impacts.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Processes\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- Manufacturing EVs, especially the batteries, is energy-intensive and can result in higher emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in renewable energy use in manufacturing can mitigate some impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is less energy-intensive than for EVs, primarily due to the absence of large batteries. However, it still involves significant emissions from steel and aluminum production.\n\n### 3. Vehicle Operation\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas.\n- **Energy Source:** The environmental impact during operation depends on the electricity source. If powered by renewable energy, the emissions are minimal. However, if the electricity comes from fossil fuels, the emissions can be significant.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Improvements in fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, but they remain higher than those of EVs, especially when EVs are charged with clean energy.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Recycling or Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of lithium-ion batteries pose challenges due to the need for specialized recycling processes to recover valuable materials and prevent environmental contamination.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Other components of EVs can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, but the battery remains the primary concern.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are generally easier to recycle, as the materials used are well-established in recycling processes. However, they still contribute to waste and pollution if not properly managed.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles offer significant environmental benefits during the operation phase due to zero tailpipe emissions, especially when powered by renewable energy. However, they have higher environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases, primarily due to battery production. Gasoline vehicles have lower initial manufacturing impacts but contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation. End-of-life recycling presents challenges for both types, with EVs focusing on battery recycling and gasoline vehicles on traditional material recycling. Overall, the shift towards renewable energy sources and improved recycling technologies can enhance the environmental benefits of electric vehicles throughout their lifecycle.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include assessing raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. The analysis would highlight the differences in emissions, resource consumption, and ecological footprint throughout each vehicle's lifecycle." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include assessing raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. The analysis would highlight the differences in emissions, resource consumption, and ecological footprint throughout each vehicle's lifecycle.", + "I can answer by reviewing scientific literature and existing studies that have evaluated the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves summarizing findings from peer-reviewed articles, government reports, and non-profit research that compare the carbon emissions, energy efficiency, and pollution levels associated with both types of vehicles. This approach provides evidence-based insights and conclusions drawn from extensive research.", + "I can answer by evaluating the energy sources used for electricity generation and how they affect the environmental benefits of electric vehicles. This approach would involve examining the energy mix of different regions, considering the proportion of renewable versus non-renewable energy sources, and assessing how this influences the overall emissions and sustainability of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles. The analysis would show how the environmental impact of EVs can vary depending on the electricity grid's composition.", + "I can answer by exploring the socio-economic and policy factors that influence the environmental impacts of both vehicle types. This strategy would consider how government incentives, regulations, and technological advancements in battery recycling and production efficiency affect the sustainability of electric vehicles compared to traditional ones. This approach highlights the role of external factors in shaping the environmental outcomes of vehicle technologies." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include assessing raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. The analysis would highlight the differences in emissions, resource consumption, and ecological footprint throughout each vehicle's lifecycle." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:49.328354", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 21 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "9433cabe-2d8b-4db8-a0f2-6674ec5c784c", + "ibfs_id": "3eeff9ef-5b54-4880-afcf-5f9c6541a0dd", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and reliance on fossil fuels, but their battery production and disposal present environmental challenges.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA). This assessment will consider the entire lifespan of both vehicle types, from raw material extraction to end-of-life disposal. Here's a detailed breakdown of each phase:\n\n### 1. Sourcing and Processing of Raw Materials\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve mining and processing of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. This process can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Electric Motor and Electronics:** These components require rare earth elements, which also have environmental costs associated with their extraction and refinement.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Fuel System:** The production of internal combustion engines involves steel, aluminum, and other metals, which also require energy-intensive mining and processing.\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction, refining, and transportation of crude oil for gasoline production contribute to environmental degradation, including oil spills, air pollution, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Emissions\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- The manufacturing process for EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher initial emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in manufacturing efficiency and the use of renewable energy can mitigate these impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Manufacturing emissions are generally lower than those of EVs initially, as the production of internal combustion engines is less energy-intensive than battery production. However, the overall emissions depend on the specific materials and processes used.\n\n### 3. Usage-Phase Emissions\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces urban air pollution.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during the usage phase depends on the electricity mix. If the grid relies heavily on fossil fuels, the emissions can be substantial, though still generally lower than gasoline vehicles. Renewable energy sources greatly reduce these emissions.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** These vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, particulate matter, and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Improvements in fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, but they remain higher than those of EVs, especially in regions with clean electricity grids.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries are critical. While recycling can recover valuable materials, improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination. Advances in battery recycling technology are improving the sustainability of EVs.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, the metal components of EVs can be recycled, reducing the need for new raw materials.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** The established infrastructure for recycling metals from gasoline vehicles helps mitigate some environmental impacts. However, the disposal of fluids and other hazardous materials remains a concern.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn a comparative life cycle assessment, electric vehicles generally offer environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of reduced emissions during the usage phase. However, the initial production phase, especially battery manufacturing, poses significant environmental challenges. The overall impact of EVs can be minimized through cleaner energy sources, improved recycling processes, and advancements in battery technology. As the energy grid becomes greener and recycling technologies advance, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to increase.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production through end-of-life disposal. This would include examining the sourcing and processing of raw materials, manufacturing emissions, usage-phase emissions, and recycling or disposal impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production through end-of-life disposal. This would include examining the sourcing and processing of raw materials, manufacturing emissions, usage-phase emissions, and recycling or disposal impacts.", + "I can answer by reviewing current scientific studies and reports that provide data on emissions and resource use associated with electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve summarizing findings from research papers, government assessments, and environmental organization reports to provide a comprehensive overview.", + "I can answer by analyzing the carbon footprint and pollution output differences between electric and gasoline vehicles during their operational life. This would involve calculating and comparing the emissions released per mile driven for each type of vehicle, taking into account the electricity generation mix and fuel consumption.", + "I can answer by examining case studies from regions that have high adoption rates of electric vehicles. This would involve looking at the real-world environmental impacts observed in these areas, including changes in air quality, energy demand shifts, and impacts on local ecosystems, compared to regions with predominantly gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production through end-of-life disposal. This would include examining the sourcing and processing of raw materials, manufacturing emissions, usage-phase emissions, and recycling or disposal impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:50.504570", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 22 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c49f8e11-dd30-4a74-9678-c018ac8093d5", + "ibfs_id": "a8778f4c-a09f-4692-ac68-941e2f43b0da", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and dependence on oil, but their battery production and disposal pose environmental challenges. Balancing benefits needed.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines each stage of their lifecycle: raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life recycling or disposal.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. Mining these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use copper and rare earth elements for electric motors and other components, contributing to additional environmental stress from mining activities.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Extraction:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and greenhouse gas emissions. Refining crude oil into gasoline is also energy-intensive and polluting.\n- **Material Use:** Gasoline vehicles use steel, aluminum, and plastics, which also require mining and processing, but generally involve less intensive mining of rare materials compared to EVs.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Processes\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** Manufacturing EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in renewable energy use in manufacturing are helping to mitigate these impacts.\n- **Complex Supply Chains:** The global supply chain for battery components can lead to additional emissions due to transportation and logistics.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Lower Initial Emissions:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles typically results in lower initial carbon emissions compared to EVs, primarily because they do not require large batteries.\n- **Standard Manufacturing:** The processes involved are well-established and optimized, though they still contribute to environmental pollution and resource use.\n\n### 3. Usage Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, significantly reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation. The environmental impact during this phase largely depends on the electricity source used for charging.\n- **Electricity Source:** If powered by renewable energy, the emissions are minimal. However, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels, the benefits are reduced but still generally lower than gasoline vehicles.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **High Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Advances in fuel efficiency have reduced emissions per mile, but they remain significantly higher than those of EVs.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Recycling or Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose environmental challenges. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable materials and reducing waste.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, EVs can be recycled for their metal components, reducing the need for new raw materials.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Established Recycling Processes:** The recycling of gasoline vehicles is well-established, with many parts being reused or recycled. However, they do not have the additional complexity of battery disposal.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, while electric vehicles initially have a higher environmental impact during the production phase due to battery manufacturing, they offer significant benefits during the usage phase by eliminating tailpipe emissions. The overall environmental impact of EVs is generally lower than that of gasoline vehicles, especially when charged with renewable energy. End-of-life recycling remains a challenge for both types of vehicles, but advancements in battery recycling are improving the sustainability of EVs.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts from the production phase through to disposal, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, usage, and end-of-life recycling or disposal." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts from the production phase through to disposal, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, usage, and end-of-life recycling or disposal.", + "I can answer by examining and summarizing scientific research studies and reports that have analyzed the emissions and pollution levels associated with both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include looking at greenhouse gas emissions, particulate matter, and other pollutants during manufacturing, operation, and disposal stages.", + "I can answer by exploring the energy source for electric vehicles, focusing on how the electricity is generated (renewable vs. non-renewable sources) and the resulting environmental impacts. This involves considering the carbon footprint of electricity production and how it compares to the emissions from burning gasoline in traditional vehicles.", + "I can answer by assessing the impact of resource extraction necessary for electric vehicles, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel mining for batteries, and comparing it to oil extraction for gasoline vehicles. This approach would include evaluating the ecological disturbance, water usage, and pollution associated with both types of resource extraction processes." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts from the production phase through to disposal, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, usage, and end-of-life recycling or disposal." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:54.424660", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 23 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "09e805b4-0658-41bb-bce2-a73870e158dd", + "ibfs_id": "f3af97d8-5e32-414a-a7c2-22171c2229ff", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce greenhouse emissions but involve battery production challenges; gasoline vehicles contribute more to air pollution and CO2.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can draw on findings from various research studies and reports by reputable environmental organizations and academic institutions. These sources provide insights into several key metrics such as emissions reduction, energy consumption, and ecological footprints.\n\n1. **Emissions Reduction**:\n - **Lifecycle Emissions**: According to a report by the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS), EVs produce significantly lower greenhouse gas emissions over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles. This includes emissions from manufacturing, driving, and disposal. The UCS report highlights that even when accounting for the emissions from electricity generation, EVs result in lower emissions than gasoline vehicles in most regions of the United States.\n - **Tailpipe Emissions**: EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, which means they do not emit pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM) during operation. This is a significant advantage over gasoline vehicles, which contribute to air pollution and associated health problems.\n\n2. **Energy Consumption**:\n - **Efficiency**: Research from the U.S. Department of Energy indicates that EVs are more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 77% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, whereas internal combustion engines (ICEs) convert only about 12%\u201330% of the energy stored in gasoline.\n - **Energy Source**: The environmental impact of EVs is influenced by the source of electricity used for charging. A study published in the journal *Nature Sustainability* found that in regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources, the environmental benefits of EVs are maximized. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal-fired power, the benefits are reduced, though EVs still tend to have a lower overall emissions profile than gasoline vehicles.\n\n3. **Ecological Footprints**:\n - **Battery Production**: One of the environmental drawbacks of EVs is the production of lithium-ion batteries, which involves energy-intensive mining and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. A study by the International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT) notes that battery production can result in significant emissions and environmental impacts. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling are helping to mitigate these effects.\n - **Resource Use**: The extraction and processing of materials for EV batteries can have ecological impacts, including habitat destruction and water pollution. Efforts are underway to develop more sustainable mining practices and to increase the recycling of battery materials to reduce these impacts.\n\n4. **Long-term Environmental Impact**:\n - **Renewable Integration**: The International Energy Agency (IEA) emphasizes that the integration of EVs with renewable energy sources can further enhance their environmental benefits. As the grid becomes greener, the lifecycle emissions of EVs will continue to decrease.\n - **Policy and Infrastructure**: Reports from the World Resources Institute (WRI) suggest that supportive policies and infrastructure development, such as expanding charging networks and incentivizing renewable energy, are crucial for maximizing the environmental benefits of EVs.\n\nIn summary, while electric vehicles offer significant environmental advantages over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of emissions reduction and energy efficiency, challenges remain in battery production and resource use. Continued advancements in technology, along with supportive policies and a transition to renewable energy sources, are essential to fully realize the environmental benefits of EVs.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by examining existing research studies and reports from reputable environmental organizations and academic institutions. This approach involves synthesizing findings from multiple sources to provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental benefits and drawbacks of EVs compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, focusing on metrics like emissions reduction, energy consumption, and ecological footprints." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal\u2014to determine their respective environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, air and water pollution, and resource depletion.", + "I can answer by examining existing research studies and reports from reputable environmental organizations and academic institutions. This approach involves synthesizing findings from multiple sources to provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental benefits and drawbacks of EVs compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, focusing on metrics like emissions reduction, energy consumption, and ecological footprints.", + "I can answer by analyzing the regional differences in environmental impacts based on the energy grid composition. This approach considers how the environmental benefits of EVs can vary depending on the electricity sources used to charge them (e.g., coal, natural gas, renewables) and compares this with the consistent emissions profile of gasoline vehicles across different regions.", + "I can answer by exploring the policy and regulatory landscape that influences the environmental impacts of both vehicle types. This strategy involves evaluating how government incentives, emissions regulations, and infrastructure development (such as charging stations for EVs) affect the overall environmental outcomes and adoption rates of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by examining existing research studies and reports from reputable environmental organizations and academic institutions. This approach involves synthesizing findings from multiple sources to provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental benefits and drawbacks of EVs compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, focusing on metrics like emissions reduction, energy consumption, and ecological footprints." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:03.583917", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 25 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "8a71af29-3779-406c-931b-bf2fa16eb915", + "ibfs_id": "ab8054e6-6a40-4190-bcbd-314aa9badf11", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and fossil fuel dependence but have battery production impacts and require renewable energy for maximum benefits.", + "final_answer": "When comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their use phase, it is crucial to focus on the emissions produced and their effects on air quality and climate change.\n\n### Greenhouse Gas Emissions\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions during their use phase. This means they do not emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), or particulate matter directly while being driven.\n - However, the greenhouse gas emissions associated with EVs during their use phase depend on the source of electricity used to charge them. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the associated emissions are minimal. Conversely, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels such as coal or natural gas, the emissions can be significant.\n - On average, even when accounting for a typical mix of energy sources, EVs tend to have lower overall greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit CO2 directly from the combustion of fuel. The average gasoline vehicle emits about 4.6 metric tons of CO2 per year, assuming a fuel economy of about 22 miles per gallon and 11,500 miles driven annually.\n - In addition to CO2, gasoline vehicles emit other pollutants such as NOx and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which contribute to smog and have adverse health effects.\n\n### Air Pollutants\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - As mentioned, EVs do not produce tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces the emission of air pollutants in urban areas, improving local air quality.\n - The air quality benefits are particularly pronounced in cities where traffic congestion leads to high levels of vehicle emissions.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Gasoline vehicles contribute to air pollution through the emission of NOx, VOCs, and particulate matter. These pollutants can form ground-level ozone and particulate pollution, which are harmful to human health and the environment.\n - The presence of these pollutants in the atmosphere can lead to respiratory problems, cardiovascular diseases, and other health issues.\n\n### Effects on Air Quality and Climate Change\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - By reducing tailpipe emissions, EVs contribute to improved air quality, especially in densely populated areas. This can lead to a reduction in health problems associated with poor air quality.\n - The impact of EVs on climate change is largely dependent on the carbon intensity of the electricity grid. As the grid becomes cleaner with more renewable energy sources, the climate benefits of EVs increase.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - The emissions from gasoline vehicles contribute significantly to climate change through the release of CO2, a major greenhouse gas.\n - The air pollutants from gasoline vehicles also contribute to environmental issues such as acid rain and the formation of urban smog, which can exacerbate climate change effects.\n\nIn summary, during the use phase, electric vehicles generally have a lower environmental impact compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to their lack of tailpipe emissions. The extent of their environmental benefits, however, is influenced by the energy sources used for electricity generation. As the energy grid becomes greener, the advantages of EVs in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving air quality become more pronounced.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the use phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, analyzing the differences in greenhouse gas emissions, air pollutants, and their subsequent effects on air quality and climate change." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, examining environmental impacts from raw material extraction, manufacturing, use, and end-of-life disposal. This would offer a holistic view of their overall environmental footprint.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the use phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, analyzing the differences in greenhouse gas emissions, air pollutants, and their subsequent effects on air quality and climate change.", + "I can answer by evaluating the environmental impact of the energy sources used to power electric vehicles compared to the extraction and refinement of fossil fuels for gasoline vehicles. This approach would highlight the importance of the electricity grid's energy mix in determining the environmental benefits of EVs.", + "I can answer by exploring the environmental impacts associated with the production and disposal of batteries used in electric vehicles, including resource depletion and waste management challenges, as compared to the production and disposal of traditional vehicle components like engines and exhaust systems." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the use phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, analyzing the differences in greenhouse gas emissions, air pollutants, and their subsequent effects on air quality and climate change." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:03.967115", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 24 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "0a999bf4-19b4-470b-9493-b1b49c585a71", + "ibfs_id": "376af2d8-2b49-48c7-a645-8d824b25d069", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but manufacturing and battery disposal present environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA). This involves examining the entire life cycle of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal. Here is a detailed analysis:\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction and Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other materials. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, soil and water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing:** The production of EVs generally requires more energy than traditional vehicles due to the complexity and weight of the batteries. However, advancements in battery technology and manufacturing processes are gradually reducing these impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline production involve significant energy use and environmental degradation, including oil spills, air and water pollution, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is typically less energy-intensive than for EVs, primarily because they do not require large batteries. However, the production still involves significant resource use and emissions.\n\n### 2. Usage Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Source:** The environmental impact during the usage phase of EVs largely depends on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the emissions are significantly lower. However, if the grid relies heavily on fossil fuels, the benefits are reduced.\n- **Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, reducing urban air pollution and associated health impacts. This is a major advantage over gasoline vehicles.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Consumption:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter, and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Efficiency:** Internal combustion engines are generally less efficient than electric motors, leading to higher emissions per mile driven.\n\n### 3. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries present environmental challenges. While recycling technologies are improving, improper disposal can lead to soil and water contamination. Efforts are underway to improve battery recycling processes to recover valuable materials and minimize environmental impacts.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** The rest of the EV can be recycled similarly to traditional vehicles, but the presence of electronic components requires careful handling.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles have established recycling processes for metals and other materials. However, the disposal of fluids and other hazardous materials still poses environmental risks.\n\n### Overall Environmental Impact\n\n- **Carbon Emissions:** Over their entire life cycle, EVs generally have lower carbon emissions than gasoline vehicles, particularly when charged with low-carbon electricity. The higher emissions during manufacturing are offset by the lower emissions during the usage phase.\n- **Resource Depletion:** Both vehicle types contribute to resource depletion, but EVs require specific minerals for batteries, which can be more environmentally taxing to extract.\n- **Pollution:** EVs offer significant reductions in air pollution during the usage phase, which is beneficial for urban environments.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles have higher environmental impacts during the manufacturing phase due to battery production, they offer substantial benefits during the usage phase, particularly in terms of emissions and air quality. The overall environmental impact of EVs is generally lower than that of gasoline vehicles, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the entire life cycle of both types of vehicles\u2014from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal\u2014to evaluate their overall environmental impacts, such as carbon emissions, resource depletion, and pollution." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the entire life cycle of both types of vehicles\u2014from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal\u2014to evaluate their overall environmental impacts, such as carbon emissions, resource depletion, and pollution.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions during the usage phase of the vehicles. This would involve analyzing the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles during operation and comparing them to the indirect emissions from electric vehicles, which depend largely on the energy sources used to generate the electricity that powers them. This approach highlights the importance of electricity generation methods in the environmental impact of electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring the impact of battery production and disposal for electric vehicles compared to the oil extraction and refining process for gasoline vehicles. This approach examines the environmental costs associated with extracting and processing materials needed for each type of vehicle, including issues such as habitat destruction, pollution, and resource scarcity.", + "I can answer by evaluating the potential for renewable energy integration in electric vehicles and its environmental benefits over time. This strategy considers the current and future potential for electric vehicles to be charged using renewable energy sources like solar and wind, reducing their carbon footprint, and contrasts this with the fixed emissions profile of gasoline vehicles, which rely on fossil fuels." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the entire life cycle of both types of vehicles\u2014from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal\u2014to evaluate their overall environmental impacts, such as carbon emissions, resource depletion, and pollution." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:09.321852", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 26 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "1d459f23-cf60-4ea1-bff0-ef1ca0771b44", + "ibfs_id": "5305365c-dadb-44a7-915d-2d97f31bedfa", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution but involve higher ecological costs in battery production and electricity generation.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine each stage of their lifecycle: raw material extraction, manufacturing, use phase, and end-of-life disposal. This approach helps us understand the overall environmental impact of each vehicle type.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Batteries:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use copper and rare earth elements for electric motors, which have their own environmental extraction impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuels:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can result in habitat disruption, oil spills, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Materials:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and other metals, which also involve mining and processing impacts.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** The manufacturing of EVs, particularly their batteries, is energy-intensive. This results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Material Processing:** Processing of battery materials contributes to emissions and environmental pollution.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Conventional Manufacturing:** Gasoline vehicle manufacturing is less energy-intensive than EVs, primarily because it does not involve battery production.\n- **Emissions:** The production process still results in significant emissions, though generally lower than those for EVs.\n\n### 3. Use Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, reducing urban air pollution and greenhouse gases during operation.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during the use phase depends heavily on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources (solar, wind) result in lower emissions, while coal-based electricity increases the carbon footprint.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Combustion Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Improvements in fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, but they remain higher than those of EVs powered by clean energy.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries are critical. Improper disposal can lead to soil and water contamination. However, advances in battery recycling technology are improving the sustainability of EVs.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Other components can be recycled similarly to traditional vehicles, though the complexity of EVs can pose challenges.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are generally easier to recycle, with established processes for metals and other materials.\n- **Environmental Impact:** The end-of-life impact is less severe compared to the challenges posed by EV batteries.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, electric vehicles tend to have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases due to battery production. However, they offer significant environmental benefits during the use phase, particularly when powered by renewable energy sources, due to zero tailpipe emissions. The end-of-life phase presents challenges for both types of vehicles, but advancements in recycling technologies are helping mitigate these impacts. In contrast, traditional gasoline vehicles have a lower initial environmental impact but contribute more significantly to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their use phase.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining the entire lifecycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase to end-of-life disposal, to assess their overall environmental impact." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining the entire lifecycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase to end-of-life disposal, to assess their overall environmental impact.", + "I can answer by focusing on specific environmental factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource consumption. I will compare how each type of vehicle performs in these areas, considering both direct emissions (like tailpipe emissions for gasoline vehicles) and indirect emissions (such as those from electricity generation for EVs).", + "I can answer by looking at regional variations in environmental impacts. This involves analyzing how the environmental benefits or drawbacks of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles may differ depending on the energy mix of the electricity grid in different areas, as well as local policies and infrastructure for vehicle manufacturing and recycling.", + "I can answer by exploring the impact of technological advancements and future trends. This approach would look into how improvements in battery technology, renewable energy integration, and vehicle efficiency could alter the current environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles, providing a forward-looking perspective." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining the entire lifecycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase to end-of-life disposal, to assess their overall environmental impact." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:09.231260", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 27 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c9439490-5c03-4e32-9155-aaad32f24549", + "ibfs_id": "9b8cec6c-8f0d-4775-829a-0b92398926d9", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles generally reduce greenhouse gas emissions, improve air quality, and decrease fossil fuel dependence compared to traditional vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To address the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can review scientific literature and meta-analyses that focus on key aspects such as carbon footprint, air pollution, and resource consumption.\n\n**1. Carbon Footprint:**\n\nA meta-analysis by Hawkins et al. (2013) in the \"Journal of Industrial Ecology\" provides a comprehensive review of the life cycle greenhouse gas emissions of electric vehicles compared to conventional vehicles. The study concludes that while the production phase of electric vehicles, particularly the battery manufacturing, results in higher emissions, the overall life cycle emissions are generally lower for EVs when powered by low-carbon electricity sources. Specifically, the use phase emissions of EVs are significantly lower due to the absence of tailpipe emissions.\n\nA more recent study by Miotti et al. (2016) in \"Environmental Science & Technology\" supports these findings, indicating that the carbon footprint of EVs is highly dependent on the energy mix used for electricity generation. In regions where renewable energy constitutes a significant portion of the grid, EVs offer substantial reductions in greenhouse gas emissions over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n**2. Air Pollution:**\n\nA study published in \"Nature Sustainability\" by Tessum et al. (2019) examines the air quality impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. The research highlights that EVs contribute to reduced air pollution levels, particularly in urban areas, due to the elimination of tailpipe emissions, which are a major source of urban air pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM). The study emphasizes that the benefits are maximized when the electricity used to charge EVs is generated from clean energy sources.\n\n**3. Resource Consumption:**\n\nThe resource consumption aspect, particularly concerning the materials used in battery production, is addressed in a study by Dunn et al. (2015) in \"Environmental Science & Technology.\" The research points out that the extraction and processing of lithium, cobalt, and other materials used in lithium-ion batteries have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and water pollution. However, the study also notes ongoing advancements in battery recycling and the development of alternative battery chemistries that could mitigate these impacts.\n\nA meta-analysis by Ellingsen et al. (2014) in \"Journal of Industrial Ecology\" further discusses the potential for reducing the environmental impact of battery production through improved recycling processes and more efficient use of materials. The study suggests that as battery technology evolves and recycling rates improve, the resource consumption impacts of EVs are expected to decrease.\n\nIn summary, scientific literature and meta-analyses indicate that electric vehicles generally offer environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of reduced greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution. However, the environmental advantages are contingent upon the energy sources used for electricity generation and advancements in battery technology and recycling.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by reviewing scientific literature and meta-analyses on the subject, summarizing key findings from recent studies that compare the carbon footprint, air pollution, and resource consumption associated with each type of vehicle." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include analyzing the sourcing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, operational emissions, and end-of-life recycling or disposal.", + "I can answer by reviewing scientific literature and meta-analyses on the subject, summarizing key findings from recent studies that compare the carbon footprint, air pollution, and resource consumption associated with each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by creating a case study comparison of specific vehicle models, one electric and one gasoline, to demonstrate how their environmental impacts differ based on factors like efficiency, geographic location, and energy source for electricity generation.", + "I can answer by examining policy and industry reports that evaluate the broader societal and ecological effects of transitioning from gasoline to electric vehicles, including impacts on energy infrastructure, mining practices for battery materials, and potential changes in urban air quality and public health." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by reviewing scientific literature and meta-analyses on the subject, summarizing key findings from recent studies that compare the carbon footprint, air pollution, and resource consumption associated with each type of vehicle." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:12.993952", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 29 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "83c21372-f405-4a59-b342-732982b50d93", + "ibfs_id": "613b8b6c-da66-4598-9d51-f87d9a604abd", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution compared to gasoline vehicles, but battery production and disposal present environmental challenges.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we can analyze the greenhouse gas emissions produced throughout their life cycles. This includes the manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life stages for both vehicle types.\n\n### Manufacturing Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- The manufacturing of EVs typically results in higher greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to the production of lithium-ion batteries. Mining and processing the raw materials (such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel) and the energy-intensive battery manufacturing process contribute significantly to these emissions.\n- Studies estimate that the production of an EV can emit approximately 15-68% more greenhouse gases than a conventional gasoline vehicle, largely depending on the size of the battery and the energy sources used in the manufacturing process.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The manufacturing emissions for gasoline vehicles are generally lower than for EVs, as they do not require large batteries. However, they still involve emissions from the extraction and processing of materials like steel, aluminum, and plastics.\n- The overall manufacturing emissions are relatively stable and well-understood, as the process has been optimized over many decades.\n\n### Operational Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- During operation, EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces their greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- The emissions associated with EV operation depend on the electricity source used for charging. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources (like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power), the operational emissions are very low. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, the emissions can be higher, though still generally lower than those from gasoline vehicles.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2) and other greenhouse gases directly from the tailpipe during operation. These emissions are a major contributor to their overall environmental impact.\n- The fuel efficiency of the vehicle plays a significant role in determining the level of emissions, with more efficient vehicles emitting less CO2 per mile traveled.\n\n### End-of-Life Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- The end-of-life stage for EVs involves the recycling or disposal of the battery, which can be challenging due to the hazardous materials involved. However, advancements in battery recycling technologies are helping to mitigate these impacts.\n- Proper recycling can recover valuable materials and reduce the overall environmental footprint of the battery.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The end-of-life process for gasoline vehicles is well-established, with many parts being recyclable. However, the disposal of engine oils and other fluids can pose environmental risks.\n- The overall emissions from this stage are generally lower than those from the manufacturing and operational stages.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nWhen considering the entire life cycle, electric vehicles tend to have a lower overall greenhouse gas emissions profile compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly as the electricity grid becomes cleaner. While the manufacturing stage of EVs is more emission-intensive due to battery production, their operational emissions are significantly lower, especially when powered by renewable energy. The end-of-life impacts are still being optimized, with ongoing improvements in recycling technologies. Overall, the transition to electric vehicles is seen as a positive step towards reducing transportation-related greenhouse gas emissions.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include assessing the emissions and resource use associated with manufacturing, operating, and recycling each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced throughout the life cycle of both vehicle types, specifically analyzing the differences in greenhouse gas emissions during the manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life stages for electric and gasoline vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include assessing the emissions and resource use associated with manufacturing, operating, and recycling each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by focusing on specific environmental factors, such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource depletion. This approach would involve comparing the emissions produced during vehicle operation, as well as the impact of sourcing and disposing of materials used in batteries versus traditional fuel.", + "I can answer by analyzing case studies and real-world data from regions that have implemented electric vehicles extensively. By examining the changes in air quality, energy consumption patterns, and economic impacts in these areas, I can provide insights into the broader environmental effects of transitioning from gasoline to electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring expert opinions and research studies from environmental scientists and automotive engineers. This approach would involve summarizing findings from academic journals, reports from environmental organizations, and insights from industry experts to provide a comprehensive view of the environmental impacts of both types of vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include assessing the emissions and resource use associated with manufacturing, operating, and recycling each type of vehicle." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced throughout the life cycle of both vehicle types, specifically analyzing the differences in greenhouse gas emissions during the manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life stages for electric and gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining the resource extraction processes involved, comparing the environmental impacts of mining for electric vehicle battery materials, such as lithium and cobalt, versus the extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by evaluating the energy consumption and efficiency of both vehicle types throughout their life cycles, considering how the source of electricity for charging electric vehicles (renewable vs. non-renewable) affects their overall environmental impact compared to the fuel consumption of gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by assessing the recycling and disposal processes for each vehicle type, investigating how the disposal of batteries and other components of electric vehicles compares environmentally to the disposal of gasoline vehicle parts, and exploring advancements in recycling technologies that mitigate these impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced throughout the life cycle of both vehicle types, specifically analyzing the differences in greenhouse gas emissions during the manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life stages for electric and gasoline vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:19.070549", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 30 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "1faa42c9-2a74-4b26-bd9c-4ca6c64d1590", + "ibfs_id": "886acc5f-06fa-4156-94e4-dde87a044eb2", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but battery production has environmental impacts compared to traditional gasoline vehicle emissions.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their operation stage, we need to focus on emissions and energy efficiency.\n\n### Emissions During Operation\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Direct Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions during operation. This means they do not emit pollutants such as carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), or particulate matter (PM) while being driven.\n - **Indirect Emissions:** The environmental impact of EVs during operation largely depends on the source of the electricity used to charge them. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the indirect emissions are minimal. However, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels such as coal or natural gas, the emissions associated with generating that electricity can be significant.\n - **Grid Mix Impact:** In regions where the grid is cleaner (i.e., has a higher percentage of renewable energy), the overall emissions from EVs are lower. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal or other fossil fuels, the emissions are higher.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Direct Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, and PM directly from the tailpipe as a result of burning gasoline. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change.\n - **Fuel Combustion:** The combustion of gasoline in internal combustion engines is less efficient and results in higher emissions per mile compared to EVs charged from a clean grid.\n\n### Energy Efficiency\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 60% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels. This is significantly higher than the efficiency of internal combustion engines.\n - **Regenerative Braking:** EVs often use regenerative braking, which recovers energy that would otherwise be lost during braking and stores it in the battery, further improving efficiency.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Efficiency:** Internal combustion engines typically convert only about 20-30% of the energy stored in gasoline into power at the wheels. The rest is lost as heat and through other inefficiencies.\n - **Fuel Economy:** While advancements have been made to improve the fuel economy of gasoline vehicles, they still lag behind the energy efficiency of EVs.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nDuring the operation stage, electric vehicles have a clear advantage over gasoline vehicles in terms of emissions and energy efficiency. EVs produce no direct emissions and are more energy-efficient. However, the overall environmental impact of EVs depends significantly on the electricity generation mix. As the grid becomes cleaner with more renewable energy sources, the environmental benefits of EVs during their operation stage will continue to increase. In contrast, gasoline vehicles consistently emit pollutants and are less efficient, contributing more to environmental degradation during their operation.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric and traditional gasoline vehicles, examining the environmental impacts from production, operation, and disposal stages. This approach considers the total environmental footprint of both vehicle types over their entire life span.", + "I can answer by concentrating on the operation stage, comparing the emissions and energy efficiency of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their use. This would involve analyzing the source of electricity used for charging electric vehicles and comparing it with the direct emissions from gasoline vehicle operation." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric and traditional gasoline vehicles, examining the environmental impacts from production, operation, and disposal stages. This approach considers the total environmental footprint of both vehicle types over their entire life span.", + "I can answer by reviewing scientific literature and studies that focus on the emissions and pollution differences between electric and gasoline vehicles, highlighting key findings about greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, and energy consumption.", + "I can answer by exploring the geopolitical and resource extraction implications of electric and gasoline vehicles, analyzing how the need for materials like lithium, cobalt, and fossil fuels affects ecosystems and communities around the world.", + "I can answer by creating a case study analysis of specific regions or cities that have implemented electric vehicle initiatives, assessing the local environmental changes compared to areas with predominantly gasoline vehicle use. This would provide practical insights into real-world impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric and traditional gasoline vehicles, examining the environmental impacts from production, operation, and disposal stages. This approach considers the total environmental footprint of both vehicle types over their entire life span." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the production stage, conducting a detailed analysis of the raw materials and energy consumption involved in manufacturing electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach will highlight the specific environmental impacts associated with material extraction, manufacturing processes, and supply chain logistics.", + "I can answer by concentrating on the operation stage, comparing the emissions and energy efficiency of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their use. This would involve analyzing the source of electricity used for charging electric vehicles and comparing it with the direct emissions from gasoline vehicle operation.", + "I can answer by delving into the disposal stage, evaluating the environmental impacts of end-of-life management for electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This includes examining recycling processes, waste management of batteries, and the environmental cost of vehicle decommissioning.", + "I can answer by integrating regional differences into the lifecycle analysis, assessing how geographic variations in energy sources, manufacturing practices, and waste management infrastructures influence the comparative environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles in different regions." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by concentrating on the operation stage, comparing the emissions and energy efficiency of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their use. This would involve analyzing the source of electricity used for charging electric vehicles and comparing it with the direct emissions from gasoline vehicle operation." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:23.576451", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 31 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "7518f790-161e-4cca-887a-990acadeda6a", + "ibfs_id": "f89fc09e-6bb4-447b-8a09-d3ccf57274c6", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and fossil fuel dependence but have battery production and disposal environmental impacts compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles through a component-level lifecycle assessment, we need to examine the major components of each vehicle type: batteries, engines, and chassis. This assessment will consider the environmental impacts from raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal.\n\n### 1. Batteries (Electric Vehicles)\n\n**Raw Material Extraction:**\n- **Lithium, Cobalt, Nickel, and Graphite:** These materials are critical for lithium-ion batteries used in EVs. Mining these elements can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Environmental Concerns:** Cobalt mining, particularly in the Democratic Republic of Congo, raises concerns about human rights and environmental degradation.\n\n**Manufacturing:**\n- **Energy-Intensive Process:** Battery production is energy-intensive, contributing to higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Emissions:** The manufacturing process emits greenhouse gases and other pollutants, although advancements are being made to reduce these impacts.\n\n**Usage:**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, reducing urban air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation.\n- **Efficiency:** Electric motors are more efficient than internal combustion engines, leading to lower energy consumption per mile.\n\n**Disposal and Recycling:**\n- **Recycling Challenges:** Battery recycling is complex but crucial to mitigate environmental impacts. Efforts are underway to improve recycling rates and processes.\n- **Potential for Reuse:** Used EV batteries can be repurposed for energy storage, extending their lifecycle.\n\n### 2. Engines (Gasoline Vehicles)\n\n**Raw Material Extraction:**\n- **Steel, Aluminum, and Plastics:** These materials are used extensively in engine manufacturing, with environmental impacts from mining and refining.\n- **Oil Extraction:** The extraction and refining of oil for gasoline contribute to significant environmental degradation and greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n**Manufacturing:**\n- **Complex Manufacturing:** Internal combustion engines (ICEs) require numerous components, each with its own environmental footprint.\n- **Emissions:** The manufacturing process emits pollutants, though typically less than battery production.\n\n**Usage:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** ICEs are generally less efficient than electric motors, leading to higher energy consumption and emissions per mile.\n\n**Disposal and Recycling:**\n- **Engine Recycling:** Engines can be recycled, but the process is less complex than battery recycling.\n- **Oil Waste:** Used oil and other fluids pose environmental hazards if not properly managed.\n\n### 3. Chassis (Both Vehicle Types)\n\n**Raw Material Extraction:**\n- **Steel and Aluminum:** Both EVs and gasoline vehicles use similar materials for the chassis, with environmental impacts from mining and processing.\n- **Environmental Concerns:** The extraction and processing of these materials can lead to habitat destruction and pollution.\n\n**Manufacturing:**\n- **Similar Processes:** The manufacturing processes for chassis are similar for both vehicle types, with energy consumption and emissions.\n- **Lightweight Materials:** Increasing use of lightweight materials like aluminum can reduce overall vehicle emissions by improving fuel efficiency.\n\n**Usage:**\n- **Durability and Efficiency:** The design and materials of the chassis can impact vehicle efficiency and lifespan, affecting overall environmental impact.\n\n**Disposal and Recycling:**\n- **Recyclability:** Steel and aluminum are highly recyclable, reducing the environmental impact at the end of the vehicle's life.\n- **Waste Management:** Proper disposal and recycling of chassis materials are crucial to minimizing environmental impacts.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nWhile electric vehicles have higher environmental impacts during the production phase, particularly due to battery manufacturing, they offer significant benefits during the usage phase with zero tailpipe emissions and higher efficiency. Gasoline vehicles, on the other hand, have lower initial production impacts but contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational life. The overall lifecycle assessment suggests that EVs have the potential for lower total environmental impacts, especially as battery technology and recycling processes improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles throughout their entire lifecycle. This includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and disposal or recycling at end-of-life.", + "I can answer by conducting a component-level lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves breaking down the vehicles into their major components\u2014such as batteries, engines, and chassis\u2014and evaluating the environmental impacts associated with each component from raw material extraction to disposal." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles throughout their entire lifecycle. This includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and disposal or recycling at end-of-life.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational emissions of each vehicle type. This approach would analyze the greenhouse gas emissions produced during the use phase of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles, considering the energy sources used to generate electricity and the efficiency of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by exploring the resource extraction and material usage for both vehicle types. This would involve comparing the environmental consequences of mining and processing materials like lithium and cobalt for electric vehicles with oil extraction and refining for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining regional and policy influences, which involves analyzing how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles differ based on geographic location and governmental regulations. This approach would consider factors like the energy grid's carbon intensity, tax incentives, and emission standards that vary by country or region." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles throughout their entire lifecycle. This includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and disposal or recycling at end-of-life." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a component-level lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves breaking down the vehicles into their major components\u2014such as batteries, engines, and chassis\u2014and evaluating the environmental impacts associated with each component from raw material extraction to disposal.", + "I can answer by focusing on regional lifecycle assessments, where I evaluate the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles based on specific geographic regions. This approach considers regional variations in energy sources, manufacturing practices, and recycling capabilities, providing a localized perspective on their environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by integrating a usage-phase focused lifecycle assessment, which emphasizes the environmental impacts during the operation phase of the vehicles. This approach analyzes factors like electricity grid mix for electric vehicles, fuel efficiency, and emissions during the driving phase, allowing a thorough comparison based on real-world usage scenarios.", + "I can answer by employing a time-based lifecycle assessment, which examines how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles change over time. This approach considers technological advancements, changes in energy sources, and improvements in recycling technologies that might alter the lifecycle impacts of both types of vehicles in the future." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a component-level lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves breaking down the vehicles into their major components\u2014such as batteries, engines, and chassis\u2014and evaluating the environmental impacts associated with each component from raw material extraction to disposal." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:27.300771", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 32 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "ecaf30e7-e65c-4049-8fa8-55135478c6c1", + "ibfs_id": "a7466193-2dde-4e77-9306-b32f5aa74153", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles offer lower emissions and reduced pollution over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles, benefiting environmental health significantly.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, it is essential to examine the lifecycle emissions of both vehicle types. This involves considering emissions from the production, operational, and disposal phases.\n\n### 1. Production Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** The production of EVs, particularly the manufacturing of lithium-ion batteries, is energy-intensive and results in significant emissions. Mining and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel contribute to these emissions. The energy used in battery manufacturing often comes from fossil fuels, especially if the production occurs in regions with carbon-intensive energy grids.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing:** Besides the battery, the rest of the EV components generally have similar manufacturing emissions to those of gasoline vehicles.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Drivetrain:** The production of internal combustion engines and associated components involves significant emissions, though typically less than the battery production for EVs.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing:** Similar to EVs, the manufacturing of the vehicle body and other components contribute to emissions, but the absence of a large battery reduces the overall production emissions compared to EVs.\n\n### 2. Operational Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Electricity Source:** The operational emissions of EVs depend heavily on the electricity source. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources, EVs have very low operational emissions. However, if the electricity comes from coal or other fossil fuels, the emissions can be higher.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Combustion:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe during operation. These emissions are a significant contributor to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction, refining, and distribution of gasoline also contribute to emissions, though these are often less visible than tailpipe emissions.\n\n### 3. Disposal Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal phase for EVs involves challenges and opportunities in battery recycling. Proper recycling can mitigate some environmental impacts by recovering valuable materials, reducing the need for new raw material extraction. However, improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, the rest of the EV can be recycled, but the presence of the battery adds complexity.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **End-of-Life Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle, with established processes for recovering metals and other materials. However, they do not have the same level of complexity as EVs due to the absence of large batteries.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nWhen considering lifecycle emissions, electric vehicles generally have higher emissions during the production phase due to battery manufacturing but lower emissions during the operational phase, especially when powered by renewable energy. Gasoline vehicles have lower production emissions but significantly higher operational emissions due to fuel combustion. The disposal phase presents challenges for both, with EVs facing additional complexity due to battery recycling. Overall, the environmental impact of EVs can be lower than gasoline vehicles, particularly as the energy grid becomes cleaner and battery recycling technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions comparison during the operational phase of both vehicle types. This approach will look at the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles versus the emissions associated with electricity generation for electric vehicles, considering different energy sources such as coal, natural gas, and renewables.", + "I can answer by examining the lifecycle emissions of both vehicle types, including production, operational, and disposal phases. This will provide a broader view of emissions beyond just the operational phase, highlighting how manufacturing processes and end-of-life recycling affect the total emissions profile of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment that examines the entire lifespan of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include analyzing the environmental impact of raw material extraction, vehicle manufacturing, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life disposal or recycling.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions comparison during the operational phase of both vehicle types. This approach will look at the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles versus the emissions associated with electricity generation for electric vehicles, considering different energy sources such as coal, natural gas, and renewables.", + "I can answer by evaluating the impact of resource extraction and battery production for electric vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental effects of mining for lithium, cobalt, and other materials necessary for electric vehicle batteries, compared to the extraction and refinement of oil for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by investigating the broader environmental implications, such as the impact on air quality and noise pollution in urban areas. This approach would consider how the adoption of electric vehicles can lead to cleaner city air and quieter streets compared to traditional gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions comparison during the operational phase of both vehicle types. This approach will look at the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles versus the emissions associated with electricity generation for electric vehicles, considering different energy sources such as coal, natural gas, and renewables." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a comparative analysis of the emissions related to the energy source mix for electricity generation in different regions. This approach will consider how the predominant use of coal, natural gas, or renewables in a specific area impacts the overall emissions associated with charging electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining the lifecycle emissions of both vehicle types, including production, operational, and disposal phases. This will provide a broader view of emissions beyond just the operational phase, highlighting how manufacturing processes and end-of-life recycling affect the total emissions profile of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by evaluating the impact of technological advancements and policy changes on emissions during the operational phase. This approach will look at how improvements in fuel efficiency for gasoline vehicles and advancements in battery technology and grid decarbonization for electric vehicles influence their emissions over time.", + "I can answer by analyzing the emissions produced by electric vehicles when charged using different types of electric grids, such as smart grids or microgrids. This approach will consider how innovations in grid technology can optimize energy use and reduce emissions compared to traditional grid systems." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by examining the lifecycle emissions of both vehicle types, including production, operational, and disposal phases. This will provide a broader view of emissions beyond just the operational phase, highlighting how manufacturing processes and end-of-life recycling affect the total emissions profile of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:33.896201", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 33 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "9b15b04b-c7e1-4b91-862b-5ed520318ab7", + "ibfs_id": "d5b8860b-bce6-4b8d-a490-7aa15af44640", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles significantly reduce greenhouse gases and air pollutants compared to gasoline vehicles, but battery production and disposal remain impactful.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can perform a cradle-to-grave analysis focusing on the carbon footprint. This involves assessing the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions at each stage of the vehicle's lifecycle: raw material extraction, manufacturing, operational use, and end-of-life disposal.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other materials. Mining and processing these materials are energy-intensive and contribute significantly to GHG emissions. For instance, the production of a typical EV battery can emit approximately 61-106 kg of CO2 per kWh of battery capacity.\n- **Other Components:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, EVs require steel, aluminum, and plastics, which also contribute to emissions during extraction and processing.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction and refining of crude oil into gasoline is a major source of emissions. This process involves significant energy use and results in substantial CO2 emissions.\n- **Vehicle Components:** Like EVs, gasoline vehicles require metals and plastics, contributing to emissions during their extraction and processing.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- Manufacturing EVs, especially the battery, typically results in higher initial emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. The production of the battery alone can account for a significant portion of the vehicle's total manufacturing emissions.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Generally, the manufacturing emissions for gasoline vehicles are lower than for EVs, primarily due to the absence of large battery packs. However, the production of internal combustion engines also contributes to emissions.\n\n### 3. Operational Use\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Electricity Source:** The operational emissions of EVs depend heavily on the electricity mix used for charging. In regions with a high share of renewable energy, EVs have significantly lower operational emissions. For instance, in areas with a predominantly coal-based electricity grid, the emissions can be higher.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid into vehicle movement.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Combustion:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2 directly from the tailpipe during fuel combustion. The average gasoline vehicle emits about 2.3 kg of CO2 per liter of gasoline burned.\n- **Efficiency:** Internal combustion engines are less efficient than electric motors, resulting in higher emissions per kilometer driven.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The recycling of EV batteries can mitigate some of the initial emissions from battery production. However, recycling processes themselves can be energy-intensive and contribute to emissions.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, the recycling of metals and other materials can reduce the overall carbon footprint.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** The recycling of metals and other components can help offset some of the emissions from manufacturing and raw material extraction.\n\n### Overall Comparison\n\n- **Initial Emissions:** EVs generally have higher initial emissions due to battery production. However, these emissions can be offset over time through lower operational emissions.\n- **Operational Emissions:** EVs typically have lower operational emissions, especially in regions with clean electricity grids. Gasoline vehicles have consistent emissions from fuel combustion.\n- **Lifecycle Emissions:** Over their entire lifecycle, EVs can have a lower carbon footprint than gasoline vehicles, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling improves.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs have higher emissions during the manufacturing phase, their lower operational emissions often result in a smaller overall carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles, especially as the energy grid transitions to renewable sources.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This involves analyzing each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, production, and usage, to disposal\u2014and comparing the environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution, associated with each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by conducting a cradle-to-grave analysis specifically focusing on the carbon footprint of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy involves quantifying the total greenhouse gas emissions from the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, operational use, and end-of-life disposal for both vehicle types, providing a detailed comparison of their carbon impacts throughout their entire lifespan." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This involves analyzing each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, production, and usage, to disposal\u2014and comparing the environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution, associated with each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by focusing on the source of the electricity used to power electric vehicles. This approach involves examining how the environmental impacts change based on whether the electricity is generated from renewable sources like solar and wind, or from fossil fuels like coal and natural gas, and comparing these impacts to those of gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by comparing the environmental policies and incentives that influence the adoption of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This strategy involves looking at how government regulations, subsidies, and tax incentives impact the environmental footprint of both types of vehicles, considering the role of policy in encouraging the use of cleaner technologies.", + "I can answer by examining the technological advancements in battery production and recycling for electric vehicles. This involves analyzing how improvements in battery efficiency, longevity, and recycling processes can mitigate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles, focusing on specific technological innovations and their ecological effects." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This involves analyzing each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, production, and usage, to disposal\u2014and comparing the environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution, associated with each type of vehicle." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a cradle-to-grave analysis specifically focusing on the carbon footprint of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy involves quantifying the total greenhouse gas emissions from the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, operational use, and end-of-life disposal for both vehicle types, providing a detailed comparison of their carbon impacts throughout their entire lifespan.", + "I can answer by performing a life cycle assessment with an emphasis on resource depletion. This approach examines the extraction and consumption of critical materials like lithium and cobalt for electric vehicle batteries versus the crude oil requirements for gasoline vehicles. It assesses the sustainability and environmental toll of obtaining and using these resources in the context of each vehicle type's life cycle.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative study that highlights the pollution levels during the operational phase of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This involves analyzing emissions of pollutants such as nitrogen oxides, sulfur dioxide, and particulate matter during the usage phase, providing insights on how each vehicle type affects urban air quality and human health.", + "I can answer by implementing a life cycle assessment focused on the disposal and recycling phase of electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy examines the environmental impacts of waste management processes, including battery recycling for electric vehicles and the treatment of end-of-life gasoline engines, to determine the sustainability and pollution potential at the end of each vehicle's life." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a cradle-to-grave analysis specifically focusing on the carbon footprint of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy involves quantifying the total greenhouse gas emissions from the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, operational use, and end-of-life disposal for both vehicle types, providing a detailed comparison of their carbon impacts throughout their entire lifespan." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:38.595356", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 34 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "7dee41f1-7319-445c-8ad2-3cb682cc0948", + "ibfs_id": "1bfcc88b-d944-4440-b6f3-1c814e20399f", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, but their battery production has environmental and resource extraction impacts.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their operation phase using a lifecycle analysis approach, we focus on several key factors: emissions from fuel or electricity consumption, energy use efficiency, and the potential for renewable energy integration.\n\n### Emissions from Fuel or Electricity Consumption\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Electricity Generation:** The emissions associated with EVs during the operation phase depend on the source of the electricity used to charge them. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the emissions are minimal. However, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels such as coal or natural gas, the emissions can be significant.\n - **Direct Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, meaning they do not emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), or particulate matter during operation. This is a significant advantage over gasoline vehicles, especially in urban areas where air quality is a concern.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Fuel Combustion:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, carbon monoxide (CO), and hydrocarbons as a result of burning gasoline. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change.\n - **Lifecycle Emissions:** The emissions from gasoline vehicles are relatively consistent, as they are directly tied to the combustion of fossil fuels.\n\n### Efficiency of Energy Use\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - **Energy Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 77% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, whereas internal combustion engines (ICEs) convert only about 12%\u201330% of the energy stored in gasoline to power at the wheels.\n - **Regenerative Braking:** EVs often use regenerative braking, which recovers energy that would otherwise be lost during braking and feeds it back into the battery, further improving efficiency.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Energy Losses:** A significant portion of the energy in gasoline is lost as heat in the engine, making them less efficient compared to EVs. The efficiency of gasoline engines is limited by thermodynamic constraints.\n\n### Potential for Renewable Energy Integration\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - **Renewable Energy Integration:** EVs have the potential to be powered entirely by renewable energy sources, depending on the electricity grid's composition. As the grid becomes greener, the environmental impact of operating EVs decreases.\n - **Grid Flexibility:** EVs can also support the integration of renewable energy by acting as flexible loads that can be charged during periods of high renewable output, helping to balance supply and demand.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Fossil Fuel Dependency:** Gasoline vehicles are inherently tied to fossil fuels, limiting their potential for renewable energy integration. While biofuels offer some potential for reducing fossil fuel use, they are not yet widely adopted and come with their own environmental challenges.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, during the operation phase, electric vehicles generally have a lower environmental impact compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to their higher energy efficiency and the potential for using renewable energy sources. The actual environmental benefits of EVs depend significantly on the electricity grid's energy mix. As grids become cleaner and more reliant on renewable energy, the advantages of EVs over gasoline vehicles in terms of emissions and environmental impact will continue to grow.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include examining the production, operation, and disposal phases of each vehicle type to assess their overall carbon footprint and resource consumption.", + "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis with a focus on the operation phase, comparing the environmental impacts of using electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles over their typical lifespan. This would include assessing the emissions from fuel or electricity consumption, the efficiency of energy use, and the potential for energy source variability such as renewable energy integration for electric vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include examining the production, operation, and disposal phases of each vehicle type to assess their overall carbon footprint and resource consumption.", + "I can answer by comparing the emissions generated during the operation phase of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach would focus on the emissions produced directly from driving each type of vehicle, taking into account the source of electricity for electric vehicles and the fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring the impact of battery production and disposal for electric vehicles compared to the environmental effects of extracting and refining petroleum for gasoline vehicles. This would involve an analysis of the mining and manufacturing processes for electric vehicle batteries and the lifecycle of fossil fuel production for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining regional differences in environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would involve analyzing how the source of electricity (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and local environmental policies in different regions affect the comparative environmental benefits or drawbacks of each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include examining the production, operation, and disposal phases of each vehicle type to assess their overall carbon footprint and resource consumption." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that focuses specifically on the production phase of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve evaluating the environmental impacts associated with the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, and the energy consumption required to build each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis with a focus on the operation phase, comparing the environmental impacts of using electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles over their typical lifespan. This would include assessing the emissions from fuel or electricity consumption, the efficiency of energy use, and the potential for energy source variability such as renewable energy integration for electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by undertaking a lifecycle analysis that centers on the disposal and recycling phase of both vehicle types. This approach would examine the environmental implications of end-of-life vehicle management, including the recycling of batteries in electric vehicles, handling of hazardous materials, and the potential for reclaiming and reusing vehicle components.", + "I can answer by conducting a detailed lifecycle analysis that incorporates geographical variations in the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would evaluate how differences in regional energy sources, recycling facilities, and manufacturing practices affect the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type, providing a more localized perspective on their impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis with a focus on the operation phase, comparing the environmental impacts of using electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles over their typical lifespan. This would include assessing the emissions from fuel or electricity consumption, the efficiency of energy use, and the potential for energy source variability such as renewable energy integration for electric vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:39.143457", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 35 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "fb91c060-43c7-4576-8555-1cb4104f191f", + "ibfs_id": "f7e4e340-0d32-448e-85b2-8d79b62f473a", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions, decrease reliance on fossil fuels, promote cleaner energy use, but require resource-intensive battery production.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, a lifecycle analysis (LCA) is conducted. This analysis considers the entire lifecycle of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction through manufacturing, usage, and disposal. Here is a detailed comparison based on each phase:\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Batteries:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other rare earth metals. Mining these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** Like gasoline vehicles, EVs require steel, aluminum, and plastics, but the battery materials add additional environmental burdens.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling and refining processes that can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Materials:** Gasoline vehicles also require steel, aluminum, and plastics, but they do not need the same rare metals as EVs.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in manufacturing processes are reducing these impacts over time.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Less Energy-Intensive:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is generally less energy-intensive than for EVs, primarily due to the absence of large battery packs.\n\n### 3. Usage Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during the usage phase depends on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources (solar, wind) result in lower emissions, while coal or natural gas can increase the carbon footprint.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Improvements in fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, but they remain higher than those of EVs powered by clean energy.\n\n### 4. Disposal and Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal of EV batteries poses challenges due to the hazardous materials involved. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable materials like lithium and cobalt.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, EVs can be recycled for their metal components, but the battery remains a significant concern.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Established Recycling Processes:** Gasoline vehicles have well-established recycling processes for metals and other materials, but they still generate waste and emissions during disposal.\n\n### Overall Environmental Impact\n\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** Over their entire lifecycle, EVs generally produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline vehicles, especially when powered by renewable energy.\n- **Air Quality:** EVs contribute to improved air quality due to the absence of tailpipe emissions.\n- **Resource Use:** EVs require more resource-intensive materials for battery production, but advancements in recycling and sustainable mining practices can mitigate some impacts.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs have higher environmental impacts during the production phase due to battery manufacturing, they offer significant benefits during the usage phase, particularly in reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving air quality. The overall lifecycle impact of EVs is generally lower than that of gasoline vehicles, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies advance.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production through end-of-life. This approach considers raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal phases to provide a comprehensive overview of total environmental impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production through end-of-life. This approach considers raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal phases to provide a comprehensive overview of total environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions perspective, comparing the greenhouse gas emissions and air pollutants associated with the operational phase of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves analyzing data related to tailpipe emissions from gasoline vehicles versus the emissions related to electricity generation for EVs.", + "I can answer by exploring the resource consumption and sustainability angle, assessing the impact of resource extraction for batteries in electric vehicles compared to the resource use in gasoline production. This approach would delve into the mining of lithium, cobalt, and other materials used in EV batteries, and compare it to oil extraction and refining processes.", + "I can answer by examining the regional and geographical differences in environmental impacts, considering how the source of electricity (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and local environmental regulations affect the performance of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles in different parts of the world. This strategy highlights how local energy grids and policies can influence the overall environmental footprint of EVs." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production through end-of-life. This approach considers raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal phases to provide a comprehensive overview of total environmental impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:48.491159", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 28 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "38f5c688-8c8f-41f2-8afa-ea64cc5d3534", + "ibfs_id": "313fb282-0594-4861-a260-dbf789bfacfd", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, promote renewable energy use, but require resource-intensive battery production affecting ecosystems.", + "final_answer": "To address the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, a thematic analysis of qualitative research papers, industry reports, and case studies reveals several key themes and patterns. These themes include resource extraction practices, battery disposal issues, energy sourcing, and overall emissions.\n\n### 1. Resource Extraction Practices\n\n**Theme:** The extraction of raw materials for EV batteries, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, has significant environmental and social impacts.\n\n- **Lithium Mining:** Research indicates that lithium extraction, particularly in regions like South America, can lead to water depletion and contamination. The process requires large amounts of water, which can affect local ecosystems and communities.\n \n- **Cobalt and Nickel Mining:** Cobalt mining, primarily in the Democratic Republic of Congo, is associated with severe environmental degradation and human rights issues. Reports highlight soil erosion, deforestation, and pollution of water sources as major concerns.\n\n### 2. Battery Disposal and Recycling\n\n**Theme:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries present environmental challenges, but also opportunities for improvement.\n\n- **Disposal Issues:** Qualitative studies emphasize the potential environmental hazards of improper battery disposal, including soil and water contamination from heavy metals.\n \n- **Recycling Opportunities:** Industry reports suggest that advancements in battery recycling technologies can mitigate these impacts. Efficient recycling processes can recover valuable materials, reducing the need for new resource extraction and minimizing waste.\n\n### 3. Energy Sourcing\n\n**Theme:** The environmental impact of EVs is heavily influenced by the energy sources used for electricity generation.\n\n- **Renewable vs. Fossil Fuels:** Case studies show that the carbon footprint of EVs is significantly lower in regions where electricity is predominantly generated from renewable sources. In contrast, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, the benefits are less pronounced.\n \n- **Grid Decarbonization:** Industry reports highlight the importance of grid decarbonization in maximizing the environmental benefits of EVs. As grids become greener, the lifecycle emissions of EVs continue to decrease.\n\n### 4. Overall Emissions\n\n**Theme:** EVs generally produce fewer emissions over their lifecycle compared to gasoline vehicles, but the extent varies based on several factors.\n\n- **Lifecycle Emissions:** Qualitative research consistently finds that EVs have lower lifetime greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline vehicles, even when accounting for manufacturing and end-of-life processes. This is primarily due to the higher efficiency of electric motors and the potential for renewable energy use.\n \n- **Urban Air Quality:** Case studies in urban areas demonstrate that EVs contribute to improved air quality by eliminating tailpipe emissions, which are a significant source of urban pollution.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe thematic analysis of qualitative research papers, industry reports, and case studies reveals that while electric vehicles offer substantial environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of emissions and urban air quality, challenges remain. These include the environmental and social impacts of resource extraction, the need for effective battery recycling, and the importance of clean energy sourcing. Addressing these challenges through technological advancements and policy measures can enhance the positive environmental impacts of electric vehicles.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive literature review of academic and industry research papers comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve summarizing findings on emissions, resource extraction, and lifecycle assessments from various studies to provide a well-rounded overview.", + "I can answer by conducting a thematic analysis of qualitative research papers, industry reports, and case studies. This would involve identifying common themes and patterns related to environmental impacts, such as resource extraction practices, battery disposal issues, and energy sourcing for EVs, to provide a more nuanced understanding of their impacts compared to gasoline vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive literature review of academic and industry research papers comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve summarizing findings on emissions, resource extraction, and lifecycle assessments from various studies to provide a well-rounded overview.", + "I can answer by performing a data-driven analysis using lifecycle assessment tools that model the emissions and resource usage of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve gathering data on manufacturing, operational, and disposal phases to quantitatively compare their overall environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by exploring expert opinions and interviews with environmental scientists and automotive industry specialists. This would involve collecting qualitative insights and perspectives on the long-term sustainability and potential environmental benefits or drawbacks of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by creating a case study comparison of specific regions or countries that have adopted electric vehicles widely. This approach would examine real-world impacts on air quality, energy consumption, and infrastructure development, contrasting these with regions that predominantly use gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive literature review of academic and industry research papers comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve summarizing findings on emissions, resource extraction, and lifecycle assessments from various studies to provide a well-rounded overview." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a meta-analysis of existing research papers that specifically aggregate data on the greenhouse gas emissions from the production and use phases of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve synthesizing quantitative data from multiple studies to present an averaged impact comparison.", + "I can answer by conducting a thematic analysis of qualitative research papers, industry reports, and case studies. This would involve identifying common themes and patterns related to environmental impacts, such as resource extraction practices, battery disposal issues, and energy sourcing for EVs, to provide a more nuanced understanding of their impacts compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by creating a comparative lifecycle assessment (LCA) synthesis that integrates findings from various LCA studies. This would involve detailing the environmental impacts associated with each stage of the vehicle's lifecycle, from raw material extraction to end-of-life disposal, and comparing these impacts across different vehicle types.", + "I can answer by conducting a critical review of policy-driven research papers and governmental reports that discuss the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would focus on how regulatory frameworks and incentives influence the environmental outcomes of vehicle use, and compare these impacts based on the policy context." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a thematic analysis of qualitative research papers, industry reports, and case studies. This would involve identifying common themes and patterns related to environmental impacts, such as resource extraction practices, battery disposal issues, and energy sourcing for EVs, to provide a more nuanced understanding of their impacts compared to gasoline vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:55.846540", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 38 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "0d22084f-ae76-422a-8e08-8f63869ca321", + "ibfs_id": "b313eb07-eecb-45c4-8d09-dc0edda5b884", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and reliance on fossil fuels but involve environmental challenges in battery production and material sourcing.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles at the manufacturing stage, we need to focus on the extraction and processing of raw materials. This involves examining the environmental consequences of mining for key materials used in EV batteries\u2014such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel\u2014versus the extraction and refinement of crude oil for gasoline vehicles.\n\n### Electric Vehicles: Raw Material Extraction and Processing\n\n1. **Lithium Extraction:**\n - **Sources:** Lithium is primarily extracted from brine pools and hard rock mining. The major sources are located in countries like Australia, Chile, and Argentina.\n - **Environmental Impacts:**\n - **Water Usage:** Brine extraction involves evaporating large amounts of water, which can deplete local water resources, affecting agriculture and local communities.\n - **Land Degradation:** Both brine and hard rock mining can lead to significant land disturbance and habitat destruction.\n - **Chemical Pollution:** The use of chemicals in lithium extraction can lead to soil and water contamination if not managed properly.\n\n2. **Cobalt Extraction:**\n - **Sources:** Cobalt is often a byproduct of nickel and copper mining, with significant production in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC).\n - **Environmental Impacts:**\n - **Toxic Waste:** Mining operations can produce toxic waste that contaminates water supplies.\n - **Land Degradation and Habitat Loss:** Mining activities can lead to deforestation and soil erosion.\n - **Humanitarian Concerns:** In the DRC, artisanal mining practices often involve poor working conditions and child labor, which are ethical rather than environmental concerns but are intertwined with sustainability issues.\n\n3. **Nickel Extraction:**\n - **Sources:** Nickel is mined from sulfide ores and laterite ores, with major producers including Indonesia, the Philippines, and Russia.\n - **Environmental Impacts:**\n - **Energy-Intensive Processing:** The extraction and processing of nickel are energy-intensive, contributing to greenhouse gas emissions.\n - **Acid Mine Drainage:** Sulfide mining can lead to acid mine drainage, which pollutes waterways and harms aquatic life.\n - **Deforestation:** Laterite mining often involves clearing large areas of tropical forest.\n\n### Gasoline Vehicles: Crude Oil Extraction and Refinement\n\n1. **Crude Oil Extraction:**\n - **Sources:** Crude oil is extracted from onshore and offshore oil fields worldwide, with major producers including Saudi Arabia, the United States, and Russia.\n - **Environmental Impacts:**\n - **Oil Spills:** Accidental spills during extraction and transportation can have devastating effects on marine and terrestrial ecosystems.\n - **Habitat Disruption:** Drilling operations can disrupt local ecosystems and wildlife habitats.\n - **Air and Water Pollution:** The extraction process can release volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and other pollutants into the environment.\n\n2. **Oil Refinement:**\n - **Process:** Refining crude oil into gasoline involves several stages, including distillation, cracking, and reforming.\n - **Environmental Impacts:**\n - **Air Pollution:** Refineries emit pollutants such as sulfur dioxide (SO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, which contribute to air quality issues and acid rain.\n - **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** The refining process is energy-intensive and contributes significantly to CO2 emissions.\n - **Waste Production:** Refineries produce solid and liquid waste, which can contaminate soil and water if not properly managed.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, both electric and gasoline vehicles have significant environmental impacts at the manufacturing stage, primarily due to the extraction and processing of raw materials. EVs require mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which can lead to water depletion, habitat destruction, and pollution. Gasoline vehicles rely on crude oil extraction and refinement, which also result in habitat disruption, pollution, and greenhouse gas emissions. While EVs offer benefits in terms of reduced tailpipe emissions during operation, the environmental costs of battery production are a critical factor to consider in their overall environmental footprint.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive lifecycle analysis, comparing the emissions and resource use from manufacturing, operating, and disposing of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would include examining the extraction and processing of raw materials, energy usage during vehicle production, emissions during vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal processes.", + "I can answer by focusing on the manufacturing stage, conducting a detailed analysis of the raw material extraction and processing for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include assessing the environmental impacts of mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries compared to the extraction and refinement of crude oil for gasoline vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive lifecycle analysis, comparing the emissions and resource use from manufacturing, operating, and disposing of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would include examining the extraction and processing of raw materials, energy usage during vehicle production, emissions during vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal processes.", + "I can answer by reviewing and summarizing the latest scientific research and reports from reputable environmental and automotive organizations. This would involve synthesizing findings from peer-reviewed studies and reports to provide a balanced view of the environmental impacts of both types of vehicles, highlighting key factors such as carbon footprints, air quality effects, and resource consumption.", + "I can answer by comparing case studies from countries or cities that have high adoption rates of electric vehicles with those that primarily use gasoline vehicles. This approach would examine real-world data on air pollution levels, greenhouse gas emissions, and other environmental indicators before and after the introduction of EVs, providing insights into their actual impact.", + "I can answer by conducting interviews with experts in environmental science and automotive technology. By gathering insights from engineers, environmentalists, and policy makers, I can provide diverse perspectives on the advantages and disadvantages of electric and gasoline vehicles, focusing on sustainability, technological advancements, and future trends in the industry." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive lifecycle analysis, comparing the emissions and resource use from manufacturing, operating, and disposing of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would include examining the extraction and processing of raw materials, energy usage during vehicle production, emissions during vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal processes." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the manufacturing stage, conducting a detailed analysis of the raw material extraction and processing for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include assessing the environmental impacts of mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries compared to the extraction and refinement of crude oil for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining the operational phase, quantifying the emissions produced during the use of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This would involve comparing the electricity generation sources for EVs in different regions against the emissions from burning gasoline, taking into account the carbon intensity of local energy grids.", + "I can answer by evaluating the end-of-life phase, specifically analyzing the recycling and disposal processes of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This would entail a study of the recyclability of EV batteries and the infrastructure available for battery recycling, as well as the environmental impacts of disposing or recycling traditional vehicle components.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle analysis, assessing how different geographic locations affect the environmental impacts of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles. This would involve looking at regional variations in electricity generation, vehicle usage patterns, and availability of recycling facilities to provide a localized perspective on the overall environmental benefits or drawbacks." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the manufacturing stage, conducting a detailed analysis of the raw material extraction and processing for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include assessing the environmental impacts of mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries compared to the extraction and refinement of crude oil for gasoline vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:52.622382", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 37 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "cfc775ca-9899-45b5-b807-84e6855cb3bc", + "ibfs_id": "fc956ff5-2f60-45bf-a985-60fb4ddbdb5a", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution but require rare minerals for batteries, impacting mining practices and disposal sustainability.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through a life cycle assessment (LCA) focused on the raw material extraction and processing stages, we need to examine the materials and processes involved in the production of key components for both types of vehicles.\n\n### Electric Vehicles (EVs)\n\n**1. Battery Production:**\n- **Materials:** The primary component of EVs that requires significant raw material extraction is the battery, typically a lithium-ion battery. Key materials include lithium, cobalt, nickel, manganese, and graphite.\n- **Extraction and Processing:**\n - **Lithium:** Extracted from brine pools or hard rock mining. Brine extraction involves pumping underground brine to the surface and evaporating the water, which can lead to significant water use and potential contamination of local water supplies.\n - **Cobalt and Nickel:** Often mined in regions with less stringent environmental regulations, leading to habitat destruction, soil and water pollution, and significant greenhouse gas emissions from mining operations.\n - **Graphite:** Extracted through mining, which can cause air and water pollution due to the release of dust and chemicals used in processing.\n\n**2. Environmental Impacts:**\n- **Water Usage and Pollution:** High water consumption, particularly for lithium extraction from brines, and potential contamination of water sources.\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** Significant emissions from mining operations and processing, especially for nickel and cobalt.\n- **Ecological Damage:** Habitat destruction and biodiversity loss due to mining activities.\n\n### Traditional Gasoline Vehicles\n\n**1. Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) Production:**\n- **Materials:** The production of an internal combustion engine involves steel, aluminum, and various alloys, which require iron ore, bauxite, and other minerals.\n- **Extraction and Processing:**\n - **Iron Ore and Steel:** Mining iron ore and processing it into steel involves significant energy use, often from fossil fuels, leading to greenhouse gas emissions.\n - **Aluminum:** Extracted from bauxite ore, which involves open-pit mining and a highly energy-intensive refining process known as the Bayer process, followed by smelting.\n\n**2. Environmental Impacts:**\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** High emissions from the energy-intensive processes of steel and aluminum production.\n- **Land Degradation:** Open-pit mining for bauxite and iron ore leads to significant land disturbance and habitat loss.\n- **Air and Water Pollution:** Emissions of particulates and pollutants from mining and processing operations.\n\n### Comparative Analysis\n\n- **Resource Intensity:** EVs require a more diverse range of materials, particularly rare metals, which can lead to higher environmental impacts in terms of resource extraction. However, traditional vehicles require large quantities of steel and aluminum, which are also resource-intensive to produce.\n- **Pollution and Emissions:** Both vehicle types have significant environmental impacts at the raw material extraction stage, but the specific impacts differ. EVs are associated with higher water use and potential pollution from lithium and cobalt mining, while traditional vehicles have higher emissions from steel and aluminum production.\n- **Sustainability Considerations:** The sustainability of EVs at this stage is heavily dependent on the sourcing and processing practices for battery materials. Improvements in recycling and more sustainable mining practices could reduce these impacts.\n\nIn conclusion, while both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles have substantial environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and processing stages, the nature and extent of these impacts vary. EVs face challenges related to the extraction of battery materials, while traditional vehicles are impacted by the energy-intensive production of metals like steel and aluminum. Addressing these challenges through improved technologies and practices is crucial for enhancing the sustainability of both vehicle types.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the environmental impacts from the production of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal for each type of vehicle. By comparing these stages, I can provide a comprehensive overview of which vehicle type has a lower overall environmental footprint.", + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) focused specifically on the raw material extraction and processing stages for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach will delve into the environmental impacts associated with mining and processing the materials needed for batteries and internal combustion engines, providing insight into which vehicle type is more sustainable at the very beginning of their life cycle." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the environmental impacts from the production of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal for each type of vehicle. By comparing these stages, I can provide a comprehensive overview of which vehicle type has a lower overall environmental footprint.", + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the emissions produced during vehicle operation. For this analysis, I would compare the tailpipe emissions of traditional gasoline vehicles with the emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs, taking into account the energy mix of different regions. This approach highlights the differences in air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during the vehicle usage phase.", + "I can answer by examining the resource extraction and material usage required for vehicle production. This approach would look into the environmental impact of mining and processing materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for electric vehicle batteries versus the extraction and refining of oil for gasoline and the materials used in internal combustion engines. This comparison can reveal the ecological consequences and sustainability concerns related to resource consumption.", + "I can answer by exploring policy and societal impacts, such as how the adoption of electric vehicles can influence energy infrastructure, urban planning, and climate change mitigation efforts. This approach would consider governmental incentives for EV adoption, the potential for reducing dependency on fossil fuels, and long-term environmental benefits that might arise from shifting towards a more electrified transport system." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the environmental impacts from the production of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal for each type of vehicle. By comparing these stages, I can provide a comprehensive overview of which vehicle type has a lower overall environmental footprint." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) focused specifically on the raw material extraction and processing stages for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach will delve into the environmental impacts associated with mining and processing the materials needed for batteries and internal combustion engines, providing insight into which vehicle type is more sustainable at the very beginning of their life cycle.", + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) that emphasizes the manufacturing and assembly process of EVs and traditional gasoline vehicles. By examining energy consumption, emissions, and waste production during the manufacturing phase, I can highlight the differences in environmental impacts that arise from the production facilities and assembly lines of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) that centers on the usage phase of EVs and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the emissions and energy efficiency during the operational life of the vehicles, considering factors like electricity sources for EVs and fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles, to determine which has a lower environmental impact while in use.", + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) with a focus on the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes for EVs and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach will assess the environmental impacts of decommissioning, recycling, and waste management for each vehicle type, revealing which one has more sustainable practices in place for minimizing environmental harm post-usage." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) focused specifically on the raw material extraction and processing stages for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach will delve into the environmental impacts associated with mining and processing the materials needed for batteries and internal combustion engines, providing insight into which vehicle type is more sustainable at the very beginning of their life cycle." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:58.019767", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 36 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "32902f78-c3b7-4c85-8179-a1d5d5dd0df0", + "ibfs_id": "49af31d3-ad06-4b28-9f94-ed75baa57a0a", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but battery production and disposal pose environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a lifecycle assessment (LCA) that examines each stage of a vehicle's life: production, usage, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. This comprehensive approach will help us understand the total environmental impact, including carbon emissions, pollution, and resource depletion.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction and Processing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Batteries:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve mining and processing of materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. These processes can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use aluminum and copper, which require energy-intensive extraction and processing.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuels:** The extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline production is energy-intensive and can lead to oil spills and habitat disruption.\n- **Materials:** Traditional vehicles primarily use steel and aluminum, which also involve energy-intensive extraction and processing, though typically less so than the materials for EV batteries.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Processes\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Use:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is generally more energy-intensive than that of gasoline vehicles. This is due to the complex processes involved in battery manufacturing.\n- **Emissions:** Manufacturing emissions for EVs are higher upfront due to the energy required for battery production.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Use:** Manufacturing processes for gasoline vehicles are less energy-intensive compared to EVs, primarily because they do not include battery production.\n- **Emissions:** While lower than EVs at the production stage, gasoline vehicles still contribute significant emissions from steel and aluminum production.\n\n### 3. Vehicle Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas. However, the overall emissions depend on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the emissions are minimal. If from coal or natural gas, emissions are higher.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Efficiency:** Internal combustion engines are less efficient than electric motors, losing more energy as heat.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries present challenges due to the complexity and toxicity of materials. However, advancements in recycling technologies are improving the recovery of valuable materials.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, the metal components of EVs can be recycled, reducing the need for new raw materials.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Traditional vehicles are generally easier to recycle, with established processes for recovering metals. However, they do not have the added complexity of battery disposal.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles have higher environmental impacts during the production phase, primarily due to battery manufacturing. However, they offer significant benefits during the usage phase by reducing emissions and improving energy efficiency, especially when powered by renewable energy. Gasoline vehicles, while having lower production impacts, contribute more to pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational life. End-of-life considerations are increasingly important for both vehicle types, with ongoing improvements in recycling technologies helping to mitigate some of the environmental impacts. Overall, the lifecycle assessment suggests that EVs have the potential for a lower total environmental impact, particularly as the energy grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies advance.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves evaluating the total environmental impact of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would look at the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle usage, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By examining each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental effects, including carbon emissions, pollution, and resource depletion associated with both vehicle types." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves evaluating the total environmental impact of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would look at the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle usage, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By examining each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental effects, including carbon emissions, pollution, and resource depletion associated with both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of the vehicles, comparing the emissions produced during the use of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles during operation and comparing them to the emissions from electricity generation used to power electric vehicles. Additionally, I would consider the impact of energy sources (renewable vs. fossil fuels) used in electricity production to evaluate how these factors influence the environmental footprint of electric vehicles during their operational life." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves evaluating the total environmental impact of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would look at the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle usage, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By examining each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental effects, including carbon emissions, pollution, and resource depletion associated with both vehicle types." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:03.854559", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 41 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "66f96578-fc10-44fe-9c37-dcad43186d3f", + "ibfs_id": "1279850a-238c-43f8-8c24-ffb5c92dab1a", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce greenhouse emissions over time but pose challenges in battery production and disposal compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we can examine specific environmental factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource consumption. This involves looking at both the operational emissions and the lifecycle impacts of each type of vehicle.\n\n### Greenhouse Gas Emissions\n\n**Operational Emissions:**\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions during operation. However, the electricity used to charge EVs can result in greenhouse gas emissions, depending on the energy mix of the grid. In regions where electricity is primarily generated from renewable sources (e.g., wind, solar, hydroelectric), the emissions associated with EVs are significantly lower. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, emissions can be higher.\n - On average, EVs tend to have lower lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, especially as grids become greener.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2) and other greenhouse gases directly from the tailpipe as a result of burning fossil fuels. These emissions are a significant contributor to global warming.\n - The average gasoline vehicle emits about 4.6 metric tons of CO2 per year, assuming a fuel economy of about 22 miles per gallon and annual travel of 11,500 miles.\n\n### Air Pollution\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - EVs do not emit nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter (PM), or volatile organic compounds (VOCs) during operation, which are common pollutants from gasoline vehicles.\n - However, the production of electricity can contribute to air pollution, depending on the energy sources used. Coal-fired power plants, for instance, emit significant amounts of NOx and sulfur dioxide (SO2).\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Gasoline vehicles contribute to air pollution through the emission of NOx, CO, VOCs, and PM. These pollutants can lead to smog formation, respiratory problems, and other health issues.\n - Advances in emission control technologies (e.g., catalytic converters) have reduced the emissions from gasoline vehicles, but they still contribute significantly to urban air pollution.\n\n### Resource Consumption\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - EVs require batteries, typically lithium-ion, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other materials. Mining these resources can have significant environmental and social impacts, including habitat destruction and pollution.\n - Battery production is energy-intensive, but recycling programs are being developed to mitigate these impacts and recover valuable materials.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - The production and refining of gasoline involve the extraction of crude oil, which can lead to environmental degradation, oil spills, and habitat destruction.\n - Gasoline production is also energy-intensive and contributes to greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n### Disposal and End-of-Life Considerations\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - The disposal of EV batteries poses environmental challenges due to the hazardous materials they contain. However, battery recycling technologies are advancing, and second-life applications for EV batteries are being explored to extend their usefulness.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - The disposal of gasoline vehicles involves recycling metals and other materials, which is relatively well-established. However, the environmental impact of oil extraction and refining remains a concern throughout the vehicle's lifecycle.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, electric vehicles generally have a lower environmental impact compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly as the electricity grid becomes cleaner. While EVs have challenges related to battery production and disposal, their operational benefits in terms of reduced greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution make them a more sustainable option in the long term. As technology and infrastructure improve, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to increase further.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by examining specific environmental factors, such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource consumption. This approach focuses on comparing the operational emissions of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles, including the emissions from electricity generation for EVs and tailpipe emissions for gasoline vehicles. Additionally, I will consider the sourcing and disposal of materials like batteries in EVs and fossil fuels in gasoline vehicles to provide a detailed comparison of their environmental footprints." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle assessment of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal. By comparing these stages, I can provide a comprehensive view of how each vehicle type affects the environment throughout its entire lifecycle.", + "I can answer by examining specific environmental factors, such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource consumption. This approach focuses on comparing the operational emissions of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles, including the emissions from electricity generation for EVs and tailpipe emissions for gasoline vehicles. Additionally, I will consider the sourcing and disposal of materials like batteries in EVs and fossil fuels in gasoline vehicles to provide a detailed comparison of their environmental footprints." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by examining specific environmental factors, such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource consumption. This approach focuses on comparing the operational emissions of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles, including the emissions from electricity generation for EVs and tailpipe emissions for gasoline vehicles. Additionally, I will consider the sourcing and disposal of materials like batteries in EVs and fossil fuels in gasoline vehicles to provide a detailed comparison of their environmental footprints." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:00.032934", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 40 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "412a622a-1b1f-444b-b260-183cc56dc319", + "ibfs_id": "bb5f54cb-e163-45f4-8de8-fc3212e03029", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions, lower carbon footprints, and use renewable energy, outpacing gasoline cars in environmental benefits overall.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, we need to examine the emissions produced during vehicle use and consider the source of electricity for EVs.\n\n1. **Emissions During Vehicle Use:**\n\n - **Traditional Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles burn gasoline to power an internal combustion engine, directly emitting carbon dioxide (CO2) and other pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO), and particulate matter (PM) into the atmosphere. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change. The amount of CO2 emitted is directly related to the fuel efficiency of the vehicle and the carbon content of the gasoline.\n\n - **Electric Vehicles:** EVs do not have tailpipe emissions because they are powered by an electric motor rather than an internal combustion engine. This means that during their operation, they do not emit CO2, NOx, CO, or PM directly. This is a significant advantage in reducing urban air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions from the transportation sector.\n\n2. **Source of Electricity for EVs:**\n\n - The environmental impact of EVs during their operational phase is significantly influenced by the source of electricity used to charge them. The carbon footprint of an EV can vary depending on the energy mix of the local electricity grid.\n\n - **Fossil Fuel-Dominated Grids:** In regions where electricity is primarily generated from coal, natural gas, or oil, the indirect emissions associated with charging EVs can be relatively high. Coal-fired power plants, in particular, are a major source of CO2 and other pollutants. In such cases, the environmental benefits of EVs over gasoline vehicles may be reduced, though they still offer advantages in terms of local air quality.\n\n - **Renewable Energy-Dominated Grids:** In areas where the electricity grid relies heavily on renewable energy sources such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the emissions associated with charging EVs are much lower. This results in a significantly smaller carbon footprint for EVs compared to gasoline vehicles. As the share of renewables in the energy mix increases, the environmental benefits of EVs become more pronounced.\n\nIn summary, while electric vehicles offer clear advantages over traditional gasoline vehicles in terms of direct emissions during operation, the overall environmental impact of EVs is closely tied to the source of electricity used for charging. Regions with cleaner, renewable-based electricity grids will see greater environmental benefits from the adoption of EVs, while areas reliant on fossil fuels for electricity generation may experience less pronounced benefits. Nonetheless, the transition to EVs is generally considered a positive step towards reducing transportation-related emissions and improving air quality.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by exploring the specific environmental impacts associated with the operational phase of electric vehicles versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the emissions produced during vehicle use, including carbon dioxide and other pollutants. I would also consider the source of electricity used to power electric vehicles, as this can vary greatly in its environmental impact depending on the energy grid's reliance on fossil fuels versus renewable sources. This approach would highlight how the environmental benefits of EVs can differ based on regional electricity generation methods." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the entire lifecycle of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, operational emissions, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. For electric vehicles, I would focus on the impact of battery production and disposal, as well as the sourcing of electricity, while for gasoline vehicles, I would look at emissions from fuel combustion and oil extraction. This comprehensive lifecycle approach would provide a holistic view of the environmental impacts associated with both types of vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring the specific environmental impacts associated with the operational phase of electric vehicles versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the emissions produced during vehicle use, including carbon dioxide and other pollutants. I would also consider the source of electricity used to power electric vehicles, as this can vary greatly in its environmental impact depending on the energy grid's reliance on fossil fuels versus renewable sources. This approach would highlight how the environmental benefits of EVs can differ based on regional electricity generation methods." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by exploring the specific environmental impacts associated with the operational phase of electric vehicles versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the emissions produced during vehicle use, including carbon dioxide and other pollutants. I would also consider the source of electricity used to power electric vehicles, as this can vary greatly in its environmental impact depending on the energy grid's reliance on fossil fuels versus renewable sources. This approach would highlight how the environmental benefits of EVs can differ based on regional electricity generation methods." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:13.145733", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 42 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "d0d64e74-0705-44e2-8b1a-ba5aa372ccc1", + "ibfs_id": "b78fb0ef-92f7-41e1-94f0-12ec084c31f3", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles emit fewer greenhouse gases over their lifecycle but have environmental costs in battery production and resource extraction.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will examine the environmental impacts at each stage of their life cycles: raw material extraction, manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life disposal. This analysis will focus on key factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Materials:** EVs require lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other rare earth metals for their batteries. The extraction and processing of these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy use.\n- **Impact:** The mining of these materials often results in higher initial environmental impacts compared to gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of resource depletion and localized ecological damage.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Materials:** Gasoline vehicles primarily use steel, aluminum, and plastics. The extraction of these materials is less intensive in terms of rare earth metals but still involves significant energy use and emissions.\n- **Impact:** The environmental impact is generally lower than that of EVs at this stage, particularly regarding resource depletion.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Process:** The production of EVs, especially the battery, is energy-intensive. The manufacturing process results in higher greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Impact:** The carbon footprint during manufacturing is higher for EVs, primarily due to battery production.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Process:** The manufacturing process is well-established and less energy-intensive than that of EVs.\n- **Impact:** Lower greenhouse gas emissions during manufacturing compared to EVs.\n\n### 3. Operation\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy Source:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions. However, the environmental impact during operation depends on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources result in significantly lower emissions, while coal-based electricity can diminish the benefits.\n- **Impact:** Generally, EVs have a lower operational carbon footprint, especially in regions with a clean energy grid.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Source:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe.\n- **Impact:** Higher greenhouse gas emissions and air pollutants during operation compared to EVs.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Recycling and Disposal:** The disposal and recycling of batteries are complex and can pose environmental challenges. However, advancements in battery recycling are improving the sustainability of EVs.\n- **Impact:** Potential environmental risks if batteries are not properly recycled, but increasing recycling efforts mitigate these impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling and Disposal:** Established recycling processes exist for gasoline vehicles, with many components being recyclable.\n- **Impact:** Generally lower environmental impact at the end-of-life stage compared to EVs, due to established recycling practices.\n\n### Overall Environmental Footprint\n\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** Over their entire life cycle, EVs tend to have a lower overall carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles, especially when charged with renewable energy.\n- **Energy Consumption:** EVs are more energy-efficient during operation, but their manufacturing process is more energy-intensive.\n- **Resource Depletion:** EVs have higher initial resource depletion due to battery materials but can offset this with lower operational impacts.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles have higher environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages, their lower operational emissions and potential for cleaner energy sources contribute to a reduced overall environmental footprint compared to traditional gasoline vehicles. The benefits of EVs are maximized when they are powered by renewable energy and when battery recycling processes are effectively implemented.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both vehicle types from cradle to grave, including the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life disposal. By analyzing factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their overall environmental footprints." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both vehicle types from cradle to grave, including the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life disposal. By analyzing factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their overall environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles and examining their emissions during usage. This approach would involve analyzing the direct emissions produced by gasoline vehicle engines and comparing them to the emissions associated with electricity generation for EV charging, which varies based on the energy mix of the grid. Additionally, I would consider how advancements in renewable energy sources could influence the environmental benefits of EVs over time. This method allows for a specific comparison of the vehicles' impacts during their operational lifetime." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both vehicle types from cradle to grave, including the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life disposal. By analyzing factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their overall environmental footprints." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:18.471038", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 43 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "2eb305d4-f89e-4dce-92a8-7f79600fe851", + "ibfs_id": "f6e4a216-8547-4216-aa89-da3eed7abe8a", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and environmental damage compared to gasoline cars, though mining for batteries poses ecological challenges.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a comprehensive life cycle analysis (LCA) that examines each stage of a vehicle's life: raw material extraction, manufacturing, use, and disposal. This analysis helps to understand the total emissions, resource usage, and ecological footprint associated with each type of vehicle.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use copper and rare earth elements for electric motors and electronics, which have their own environmental extraction impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can cause oil spills, habitat disruption, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Material Use:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and plastics, similar to EVs, but generally in smaller quantities for components like engines.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and often results in higher initial emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Emissions:** Manufacturing emissions for EVs can be higher due to the complexity of battery production.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Conventional Manufacturing:** Gasoline vehicles have a more established manufacturing process with lower initial emissions compared to EVs.\n- **Engine Production:** The production of internal combustion engines is less energy-intensive than battery production.\n\n### 3. Use Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, reducing air pollution and greenhouse gases during operation.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during the use phase depends heavily on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources (solar, wind) significantly reduce emissions, while coal-based electricity increases them.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Combustion Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Advances in fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, but they remain higher than those of EVs powered by clean energy.\n\n### 4. Disposal and Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal of EV batteries poses challenges due to hazardous materials. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable metals.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, EVs can be recycled for metals and other materials, though the battery remains a significant concern.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **End-of-Life Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically recycled for metals and parts, with established processes in place.\n- **Environmental Impact:** The disposal of engine oils and fluids can pose environmental risks if not managed properly.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, while electric vehicles have higher environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages due to battery production, they offer significant advantages during the use phase by eliminating tailpipe emissions. The overall environmental benefits of EVs are maximized when they are powered by renewable energy sources. Gasoline vehicles, on the other hand, have lower initial manufacturing emissions but contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational life. As battery recycling technologies improve and the energy grid becomes cleaner, the life cycle environmental impact of EVs is expected to decrease further, enhancing their sustainability compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive life cycle analysis of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing through to use and disposal. By comparing the total emissions, resource usage, and ecological footprint of each type of vehicle, I can provide a detailed picture of their respective environmental impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive life cycle analysis of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing through to use and disposal. By comparing the total emissions, resource usage, and ecological footprint of each type of vehicle, I can provide a detailed picture of their respective environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, examining emissions and energy consumption during their use. This approach would involve analyzing the differences in greenhouse gas emissions, energy efficiency, and pollution generated while the vehicles are in operation. Additionally, I can explore the impacts of electricity generation sources (renewable vs. fossil fuels) on the environmental benefits of operating EVs compared to gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive life cycle analysis of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing through to use and disposal. By comparing the total emissions, resource usage, and ecological footprint of each type of vehicle, I can provide a detailed picture of their respective environmental impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:18.853802", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 44 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "60e03179-6184-4fc4-af91-3ce2d4b647e7", + "ibfs_id": "39213203-221f-406a-9389-5760f3406587", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce fewer emissions, reduce fossil fuel reliance, but involve significant battery production impacts, compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will analyze the environmental impacts of each type of vehicle throughout their entire life cycle. This includes stages such as raw material extraction, manufacturing, use, and end-of-life disposal. The LCA will help us understand the differences in emissions, resource consumption, and overall environmental footprint of both vehicle types.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Materials:** EVs require lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other rare earth metals for their batteries. The extraction of these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Materials:** EVs also use aluminum, steel, and plastics, similar to gasoline vehicles, but the battery materials are a significant additional factor.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fossil Fuels:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline production involves drilling and refining processes that can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and significant greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Materials:** Like EVs, gasoline vehicles use steel, aluminum, and plastics, but they do not require the same rare metals as EVs.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive. This results in higher emissions during the manufacturing phase compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Emissions:** The emissions from manufacturing an EV can be higher due to the energy required to produce the battery, but this can vary depending on the energy mix of the manufacturing location.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Standard Manufacturing:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is less energy-intensive compared to EVs, primarily because they do not require large batteries.\n- **Emissions:** Emissions are generally lower during the manufacturing phase compared to EVs, but this advantage is often offset during the use phase.\n\n### 3. Use Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during the use phase depends on the electricity source. If the electricity comes from renewable sources, the emissions are minimal. However, if it comes from coal or other fossil fuels, the emissions can be higher.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Improvements in fuel efficiency have reduced emissions, but they are still higher than those of EVs, especially in terms of CO2 emissions per mile.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries are critical. Proper recycling can mitigate some environmental impacts, but current recycling rates and technologies are still developing.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, the metal and plastic components can be recycled, reducing the environmental impact.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** The recycling processes for gasoline vehicles are well-established, and most materials can be effectively recycled.\n- **Waste:** There is no battery disposal issue, but the emissions during the vehicle's life are a significant environmental concern.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases due to the production of batteries. However, they offer significant environmental benefits during the use phase, especially if powered by renewable energy, due to zero tailpipe emissions and higher energy efficiency. Gasoline vehicles have lower impacts during manufacturing but contribute significantly to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their use phase. The end-of-life disposal of both vehicle types involves recycling, but EVs face additional challenges with battery disposal. Overall, the life cycle assessment indicates that EVs can have a lower overall environmental impact, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the environmental impacts of each type of vehicle throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to end-of-life disposal. This method helps highlight the differences in emissions, resource consumption, and overall environmental footprint of both vehicle types." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the environmental impacts of each type of vehicle throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to end-of-life disposal. This method helps highlight the differences in emissions, resource consumption, and overall environmental footprint of both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by evaluating the direct emissions and energy efficiency during the usage phase of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This strategy focuses on comparing the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles with the zero emissions at the point of use for electric vehicles, while also considering the emissions related to electricity generation for EVs. By examining fuel efficiency and the sources of electricity, I can provide insights into how each vehicle type contributes to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the environmental impacts of each type of vehicle throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to end-of-life disposal. This method helps highlight the differences in emissions, resource consumption, and overall environmental footprint of both vehicle types." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:21.614755", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 45 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "a5180bea-2397-4748-b2ce-44665f4db8bb", + "ibfs_id": "4c34ca44-58c0-44c1-90d7-e4d3b6e780ef", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and improve air quality but require resource-intensive battery production and raises recycling challenges.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles during their usage phase, we focus on fuel consumption, energy efficiency, and the resulting greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution.\n\n1. **Energy Efficiency**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. They convert over 77% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels. This high efficiency is due to the electric motor's ability to convert electrical energy into motion with minimal energy loss.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: In contrast, gasoline vehicles convert only about 12%\u201330% of the energy stored in gasoline to power at the wheels. The internal combustion engine (ICE) loses a significant amount of energy as heat.\n\n2. **Greenhouse Gas Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: During the usage phase, EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions. However, the overall greenhouse gas emissions depend on the electricity source. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources (such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power), the emissions are significantly lower. Conversely, if the electricity comes from fossil fuels (coal or natural gas), the emissions are higher, though still generally lower than those from gasoline vehicles.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), a major greenhouse gas, directly from the tailpipe as a result of burning gasoline. The emissions are consistent regardless of the fuel source, as they are inherent to the combustion process.\n\n3. **Air Pollution**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs do not emit pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) or particulate matter (PM) during operation. This leads to improved air quality, especially in urban areas. The only indirect emissions come from electricity generation, which can be mitigated by cleaner energy sources.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles emit significant amounts of NOx, hydrocarbons, and PM, contributing to air pollution and health issues like respiratory problems and smog formation. Catalytic converters reduce some of these emissions, but they do not eliminate them entirely.\n\nIn summary, during the usage phase, electric vehicles offer substantial environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles in terms of energy efficiency and reduced greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, particularly when powered by clean electricity sources. The transition to EVs can significantly improve air quality and reduce the carbon footprint of personal transportation, especially as the grid becomes greener.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from raw material extraction, through production, usage, and finally to disposal or recycling. This comprehensive approach considers all stages of the vehicle's life and can highlight differences in environmental impact, such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource usage.", + "I can answer by emphasizing the usage phase in the life cycle assessment, analyzing how differences in fuel consumption and energy efficiency impact the environment. This strategy would particularly assess greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution during the operational life of both electric and gasoline vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from raw material extraction, through production, usage, and finally to disposal or recycling. This comprehensive approach considers all stages of the vehicle's life and can highlight differences in environmental impact, such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource usage.", + "I can answer by focusing on the energy source and emissions during the usage phase. This involves comparing the emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during combustion with the emissions associated with electricity generation for electric vehicles. This approach takes into account the energy mix of the electricity grid, which can greatly influence the environmental impact of electric vehicles depending on whether it relies on renewable sources or fossil fuels.", + "I can answer by examining the supply chain and material sourcing for both types of vehicles. This approach would look at the environmental impact related to extracting and processing materials like lithium, cobalt, and copper for electric vehicles compared to the extraction and refinement of oil for gasoline vehicles. It would highlight the ecological and social considerations tied to material sourcing and the implications these have on the overall environmental impact.", + "I can answer by considering the end-of-life processing and recycling of both vehicle types. This strategy would explore how batteries in electric vehicles are recycled or disposed of compared to the scrapping and recycling processes for gasoline vehicles. It would assess the environmental impact of waste generation and resource recovery, considering how advancements in recycling technology could mitigate some of these impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from raw material extraction, through production, usage, and finally to disposal or recycling. This comprehensive approach considers all stages of the vehicle's life and can highlight differences in environmental impact, such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource usage." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a cradle-to-gate life cycle assessment, which examines the environmental impacts from raw material extraction to the point where the vehicles leave the factory. This approach highlights differences in manufacturing processes and supply chain emissions for electric and gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by emphasizing the usage phase in the life cycle assessment, analyzing how differences in fuel consumption and energy efficiency impact the environment. This strategy would particularly assess greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution during the operational life of both electric and gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by conducting a cradle-to-grave life cycle assessment with a particular focus on end-of-life processes, comparing how recycling, waste management, and disposal affect the environmental footprint of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This approach could spotlight the benefits and challenges of battery recycling and the disposal of engine components.", + "I can answer by performing a geographic-specific life cycle assessment that considers regional variations in electricity generation and fuel production. This strategy would assess how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles differ depending on the local energy grid's reliance on renewable versus fossil fuels, as well as regional manufacturing practices." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by emphasizing the usage phase in the life cycle assessment, analyzing how differences in fuel consumption and energy efficiency impact the environment. This strategy would particularly assess greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution during the operational life of both electric and gasoline vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:16.599251", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 39 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c69c57d8-bbc4-42ea-b792-779ef04f2375", + "ibfs_id": "658f6166-b765-4cd0-a6ee-73f8db81b2ac", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions during operation but involve significant environmental impact during battery production and resource extraction.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we will conduct a life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines each stage of the vehicles' life cycles: raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal or recycling.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use materials like aluminum and copper, which have their own environmental extraction impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** Gasoline vehicles rely on crude oil extraction, which can result in oil spills, habitat disruption, and significant greenhouse gas emissions during extraction and refining.\n- **Material Use:** Traditional vehicles primarily use steel and aluminum, which also require energy-intensive extraction processes.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Higher Initial Emissions:** Manufacturing EVs, particularly the battery, generally results in higher initial emissions compared to gasoline vehicles due to the energy-intensive processes involved in battery production.\n- **Renewable Energy Potential:** The environmental impact can be mitigated if renewable energy sources are used in the manufacturing process.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Lower Initial Emissions:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles typically results in lower initial emissions compared to EVs, as they do not require large batteries.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces local air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation.\n- **Electricity Source Matters:** The environmental impact during the usage phase depends on the electricity source. If the grid relies on coal, the emissions can be higher; however, renewable energy sources drastically reduce the carbon footprint.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **High Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants directly into the atmosphere, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency Variability:** The environmental impact varies with fuel efficiency, with more efficient vehicles having a lower impact.\n\n### 4. Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling Challenges:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose significant challenges. While recycling technologies are improving, improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination.\n- **Potential for Reuse:** Batteries can be repurposed for secondary applications, such as energy storage, extending their life cycle.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Established Recycling Processes:** Traditional vehicles have well-established recycling processes for metals like steel and aluminum, reducing their end-of-life environmental impact.\n- **Oil Disposal:** Used oil and other fluids require careful disposal to prevent environmental contamination.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases, primarily due to battery production. However, they offer significant environmental benefits during the usage phase due to zero tailpipe emissions, especially when powered by renewable energy. Gasoline vehicles have lower initial manufacturing emissions but contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational life. The disposal phase presents challenges for both vehicle types, with EVs focusing on battery recycling and gasoline vehicles on fluid disposal. Overall, the life cycle assessment indicates that EVs have the potential for a lower overall environmental footprint, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies advance.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of both types of vehicles throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage to disposal or recycling. By examining factors such as emissions during manufacturing, energy consumption, and waste generation, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of both types of vehicles throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage to disposal or recycling. By examining factors such as emissions during manufacturing, energy consumption, and waste generation, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles to compare their environmental impacts. This approach will involve analyzing factors such as tailpipe emissions, fuel/energy efficiency, and the sources of electricity used for EVs. I will explore how these factors contribute to air pollution, greenhouse gas emissions, and overall energy consumption during the vehicle's usage phase, providing a clear picture of their impacts while they are in operation." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of both types of vehicles throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage to disposal or recycling. By examining factors such as emissions during manufacturing, energy consumption, and waste generation, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:24.244473", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 46 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "3207a6ed-7190-4249-8024-b1d006f1f69d", + "ibfs_id": "e7d1cd17-380b-4ac0-ba0c-03c74ca5d627", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce fewer emissions, reduce dependence on fossil fuels, but battery production and disposal have environmental challenges.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will examine the environmental impacts at each stage of their life cycles: raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. This analysis will focus on energy consumption, emissions, and resource use.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, EVs require steel, aluminum, and plastics, but the battery production is the most resource-intensive part.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and significant energy use.\n- **Vehicle Components:** The materials used in gasoline vehicles (steel, aluminum, plastics) also require energy-intensive extraction processes.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Use:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive. However, advancements in battery technology and manufacturing efficiency are reducing this impact.\n- **Emissions:** Manufacturing EVs generally results in higher initial emissions compared to gasoline vehicles due to the battery production.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Use:** Manufacturing processes are well-established and less energy-intensive compared to EVs, primarily because they do not require large batteries.\n- **Emissions:** The emissions from manufacturing gasoline vehicles are generally lower initially, but this advantage decreases over the vehicle's lifetime.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Consumption:** EVs are more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. They convert a higher percentage of electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n- **Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions. However, the overall emissions depend on the electricity mix used for charging. Renewable energy sources significantly reduce the carbon footprint.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Consumption:** Gasoline engines are less efficient, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n- **Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, and particulate matter during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries are critical. Current technologies allow for the recycling of lithium, cobalt, and nickel, but the processes are still developing.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, the metal components can be recycled, reducing the need for new raw materials.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel System Disposal:** Components related to the fuel system can pose environmental hazards if not properly disposed of.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Established recycling processes exist for metals, but the environmental impact of disposing of used oil and other fluids remains a concern.\n\n### Overall Environmental Footprint\n\n- **Electric Vehicles:** While EVs have higher environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages, they offer significant benefits during the usage phase, especially when powered by renewable energy. Over their lifetime, they generally have a lower carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles.\n \n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles have lower initial manufacturing impacts but contribute more significantly to environmental degradation during the usage phase due to emissions and lower energy efficiency.\n\nIn conclusion, the life cycle assessment shows that electric vehicles have the potential to be more environmentally friendly than traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies improve. However, addressing the environmental impacts of battery production and disposal remains crucial for maximizing the benefits of EVs.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of each vehicle type throughout their entire life cycle\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. By examining factors such as energy consumption, emissions, and resource use at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive understanding of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of each vehicle type throughout their entire life cycle\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. By examining factors such as energy consumption, emissions, and resource use at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive understanding of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impacts related to the energy sources used by each vehicle type. This approach involves analyzing the emissions and environmental effects associated with the electricity generation that powers EVs, which can vary widely depending on the energy mix (e.g., coal, natural gas, renewables). For gasoline vehicles, I would assess the impacts of extracting, refining, and burning fossil fuels. By doing so, I can evaluate how the environmental effects of the energy supply chain differ between EVs and gasoline vehicles under different scenarios and energy policies." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of each vehicle type throughout their entire life cycle\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. By examining factors such as energy consumption, emissions, and resource use at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive understanding of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:24.136259", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 47 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "1dd1c919-e76c-4310-a244-640de09ab375", + "ibfs_id": "9e5b551e-a546-46ea-b1b1-179271448acf", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, offering sustainable alternatives, while battery production poses environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a lifecycle assessment (LCA) that examines each stage of the vehicles' lifecycles: raw material extraction, manufacturing, use, and disposal or recycling. This approach allows us to evaluate the energy consumption, emissions, and resource use associated with each vehicle type.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to habitat destruction, soil and water pollution, and significant energy use.\n- **Other Components:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, EVs require steel, aluminum, and plastics, but the battery materials add additional environmental burdens.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can result in habitat disruption, oil spills, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Vehicle Materials:** Like EVs, gasoline vehicles also require steel, aluminum, and plastics, but they do not require the same battery materials as EVs.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy-Intensive Battery Manufacturing:** The production of EV batteries is energy-intensive, contributing to higher emissions during the manufacturing stage compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Overall Manufacturing:** The assembly of EVs is similar to gasoline vehicles, but the additional complexity and weight of the battery can increase energy use.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Standard Manufacturing:** The manufacturing process is well-established, with emissions primarily from steel and aluminum production and vehicle assembly.\n\n### 3. Use Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, reducing air pollution in urban areas.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during the use phase depends on the electricity mix. If the grid is powered by renewable energy, the emissions are significantly lower than those of gasoline vehicles. However, if coal or other fossil fuels dominate, the emissions can be higher.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid into vehicle movement.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** The efficiency varies by model, but gasoline engines typically convert less energy into movement compared to electric motors.\n\n### 4. Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries pose challenges due to the hazardous materials involved. However, advancements in battery recycling technologies are improving the recovery of valuable materials.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, the metal components can be recycled, reducing the need for new raw materials.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Standard Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle, with established processes for recovering metals and other materials.\n- **End-of-Life Emissions:** The disposal of gasoline vehicles involves fewer hazardous materials compared to EV batteries.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles offer significant environmental benefits during the use phase, particularly in regions with clean electricity grids, due to their zero tailpipe emissions and higher energy efficiency. However, they have higher environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages, primarily due to battery production. Gasoline vehicles have more established recycling processes and lower initial manufacturing emissions but contribute significantly to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their use phase. The overall environmental impact of each vehicle type depends heavily on factors such as the electricity mix for EVs and the fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing every stage of both types of vehicles' lifecycles, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling. By examining the energy consumption, emissions, and resource use at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts associated with each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing every stage of both types of vehicles' lifecycles, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling. By examining the energy consumption, emissions, and resource use at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts associated with each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy use during the operational phase of vehicles. This approach specifically compares the direct environmental impacts while the vehicles are in use, such as tailpipe emissions for gasoline vehicles and the source of electricity for EVs. I would also consider the carbon intensity of electricity grids in different regions to assess how the environmental benefits of EVs can vary geographically. This strategy provides insight into the immediate and visible environmental impacts associated with driving each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing every stage of both types of vehicles' lifecycles, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling. By examining the energy consumption, emissions, and resource use at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts associated with each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:30.768242", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 48 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "276fb0e7-649d-4a62-83c5-fdb78c3ffdb0", + "ibfs_id": "2f6e051b-0e8f-47ea-ac62-c1975b559356", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce air pollution and emissions, but their battery production and disposal pose environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a lifecycle analysis that considers each stage of the vehicle's life: production, operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling.\n\n### 1. Extraction and Processing of Raw Materials\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other materials. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also require copper for wiring and rare earth elements for electric motors, which involve energy-intensive extraction processes.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction and refining of crude oil into gasoline is energy-intensive and can result in oil spills, habitat destruction, and water contamination.\n- **Vehicle Components:** Traditional vehicles require steel, aluminum, and other materials, which also involve energy-intensive extraction and processing.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Processes\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- The manufacturing of EVs, particularly the battery, is more energy-intensive compared to gasoline vehicles. This is due to the complex processes involved in battery cell production and assembly.\n- However, EVs generally have fewer moving parts, which can reduce the complexity and energy requirements of other manufacturing processes.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Manufacturing processes for gasoline vehicles are well-established but still energy-intensive, particularly for engine and transmission components.\n- The production of emissions control systems (like catalytic converters) also involves the use of precious metals.\n\n### 3. Operation and Maintenance\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Operation:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas. However, the environmental impact depends on the electricity source; coal-based electricity increases emissions, while renewable energy reduces them.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n- **Maintenance:** EVs require less maintenance due to fewer moving parts and no need for oil changes.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Operation:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Efficiency:** Internal combustion engines are less efficient, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n- **Maintenance:** Regular maintenance is required, including oil changes, exhaust system repairs, and engine tune-ups.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The recycling of lithium-ion batteries is complex and not yet widespread, but it is crucial to prevent environmental contamination and recover valuable materials.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Other components of EVs can be recycled similarly to traditional vehicles, but the process can be more complex due to the presence of electronic components.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** The recycling process for gasoline vehicles is well-established, with many parts being recoverable, such as metals and plastics.\n- **Environmental Impact:** Disposal of fluids and emissions control components can pose environmental risks if not handled properly.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles have a different environmental impact profile compared to gasoline vehicles. While the production of EVs, particularly their batteries, is more resource and energy-intensive, their operation results in significantly lower emissions, especially when powered by renewable energy. Gasoline vehicles have a more established recycling process but contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational phase. The overall environmental benefit of EVs improves as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies advance.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include examining the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, operation and maintenance, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By assessing each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include examining the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, operation and maintenance, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By assessing each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of vehicles and comparing the emissions associated with using electric versus gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the greenhouse gas emissions and air pollutants produced during the operation of each vehicle type. For electric vehicles, I would take into account the source of electricity generation (e.g., coal, natural gas, renewables) and for gasoline vehicles, I would consider the direct emissions from fuel combustion. This approach emphasizes the impacts associated with the use phase rather than the entire lifecycle." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include examining the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, operation and maintenance, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By assessing each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:38.212793", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 49 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "5613c61b-696e-4399-9a92-5ebd98280d9f", + "ibfs_id": "8cf951fd-c8ff-4c00-b6d0-a3209a1bc4ec", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions over their lifecycle, but battery production impacts, and resource extraction pose environmental challenges.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles during their operational lifetime, we need to focus on emissions and energy efficiency during the use phase.\n\n### Emissions from Gasoline Vehicles\n\nGasoline vehicles emit greenhouse gases (GHGs) and other pollutants directly from their tailpipes during operation. The primary emissions include:\n\n1. **Carbon Dioxide (CO2):** Gasoline combustion in internal combustion engines produces CO2, a major contributor to climate change.\n2. **Nitrogen Oxides (NOx):** These contribute to smog and acid rain and can cause respiratory problems.\n3. **Particulate Matter (PM):** Tiny particles that can penetrate the lungs and cause health issues.\n4. **Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs):** Contribute to ozone formation and smog.\n\nThe emissions from gasoline vehicles are directly proportional to fuel consumption, which is influenced by the vehicle's fuel efficiency.\n\n### Emissions from Electric Vehicles\n\nElectric vehicles do not produce tailpipe emissions during operation. However, the environmental impact during the use phase depends on the source of electricity used to charge them:\n\n1. **Renewable Energy Sources:** If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the emissions associated with EV operation are minimal. This scenario represents the best-case environmental outcome for EVs.\n \n2. **Fossil Fuel-Based Electricity:** If the electricity is generated from coal, natural gas, or oil, there are upstream emissions associated with power generation. The impact varies based on the energy mix of the grid:\n - **Coal:** High CO2 emissions per unit of electricity generated.\n - **Natural Gas:** Lower CO2 emissions compared to coal but still significant.\n - **Oil:** Similar to natural gas but less common for electricity generation.\n\n### Energy Efficiency\n\nElectric vehicles are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. This efficiency is measured by how much of the energy from the fuel (or electricity) is converted into actual vehicle movement:\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:** EVs typically convert over 60% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels. This high efficiency contributes to lower overall emissions, especially when powered by cleaner energy sources.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:** Internal combustion engines convert only about 20-30% of the energy stored in gasoline into power at the wheels, with the rest lost as heat and through other inefficiencies.\n\n### Long-Term Environmental Consequences\n\n- **Climate Impact:** EVs have the potential to significantly reduce GHG emissions during their use phase, especially as the electricity grid becomes cleaner with more renewable energy sources.\n- **Air Quality:** The absence of tailpipe emissions from EVs improves urban air quality by reducing pollutants like NOx and PM.\n- **Energy Transition:** As the energy grid transitions towards more renewable sources, the environmental benefits of EVs will continue to increase, making them a more sustainable choice in the long term.\n\nIn summary, during the operational lifetime, electric vehicles offer significant environmental advantages over gasoline vehicles, primarily due to their higher energy efficiency and the potential for low emissions when powered by renewable energy sources. However, the overall impact depends on the electricity generation mix used for charging. As the grid becomes greener, the benefits of EVs will become even more pronounced.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison. This approach involves analyzing the entire lifecycle of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to vehicle use and end-of-life disposal. By examining each stage, I can provide a comprehensive view of their respective environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion.", + "I can answer by concentrating on the vehicle use phase, examining the environmental impacts during the operational lifetime of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve assessing the emissions associated with driving, including the source of electricity for EVs (whether renewable or fossil fuel-based) and the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles. By focusing on the energy efficiency and emissions output during the use phase, I can shed light on the long-term environmental consequences of choosing one vehicle type over the other." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison. This approach involves analyzing the entire lifecycle of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to vehicle use and end-of-life disposal. By examining each stage, I can provide a comprehensive view of their respective environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion.", + "I can answer by focusing on the regional energy grid analysis. This involves assessing how the environmental impact of electric vehicles varies depending on the energy mix of the electricity grid in different regions. For example, the impact in regions relying heavily on coal might differ vastly from those using renewable energy sources. I would compare this with the emissions and environmental impact of gasoline vehicles, which remain relatively consistent regardless of location, to highlight the differences." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison. This approach involves analyzing the entire lifecycle of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to vehicle use and end-of-life disposal. By examining each stage, I can provide a comprehensive view of their respective environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a detailed comparison of the manufacturing processes of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve analyzing the environmental impacts associated with the production phase, such as the energy use and emissions resulting from the mining of raw materials like lithium for batteries versus the extraction of crude oil for gasoline vehicles. By highlighting the distinct environmental footprints of manufacturing each type of vehicle, I can provide insights into the initial phase of their lifecycle assessment.", + "I can answer by concentrating on the vehicle use phase, examining the environmental impacts during the operational lifetime of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve assessing the emissions associated with driving, including the source of electricity for EVs (whether renewable or fossil fuel-based) and the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles. By focusing on the energy efficiency and emissions output during the use phase, I can shed light on the long-term environmental consequences of choosing one vehicle type over the other." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by concentrating on the vehicle use phase, examining the environmental impacts during the operational lifetime of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve assessing the emissions associated with driving, including the source of electricity for EVs (whether renewable or fossil fuel-based) and the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles. By focusing on the energy efficiency and emissions output during the use phase, I can shed light on the long-term environmental consequences of choosing one vehicle type over the other." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:46.371891", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 51 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "08c7388e-9ab1-4ee5-a237-fe58f66ea3b9", + "ibfs_id": "8f12e43e-1ca6-46c3-bb57-873d51ce9208", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles offer reduced emissions and lower lifetime environmental impact, though battery production and disposal pose environmental challenges.", + "final_answer": "To understand the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through a regional lifecycle analysis, we must consider several key factors that vary by location: the composition of the electricity grid, regional manufacturing practices, and waste management infrastructure. These factors significantly influence the emissions, resource use, and sustainability of each vehicle type.\n\n### 1. Electricity Grid Composition\n\nThe environmental impact of EVs is heavily influenced by the source of electricity used for charging. Regions with cleaner energy sources, such as hydroelectric, wind, or solar power, will have lower associated emissions for EVs compared to regions reliant on coal or natural gas.\n\n- **Norway**: In Norway, where the electricity grid is predominantly powered by hydropower, EVs have a significantly lower carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. The lifecycle emissions from EVs in this region are much lower due to the clean energy used for charging.\n\n- **China**: In contrast, China\u2019s electricity grid is still heavily reliant on coal. As a result, the lifecycle emissions of EVs in China are higher than in Norway, though still generally lower than gasoline vehicles. However, the benefits of EVs in terms of emissions are less pronounced here compared to regions with cleaner grids.\n\n### 2. Regional Manufacturing Practices\n\nThe environmental impact of vehicle manufacturing also varies by region, influenced by local industrial practices and energy sources.\n\n- **Germany**: In Germany, where there is a strong emphasis on sustainable manufacturing and the use of renewable energy in industrial processes, the production of EVs tends to have a lower environmental impact compared to regions with less efficient manufacturing practices.\n\n- **United States**: In the U.S., the impact can vary significantly by state. States with more stringent environmental regulations and cleaner energy sources for manufacturing, like California, will have a lower impact compared to states with less focus on sustainable practices.\n\n### 3. Waste Management Infrastructure\n\nThe end-of-life phase of vehicles, including recycling and disposal, also contributes to their environmental impact. Effective recycling programs can mitigate the environmental footprint of both EVs and gasoline vehicles.\n\n- **European Union**: The EU has robust recycling regulations, which help reduce the environmental impact of EV batteries by recovering valuable materials and ensuring safe disposal. This makes EVs more sustainable in the EU compared to regions with less developed recycling infrastructure.\n\n- **India**: In India, where waste management infrastructure is less developed, the disposal of EV batteries poses significant environmental challenges. The lack of efficient recycling processes can lead to increased environmental harm from battery waste.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe regional lifecycle analysis reveals that the environmental benefits of electric vehicles over gasoline vehicles are highly dependent on geographic factors. In regions with clean energy grids, sustainable manufacturing practices, and efficient waste management systems, EVs offer substantial environmental advantages. However, in regions with coal-dependent grids, less efficient manufacturing, and inadequate recycling infrastructure, the benefits of EVs are reduced, though they often still outperform gasoline vehicles in terms of emissions. This analysis underscores the importance of regional context in assessing the environmental impacts of vehicle technologies.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which involves examining the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from raw material extraction through manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. This approach will cover factors such as resource consumption, emissions during production, energy efficiency, and recycling potential, providing a comprehensive overview of their environmental footprints throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by performing a regional lifecycle analysis to understand the geographic variations in environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This approach examines how factors such as local electricity grid composition, regional manufacturing practices, and waste management infrastructure influence the environmental footprint of each vehicle type. By focusing on specific regions, I can highlight variations in emissions, resource use, and overall sustainability due to differing regional conditions." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which involves examining the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from raw material extraction through manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. This approach will cover factors such as resource consumption, emissions during production, energy efficiency, and recycling potential, providing a comprehensive overview of their environmental footprints throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase, specifically analyzing the emissions and energy consumption during the use of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach will highlight the differences in greenhouse gas emissions, air pollutants, and energy efficiency when the vehicles are driven, considering factors like electricity generation sources for EVs and fuel efficiency for gasoline vehicles. This will offer insights into the day-to-day environmental impacts of using each type of vehicle." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which involves examining the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from raw material extraction through manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. This approach will cover factors such as resource consumption, emissions during production, energy efficiency, and recycling potential, providing a comprehensive overview of their environmental footprints throughout their entire lifecycles." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a cradle-to-cradle lifecycle assessment that specifically focuses on the circularity of materials used in electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the potential for reusing and recycling materials at the end of each vehicle's life, assessing how the design of each vehicle type supports a circular economy, and comparing the environmental benefits of material recovery processes for both types of vehicles.", + "I can answer by performing a regional lifecycle analysis to understand the geographic variations in environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This approach examines how factors such as local electricity grid composition, regional manufacturing practices, and waste management infrastructure influence the environmental footprint of each vehicle type. By focusing on specific regions, I can highlight variations in emissions, resource use, and overall sustainability due to differing regional conditions." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by performing a regional lifecycle analysis to understand the geographic variations in environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This approach examines how factors such as local electricity grid composition, regional manufacturing practices, and waste management infrastructure influence the environmental footprint of each vehicle type. By focusing on specific regions, I can highlight variations in emissions, resource use, and overall sustainability due to differing regional conditions." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:49.425727", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 54 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "dacb02e6-bd8c-4d2f-9638-2c9c2bc4b35c", + "ibfs_id": "8a7af59c-63c5-4a51-b5d3-5d0e1ae1a36c", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but their battery production and disposal have environmental impacts compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles during the manufacturing phase, we can conduct a life cycle assessment (LCA) that focuses on energy consumption, raw material sourcing, and emissions associated with the production of each vehicle type.\n\n### Energy Consumption\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Battery Production:** The most energy-intensive component in EV manufacturing is the production of lithium-ion batteries. This process involves mining, refining, and processing raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. The energy required for these processes is significant, often relying on electricity that may be generated from fossil fuels, depending on the region.\n - **Vehicle Assembly:** The assembly of EVs is similar to that of traditional vehicles, but the integration of the battery system requires additional energy, particularly in the form of precision engineering and safety testing.\n\n2. **Traditional Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Engine Production:** The manufacturing of internal combustion engines (ICEs) involves casting, machining, and assembling numerous metal components. This process is energy-intensive due to the high temperatures required for metalworking and the complexity of engine design.\n - **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to EVs, the assembly process for gasoline vehicles involves significant energy use, though it does not require the additional steps associated with battery integration.\n\n### Raw Material Sourcing\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Battery Materials:** The sourcing of lithium, cobalt, and nickel is critical for EV batteries. Mining these materials can have substantial environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high carbon emissions. Cobalt mining, in particular, has raised ethical concerns due to labor practices in certain regions.\n - **Lightweight Materials:** EVs often use lightweight materials such as aluminum and advanced composites to offset the weight of the battery, which requires additional energy for extraction and processing.\n\n2. **Traditional Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Metals for Engine and Body:** The production of gasoline vehicles primarily involves steel and aluminum for the engine and body. The extraction and processing of these metals also have environmental impacts, though the processes are well-established and have seen efficiency improvements over time.\n - **Plastics and Other Materials:** Gasoline vehicles use a variety of materials, including plastics derived from petroleum, which have their own environmental footprint in terms of extraction and processing.\n\n### Emissions\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Battery Manufacturing Emissions:** The production of EV batteries is associated with higher greenhouse gas emissions compared to the manufacturing of ICEs. This is due to the energy-intensive processes involved in mining and refining battery materials.\n - **Overall Manufacturing Emissions:** While the initial emissions from manufacturing are higher for EVs, these are often offset over the vehicle's lifetime due to lower operational emissions.\n\n2. **Traditional Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Engine Manufacturing Emissions:** The production of ICEs involves emissions from metal processing and assembly. However, these emissions are generally lower than those associated with EV battery production.\n - **Overall Manufacturing Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles typically have lower manufacturing emissions compared to EVs, but this advantage diminishes when considering the entire life cycle, including fuel combustion during operation.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, the manufacturing phase of electric vehicles is characterized by higher energy consumption and emissions primarily due to battery production. The sourcing of raw materials for EV batteries also presents significant environmental challenges. In contrast, traditional gasoline vehicles have a more established manufacturing process with lower initial emissions, but they incur higher emissions during their operational phase. Understanding these differences is crucial for assessing the overall environmental impact of each vehicle type.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of both vehicle types throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. This method will provide a comprehensive view of the overall environmental footprint, including factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution.", + "I can answer by focusing the life cycle assessment (LCA) specifically on the manufacturing phase of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve a detailed analysis of the energy consumption, raw material sourcing, and emissions associated with the production of each vehicle type. By honing in on the manufacturing process, we can uncover specific environmental impacts related to the production of batteries for EVs compared to internal combustion engines for gasoline vehicles, providing insights into the most resource-intensive and environmentally impactful aspects of vehicle production." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of both vehicle types throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. This method will provide a comprehensive view of the overall environmental footprint, including factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution.", + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the differences in emissions during the usage phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during combustion and comparing them to the emissions generated by power plants that supply electricity for EVs, considering the energy mix of the grid. Additionally, this strategy would include an analysis of the impact of energy source variability on emissions, such as renewable energy versus fossil fuels, and how this affects the environmental benefits of electric vehicles over their operational life." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of both vehicle types throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. This method will provide a comprehensive view of the overall environmental footprint, including factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing the life cycle assessment (LCA) specifically on the manufacturing phase of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve a detailed analysis of the energy consumption, raw material sourcing, and emissions associated with the production of each vehicle type. By honing in on the manufacturing process, we can uncover specific environmental impacts related to the production of batteries for EVs compared to internal combustion engines for gasoline vehicles, providing insights into the most resource-intensive and environmentally impactful aspects of vehicle production.", + "I can answer by emphasizing the usage phase within the life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve a comparative analysis of the emissions and environmental impacts during the operational life of each vehicle type, taking into account factors such as fuel or electricity consumption, maintenance requirements, and regional variations in energy sources. By concentrating on the usage phase, we can evaluate the real-world environmental performance of each vehicle type over its operational life, which can vary significantly based on geographical location, driving habits, and the mix of energy sources used to generate electricity for EVs." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing the life cycle assessment (LCA) specifically on the manufacturing phase of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve a detailed analysis of the energy consumption, raw material sourcing, and emissions associated with the production of each vehicle type. By honing in on the manufacturing process, we can uncover specific environmental impacts related to the production of batteries for EVs compared to internal combustion engines for gasoline vehicles, providing insights into the most resource-intensive and environmentally impactful aspects of vehicle production." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:51.014972", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 50 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c47ead2f-b47f-4cde-a9a2-b4ff91c4ab3a", + "ibfs_id": "89f6c8f8-4f40-4cda-85f2-f6ac20ebb5aa", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce greenhouse gases and pollution significantly, but their production and battery disposal present environmental challenges.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a component-focused lifecycle analysis. This involves examining the environmental impact of each major component involved in the lifecycle of both vehicle types, from production to disposal. Key components include the battery for EVs, the engine for gasoline vehicles, and other shared components like the body and tires. We'll assess these components based on energy consumption, emissions, and resource depletion.\n\n### 1. Battery Production (Electric Vehicles)\n\n**Energy Consumption and Emissions:**\n- **Production:** The production of lithium-ion batteries, which are commonly used in EVs, is energy-intensive. It involves mining and processing raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. This process emits significant greenhouse gases (GHGs) due to the energy required, often from fossil fuels.\n- **Resource Depletion:** Mining for battery materials can lead to habitat destruction and water pollution. Cobalt mining, in particular, has raised ethical concerns due to labor practices and environmental degradation.\n\n### 2. Engine Manufacturing (Gasoline Vehicles)\n\n**Energy Consumption and Emissions:**\n- **Production:** Manufacturing an internal combustion engine (ICE) involves casting, machining, and assembling various metal components. This process is less energy-intensive than battery production but still contributes to GHG emissions.\n- **Resource Depletion:** The production of ICEs requires steel and aluminum, which involve mining and processing that can lead to environmental degradation.\n\n### 3. Vehicle Assembly and Body Production (Both EVs and Gasoline Vehicles)\n\n**Energy Consumption and Emissions:**\n- **Production:** The assembly of both EVs and gasoline vehicles involves similar processes, such as stamping, welding, and painting. These processes consume energy and produce emissions, though the impact is relatively similar for both vehicle types.\n- **Resource Depletion:** The materials used, such as steel, aluminum, and plastics, require mining and processing, contributing to resource depletion and environmental impact.\n\n### 4. Fuel Production and Consumption (Gasoline Vehicles)\n\n**Energy Consumption and Emissions:**\n- **Fuel Production:** Extracting, refining, and transporting gasoline is energy-intensive and results in significant GHG emissions. Oil extraction can also lead to spills and habitat destruction.\n- **Consumption:** During operation, gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, and other pollutants, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n\n### 5. Electricity Generation and Consumption (Electric Vehicles)\n\n**Energy Consumption and Emissions:**\n- **Electricity Generation:** The environmental impact of EVs during operation depends on the energy mix used to generate electricity. Coal-based electricity results in higher emissions, whereas renewable sources like wind or solar have minimal emissions.\n- **Consumption:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, reducing local air pollution compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n### 6. End-of-Life and Recycling (Both EVs and Gasoline Vehicles)\n\n**Energy Consumption and Emissions:**\n- **Recycling:** Both vehicle types can be recycled, but the processes differ. EV batteries require specialized recycling to recover valuable materials, which is energy-intensive but reduces the need for new raw materials.\n- **Disposal:** Improper disposal of batteries can lead to environmental contamination, while gasoline vehicles primarily contribute to metal waste if not recycled.\n\n### Comparative Summary\n\n- **Production Phase:** EVs have a higher environmental impact during production due to battery manufacturing, but gasoline vehicles have a lower impact in this phase.\n- **Use Phase:** EVs generally have lower environmental impacts during use, especially if powered by renewable energy, due to zero tailpipe emissions. Gasoline vehicles have higher emissions due to fuel combustion.\n- **End-of-Life Phase:** Both vehicle types have opportunities for recycling, but EVs require more specialized processes for battery recycling.\n\nOverall, while EVs have a higher initial environmental impact during production, they tend to offer lower impacts during the use phase, especially when powered by clean energy. The end-of-life impacts can be mitigated through effective recycling strategies for both vehicle types.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves assessing the environmental impact from production to disposal, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling. By comparing the complete lifecycle emissions and resource use of electric vehicles (EVs) to that of traditional gasoline vehicles, I can provide a comprehensive understanding of their relative environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by conducting a component-focused lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This method would involve breaking down the lifecycle into specific components, such as the battery production for EVs and engine manufacturing for gasoline vehicles. By assessing the environmental impact of each component separately, such as energy consumption, emissions, and resource depletion, I can compare how individual parts contribute to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type, offering a detailed view of their comparative impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves assessing the environmental impact from production to disposal, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling. By comparing the complete lifecycle emissions and resource use of electric vehicles (EVs) to that of traditional gasoline vehicles, I can provide a comprehensive understanding of their relative environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by examining specific environmental factors separately, such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource consumption. For instance, I can analyze the carbon emissions produced during the use phase of each vehicle type and compare them. Additionally, I can look at the impact on air quality due to tailpipe emissions from gasoline vehicles versus the emissions from electricity generation for EVs. By breaking down the environmental impacts into distinct categories, I can offer a detailed comparison that highlights the strengths and weaknesses of each vehicle type in each area." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves assessing the environmental impact from production to disposal, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling. By comparing the complete lifecycle emissions and resource use of electric vehicles (EVs) to that of traditional gasoline vehicles, I can provide a comprehensive understanding of their relative environmental impacts." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a region-specific lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would consider the environmental impacts unique to different geographic areas, such as the source of electricity for EVs (renewable vs. non-renewable) and the local availability of recycling facilities. By analyzing how these regional variations affect the total lifecycle emissions and resource use, I can provide insights into the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles in specific contexts, leading to a more tailored understanding of their impacts.", + "I can answer by conducting a component-focused lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This method would involve breaking down the lifecycle into specific components, such as the battery production for EVs and engine manufacturing for gasoline vehicles. By assessing the environmental impact of each component separately, such as energy consumption, emissions, and resource depletion, I can compare how individual parts contribute to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type, offering a detailed view of their comparative impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a component-focused lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This method would involve breaking down the lifecycle into specific components, such as the battery production for EVs and engine manufacturing for gasoline vehicles. By assessing the environmental impact of each component separately, such as energy consumption, emissions, and resource depletion, I can compare how individual parts contribute to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type, offering a detailed view of their comparative impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:52.229869", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 52 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c8f83bda-fb7f-420d-b698-26c889d50bce", + "ibfs_id": "fd057b24-490f-4f31-a2bc-05dabba9137c", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce zero tailpipe emissions and use renewable energy, reducing pollution compared to gasoline vehicles which emit pollutants.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a meta-analysis of the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, I will synthesize data from multiple peer-reviewed scientific studies that have quantitatively assessed these impacts. The focus will be on greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, and other relevant environmental metrics.\n\n### Greenhouse Gas Emissions\n\n1. **Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) Studies**: Numerous LCA studies have been conducted to compare the total greenhouse gas emissions of EVs and gasoline vehicles. A meta-analysis of these studies shows that, on average, EVs produce significantly lower greenhouse gas emissions over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles. For instance, a study by Hawkins et al. (2013) found that EVs can reduce emissions by approximately 20-30% in regions with average electricity grids, and up to 50% in regions with cleaner energy sources.\n\n2. **Electricity Source Dependency**: The environmental benefit of EVs is highly dependent on the electricity mix used for charging. A meta-analysis by Nordel\u00f6f et al. (2014) indicates that in areas with a high percentage of renewable energy, the reduction in emissions can be as high as 70% compared to gasoline vehicles. Conversely, in regions reliant on coal, the benefits are reduced but still present.\n\n### Air Quality\n\n1. **Tailpipe Emissions**: EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, which directly improves urban air quality by reducing pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM). A meta-analysis of urban air quality studies, such as those by Timmers and Achten (2016), shows a consistent reduction in NOx and PM levels in cities with higher EV adoption.\n\n2. **Upstream Emissions**: While EVs eliminate tailpipe emissions, the production of electricity and manufacturing of batteries contribute to upstream emissions. However, a synthesis of studies, including those by Notter et al. (2010), suggests that the overall impact on air quality is still positive, as the reduction in urban pollutants outweighs the emissions from electricity generation, especially as grids become greener.\n\n### Resource Use and Environmental Impact\n\n1. **Battery Production**: The production of lithium-ion batteries for EVs is resource-intensive, involving materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. A meta-analysis by Dunn et al. (2012) highlights that while battery production has a higher environmental impact than conventional vehicle manufacturing, advancements in recycling and battery technology are mitigating these effects.\n\n2. **End-of-Life Management**: Studies such as those by Gaines (2014) show that the environmental impact of EVs can be further reduced through effective recycling and reuse of battery materials, which is becoming more feasible with technological advancements.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe meta-analysis of peer-reviewed studies indicates that electric vehicles generally have a lower environmental impact than traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of greenhouse gas emissions and urban air quality. The benefits are more pronounced in regions with cleaner electricity grids and are expected to increase as renewable energy adoption grows and battery technologies improve. While there are challenges related to battery production and resource use, ongoing advancements in these areas are likely to enhance the environmental benefits of EVs over time.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by reviewing existing scientific studies and reports from reputable organizations and research institutions. This approach entails summarizing key findings from these studies, focusing on various environmental factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, resource depletion, and ecological impacts related to electric and gasoline vehicles. By synthesizing the consensus and differing viewpoints in the literature, I can provide a comprehensive overview of their environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by conducting a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed scientific papers that have quantitatively assessed the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This involves statistically analyzing the data from multiple studies to identify general trends and patterns, such as the average reduction in greenhouse gas emissions or changes in air quality metrics. By presenting a statistically robust synthesis, I can provide insights into the overall environmental impact that combines various study results into a coherent conclusion." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining every stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage to disposal\u2014to assess their environmental impacts. I will gather data on emissions, energy consumption, and resource use for both types of vehicles during each stage and then compare the cumulative environmental footprint.", + "I can answer by reviewing existing scientific studies and reports from reputable organizations and research institutions. This approach entails summarizing key findings from these studies, focusing on various environmental factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, resource depletion, and ecological impacts related to electric and gasoline vehicles. By synthesizing the consensus and differing viewpoints in the literature, I can provide a comprehensive overview of their environmental impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by reviewing existing scientific studies and reports from reputable organizations and research institutions. This approach entails summarizing key findings from these studies, focusing on various environmental factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, resource depletion, and ecological impacts related to electric and gasoline vehicles. By synthesizing the consensus and differing viewpoints in the literature, I can provide a comprehensive overview of their environmental impacts." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed scientific papers that have quantitatively assessed the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This involves statistically analyzing the data from multiple studies to identify general trends and patterns, such as the average reduction in greenhouse gas emissions or changes in air quality metrics. By presenting a statistically robust synthesis, I can provide insights into the overall environmental impact that combines various study results into a coherent conclusion.", + "I can answer by creating a comparative case study analysis, where I select specific geographic regions or countries that have transitioned significantly to electric vehicles and compare them to regions still predominantly using gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining region-specific scientific studies and government reports to evaluate localized environmental impacts, such as improvements in urban air quality or changes in local ecosystems. By comparing these case studies, I can highlight how the environmental impacts of electric vehicles vary across different socio-economic and environmental contexts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed scientific papers that have quantitatively assessed the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This involves statistically analyzing the data from multiple studies to identify general trends and patterns, such as the average reduction in greenhouse gas emissions or changes in air quality metrics. By presenting a statistically robust synthesis, I can provide insights into the overall environmental impact that combines various study results into a coherent conclusion." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:57.431043", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 53 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c968e9bf-0e3f-491a-8333-f74368dc8f61", + "ibfs_id": "29aa0f17-fafe-4b4a-a1eb-ed82b236b995", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles emit less CO2, reducing air pollution, but battery production impacts must be considered compared to gasoline vehicle emissions.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles using a gate-to-grave analysis, we focus on the latter stages of their lifecycle: operation, maintenance, and disposal.\n\n### Operation\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Emissions:** During operation, EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions. This means they do not emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), or particulate matter, which are common pollutants from gasoline vehicles. However, the overall emissions depend on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the emissions are minimal. Conversely, if the electricity comes from coal or other fossil fuels, indirect emissions can be significant.\n- **Energy Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. They convert over 77% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, whereas gasoline vehicles convert only about 12%\u201330% of the energy stored in gasoline.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change. The amount of emissions depends on the vehicle's fuel efficiency and the type of fuel used.\n- **Energy Efficiency:** Gasoline vehicles are less efficient in converting fuel energy into movement, resulting in higher operational emissions per mile compared to EVs.\n\n### Maintenance\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Maintenance Needs:** EVs typically require less maintenance than gasoline vehicles. They have fewer moving parts, no oil changes, and less wear on brakes due to regenerative braking systems. This can lead to reduced environmental impact from maintenance activities.\n- **Battery Life:** The main maintenance concern is the battery, which can degrade over time. However, advancements in battery technology are improving longevity and performance.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Maintenance Needs:** These vehicles require regular oil changes, air filter replacements, and other maintenance activities that can have environmental impacts due to the disposal of used oil and parts.\n- **Engine Wear:** Internal combustion engines have more moving parts, which can lead to more frequent repairs and replacements, contributing to waste and resource use.\n\n### Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal of EV batteries is a significant environmental concern. Batteries contain valuable materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which can be recycled. However, the recycling process can be energy-intensive and may produce waste if not managed properly. Efforts are being made to improve battery recycling technologies and infrastructure to minimize environmental impacts.\n- **End-of-Life Management:** As EVs reach the end of their life, proper recycling and disposal of electronic components and batteries are crucial to minimize environmental harm.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **End-of-Life Management:** Traditional vehicles are typically dismantled, and materials like steel and aluminum are recycled. However, fluids and other hazardous materials must be carefully managed to prevent environmental contamination.\n- **Waste Generation:** The disposal of used oil, filters, and other components can pose environmental risks if not handled correctly.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, during the operation phase, EVs have a clear advantage over gasoline vehicles in terms of emissions and energy efficiency. Maintenance for EVs is generally less environmentally impactful due to fewer moving parts and no need for oil changes. However, the disposal phase presents challenges for both vehicle types. EVs require effective battery recycling processes to mitigate environmental impacts, while gasoline vehicles need careful management of hazardous materials. Overall, the long-term ecological implications favor EVs, particularly as renewable energy sources become more prevalent for electricity generation.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation, to disposal. This approach will help quantify and compare elements such as carbon emissions, resource depletion, and waste generation associated with each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by performing a gate-to-grave analysis, concentrating on the latter stages of the lifecycle for electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy emphasizes the environmental impacts during the operation, maintenance, and eventual disposal of the vehicles. By assessing aspects such as emissions during vehicle use, the sustainability of battery recycling processes, and waste management challenges, this approach aims to highlight the long-term ecological implications and end-of-life considerations for both vehicle types." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation, to disposal. This approach will help quantify and compare elements such as carbon emissions, resource depletion, and waste generation associated with each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of the vehicles. This strategy would involve analyzing the emissions produced during the use of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles, considering factors such as the source of electricity for EVs (renewable vs. non-renewable) and the fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles. This will provide insights into the immediate environmental impacts related to vehicle operation, such as greenhouse gas emissions and air quality effects." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation, to disposal. This approach will help quantify and compare elements such as carbon emissions, resource depletion, and waste generation associated with each type of vehicle." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a cradle-to-gate analysis focused on the initial stages of the lifecycle for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy involves a detailed examination of the environmental impacts from raw material extraction to the manufacturing process. By evaluating factors such as the energy consumption during battery production for electric vehicles and the environmental cost of refining oil for gasoline vehicles, this approach provides insights into the early-stage ecological footprints of each type.", + "I can answer by performing a gate-to-grave analysis, concentrating on the latter stages of the lifecycle for electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy emphasizes the environmental impacts during the operation, maintenance, and eventual disposal of the vehicles. By assessing aspects such as emissions during vehicle use, the sustainability of battery recycling processes, and waste management challenges, this approach aims to highlight the long-term ecological implications and end-of-life considerations for both vehicle types." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by performing a gate-to-grave analysis, concentrating on the latter stages of the lifecycle for electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy emphasizes the environmental impacts during the operation, maintenance, and eventual disposal of the vehicles. By assessing aspects such as emissions during vehicle use, the sustainability of battery recycling processes, and waste management challenges, this approach aims to highlight the long-term ecological implications and end-of-life considerations for both vehicle types." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:00.448298", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 55 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "62469360-a8b9-40c1-90c7-87ad4a3fc290", + "ibfs_id": "bc0abf6e-7a39-4dff-8fb0-f219d511bcca", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but battery production and disposal pose environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine the energy sources used throughout their life cycles. This involves analyzing the electricity generation mix for EVs and the extraction and refining processes of fossil fuels for gasoline vehicles.\n\n### Electric Vehicles (EVs)\n\n1. **Electricity Generation Mix:**\n - **Renewable Sources:** EVs can be powered by electricity generated from renewable sources such as wind, solar, hydroelectric, and geothermal energy. These sources are generally low in carbon emissions and have minimal environmental impact compared to fossil fuels. The more a region relies on renewables, the lower the carbon footprint of EVs.\n - **Non-Renewable Sources:** In many regions, electricity is still partially generated from non-renewable sources like coal, natural gas, and oil. Coal-fired power plants are particularly carbon-intensive, emitting significant amounts of CO2 and other pollutants. Natural gas is cleaner than coal but still contributes to greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n2. **Carbon Intensity and Pollution Levels:**\n - The carbon intensity of electricity varies widely depending on the energy mix. For example, regions with a high percentage of coal in their energy mix will have higher emissions associated with EV use compared to regions with a high percentage of renewables.\n - The overall environmental impact of EVs is reduced as the grid becomes greener, with more renewable energy sources being integrated.\n\n### Gasoline Vehicles\n\n1. **Fossil Fuel Extraction and Refining:**\n - **Extraction:** The extraction of crude oil involves drilling and pumping, which can lead to environmental degradation, habitat destruction, and oil spills. These activities also release methane, a potent greenhouse gas.\n - **Refining:** Crude oil must be refined into gasoline, a process that is energy-intensive and emits CO2 and other pollutants. Refineries also release volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and sulfur dioxide (SO2), contributing to air pollution and acid rain.\n\n2. **Carbon Intensity and Pollution Levels:**\n - Gasoline combustion in internal combustion engines produces CO2, nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter, and other pollutants. These emissions contribute to climate change, smog, and respiratory health issues.\n - The carbon intensity of gasoline vehicles is relatively fixed, as it primarily depends on the efficiency of the vehicle and the carbon content of the fuel.\n\n### Comparative Insights\n\n- **Life Cycle Emissions:** Over their entire life cycle, EVs tend to have lower greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline vehicles, especially as the electricity grid becomes cleaner. This is because the emissions from electricity generation can be significantly lower than those from fuel extraction, refining, and combustion.\n- **Pollution Levels:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which can lead to improved air quality in urban areas. However, the environmental benefits depend on the cleanliness of the electricity used to charge them.\n- **Energy Transition:** The environmental impact of EVs will continue to improve as the global energy transition progresses, with increased adoption of renewable energy sources and advancements in battery technology.\n\nIn conclusion, while both vehicle types have environmental impacts associated with their energy sources, EVs generally offer a pathway to reduced emissions and pollution, particularly as the energy sector shifts towards more sustainable practices.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling. By comparing the total environmental footprint, including carbon emissions, resource use, and pollution, I can provide a comprehensive comparison between the two vehicle types.", + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the energy sources used throughout the life cycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves a detailed assessment of the environmental impacts associated with the electricity generation mix for electric vehicles, including renewable and non-renewable sources, as well as the extraction and refining processes of fossil fuels for gasoline vehicles. By comparing the carbon intensity and pollution levels of these energy sources, I can provide insights into how energy production and consumption contribute to the overall environmental impact of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling. By comparing the total environmental footprint, including carbon emissions, resource use, and pollution, I can provide a comprehensive comparison between the two vehicle types.", + "I can answer by focusing on the energy source used during the operation phase of the vehicles. This strategy involves analyzing the emissions and environmental impact of generating electricity for electric vehicles versus the direct emissions from burning gasoline in traditional vehicles. This includes examining the carbon intensity of the electricity grid in different regions, as well as the potential for renewable energy integration to reduce the environmental impact of electric vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling. By comparing the total environmental footprint, including carbon emissions, resource use, and pollution, I can provide a comprehensive comparison between the two vehicle types." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the energy sources used throughout the life cycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves a detailed assessment of the environmental impacts associated with the electricity generation mix for electric vehicles, including renewable and non-renewable sources, as well as the extraction and refining processes of fossil fuels for gasoline vehicles. By comparing the carbon intensity and pollution levels of these energy sources, I can provide insights into how energy production and consumption contribute to the overall environmental impact of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by conducting a geographical life cycle assessment (LCA) that considers the regional variations in environmental impacts for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach evaluates how factors like local electricity grid compositions, transportation infrastructure, and recycling capabilities affect the life cycle impacts of vehicles in different regions. By analyzing these regional differences, I can provide a nuanced comparison that highlights how location-specific factors influence the overall environmental footprint of electric versus gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing specifically on the energy sources used throughout the life cycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves a detailed assessment of the environmental impacts associated with the electricity generation mix for electric vehicles, including renewable and non-renewable sources, as well as the extraction and refining processes of fossil fuels for gasoline vehicles. By comparing the carbon intensity and pollution levels of these energy sources, I can provide insights into how energy production and consumption contribute to the overall environmental impact of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:07.389583", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 56 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "fd8b14a2-a88b-46cd-97b6-ed9392936394", + "ibfs_id": "2aed9d21-cb72-47ef-921c-d1b923e8676c", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce greenhouse emissions and air pollution but involve environmental costs through battery production and raw material mining.", + "final_answer": "To analyze the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we will conduct a comparative case study analysis focusing on three regions with distinct energy profiles: Norway, China, and the United States. Each region has varying levels of renewable energy integration and vehicle adoption rates, which affect the overall environmental impact of EVs.\n\n### Norway\n\n**Energy Profile and Vehicle Adoption:**\n- Norway is a leader in renewable energy, with approximately 98% of its electricity generated from hydropower.\n- The country has one of the highest per capita rates of EV adoption in the world, with EVs making up over 80% of new car sales as of 2023.\n\n**Environmental Impacts:**\n- **Emissions:** Due to the high share of renewable energy, the lifecycle emissions of EVs in Norway are significantly lower than those of gasoline vehicles. The carbon footprint of charging EVs is minimal, resulting in substantial reductions in greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Energy Source Dependency:** The reliance on hydropower means that EVs in Norway contribute minimally to fossil fuel dependency, enhancing energy security and reducing pollution.\n- **Recycling Practices:** Norway has established recycling systems for EV batteries, which further mitigates environmental impacts by reducing waste and recovering valuable materials.\n\n### China\n\n**Energy Profile and Vehicle Adoption:**\n- China has rapidly increased its EV adoption, with the government heavily promoting EVs as part of its strategy to reduce urban air pollution.\n- The country's energy mix is still heavily reliant on coal, although there is a growing investment in renewables like wind and solar.\n\n**Environmental Impacts:**\n- **Emissions:** While EVs help reduce urban air pollution, their lifecycle emissions in China are higher than in Norway due to the coal-dominated energy mix. However, they still offer a reduction in emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, particularly in urban areas where air quality is a significant concern.\n- **Energy Source Dependency:** The transition to EVs is part of China's strategy to reduce oil imports and increase energy independence. However, the coal-based electricity generation still poses environmental challenges.\n- **Recycling Practices:** China is developing battery recycling infrastructure, which is crucial given the scale of EV adoption. Effective recycling can mitigate some of the environmental impacts associated with battery production and disposal.\n\n### United States\n\n**Energy Profile and Vehicle Adoption:**\n- The U.S. has a diverse energy mix, with significant contributions from natural gas, coal, nuclear, and an increasing share of renewables.\n- EV adoption is growing, but gasoline vehicles still dominate the market.\n\n**Environmental Impacts:**\n- **Emissions:** The environmental impact of EVs in the U.S. varies by region, depending on the local energy mix. In states with higher renewable energy penetration, such as California, EVs have a lower carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. In regions reliant on coal, the benefits are less pronounced but still present.\n- **Energy Source Dependency:** EVs help reduce reliance on imported oil, contributing to energy security. The shift to renewables in the electricity sector further enhances the environmental benefits of EVs.\n- **Recycling Practices:** The U.S. is investing in battery recycling technologies, which is essential for minimizing the environmental impact of EVs and ensuring sustainable resource use.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles vary significantly across regions, influenced by the local energy mix, adoption rates, and recycling practices. In Norway, the high share of renewable energy makes EVs a clear environmental winner. In China, while coal reliance diminishes some benefits, EVs still contribute to reduced urban air pollution. In the U.S., regional differences in energy sources lead to varying impacts, with states investing in renewables seeing the most significant benefits. Effective battery recycling is a common challenge and opportunity across all regions, crucial for maximizing the environmental advantages of EVs.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by reviewing existing scientific studies and reports from authoritative sources such as government agencies, environmental organizations, and academic institutions. This approach will involve summarizing key findings from these studies regarding the environmental impacts of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles, focusing on factors like emissions during operation, energy sources for electricity production, and advances in battery technology and recycling.", + "I can answer by creating a comparative case study analysis using reports from specific regions or countries with different energy profiles. This approach will involve examining how the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles vary in places with different levels of renewable energy integration and vehicle adoption rates. The case studies will highlight differences in emissions, energy source dependencies, and recycling practices relevant to each region's unique context." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining each stage of a vehicle's life \u2014 from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal or recycling. I will evaluate the environmental impacts at each stage, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution, to provide a comprehensive comparison.", + "I can answer by reviewing existing scientific studies and reports from authoritative sources such as government agencies, environmental organizations, and academic institutions. This approach will involve summarizing key findings from these studies regarding the environmental impacts of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles, focusing on factors like emissions during operation, energy sources for electricity production, and advances in battery technology and recycling." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by reviewing existing scientific studies and reports from authoritative sources such as government agencies, environmental organizations, and academic institutions. This approach will involve summarizing key findings from these studies regarding the environmental impacts of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles, focusing on factors like emissions during operation, energy sources for electricity production, and advances in battery technology and recycling." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a meta-analysis of multiple scientific studies and reports from diverse authoritative sources. This approach will involve statistically synthesizing data from various studies to quantify the overall environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles. The analysis will focus on emissions during operation, lifecycle assessments, and the carbon footprint of manufacturing and recycling processes.", + "I can answer by creating a comparative case study analysis using reports from specific regions or countries with different energy profiles. This approach will involve examining how the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles vary in places with different levels of renewable energy integration and vehicle adoption rates. The case studies will highlight differences in emissions, energy source dependencies, and recycling practices relevant to each region's unique context." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by creating a comparative case study analysis using reports from specific regions or countries with different energy profiles. This approach will involve examining how the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles vary in places with different levels of renewable energy integration and vehicle adoption rates. The case studies will highlight differences in emissions, energy source dependencies, and recycling practices relevant to each region's unique context." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:11.661873", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 57 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "3c46622b-6121-4766-895e-2b51b4c36fab", + "ibfs_id": "d7e8e463-68c2-429b-8612-5327ebb4dbfe", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce carbon emissions, offer cleaner energy options, but have battery production impacts compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles during their operation phase, we need to focus on the emissions produced while each type of vehicle is in use.\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n\n1. **Direct Emissions:**\n - Electric vehicles produce zero tailpipe emissions. This means they do not emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter (PM), or other pollutants directly from the vehicle itself during operation.\n\n2. **Indirect Emissions:**\n - The emissions associated with electric vehicles during their operation phase are primarily indirect, stemming from the electricity generation process used to charge the vehicle's battery.\n - The environmental impact of these emissions varies significantly depending on the energy mix of the electricity grid. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources (such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power), the indirect emissions are very low. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, the emissions can be higher.\n - On average, even when accounting for electricity generation from fossil fuels, EVs typically result in lower overall greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles due to the higher efficiency of electric motors and the potential for cleaner energy sources.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n\n1. **Direct Emissions:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, carbon monoxide (CO), volatile organic compounds (VOCs), and particulate matter directly from the tailpipe as a result of burning fossil fuels.\n - These emissions contribute to air pollution and have significant impacts on human health and the environment, including contributing to smog formation and respiratory problems.\n\n2. **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:**\n - The operation of gasoline vehicles is a major source of CO2 emissions, a key greenhouse gas contributing to climate change. The amount of CO2 emitted is directly related to the fuel efficiency of the vehicle and the carbon content of the gasoline.\n\nIn summary, during the operation phase, electric vehicles have a clear advantage over gasoline vehicles in terms of direct emissions, as they produce none. However, the environmental impact of EVs is influenced by the source of electricity used for charging. Generally, even with a fossil-fuel-heavy electricity grid, EVs tend to have lower overall emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, especially as grids become cleaner over time with increased use of renewable energy sources.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the operation phase of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach will highlight the differences in greenhouse gas emissions and other pollutants released during the use of each type of vehicle, considering factors like electricity generation sources for electric vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles, which includes evaluating the environmental impact of production, usage, and disposal of each vehicle type. This approach will provide a comprehensive overview of the total environmental footprint of each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the operation phase of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach will highlight the differences in greenhouse gas emissions and other pollutants released during the use of each type of vehicle, considering factors like electricity generation sources for electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining the supply chain and resource extraction involved in the production of electric and gasoline vehicles. This includes looking at the mining of lithium, cobalt, and other materials for electric vehicle batteries compared to the extraction and refining of oil for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by evaluating the impact on energy infrastructure and resource consumption. This approach considers how the widespread adoption of electric vehicles might affect energy grid demands and the potential for renewable energy integration, versus the continued reliance on fossil fuels for gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the operation phase of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach will highlight the differences in greenhouse gas emissions and other pollutants released during the use of each type of vehicle, considering factors like electricity generation sources for electric vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:16.243256", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 62 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "d5ecfeed-76be-46cd-bf3c-51e3120329c8", + "ibfs_id": "cb1c59e8-6595-4193-99ef-3570edf9af9d", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution overall, but concerns include battery production impacts and resource extraction environmental consequences.", + "final_answer": "To address the query regarding the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, I conducted a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed academic papers focusing on lifecycle assessments (LCAs) of these vehicle types. This approach allows us to systematically review and statistically combine results from multiple studies to identify common findings and variations.\n\n### Meta-Analysis of Lifecycle Assessments\n\n#### Production Phase\n\n1. **Material Extraction and Manufacturing**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is more resource-intensive than that of gasoline vehicles. Studies consistently show that battery manufacturing contributes significantly to the overall emissions of EVs. For instance, the production of lithium-ion batteries involves mining and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which are energy-intensive and have notable environmental impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The production emissions are generally lower than those of EVs due to the absence of large batteries. However, the manufacturing of internal combustion engines and associated components still contributes to emissions.\n\n2. **Common Findings**: Across multiple studies, the consensus is that EVs have higher production emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to battery manufacturing.\n\n#### Operational Phase\n\n1. **Energy Efficiency and Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs are more energy-efficient and have zero tailpipe emissions. The environmental impact during the operational phase largely depends on the electricity mix used for charging. Studies indicate that in regions with a high share of renewable energy, EVs can significantly reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles emit CO2 and other pollutants during operation. The efficiency of gasoline vehicles has improved over time, but they still contribute significantly to air pollution and GHG emissions.\n\n2. **Common Findings**: The operational phase is where EVs generally outperform gasoline vehicles, especially in regions with clean electricity grids. The reduction in emissions during this phase often offsets the higher production emissions of EVs over their lifecycle.\n\n#### End-of-Life Disposal\n\n1. **Recycling and Disposal**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The disposal and recycling of batteries pose environmental challenges. However, advancements in battery recycling technologies are improving the sustainability of EVs. Studies highlight the importance of developing efficient recycling processes to mitigate the environmental impact.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: End-of-life disposal is more straightforward, with established recycling processes for metals and other materials. However, the disposal of oil and other fluids can have environmental impacts.\n\n2. **Common Findings**: Both vehicle types face challenges at the end-of-life stage, but the potential for recycling EV batteries is a critical area for reducing their environmental impact.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe meta-analysis of lifecycle assessments reveals that while electric vehicles have higher emissions during the production phase, they offer significant environmental benefits during the operational phase, especially in regions with clean energy sources. Over the entire lifecycle, EVs tend to have a lower overall environmental impact compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to reduced operational emissions. However, the environmental benefits of EVs are contingent on advancements in battery technology, recycling processes, and the decarbonization of electricity grids.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by summarizing and synthesizing findings from existing research studies and reports that have analyzed the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach focuses on gathering data from authoritative sources such as government agencies, academic institutions, and environmental organizations. By comparing key metrics like emissions during operation, energy source sustainability, and battery production impacts, I can provide a balanced overview of the environmental benefits and drawbacks of each vehicle type based on established literature.", + "I can answer by conducting a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed academic papers that specifically focus on lifecycle assessments of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves systematically reviewing and statistically combining the results from multiple studies to identify common findings and variations in the data. By analyzing factors such as production emissions, operational efficiency, and end-of-life disposal, I can derive a comprehensive and statistically robust conclusion about the environmental impacts of the two vehicle types." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental impacts of each vehicle type throughout their entire lifecycle, from raw material extraction and manufacturing through operation and end-of-life disposal. By assessing factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution at each stage, we can gain a comprehensive understanding of the overall environmental footprint of each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by summarizing and synthesizing findings from existing research studies and reports that have analyzed the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach focuses on gathering data from authoritative sources such as government agencies, academic institutions, and environmental organizations. By comparing key metrics like emissions during operation, energy source sustainability, and battery production impacts, I can provide a balanced overview of the environmental benefits and drawbacks of each vehicle type based on established literature." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by summarizing and synthesizing findings from existing research studies and reports that have analyzed the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach focuses on gathering data from authoritative sources such as government agencies, academic institutions, and environmental organizations. By comparing key metrics like emissions during operation, energy source sustainability, and battery production impacts, I can provide a balanced overview of the environmental benefits and drawbacks of each vehicle type based on established literature." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed academic papers that specifically focus on lifecycle assessments of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves systematically reviewing and statistically combining the results from multiple studies to identify common findings and variations in the data. By analyzing factors such as production emissions, operational efficiency, and end-of-life disposal, I can derive a comprehensive and statistically robust conclusion about the environmental impacts of the two vehicle types.", + "I can answer by creating a comparative case study analysis that draws on specific research reports and data from different geographic regions. This involves selecting case studies that highlight the regional variability in environmental impacts due to factors like electricity grid composition, vehicle usage patterns, and local manufacturing practices. By examining these case studies, I can provide insights into how local conditions influence the environmental performance of electric versus gasoline vehicles, offering a nuanced understanding that goes beyond generalized findings." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed academic papers that specifically focus on lifecycle assessments of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves systematically reviewing and statistically combining the results from multiple studies to identify common findings and variations in the data. By analyzing factors such as production emissions, operational efficiency, and end-of-life disposal, I can derive a comprehensive and statistically robust conclusion about the environmental impacts of the two vehicle types." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:16.378474", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 59 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "02d3b124-76d0-49b4-92ae-d5ef194c14de", + "ibfs_id": "46652c31-b18e-42c5-82c5-d12a39375768", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles have lower emissions and energy efficiency advantages but involve resource-intensive battery production and recycling challenges.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a detailed toxicological assessment of the materials used in electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to evaluate the extraction and processing of raw materials, focusing on the environmental toxicity and human health risks associated with each.\n\n### Electric Vehicles (EVs)\n\n#### Key Materials:\n1. **Lithium**: \n - **Extraction**: Lithium is primarily extracted from brine pools and hard rock mining. The brine extraction process involves pumping groundwater to the surface and allowing it to evaporate, which can lead to significant water depletion in arid regions, impacting local ecosystems and communities.\n - **Toxicological Impacts**: The evaporation process can lead to soil and water contamination with heavy metals. Additionally, the mining process can disrupt local habitats and biodiversity.\n\n2. **Cobalt**:\n - **Extraction**: Cobalt is often mined as a byproduct of copper and nickel mining. Major sources are in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where mining practices can be environmentally damaging and socially problematic.\n - **Toxicological Impacts**: Cobalt mining can lead to soil and water pollution with heavy metals, posing risks to local communities' health. The mining process can also release particulate matter and other pollutants into the air, contributing to respiratory issues.\n\n3. **Nickel**:\n - **Extraction**: Nickel is extracted through sulfide or laterite mining. Both methods can have significant environmental impacts.\n - **Toxicological Impacts**: Sulfide mining can lead to acid mine drainage, which can severely impact water quality and aquatic life. Nickel mining and processing can release sulfur dioxide and other pollutants, contributing to air pollution and acid rain.\n\n### Gasoline Vehicles\n\n#### Key Materials:\n1. **Crude Oil**:\n - **Extraction**: Oil extraction involves drilling and can include methods like hydraulic fracturing (fracking). These processes can lead to habitat destruction, oil spills, and groundwater contamination.\n - **Toxicological Impacts**: Oil spills are catastrophic for marine and coastal ecosystems, leading to long-term ecological damage. Fracking fluids can contaminate groundwater with toxic chemicals, posing health risks to humans and wildlife.\n\n2. **Refining**:\n - **Process**: Crude oil refining involves separating hydrocarbons and converting them into usable fuels, which is energy-intensive and produces significant emissions.\n - **Toxicological Impacts**: Refining releases pollutants such as volatile organic compounds (VOCs), sulfur oxides, and nitrogen oxides, contributing to air pollution and respiratory health issues. The process also generates hazardous waste that can contaminate soil and water.\n\n### Comparative Analysis\n\n- **Environmental Toxicity**: Both EVs and gasoline vehicles have significant environmental impacts at different stages. EVs primarily impact the environment during the extraction and processing of battery materials, while gasoline vehicles have major impacts during oil extraction and refining.\n\n- **Human Health Risks**: The health risks associated with EVs are mostly related to the mining of materials like cobalt and nickel, which can lead to respiratory issues and heavy metal exposure. Gasoline vehicles pose health risks through air pollution from refining and combustion, leading to respiratory and cardiovascular diseases.\n\n- **Lifecycle Considerations**: While EVs have a higher environmental impact during the production phase due to battery materials, they generally have lower emissions during the use phase compared to gasoline vehicles. Gasoline vehicles, on the other hand, continue to emit pollutants throughout their lifecycle.\n\nIn conclusion, both electric and gasoline vehicles have distinct environmental and health impacts, with EVs being more impactful during the material extraction phase and gasoline vehicles during fuel extraction and use. Transitioning to EVs could reduce overall emissions, but it is crucial to address the environmental and social impacts of battery material extraction to ensure a sustainable transition.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include evaluating raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By comparing each stage of the vehicle lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive assessment of their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by conducting a detailed toxicological assessment of the materials used in both electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve evaluating the extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries, as well as the environmental and health impacts of oil extraction and refining for gasoline. By comparing the environmental toxicity and human health risks across both vehicle types, I can highlight specific stages where the impacts may be most significant." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include evaluating raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By comparing each stage of the vehicle lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive assessment of their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of vehicles and analyzing the emissions produced during their use. This approach would involve comparing tailpipe emissions from gasoline vehicles with the emissions generated by the electricity production needed to charge EVs. By considering different energy sources for electricity (e.g., coal, natural gas, renewable energy), I can evaluate how regional energy mixes influence the comparative environmental impacts of driving electric versus gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include evaluating raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By comparing each stage of the vehicle lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive assessment of their environmental footprints." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the energy sources used during the operation phase of electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve analyzing the environmental impacts of the electricity generation mix (e.g., coal, natural gas, renewables) for EVs in different regions compared to the emissions from gasoline combustion. By examining how the source of energy affects the lifecycle emissions, I can provide insights into regional variations in the environmental benefits of EVs.", + "I can answer by conducting a detailed toxicological assessment of the materials used in both electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve evaluating the extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries, as well as the environmental and health impacts of oil extraction and refining for gasoline. By comparing the environmental toxicity and human health risks across both vehicle types, I can highlight specific stages where the impacts may be most significant." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a detailed toxicological assessment of the materials used in both electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve evaluating the extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries, as well as the environmental and health impacts of oil extraction and refining for gasoline. By comparing the environmental toxicity and human health risks across both vehicle types, I can highlight specific stages where the impacts may be most significant." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:17.057563", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 58 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "27b0ee75-2f05-4045-8f96-4c328d1a8ecd", + "ibfs_id": "8570b48e-ebc9-43cd-8d3e-a3e54915e27b", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles offer reduced emissions and decreased fossil fuel dependence, but require energy-intensive battery production and renewable energy sources.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a life cycle assessment (LCA) analysis. This involves examining each stage of the vehicle's life cycle: raw material extraction, manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life disposal.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve mining for lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, soil and water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use aluminum and copper more extensively than gasoline vehicles, contributing to additional mining impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fossil Fuels:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and pollution.\n- **Materials:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and plastics, but generally in lesser quantities than the metals used in EV batteries.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** Manufacturing EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive, often resulting in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Material Processing:** The processing of battery materials also contributes to emissions and environmental impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Less Energy-Intensive:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is typically less energy-intensive than for EVs, primarily due to the absence of large battery packs.\n- **Standard Components:** The production involves standard automotive components, which have established manufacturing processes with relatively lower emissions.\n\n### 3. Operation\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, reducing air pollution and greenhouse gases during operation.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during operation depends on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources (solar, wind) significantly reduce emissions, while coal-based electricity increases them.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Advances in fuel efficiency have reduced emissions, but they remain higher than those from EVs powered by clean energy.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of lithium-ion batteries are challenging. Improper disposal can lead to toxic chemical leaching. However, advancements in recycling technology are improving the recovery of valuable materials.\n- **Recyclability:** Other components of EVs are similar to gasoline vehicles and can be recycled through existing processes.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Established Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles have established recycling processes for metals and other materials.\n- **Environmental Risks:** Disposal of engine oils and other fluids poses environmental risks if not managed properly.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, electric vehicles tend to have higher environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages due to battery production. However, they offer significant environmental benefits during the operation phase, especially when powered by renewable energy, due to zero tailpipe emissions. The end-of-life impacts of EVs are currently more challenging due to battery disposal, but improvements in recycling technologies are mitigating these issues.\n\nIn contrast, gasoline vehicles have lower initial manufacturing impacts but contribute more significantly to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational life. Their end-of-life disposal is generally well-managed but still poses environmental risks.\n\nThe net environmental impact of EVs versus gasoline vehicles largely depends on the electricity mix used to power EVs and advancements in battery technology and recycling.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) analysis for both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the entire life cycle of each type of vehicle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation to end-of-life disposal. By comparing the environmental impacts at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each vehicle type affects the environment throughout its life span." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) analysis for both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the entire life cycle of each type of vehicle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation to end-of-life disposal. By comparing the environmental impacts at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each vehicle type affects the environment throughout its life span.", + "I can answer by focusing on the carbon emissions associated with each vehicle type. This approach would specifically compare greenhouse gas emissions produced during the operation of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. I would also take into account the emissions from electricity generation for electric vehicles and the fuel production and combustion processes for gasoline vehicles, providing insights into their respective contributions to global warming.", + "I can answer by examining the resource and material usage of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This strategy involves analyzing the raw materials required for battery production in electric vehicles, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, and comparing them to the materials needed for gasoline vehicle production, like steel and aluminum. This would highlight issues such as resource depletion, mining impacts, and the sustainability of supply chains for both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by considering the impact on air quality and public health. This approach focuses on the pollutants emitted by gasoline vehicles, such as nitrogen oxides and particulate matter, compared to the localized emissions reductions from electric vehicles. I would also explore how the shift to electric vehicles can lead to improved air quality in urban areas and potentially reduce adverse health outcomes related to pollution." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) analysis for both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the entire life cycle of each type of vehicle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation to end-of-life disposal. By comparing the environmental impacts at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each vehicle type affects the environment throughout its life span." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:21.672268", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 61 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "8b5c49b5-b5df-41b1-aab3-a72323f82f1a", + "ibfs_id": "bc1c121a-ef93-4be3-89d2-636c514f231c", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce fewer emissions, lower air pollution, and have a smaller carbon footprint compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, we will focus on the emissions and energy use associated with each type of vehicle.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n\n1. **Emissions During Operation:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit greenhouse gases (GHGs) directly from the tailpipe as a result of fuel combustion. The primary emissions include carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO), and particulate matter.\n - The amount of CO2 emitted is directly related to the fuel efficiency of the vehicle and the carbon content of the gasoline. On average, burning one gallon of gasoline produces about 8,887 grams of CO2.\n\n2. **Energy Use:**\n - Gasoline vehicles convert the chemical energy in gasoline into mechanical energy to power the vehicle. However, internal combustion engines are relatively inefficient, with only about 20-30% of the energy from gasoline being used to move the vehicle, while the rest is lost as heat.\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n\n1. **Emissions During Operation:**\n - EVs do not produce tailpipe emissions, as they rely on electric motors powered by batteries. However, the emissions associated with EVs depend on the source of the electricity used to charge them.\n - If the electricity comes from renewable sources such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the associated emissions are minimal. Conversely, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels like coal or natural gas, the emissions can be significant.\n\n2. **Energy Use:**\n - EVs are generally more efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 60% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, compared to the much lower efficiency of internal combustion engines.\n - The efficiency of EVs can be influenced by factors such as driving conditions, temperature, and the efficiency of the battery and charging systems.\n\n**Comparison:**\n\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:**\n - Gasoline vehicles consistently emit GHGs during operation due to fuel combustion. In contrast, EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, but their overall emissions depend on the electricity mix.\n - In regions where electricity is predominantly generated from renewable sources, EVs have a significantly lower carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. However, in areas reliant on coal or other fossil fuels, the emissions from EVs can be higher, though still typically lower than those from gasoline vehicles.\n\n- **Energy Efficiency:**\n - EVs are more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, leading to lower energy consumption per mile traveled. This efficiency advantage contributes to reduced overall emissions, especially when powered by clean energy.\n\nIn summary, during the operational phase, electric vehicles generally have a lower environmental impact compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, primarily due to their higher efficiency and the potential for low emissions when powered by renewable energy sources. However, the exact environmental benefit of EVs depends significantly on the energy mix used for electricity generation in a given region.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy use during the operational phase of the vehicles. This approach would compare the greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion with the emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs. I would consider the sources of electricity (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and analyze how these contribute to the overall carbon footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the entire lifecycle of each type of vehicle, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal. By analyzing factors such as energy consumption, emissions, and resource depletion at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy use during the operational phase of the vehicles. This approach would compare the greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion with the emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs. I would consider the sources of electricity (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and analyze how these contribute to the overall carbon footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by exploring the implications of battery production and disposal for electric vehicles. This approach would specifically investigate the environmental impacts associated with the extraction and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which are critical for EV batteries. Additionally, I would examine the challenges and environmental consequences of battery recycling and disposal compared to the disposal of gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by evaluating the broader environmental and social impacts of infrastructure changes required for each vehicle type. This would include an analysis of the environmental footprint of developing charging infrastructure for EVs versus the impact of maintaining the existing network of gas stations for gasoline vehicles. I would also consider the potential for reduced air and noise pollution in urban areas due to increased EV adoption and the societal benefits of transitioning to cleaner transportation." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy use during the operational phase of the vehicles. This approach would compare the greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion with the emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs. I would consider the sources of electricity (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and analyze how these contribute to the overall carbon footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:22.457462", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 60 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "1a6446b8-0cf5-4e4e-afd7-5f06ff57add2", + "ibfs_id": "23e8bc43-c89f-44cf-a9cb-b2bb1ef03878", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles offer reduced emissions and lower pollution, but battery production impacts are significant compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we will conduct a life cycle assessment (LCA). This assessment considers the entire lifespan of the vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to use and disposal.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction and Manufacturing\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Production**: EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction and water pollution. The energy-intensive process of battery production also results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing**: The manufacturing process for EVs is similar to that of gasoline vehicles, but the additional complexity and weight of the battery can increase the energy and material inputs required.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Fuel System Components**: Gasoline vehicles require the extraction and refinement of crude oil, which has its own environmental impacts, including oil spills, habitat destruction, and significant carbon emissions.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing**: The manufacturing of gasoline vehicles involves the production of internal combustion engines and associated components, which generally have lower initial carbon emissions than EVs due to the absence of large batteries.\n\n### 2. Use Phase\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Energy Source**: The environmental impact during the use phase of EVs largely depends on the electricity mix used for charging. EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces local air pollution. However, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels, the overall carbon emissions can be substantial.\n- **Efficiency**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid into vehicle movement.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Fuel Consumption**: Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Efficiency**: Internal combustion engines are less efficient than electric motors, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n\n### 3. End-of-Life and Disposal\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Disposal and Recycling**: The disposal of EV batteries poses environmental challenges. While recycling technologies are improving, the process is still energy-intensive and not all materials can be fully recovered. Improper disposal can lead to soil and water contamination.\n- **Vehicle Recycling**: The rest of the EV can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, with metals and other materials being recovered and reused.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Vehicle Recycling**: Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle due to the absence of large battery systems. Metals and other materials can be efficiently recovered.\n- **Environmental Impact**: The disposal of gasoline vehicles does not involve the same level of hazardous waste as EVs, but the cumulative environmental impact of emissions during the use phase is significant.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, the life cycle assessment reveals that electric vehicles have higher environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases, primarily due to battery production. However, they offer significant benefits during the use phase, especially in regions with clean electricity grids, due to their higher efficiency and lack of tailpipe emissions. The end-of-life phase presents challenges for both vehicle types, but EVs face additional hurdles with battery disposal and recycling. Overall, the environmental impact of EVs can be lower than that of gasoline vehicles, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing through to use and disposal, to provide a comprehensive comparison." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing through to use and disposal, to provide a comprehensive comparison.", + "I can answer by focusing on the direct emissions produced by both types of vehicles during their operational phase. This would involve comparing the emissions from the tailpipes of gasoline vehicles with the emissions associated with electricity generation for electric vehicles, considering the energy mix of the grid.", + "I can answer by examining the broader ecological implications of resource extraction for both vehicle types. For electric vehicles, this would include the mining of lithium, cobalt, and other rare earth metals for batteries, whereas for gasoline vehicles, it would involve the extraction and refining of crude oil.", + "I can answer by exploring the potential for renewable energy integration with electric vehicles. This approach would assess how electric vehicles can be powered by renewable energy sources such as wind or solar, potentially reducing their environmental impact compared to gasoline vehicles that rely on fossil fuels." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing through to use and disposal, to provide a comprehensive comparison." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:28.592286", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 63 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "cfc7346f-1f05-4036-8888-c165409cf3ae", + "ibfs_id": "15b1016a-a06d-4235-8a29-d1df906a632b", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles generally produce lower greenhouse gas emissions, reduce air pollution, and decrease dependence on fossil fuels compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can focus on the carbon footprint associated with both types of vehicles. This involves examining the greenhouse gas emissions produced during their production and operation phases, as well as the potential reductions in emissions when using renewable energy sources for charging EVs.\n\n### Production Phase\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - The production of EVs generally results in higher greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to the manufacturing of lithium-ion batteries. The extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel are energy-intensive and contribute significantly to the carbon footprint.\n - Studies estimate that the production emissions for EVs can be 30-40% higher than those for conventional vehicles. However, this varies based on the size of the battery and the energy mix used in the manufacturing process.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - The production of gasoline vehicles involves emissions from the extraction and refining of oil, as well as the manufacturing of the vehicle itself. These emissions are relatively lower compared to EVs, mainly because they do not require large batteries.\n\n### Operation Phase\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces their operational carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. However, the overall emissions depend on the source of electricity used for charging.\n - If the electricity comes from fossil fuels, such as coal or natural gas, the emissions can be substantial. However, as the grid becomes greener with more renewable energy sources like wind, solar, and hydroelectric power, the operational emissions of EVs decrease significantly.\n - In regions with a high share of renewable energy, the carbon footprint of operating an EV can be reduced by up to 70-80% compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe. The average gasoline vehicle emits about 4.6 metric tons of carbon dioxide per year, assuming a fuel economy of about 22 miles per gallon and an annual mileage of 11,500 miles.\n - These emissions are a direct result of burning fossil fuels and are not offset by renewable energy sources.\n\n### Potential Reductions with Renewable Energy\n\n- The carbon footprint of EVs can be further reduced by charging them with electricity generated from renewable sources. This transition is crucial for maximizing the environmental benefits of EVs.\n- In scenarios where the electricity grid is predominantly powered by renewables, the lifecycle emissions of EVs can be reduced by up to 80% compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- As more countries and regions invest in renewable energy infrastructure, the environmental advantages of EVs over gasoline vehicles are expected to increase.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nWhile the production of EVs currently results in higher emissions due to battery manufacturing, their operational phase offers significant reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, especially when charged with renewable energy. In contrast, gasoline vehicles have lower production emissions but consistently high operational emissions due to fossil fuel combustion. As the energy grid becomes cleaner, the carbon footprint of EVs will continue to decrease, making them a more environmentally friendly option in the long run.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by evaluating the carbon footprint associated with both types of vehicles. This strategy would focus on quantifying the greenhouse gas emissions produced during the production and operation of EVs and gasoline vehicles, as well as the potential reductions in emissions when using renewable energy sources for charging EVs." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life-cycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from manufacturing through disposal. This would include an examination of raw material extraction, production processes, energy consumption during vehicle usage, and end-of-life recycling or disposal processes.", + "I can answer by evaluating the carbon footprint associated with both types of vehicles. This strategy would focus on quantifying the greenhouse gas emissions produced during the production and operation of EVs and gasoline vehicles, as well as the potential reductions in emissions when using renewable energy sources for charging EVs.", + "I can answer by examining the supply chain and resource dependency of both vehicle types. This would include an analysis of the environmental impact of mining for materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries compared to oil drilling and refining processes for gasoline vehicles. This approach would also consider geopolitical and ecological impacts associated with resource extraction.", + "I can answer by exploring the policies and incentives that influence the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing how government regulations, subsidies for clean energy, and emissions standards impact the adoption and development of each vehicle type, and how these policies affect their overall environmental footprint." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by evaluating the carbon footprint associated with both types of vehicles. This strategy would focus on quantifying the greenhouse gas emissions produced during the production and operation of EVs and gasoline vehicles, as well as the potential reductions in emissions when using renewable energy sources for charging EVs." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:31.349454", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 64 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "1bd18304-4581-49eb-a9c0-075c4ad1867e", + "ibfs_id": "660f31e3-6961-4a07-883f-3885e3bf1fb7", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles offer reduced emissions and lower environmental impact over lifecycle compared to gasoline vehicles, despite battery production concerns.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a life-cycle assessment (LCA) that examines each stage of the vehicles' life cycle: raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal or recycling.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of materials like lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction, soil and water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also require copper and aluminum, which are less environmentally intensive than battery materials but still contribute to the overall impact.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline involve significant energy use and environmental risks, such as oil spills and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Vehicle Materials:** Gasoline vehicles primarily use steel and aluminum, which have a lower environmental impact compared to the materials used in EV batteries.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher emissions compared to the manufacturing of gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in battery technology and manufacturing processes are gradually reducing these impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Manufacturing emissions are generally lower than those of EVs, mainly due to the absence of large battery systems. However, the production of internal combustion engines and associated components still contributes to environmental impacts.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, significantly reducing air pollution in urban areas. However, the environmental impact during usage largely depends on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the impact is minimal. Conversely, if it comes from coal or other fossil fuels, the benefits are reduced.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** While improvements have been made, gasoline vehicles are less efficient than EVs, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose environmental challenges. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable materials and reducing the environmental footprint.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, EVs can be dismantled and recycled, with metals and other materials being reused.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle due to the absence of complex battery systems. Most of the vehicle's materials, such as steel and aluminum, can be efficiently recycled.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe life-cycle assessment reveals that while EVs have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages, they offer significant benefits during the usage phase, especially when powered by renewable energy. The end-of-life impacts are being mitigated by advancements in recycling technologies. In contrast, gasoline vehicles have lower initial manufacturing impacts but contribute more significantly to environmental degradation during their usage phase due to emissions. Overall, EVs present a more sustainable option in the long term, particularly as the energy grid becomes greener and battery technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life-cycle assessment (LCA) comparison of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the environmental impacts associated with each stage of the vehicles' life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. This method provides a comprehensive overview of the total environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life-cycle assessment (LCA) comparison of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the environmental impacts associated with each stage of the vehicles' life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. This method provides a comprehensive overview of the total environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational emissions of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This strategy involves comparing the emissions produced during the use phase of both types of vehicles, including tailpipe emissions from gasoline vehicles and the emissions from electricity generation for charging EVs. This approach highlights the differences in air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during vehicle operation.", + "I can answer by examining the raw materials and resource consumption involved in the production of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would analyze the environmental impact of extracting and processing materials such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries, compared to the impacts of extracting crude oil and refining it into gasoline. It would also consider the sustainability and ethical concerns related to resource extraction.", + "I can answer by evaluating the potential for renewable energy integration with electric vehicles. This strategy involves discussing how the environmental impact of EVs can be mitigated by charging them using renewable energy sources like solar or wind power. This approach contrasts the possibilities of achieving a lower carbon footprint with EVs when compared to the fixed emissions profile of gasoline vehicles, which depend on fossil fuels." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life-cycle assessment (LCA) comparison of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the environmental impacts associated with each stage of the vehicles' life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. This method provides a comprehensive overview of the total environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:37.276756", + "similarity_score": 0.7, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 65 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "dc0d16b2-f461-43f5-b07e-838a51cd5630", + "ibfs_id": "156bf047-62e5-46d2-b085-cd2956f97223", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and air pollution but have challenges with battery production, resource extraction, and end-of-life disposal.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines each stage of the vehicles' life spans: raw material extraction, manufacturing, use phase, and end-of-life disposal. This comprehensive analysis will help us understand the carbon footprint and resource consumption associated with each type of vehicle.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Batteries:** EVs rely heavily on lithium-ion batteries, which require the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy use.\n- **Metals and Components:** EVs also use aluminum and copper, which require energy-intensive extraction processes.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fossil Fuels:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling and refining, which can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and significant greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Metals and Components:** Similar to EVs, gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and other metals, though typically in different proportions.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** The production of batteries is energy-intensive, contributing to a higher initial carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** EV manufacturing processes are generally similar to those of gasoline vehicles but may involve additional energy for battery integration.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine Production:** Manufacturing internal combustion engines is complex and energy-intensive, but generally less so than battery production.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to EVs, with a focus on integrating the engine and fuel systems.\n\n### 3. Use Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy Source:** The environmental impact during the use phase largely depends on the electricity mix used for charging. Renewable energy sources (solar, wind) significantly reduce emissions, whereas coal-based electricity increases them.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Combustion:** Burning gasoline releases CO2 and other pollutants, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Efficiency:** Internal combustion engines are less efficient, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries are critical. While recycling can recover valuable materials, improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, with a focus on recovering metals and other materials.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Established processes exist for recycling metals and other components, though the disposal of oil and other fluids poses environmental risks.\n\n### Overall Environmental Impact\n\n- **Carbon Footprint:** EVs generally have a higher initial carbon footprint due to battery production but can offset this during the use phase, especially if powered by renewable energy. Over their lifetime, EVs typically produce fewer emissions than gasoline vehicles.\n- **Resource Consumption:** Both vehicle types require significant resources, but EVs depend more on critical minerals for batteries, which can have geopolitical and environmental implications.\n- **Pollution:** EVs have the potential to reduce air pollution in urban areas due to zero tailpipe emissions, while gasoline vehicles contribute to local air quality issues.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs have some environmental challenges, particularly in raw material extraction and battery production, they offer significant advantages in reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving air quality during the use phase. The overall environmental impact of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles is generally lower, especially when powered by clean energy sources.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the entire life span of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase, to end-of-life disposal. By comparing the carbon footprint and resource consumption at each stage, I would provide a comprehensive overview of their respective environmental impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the entire life span of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase, to end-of-life disposal. By comparing the carbon footprint and resource consumption at each stage, I would provide a comprehensive overview of their respective environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This method would involve comparing the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles with the emissions from electricity generation for EVs, which vary depending on the energy mix of the grid. This approach highlights the differences in air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during the usage stage of the vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining regional differences in environmental impacts. This strategy involves exploring how the environmental benefits of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles can vary depending on the local energy infrastructure, government policies, availability of recycling facilities, and public transportation options. By providing specific examples from different regions, I would illustrate how these factors influence the overall environmental impact.", + "I can answer by assessing the broader ecological and societal impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This approach would consider not only the direct environmental effects, such as emissions and resource depletion but also the indirect impacts, such as the mining of materials for batteries, potential shifts in employment due to changes in the automotive industry, and the implications for energy independence and security. This holistic analysis would provide a more context-driven understanding of the broader consequences of adopting electric vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the entire life span of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase, to end-of-life disposal. By comparing the carbon footprint and resource consumption at each stage, I would provide a comprehensive overview of their respective environmental impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:40.182004", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 66 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "d01ebeb8-5d1b-49f4-af4d-614ab4e23d8c", + "ibfs_id": "762c6ab6-42a3-497f-af5b-feb4164f5558", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce air pollution and reliance on fossil fuels but have significant battery production and disposal impacts.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative lifecycle analysis of the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to evaluate each stage of a vehicle's lifecycle: production, usage, and end-of-life management. This analysis will consider factors such as carbon footprint, resource extraction, manufacturing processes, and disposal.\n\n### 1. Production Phase\n\n#### Resource Extraction and Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other materials. Mining these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing:** The production of EVs generally requires more energy than gasoline vehicles, primarily due to the energy-intensive battery manufacturing process. However, advancements in technology and recycling are helping to mitigate these impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Fuel System Production:** Gasoline vehicles require the extraction and processing of crude oil for fuel, which involves significant environmental risks, including oil spills and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing:** The production of gasoline vehicles is less energy-intensive compared to EVs, as they do not require large batteries. However, the manufacturing process still involves significant emissions and resource use.\n\n### 2. Usage Phase\n\n#### Carbon Footprint and Emissions\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Operation Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces local air pollution. However, the overall carbon footprint depends on the electricity source used for charging. Renewable energy sources result in a much lower carbon footprint compared to coal or natural gas.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Operation Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** While improvements in fuel efficiency have been made, gasoline vehicles still convert less energy from fuel to power at the wheels compared to EVs.\n\n### 3. End-of-Life Management\n\n#### Disposal and Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Disposal:** The disposal and recycling of lithium-ion batteries are critical environmental concerns. Improper disposal can lead to soil and water contamination. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable materials.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** EVs can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, with metals and other materials being reused.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Vehicle Disposal:** Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle, as they do not contain large batteries. Metals and other components can be recovered and reused.\n- **Environmental Impact:** The disposal of gasoline vehicles still involves environmental impacts, particularly from fluids and other hazardous materials.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles offer significant environmental benefits during the usage phase due to their lack of tailpipe emissions and higher energy efficiency. However, the production phase of EVs, particularly battery manufacturing, has a higher environmental impact compared to gasoline vehicles. The end-of-life phase presents challenges for both vehicle types, with battery recycling being a key area for improvement in EVs. Overall, the environmental impact of EVs can be significantly reduced by using renewable energy sources for electricity and improving battery recycling technologies.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impact of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include assessing the carbon footprint, resource extraction, manufacturing processes, usage, and end-of-life management, providing a comprehensive overview of the entire lifecycle for each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impact of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include assessing the carbon footprint, resource extraction, manufacturing processes, usage, and end-of-life management, providing a comprehensive overview of the entire lifecycle for each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by analyzing the differences in emissions during the use phase of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This approach would focus on comparing the tailpipe emissions of traditional vehicles with the emissions generated from electricity production for electric vehicles, considering different energy sources like coal, natural gas, and renewables used in electricity generation.", + "I can answer by exploring the resource extraction and material use involved in both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would involve a detailed examination of the mining and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for electric vehicle batteries versus the extraction and refining of petroleum for gasoline vehicles, highlighting the environmental impacts associated with each process.", + "I can answer by reviewing and summarizing existing research studies and expert opinions on the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would involve gathering data from peer-reviewed articles, governmental reports, and industry analyses to provide a well-rounded perspective based on expert consensus and empirical evidence." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impact of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include assessing the carbon footprint, resource extraction, manufacturing processes, usage, and end-of-life management, providing a comprehensive overview of the entire lifecycle for each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:41.960854", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 67 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "7e878f6e-258a-43ce-901a-4e78372a5b06", + "ibfs_id": "163d9949-98ac-4e4e-bc38-37cbf9ddc85c", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and energy consumption, but battery production and disposal present significant environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a lifecycle analysis that examines the entire lifecycle of both types of vehicles. This analysis includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Batteries:** EVs require large batteries, typically lithium-ion, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, soil and water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Electric Motors:** Require rare earth elements like neodymium, which also have environmental and social impacts associated with their extraction.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Vehicle Components:** Require steel, aluminum, and other materials, which also have environmental impacts from mining and refining processes.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Processes\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** Manufacturing batteries is energy-intensive and contributes significantly to the carbon footprint of EVs. However, advancements in technology and recycling can mitigate some impacts.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Generally similar to gasoline vehicles but may involve additional processes for integrating electric drivetrains.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine Production:** Manufacturing internal combustion engines involves complex processes that are energy-intensive and produce emissions.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to EVs, with established processes that have been optimized over decades.\n\n### 3. Vehicle Operation\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces urban air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation.\n- **Energy Source:** The environmental impact depends on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources (solar, wind, hydro) greatly reduce the carbon footprint, while coal or natural gas increase it.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** Emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter, and other pollutants, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Varies by model, but generally less efficient than EVs in terms of energy conversion.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** Batteries can be recycled, but the process is complex and not yet fully efficient. Improper disposal can lead to environmental hazards.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, with metals and other materials being recycled.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Established processes exist for recycling metals and other components. However, the disposal of oil and other fluids poses environmental risks.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles generally have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases, primarily due to battery production. However, they offer significant environmental benefits during the operation phase, especially when powered by renewable energy sources, due to their zero tailpipe emissions and higher energy efficiency. Gasoline vehicles, while having a lower initial environmental impact in terms of raw material extraction and manufacturing, contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational phase. End-of-life impacts for both vehicle types depend on the effectiveness of recycling processes and the management of hazardous materials. Overall, the lifecycle analysis suggests that EVs have the potential to be more environmentally friendly than gasoline vehicles, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, examining the entire lifecycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. This approach provides a comprehensive view of the environmental impacts associated with each type of vehicle." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, examining the entire lifecycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. This approach provides a comprehensive view of the environmental impacts associated with each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of the vehicles, comparing the emissions produced during their use. This strategy would evaluate the greenhouse gas emissions and other pollutants emitted by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion against the emissions generated from electricity production for charging electric vehicles, considering different energy sources like coal, natural gas, and renewables.", + "I can answer by examining the resource and energy consumption involved in the production of electric vehicles, particularly focusing on the extraction and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel used in batteries. This approach would compare these impacts to the oil extraction and refining processes required for gasoline vehicles, highlighting the environmental costs of resource extraction for both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by analyzing the broader environmental and societal implications, such as the potential for reducing urban air pollution and noise with electric vehicles, versus the economic and environmental impacts of maintaining existing gasoline infrastructure. This would include considering the benefits of improved air quality and reduced noise pollution in urban areas and the challenges related to transitioning infrastructure and workforce from gasoline to electric vehicle support." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, examining the entire lifecycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. This approach provides a comprehensive view of the environmental impacts associated with each type of vehicle." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:48.067835", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 69 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "12fe16e1-6cee-4953-b706-24eb2f99867c", + "ibfs_id": "f7d59b8a-739e-47e7-87ff-a9a918a66604", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles have a smaller carbon footprint, reduce air pollution, but battery production and disposal carry significant environmental concerns.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines each stage of a vehicle's life: raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal or recycling. This approach allows us to evaluate and compare the environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and energy consumption.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. This process can be energy-intensive and environmentally damaging, particularly in terms of water usage and habitat disruption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use aluminum and copper, which have significant environmental footprints due to mining and refining processes.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fossil Fuels:** The extraction and refinement of crude oil for gasoline involve significant energy use and environmental risks, such as oil spills and habitat destruction.\n- **Metals and Materials:** Gasoline vehicles use steel, aluminum, and other materials, but typically in smaller quantities compared to the materials needed for EV batteries.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is more energy-intensive than that of gasoline vehicles. This results in higher initial greenhouse gas emissions during the manufacturing phase.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Less Energy-Intensive:** Manufacturing gasoline vehicles generally requires less energy compared to EVs, resulting in lower initial emissions.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs do not emit greenhouse gases during operation. However, the environmental impact depends on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the emissions are minimal. If it's from fossil fuels, the emissions are higher.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and other pollutants during operation, contributing significantly to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Gasoline vehicles are less efficient, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n\n### 4. Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of lithium-ion batteries pose environmental challenges. However, recycling technologies are improving, which can mitigate some impacts.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Other components of EVs can be recycled similarly to those of gasoline vehicles.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **End-of-Life Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle, with established processes for metals and other materials. However, they do not have the added complexity of battery disposal.\n\n### Overall Comparison\n\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** Over their entire life cycle, EVs generally produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline vehicles, especially if powered by renewable energy.\n- **Resource Depletion:** EVs have higher resource depletion impacts due to battery materials but can be mitigated through recycling and sustainable mining practices.\n- **Energy Consumption:** While EVs have higher energy consumption during manufacturing, their operational efficiency often offsets this over the vehicle's lifetime.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages, they offer significant benefits during the usage phase, particularly in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution. The overall environmental impact of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles depends heavily on the electricity source and advancements in battery recycling technologies.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at every stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal or recycling. Through this comprehensive analysis, I can compare factors like greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and energy consumption for both vehicle types." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at every stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal or recycling. Through this comprehensive analysis, I can compare factors like greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and energy consumption for both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by reviewing recent academic research and scientific studies that analyze the environmental benefits and drawbacks of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve summarizing findings from peer-reviewed journals and reports that focus on emissions, air quality, and overall ecological footprint, providing a detailed comparison based on up-to-date research.", + "I can answer by analyzing case studies of specific regions or countries that have adopted electric vehicles on a large scale. This would involve examining real-world data on how the shift to electric vehicles has affected environmental indicators such as air pollution levels, carbon emissions, and energy resource consumption, comparing these with areas reliant on traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring the technological and infrastructural aspects that influence the environmental impact of both vehicle types. This would include looking into the sources of electricity for EVs (renewable vs. non-renewable), the efficiency of battery recycling processes, and the impact of oil extraction and refinement for gasoline vehicles, providing a nuanced comparison based on these critical factors." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at every stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal or recycling. Through this comprehensive analysis, I can compare factors like greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and energy consumption for both vehicle types." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:49.710069", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 68 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "b4c778c7-9960-4d02-8584-d720dad666eb", + "ibfs_id": "4775b8f4-c425-4ba8-a40a-6a9e7d50c3eb", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions significantly, minimize air pollution, and lower carbon footprint compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, we can focus on tailpipe emissions, particularly carbon dioxide (CO\u2082) and other pollutants.\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Electric vehicles do not produce tailpipe emissions during their operation. This means they do not emit carbon dioxide (CO\u2082), nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter (PM), or other harmful pollutants directly from the vehicle itself. This is a significant environmental advantage, especially in urban areas where air quality is a concern.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Traditional gasoline vehicles emit a variety of pollutants during their operation. The primary emissions include:\n - **Carbon Dioxide (CO\u2082):** Gasoline vehicles emit CO\u2082 as a byproduct of burning fossil fuels. The amount of CO\u2082 emitted depends on the fuel efficiency of the vehicle and the carbon content of the gasoline.\n - **Nitrogen Oxides (NOx):** These are significant contributors to smog and respiratory problems. Gasoline engines produce NOx during combustion.\n - **Particulate Matter (PM):** Gasoline vehicles can emit particulate matter, which contributes to air pollution and can have adverse health effects.\n - **Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs):** These contribute to the formation of ground-level ozone and smog.\n\nIn summary, during their operational phase, electric vehicles have a clear advantage over gasoline vehicles in terms of tailpipe emissions. EVs produce no direct emissions, which helps reduce local air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions associated with vehicle operation. In contrast, gasoline vehicles emit several pollutants, including CO\u2082, which contribute to climate change and air quality issues.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of the vehicles, specifically looking at the emissions produced during their use. This would involve comparing the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles, such as CO", + "I can answer by examining the tailpipe emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, focusing on pollutants like carbon dioxide (CO" + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This method involves evaluating the total environmental impact of each vehicle type from production through operation to disposal. By examining factors such as resource extraction, manufacturing emissions, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life processing, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of the vehicles, specifically looking at the emissions produced during their use. This would involve comparing the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles, such as CO", + "I can answer by examining the broader ecological and societal impacts of adopting electric vehicles over traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include factors such as the reduction in urban air pollution and its health benefits, the potential changes in infrastructure requirements (like charging stations vs. fuel stations), and the impact on oil dependency and energy security. By taking a holistic view, I can evaluate how a shift to electric vehicles might influence environmental sustainability on a broader scale.", + "I can answer by analyzing recent research studies and reports from credible environmental organizations and academic institutions. By summarizing findings from multiple sources, including data on emissions, resource use, and environmental policies, I can present an evidence-based overview that reflects the current scientific consensus on the comparative environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach ensures that the answer is grounded in up-to-date and reliable information." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of the vehicles, specifically looking at the emissions produced during their use. This would involve comparing the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles, such as CO" + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by examining the tailpipe emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, focusing on pollutants like carbon dioxide (CO", + "I can answer by analyzing the emissions produced indirectly from the energy sources used to power electric and gasoline vehicles. For electric vehicles, this means looking at the emissions from electricity generation based on the energy mix of the grid, while for gasoline vehicles, it involves calculating the emissions from refining and transporting gasoline.", + "I can answer by considering the lifecycle emissions during the operational phase, which includes not only direct emissions but also the emissions associated with vehicle maintenance and parts replacement. This would involve assessing the environmental impact of maintaining electric vehicle batteries versus internal combustion engine components over the vehicle's lifespan.", + "I can answer by investigating regional variations in emissions during the operational phase, comparing areas with different electricity generation profiles and fuel standards. This would involve analyzing how the environmental impact of electric vehicles changes in regions with renewable-heavy grids versus those reliant on fossil fuels, compared to gasoline vehicles operating under varying fuel quality regulations." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by examining the tailpipe emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, focusing on pollutants like carbon dioxide (CO" + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:02.837377", + "similarity_score": 0.8, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 71 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "b154e69a-205d-4619-aef8-3b32842c6544", + "ibfs_id": "b36dc164-729a-4369-b736-ee241067f93a", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles are more environmentally friendly, reducing emissions and pollution compared to gasoline vehicles, but mining impacts remain substantial.", + "final_answer": "A cradle-to-grave analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles involves examining the environmental impacts from the extraction of raw materials to the end of the vehicle's life. This analysis highlights significant differences in the material extraction processes for each type of vehicle, particularly focusing on the extraction of lithium and cobalt for EV batteries versus oil extraction for gasoline.\n\n**Material Extraction for Electric Vehicles:**\n\n1. **Lithium Mining:**\n - **Environmental Impact:** Lithium is primarily extracted from brine pools in regions like the Atacama Desert in Chile, or from hard rock mining in Australia. The extraction process involves pumping groundwater to the surface, where it evaporates, leaving lithium behind. This process can lead to significant water depletion in arid regions, affecting local ecosystems and communities.\n - **Ecological Footprint:** The evaporation process can take up to 500,000 gallons of water per ton of lithium extracted. This can disrupt local water supplies and harm biodiversity in these sensitive environments.\n\n2. **Cobalt Mining:**\n - **Environmental Impact:** Cobalt is often mined as a byproduct of nickel and copper mining, with significant production in the Democratic Republic of Congo. The mining process can lead to deforestation, soil erosion, and contamination of water sources with heavy metals.\n - **Ecological Footprint:** Cobalt mining is associated with both environmental and social issues, including habitat destruction and human rights concerns due to artisanal mining practices.\n\n**Material Extraction for Gasoline Vehicles:**\n\n1. **Oil Extraction:**\n - **Environmental Impact:** Oil extraction involves drilling into the earth to access crude oil reserves. This process can lead to oil spills, which have devastating effects on marine and terrestrial ecosystems. Additionally, the infrastructure required for extraction, such as drilling rigs and pipelines, can disrupt habitats.\n - **Ecological Footprint:** Oil extraction and refining are energy-intensive processes that contribute significantly to greenhouse gas emissions. The risk of spills and leaks poses a constant threat to the environment, with long-lasting impacts on wildlife and water quality.\n\n**Comparative Analysis:**\n\n- **Resource Intensity:** Both EVs and gasoline vehicles require significant resource extraction, but the types of resources and their associated impacts differ. EVs rely heavily on lithium and cobalt, which have localized environmental impacts, particularly concerning water use and pollution. Gasoline vehicles depend on oil, which has broader implications due to greenhouse gas emissions and the potential for catastrophic spills.\n\n- **Global Warming Potential:** Over their lifetime, EVs generally have a lower global warming potential compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to the reduced emissions during the use phase. However, the initial environmental cost of battery production can be higher due to the energy-intensive mining and processing of lithium and cobalt.\n\n- **End-of-Life Considerations:** EV batteries pose challenges for recycling and disposal, though advancements in battery recycling technologies aim to mitigate these impacts. In contrast, gasoline vehicles have a more established recycling process for their components.\n\nIn conclusion, while both electric and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts associated with their material extraction processes, the nature and scale of these impacts differ. Electric vehicles present challenges related to water use and mining pollution, while gasoline vehicles contribute significantly to greenhouse gas emissions and pose risks of oil spills. Understanding these differences is crucial for developing strategies to minimize the ecological footprint of both vehicle types.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining all stages of each vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling\u2014and comparing their total environmental impacts in terms of greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution.", + "I can answer by focusing on a comparative cradle-to-grave analysis for both electric and gasoline vehicles, emphasizing the differences in material extraction processes. This sub-strategy would delve deeper into the specific environmental impacts associated with mining for lithium and cobalt for EV batteries versus oil extraction for gasoline, providing insights into their respective ecological footprints." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining all stages of each vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling\u2014and comparing their total environmental impacts in terms of greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution.", + "I can answer by analyzing the energy sources used for electricity generation in different regions, as the environmental impact of electric vehicles largely depends on whether the electricity comes from renewable sources (like wind and solar) or non-renewable sources (like coal and natural gas). In contrast, gasoline vehicles' impact is more consistent as it primarily depends on fossil fuel combustion. This approach would provide insights into regional differences in EV impacts.", + "I can answer by examining and comparing the raw materials used in the production of electric and gasoline vehicles, focusing specifically on the extraction and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries versus the materials needed for internal combustion engines. This approach would highlight the environmental and social implications of mining and resource depletion.", + "I can answer by considering the long-term environmental benefits and drawbacks, including the potential for electric vehicles to contribute to urban air quality improvement and noise reduction, while also assessing the challenges related to battery recycling and disposal. This approach would provide a broader perspective on how these vehicles could shape future environmental conditions." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining all stages of each vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling\u2014and comparing their total environmental impacts in terms of greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a comparative cradle-to-grave analysis for both electric and gasoline vehicles, emphasizing the differences in material extraction processes. This sub-strategy would delve deeper into the specific environmental impacts associated with mining for lithium and cobalt for EV batteries versus oil extraction for gasoline, providing insights into their respective ecological footprints.", + "I can answer by performing a detailed usage phase comparison within the life cycle assessment, concentrating on energy consumption and emissions during the operational life of the vehicles. This approach would highlight how the source of electricity (renewable vs. non-renewable) for EVs and the efficiency of gasoline engines affect overall greenhouse gas emissions and air quality.", + "I can answer by emphasizing the end-of-life phase in the life cycle assessment, exploring the recycling and disposal processes of EV batteries versus gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would assess the environmental benefits and challenges of recycling battery materials and the potential pollution from landfilling or incinerating vehicle components.", + "I can answer by broadening the life cycle assessment to include the infrastructure needed for both vehicle types, such as the environmental impact of building and maintaining charging stations for EVs versus refineries and gas stations for gasoline vehicles. This approach would consider the long-term environmental implications of supporting infrastructure and its role in the overall environmental impact of each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on a comparative cradle-to-grave analysis for both electric and gasoline vehicles, emphasizing the differences in material extraction processes. This sub-strategy would delve deeper into the specific environmental impacts associated with mining for lithium and cobalt for EV batteries versus oil extraction for gasoline, providing insights into their respective ecological footprints." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:08.767145", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 70 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "3cf69da0-f1f8-49eb-9151-71ad9eff95b0", + "ibfs_id": "ed1296a7-8ab8-4a30-8738-5022449b3285", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and air pollution but involve mining impacts; still generally less harmful than gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can focus on the lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions, which encompass the carbon footprint from raw material extraction, production, operation, and disposal.\n\n1. **Raw Material Extraction:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The production of EVs involves significant emissions during the extraction and processing of raw materials, particularly for lithium-ion batteries. Mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel is energy-intensive and contributes to higher initial emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** The extraction of raw materials for gasoline vehicles primarily involves steel, aluminum, and other metals, which also have associated emissions. However, these are generally lower than those for EV battery materials.\n\n2. **Production:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** Manufacturing EVs, especially the battery, results in higher emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. The energy required to produce batteries is substantial, contributing to a larger carbon footprint at this stage.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** The production emissions for gasoline vehicles are lower than for EVs, as they do not require the complex battery systems that EVs do.\n\n3. **Operation (Fuel/Electricity Consumption):**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** During operation, EVs typically have lower emissions than gasoline vehicles, as they do not burn fossil fuels directly. The carbon footprint depends on the electricity source; renewable energy sources (like wind or solar) significantly reduce emissions, whereas coal-based electricity increases them.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases directly from the tailpipe during operation. The emissions are consistent and directly tied to fuel consumption, with no variation based on energy source.\n\n4. **Disposal:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose environmental challenges. However, advancements in recycling technologies are reducing the emissions associated with this stage. Proper recycling can mitigate some of the initial emissions from battery production.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Disposal emissions are generally lower than for EVs, as traditional vehicles do not have large battery systems. However, the recycling of metals and other components still contributes to emissions.\n\n**Overall Lifecycle Emissions:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** Despite higher emissions during production, EVs typically have a lower overall carbon footprint over their lifespan, especially when powered by clean electricity. As the grid becomes greener, the operational emissions of EVs continue to decrease.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles have higher operational emissions, which accumulate over time, leading to a larger carbon footprint compared to EVs, especially as the vehicle ages.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs start with a higher carbon footprint due to battery production, their lower operational emissions often result in a smaller overall carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles, particularly when charged with renewable energy. The lifecycle emissions advantage of EVs becomes more pronounced as the electricity grid becomes less reliant on fossil fuels.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's lifecycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal and recycling. I would compare factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and waste generation at each stage.", + "I can answer by evaluating the lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions specifically, focusing on the carbon footprint aspect of EVs and gasoline vehicles across their lifespan. This approach would involve comparing emissions from raw material extraction, production, operation (fuel/electricity consumption), and disposal, providing a focused perspective on the climate impact." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's lifecycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal and recycling. I would compare factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and waste generation at each stage.", + "I can answer by focusing on the energy source used for electric vehicles. This approach would analyze the environmental impacts based on the electricity generation mix in different regions (e.g., coal, natural gas, renewable sources). I would compare this with the emissions from gasoline vehicles to assess how the source of electricity influences the overall environmental impact of EVs.", + "I can answer by investigating the impact of electric and gasoline vehicles on specific environmental factors, such as air quality and noise pollution. This would involve looking at data and studies that measure emissions of pollutants like nitrogen oxides and particulates, as well as the noise levels produced by each vehicle type, and their effects on urban environments.", + "I can answer by considering the broader economic and social implications that influence environmental outcomes. This strategy would evaluate how the adoption of electric vehicles affects infrastructure development, changes in energy policies, and shifts in consumer behavior, and how these factors contribute to overall environmental impacts compared to traditional gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's lifecycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal and recycling. I would compare factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and waste generation at each stage." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the manufacturing stage of EVs and gasoline vehicles. This involves analyzing the environmental impacts associated with the production processes, energy consumption during manufacturing, and emissions generated from factories. By isolating this stage, I can identify key differences in environmental footprints related to vehicle assembly and production.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle analysis, which examines how the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles vary based on location. This would consider factors such as the electricity grid's energy mix, local resource availability, and regional recycling capabilities, providing insights into how geography influences the overall environmental impact.", + "I can answer by performing a comparative analysis of the recycling and disposal phases of EVs and gasoline vehicles. This entails evaluating the end-of-life processes, including recycling efficiency of batteries, disposal of hazardous materials, and waste management practices, to determine which vehicle type has a more sustainable end-of-life impact.", + "I can answer by evaluating the lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions specifically, focusing on the carbon footprint aspect of EVs and gasoline vehicles across their lifespan. This approach would involve comparing emissions from raw material extraction, production, operation (fuel/electricity consumption), and disposal, providing a focused perspective on the climate impact." + ], + "choice_idx": 3, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by evaluating the lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions specifically, focusing on the carbon footprint aspect of EVs and gasoline vehicles across their lifespan. This approach would involve comparing emissions from raw material extraction, production, operation (fuel/electricity consumption), and disposal, providing a focused perspective on the climate impact." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:10.953507", + "similarity_score": 0.7, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 72 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "6361c264-28b6-4f3e-a2f5-d6b1d68618a1", + "ibfs_id": "9fe712f7-6213-431b-a77b-688025c1a97f", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions overall, but battery production impacts resources; they're still environmentally preferable to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative lifecycle analysis focused on the carbon footprint of electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to evaluate the greenhouse gas emissions associated with each phase of the vehicles' lifecycle: manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life.\n\n### 1. Manufacturing Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** The production of lithium-ion batteries, which are essential for EVs, is energy-intensive and contributes significantly to the carbon footprint. The extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel are major contributors to emissions.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to traditional vehicles, the assembly of EVs involves emissions from the production of steel, aluminum, and other materials. However, the battery production adds a substantial additional carbon footprint.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Transmission Production:** The manufacturing of internal combustion engines and transmissions is less carbon-intensive than battery production but still contributes significantly to emissions.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to EVs, emissions result from the production of materials like steel and aluminum.\n\n**Comparison:** Overall, the manufacturing phase of EVs generally results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to battery production.\n\n### 2. Operation Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Electricity Use:** The carbon footprint during the operation of EVs depends on the electricity mix used to charge them. If the electricity comes from renewable sources, the emissions are minimal. However, if the grid relies heavily on coal or natural gas, emissions can be higher.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Combustion:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases directly through the combustion of fossil fuels. The emissions are consistent and significant over the vehicle's lifespan.\n\n**Comparison:** In the operation phase, EVs typically have a lower carbon footprint than gasoline vehicles, especially in regions with cleaner electricity grids. The efficiency of electric motors and the potential for renewable energy charging contribute to this advantage.\n\n### 3. End-of-Life Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The recycling of EV batteries can mitigate some of the emissions from the manufacturing phase. However, the recycling process itself can be energy-intensive and may contribute to emissions if not managed sustainably.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, the recycling of materials like steel and aluminum can reduce the overall carbon footprint.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** The recycling of materials is comparable to that of EVs, with emissions associated with the recycling process.\n\n**Comparison:** The end-of-life phase for both types of vehicles involves emissions from recycling processes. However, the potential for battery recycling in EVs can help offset some of the initial manufacturing emissions.\n\n### Overall Lifecycle Analysis\n\nWhen considering the entire lifecycle, EVs generally have a lower carbon footprint than gasoline vehicles, despite the higher emissions during manufacturing. The key factors are the reduced emissions during the operation phase and the potential for using renewable energy for charging. Over time, as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery production and recycling processes improve, the carbon footprint of EVs is expected to decrease further, enhancing their environmental benefits compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would detail emissions and resource use at each stage: manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life management, providing a holistic view of each vehicle type's environmental footprint.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis focused specifically on the carbon footprint of electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve calculating and comparing the total greenhouse gas emissions generated during the manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life phases for each vehicle type, thus providing a clear picture of their respective contributions to climate change." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would detail emissions and resource use at each stage: manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life management, providing a holistic view of each vehicle type's environmental footprint.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both vehicle types, specifically analyzing the emissions associated with the operation of EVs versus gasoline vehicles. This approach would evaluate emissions reductions from EVs when powered by different energy sources, such as coal-based electricity versus renewable energy, and compare them to the emissions from burning gasoline.", + "I can answer by examining the resource extraction and material sourcing needed for both types of vehicles. This strategy would involve assessing the environmental impacts of mining for lithium, cobalt, and other materials used in EV batteries compared to the extraction and refining of oil for gasoline, highlighting differences in land use, water consumption, and habitat disruption.", + "I can answer by investigating the regional variations in environmental impacts due to differences in energy grids and infrastructure. This approach would consider how the environmental benefits of EVs might vary in regions with cleaner electricity grids compared to those reliant on fossil fuels, and how local policies and infrastructure can influence these impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would detail emissions and resource use at each stage: manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life management, providing a holistic view of each vehicle type's environmental footprint." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis focused specifically on the carbon footprint of electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve calculating and comparing the total greenhouse gas emissions generated during the manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life phases for each vehicle type, thus providing a clear picture of their respective contributions to climate change.", + "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis that emphasizes the resource consumption differences between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would detail the extraction and use of raw materials, such as lithium for batteries in EVs and crude oil for gasoline vehicles, to understand how each type impacts natural resource depletion and ecosystem disruption.", + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that hones in on the water usage involved in the production and operation of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining water use in the manufacturing of components, such as batteries, and the refining processes for gasoline, providing insights into each vehicle type's impact on water resources.", + "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis with a focus on the air quality impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would assess the pollutants released at each stage of the vehicle lifecycle, particularly during operation, and evaluate how each vehicle type contributes to air pollution and related health effects, offering a comprehensive view of their environmental implications." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis focused specifically on the carbon footprint of electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve calculating and comparing the total greenhouse gas emissions generated during the manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life phases for each vehicle type, thus providing a clear picture of their respective contributions to climate change." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:12.598843", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 73 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "764b651f-9b5c-4979-ae87-c2c6b58feace", + "ibfs_id": "6881a9e0-80bf-4cc0-a85c-e23a35c85696", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce lower emissions and less pollution but require resource-intensive battery production, impacting the environment differently than gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a lifecycle analysis that examines emissions from the production, operation, and disposal phases of both types of vehicles.\n\n### 1. Production Phase\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Manufacturing**: The production of EVs, particularly the lithium-ion batteries, is energy-intensive. Mining for raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel involves significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and pollution. The manufacturing process itself requires substantial energy, often from non-renewable sources, leading to higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Vehicle Assembly**: Apart from the battery, the rest of the EV's manufacturing process is similar to that of gasoline vehicles, involving emissions from steel, aluminum, and plastic production.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Oil Refining and Vehicle Manufacturing**: The production of gasoline vehicles involves emissions from extracting and refining oil into gasoline. The vehicle assembly process is similar to that of EVs, with emissions from steel, aluminum, and plastic production. However, gasoline vehicles do not require the energy-intensive battery manufacturing process.\n\n### 2. Operation Phase\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Electricity Generation**: The operation of EVs involves electricity consumption, which can vary in environmental impact depending on the energy source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources (e.g., wind, solar), the emissions are minimal. However, if the electricity comes from coal or natural gas, the emissions are higher.\n- **Efficiency**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Fuel Combustion**: Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe during operation. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency**: Gasoline vehicles are less efficient than EVs, as a significant portion of the energy in gasoline is lost as heat.\n\n### 3. Disposal Phase\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Recycling**: The disposal of EVs involves challenges related to battery recycling. While recycling technologies are improving, the process can be energy-intensive and may release pollutants if not managed properly. However, recycling can recover valuable materials, reducing the need for new mining.\n- **Vehicle Disposal**: The rest of the vehicle can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, involving emissions from the recycling process.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **End-of-Life Recycling**: Gasoline vehicles are typically dismantled, and materials like steel and aluminum are recycled. This process also involves emissions but is generally well-established and less complex than battery recycling.\n\n### Overall Comparison\n\n- **Initial Emissions**: EVs tend to have higher emissions during the production phase due to battery manufacturing. However, this is often offset by lower emissions during the operation phase, especially if the electricity comes from low-carbon sources.\n- **Operational Emissions**: EVs generally produce fewer emissions during operation compared to gasoline vehicles, particularly if powered by renewable energy.\n- **End-of-Life**: Both types of vehicles have environmental impacts during disposal, but EVs face additional challenges with battery recycling.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles have higher initial emissions due to battery production, they typically result in lower overall emissions over their lifecycle compared to gasoline vehicles, especially when powered by clean electricity. The environmental benefits of EVs increase as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions aspect, comparing the greenhouse gases and pollutants emitted during the operation of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This would include examining tailpipe emissions for gasoline cars and the emissions from electricity production for electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis, which includes a detailed comparison of emissions from the production, operation, and disposal phases of both electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This approach would consider the emissions from manufacturing batteries for electric cars and refining oil for gasoline cars, providing a comprehensive view of their environmental impact." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves assessing the environmental impacts at every stage from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal or recycling, providing a comprehensive overview of their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions aspect, comparing the greenhouse gases and pollutants emitted during the operation of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This would include examining tailpipe emissions for gasoline cars and the emissions from electricity production for electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by reviewing existing scientific studies and reports that compare the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. By summarizing the findings and conclusions from these authoritative sources, I can provide an evidence-based perspective on the topic.", + "I can answer by evaluating the resource extraction and supply chain impacts associated with each vehicle type. This includes analyzing the mining of lithium, cobalt, and other materials for electric vehicle batteries compared to the oil extraction and refining processes needed for gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions aspect, comparing the greenhouse gases and pollutants emitted during the operation of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This would include examining tailpipe emissions for gasoline cars and the emissions from electricity production for electric vehicles." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis, which includes a detailed comparison of emissions from the production, operation, and disposal phases of both electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This approach would consider the emissions from manufacturing batteries for electric cars and refining oil for gasoline cars, providing a comprehensive view of their environmental impact.", + "I can answer by analyzing regional variations in emissions, focusing on how the source of electricity affects the emissions of electric vehicles in different areas. This would involve comparing emissions in regions that rely heavily on coal for electricity versus those using renewable energy sources, alongside the uniform emissions profile of gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring the emissions related to the supply chain and infrastructure required for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the emissions from building and maintaining charging stations versus gas stations, as well as the transportation and refining of oil compared to the extraction and processing of materials for batteries.", + "I can answer by evaluating the potential for emissions reduction through future technological advancements and policy changes. This would include examining how improvements in battery technology, grid decarbonization, and fuel efficiency standards could alter the emissions profiles of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles over time." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis, which includes a detailed comparison of emissions from the production, operation, and disposal phases of both electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This approach would consider the emissions from manufacturing batteries for electric cars and refining oil for gasoline cars, providing a comprehensive view of their environmental impact." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:12.911532", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 74 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "698a708b-17dc-482d-b33e-69557704b174", + "ibfs_id": "bc55417b-8d7b-415e-b96c-75b72f0f97e9", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but battery production impacts and resource extraction need sustainable solutions.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles during the raw material extraction phase, we need to consider the different materials and processes involved in each type of vehicle.\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n\n1. **Lithium Extraction:**\n - Lithium is a critical component of lithium-ion batteries used in EVs. It is primarily extracted from brine pools in South America (Chile, Argentina, Bolivia) and from hard rock mining in Australia.\n - The extraction from brine involves pumping lithium-rich brine to the surface and allowing it to evaporate, which can lead to significant water depletion in arid regions, affecting local water supplies and ecosystems.\n - Hard rock mining for lithium is energy-intensive and can result in habitat destruction and soil erosion.\n\n2. **Cobalt Mining:**\n - Cobalt is another essential material for EV batteries, with a significant portion sourced from the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC).\n - The mining process often involves artisanal and small-scale mining, which can lead to unsafe working conditions and child labor.\n - Environmental impacts include habitat destruction, soil and water contamination from mining waste, and significant carbon emissions from the energy-intensive extraction process.\n\n3. **Nickel Extraction:**\n - Nickel is used in many EV battery chemistries, and its extraction involves both open-pit and underground mining.\n - The process can lead to deforestation, soil erosion, and contamination of water bodies with heavy metals and sulfuric acid from tailings.\n - Nickel mining is energy-intensive, contributing to greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n\n1. **Crude Oil Extraction:**\n - The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling and pumping oil from underground reserves, often located in sensitive environments such as the Arctic, deep-sea regions, and rainforests.\n - Oil extraction can lead to habitat destruction, oil spills, and water contamination, significantly impacting marine and terrestrial ecosystems.\n - The process is energy-intensive, contributing to greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution.\n\n2. **Oil Refining:**\n - Once extracted, crude oil is refined into gasoline, a process that involves significant energy use and emissions of pollutants such as sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and volatile organic compounds.\n - Refineries can also contribute to localized air and water pollution, impacting human health and the environment.\n\n**Comparative Analysis:**\n\n- **Resource Intensity:** EVs require more diverse and often more environmentally impactful materials (lithium, cobalt, nickel) compared to the relatively straightforward extraction of crude oil for gasoline.\n- **Water Use:** Lithium extraction from brine is particularly water-intensive, impacting local water availability, whereas oil extraction can lead to water contamination.\n- **Carbon Emissions:** Both processes are energy-intensive, but the specific emissions depend on the energy sources used (e.g., fossil fuels vs. renewable energy).\n- **Social and Environmental Justice:** Cobalt mining raises significant ethical concerns due to labor practices and environmental degradation in the DRC, while oil extraction often affects indigenous and local communities.\n\nIn conclusion, the raw material extraction phase for EVs and gasoline vehicles presents distinct environmental challenges. EVs involve complex supply chains with significant impacts from mining critical battery materials, while gasoline vehicles primarily impact the environment through oil extraction and refining. Both require careful management to mitigate their environmental footprints.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the entire life cycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction to manufacturing, usage, and disposal, to evaluate their overall environmental impacts, including greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion.", + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the raw material extraction phase of the life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach delves into the environmental impacts associated with mining and processing the materials needed for batteries in EVs, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, compared to the extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the entire life cycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction to manufacturing, usage, and disposal, to evaluate their overall environmental impacts, including greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion.", + "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impact of emissions during the use phase of both vehicle types. This would involve comparing the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles with the emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs, taking into account the energy sources that power the electric grid in different regions.", + "I can answer by exploring the environmental implications of the supply chain for both EVs and gasoline vehicles. This includes analyzing the mining and processing of materials like lithium and cobalt for electric vehicle batteries, as well as the extraction and refinement of oil for gasoline production, to assess their respective ecological footprints.", + "I can answer by reviewing scientific literature and case studies on the topic. This approach would involve summarizing findings from existing research papers and reports that compare the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles, highlighting key insights and conclusions drawn by experts in the field." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the entire life cycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction to manufacturing, usage, and disposal, to evaluate their overall environmental impacts, including greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the raw material extraction phase of the life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach delves into the environmental impacts associated with mining and processing the materials needed for batteries in EVs, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, compared to the extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by concentrating on the manufacturing phase of the life cycle assessment, comparing the environmental impacts of producing electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This involves analyzing the energy consumption and emissions related to the production processes of electric motors and batteries, as well as traditional internal combustion engines and fuel systems.", + "I can answer by examining the usage phase of the life cycle assessment for both vehicle types. This approach emphasizes the differences in emissions and energy efficiency during the operational life of the vehicles, taking into account factors like the electricity grid's energy mix for EVs and fuel consumption rates for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by investigating the end-of-life and disposal phase of the life cycle assessment, evaluating the environmental impacts associated with recycling and disposing of electric vehicle batteries and gasoline vehicle components. This includes assessing the potential for resource recovery and the risks of environmental contamination from waste products." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing specifically on the raw material extraction phase of the life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach delves into the environmental impacts associated with mining and processing the materials needed for batteries in EVs, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, compared to the extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:17.584138", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 75 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "3f1b7fd2-16ba-49fd-9774-765234f4e39a", + "ibfs_id": "45b4c407-7558-4c9d-8b46-e2e3acab2456", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and noise pollution, but battery production and disposal pose environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a well-to-wheel life cycle assessment (LCA). This approach evaluates the entire energy supply chain from the production of energy sources to their consumption in vehicles, providing a comprehensive view of emissions and resource use.\n\n### Well-to-Wheel LCA Comparison\n\n#### 1. Energy Production\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n\n- **Electricity Generation:** The environmental impact of EVs largely depends on how the electricity used to charge them is generated. In regions where electricity comes from renewable sources (e.g., wind, solar, hydro), the emissions associated with EVs are significantly lower. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, the emissions can be higher.\n- **Grid Mix Variability:** The carbon intensity of the grid varies by location and time. For example, countries with a high percentage of renewables or nuclear energy have a lower carbon footprint for EVs.\n- **Transmission and Distribution Losses:** Approximately 5-10% of electricity is lost during transmission and distribution, which slightly increases the overall energy demand for EVs.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n\n- **Fuel Extraction and Refining:** The production of gasoline involves extracting crude oil, transporting it, and refining it into gasoline. This process is energy-intensive and results in significant greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.\n- **Distribution:** Transporting gasoline to fueling stations also contributes to emissions, though these are relatively minor compared to extraction and refining.\n\n#### 2. Vehicle Operation\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 85% of electrical energy into motion, compared to about 20-30% for internal combustion engines (ICEs).\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, which reduces local air pollution and improves urban air quality.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n\n- **Combustion Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter, and other pollutants during operation. These emissions contribute to climate change and air quality issues.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** The fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles varies widely, but even the most efficient models produce more emissions per mile than EVs powered by a clean grid.\n\n#### 3. Overall Emissions and Resource Use\n\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** On average, EVs have lower lifecycle GHG emissions than gasoline vehicles, especially when charged on a low-carbon grid. However, in areas with a coal-heavy grid, the benefits are reduced but still generally favorable.\n- **Resource Depletion:** The production of EV batteries requires significant amounts of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. While this raises concerns about resource depletion and mining impacts, advancements in battery recycling and alternative chemistries are addressing these issues.\n- **Lifecycle Impact:** Over their lifetime, EVs tend to have a smaller environmental footprint compared to gasoline vehicles, considering both direct emissions and the broader impacts of energy production.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe well-to-wheel LCA comparison shows that electric vehicles generally have a lower environmental impact than traditional gasoline vehicles, primarily due to their higher efficiency and the potential for low-emission electricity generation. The extent of these benefits depends on the energy mix used for electricity generation and ongoing improvements in battery technology and recycling. As the grid becomes cleaner and battery technologies advance, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to increase further.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to use and end-of-life. By analyzing factors such as emissions, resource consumption, and waste generation, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts of both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by conducting a well-to-wheel LCA comparison of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would emphasize the energy production and consumption aspects, examining how electricity generation for EVs and fuel production for gasoline vehicles contribute to overall emissions and resource depletion. This method would provide insight into the environmental impacts associated with powering each type of vehicle during their operational life." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to use and end-of-life. By analyzing factors such as emissions, resource consumption, and waste generation, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts of both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the use phase of the vehicles. This approach would compare the greenhouse gas emissions from the tailpipes of gasoline vehicles with the indirect emissions associated with the electricity generation required to power EVs. I can also explore how the grid's energy mix (renewable vs. fossil fuels) affects the environmental impact of EVs.", + "I can answer by examining the impact of resource extraction and battery production for electric vehicles. This would involve investigating the environmental consequences of mining for materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which are crucial for EV batteries, and comparing these impacts with those associated with oil extraction and refining for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by evaluating the potential for reducing environmental impacts through technological advancements and policy measures. This would include looking at improvements in EV battery technology, such as increased efficiency and recyclability, as well as the role of government incentives and regulations aimed at reducing emissions from both vehicle types. This strategy would help highlight future trends and possibilities for minimizing environmental impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to use and end-of-life. By analyzing factors such as emissions, resource consumption, and waste generation, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts of both vehicle types." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a cradle-to-gate life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would concentrate specifically on the environmental impacts associated with the raw material extraction, transportation, and manufacturing processes up to the point when the vehicle is ready to be distributed. By comparing these initial stages, I can highlight the differences in resource use and emissions before the vehicles even hit the road.", + "I can answer by conducting a well-to-wheel LCA comparison of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would emphasize the energy production and consumption aspects, examining how electricity generation for EVs and fuel production for gasoline vehicles contribute to overall emissions and resource depletion. This method would provide insight into the environmental impacts associated with powering each type of vehicle during their operational life.", + "I can answer by performing an end-of-life LCA comparison, which would examine the processes involved in the disposal and recycling of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This approach would analyze the environmental impacts of vehicle dismantling, material recovery, and waste management, highlighting the sustainability and potential benefits of recycling practices for both types of vehicles.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative LCA with a regional focus, analyzing how the environmental impacts of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles differ based on geographical location. This approach would consider variations in electricity grid composition, fuel sourcing, and regulatory frameworks to provide a region-specific assessment of environmental impacts, offering insights into how local conditions influence the sustainability of each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a well-to-wheel LCA comparison of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would emphasize the energy production and consumption aspects, examining how electricity generation for EVs and fuel production for gasoline vehicles contribute to overall emissions and resource depletion. This method would provide insight into the environmental impacts associated with powering each type of vehicle during their operational life." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:22.681974", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 76 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "b229da37-7972-4c02-9842-5906d50b9708", + "ibfs_id": "b663e8fe-8208-4915-ae77-758ac86835a2", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions, improve air quality, and have a smaller carbon footprint than gasoline vehicles, despite battery production concerns.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a life-cycle assessment (LCA) that considers emissions and energy consumption across several stages: manufacturing, operational use, and disposal.\n\n### 1. Manufacturing Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** The production of EV batteries, particularly lithium-ion batteries, is energy-intensive and results in significant emissions. Mining and processing raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel contribute to environmental degradation and carbon emissions.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** The assembly of EVs generally requires less energy than gasoline vehicles, as electric drivetrains are simpler. However, the overall manufacturing emissions are higher due to the battery.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Transmission Production:** Manufacturing internal combustion engines and transmissions involves complex processes and materials, leading to substantial energy use and emissions.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to EVs, the assembly of gasoline vehicles contributes to emissions, but the absence of large battery packs results in lower manufacturing emissions compared to EVs.\n\n### 2. Operational Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Source:** The environmental impact during the operational phase largely depends on the electricity source. EVs charged with renewable energy (solar, wind) have minimal emissions, while those charged with coal-based electricity have higher emissions.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Combustion:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and other pollutants directly through the combustion of fossil fuels.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Although improvements in fuel efficiency have been made, gasoline vehicles still emit significant greenhouse gases over their lifetime.\n\n### 3. Disposal Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal phase involves recycling or disposing of batteries, which can be environmentally challenging. Advances in recycling technologies are improving the recovery of valuable materials, but the process still has environmental impacts.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** The rest of the vehicle can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, with metals and other materials being reused.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **End-of-Life Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically dismantled, and materials such as steel, aluminum, and plastics are recycled. The absence of large batteries simplifies the recycling process compared to EVs.\n\n### Overall Environmental Impact\n\n- **Carbon Footprint:** Over their entire life cycle, EVs generally have a lower carbon footprint than gasoline vehicles, especially when charged with low-carbon electricity. The higher emissions from manufacturing are offset by lower operational emissions.\n- **Pollutants:** EVs produce fewer air pollutants during operation, contributing to better air quality, particularly in urban areas.\n- **Resource Use:** EVs require specific minerals for batteries, which can lead to environmental and social issues related to mining. However, ongoing improvements in battery technology and recycling can mitigate these impacts.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs have higher emissions during the manufacturing phase due to battery production, they offer significant environmental benefits during the operational phase, particularly when powered by renewable energy. The disposal phase presents challenges for both vehicle types, but advancements in recycling are helping to reduce impacts. Overall, EVs tend to have a more favorable environmental profile over their entire life cycle compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy consumption during the operational phase of each vehicle type. This would involve comparing the carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion versus the emissions from electricity generation required to charge electric vehicles, accounting for the energy mix of the grid.", + "I can answer by conducting a life-cycle assessment that examines emissions and energy consumption not only during the operational phase but also during the manufacturing and disposal phases of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This holistic approach would provide a more comprehensive understanding of overall environmental impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts during the entire lifespan of the vehicles, from manufacturing and operation to disposal. The LCA would consider factors such as raw material extraction, energy consumption, emissions during production, and end-of-life recycling.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy consumption during the operational phase of each vehicle type. This would involve comparing the carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion versus the emissions from electricity generation required to charge electric vehicles, accounting for the energy mix of the grid.", + "I can answer by examining the resource and material extraction impacts associated with each vehicle type. This would look into the mining and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and rare earth elements for electric vehicle batteries, compared to the oil extraction, refining, and transportation processes needed for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by evaluating the broader ecological and health impacts using a systems thinking approach. This includes not only direct emissions and resource use but also secondary effects such as habitat destruction from mining, pollution from manufacturing plants, and the impact of battery disposal. Additionally, I would consider the public health benefits from reduced air pollution in urban areas due to the use of electric vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy consumption during the operational phase of each vehicle type. This would involve comparing the carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion versus the emissions from electricity generation required to charge electric vehicles, accounting for the energy mix of the grid." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life-cycle assessment that examines emissions and energy consumption not only during the operational phase but also during the manufacturing and disposal phases of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This holistic approach would provide a more comprehensive understanding of overall environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by comparing the energy efficiency of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles during their operational phase. This would involve analyzing how much energy each vehicle type consumes to travel a certain distance and the associated emissions from this energy consumption, particularly focusing on the energy mix used in different regions.", + "I can answer by focusing on regional variations in the emissions and energy consumption of electric vehicles. This would involve evaluating how the local energy grid's composition (coal, nuclear, renewables, etc.) affects the emissions profile of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles in different geographic areas.", + "I can answer by examining the impact of technological advancements on emissions and energy consumption during the operational phase. This would involve analyzing how improvements in battery technology and fuel efficiency affect the environmental performance of electric versus gasoline vehicles over time, including potential future scenarios." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life-cycle assessment that examines emissions and energy consumption not only during the operational phase but also during the manufacturing and disposal phases of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This holistic approach would provide a more comprehensive understanding of overall environmental impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:25.060696", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 77 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "1c535ea5-74fc-4285-ab1e-968f56bebe56", + "ibfs_id": "35b3eda4-b177-4866-8021-399c305cd3dd", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution but entail mining impacts; gasoline vehicles generate more CO2 and air pollution.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative analysis of the carbon footprints associated with the supply chains of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine several stages: raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, and transportation logistics. Each stage contributes differently to the overall carbon footprint of the vehicles.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs primarily rely on lithium-ion batteries, which require mining and refining of materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. The extraction and processing of these materials are energy-intensive and often involve significant greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. For instance, cobalt mining, primarily in the Democratic Republic of Congo, involves substantial energy use and environmental degradation.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also require copper for wiring and other components, which involves additional mining and refining activities.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction and refining of crude oil into gasoline is a major source of emissions. Oil drilling, transportation, and refining are energy-intensive processes that release significant amounts of CO2 and other pollutants.\n- **Vehicle Components:** Traditional vehicles require steel and aluminum for construction, which also involve mining and refining. However, the absence of large batteries reduces the need for certain minerals like lithium and cobalt.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Processes\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Manufacturing:** The production of lithium-ion batteries is one of the most carbon-intensive parts of EV manufacturing. It involves high energy consumption, often from fossil fuel sources, especially in regions where renewable energy is less prevalent.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** EVs generally have fewer moving parts than gasoline vehicles, which can reduce emissions during assembly. However, the energy used in battery production often offsets these savings.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Transmission Manufacturing:** The production of internal combustion engines and complex transmissions involves significant energy use and emissions. These components are more complex than electric drivetrains, leading to higher emissions during manufacturing.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** The overall assembly process for gasoline vehicles is similar in energy use to that of EVs, excluding the battery production.\n\n### 3. Transportation Logistics\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Transport:** The transportation of batteries, often across continents, adds to the carbon footprint. Batteries are heavy and require specialized handling, which can increase emissions.\n- **Vehicle Distribution:** The logistics of distributing EVs are similar to gasoline vehicles, though the weight of batteries can increase emissions during transportation.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Supply Chain:** The transportation of crude oil and refined gasoline involves a complex global supply chain, contributing to emissions. Tanker ships, pipelines, and trucks all play a role in delivering fuel to end-users.\n- **Vehicle Distribution:** Similar to EVs, the distribution of gasoline vehicles involves emissions from logistics operations.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles tend to have a higher carbon footprint during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages, primarily due to battery production. However, they benefit from lower emissions during the vehicle's operational phase due to the absence of tailpipe emissions. Gasoline vehicles, on the other hand, have a more balanced distribution of emissions across their lifecycle, with significant contributions from fuel production and consumption.\n\nOverall, while EVs may start with a higher carbon footprint due to their supply chain, they can offset this through cleaner operation, especially when charged with renewable energy. The net environmental impact depends on various factors, including the energy mix used in battery production and vehicle operation.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by comparing the lifecycle emissions of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles, which involves analyzing the environmental impact from manufacturing to disposal. This would include the extraction of raw materials, production processes, the electricity generation for EVs, and the fuel production and consumption for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the carbon footprints associated with the supply chains of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the emissions from the mining and refining of raw materials, manufacturing processes, and transportation logistics for both vehicle types." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by comparing the lifecycle emissions of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles, which involves analyzing the environmental impact from manufacturing to disposal. This would include the extraction of raw materials, production processes, the electricity generation for EVs, and the fuel production and consumption for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining the differences in air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during the operation of both types of vehicles. This approach focuses on tailpipe emissions for gasoline vehicles versus the emissions from power plants that generate electricity for charging electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by investigating the impact of battery production and disposal in electric vehicles compared to the environmental costs associated with oil extraction and refinement for gasoline vehicles. This strategy will explore the resource extraction and waste management challenges unique to each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by evaluating the potential for renewable energy integration with electric vehicles versus improvements in fuel efficiency and alternative fuels for gasoline vehicles. This involves exploring future scenarios where EVs are charged using renewable energy sources and comparing that to advancements in gasoline vehicle technology that aim to reduce environmental impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by comparing the lifecycle emissions of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles, which involves analyzing the environmental impact from manufacturing to disposal. This would include the extraction of raw materials, production processes, the electricity generation for EVs, and the fuel production and consumption for gasoline vehicles." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the carbon footprints associated with the supply chains of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the emissions from the mining and refining of raw materials, manufacturing processes, and transportation logistics for both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by performing a regional case study analysis, comparing the lifecycle emissions of electric and gasoline vehicles in different geographical locations. This would consider regional variations in electricity generation sources for EVs, local emissions standards, and the availability of raw materials.", + "I can answer by evaluating the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes for electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would focus on the environmental impacts of recycling batteries in EVs versus the disposal of traditional vehicle components, assessing how these processes contribute to overall emissions.", + "I can answer by modeling the potential emissions reduction scenarios over the lifespan of electric and gasoline vehicles. This would involve simulating different scenarios of vehicle usage patterns, including urban versus rural driving, varying electricity grid mixes, and advancements in battery technology to predict future environmental impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the carbon footprints associated with the supply chains of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the emissions from the mining and refining of raw materials, manufacturing processes, and transportation logistics for both vehicle types." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:38.310506", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 79 + }, + { + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c0ec38cd-64d2-4d5b-9bbe-b07d7ecf7117", + "ibfs_id": "8ee85a92-4e7b-4e57-877c-0472cd70d4e2", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, are energy-efficient, but battery production impacts remain concerning compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through the lens of electric vehicle infrastructure, we need to focus on how the increased demand for electricity from EV charging stations affects energy grids and local ecosystems.\n\n**Impact on Energy Grids:**\n\n1. **Increased Demand for Electricity:**\n - As the number of EVs increases, so does the demand for electricity to power these vehicles. This can lead to a significant rise in overall electricity consumption.\n - If the charging demand peaks at certain times, such as during the evening when people return home from work, it can strain the existing grid infrastructure. This may necessitate upgrades to transmission lines, transformers, and other grid components to handle the increased load.\n\n2. **Changes in Energy Production Methods:**\n - To meet the increased electricity demand from EVs, utilities may need to adjust their energy production strategies. This could involve ramping up production from existing power plants or investing in new capacity.\n - If the additional electricity demand is met by fossil fuel-based power plants, such as coal or natural gas, it could negate some of the emissions benefits of switching from gasoline to electric vehicles. However, if the demand is met by renewable energy sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the environmental impact is significantly reduced.\n\n3. **Grid Modernization and Smart Grids:**\n - The integration of smart grid technologies can help manage the increased demand more efficiently. Smart grids can optimize electricity distribution and reduce peak loads through demand response programs, where EV charging is scheduled during off-peak hours.\n - Investment in energy storage solutions, such as batteries, can also help balance supply and demand, storing excess renewable energy generated during low-demand periods for use during high-demand times.\n\n**Impact on Local Ecosystems:**\n\n1. **Construction of Charging Infrastructure:**\n - The development of EV charging stations requires land and resources, which can impact local ecosystems. This includes the physical footprint of charging stations and any associated infrastructure, such as roads or parking lots.\n - Careful planning and site selection can mitigate these impacts by avoiding ecologically sensitive areas and minimizing habitat disruption.\n\n2. **Potential for Renewable Energy Integration:**\n - Charging stations powered by renewable energy sources, such as solar panels, can reduce the ecological footprint of EV infrastructure. This integration can help preserve local ecosystems by reducing reliance on fossil fuels and lowering emissions.\n\n3. **Localized Environmental Effects:**\n - In areas where the grid is heavily reliant on fossil fuels, increased electricity demand from EVs could lead to more localized pollution from power plants, affecting air quality and local ecosystems.\n - Conversely, in regions with a high penetration of renewables, the shift to EVs can lead to cleaner air and reduced ecological disturbance.\n\nIn summary, while the transition to electric vehicles presents challenges in terms of increased electricity demand and potential impacts on local ecosystems, it also offers opportunities for cleaner energy production and infrastructure development. The environmental impact largely depends on how the electricity is generated and the strategies employed to integrate EV infrastructure into the existing grid. By prioritizing renewable energy sources and smart grid technologies, the negative impacts can be minimized, leading to a more sustainable transportation system.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by exploring the impact on infrastructure and ecosystems. I would analyze how the shift to electric vehicles affects the development of charging infrastructure, changes in land use, and potential effects on ecosystems compared to the infrastructure needed for gasoline vehicles, such as gas stations and oil refineries.", + "I can answer by assessing the impact of electric vehicle infrastructure on energy grids and local ecosystems, specifically examining how increased demand for electricity from charging stations might lead to changes in energy production methods and potential effects on nearby natural habitats." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles, which would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, through manufacturing and use, to disposal. This comprehensive approach would highlight differences in resource use, emissions, and waste generation.", + "I can answer by focusing on emissions and air quality impact specifically. I would compare the greenhouse gas emissions and pollutants released during the operation of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This would include an assessment of emissions from electricity generation for EVs and tailpipe emissions from gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by considering the broader energy and resource consumption implications. This would involve evaluating the demand on natural resources such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel for electric vehicle batteries, compared to the petroleum consumption for gasoline vehicles. This approach would discuss the sustainability and geopolitical implications of resource extraction and use.", + "I can answer by exploring the impact on infrastructure and ecosystems. I would analyze how the shift to electric vehicles affects the development of charging infrastructure, changes in land use, and potential effects on ecosystems compared to the infrastructure needed for gasoline vehicles, such as gas stations and oil refineries." + ], + "choice_idx": 3, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by exploring the impact on infrastructure and ecosystems. I would analyze how the shift to electric vehicles affects the development of charging infrastructure, changes in land use, and potential effects on ecosystems compared to the infrastructure needed for gasoline vehicles, such as gas stations and oil refineries." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the spatial footprint required for electric vehicle charging stations versus traditional gasoline stations, including the land and resources needed for construction and maintenance, and examining how these differences might affect local ecosystems and urban development.", + "I can answer by investigating the environmental impact of the supply chain for electric vehicle infrastructure, focusing on the production, transportation, and disposal of materials used in electric charging stations compared to those used in gasoline station construction and maintenance.", + "I can answer by assessing the impact of electric vehicle infrastructure on energy grids and local ecosystems, specifically examining how increased demand for electricity from charging stations might lead to changes in energy production methods and potential effects on nearby natural habitats.", + "I can answer by exploring the long-term ecological benefits and challenges associated with the decommissioning of gasoline-related infrastructure versus the establishment of electric vehicle infrastructure, looking at changes in land restoration opportunities, pollution reduction, and biodiversity recovery." + ], + "choice_idx": 2, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by assessing the impact of electric vehicle infrastructure on energy grids and local ecosystems, specifically examining how increased demand for electricity from charging stations might lead to changes in energy production methods and potential effects on nearby natural habitats." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:45.241706", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 78 + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_config.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_config.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3bae89ba5dc505e83cfd8942f183b83e66fd134a --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_config.json @@ -0,0 +1,23 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "queries": [ + "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?" + ], + "diversity_levels": [ + "low", + "medium" + ], + "branching_factors": [ + 2, + 4 + ], + "max_depths": [ + 1, + 2 + ], + "epsilon_values": [ + 0.2 + ], + "repetitions": 10, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:27.301057" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_0.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_0.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..975358dc175a4c4a8cefe3571e2c9e3cf190c936 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_0.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "a00f9058-2cf5-4e3b-9c12-434c54c8db3a", + "ibfs_id": "80f9f3ed-49da-4e30-807e-6ea515abe5a9", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and reliance on fossil fuels but require energy-intensive battery production, impacting environmental sustainability.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative lifecycle analysis of the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine several stages: production, operation, and end-of-life disposal. Each stage has distinct environmental implications for both types of vehicles.\n\n### 1. Production\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Production**: The production of EVs, particularly the lithium-ion batteries, is resource-intensive. Key materials include lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. Mining and processing these materials can have significant environmental impacts, such as habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Manufacturing Emissions**: EVs generally require more energy to produce than gasoline vehicles, primarily due to the battery. This results in higher initial carbon emissions during manufacturing.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Oil Extraction and Refining**: The production of gasoline vehicles involves the extraction and refining of oil, which can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and significant greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing**: The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is less energy-intensive compared to EVs, resulting in lower initial carbon emissions.\n\n### 2. Operation\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Energy Source**: The environmental impact during the operation of EVs largely depends on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the operational emissions are minimal. However, if it comes from coal or natural gas, the emissions can be significant.\n- **Efficiency**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Fuel Combustion**: Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants during operation. The emissions are directly related to fuel consumption and are a major source of urban air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Efficiency**: Internal combustion engines are less efficient than electric motors, leading to higher energy consumption and emissions per mile driven.\n\n### 3. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Recycling**: The disposal of EV batteries poses environmental challenges. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable materials like lithium and cobalt. Proper recycling can mitigate some environmental impacts.\n- **Vehicle Recycling**: The rest of the vehicle can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, with metals and other materials being reused.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Vehicle Recycling**: Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle, as they do not have large batteries. The metals and other materials can be efficiently recovered and reused.\n- **Waste Oil**: Used oil and other fluids need to be disposed of properly to prevent environmental contamination.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles have a higher environmental impact during the production phase due to battery manufacturing. However, they offer significant benefits during the operation phase, especially if powered by renewable energy, due to their higher efficiency and lower emissions. The end-of-life disposal of EVs, particularly battery recycling, presents challenges but also opportunities for material recovery. Gasoline vehicles have lower initial production emissions but contribute significantly to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation. Their end-of-life disposal is more straightforward but still requires careful handling of waste fluids. Overall, the environmental benefits of EVs become more pronounced as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies advance.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles from production through disposal. This would include analyzing the emissions produced during manufacturing, the resources used (such as lithium for batteries in electric vehicles versus oil for gasoline vehicles), the energy consumption during operation, and the end-of-life recycling or disposal processes. This comprehensive approach would provide a detailed picture of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles from production through disposal. This would include analyzing the emissions produced during manufacturing, the resources used (such as lithium for batteries in electric vehicles versus oil for gasoline vehicles), the energy consumption during operation, and the end-of-life recycling or disposal processes. This comprehensive approach would provide a detailed picture of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both vehicle types, specifically analyzing the emissions during usage and the source of the energy (electricity versus gasoline). I would look into how the electricity for electric vehicles is generated (renewable sources versus fossil fuels) and compare it to the emissions from burning gasoline. This approach highlights the differences in carbon emissions and pollution during the actual use of the vehicles, offering insight into their environmental impact while they are being driven." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles from production through disposal. This would include analyzing the emissions produced during manufacturing, the resources used (such as lithium for batteries in electric vehicles versus oil for gasoline vehicles), the energy consumption during operation, and the end-of-life recycling or disposal processes. This comprehensive approach would provide a detailed picture of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:52.591843", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 0 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_1.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_1.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fa767ffe427f7bbd406a6406f88d8d7c3e23a7af --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_1.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "46d99c5a-7575-42c7-a908-2e6c04ca7d80", + "ibfs_id": "9c4f5dbc-73c9-477c-8104-55130a0b0401", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution over their lifecycle, despite requiring resource-intensive production compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative analysis of the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine the entire lifecycle of both types of vehicles. This includes the production, operation, and disposal phases.\n\n### Production Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Raw Material Extraction:** The production of EVs, particularly their batteries, requires significant amounts of raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. The extraction and processing of these materials can have substantial environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Manufacturing:** The manufacturing process for EVs generally requires more energy compared to gasoline vehicles due to the complexity and energy-intensity of battery production. However, advancements in technology and recycling processes are helping to reduce these impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Raw Material Extraction:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and other materials, which also involve mining and processing. However, the environmental impact is generally lower than that of battery production for EVs.\n- **Manufacturing:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is well-established and typically less energy-intensive than that for EVs, primarily because it does not involve battery production.\n\n### Operation Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Electricity Generation:** The environmental impact of operating EVs largely depends on the source of electricity used for charging. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind or solar, the emissions are minimal. However, if the electricity is generated from coal or natural gas, the emissions can be significant.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Combustion:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter, and other pollutants during fuel combustion. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Efficiency:** Internal combustion engines are less efficient than electric motors, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n\n### Disposal Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Disposal/Recycling:** The disposal of EV batteries poses environmental challenges due to the toxic materials they contain. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable materials and reducing environmental harm.\n- **Vehicle Disposal:** The rest of the EV can be recycled similarly to traditional vehicles, but the focus remains on improving battery recycling.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Vehicle Disposal:** Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle, as they do not contain large batteries. However, the disposal of engine fluids and other hazardous materials must be managed carefully.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, both electric and gasoline vehicles have distinct environmental impacts across their lifecycles. Electric vehicles tend to have higher environmental impacts during the production phase due to battery manufacturing but offer significant advantages during the operation phase, especially when charged with renewable energy. Gasoline vehicles have lower production impacts but contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation. The disposal phase presents challenges for both types, with a particular focus on battery recycling for EVs. Overall, the shift towards renewable energy sources and improved recycling technologies can enhance the environmental benefits of electric vehicles over their lifecycle.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the entire lifecycle of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve looking at the environmental impacts from production, operation, and disposal phases. For electric vehicles, I would consider the extraction and processing of raw materials for batteries, the electricity sources used for charging, and battery disposal or recycling. For gasoline vehicles, I would focus on the extraction, refining, and combustion of fossil fuels. This comprehensive lifecycle assessment would provide a broad view of the environmental impacts across different stages." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the entire lifecycle of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve looking at the environmental impacts from production, operation, and disposal phases. For electric vehicles, I would consider the extraction and processing of raw materials for batteries, the electricity sources used for charging, and battery disposal or recycling. For gasoline vehicles, I would focus on the extraction, refining, and combustion of fossil fuels. This comprehensive lifecycle assessment would provide a broad view of the environmental impacts across different stages.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational emissions of electric versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would analyze the emissions produced during the use phase of the vehicles. For electric vehicles, I would examine the emissions related to electricity generation based on different energy mixes (renewable versus non-renewable sources). For gasoline vehicles, I would discuss the direct emissions from burning gasoline. This strategy allows for an evaluation of the immediate environmental impacts related to vehicle use and highlights the differences in carbon footprints during their operation." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the entire lifecycle of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve looking at the environmental impacts from production, operation, and disposal phases. For electric vehicles, I would consider the extraction and processing of raw materials for batteries, the electricity sources used for charging, and battery disposal or recycling. For gasoline vehicles, I would focus on the extraction, refining, and combustion of fossil fuels. This comprehensive lifecycle assessment would provide a broad view of the environmental impacts across different stages." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:50.671724", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 1 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_10.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_10.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..255322c85f27425c100027389593ff5505155dd9 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_10.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c5d4f863-7530-4534-a9ee-640fc803cf2d", + "ibfs_id": "76036b0c-d83c-434c-8715-b7e107d106b0", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles greatly reduce emissions during operation but entail environmental concerns from battery production and electricity generation impacts.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles using a regional lifecycle assessment, we need to consider several factors that vary by location, including the energy grid composition, resource availability, and recycling capabilities. This analysis will focus on three distinct regions: a coal-heavy grid, a renewable-heavy grid, and a region with moderate renewable integration.\n\n### Region 1: Coal-Heavy Grid (e.g., parts of the Midwest, USA)\n\n**Energy Production:**\n- **Electric Vehicles (EVs):** In regions where the electricity grid is predominantly powered by coal, the environmental benefits of EVs are reduced. The high carbon emissions associated with coal-fired power plants mean that charging EVs can result in significant greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, potentially offsetting the benefits of zero tailpipe emissions.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles emit GHGs directly through combustion. In a coal-heavy region, the lifecycle emissions of gasoline vehicles might be comparable to or even lower than those of EVs, depending on the specific grid mix.\n\n**Resource Availability and Recycling:**\n- **EVs:** The production of EV batteries requires significant mineral resources, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel. If the region lacks robust recycling facilities, the environmental impact of mining and processing these materials can be substantial.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The extraction and refining of oil also have environmental impacts, but these are more established processes with existing infrastructure.\n\n### Region 2: Renewable-Heavy Grid (e.g., parts of Scandinavia)\n\n**Energy Production:**\n- **Electric Vehicles (EVs):** In regions where the grid is powered largely by renewables like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, EVs have a clear environmental advantage. The low-carbon electricity significantly reduces the lifecycle GHG emissions of EVs, making them a much cleaner option compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** Despite improvements in fuel efficiency, gasoline vehicles continue to emit GHGs and other pollutants directly, making them less environmentally friendly in regions with clean energy grids.\n\n**Resource Availability and Recycling:**\n- **EVs:** Regions with advanced recycling technologies can mitigate the environmental impact of battery production by recovering valuable materials, reducing the need for new mining operations.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The environmental impact remains relatively constant, as the primary emissions are from fuel combustion.\n\n### Region 3: Moderate Renewable Integration (e.g., parts of California, USA)\n\n**Energy Production:**\n- **Electric Vehicles (EVs):** In regions with a balanced mix of renewables and fossil fuels, the environmental impact of EVs is moderate. The cleaner the grid, the more beneficial EVs become in terms of reducing GHG emissions.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** While still emitting GHGs, the impact is less severe compared to a coal-heavy region but remains higher than EVs in a renewable-heavy region.\n\n**Resource Availability and Recycling:**\n- **EVs:** With moderate recycling capabilities, the region can partially offset the environmental impact of battery production by reusing materials.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The environmental impact is primarily dependent on fuel efficiency and emissions standards.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles vary significantly by region due to differences in energy grid composition and resource management capabilities. In regions with renewable-heavy grids, EVs offer substantial environmental benefits over gasoline vehicles. Conversely, in coal-heavy regions, the benefits of EVs are diminished, and their lifecycle emissions may be comparable to those of gasoline vehicles. Regions with moderate renewable integration see a mixed impact, with EVs generally offering a cleaner alternative, especially as grid decarbonization progresses. Additionally, local recycling capabilities play a crucial role in mitigating the environmental impacts associated with the production and disposal of EV batteries.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach will consider factors such as the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By evaluating the entire lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each vehicle type affects the environment in terms of carbon emissions, resource consumption, and pollution.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle assessment that takes into account the geographical variations in energy production and resource availability. This approach will analyze how the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles differ depending on the regional energy grid composition (e.g., coal-heavy versus renewable-heavy) and local recycling capabilities. By tailoring the lifecycle analysis to specific regions, I can provide insights into how location influences the environmental benefits or drawbacks of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach will consider factors such as the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By evaluating the entire lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each vehicle type affects the environment in terms of carbon emissions, resource consumption, and pollution.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase and analyzing the direct emissions and energy consumption of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This strategy involves examining the emissions produced during vehicle use, particularly the greenhouse gases emitted from gasoline combustion compared to the emissions from electricity generation that powers EVs. Additionally, I will consider the energy efficiency of each vehicle type and how the energy source mix (renewables versus fossil fuels) influences the overall environmental impact during the operational phase." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach will consider factors such as the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By evaluating the entire lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each vehicle type affects the environment in terms of carbon emissions, resource consumption, and pollution." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a detailed cradle-to-grave analysis, which delves into each stage of the vehicle's life separately. This approach will start with the extraction of raw materials, move through the manufacturing and assembly processes, continue with the energy use and emissions during the vehicle's operational phase, and conclude with disposal or recycling processes. By breaking down each phase, I can identify specific areas where electric vehicles outperform or fall short compared to gasoline vehicles in terms of environmental impact.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle assessment that takes into account the geographical variations in energy production and resource availability. This approach will analyze how the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles differ depending on the regional energy grid composition (e.g., coal-heavy versus renewable-heavy) and local recycling capabilities. By tailoring the lifecycle analysis to specific regions, I can provide insights into how location influences the environmental benefits or drawbacks of each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle assessment that takes into account the geographical variations in energy production and resource availability. This approach will analyze how the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles differ depending on the regional energy grid composition (e.g., coal-heavy versus renewable-heavy) and local recycling capabilities. By tailoring the lifecycle analysis to specific regions, I can provide insights into how location influences the environmental benefits or drawbacks of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:15.022897", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 10 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_11.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_11.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c569046c059adc32f1c2cf5d56a47ac0bc61097c --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_11.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "66366a9f-3fdf-4ca1-ab83-5b1c43b1a4df", + "ibfs_id": "e44ba9ee-a410-4b94-9795-15927e74c9cc", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but battery production and disposal have environmental impacts compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through a stakeholder-focused lifecycle analysis, we will consider the perspectives of three main stakeholders: manufacturers, consumers, and policymakers. This analysis will cover the stages of material sourcing, production, use, and disposal.\n\n### Manufacturers\n\n**Material Sourcing:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** Manufacturers of EVs face significant environmental challenges in sourcing materials, particularly for batteries. The extraction of lithium, cobalt, and nickel can lead to habitat destruction, water pollution, and high carbon emissions. These impacts are critical for manufacturers to manage, as sustainable sourcing becomes a competitive advantage and a regulatory requirement.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The primary environmental concern is the extraction and refining of oil for fuel. While the materials for vehicle construction (steel, aluminum) are similar to EVs, the ongoing demand for oil has significant environmental impacts, including oil spills and greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n**Production:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** The production of EVs, especially battery manufacturing, is energy-intensive and can result in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. Manufacturers must invest in cleaner production technologies and renewable energy sources to mitigate these impacts.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** The production process is relatively mature and optimized, but still involves significant energy use and emissions. Manufacturers are pressured to improve efficiency and reduce emissions in line with environmental standards.\n\n### Consumers\n\n**Energy Consumption During Use:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** Consumers benefit from lower emissions during the use phase, as EVs produce no tailpipe emissions. The environmental impact largely depends on the electricity source; renewable energy significantly reduces the carbon footprint. Consumers are increasingly aware of this and may choose EVs based on the availability of clean energy.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles emit CO2 and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change. Consumers face increasing fuel costs and potential restrictions in urban areas due to emissions.\n\n**Cost and Maintenance:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** While EVs often have higher upfront costs, they generally have lower operating and maintenance costs due to fewer moving parts and the absence of oil changes. Consumers are attracted to these long-term savings and the environmental benefits.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** Typically cheaper upfront, but with higher fuel and maintenance costs over time. Consumers may prioritize short-term affordability over long-term environmental impact.\n\n### Policymakers\n\n**Regulatory and Environmental Impact:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** Policymakers are focused on promoting EV adoption to reduce urban air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. Incentives such as tax credits, rebates, and infrastructure investments (charging stations) are common strategies to encourage EV use.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** Policymakers are increasingly imposing stricter emissions standards and fuel efficiency requirements. There is a push for transitioning to cleaner alternatives to meet climate goals.\n\n**End-of-Life and Disposal:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** The disposal and recycling of batteries present significant environmental challenges. Policymakers are concerned with developing effective recycling programs and regulations to manage battery waste and recover valuable materials.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** End-of-life disposal involves recycling metals and managing hazardous materials like oil and coolants. While established, these processes still have environmental impacts that require oversight.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nFrom a stakeholder-focused lifecycle analysis, electric vehicles present both challenges and opportunities across their lifecycle stages. Manufacturers must address the environmental impacts of material sourcing and production, consumers benefit from lower emissions and operating costs, and policymakers see EVs as a critical component of reducing transportation-related emissions. Conversely, gasoline vehicles have a more established lifecycle with significant emissions during use, presenting ongoing environmental challenges for all stakeholders. This nuanced understanding highlights the importance of collaboration among stakeholders to maximize the environmental benefits of transitioning to electric vehicles.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which includes examining the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach will involve looking at the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By assessing these stages, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each type of vehicle affects the environment throughout its entire lifecycle.", + "I can answer by performing a stakeholder-focused lifecycle analysis, which considers the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles from the perspectives of various stakeholders such as manufacturers, consumers, and policymakers. This approach will involve evaluating how each stage of the vehicle lifecycle affects these stakeholders differently, including the sourcing of materials, energy consumption during vehicle use, and disposal practices. By addressing the concerns and priorities of each stakeholder group, I can deliver a nuanced understanding of the environmental implications for each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which includes examining the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach will involve looking at the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By assessing these stages, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each type of vehicle affects the environment throughout its entire lifecycle.", + "I can answer by investigating the specific environmental impacts of the energy sources used to power electric vehicles compared to the emissions from gasoline vehicles. This approach will focus on analyzing the carbon footprint and pollution associated with electricity generation (e.g., coal, natural gas, renewables) versus the emissions resulting directly from burning gasoline. Additionally, I can consider how regional energy grids and their reliance on different energy sources can influence the overall environmental benefits or drawbacks of using EVs in various locations." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which includes examining the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach will involve looking at the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By assessing these stages, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each type of vehicle affects the environment throughout its entire lifecycle." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle analysis, focusing on how geographic factors influence the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach will involve examining the variations in raw material availability, energy sources for manufacturing and charging, and local recycling infrastructure in different regions. By assessing these regional differences, I can provide insights into how the environmental impacts of vehicles may vary depending on where they are produced, operated, and disposed of.", + "I can answer by performing a stakeholder-focused lifecycle analysis, which considers the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles from the perspectives of various stakeholders such as manufacturers, consumers, and policymakers. This approach will involve evaluating how each stage of the vehicle lifecycle affects these stakeholders differently, including the sourcing of materials, energy consumption during vehicle use, and disposal practices. By addressing the concerns and priorities of each stakeholder group, I can deliver a nuanced understanding of the environmental implications for each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by performing a stakeholder-focused lifecycle analysis, which considers the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles from the perspectives of various stakeholders such as manufacturers, consumers, and policymakers. This approach will involve evaluating how each stage of the vehicle lifecycle affects these stakeholders differently, including the sourcing of materials, energy consumption during vehicle use, and disposal practices. By addressing the concerns and priorities of each stakeholder group, I can deliver a nuanced understanding of the environmental implications for each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:19.572955", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 11 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_12.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_12.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8d8e9cec40a06d06cd811480cfbaf8fda39db2f2 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_12.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "4eb26326-ee83-48c1-b059-98bb13ce5496", + "ibfs_id": "6910ba0c-178c-4a41-90cc-6c3c065eb400", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and reliance on fossil fuels but involve battery production and recycling challenges impacting the environment.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles during the production phase, we need to examine the sourcing and processing of raw materials, as well as the energy consumption and emissions associated with manufacturing each type of vehicle.\n\n### Electric Vehicles (EVs)\n\n#### Raw Materials and Production\n\n1. **Lithium-ion Batteries**: \n - **Lithium**: The production of lithium-ion batteries, which are crucial for EVs, requires significant amounts of lithium. Lithium is primarily extracted from brine pools or hard rock mining. Both methods have environmental impacts. Brine extraction, common in South America, involves pumping water into underground reservoirs to bring lithium to the surface, which can lead to water depletion and contamination. Hard rock mining, prevalent in Australia, involves more energy-intensive processes and can result in habitat destruction.\n - **Cobalt and Nickel**: These metals are also critical for battery production. Cobalt mining, often concentrated in the Democratic Republic of Congo, has been associated with severe environmental degradation, including soil and water pollution. Nickel mining can lead to deforestation and soil erosion.\n - **Graphite**: Used as an anode material, graphite mining can result in air and water pollution due to the release of fine particles and chemicals.\n\n2. **Energy Consumption and Emissions**:\n - The production of EV batteries is energy-intensive, often relying on electricity from fossil fuels, which contributes to greenhouse gas emissions. The carbon footprint of battery production can be significant, depending on the energy mix of the manufacturing location.\n - Manufacturing the rest of the EV (body, electronics, etc.) is similar to traditional vehicles in terms of energy use and emissions.\n\n### Traditional Gasoline Vehicles\n\n#### Raw Materials and Production\n\n1. **Steel and Aluminum**:\n - **Steel**: The production of steel, a primary material in gasoline vehicles, involves mining iron ore and using coal in blast furnaces. This process is energy-intensive and emits significant amounts of CO2. Steel production is one of the largest industrial sources of greenhouse gases.\n - **Aluminum**: Used for lighter vehicle components, aluminum production involves bauxite mining and electrolysis, which is also energy-intensive and can result in significant emissions and environmental degradation.\n\n2. **Plastics and Other Materials**:\n - Derived from petroleum, the production of plastics used in vehicles involves chemical processes that emit greenhouse gases and other pollutants.\n\n3. **Energy Consumption and Emissions**:\n - The overall energy consumption for manufacturing a gasoline vehicle is generally lower than that for an EV, primarily due to the absence of a large battery pack. However, the emissions from steel and aluminum production contribute significantly to the vehicle's initial carbon footprint.\n\n### Comparative Analysis\n\n- **Emissions**: The production of EVs, particularly the battery, tends to result in higher initial emissions compared to traditional gasoline vehicles. However, this is often offset over the vehicle's lifetime due to the lower emissions during operation.\n- **Resource Extraction**: EV production involves more intensive mining activities for battery materials, which can have localized environmental impacts. In contrast, gasoline vehicles rely more heavily on steel and aluminum, with significant emissions from their production processes.\n- **Energy Use**: The energy required for producing EVs is generally higher, largely due to battery manufacturing. The environmental impact of this energy use depends on the energy sources of the manufacturing region.\n\nIn conclusion, while the production phase of EVs has a higher environmental impact in terms of emissions and resource extraction compared to gasoline vehicles, the overall environmental benefits of EVs can become apparent when considering their entire lifecycle, including the operational phase.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts from the production, use, and disposal phases of both types of vehicles. I would look into the materials used in manufacturing, the energy sources for vehicle operation, and the recycling processes at the end of a vehicle's life. This analysis would provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of both vehicle types throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the production phase of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy involves a deep dive into the environmental impacts associated with sourcing and processing raw materials, such as lithium for EV batteries and steel for gasoline vehicles. By analyzing the energy consumption and emissions during the manufacturing process, I can provide insights into how the initial production stage contributes to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts from the production, use, and disposal phases of both types of vehicles. I would look into the materials used in manufacturing, the energy sources for vehicle operation, and the recycling processes at the end of a vehicle's life. This analysis would provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of both vehicle types throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by evaluating the emissions and pollution differences between electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would focus on the operational phase, analyzing the direct emissions produced by gasoline vehicles compared to the indirect emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs. I would consider factors such as the carbon intensity of the electricity grid, advancements in battery technology, and the potential for renewable energy integration, providing insights into how these factors influence the overall environmental impact of each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts from the production, use, and disposal phases of both types of vehicles. I would look into the materials used in manufacturing, the energy sources for vehicle operation, and the recycling processes at the end of a vehicle's life. This analysis would provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of both vehicle types throughout their entire lifecycles." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the production phase of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy involves a deep dive into the environmental impacts associated with sourcing and processing raw materials, such as lithium for EV batteries and steel for gasoline vehicles. By analyzing the energy consumption and emissions during the manufacturing process, I can provide insights into how the initial production stage contributes to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by emphasizing the use phase of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the differences in emissions and energy consumption when these vehicles are in operation. For EVs, I would explore how the source of electricity (renewable vs. non-renewable) impacts their environmental benefits, while for gasoline vehicles, I would assess the emissions from fuel combustion and their efficiency. This analysis would highlight how the operational phase contributes to the total environmental impact over the vehicles' lifetimes." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing specifically on the production phase of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy involves a deep dive into the environmental impacts associated with sourcing and processing raw materials, such as lithium for EV batteries and steel for gasoline vehicles. By analyzing the energy consumption and emissions during the manufacturing process, I can provide insights into how the initial production stage contributes to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:18.607942", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 12 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_13.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_13.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4013b90ff9e0558b8a299964abc9a8b642600ffe --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_13.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "41bd84ff-7932-4064-9d28-8263bd354890", + "ibfs_id": "6625dfcc-ed3b-496c-8cf5-fc06e1fd95de", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles generally reduce emissions long-term, but battery production has significant environmental impacts compared to gasoline vehicle manufacturing.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we must consider the entire life cycle of each vehicle type, focusing on the energy sources used at each stage. This includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Lithium Mining:** EVs rely heavily on lithium-ion batteries, which require the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other materials. Lithium is primarily extracted through mining or evaporation from brine pools, processes that can lead to significant environmental impacts. Mining can result in habitat destruction, water pollution, and high water usage, particularly in arid regions like the Atacama Desert in Chile.\n- **Cobalt and Nickel:** These materials are often mined in regions with less stringent environmental regulations, leading to deforestation, soil erosion, and pollution. Cobalt mining, particularly in the Democratic Republic of Congo, has raised concerns about human rights and environmental degradation.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Crude Oil Extraction:** The extraction of crude oil involves drilling, which can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and pollution. Offshore drilling poses risks to marine ecosystems, while onshore drilling can impact local wildlife and water resources. The refining process also generates significant emissions and waste.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in battery technology and manufacturing efficiency are gradually reducing this impact.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Traditional vehicles have a less energy-intensive manufacturing process compared to EVs, primarily due to the absence of large battery packs. However, the production of internal combustion engines and associated components still contributes to environmental pollution.\n\n### 3. Operation\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Electricity Generation:** The carbon footprint of operating an EV largely depends on the energy mix used to generate electricity. In regions where electricity is primarily generated from renewable sources (e.g., wind, solar, hydro), EVs have a significantly lower carbon footprint. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, the benefits are reduced but still generally favorable compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Combustion Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change. The efficiency of gasoline engines is lower than that of electric motors, leading to higher emissions per mile driven.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose environmental challenges. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, reducing the need for new mining.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like traditional vehicles, EVs can be recycled for their metal components, though the battery remains a key focus for environmental impact.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Traditional vehicles are generally recycled for their metal content, but the disposal of fluids and other components can lead to environmental issues if not managed properly.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, while electric vehicles have a higher environmental impact during the manufacturing phase due to battery production, they offer significant advantages during the operational phase, especially in regions with clean electricity grids. The reduction in tailpipe emissions and improved energy efficiency contribute to a lower overall carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. However, the environmental benefits of EVs are contingent on responsible sourcing of raw materials and advancements in battery recycling technologies.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the full life cycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would include assessing the environmental impacts during the manufacturing process, the source and type of energy used for operation (electricity vs. gasoline), and the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes. By evaluating each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by focusing on a detailed breakdown of the energy sources used throughout the life cycle of electric and gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the environmental impacts of extracting raw materials, especially the mining of lithium for electric vehicle batteries versus crude oil extraction for gasoline. Additionally, I would assess the carbon footprint of electricity generation for electric vehicles compared to gasoline combustion in traditional vehicles, considering regional variations in energy sources." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the full life cycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would include assessing the environmental impacts during the manufacturing process, the source and type of energy used for operation (electricity vs. gasoline), and the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes. By evaluating each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, specifically analyzing their emissions and energy efficiency during use. For electric vehicles, this would involve examining the carbon intensity of electricity grids in different regions, while for gasoline vehicles, it would involve assessing tailpipe emissions and fuel consumption. This approach would help highlight the differences in emissions and energy use once the vehicles are on the road." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the full life cycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would include assessing the environmental impacts during the manufacturing process, the source and type of energy used for operation (electricity vs. gasoline), and the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes. By evaluating each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprints of both vehicle types." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a detailed breakdown of the energy sources used throughout the life cycle of electric and gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the environmental impacts of extracting raw materials, especially the mining of lithium for electric vehicle batteries versus crude oil extraction for gasoline. Additionally, I would assess the carbon footprint of electricity generation for electric vehicles compared to gasoline combustion in traditional vehicles, considering regional variations in energy sources.", + "I can answer by conducting a sector-specific impact assessment, where I evaluate the environmental effects of electric and gasoline vehicles within different sectors, such as urban versus rural environments. In this approach, I would examine how the manufacturing, operational, and disposal stages of vehicles differently affect air quality, noise pollution, and waste management in these areas. This strategy would highlight how the environmental impacts vary based on the context in which the vehicles are used." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on a detailed breakdown of the energy sources used throughout the life cycle of electric and gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the environmental impacts of extracting raw materials, especially the mining of lithium for electric vehicle batteries versus crude oil extraction for gasoline. Additionally, I would assess the carbon footprint of electricity generation for electric vehicles compared to gasoline combustion in traditional vehicles, considering regional variations in energy sources." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:22.827542", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 13 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_14.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_14.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7291d321c05281064d29e56922a041b36d7d0ad9 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_14.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "7eef3907-d175-4235-a824-4a938c18414f", + "ibfs_id": "b51d7188-912e-4abc-b76d-785c40ba9cf5", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and dependence on fossil fuels but require resource-intensive battery production and electricity generation improvements.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a time-sensitive life-cycle analysis comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to consider several key factors that have evolved over time and will continue to change in the future. These factors include technological advancements, shifts in energy sources, and improvements in recycling methods. By analyzing historical data and projecting future trends, we can gain insights into how the sustainability of both vehicle types is likely to evolve.\n\n### Historical Context and Technological Advancements\n\n1. **Manufacturing and Materials:**\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Traditionally, gasoline vehicles have relied on internal combustion engines (ICEs) with a focus on improving fuel efficiency and reducing emissions through catalytic converters and better engine designs.\n - **Electric Vehicles:** Initially, EVs faced challenges with battery technology, particularly in terms of energy density and cost. However, over the past decade, there have been significant advancements in lithium-ion battery technology, leading to increased range, reduced costs, and improved energy efficiency.\n\n2. **Energy Sources:**\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** The environmental impact of gasoline vehicles is heavily influenced by the extraction, refining, and combustion of fossil fuels, which contribute to greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution.\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The environmental impact of EVs depends on the electricity mix used for charging. Historically, this mix included a significant proportion of coal and natural gas. However, there has been a shift towards renewable energy sources such as wind, solar, and hydroelectric power, reducing the carbon footprint of EVs over time.\n\n3. **Recycling and End-of-Life:**\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Recycling efforts have focused on metal recovery and reusing parts, but the environmental benefits are limited by the ongoing need for fossil fuels.\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The recycling of EV batteries is a critical area of development. Recent advancements in recycling technologies aim to recover valuable materials such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, reducing the need for new mining and minimizing environmental impacts.\n\n### Current Trends and Future Projections\n\n1. **Battery Technology:**\n - Continued improvements in battery technology are expected, with solid-state batteries and other innovations promising higher energy densities, faster charging, and longer lifespans. These advancements will reduce the environmental impact associated with battery production and disposal.\n\n2. **Energy Transition:**\n - The global energy transition towards renewables is expected to accelerate. As the grid becomes greener, the lifecycle emissions of EVs will decrease further, making them increasingly sustainable compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n3. **Recycling Innovations:**\n - Emerging recycling methods, such as direct recycling and closed-loop systems, are projected to enhance the recovery of battery materials, reducing the environmental footprint of EVs. These methods will also lower the demand for new raw materials, mitigating the environmental impacts of mining.\n\n### Comparative Environmental Impacts Over Time\n\n- **Short-Term (Next 5-10 Years):** In the short term, EVs are likely to continue benefiting from improvements in battery technology and a cleaner electricity grid. Gasoline vehicles will remain reliant on fossil fuels, with limited potential for significant environmental impact reduction.\n \n- **Medium-Term (10-20 Years):** As renewable energy becomes more dominant and recycling technologies mature, the environmental advantages of EVs will become more pronounced. Gasoline vehicles will face increasing regulatory pressures and potential obsolescence due to stricter emissions standards.\n\n- **Long-Term (20+ Years):** In the long term, EVs are expected to achieve near-zero lifecycle emissions as the grid becomes fully renewable and battery recycling reaches high efficiency. Gasoline vehicles, on the other hand, will likely be phased out or relegated to niche markets due to their unsustainable environmental impact.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOver the next few decades, electric vehicles are projected to become significantly more sustainable than traditional gasoline vehicles due to advancements in technology, shifts in energy sources, and improvements in recycling methods. While gasoline vehicles will continue to have a substantial environmental impact due to their reliance on fossil fuels, EVs will benefit from a cleaner energy grid and more efficient recycling processes, making them the more environmentally friendly option in the long run.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life-cycle analysis that examines the entire lifespan of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By evaluating each stage, I can provide a detailed comparison of the environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution.", + "I can answer by conducting a time-sensitive life-cycle analysis that evaluates how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles change over time. This would involve analyzing historical data on technological advancements, shifts in energy sources, and emerging recycling methods. By projecting future trends, I can compare the potential environmental impacts of both vehicle types over the next few decades, offering insights into their evolving sustainability." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life-cycle analysis that examines the entire lifespan of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By evaluating each stage, I can provide a detailed comparison of the environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution.", + "I can answer by focusing on specific environmental factors, such as greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, during the operation phase of the vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing emissions data and energy efficiency for both electric and gasoline vehicles, considering the source of electricity for electric vehicles, and discussing how regional variations in energy production can affect their environmental impact compared to gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life-cycle analysis that examines the entire lifespan of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By evaluating each stage, I can provide a detailed comparison of the environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a geographic-specific life-cycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles in different regions. By considering variations in electricity generation sources, local vehicle manufacturing practices, and regional recycling capabilities, I can provide a nuanced comparison that reflects the diverse environmental impacts unique to each geographic area.", + "I can answer by conducting a time-sensitive life-cycle analysis that evaluates how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles change over time. This would involve analyzing historical data on technological advancements, shifts in energy sources, and emerging recycling methods. By projecting future trends, I can compare the potential environmental impacts of both vehicle types over the next few decades, offering insights into their evolving sustainability." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a time-sensitive life-cycle analysis that evaluates how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles change over time. This would involve analyzing historical data on technological advancements, shifts in energy sources, and emerging recycling methods. By projecting future trends, I can compare the potential environmental impacts of both vehicle types over the next few decades, offering insights into their evolving sustainability." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:31.759457", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 14 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_15.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_15.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c7e81744ec3c7d6703229a0a2c62eb31b288d73e --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_15.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "5a2eab31-8be5-431f-bae7-6618ece85f34", + "ibfs_id": "f4866d16-c3e0-477b-9bd3-0ca8ef592a4d", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution over their lifecycle, but battery production creates significant environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative analysis of the environmental impacts of the manufacturing processes of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to focus on several key aspects: energy consumption, emissions, and waste generation during the production of their respective components, particularly batteries for EVs and engines for gasoline vehicles.\n\n### Energy Consumption\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- The manufacturing of EVs, particularly the battery production, is energy-intensive. Lithium-ion batteries, which are commonly used in EVs, require significant amounts of energy to extract and process raw materials like lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite.\n- The energy consumption for producing these batteries is substantial, often resulting in higher initial energy use compared to the manufacturing of internal combustion engines (ICEs) for gasoline vehicles.\n- However, advancements in battery technology and manufacturing processes are gradually reducing the energy intensity of battery production.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The production of traditional gasoline vehicles involves the manufacturing of internal combustion engines, which is less energy-intensive compared to the production of EV batteries.\n- The energy required to produce steel and aluminum for engine components is significant, but generally less than the energy required for battery production in EVs.\n\n### Emissions\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- The production of EV batteries is associated with higher greenhouse gas emissions compared to the production of gasoline engines. This is primarily due to the energy-intensive processes involved in mining and refining the raw materials.\n- Emissions from battery production can vary significantly depending on the energy sources used in the manufacturing process. For instance, if the electricity used comes from renewable sources, the emissions can be considerably lower.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The emissions from manufacturing gasoline vehicles are generally lower than those from EVs, primarily because engine production is less energy-intensive.\n- However, the overall emissions from gasoline vehicles during their lifecycle are higher due to the combustion of fossil fuels during operation, which is not a factor in the manufacturing phase but is relevant for the vehicle's total environmental impact.\n\n### Waste Generation\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- The production of EV batteries generates waste, including chemical byproducts and spent materials from mining operations.\n- Proper disposal and recycling of batteries are critical to minimizing waste and environmental harm. The development of efficient recycling processes is essential to manage the waste associated with EV battery production.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The manufacturing of gasoline engines produces waste in the form of metal shavings, used lubricants, and other byproducts of metalworking processes.\n- The waste generated is generally less hazardous compared to the chemical waste from battery production, but it still requires proper management and disposal.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, the manufacturing phase of electric vehicles, particularly the production of lithium-ion batteries, is more energy-intensive and generates higher emissions compared to the production of traditional gasoline engines. However, the environmental impact of EVs can be mitigated by using cleaner energy sources for manufacturing and improving battery recycling processes. On the other hand, while gasoline vehicle production has a lower environmental impact during manufacturing, the overall lifecycle emissions from these vehicles are higher due to fuel combustion. As battery technology improves and manufacturing processes become more efficient, the environmental footprint of EV production is expected to decrease, potentially making them a more sustainable option in the long term.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the entire lifecycle of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include evaluating the environmental impacts of raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By considering the full lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each type of vehicle affects the environment across its lifespan.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that focuses specifically on the environmental impacts of the manufacturing processes of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include a detailed examination of the energy consumption, emissions, and waste generation associated with the production of components like batteries for EVs and engines for gasoline vehicles. By concentrating on the manufacturing phase, I can provide insights into how the production of each type of vehicle contributes to its overall environmental footprint." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the entire lifecycle of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include evaluating the environmental impacts of raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By considering the full lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each type of vehicle affects the environment across its lifespan.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, specifically analyzing emissions and energy consumption during use. This approach would involve comparing the carbon footprint and pollutant emissions of electric vehicles, which rely on electricity (potentially from renewable sources), to the emissions produced by burning gasoline in traditional vehicles. This strategy highlights the immediate environmental benefits of reduced emissions from using electric vehicles on the road." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that examines the entire lifecycle of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include evaluating the environmental impacts of raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By considering the full lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each type of vehicle affects the environment across its lifespan." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that focuses specifically on the environmental impacts of the manufacturing processes of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include a detailed examination of the energy consumption, emissions, and waste generation associated with the production of components like batteries for EVs and engines for gasoline vehicles. By concentrating on the manufacturing phase, I can provide insights into how the production of each type of vehicle contributes to its overall environmental footprint.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that emphasizes the environmental impacts during the operational phase of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the emissions produced during vehicle operation, the energy sources and efficiency of EVs compared to gasoline consumption, and the long-term effects of these factors on air quality and climate change. By focusing on the use phase, I can illuminate how the day-to-day operation of each vehicle type affects the environment." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis that focuses specifically on the environmental impacts of the manufacturing processes of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include a detailed examination of the energy consumption, emissions, and waste generation associated with the production of components like batteries for EVs and engines for gasoline vehicles. By concentrating on the manufacturing phase, I can provide insights into how the production of each type of vehicle contributes to its overall environmental footprint." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:28.585785", + "similarity_score": 0.7, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 15 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_16.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_16.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..29035c83b2da066b4e19315f9ce7b29d7c2489d1 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_16.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c841f652-3ae8-482c-8ce8-cd564687f2df", + "ibfs_id": "3d4dce46-0dab-43ff-8dcb-c49d4f0b42b7", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and fossil fuel dependency but involve significant resource use and pollution during battery production and disposal.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through a lifecycle analysis focusing on resource consumption and material sustainability, we need to examine several key stages: raw material extraction, production, usage, and end-of-life management.\n\n### Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n1. **Batteries:** EVs primarily rely on lithium-ion batteries, which require significant amounts of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and manganese. These materials are often sourced from regions with limited environmental regulations, leading to concerns about ecological damage and human rights issues. For instance, cobalt mining in the Democratic Republic of Congo has been associated with environmental degradation and unethical labor practices.\n2. **Rare Earth Metals:** EV motors often use rare earth elements like neodymium and dysprosium. The extraction of these metals is energy-intensive and can result in substantial environmental harm, including habitat destruction and pollution from tailings and chemical processing.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n1. **Fossil Fuels:** The primary raw material for gasoline vehicles is crude oil, which is extracted through drilling. This process can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and significant greenhouse gas emissions.\n2. **Metals and Materials:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and other metals for construction, similar to EVs. However, they do not require the same quantity of rare earth metals as EVs.\n\n### Production\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in manufacturing processes and increased use of renewable energy in production are helping to mitigate these impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The production of gasoline vehicles is less energy-intensive than EVs, primarily due to the absence of large battery systems. However, the manufacturing process still involves significant emissions and resource use.\n\n### Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, leading to reduced air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation. The environmental benefits are contingent on the electricity source; renewable energy sources enhance sustainability, while coal-based electricity can diminish these benefits.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change. The efficiency of the engine and fuel quality can affect the level of emissions.\n\n### End-of-Life Management\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- Battery recycling is a significant challenge and opportunity. While recycling technologies are improving, the current rate of battery recycling is low. Effective recycling can recover valuable materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, reducing the need for new raw material extraction and minimizing waste.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- End-of-life gasoline vehicles are typically dismantled, with metals being recycled. However, the disposal of fluids and other non-metal components can pose environmental risks.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, both electric and gasoline vehicles have distinct environmental impacts throughout their lifecycles. EVs offer significant advantages in reducing operational emissions, especially when powered by renewable energy. However, they present challenges in terms of raw material extraction and battery recycling. Gasoline vehicles have a more established recycling infrastructure but contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during use. Addressing the sustainability of EVs requires advancements in battery technology, improved recycling processes, and a shift towards cleaner energy sources.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and disposal. This approach will highlight differences in resource consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and pollution associated with electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles. I would gather data from existing studies and reports to provide a comprehensive assessment of their environmental impacts throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis that emphasizes resource consumption and material sustainability. This approach would delve into the types and quantities of raw materials required for the production of electric versus gasoline vehicles, including rare earth metals for batteries and fossil fuels for combustion engines. By examining the sourcing, usage, and recyclability of these materials, I can highlight the sustainability challenges and opportunities associated with each vehicle type. Data would be collected from recent industry reports and sustainability assessments to ensure a comprehensive evaluation of material impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and disposal. This approach will highlight differences in resource consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and pollution associated with electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles. I would gather data from existing studies and reports to provide a comprehensive assessment of their environmental impacts throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both vehicle types, specifically analyzing their emissions during use. This approach will involve comparing tailpipe emissions from gasoline vehicles with the emissions related to electricity generation for EVs, taking into account the energy mix in different regions. I would also consider the potential for renewable energy sources to power EVs and how that could further reduce their environmental footprint compared to gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and disposal. This approach will highlight differences in resource consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and pollution associated with electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles. I would gather data from existing studies and reports to provide a comprehensive assessment of their environmental impacts throughout their entire lifecycles." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis focused specifically on the carbon footprint of electric and gasoline vehicles. This variation would involve quantifying the total greenhouse gas emissions produced at each stage of a vehicle's lifecycle, such as the energy used in manufacturing, the emissions during operation, and the environmental costs of disposal. I would utilize carbon accounting methodologies and gather data from peer-reviewed studies to determine the net carbon impact of each vehicle type over its expected lifespan.", + "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis that emphasizes resource consumption and material sustainability. This approach would delve into the types and quantities of raw materials required for the production of electric versus gasoline vehicles, including rare earth metals for batteries and fossil fuels for combustion engines. By examining the sourcing, usage, and recyclability of these materials, I can highlight the sustainability challenges and opportunities associated with each vehicle type. Data would be collected from recent industry reports and sustainability assessments to ensure a comprehensive evaluation of material impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis that emphasizes resource consumption and material sustainability. This approach would delve into the types and quantities of raw materials required for the production of electric versus gasoline vehicles, including rare earth metals for batteries and fossil fuels for combustion engines. By examining the sourcing, usage, and recyclability of these materials, I can highlight the sustainability challenges and opportunities associated with each vehicle type. Data would be collected from recent industry reports and sustainability assessments to ensure a comprehensive evaluation of material impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:32.558214", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 16 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_17.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_17.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8065a749fd3b504f05fad0a06e0979d5778ff9c9 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_17.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "017d99cb-3072-4a6c-9072-e6389466431f", + "ibfs_id": "91a4288c-dfb5-43a7-9f96-b910ff2c24a4", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce greenhouse gases and pollution but have battery production and disposal impacts compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through a comparative lifecycle analysis, we must consider several key stages: raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. This analysis will also emphasize technological advancements over time, particularly in battery technology, vehicle efficiency, and manufacturing processes.\n\n### Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Batteries:** The production of lithium-ion batteries, which power most EVs, requires mining of raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel. Historically, this process has had significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and water pollution.\n- **Technological Advancements:** Over time, there have been improvements in battery chemistry and recycling processes. For example, newer battery technologies are reducing reliance on cobalt, which is more environmentally damaging to extract. Companies are also investing in more sustainable mining practices and recycling programs to recover valuable materials from used batteries.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Extraction:** The extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline have long been associated with environmental issues, including oil spills, greenhouse gas emissions, and ecosystem disruption.\n- **Technological Advancements:** While there have been improvements in drilling and refining efficiency, the fundamental environmental impacts of oil extraction remain significant.\n\n### Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Use:** Manufacturing EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and initially results in higher emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Technological Advancements:** Over time, manufacturing processes have become more energy-efficient. The use of renewable energy in production facilities has also increased, reducing the carbon footprint of EV manufacturing.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Manufacturing Processes:** The production of gasoline vehicles is less energy-intensive than EVs, primarily due to the absence of large battery packs.\n- **Technological Advancements:** Incremental improvements in manufacturing efficiency have occurred, but they have not significantly altered the environmental impact compared to the advancements seen in EV production.\n\n### Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, significantly reducing air pollution in urban areas.\n- **Energy Source:** The environmental impact during the usage phase depends on the electricity source. As the grid becomes greener with more renewable energy, the lifecycle emissions of EVs decrease.\n- **Technological Advancements:** Improvements in battery efficiency and vehicle aerodynamics have extended the range of EVs, making them more competitive with gasoline vehicles in terms of energy consumption.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other pollutants during operation, contributing to climate change and air quality issues.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Technological advancements have led to more fuel-efficient engines, but these improvements are often offset by increased vehicle size and power.\n\n### End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal of EV batteries poses a challenge due to hazardous materials. However, advancements in recycling technologies are improving the recovery of materials, reducing environmental impacts.\n- **Technological Advancements:** Companies are developing second-life applications for EV batteries, such as energy storage systems, extending their useful life and reducing waste.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Traditional vehicles are largely recyclable, with established processes for metal recovery. However, the environmental impact of end-of-life disposal is generally lower than that of EVs due to the absence of large battery packs.\n\n### Timeline Perspective and Future Scenarios\n\n- **Past:** Initially, the environmental impact of EVs was higher due to less efficient manufacturing and reliance on fossil fuel-based electricity.\n- **Present:** With advancements in battery technology, increased use of renewable energy, and more efficient manufacturing, the lifecycle emissions of EVs have decreased significantly.\n- **Future:** Continued technological innovations, such as solid-state batteries and further decarbonization of the electricity grid, are expected to further reduce the environmental impact of EVs. As these technologies mature, EVs are likely to become even more environmentally friendly compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\nIn conclusion, while both electric and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts, technological advancements have increasingly tipped the balance in favor of EVs. As these innovations continue, the environmental benefits of electric vehicles are expected to grow, potentially leading to a more sustainable transportation future.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, focusing on key stages such as production, use, and disposal. This approach would assess energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource use at each stage, providing a detailed understanding of the environmental impacts associated with both types of vehicles throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis with an emphasis on technological advancements over time. This strategy would involve examining how improvements in battery technology, vehicle efficiency, and manufacturing processes have changed the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles. By including a timeline perspective, this approach would reveal trends and potential future scenarios, illustrating how ongoing innovations could alter the environmental balance between these two types of vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, focusing on key stages such as production, use, and disposal. This approach would assess energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource use at each stage, providing a detailed understanding of the environmental impacts associated with both types of vehicles throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by examining the environmental policies and technological advancements that influence the sustainability of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would analyze how government regulations, incentives, and innovations in battery technology and fuel efficiency contribute to reducing or exacerbating the environmental impacts of each vehicle type, offering a perspective on how future developments might alter their comparative impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, focusing on key stages such as production, use, and disposal. This approach would assess energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and resource use at each stage, providing a detailed understanding of the environmental impacts associated with both types of vehicles throughout their entire lifecycles." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that incorporates geographical variations in production and use. This approach would involve evaluating how the environmental impacts of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles differ based on factors such as the source of electricity (renewable vs. non-renewable) in different regions, the local availability of materials for battery production, and regional recycling capabilities. By considering these geographical factors, this analysis would provide insights into how location-specific elements influence the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis with an emphasis on technological advancements over time. This strategy would involve examining how improvements in battery technology, vehicle efficiency, and manufacturing processes have changed the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles. By including a timeline perspective, this approach would reveal trends and potential future scenarios, illustrating how ongoing innovations could alter the environmental balance between these two types of vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis with an emphasis on technological advancements over time. This strategy would involve examining how improvements in battery technology, vehicle efficiency, and manufacturing processes have changed the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles. By including a timeline perspective, this approach would reveal trends and potential future scenarios, illustrating how ongoing innovations could alter the environmental balance between these two types of vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:41.828829", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 17 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_18.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_18.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0d5444a87e2dab1beb76988d28a48a61deffbd2e --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_18.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "99fb7dc6-27ce-4728-9d3f-4188c2560708", + "ibfs_id": "d8a31d7c-e78f-4b0b-89d9-4cf94b6ecdaa", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles offer lower emissions, reduced pollution, and decreased dependency on fossil fuels compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will focus on lifecycle emissions, particularly emphasizing the operational phase. This involves calculating the average emissions per mile driven for both types of vehicles and considering variations in electricity generation sources.\n\n### Gasoline Vehicles\n\n1. **Lifecycle Emissions**: For gasoline vehicles, emissions are primarily generated during the operational phase, where combustion of gasoline releases carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and other pollutants. \n\n2. **Average Emissions**: On average, gasoline vehicles emit about 411 grams of CO2 per mile. This figure can vary based on vehicle efficiency, with more fuel-efficient cars emitting less CO2.\n\n### Electric Vehicles\n\n1. **Lifecycle Emissions**: For EVs, emissions are mainly associated with electricity generation during the operational phase. The emissions depend heavily on the energy mix of the grid from which the electricity is sourced.\n\n2. **Average Emissions**: The emissions per mile for EVs vary significantly based on the grid's energy sources:\n - **Coal-Dominated Grid**: In regions where coal is a major source of electricity, EVs might emit around 200-300 grams of CO2 per mile. This is still generally lower than gasoline vehicles but not as low as in cleaner grids.\n - **Natural Gas-Dominated Grid**: In areas where natural gas is predominant, emissions can be around 150-200 grams of CO2 per mile.\n - **Renewable Energy-Dominated Grid**: In regions with a high percentage of renewable energy (e.g., wind, solar, hydro), EV emissions can be as low as 0-50 grams of CO2 per mile.\n\n### Comparative Analysis\n\n- **Regions with High Renewable Energy**: In areas where the grid is predominantly powered by renewable sources, EVs have a clear advantage over gasoline vehicles, with significantly lower emissions per mile.\n \n- **Regions with Fossil Fuel-Heavy Grids**: Even in regions where the grid relies heavily on fossil fuels, EVs tend to have lower emissions than gasoline vehicles, although the margin is smaller.\n\n- **Grid Decarbonization**: As grids become greener over time, the emissions associated with EVs will continue to decrease, enhancing their environmental benefits compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, electric vehicles generally have lower operational emissions compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, especially as the electricity grid becomes cleaner. The extent of the environmental benefit varies by region, depending on the local energy mix used for electricity generation. As renewable energy adoption increases, the emissions advantage of EVs over gasoline vehicles is expected to grow further.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impacts related to the energy sources and emissions during the use phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the emissions produced during the operation of gasoline vehicles and comparing them to the emissions associated with generating the electricity used to power electric vehicles. Additionally, I can consider the geographical variations in energy production, such as the use of coal versus renewable energy sources, to provide a nuanced comparison of their environmental impacts during the operational phase.", + "I can answer by examining the lifecycle emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles, with an emphasis on the operational phase. This approach would involve calculating the average emissions per mile driven for gasoline vehicles and comparing them to the emissions resulting from electricity generation for electric vehicles. To ensure a comprehensive analysis, I would include variations in grid energy sources, such as regions predominantly using renewable energy versus those using fossil fuels, to highlight how these differences affect the overall environmental impact." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the environmental impacts from the production phase, including the extraction and processing of raw materials, through the operational phase, where the vehicles are used, and finally to the end-of-life phase, where they are disposed of or recycled. By comparing the complete life cycle of both vehicle types, I can provide a detailed comparison of their environmental impacts, such as carbon emissions, resource depletion, and pollution.", + "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impacts related to the energy sources and emissions during the use phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the emissions produced during the operation of gasoline vehicles and comparing them to the emissions associated with generating the electricity used to power electric vehicles. Additionally, I can consider the geographical variations in energy production, such as the use of coal versus renewable energy sources, to provide a nuanced comparison of their environmental impacts during the operational phase." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impacts related to the energy sources and emissions during the use phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the emissions produced during the operation of gasoline vehicles and comparing them to the emissions associated with generating the electricity used to power electric vehicles. Additionally, I can consider the geographical variations in energy production, such as the use of coal versus renewable energy sources, to provide a nuanced comparison of their environmental impacts during the operational phase." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by examining the lifecycle emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles, with an emphasis on the operational phase. This approach would involve calculating the average emissions per mile driven for gasoline vehicles and comparing them to the emissions resulting from electricity generation for electric vehicles. To ensure a comprehensive analysis, I would include variations in grid energy sources, such as regions predominantly using renewable energy versus those using fossil fuels, to highlight how these differences affect the overall environmental impact.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional case study analysis that compares the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles specifically in areas with contrasting energy profiles. This approach would involve selecting two or more regions with distinct energy mixes\u2014such as one reliant on coal and another on hydropower\u2014and analyzing the emissions produced during the operational phase of vehicles in these areas. By focusing on regional differences, I can provide a more detailed understanding of how local energy production influences the environmental benefits or drawbacks of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by examining the lifecycle emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles, with an emphasis on the operational phase. This approach would involve calculating the average emissions per mile driven for gasoline vehicles and comparing them to the emissions resulting from electricity generation for electric vehicles. To ensure a comprehensive analysis, I would include variations in grid energy sources, such as regions predominantly using renewable energy versus those using fossil fuels, to highlight how these differences affect the overall environmental impact." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:44.266118", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 18 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_19.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_19.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ce37e6d4f7db451975214bcfd1e33a2f7be205c0 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_19.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "b066ac05-51fe-400f-aa0d-67186b4f8d01", + "ibfs_id": "222ed71e-347d-42c0-a979-ab78de7ebaff", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but battery production and disposal pose environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through a lifecycle analysis with a focus on end-of-life disposal and recycling processes, we must consider several key aspects: battery recycling, vehicle dismantling, and waste management strategies.\n\n### 1. Battery Recycling in Electric Vehicles\n\n**Environmental Implications:**\n- **Resource Recovery:** EVs primarily rely on lithium-ion batteries, which contain valuable materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and manganese. The recycling of these batteries is crucial for recovering these materials, reducing the need for new mining operations, and minimizing environmental degradation.\n- **Recycling Processes:** Current recycling methods include pyrometallurgical, hydrometallurgical, and direct recycling processes. Each has its environmental footprint, with hydrometallurgical processes generally offering a better environmental profile due to lower energy consumption and emissions.\n- **Challenges:** The recycling infrastructure for EV batteries is still developing. Efficient collection systems, standardized battery designs, and improved recycling technologies are needed to enhance material recovery rates and reduce environmental impacts.\n\n**Opportunities:**\n- **Circular Economy:** Effective battery recycling can contribute to a circular economy by reintroducing recovered materials into the production cycle, thus reducing the environmental impact of raw material extraction.\n- **Innovation in Recycling Technologies:** Advances in recycling technologies can improve the efficiency and environmental performance of battery recycling processes.\n\n### 2. Vehicle Dismantling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Complexity:** EVs have fewer moving parts than gasoline vehicles, but their dismantling can be more complex due to the presence of high-voltage systems and the need for specialized handling of batteries.\n- **Material Recovery:** EVs offer opportunities for recovering high-value materials from components such as electric motors and electronic systems.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Established Processes:** The dismantling and recycling processes for gasoline vehicles are well-established, with mature markets for scrap metal recovery.\n- **Environmental Concerns:** Gasoline vehicles contain fluids and components that require careful handling to prevent environmental contamination, such as oils, coolants, and lead-acid batteries.\n\n### 3. Waste Management Strategies\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Waste:** The management of battery waste is a significant concern. Improper disposal can lead to environmental hazards due to the release of toxic substances.\n- **Regulatory Frameworks:** Many regions are developing regulations and extended producer responsibility (EPR) schemes to ensure proper battery disposal and recycling.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Hazardous Materials:** Gasoline vehicles contain hazardous materials that must be managed carefully to prevent soil and water contamination.\n- **Recycling Rates:** The recycling rates for materials like steel and aluminum are high, but there is room for improvement in recycling plastics and other non-metal components.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe end-of-life disposal and recycling processes of electric and gasoline vehicles present distinct environmental challenges and opportunities. EVs offer significant potential for resource recovery through battery recycling, contributing to a more sustainable lifecycle. However, the current recycling infrastructure and technologies need further development to maximize these benefits. Gasoline vehicles, while benefiting from established recycling processes, pose environmental risks due to hazardous materials. Both vehicle types require robust waste management strategies to mitigate their environmental impacts at the end of their lifecycle.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to operation and end-of-life disposal. This approach would provide a comprehensive overview of the emissions and resource use associated with both types of vehicles, highlighting key differences in their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that emphasizes the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would delve into the environmental implications of battery recycling, vehicle dismantling, and waste management strategies. By highlighting the differences in how these vehicles are disposed of and the potential for material recovery, I can shed light on the sustainability challenges and opportunities associated with decommissioning each type of vehicle." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to operation and end-of-life disposal. This approach would provide a comprehensive overview of the emissions and resource use associated with both types of vehicles, highlighting key differences in their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, specifically analyzing emissions and energy consumption during their use. This approach would compare the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles with the indirect emissions from electricity generation for electric vehicles. It would also consider the impact of different energy sources used to generate electricity, such as coal, natural gas, or renewables, and how these affect the overall environmental impact of electric vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to operation and end-of-life disposal. This approach would provide a comprehensive overview of the emissions and resource use associated with both types of vehicles, highlighting key differences in their environmental footprints." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing the lifecycle analysis specifically on the manufacturing processes of electric vehicles versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve a detailed examination of the environmental impacts associated with the extraction and processing of raw materials, such as lithium for batteries and steel for engines, as well as the energy consumption and emissions during the assembly processes. By isolating the manufacturing stage, I can provide insights into how production methods contribute to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that emphasizes the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would delve into the environmental implications of battery recycling, vehicle dismantling, and waste management strategies. By highlighting the differences in how these vehicles are disposed of and the potential for material recovery, I can shed light on the sustainability challenges and opportunities associated with decommissioning each type of vehicle." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that emphasizes the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would delve into the environmental implications of battery recycling, vehicle dismantling, and waste management strategies. By highlighting the differences in how these vehicles are disposed of and the potential for material recovery, I can shed light on the sustainability challenges and opportunities associated with decommissioning each type of vehicle." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:40.317142", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 19 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_2.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_2.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..99c3f6c999b2b5dd0be3243455ef538bdce2dd2e --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_2.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "eb3f4598-4f8c-4d28-9004-2bafc54459a9", + "ibfs_id": "e4427e40-0f46-4491-a578-3e899870aaf1", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce zero tailpipe emissions, reduce greenhouse gases, but have environmental costs in battery production and electricity sources.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can review existing studies and reports from credible sources. These studies typically evaluate the entire lifecycle of vehicles, including manufacturing, operation, and disposal, to provide a comprehensive understanding of their environmental impacts.\n\n1. **Lifecycle Greenhouse Gas Emissions**:\n - A study by the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS) found that electric vehicles produce significantly lower greenhouse gas emissions over their lifetimes compared to gasoline vehicles. This is primarily due to the higher efficiency of electric motors and the potential for electricity to be generated from renewable sources. According to their 2020 report, even when accounting for the emissions from electricity generation, EVs in the U.S. produce less than half the emissions of comparable gasoline vehicles.\n - The International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT) also supports these findings, indicating that EVs have lower lifecycle emissions, especially as the grid becomes cleaner with more renewable energy sources.\n\n2. **Manufacturing Impact**:\n - The production of electric vehicles, particularly the batteries, is more energy-intensive than that of gasoline vehicles. A report from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) highlights that battery production is a significant source of emissions. However, these emissions are offset during the vehicle's operational phase due to the higher efficiency and lower emissions of EVs.\n - The European Environment Agency (EEA) notes that while battery production has a higher environmental footprint, advancements in battery technology and recycling can mitigate these impacts.\n\n3. **Air Quality**:\n - EVs contribute to improved air quality by eliminating tailpipe emissions, which are a significant source of urban air pollution. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) emphasizes that reducing emissions from transportation is crucial for improving air quality and public health, particularly in urban areas.\n - A study published in the journal *Nature Sustainability* found that widespread adoption of EVs could lead to substantial reductions in air pollutants like nitrogen oxides and particulate matter, which are harmful to human health.\n\n4. **Resource Use and Recycling**:\n - The extraction and processing of materials for EV batteries, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, have environmental and social implications. Reports from organizations like Amnesty International highlight concerns about mining practices and their environmental and human rights impacts.\n - However, the industry is moving towards more sustainable practices, and research from the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) suggests that recycling and second-life applications for batteries can reduce the demand for raw materials and lower the environmental impact.\n\n5. **Energy Source Variability**:\n - The environmental benefits of EVs are closely tied to the energy sources used for electricity generation. A report from the International Energy Agency (IEA) indicates that in regions where coal is the dominant energy source, the benefits of EVs are reduced. However, as grids incorporate more renewable energy, the advantages of EVs increase significantly.\n\nIn summary, existing studies and reports generally agree that electric vehicles offer substantial environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving air quality. While there are challenges related to battery production and resource use, advancements in technology and energy sourcing are expected to enhance the environmental performance of EVs further.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by reviewing existing studies and reports from credible sources such as environmental organizations, governmental agencies, and academic research that have analyzed the environmental impacts of electric versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve summarizing key findings from these studies, highlighting the consensus and any differing opinions on the environmental benefits and drawbacks of each vehicle type. This method relies on existing research to provide a synthesized overview of the current understanding in this field." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would consider the raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, usage phase, and end-of-life management for both types of vehicles. By examining the entire lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive analysis of how each type of vehicle impacts the environment over its lifespan.", + "I can answer by reviewing existing studies and reports from credible sources such as environmental organizations, governmental agencies, and academic research that have analyzed the environmental impacts of electric versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve summarizing key findings from these studies, highlighting the consensus and any differing opinions on the environmental benefits and drawbacks of each vehicle type. This method relies on existing research to provide a synthesized overview of the current understanding in this field." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by reviewing existing studies and reports from credible sources such as environmental organizations, governmental agencies, and academic research that have analyzed the environmental impacts of electric versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve summarizing key findings from these studies, highlighting the consensus and any differing opinions on the environmental benefits and drawbacks of each vehicle type. This method relies on existing research to provide a synthesized overview of the current understanding in this field." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:45.380396", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 2 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_20.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_20.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..537a171deb2ba4c80675c224c0072acde3b9d00c --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_20.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "f8912601-b5d5-46b5-8fbf-70d9ca4fa7aa", + "ibfs_id": "736eac86-411e-4ed1-a1fc-e8658527821d", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce fewer emissions overall, reduce dependence on fossil fuels, and offer cleaner energy options compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, we need to examine the carbon emissions produced by each type of vehicle when they are in use. This involves looking at the emissions from burning gasoline in internal combustion engines and the emissions associated with generating the electricity used to charge EVs.\n\n### Gasoline Vehicles\n\nGasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2) directly from their tailpipes as a result of burning gasoline. The amount of CO2 emitted depends on the fuel efficiency of the vehicle, which is typically measured in miles per gallon (mpg). On average, a gasoline vehicle emits about 8,887 grams of CO2 per gallon of gasoline burned. For a vehicle with a fuel efficiency of 25 mpg, this translates to approximately 355 grams of CO2 per mile driven.\n\n### Electric Vehicles\n\nElectric vehicles do not emit CO2 directly when driven, as they use electric motors powered by batteries. However, the carbon emissions associated with EVs depend on the source of the electricity used to charge them. The carbon intensity of electricity generation varies significantly based on the energy mix of the grid.\n\n1. **Coal-Powered Electricity**: If the electricity used to charge an EV comes primarily from coal-fired power plants, the emissions can be relatively high. Coal-fired plants emit about 2.21 pounds of CO2 per kWh. An EV that consumes 0.3 kWh per mile would thus be responsible for approximately 0.663 pounds (or about 300 grams) of CO2 per mile.\n\n2. **Natural Gas-Powered Electricity**: Natural gas plants emit less CO2 than coal plants, approximately 0.91 pounds of CO2 per kWh. Using the same EV consumption rate, this would result in about 0.273 pounds (or about 124 grams) of CO2 per mile.\n\n3. **Renewable Energy**: If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the associated CO2 emissions are negligible. In this case, the operational phase of an EV can be nearly carbon-free.\n\n### Comparison\n\n- **High Carbon Intensity Grid (Coal)**: In regions where coal is the dominant energy source, the carbon emissions of EVs can approach those of gasoline vehicles, though they are often still slightly lower.\n \n- **Moderate Carbon Intensity Grid (Natural Gas)**: In areas where natural gas is prevalent, EVs generally have significantly lower carbon emissions per mile compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n- **Low Carbon Intensity Grid (Renewables)**: In regions with a high penetration of renewable energy, EVs can have near-zero operational carbon emissions, offering a substantial environmental advantage over gasoline vehicles.\n\nOverall, the carbon emissions of electric vehicles during their operational phase can vary widely based on the energy mix of the electricity grid. However, as the grid becomes increasingly decarbonized with more renewable energy, the environmental benefits of EVs over gasoline vehicles become more pronounced.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by comparing the carbon emissions of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their operational phase. This approach would focus on the emissions produced by each type of vehicle during use, taking into account the energy source for EVs (e.g., coal vs. renewable energy) and the fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to end-of-life. This would include assessing the raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during operation, and disposal or recycling of the vehicles.", + "I can answer by comparing the carbon emissions of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their operational phase. This approach would focus on the emissions produced by each type of vehicle during use, taking into account the energy source for EVs (e.g., coal vs. renewable energy) and the fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by reviewing scientific studies and reports that have evaluated the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This would involve summarizing key findings from credible research papers and expert analyses, highlighting the consensus and any ongoing debates within the scientific community.", + "I can answer by investigating the environmental impacts of the supply chain for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include examining the extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium for EV batteries and the environmental costs of drilling and refining petroleum for gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by comparing the carbon emissions of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their operational phase. This approach would focus on the emissions produced by each type of vehicle during use, taking into account the energy source for EVs (e.g., coal vs. renewable energy) and the fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:41.857698", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 20 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_21.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_21.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f1ceaec2eaaddf97c920a543b8dfa74f25512e18 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_21.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "a9f84eac-c57e-4a94-a508-9075dfe8523a", + "ibfs_id": "efad1fe0-2fcd-4d2a-8b9d-a1fce2d8726d", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions, use renewable energy, but involve mining impacts; gasoline vehicles release more CO2 and pollutants.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine each stage of the vehicle's lifecycle: raw material extraction, manufacturing, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. This analysis will help us understand the environmental impacts of both types of vehicles.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Batteries:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can result in significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use copper and rare earth elements for electric motors and other components, which have their own environmental impacts due to mining.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fossil Fuels:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling and can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Metals and Materials:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and other materials, which also involve mining and processing with associated environmental impacts.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Processes\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- Manufacturing EVs, especially the batteries, is energy-intensive and can result in higher emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in renewable energy use in manufacturing can mitigate some impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is less energy-intensive than for EVs, primarily due to the absence of large batteries. However, it still involves significant emissions from steel and aluminum production.\n\n### 3. Vehicle Operation\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas.\n- **Energy Source:** The environmental impact during operation depends on the electricity source. If powered by renewable energy, the emissions are minimal. However, if the electricity comes from fossil fuels, the emissions can be significant.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Improvements in fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, but they remain higher than those of EVs, especially when EVs are charged with clean energy.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Recycling or Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of lithium-ion batteries pose challenges due to the need for specialized recycling processes to recover valuable materials and prevent environmental contamination.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Other components of EVs can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, but the battery remains the primary concern.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are generally easier to recycle, as the materials used are well-established in recycling processes. However, they still contribute to waste and pollution if not properly managed.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles offer significant environmental benefits during the operation phase due to zero tailpipe emissions, especially when powered by renewable energy. However, they have higher environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases, primarily due to battery production. Gasoline vehicles have lower initial manufacturing impacts but contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation. End-of-life recycling presents challenges for both types, with EVs focusing on battery recycling and gasoline vehicles on traditional material recycling. Overall, the shift towards renewable energy sources and improved recycling technologies can enhance the environmental benefits of electric vehicles throughout their lifecycle.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include assessing raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. The analysis would highlight the differences in emissions, resource consumption, and ecological footprint throughout each vehicle's lifecycle." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include assessing raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. The analysis would highlight the differences in emissions, resource consumption, and ecological footprint throughout each vehicle's lifecycle.", + "I can answer by reviewing scientific literature and existing studies that have evaluated the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves summarizing findings from peer-reviewed articles, government reports, and non-profit research that compare the carbon emissions, energy efficiency, and pollution levels associated with both types of vehicles. This approach provides evidence-based insights and conclusions drawn from extensive research.", + "I can answer by evaluating the energy sources used for electricity generation and how they affect the environmental benefits of electric vehicles. This approach would involve examining the energy mix of different regions, considering the proportion of renewable versus non-renewable energy sources, and assessing how this influences the overall emissions and sustainability of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles. The analysis would show how the environmental impact of EVs can vary depending on the electricity grid's composition.", + "I can answer by exploring the socio-economic and policy factors that influence the environmental impacts of both vehicle types. This strategy would consider how government incentives, regulations, and technological advancements in battery recycling and production efficiency affect the sustainability of electric vehicles compared to traditional ones. This approach highlights the role of external factors in shaping the environmental outcomes of vehicle technologies." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include assessing raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. The analysis would highlight the differences in emissions, resource consumption, and ecological footprint throughout each vehicle's lifecycle." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:49.328354", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 21 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_22.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_22.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..23cd675d88c98a26535aa17d38912fb082bfd2e0 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_22.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "9433cabe-2d8b-4db8-a0f2-6674ec5c784c", + "ibfs_id": "3eeff9ef-5b54-4880-afcf-5f9c6541a0dd", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and reliance on fossil fuels, but their battery production and disposal present environmental challenges.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA). This assessment will consider the entire lifespan of both vehicle types, from raw material extraction to end-of-life disposal. Here's a detailed breakdown of each phase:\n\n### 1. Sourcing and Processing of Raw Materials\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve mining and processing of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. This process can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Electric Motor and Electronics:** These components require rare earth elements, which also have environmental costs associated with their extraction and refinement.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Fuel System:** The production of internal combustion engines involves steel, aluminum, and other metals, which also require energy-intensive mining and processing.\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction, refining, and transportation of crude oil for gasoline production contribute to environmental degradation, including oil spills, air pollution, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Emissions\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- The manufacturing process for EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher initial emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in manufacturing efficiency and the use of renewable energy can mitigate these impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Manufacturing emissions are generally lower than those of EVs initially, as the production of internal combustion engines is less energy-intensive than battery production. However, the overall emissions depend on the specific materials and processes used.\n\n### 3. Usage-Phase Emissions\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces urban air pollution.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during the usage phase depends on the electricity mix. If the grid relies heavily on fossil fuels, the emissions can be substantial, though still generally lower than gasoline vehicles. Renewable energy sources greatly reduce these emissions.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** These vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, particulate matter, and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Improvements in fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, but they remain higher than those of EVs, especially in regions with clean electricity grids.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries are critical. While recycling can recover valuable materials, improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination. Advances in battery recycling technology are improving the sustainability of EVs.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, the metal components of EVs can be recycled, reducing the need for new raw materials.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** The established infrastructure for recycling metals from gasoline vehicles helps mitigate some environmental impacts. However, the disposal of fluids and other hazardous materials remains a concern.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn a comparative life cycle assessment, electric vehicles generally offer environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of reduced emissions during the usage phase. However, the initial production phase, especially battery manufacturing, poses significant environmental challenges. The overall impact of EVs can be minimized through cleaner energy sources, improved recycling processes, and advancements in battery technology. As the energy grid becomes greener and recycling technologies advance, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to increase.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production through end-of-life disposal. This would include examining the sourcing and processing of raw materials, manufacturing emissions, usage-phase emissions, and recycling or disposal impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production through end-of-life disposal. This would include examining the sourcing and processing of raw materials, manufacturing emissions, usage-phase emissions, and recycling or disposal impacts.", + "I can answer by reviewing current scientific studies and reports that provide data on emissions and resource use associated with electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve summarizing findings from research papers, government assessments, and environmental organization reports to provide a comprehensive overview.", + "I can answer by analyzing the carbon footprint and pollution output differences between electric and gasoline vehicles during their operational life. This would involve calculating and comparing the emissions released per mile driven for each type of vehicle, taking into account the electricity generation mix and fuel consumption.", + "I can answer by examining case studies from regions that have high adoption rates of electric vehicles. This would involve looking at the real-world environmental impacts observed in these areas, including changes in air quality, energy demand shifts, and impacts on local ecosystems, compared to regions with predominantly gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production through end-of-life disposal. This would include examining the sourcing and processing of raw materials, manufacturing emissions, usage-phase emissions, and recycling or disposal impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:50.504570", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 22 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_23.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_23.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..54ad02967d6cdee44f08cc3193b87574b228f070 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_23.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c49f8e11-dd30-4a74-9678-c018ac8093d5", + "ibfs_id": "a8778f4c-a09f-4692-ac68-941e2f43b0da", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and dependence on oil, but their battery production and disposal pose environmental challenges. Balancing benefits needed.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines each stage of their lifecycle: raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life recycling or disposal.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. Mining these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use copper and rare earth elements for electric motors and other components, contributing to additional environmental stress from mining activities.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Extraction:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and greenhouse gas emissions. Refining crude oil into gasoline is also energy-intensive and polluting.\n- **Material Use:** Gasoline vehicles use steel, aluminum, and plastics, which also require mining and processing, but generally involve less intensive mining of rare materials compared to EVs.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Processes\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** Manufacturing EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in renewable energy use in manufacturing are helping to mitigate these impacts.\n- **Complex Supply Chains:** The global supply chain for battery components can lead to additional emissions due to transportation and logistics.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Lower Initial Emissions:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles typically results in lower initial carbon emissions compared to EVs, primarily because they do not require large batteries.\n- **Standard Manufacturing:** The processes involved are well-established and optimized, though they still contribute to environmental pollution and resource use.\n\n### 3. Usage Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, significantly reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation. The environmental impact during this phase largely depends on the electricity source used for charging.\n- **Electricity Source:** If powered by renewable energy, the emissions are minimal. However, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels, the benefits are reduced but still generally lower than gasoline vehicles.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **High Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Advances in fuel efficiency have reduced emissions per mile, but they remain significantly higher than those of EVs.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Recycling or Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose environmental challenges. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable materials and reducing waste.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, EVs can be recycled for their metal components, reducing the need for new raw materials.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Established Recycling Processes:** The recycling of gasoline vehicles is well-established, with many parts being reused or recycled. However, they do not have the additional complexity of battery disposal.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, while electric vehicles initially have a higher environmental impact during the production phase due to battery manufacturing, they offer significant benefits during the usage phase by eliminating tailpipe emissions. The overall environmental impact of EVs is generally lower than that of gasoline vehicles, especially when charged with renewable energy. End-of-life recycling remains a challenge for both types of vehicles, but advancements in battery recycling are improving the sustainability of EVs.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts from the production phase through to disposal, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, usage, and end-of-life recycling or disposal." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts from the production phase through to disposal, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, usage, and end-of-life recycling or disposal.", + "I can answer by examining and summarizing scientific research studies and reports that have analyzed the emissions and pollution levels associated with both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include looking at greenhouse gas emissions, particulate matter, and other pollutants during manufacturing, operation, and disposal stages.", + "I can answer by exploring the energy source for electric vehicles, focusing on how the electricity is generated (renewable vs. non-renewable sources) and the resulting environmental impacts. This involves considering the carbon footprint of electricity production and how it compares to the emissions from burning gasoline in traditional vehicles.", + "I can answer by assessing the impact of resource extraction necessary for electric vehicles, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel mining for batteries, and comparing it to oil extraction for gasoline vehicles. This approach would include evaluating the ecological disturbance, water usage, and pollution associated with both types of resource extraction processes." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts from the production phase through to disposal, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, usage, and end-of-life recycling or disposal." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:54.424660", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 23 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_24.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_24.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d90b980c8d4ae0c759c22096c420441bdcbd9089 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_24.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "8a71af29-3779-406c-931b-bf2fa16eb915", + "ibfs_id": "ab8054e6-6a40-4190-bcbd-314aa9badf11", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and fossil fuel dependence but have battery production impacts and require renewable energy for maximum benefits.", + "final_answer": "When comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their use phase, it is crucial to focus on the emissions produced and their effects on air quality and climate change.\n\n### Greenhouse Gas Emissions\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions during their use phase. This means they do not emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), or particulate matter directly while being driven.\n - However, the greenhouse gas emissions associated with EVs during their use phase depend on the source of electricity used to charge them. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the associated emissions are minimal. Conversely, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels such as coal or natural gas, the emissions can be significant.\n - On average, even when accounting for a typical mix of energy sources, EVs tend to have lower overall greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit CO2 directly from the combustion of fuel. The average gasoline vehicle emits about 4.6 metric tons of CO2 per year, assuming a fuel economy of about 22 miles per gallon and 11,500 miles driven annually.\n - In addition to CO2, gasoline vehicles emit other pollutants such as NOx and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which contribute to smog and have adverse health effects.\n\n### Air Pollutants\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - As mentioned, EVs do not produce tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces the emission of air pollutants in urban areas, improving local air quality.\n - The air quality benefits are particularly pronounced in cities where traffic congestion leads to high levels of vehicle emissions.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Gasoline vehicles contribute to air pollution through the emission of NOx, VOCs, and particulate matter. These pollutants can form ground-level ozone and particulate pollution, which are harmful to human health and the environment.\n - The presence of these pollutants in the atmosphere can lead to respiratory problems, cardiovascular diseases, and other health issues.\n\n### Effects on Air Quality and Climate Change\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - By reducing tailpipe emissions, EVs contribute to improved air quality, especially in densely populated areas. This can lead to a reduction in health problems associated with poor air quality.\n - The impact of EVs on climate change is largely dependent on the carbon intensity of the electricity grid. As the grid becomes cleaner with more renewable energy sources, the climate benefits of EVs increase.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - The emissions from gasoline vehicles contribute significantly to climate change through the release of CO2, a major greenhouse gas.\n - The air pollutants from gasoline vehicles also contribute to environmental issues such as acid rain and the formation of urban smog, which can exacerbate climate change effects.\n\nIn summary, during the use phase, electric vehicles generally have a lower environmental impact compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to their lack of tailpipe emissions. The extent of their environmental benefits, however, is influenced by the energy sources used for electricity generation. As the energy grid becomes greener, the advantages of EVs in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving air quality become more pronounced.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the use phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, analyzing the differences in greenhouse gas emissions, air pollutants, and their subsequent effects on air quality and climate change." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, examining environmental impacts from raw material extraction, manufacturing, use, and end-of-life disposal. This would offer a holistic view of their overall environmental footprint.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the use phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, analyzing the differences in greenhouse gas emissions, air pollutants, and their subsequent effects on air quality and climate change.", + "I can answer by evaluating the environmental impact of the energy sources used to power electric vehicles compared to the extraction and refinement of fossil fuels for gasoline vehicles. This approach would highlight the importance of the electricity grid's energy mix in determining the environmental benefits of EVs.", + "I can answer by exploring the environmental impacts associated with the production and disposal of batteries used in electric vehicles, including resource depletion and waste management challenges, as compared to the production and disposal of traditional vehicle components like engines and exhaust systems." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the use phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, analyzing the differences in greenhouse gas emissions, air pollutants, and their subsequent effects on air quality and climate change." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:03.967115", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 24 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_25.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_25.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f123d9189b027cd3468c515cf028abef3964d137 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_25.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "09e805b4-0658-41bb-bce2-a73870e158dd", + "ibfs_id": "f3af97d8-5e32-414a-a7c2-22171c2229ff", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce greenhouse emissions but involve battery production challenges; gasoline vehicles contribute more to air pollution and CO2.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can draw on findings from various research studies and reports by reputable environmental organizations and academic institutions. These sources provide insights into several key metrics such as emissions reduction, energy consumption, and ecological footprints.\n\n1. **Emissions Reduction**:\n - **Lifecycle Emissions**: According to a report by the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS), EVs produce significantly lower greenhouse gas emissions over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles. This includes emissions from manufacturing, driving, and disposal. The UCS report highlights that even when accounting for the emissions from electricity generation, EVs result in lower emissions than gasoline vehicles in most regions of the United States.\n - **Tailpipe Emissions**: EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, which means they do not emit pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM) during operation. This is a significant advantage over gasoline vehicles, which contribute to air pollution and associated health problems.\n\n2. **Energy Consumption**:\n - **Efficiency**: Research from the U.S. Department of Energy indicates that EVs are more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 77% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, whereas internal combustion engines (ICEs) convert only about 12%\u201330% of the energy stored in gasoline.\n - **Energy Source**: The environmental impact of EVs is influenced by the source of electricity used for charging. A study published in the journal *Nature Sustainability* found that in regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources, the environmental benefits of EVs are maximized. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal-fired power, the benefits are reduced, though EVs still tend to have a lower overall emissions profile than gasoline vehicles.\n\n3. **Ecological Footprints**:\n - **Battery Production**: One of the environmental drawbacks of EVs is the production of lithium-ion batteries, which involves energy-intensive mining and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. A study by the International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT) notes that battery production can result in significant emissions and environmental impacts. However, advancements in battery technology and recycling are helping to mitigate these effects.\n - **Resource Use**: The extraction and processing of materials for EV batteries can have ecological impacts, including habitat destruction and water pollution. Efforts are underway to develop more sustainable mining practices and to increase the recycling of battery materials to reduce these impacts.\n\n4. **Long-term Environmental Impact**:\n - **Renewable Integration**: The International Energy Agency (IEA) emphasizes that the integration of EVs with renewable energy sources can further enhance their environmental benefits. As the grid becomes greener, the lifecycle emissions of EVs will continue to decrease.\n - **Policy and Infrastructure**: Reports from the World Resources Institute (WRI) suggest that supportive policies and infrastructure development, such as expanding charging networks and incentivizing renewable energy, are crucial for maximizing the environmental benefits of EVs.\n\nIn summary, while electric vehicles offer significant environmental advantages over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of emissions reduction and energy efficiency, challenges remain in battery production and resource use. Continued advancements in technology, along with supportive policies and a transition to renewable energy sources, are essential to fully realize the environmental benefits of EVs.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by examining existing research studies and reports from reputable environmental organizations and academic institutions. This approach involves synthesizing findings from multiple sources to provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental benefits and drawbacks of EVs compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, focusing on metrics like emissions reduction, energy consumption, and ecological footprints." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal\u2014to determine their respective environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, air and water pollution, and resource depletion.", + "I can answer by examining existing research studies and reports from reputable environmental organizations and academic institutions. This approach involves synthesizing findings from multiple sources to provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental benefits and drawbacks of EVs compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, focusing on metrics like emissions reduction, energy consumption, and ecological footprints.", + "I can answer by analyzing the regional differences in environmental impacts based on the energy grid composition. This approach considers how the environmental benefits of EVs can vary depending on the electricity sources used to charge them (e.g., coal, natural gas, renewables) and compares this with the consistent emissions profile of gasoline vehicles across different regions.", + "I can answer by exploring the policy and regulatory landscape that influences the environmental impacts of both vehicle types. This strategy involves evaluating how government incentives, emissions regulations, and infrastructure development (such as charging stations for EVs) affect the overall environmental outcomes and adoption rates of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by examining existing research studies and reports from reputable environmental organizations and academic institutions. This approach involves synthesizing findings from multiple sources to provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental benefits and drawbacks of EVs compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, focusing on metrics like emissions reduction, energy consumption, and ecological footprints." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:03.583917", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 25 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_26.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_26.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2d64f07992d6479ba6bf906b71396e87406f00ec --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_26.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "0a999bf4-19b4-470b-9493-b1b49c585a71", + "ibfs_id": "376af2d8-2b49-48c7-a645-8d824b25d069", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but manufacturing and battery disposal present environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA). This involves examining the entire life cycle of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal. Here is a detailed analysis:\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction and Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other materials. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, soil and water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing:** The production of EVs generally requires more energy than traditional vehicles due to the complexity and weight of the batteries. However, advancements in battery technology and manufacturing processes are gradually reducing these impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline production involve significant energy use and environmental degradation, including oil spills, air and water pollution, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is typically less energy-intensive than for EVs, primarily because they do not require large batteries. However, the production still involves significant resource use and emissions.\n\n### 2. Usage Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Source:** The environmental impact during the usage phase of EVs largely depends on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the emissions are significantly lower. However, if the grid relies heavily on fossil fuels, the benefits are reduced.\n- **Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, reducing urban air pollution and associated health impacts. This is a major advantage over gasoline vehicles.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Consumption:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter, and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Efficiency:** Internal combustion engines are generally less efficient than electric motors, leading to higher emissions per mile driven.\n\n### 3. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries present environmental challenges. While recycling technologies are improving, improper disposal can lead to soil and water contamination. Efforts are underway to improve battery recycling processes to recover valuable materials and minimize environmental impacts.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** The rest of the EV can be recycled similarly to traditional vehicles, but the presence of electronic components requires careful handling.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles have established recycling processes for metals and other materials. However, the disposal of fluids and other hazardous materials still poses environmental risks.\n\n### Overall Environmental Impact\n\n- **Carbon Emissions:** Over their entire life cycle, EVs generally have lower carbon emissions than gasoline vehicles, particularly when charged with low-carbon electricity. The higher emissions during manufacturing are offset by the lower emissions during the usage phase.\n- **Resource Depletion:** Both vehicle types contribute to resource depletion, but EVs require specific minerals for batteries, which can be more environmentally taxing to extract.\n- **Pollution:** EVs offer significant reductions in air pollution during the usage phase, which is beneficial for urban environments.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles have higher environmental impacts during the manufacturing phase due to battery production, they offer substantial benefits during the usage phase, particularly in terms of emissions and air quality. The overall environmental impact of EVs is generally lower than that of gasoline vehicles, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the entire life cycle of both types of vehicles\u2014from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal\u2014to evaluate their overall environmental impacts, such as carbon emissions, resource depletion, and pollution." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the entire life cycle of both types of vehicles\u2014from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal\u2014to evaluate their overall environmental impacts, such as carbon emissions, resource depletion, and pollution.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions during the usage phase of the vehicles. This would involve analyzing the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles during operation and comparing them to the indirect emissions from electric vehicles, which depend largely on the energy sources used to generate the electricity that powers them. This approach highlights the importance of electricity generation methods in the environmental impact of electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring the impact of battery production and disposal for electric vehicles compared to the oil extraction and refining process for gasoline vehicles. This approach examines the environmental costs associated with extracting and processing materials needed for each type of vehicle, including issues such as habitat destruction, pollution, and resource scarcity.", + "I can answer by evaluating the potential for renewable energy integration in electric vehicles and its environmental benefits over time. This strategy considers the current and future potential for electric vehicles to be charged using renewable energy sources like solar and wind, reducing their carbon footprint, and contrasts this with the fixed emissions profile of gasoline vehicles, which rely on fossil fuels." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the entire life cycle of both types of vehicles\u2014from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal\u2014to evaluate their overall environmental impacts, such as carbon emissions, resource depletion, and pollution." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:09.321852", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 26 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_27.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_27.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ea9f4c71ef953fe3c43d687906b9daa95f881b68 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_27.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "1d459f23-cf60-4ea1-bff0-ef1ca0771b44", + "ibfs_id": "5305365c-dadb-44a7-915d-2d97f31bedfa", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution but involve higher ecological costs in battery production and electricity generation.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine each stage of their lifecycle: raw material extraction, manufacturing, use phase, and end-of-life disposal. This approach helps us understand the overall environmental impact of each vehicle type.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Batteries:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use copper and rare earth elements for electric motors, which have their own environmental extraction impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuels:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can result in habitat disruption, oil spills, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Materials:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and other metals, which also involve mining and processing impacts.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** The manufacturing of EVs, particularly their batteries, is energy-intensive. This results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Material Processing:** Processing of battery materials contributes to emissions and environmental pollution.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Conventional Manufacturing:** Gasoline vehicle manufacturing is less energy-intensive than EVs, primarily because it does not involve battery production.\n- **Emissions:** The production process still results in significant emissions, though generally lower than those for EVs.\n\n### 3. Use Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, reducing urban air pollution and greenhouse gases during operation.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during the use phase depends heavily on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources (solar, wind) result in lower emissions, while coal-based electricity increases the carbon footprint.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Combustion Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Improvements in fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, but they remain higher than those of EVs powered by clean energy.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries are critical. Improper disposal can lead to soil and water contamination. However, advances in battery recycling technology are improving the sustainability of EVs.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Other components can be recycled similarly to traditional vehicles, though the complexity of EVs can pose challenges.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are generally easier to recycle, with established processes for metals and other materials.\n- **Environmental Impact:** The end-of-life impact is less severe compared to the challenges posed by EV batteries.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, electric vehicles tend to have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases due to battery production. However, they offer significant environmental benefits during the use phase, particularly when powered by renewable energy sources, due to zero tailpipe emissions. The end-of-life phase presents challenges for both types of vehicles, but advancements in recycling technologies are helping mitigate these impacts. In contrast, traditional gasoline vehicles have a lower initial environmental impact but contribute more significantly to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their use phase.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining the entire lifecycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase to end-of-life disposal, to assess their overall environmental impact." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining the entire lifecycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase to end-of-life disposal, to assess their overall environmental impact.", + "I can answer by focusing on specific environmental factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource consumption. I will compare how each type of vehicle performs in these areas, considering both direct emissions (like tailpipe emissions for gasoline vehicles) and indirect emissions (such as those from electricity generation for EVs).", + "I can answer by looking at regional variations in environmental impacts. This involves analyzing how the environmental benefits or drawbacks of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles may differ depending on the energy mix of the electricity grid in different areas, as well as local policies and infrastructure for vehicle manufacturing and recycling.", + "I can answer by exploring the impact of technological advancements and future trends. This approach would look into how improvements in battery technology, renewable energy integration, and vehicle efficiency could alter the current environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles, providing a forward-looking perspective." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining the entire lifecycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase to end-of-life disposal, to assess their overall environmental impact." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:09.231260", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 27 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_28.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_28.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..20da40d550a1ef02665ea7a504c3cf6656be4a11 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_28.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "fb91c060-43c7-4576-8555-1cb4104f191f", + "ibfs_id": "f7e4e340-0d32-448e-85b2-8d79b62f473a", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions, decrease reliance on fossil fuels, promote cleaner energy use, but require resource-intensive battery production.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, a lifecycle analysis (LCA) is conducted. This analysis considers the entire lifecycle of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction through manufacturing, usage, and disposal. Here is a detailed comparison based on each phase:\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Batteries:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other rare earth metals. Mining these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** Like gasoline vehicles, EVs require steel, aluminum, and plastics, but the battery materials add additional environmental burdens.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling and refining processes that can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Materials:** Gasoline vehicles also require steel, aluminum, and plastics, but they do not need the same rare metals as EVs.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in manufacturing processes are reducing these impacts over time.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Less Energy-Intensive:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is generally less energy-intensive than for EVs, primarily due to the absence of large battery packs.\n\n### 3. Usage Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during the usage phase depends on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources (solar, wind) result in lower emissions, while coal or natural gas can increase the carbon footprint.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Improvements in fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, but they remain higher than those of EVs powered by clean energy.\n\n### 4. Disposal and Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal of EV batteries poses challenges due to the hazardous materials involved. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable materials like lithium and cobalt.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, EVs can be recycled for their metal components, but the battery remains a significant concern.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Established Recycling Processes:** Gasoline vehicles have well-established recycling processes for metals and other materials, but they still generate waste and emissions during disposal.\n\n### Overall Environmental Impact\n\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** Over their entire lifecycle, EVs generally produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline vehicles, especially when powered by renewable energy.\n- **Air Quality:** EVs contribute to improved air quality due to the absence of tailpipe emissions.\n- **Resource Use:** EVs require more resource-intensive materials for battery production, but advancements in recycling and sustainable mining practices can mitigate some impacts.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs have higher environmental impacts during the production phase due to battery manufacturing, they offer significant benefits during the usage phase, particularly in reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving air quality. The overall lifecycle impact of EVs is generally lower than that of gasoline vehicles, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies advance.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production through end-of-life. This approach considers raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal phases to provide a comprehensive overview of total environmental impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production through end-of-life. This approach considers raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal phases to provide a comprehensive overview of total environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions perspective, comparing the greenhouse gas emissions and air pollutants associated with the operational phase of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves analyzing data related to tailpipe emissions from gasoline vehicles versus the emissions related to electricity generation for EVs.", + "I can answer by exploring the resource consumption and sustainability angle, assessing the impact of resource extraction for batteries in electric vehicles compared to the resource use in gasoline production. This approach would delve into the mining of lithium, cobalt, and other materials used in EV batteries, and compare it to oil extraction and refining processes.", + "I can answer by examining the regional and geographical differences in environmental impacts, considering how the source of electricity (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and local environmental regulations affect the performance of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles in different parts of the world. This strategy highlights how local energy grids and policies can influence the overall environmental footprint of EVs." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production through end-of-life. This approach considers raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal phases to provide a comprehensive overview of total environmental impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:48.491159", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 28 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_29.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_29.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..84331d7d1caa0003882d58338854bcb6af0776fd --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_29.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c9439490-5c03-4e32-9155-aaad32f24549", + "ibfs_id": "9b8cec6c-8f0d-4775-829a-0b92398926d9", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles generally reduce greenhouse gas emissions, improve air quality, and decrease fossil fuel dependence compared to traditional vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To address the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can review scientific literature and meta-analyses that focus on key aspects such as carbon footprint, air pollution, and resource consumption.\n\n**1. Carbon Footprint:**\n\nA meta-analysis by Hawkins et al. (2013) in the \"Journal of Industrial Ecology\" provides a comprehensive review of the life cycle greenhouse gas emissions of electric vehicles compared to conventional vehicles. The study concludes that while the production phase of electric vehicles, particularly the battery manufacturing, results in higher emissions, the overall life cycle emissions are generally lower for EVs when powered by low-carbon electricity sources. Specifically, the use phase emissions of EVs are significantly lower due to the absence of tailpipe emissions.\n\nA more recent study by Miotti et al. (2016) in \"Environmental Science & Technology\" supports these findings, indicating that the carbon footprint of EVs is highly dependent on the energy mix used for electricity generation. In regions where renewable energy constitutes a significant portion of the grid, EVs offer substantial reductions in greenhouse gas emissions over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n**2. Air Pollution:**\n\nA study published in \"Nature Sustainability\" by Tessum et al. (2019) examines the air quality impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. The research highlights that EVs contribute to reduced air pollution levels, particularly in urban areas, due to the elimination of tailpipe emissions, which are a major source of urban air pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM). The study emphasizes that the benefits are maximized when the electricity used to charge EVs is generated from clean energy sources.\n\n**3. Resource Consumption:**\n\nThe resource consumption aspect, particularly concerning the materials used in battery production, is addressed in a study by Dunn et al. (2015) in \"Environmental Science & Technology.\" The research points out that the extraction and processing of lithium, cobalt, and other materials used in lithium-ion batteries have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and water pollution. However, the study also notes ongoing advancements in battery recycling and the development of alternative battery chemistries that could mitigate these impacts.\n\nA meta-analysis by Ellingsen et al. (2014) in \"Journal of Industrial Ecology\" further discusses the potential for reducing the environmental impact of battery production through improved recycling processes and more efficient use of materials. The study suggests that as battery technology evolves and recycling rates improve, the resource consumption impacts of EVs are expected to decrease.\n\nIn summary, scientific literature and meta-analyses indicate that electric vehicles generally offer environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of reduced greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution. However, the environmental advantages are contingent upon the energy sources used for electricity generation and advancements in battery technology and recycling.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by reviewing scientific literature and meta-analyses on the subject, summarizing key findings from recent studies that compare the carbon footprint, air pollution, and resource consumption associated with each type of vehicle." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include analyzing the sourcing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, operational emissions, and end-of-life recycling or disposal.", + "I can answer by reviewing scientific literature and meta-analyses on the subject, summarizing key findings from recent studies that compare the carbon footprint, air pollution, and resource consumption associated with each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by creating a case study comparison of specific vehicle models, one electric and one gasoline, to demonstrate how their environmental impacts differ based on factors like efficiency, geographic location, and energy source for electricity generation.", + "I can answer by examining policy and industry reports that evaluate the broader societal and ecological effects of transitioning from gasoline to electric vehicles, including impacts on energy infrastructure, mining practices for battery materials, and potential changes in urban air quality and public health." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by reviewing scientific literature and meta-analyses on the subject, summarizing key findings from recent studies that compare the carbon footprint, air pollution, and resource consumption associated with each type of vehicle." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:12.993952", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 29 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_3.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_3.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..730e4d683519bd0567b96386b1bc33cdda1f1c02 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_3.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "8ac5ec5e-2b64-451e-af70-29e9ed08f127", + "ibfs_id": "a98443f7-ef1a-4882-917e-a383b08211c7", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and reliance on fossil fuels, but battery production and disposal have environmental impacts.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, I reviewed and synthesized findings from current scientific literature and reports from credible sources, including environmental agencies, research institutions, and industry analyses. Here are the key insights:\n\n1. **Greenhouse Gas Emissions**:\n - **Lifecycle Emissions**: According to a report by the International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT), electric vehicles generally produce fewer greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles. This includes emissions from vehicle manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life disposal. The reduction in emissions is more pronounced when the electricity used to charge EVs comes from renewable sources.\n - **Operational Emissions**: EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces GHG emissions during the operational phase compared to gasoline vehicles that emit CO2 and other pollutants directly from combustion.\n\n2. **Air Pollution**:\n - **Local Air Quality**: EVs contribute to improved local air quality because they do not emit nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM) from tailpipes, which are common pollutants from gasoline vehicles. Studies, such as those by the European Environment Agency (EEA), highlight the potential for EVs to reduce urban air pollution significantly.\n - **Upstream Emissions**: While EVs do not emit pollutants during operation, the electricity generation process can contribute to air pollution if fossil fuels are used. However, the shift towards renewable energy sources is mitigating these upstream emissions.\n\n3. **Resource Depletion**:\n - **Battery Production**: The production of lithium-ion batteries for EVs involves mining for materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and water pollution. Reports from the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS) emphasize the need for sustainable mining practices and recycling to minimize these impacts.\n - **Oil Extraction**: Gasoline vehicles rely on oil extraction and refining, which also have substantial environmental impacts, including oil spills and habitat disruption.\n\n4. **Energy Consumption**:\n - **Efficiency**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. The U.S. Department of Energy reports that electric drivetrains convert over 60% of electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, compared to about 20% for gasoline vehicles.\n - **Renewable Energy Integration**: The increasing integration of renewable energy into the grid enhances the environmental benefits of EVs. As more electricity is generated from wind, solar, and other renewable sources, the overall carbon footprint of EVs continues to decrease.\n\n5. **Technological Advancements**:\n - **Battery Technology**: Advances in battery technology, such as increased energy density and reduced reliance on rare materials, are improving the environmental performance of EVs. Research from institutions like the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) suggests that these advancements will further reduce the environmental impact of battery production and disposal.\n - **Renewable Energy**: The transition to renewable energy sources for electricity generation is crucial for maximizing the environmental benefits of EVs. Reports from the International Energy Agency (IEA) indicate that policies promoting renewable energy adoption are key to reducing the carbon footprint of EVs.\n\n**Consensus and Differences**:\nThere is a broad consensus among researchers that EVs offer significant environmental benefits over gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of reducing GHG emissions and improving air quality. However, the extent of these benefits can vary depending on factors such as the energy mix of the electricity grid and the lifecycle management of batteries. Differences in regional energy policies and infrastructure also influence the overall environmental impact of EVs.\n\n**Implications**:\nThe continued development of cleaner energy sources and battery technologies will enhance the environmental advantages of EVs. Policymakers and industry stakeholders are encouraged to support these advancements to ensure that the transition to electric mobility contributes positively to environmental sustainability.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by reviewing and synthesizing current scientific literature and reports from credible sources such as environmental agencies, research institutions, and automotive industry analyses. This approach would involve gathering data and findings from various studies that have evaluated the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles. I would focus on summarizing key insights related to greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, resource depletion, and energy consumption. Additionally, I would highlight any consensus or significant differences among researchers, and discuss the implications of technological advancements, such as improvements in battery technology or the increased use of renewable energy for electricity generation, on the environmental performance of electric vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a detailed comparative analysis of the life cycle assessments (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life cycle\u2014manufacturing, usage, and disposal. I would look into the raw material extraction, especially the mining of lithium for EV batteries, and compare it to the extraction and refining processes for gasoline. Additionally, I would assess the emissions during the vehicle's operation, including tailpipe emissions for gasoline vehicles and the emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs. Finally, I would explore the end-of-life disposal or recycling processes for both types of vehicles and their components.", + "I can answer by reviewing and synthesizing current scientific literature and reports from credible sources such as environmental agencies, research institutions, and automotive industry analyses. This approach would involve gathering data and findings from various studies that have evaluated the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles. I would focus on summarizing key insights related to greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, resource depletion, and energy consumption. Additionally, I would highlight any consensus or significant differences among researchers, and discuss the implications of technological advancements, such as improvements in battery technology or the increased use of renewable energy for electricity generation, on the environmental performance of electric vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by reviewing and synthesizing current scientific literature and reports from credible sources such as environmental agencies, research institutions, and automotive industry analyses. This approach would involve gathering data and findings from various studies that have evaluated the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles. I would focus on summarizing key insights related to greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, resource depletion, and energy consumption. Additionally, I would highlight any consensus or significant differences among researchers, and discuss the implications of technological advancements, such as improvements in battery technology or the increased use of renewable energy for electricity generation, on the environmental performance of electric vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:52.495929", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 3 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_30.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_30.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..037188043613a814914ff95f94a90e4e2377eb8c --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_30.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "83c21372-f405-4a59-b342-732982b50d93", + "ibfs_id": "613b8b6c-da66-4598-9d51-f87d9a604abd", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution compared to gasoline vehicles, but battery production and disposal present environmental challenges.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we can analyze the greenhouse gas emissions produced throughout their life cycles. This includes the manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life stages for both vehicle types.\n\n### Manufacturing Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- The manufacturing of EVs typically results in higher greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to the production of lithium-ion batteries. Mining and processing the raw materials (such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel) and the energy-intensive battery manufacturing process contribute significantly to these emissions.\n- Studies estimate that the production of an EV can emit approximately 15-68% more greenhouse gases than a conventional gasoline vehicle, largely depending on the size of the battery and the energy sources used in the manufacturing process.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The manufacturing emissions for gasoline vehicles are generally lower than for EVs, as they do not require large batteries. However, they still involve emissions from the extraction and processing of materials like steel, aluminum, and plastics.\n- The overall manufacturing emissions are relatively stable and well-understood, as the process has been optimized over many decades.\n\n### Operational Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- During operation, EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces their greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- The emissions associated with EV operation depend on the electricity source used for charging. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources (like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power), the operational emissions are very low. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, the emissions can be higher, though still generally lower than those from gasoline vehicles.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2) and other greenhouse gases directly from the tailpipe during operation. These emissions are a major contributor to their overall environmental impact.\n- The fuel efficiency of the vehicle plays a significant role in determining the level of emissions, with more efficient vehicles emitting less CO2 per mile traveled.\n\n### End-of-Life Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- The end-of-life stage for EVs involves the recycling or disposal of the battery, which can be challenging due to the hazardous materials involved. However, advancements in battery recycling technologies are helping to mitigate these impacts.\n- Proper recycling can recover valuable materials and reduce the overall environmental footprint of the battery.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- The end-of-life process for gasoline vehicles is well-established, with many parts being recyclable. However, the disposal of engine oils and other fluids can pose environmental risks.\n- The overall emissions from this stage are generally lower than those from the manufacturing and operational stages.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nWhen considering the entire life cycle, electric vehicles tend to have a lower overall greenhouse gas emissions profile compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly as the electricity grid becomes cleaner. While the manufacturing stage of EVs is more emission-intensive due to battery production, their operational emissions are significantly lower, especially when powered by renewable energy. The end-of-life impacts are still being optimized, with ongoing improvements in recycling technologies. Overall, the transition to electric vehicles is seen as a positive step towards reducing transportation-related greenhouse gas emissions.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include assessing the emissions and resource use associated with manufacturing, operating, and recycling each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced throughout the life cycle of both vehicle types, specifically analyzing the differences in greenhouse gas emissions during the manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life stages for electric and gasoline vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include assessing the emissions and resource use associated with manufacturing, operating, and recycling each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by focusing on specific environmental factors, such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource depletion. This approach would involve comparing the emissions produced during vehicle operation, as well as the impact of sourcing and disposing of materials used in batteries versus traditional fuel.", + "I can answer by analyzing case studies and real-world data from regions that have implemented electric vehicles extensively. By examining the changes in air quality, energy consumption patterns, and economic impacts in these areas, I can provide insights into the broader environmental effects of transitioning from gasoline to electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring expert opinions and research studies from environmental scientists and automotive engineers. This approach would involve summarizing findings from academic journals, reports from environmental organizations, and insights from industry experts to provide a comprehensive view of the environmental impacts of both types of vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle analysis, which examines the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include assessing the emissions and resource use associated with manufacturing, operating, and recycling each type of vehicle." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced throughout the life cycle of both vehicle types, specifically analyzing the differences in greenhouse gas emissions during the manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life stages for electric and gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining the resource extraction processes involved, comparing the environmental impacts of mining for electric vehicle battery materials, such as lithium and cobalt, versus the extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by evaluating the energy consumption and efficiency of both vehicle types throughout their life cycles, considering how the source of electricity for charging electric vehicles (renewable vs. non-renewable) affects their overall environmental impact compared to the fuel consumption of gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by assessing the recycling and disposal processes for each vehicle type, investigating how the disposal of batteries and other components of electric vehicles compares environmentally to the disposal of gasoline vehicle parts, and exploring advancements in recycling technologies that mitigate these impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced throughout the life cycle of both vehicle types, specifically analyzing the differences in greenhouse gas emissions during the manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life stages for electric and gasoline vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:19.070549", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 30 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_31.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_31.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1f32b812131ec68ef8a613693186cef12a0c8cff --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_31.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "1faa42c9-2a74-4b26-bd9c-4ca6c64d1590", + "ibfs_id": "886acc5f-06fa-4156-94e4-dde87a044eb2", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but battery production has environmental impacts compared to traditional gasoline vehicle emissions.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their operation stage, we need to focus on emissions and energy efficiency.\n\n### Emissions During Operation\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Direct Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions during operation. This means they do not emit pollutants such as carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), or particulate matter (PM) while being driven.\n - **Indirect Emissions:** The environmental impact of EVs during operation largely depends on the source of the electricity used to charge them. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the indirect emissions are minimal. However, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels such as coal or natural gas, the emissions associated with generating that electricity can be significant.\n - **Grid Mix Impact:** In regions where the grid is cleaner (i.e., has a higher percentage of renewable energy), the overall emissions from EVs are lower. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal or other fossil fuels, the emissions are higher.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Direct Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, and PM directly from the tailpipe as a result of burning gasoline. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change.\n - **Fuel Combustion:** The combustion of gasoline in internal combustion engines is less efficient and results in higher emissions per mile compared to EVs charged from a clean grid.\n\n### Energy Efficiency\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 60% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels. This is significantly higher than the efficiency of internal combustion engines.\n - **Regenerative Braking:** EVs often use regenerative braking, which recovers energy that would otherwise be lost during braking and stores it in the battery, further improving efficiency.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Efficiency:** Internal combustion engines typically convert only about 20-30% of the energy stored in gasoline into power at the wheels. The rest is lost as heat and through other inefficiencies.\n - **Fuel Economy:** While advancements have been made to improve the fuel economy of gasoline vehicles, they still lag behind the energy efficiency of EVs.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nDuring the operation stage, electric vehicles have a clear advantage over gasoline vehicles in terms of emissions and energy efficiency. EVs produce no direct emissions and are more energy-efficient. However, the overall environmental impact of EVs depends significantly on the electricity generation mix. As the grid becomes cleaner with more renewable energy sources, the environmental benefits of EVs during their operation stage will continue to increase. In contrast, gasoline vehicles consistently emit pollutants and are less efficient, contributing more to environmental degradation during their operation.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric and traditional gasoline vehicles, examining the environmental impacts from production, operation, and disposal stages. This approach considers the total environmental footprint of both vehicle types over their entire life span.", + "I can answer by concentrating on the operation stage, comparing the emissions and energy efficiency of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their use. This would involve analyzing the source of electricity used for charging electric vehicles and comparing it with the direct emissions from gasoline vehicle operation." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric and traditional gasoline vehicles, examining the environmental impacts from production, operation, and disposal stages. This approach considers the total environmental footprint of both vehicle types over their entire life span.", + "I can answer by reviewing scientific literature and studies that focus on the emissions and pollution differences between electric and gasoline vehicles, highlighting key findings about greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, and energy consumption.", + "I can answer by exploring the geopolitical and resource extraction implications of electric and gasoline vehicles, analyzing how the need for materials like lithium, cobalt, and fossil fuels affects ecosystems and communities around the world.", + "I can answer by creating a case study analysis of specific regions or cities that have implemented electric vehicle initiatives, assessing the local environmental changes compared to areas with predominantly gasoline vehicle use. This would provide practical insights into real-world impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric and traditional gasoline vehicles, examining the environmental impacts from production, operation, and disposal stages. This approach considers the total environmental footprint of both vehicle types over their entire life span." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the production stage, conducting a detailed analysis of the raw materials and energy consumption involved in manufacturing electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach will highlight the specific environmental impacts associated with material extraction, manufacturing processes, and supply chain logistics.", + "I can answer by concentrating on the operation stage, comparing the emissions and energy efficiency of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their use. This would involve analyzing the source of electricity used for charging electric vehicles and comparing it with the direct emissions from gasoline vehicle operation.", + "I can answer by delving into the disposal stage, evaluating the environmental impacts of end-of-life management for electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This includes examining recycling processes, waste management of batteries, and the environmental cost of vehicle decommissioning.", + "I can answer by integrating regional differences into the lifecycle analysis, assessing how geographic variations in energy sources, manufacturing practices, and waste management infrastructures influence the comparative environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles in different regions." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by concentrating on the operation stage, comparing the emissions and energy efficiency of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles during their use. This would involve analyzing the source of electricity used for charging electric vehicles and comparing it with the direct emissions from gasoline vehicle operation." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:23.576451", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 31 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_32.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_32.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6b5e5148ed3e8fb9384348d413c55d96fa3fdc54 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_32.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "7518f790-161e-4cca-887a-990acadeda6a", + "ibfs_id": "f89fc09e-6bb4-447b-8a09-d3ccf57274c6", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and fossil fuel dependence but have battery production and disposal environmental impacts compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles through a component-level lifecycle assessment, we need to examine the major components of each vehicle type: batteries, engines, and chassis. This assessment will consider the environmental impacts from raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal.\n\n### 1. Batteries (Electric Vehicles)\n\n**Raw Material Extraction:**\n- **Lithium, Cobalt, Nickel, and Graphite:** These materials are critical for lithium-ion batteries used in EVs. Mining these elements can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Environmental Concerns:** Cobalt mining, particularly in the Democratic Republic of Congo, raises concerns about human rights and environmental degradation.\n\n**Manufacturing:**\n- **Energy-Intensive Process:** Battery production is energy-intensive, contributing to higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Emissions:** The manufacturing process emits greenhouse gases and other pollutants, although advancements are being made to reduce these impacts.\n\n**Usage:**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, reducing urban air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation.\n- **Efficiency:** Electric motors are more efficient than internal combustion engines, leading to lower energy consumption per mile.\n\n**Disposal and Recycling:**\n- **Recycling Challenges:** Battery recycling is complex but crucial to mitigate environmental impacts. Efforts are underway to improve recycling rates and processes.\n- **Potential for Reuse:** Used EV batteries can be repurposed for energy storage, extending their lifecycle.\n\n### 2. Engines (Gasoline Vehicles)\n\n**Raw Material Extraction:**\n- **Steel, Aluminum, and Plastics:** These materials are used extensively in engine manufacturing, with environmental impacts from mining and refining.\n- **Oil Extraction:** The extraction and refining of oil for gasoline contribute to significant environmental degradation and greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n**Manufacturing:**\n- **Complex Manufacturing:** Internal combustion engines (ICEs) require numerous components, each with its own environmental footprint.\n- **Emissions:** The manufacturing process emits pollutants, though typically less than battery production.\n\n**Usage:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** ICEs are generally less efficient than electric motors, leading to higher energy consumption and emissions per mile.\n\n**Disposal and Recycling:**\n- **Engine Recycling:** Engines can be recycled, but the process is less complex than battery recycling.\n- **Oil Waste:** Used oil and other fluids pose environmental hazards if not properly managed.\n\n### 3. Chassis (Both Vehicle Types)\n\n**Raw Material Extraction:**\n- **Steel and Aluminum:** Both EVs and gasoline vehicles use similar materials for the chassis, with environmental impacts from mining and processing.\n- **Environmental Concerns:** The extraction and processing of these materials can lead to habitat destruction and pollution.\n\n**Manufacturing:**\n- **Similar Processes:** The manufacturing processes for chassis are similar for both vehicle types, with energy consumption and emissions.\n- **Lightweight Materials:** Increasing use of lightweight materials like aluminum can reduce overall vehicle emissions by improving fuel efficiency.\n\n**Usage:**\n- **Durability and Efficiency:** The design and materials of the chassis can impact vehicle efficiency and lifespan, affecting overall environmental impact.\n\n**Disposal and Recycling:**\n- **Recyclability:** Steel and aluminum are highly recyclable, reducing the environmental impact at the end of the vehicle's life.\n- **Waste Management:** Proper disposal and recycling of chassis materials are crucial to minimizing environmental impacts.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nWhile electric vehicles have higher environmental impacts during the production phase, particularly due to battery manufacturing, they offer significant benefits during the usage phase with zero tailpipe emissions and higher efficiency. Gasoline vehicles, on the other hand, have lower initial production impacts but contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational life. The overall lifecycle assessment suggests that EVs have the potential for lower total environmental impacts, especially as battery technology and recycling processes improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles throughout their entire lifecycle. This includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and disposal or recycling at end-of-life.", + "I can answer by conducting a component-level lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves breaking down the vehicles into their major components\u2014such as batteries, engines, and chassis\u2014and evaluating the environmental impacts associated with each component from raw material extraction to disposal." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles throughout their entire lifecycle. This includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and disposal or recycling at end-of-life.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational emissions of each vehicle type. This approach would analyze the greenhouse gas emissions produced during the use phase of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles, considering the energy sources used to generate electricity and the efficiency of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by exploring the resource extraction and material usage for both vehicle types. This would involve comparing the environmental consequences of mining and processing materials like lithium and cobalt for electric vehicles with oil extraction and refining for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining regional and policy influences, which involves analyzing how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles differ based on geographic location and governmental regulations. This approach would consider factors like the energy grid's carbon intensity, tax incentives, and emission standards that vary by country or region." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles throughout their entire lifecycle. This includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and disposal or recycling at end-of-life." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a component-level lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves breaking down the vehicles into their major components\u2014such as batteries, engines, and chassis\u2014and evaluating the environmental impacts associated with each component from raw material extraction to disposal.", + "I can answer by focusing on regional lifecycle assessments, where I evaluate the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles based on specific geographic regions. This approach considers regional variations in energy sources, manufacturing practices, and recycling capabilities, providing a localized perspective on their environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by integrating a usage-phase focused lifecycle assessment, which emphasizes the environmental impacts during the operation phase of the vehicles. This approach analyzes factors like electricity grid mix for electric vehicles, fuel efficiency, and emissions during the driving phase, allowing a thorough comparison based on real-world usage scenarios.", + "I can answer by employing a time-based lifecycle assessment, which examines how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles change over time. This approach considers technological advancements, changes in energy sources, and improvements in recycling technologies that might alter the lifecycle impacts of both types of vehicles in the future." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a component-level lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves breaking down the vehicles into their major components\u2014such as batteries, engines, and chassis\u2014and evaluating the environmental impacts associated with each component from raw material extraction to disposal." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:27.300771", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 32 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_33.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_33.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ce1951d8cfcff4e36c59703b7e398b0f53970790 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_33.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "ecaf30e7-e65c-4049-8fa8-55135478c6c1", + "ibfs_id": "a7466193-2dde-4e77-9306-b32f5aa74153", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles offer lower emissions and reduced pollution over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles, benefiting environmental health significantly.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, it is essential to examine the lifecycle emissions of both vehicle types. This involves considering emissions from the production, operational, and disposal phases.\n\n### 1. Production Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** The production of EVs, particularly the manufacturing of lithium-ion batteries, is energy-intensive and results in significant emissions. Mining and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel contribute to these emissions. The energy used in battery manufacturing often comes from fossil fuels, especially if the production occurs in regions with carbon-intensive energy grids.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing:** Besides the battery, the rest of the EV components generally have similar manufacturing emissions to those of gasoline vehicles.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Drivetrain:** The production of internal combustion engines and associated components involves significant emissions, though typically less than the battery production for EVs.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing:** Similar to EVs, the manufacturing of the vehicle body and other components contribute to emissions, but the absence of a large battery reduces the overall production emissions compared to EVs.\n\n### 2. Operational Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Electricity Source:** The operational emissions of EVs depend heavily on the electricity source. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources, EVs have very low operational emissions. However, if the electricity comes from coal or other fossil fuels, the emissions can be higher.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Combustion:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe during operation. These emissions are a significant contributor to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction, refining, and distribution of gasoline also contribute to emissions, though these are often less visible than tailpipe emissions.\n\n### 3. Disposal Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal phase for EVs involves challenges and opportunities in battery recycling. Proper recycling can mitigate some environmental impacts by recovering valuable materials, reducing the need for new raw material extraction. However, improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, the rest of the EV can be recycled, but the presence of the battery adds complexity.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **End-of-Life Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle, with established processes for recovering metals and other materials. However, they do not have the same level of complexity as EVs due to the absence of large batteries.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nWhen considering lifecycle emissions, electric vehicles generally have higher emissions during the production phase due to battery manufacturing but lower emissions during the operational phase, especially when powered by renewable energy. Gasoline vehicles have lower production emissions but significantly higher operational emissions due to fuel combustion. The disposal phase presents challenges for both, with EVs facing additional complexity due to battery recycling. Overall, the environmental impact of EVs can be lower than gasoline vehicles, particularly as the energy grid becomes cleaner and battery recycling technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions comparison during the operational phase of both vehicle types. This approach will look at the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles versus the emissions associated with electricity generation for electric vehicles, considering different energy sources such as coal, natural gas, and renewables.", + "I can answer by examining the lifecycle emissions of both vehicle types, including production, operational, and disposal phases. This will provide a broader view of emissions beyond just the operational phase, highlighting how manufacturing processes and end-of-life recycling affect the total emissions profile of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment that examines the entire lifespan of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include analyzing the environmental impact of raw material extraction, vehicle manufacturing, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life disposal or recycling.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions comparison during the operational phase of both vehicle types. This approach will look at the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles versus the emissions associated with electricity generation for electric vehicles, considering different energy sources such as coal, natural gas, and renewables.", + "I can answer by evaluating the impact of resource extraction and battery production for electric vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental effects of mining for lithium, cobalt, and other materials necessary for electric vehicle batteries, compared to the extraction and refinement of oil for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by investigating the broader environmental implications, such as the impact on air quality and noise pollution in urban areas. This approach would consider how the adoption of electric vehicles can lead to cleaner city air and quieter streets compared to traditional gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions comparison during the operational phase of both vehicle types. This approach will look at the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles versus the emissions associated with electricity generation for electric vehicles, considering different energy sources such as coal, natural gas, and renewables." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a comparative analysis of the emissions related to the energy source mix for electricity generation in different regions. This approach will consider how the predominant use of coal, natural gas, or renewables in a specific area impacts the overall emissions associated with charging electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining the lifecycle emissions of both vehicle types, including production, operational, and disposal phases. This will provide a broader view of emissions beyond just the operational phase, highlighting how manufacturing processes and end-of-life recycling affect the total emissions profile of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by evaluating the impact of technological advancements and policy changes on emissions during the operational phase. This approach will look at how improvements in fuel efficiency for gasoline vehicles and advancements in battery technology and grid decarbonization for electric vehicles influence their emissions over time.", + "I can answer by analyzing the emissions produced by electric vehicles when charged using different types of electric grids, such as smart grids or microgrids. This approach will consider how innovations in grid technology can optimize energy use and reduce emissions compared to traditional grid systems." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by examining the lifecycle emissions of both vehicle types, including production, operational, and disposal phases. This will provide a broader view of emissions beyond just the operational phase, highlighting how manufacturing processes and end-of-life recycling affect the total emissions profile of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:33.896201", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 33 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_34.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_34.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bd2baa307d69909e99d7c3a18a7ed2921c40b8ff --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_34.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "9b15b04b-c7e1-4b91-862b-5ed520318ab7", + "ibfs_id": "d5b8860b-bce6-4b8d-a490-7aa15af44640", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles significantly reduce greenhouse gases and air pollutants compared to gasoline vehicles, but battery production and disposal remain impactful.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can perform a cradle-to-grave analysis focusing on the carbon footprint. This involves assessing the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions at each stage of the vehicle's lifecycle: raw material extraction, manufacturing, operational use, and end-of-life disposal.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other materials. Mining and processing these materials are energy-intensive and contribute significantly to GHG emissions. For instance, the production of a typical EV battery can emit approximately 61-106 kg of CO2 per kWh of battery capacity.\n- **Other Components:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, EVs require steel, aluminum, and plastics, which also contribute to emissions during extraction and processing.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction and refining of crude oil into gasoline is a major source of emissions. This process involves significant energy use and results in substantial CO2 emissions.\n- **Vehicle Components:** Like EVs, gasoline vehicles require metals and plastics, contributing to emissions during their extraction and processing.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- Manufacturing EVs, especially the battery, typically results in higher initial emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. The production of the battery alone can account for a significant portion of the vehicle's total manufacturing emissions.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Generally, the manufacturing emissions for gasoline vehicles are lower than for EVs, primarily due to the absence of large battery packs. However, the production of internal combustion engines also contributes to emissions.\n\n### 3. Operational Use\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Electricity Source:** The operational emissions of EVs depend heavily on the electricity mix used for charging. In regions with a high share of renewable energy, EVs have significantly lower operational emissions. For instance, in areas with a predominantly coal-based electricity grid, the emissions can be higher.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid into vehicle movement.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Combustion:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2 directly from the tailpipe during fuel combustion. The average gasoline vehicle emits about 2.3 kg of CO2 per liter of gasoline burned.\n- **Efficiency:** Internal combustion engines are less efficient than electric motors, resulting in higher emissions per kilometer driven.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The recycling of EV batteries can mitigate some of the initial emissions from battery production. However, recycling processes themselves can be energy-intensive and contribute to emissions.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, the recycling of metals and other materials can reduce the overall carbon footprint.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** The recycling of metals and other components can help offset some of the emissions from manufacturing and raw material extraction.\n\n### Overall Comparison\n\n- **Initial Emissions:** EVs generally have higher initial emissions due to battery production. However, these emissions can be offset over time through lower operational emissions.\n- **Operational Emissions:** EVs typically have lower operational emissions, especially in regions with clean electricity grids. Gasoline vehicles have consistent emissions from fuel combustion.\n- **Lifecycle Emissions:** Over their entire lifecycle, EVs can have a lower carbon footprint than gasoline vehicles, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling improves.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs have higher emissions during the manufacturing phase, their lower operational emissions often result in a smaller overall carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles, especially as the energy grid transitions to renewable sources.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This involves analyzing each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, production, and usage, to disposal\u2014and comparing the environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution, associated with each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by conducting a cradle-to-grave analysis specifically focusing on the carbon footprint of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy involves quantifying the total greenhouse gas emissions from the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, operational use, and end-of-life disposal for both vehicle types, providing a detailed comparison of their carbon impacts throughout their entire lifespan." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This involves analyzing each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, production, and usage, to disposal\u2014and comparing the environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution, associated with each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by focusing on the source of the electricity used to power electric vehicles. This approach involves examining how the environmental impacts change based on whether the electricity is generated from renewable sources like solar and wind, or from fossil fuels like coal and natural gas, and comparing these impacts to those of gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by comparing the environmental policies and incentives that influence the adoption of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This strategy involves looking at how government regulations, subsidies, and tax incentives impact the environmental footprint of both types of vehicles, considering the role of policy in encouraging the use of cleaner technologies.", + "I can answer by examining the technological advancements in battery production and recycling for electric vehicles. This involves analyzing how improvements in battery efficiency, longevity, and recycling processes can mitigate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles, focusing on specific technological innovations and their ecological effects." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This involves analyzing each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, production, and usage, to disposal\u2014and comparing the environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution, associated with each type of vehicle." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a cradle-to-grave analysis specifically focusing on the carbon footprint of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy involves quantifying the total greenhouse gas emissions from the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, operational use, and end-of-life disposal for both vehicle types, providing a detailed comparison of their carbon impacts throughout their entire lifespan.", + "I can answer by performing a life cycle assessment with an emphasis on resource depletion. This approach examines the extraction and consumption of critical materials like lithium and cobalt for electric vehicle batteries versus the crude oil requirements for gasoline vehicles. It assesses the sustainability and environmental toll of obtaining and using these resources in the context of each vehicle type's life cycle.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative study that highlights the pollution levels during the operational phase of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This involves analyzing emissions of pollutants such as nitrogen oxides, sulfur dioxide, and particulate matter during the usage phase, providing insights on how each vehicle type affects urban air quality and human health.", + "I can answer by implementing a life cycle assessment focused on the disposal and recycling phase of electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy examines the environmental impacts of waste management processes, including battery recycling for electric vehicles and the treatment of end-of-life gasoline engines, to determine the sustainability and pollution potential at the end of each vehicle's life." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a cradle-to-grave analysis specifically focusing on the carbon footprint of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy involves quantifying the total greenhouse gas emissions from the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, operational use, and end-of-life disposal for both vehicle types, providing a detailed comparison of their carbon impacts throughout their entire lifespan." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:38.595356", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 34 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_35.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_35.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..090ed287b8f7cc352faf5c3f2ac8b09001c76334 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_35.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "7dee41f1-7319-445c-8ad2-3cb682cc0948", + "ibfs_id": "1bfcc88b-d944-4440-b6f3-1c814e20399f", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, but their battery production has environmental and resource extraction impacts.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their operation phase using a lifecycle analysis approach, we focus on several key factors: emissions from fuel or electricity consumption, energy use efficiency, and the potential for renewable energy integration.\n\n### Emissions from Fuel or Electricity Consumption\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Electricity Generation:** The emissions associated with EVs during the operation phase depend on the source of the electricity used to charge them. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the emissions are minimal. However, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels such as coal or natural gas, the emissions can be significant.\n - **Direct Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, meaning they do not emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), or particulate matter during operation. This is a significant advantage over gasoline vehicles, especially in urban areas where air quality is a concern.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Fuel Combustion:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, carbon monoxide (CO), and hydrocarbons as a result of burning gasoline. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change.\n - **Lifecycle Emissions:** The emissions from gasoline vehicles are relatively consistent, as they are directly tied to the combustion of fossil fuels.\n\n### Efficiency of Energy Use\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - **Energy Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 77% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, whereas internal combustion engines (ICEs) convert only about 12%\u201330% of the energy stored in gasoline to power at the wheels.\n - **Regenerative Braking:** EVs often use regenerative braking, which recovers energy that would otherwise be lost during braking and feeds it back into the battery, further improving efficiency.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Energy Losses:** A significant portion of the energy in gasoline is lost as heat in the engine, making them less efficient compared to EVs. The efficiency of gasoline engines is limited by thermodynamic constraints.\n\n### Potential for Renewable Energy Integration\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - **Renewable Energy Integration:** EVs have the potential to be powered entirely by renewable energy sources, depending on the electricity grid's composition. As the grid becomes greener, the environmental impact of operating EVs decreases.\n - **Grid Flexibility:** EVs can also support the integration of renewable energy by acting as flexible loads that can be charged during periods of high renewable output, helping to balance supply and demand.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Fossil Fuel Dependency:** Gasoline vehicles are inherently tied to fossil fuels, limiting their potential for renewable energy integration. While biofuels offer some potential for reducing fossil fuel use, they are not yet widely adopted and come with their own environmental challenges.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, during the operation phase, electric vehicles generally have a lower environmental impact compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to their higher energy efficiency and the potential for using renewable energy sources. The actual environmental benefits of EVs depend significantly on the electricity grid's energy mix. As grids become cleaner and more reliant on renewable energy, the advantages of EVs over gasoline vehicles in terms of emissions and environmental impact will continue to grow.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include examining the production, operation, and disposal phases of each vehicle type to assess their overall carbon footprint and resource consumption.", + "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis with a focus on the operation phase, comparing the environmental impacts of using electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles over their typical lifespan. This would include assessing the emissions from fuel or electricity consumption, the efficiency of energy use, and the potential for energy source variability such as renewable energy integration for electric vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include examining the production, operation, and disposal phases of each vehicle type to assess their overall carbon footprint and resource consumption.", + "I can answer by comparing the emissions generated during the operation phase of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach would focus on the emissions produced directly from driving each type of vehicle, taking into account the source of electricity for electric vehicles and the fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring the impact of battery production and disposal for electric vehicles compared to the environmental effects of extracting and refining petroleum for gasoline vehicles. This would involve an analysis of the mining and manufacturing processes for electric vehicle batteries and the lifecycle of fossil fuel production for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining regional differences in environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would involve analyzing how the source of electricity (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and local environmental policies in different regions affect the comparative environmental benefits or drawbacks of each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include examining the production, operation, and disposal phases of each vehicle type to assess their overall carbon footprint and resource consumption." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that focuses specifically on the production phase of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve evaluating the environmental impacts associated with the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, and the energy consumption required to build each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis with a focus on the operation phase, comparing the environmental impacts of using electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles over their typical lifespan. This would include assessing the emissions from fuel or electricity consumption, the efficiency of energy use, and the potential for energy source variability such as renewable energy integration for electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by undertaking a lifecycle analysis that centers on the disposal and recycling phase of both vehicle types. This approach would examine the environmental implications of end-of-life vehicle management, including the recycling of batteries in electric vehicles, handling of hazardous materials, and the potential for reclaiming and reusing vehicle components.", + "I can answer by conducting a detailed lifecycle analysis that incorporates geographical variations in the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would evaluate how differences in regional energy sources, recycling facilities, and manufacturing practices affect the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type, providing a more localized perspective on their impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis with a focus on the operation phase, comparing the environmental impacts of using electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles over their typical lifespan. This would include assessing the emissions from fuel or electricity consumption, the efficiency of energy use, and the potential for energy source variability such as renewable energy integration for electric vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:39.143457", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 35 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_36.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_36.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7b7ada87bfa732bd06674a195883756fe07a8db6 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_36.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "cfc775ca-9899-45b5-b807-84e6855cb3bc", + "ibfs_id": "fc956ff5-2f60-45bf-a985-60fb4ddbdb5a", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution but require rare minerals for batteries, impacting mining practices and disposal sustainability.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through a life cycle assessment (LCA) focused on the raw material extraction and processing stages, we need to examine the materials and processes involved in the production of key components for both types of vehicles.\n\n### Electric Vehicles (EVs)\n\n**1. Battery Production:**\n- **Materials:** The primary component of EVs that requires significant raw material extraction is the battery, typically a lithium-ion battery. Key materials include lithium, cobalt, nickel, manganese, and graphite.\n- **Extraction and Processing:**\n - **Lithium:** Extracted from brine pools or hard rock mining. Brine extraction involves pumping underground brine to the surface and evaporating the water, which can lead to significant water use and potential contamination of local water supplies.\n - **Cobalt and Nickel:** Often mined in regions with less stringent environmental regulations, leading to habitat destruction, soil and water pollution, and significant greenhouse gas emissions from mining operations.\n - **Graphite:** Extracted through mining, which can cause air and water pollution due to the release of dust and chemicals used in processing.\n\n**2. Environmental Impacts:**\n- **Water Usage and Pollution:** High water consumption, particularly for lithium extraction from brines, and potential contamination of water sources.\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** Significant emissions from mining operations and processing, especially for nickel and cobalt.\n- **Ecological Damage:** Habitat destruction and biodiversity loss due to mining activities.\n\n### Traditional Gasoline Vehicles\n\n**1. Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) Production:**\n- **Materials:** The production of an internal combustion engine involves steel, aluminum, and various alloys, which require iron ore, bauxite, and other minerals.\n- **Extraction and Processing:**\n - **Iron Ore and Steel:** Mining iron ore and processing it into steel involves significant energy use, often from fossil fuels, leading to greenhouse gas emissions.\n - **Aluminum:** Extracted from bauxite ore, which involves open-pit mining and a highly energy-intensive refining process known as the Bayer process, followed by smelting.\n\n**2. Environmental Impacts:**\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** High emissions from the energy-intensive processes of steel and aluminum production.\n- **Land Degradation:** Open-pit mining for bauxite and iron ore leads to significant land disturbance and habitat loss.\n- **Air and Water Pollution:** Emissions of particulates and pollutants from mining and processing operations.\n\n### Comparative Analysis\n\n- **Resource Intensity:** EVs require a more diverse range of materials, particularly rare metals, which can lead to higher environmental impacts in terms of resource extraction. However, traditional vehicles require large quantities of steel and aluminum, which are also resource-intensive to produce.\n- **Pollution and Emissions:** Both vehicle types have significant environmental impacts at the raw material extraction stage, but the specific impacts differ. EVs are associated with higher water use and potential pollution from lithium and cobalt mining, while traditional vehicles have higher emissions from steel and aluminum production.\n- **Sustainability Considerations:** The sustainability of EVs at this stage is heavily dependent on the sourcing and processing practices for battery materials. Improvements in recycling and more sustainable mining practices could reduce these impacts.\n\nIn conclusion, while both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles have substantial environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and processing stages, the nature and extent of these impacts vary. EVs face challenges related to the extraction of battery materials, while traditional vehicles are impacted by the energy-intensive production of metals like steel and aluminum. Addressing these challenges through improved technologies and practices is crucial for enhancing the sustainability of both vehicle types.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the environmental impacts from the production of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal for each type of vehicle. By comparing these stages, I can provide a comprehensive overview of which vehicle type has a lower overall environmental footprint.", + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) focused specifically on the raw material extraction and processing stages for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach will delve into the environmental impacts associated with mining and processing the materials needed for batteries and internal combustion engines, providing insight into which vehicle type is more sustainable at the very beginning of their life cycle." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the environmental impacts from the production of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal for each type of vehicle. By comparing these stages, I can provide a comprehensive overview of which vehicle type has a lower overall environmental footprint.", + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the emissions produced during vehicle operation. For this analysis, I would compare the tailpipe emissions of traditional gasoline vehicles with the emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs, taking into account the energy mix of different regions. This approach highlights the differences in air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during the vehicle usage phase.", + "I can answer by examining the resource extraction and material usage required for vehicle production. This approach would look into the environmental impact of mining and processing materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for electric vehicle batteries versus the extraction and refining of oil for gasoline and the materials used in internal combustion engines. This comparison can reveal the ecological consequences and sustainability concerns related to resource consumption.", + "I can answer by exploring policy and societal impacts, such as how the adoption of electric vehicles can influence energy infrastructure, urban planning, and climate change mitigation efforts. This approach would consider governmental incentives for EV adoption, the potential for reducing dependency on fossil fuels, and long-term environmental benefits that might arise from shifting towards a more electrified transport system." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the environmental impacts from the production of raw materials, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal for each type of vehicle. By comparing these stages, I can provide a comprehensive overview of which vehicle type has a lower overall environmental footprint." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) focused specifically on the raw material extraction and processing stages for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach will delve into the environmental impacts associated with mining and processing the materials needed for batteries and internal combustion engines, providing insight into which vehicle type is more sustainable at the very beginning of their life cycle.", + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) that emphasizes the manufacturing and assembly process of EVs and traditional gasoline vehicles. By examining energy consumption, emissions, and waste production during the manufacturing phase, I can highlight the differences in environmental impacts that arise from the production facilities and assembly lines of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) that centers on the usage phase of EVs and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the emissions and energy efficiency during the operational life of the vehicles, considering factors like electricity sources for EVs and fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles, to determine which has a lower environmental impact while in use.", + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) with a focus on the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes for EVs and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach will assess the environmental impacts of decommissioning, recycling, and waste management for each vehicle type, revealing which one has more sustainable practices in place for minimizing environmental harm post-usage." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) focused specifically on the raw material extraction and processing stages for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach will delve into the environmental impacts associated with mining and processing the materials needed for batteries and internal combustion engines, providing insight into which vehicle type is more sustainable at the very beginning of their life cycle." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:58.019767", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 36 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_37.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_37.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f723ef3e34e973dda44b978cd966c9e0727e1ca1 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_37.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "0d22084f-ae76-422a-8e08-8f63869ca321", + "ibfs_id": "b313eb07-eecb-45c4-8d09-dc0edda5b884", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and reliance on fossil fuels but involve environmental challenges in battery production and material sourcing.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles at the manufacturing stage, we need to focus on the extraction and processing of raw materials. This involves examining the environmental consequences of mining for key materials used in EV batteries\u2014such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel\u2014versus the extraction and refinement of crude oil for gasoline vehicles.\n\n### Electric Vehicles: Raw Material Extraction and Processing\n\n1. **Lithium Extraction:**\n - **Sources:** Lithium is primarily extracted from brine pools and hard rock mining. The major sources are located in countries like Australia, Chile, and Argentina.\n - **Environmental Impacts:**\n - **Water Usage:** Brine extraction involves evaporating large amounts of water, which can deplete local water resources, affecting agriculture and local communities.\n - **Land Degradation:** Both brine and hard rock mining can lead to significant land disturbance and habitat destruction.\n - **Chemical Pollution:** The use of chemicals in lithium extraction can lead to soil and water contamination if not managed properly.\n\n2. **Cobalt Extraction:**\n - **Sources:** Cobalt is often a byproduct of nickel and copper mining, with significant production in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC).\n - **Environmental Impacts:**\n - **Toxic Waste:** Mining operations can produce toxic waste that contaminates water supplies.\n - **Land Degradation and Habitat Loss:** Mining activities can lead to deforestation and soil erosion.\n - **Humanitarian Concerns:** In the DRC, artisanal mining practices often involve poor working conditions and child labor, which are ethical rather than environmental concerns but are intertwined with sustainability issues.\n\n3. **Nickel Extraction:**\n - **Sources:** Nickel is mined from sulfide ores and laterite ores, with major producers including Indonesia, the Philippines, and Russia.\n - **Environmental Impacts:**\n - **Energy-Intensive Processing:** The extraction and processing of nickel are energy-intensive, contributing to greenhouse gas emissions.\n - **Acid Mine Drainage:** Sulfide mining can lead to acid mine drainage, which pollutes waterways and harms aquatic life.\n - **Deforestation:** Laterite mining often involves clearing large areas of tropical forest.\n\n### Gasoline Vehicles: Crude Oil Extraction and Refinement\n\n1. **Crude Oil Extraction:**\n - **Sources:** Crude oil is extracted from onshore and offshore oil fields worldwide, with major producers including Saudi Arabia, the United States, and Russia.\n - **Environmental Impacts:**\n - **Oil Spills:** Accidental spills during extraction and transportation can have devastating effects on marine and terrestrial ecosystems.\n - **Habitat Disruption:** Drilling operations can disrupt local ecosystems and wildlife habitats.\n - **Air and Water Pollution:** The extraction process can release volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and other pollutants into the environment.\n\n2. **Oil Refinement:**\n - **Process:** Refining crude oil into gasoline involves several stages, including distillation, cracking, and reforming.\n - **Environmental Impacts:**\n - **Air Pollution:** Refineries emit pollutants such as sulfur dioxide (SO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, which contribute to air quality issues and acid rain.\n - **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** The refining process is energy-intensive and contributes significantly to CO2 emissions.\n - **Waste Production:** Refineries produce solid and liquid waste, which can contaminate soil and water if not properly managed.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, both electric and gasoline vehicles have significant environmental impacts at the manufacturing stage, primarily due to the extraction and processing of raw materials. EVs require mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which can lead to water depletion, habitat destruction, and pollution. Gasoline vehicles rely on crude oil extraction and refinement, which also result in habitat disruption, pollution, and greenhouse gas emissions. While EVs offer benefits in terms of reduced tailpipe emissions during operation, the environmental costs of battery production are a critical factor to consider in their overall environmental footprint.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive lifecycle analysis, comparing the emissions and resource use from manufacturing, operating, and disposing of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would include examining the extraction and processing of raw materials, energy usage during vehicle production, emissions during vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal processes.", + "I can answer by focusing on the manufacturing stage, conducting a detailed analysis of the raw material extraction and processing for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include assessing the environmental impacts of mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries compared to the extraction and refinement of crude oil for gasoline vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive lifecycle analysis, comparing the emissions and resource use from manufacturing, operating, and disposing of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would include examining the extraction and processing of raw materials, energy usage during vehicle production, emissions during vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal processes.", + "I can answer by reviewing and summarizing the latest scientific research and reports from reputable environmental and automotive organizations. This would involve synthesizing findings from peer-reviewed studies and reports to provide a balanced view of the environmental impacts of both types of vehicles, highlighting key factors such as carbon footprints, air quality effects, and resource consumption.", + "I can answer by comparing case studies from countries or cities that have high adoption rates of electric vehicles with those that primarily use gasoline vehicles. This approach would examine real-world data on air pollution levels, greenhouse gas emissions, and other environmental indicators before and after the introduction of EVs, providing insights into their actual impact.", + "I can answer by conducting interviews with experts in environmental science and automotive technology. By gathering insights from engineers, environmentalists, and policy makers, I can provide diverse perspectives on the advantages and disadvantages of electric and gasoline vehicles, focusing on sustainability, technological advancements, and future trends in the industry." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive lifecycle analysis, comparing the emissions and resource use from manufacturing, operating, and disposing of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would include examining the extraction and processing of raw materials, energy usage during vehicle production, emissions during vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal processes." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the manufacturing stage, conducting a detailed analysis of the raw material extraction and processing for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include assessing the environmental impacts of mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries compared to the extraction and refinement of crude oil for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining the operational phase, quantifying the emissions produced during the use of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This would involve comparing the electricity generation sources for EVs in different regions against the emissions from burning gasoline, taking into account the carbon intensity of local energy grids.", + "I can answer by evaluating the end-of-life phase, specifically analyzing the recycling and disposal processes of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This would entail a study of the recyclability of EV batteries and the infrastructure available for battery recycling, as well as the environmental impacts of disposing or recycling traditional vehicle components.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle analysis, assessing how different geographic locations affect the environmental impacts of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles. This would involve looking at regional variations in electricity generation, vehicle usage patterns, and availability of recycling facilities to provide a localized perspective on the overall environmental benefits or drawbacks." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the manufacturing stage, conducting a detailed analysis of the raw material extraction and processing for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include assessing the environmental impacts of mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries compared to the extraction and refinement of crude oil for gasoline vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:52.622382", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 37 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_38.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_38.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3b5a833308d78ad5766ae0cb4e7cc737fa35c530 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_38.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "38f5c688-8c8f-41f2-8afa-ea64cc5d3534", + "ibfs_id": "313fb282-0594-4861-a260-dbf789bfacfd", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, promote renewable energy use, but require resource-intensive battery production affecting ecosystems.", + "final_answer": "To address the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, a thematic analysis of qualitative research papers, industry reports, and case studies reveals several key themes and patterns. These themes include resource extraction practices, battery disposal issues, energy sourcing, and overall emissions.\n\n### 1. Resource Extraction Practices\n\n**Theme:** The extraction of raw materials for EV batteries, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, has significant environmental and social impacts.\n\n- **Lithium Mining:** Research indicates that lithium extraction, particularly in regions like South America, can lead to water depletion and contamination. The process requires large amounts of water, which can affect local ecosystems and communities.\n \n- **Cobalt and Nickel Mining:** Cobalt mining, primarily in the Democratic Republic of Congo, is associated with severe environmental degradation and human rights issues. Reports highlight soil erosion, deforestation, and pollution of water sources as major concerns.\n\n### 2. Battery Disposal and Recycling\n\n**Theme:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries present environmental challenges, but also opportunities for improvement.\n\n- **Disposal Issues:** Qualitative studies emphasize the potential environmental hazards of improper battery disposal, including soil and water contamination from heavy metals.\n \n- **Recycling Opportunities:** Industry reports suggest that advancements in battery recycling technologies can mitigate these impacts. Efficient recycling processes can recover valuable materials, reducing the need for new resource extraction and minimizing waste.\n\n### 3. Energy Sourcing\n\n**Theme:** The environmental impact of EVs is heavily influenced by the energy sources used for electricity generation.\n\n- **Renewable vs. Fossil Fuels:** Case studies show that the carbon footprint of EVs is significantly lower in regions where electricity is predominantly generated from renewable sources. In contrast, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, the benefits are less pronounced.\n \n- **Grid Decarbonization:** Industry reports highlight the importance of grid decarbonization in maximizing the environmental benefits of EVs. As grids become greener, the lifecycle emissions of EVs continue to decrease.\n\n### 4. Overall Emissions\n\n**Theme:** EVs generally produce fewer emissions over their lifecycle compared to gasoline vehicles, but the extent varies based on several factors.\n\n- **Lifecycle Emissions:** Qualitative research consistently finds that EVs have lower lifetime greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline vehicles, even when accounting for manufacturing and end-of-life processes. This is primarily due to the higher efficiency of electric motors and the potential for renewable energy use.\n \n- **Urban Air Quality:** Case studies in urban areas demonstrate that EVs contribute to improved air quality by eliminating tailpipe emissions, which are a significant source of urban pollution.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe thematic analysis of qualitative research papers, industry reports, and case studies reveals that while electric vehicles offer substantial environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of emissions and urban air quality, challenges remain. These include the environmental and social impacts of resource extraction, the need for effective battery recycling, and the importance of clean energy sourcing. Addressing these challenges through technological advancements and policy measures can enhance the positive environmental impacts of electric vehicles.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive literature review of academic and industry research papers comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve summarizing findings on emissions, resource extraction, and lifecycle assessments from various studies to provide a well-rounded overview.", + "I can answer by conducting a thematic analysis of qualitative research papers, industry reports, and case studies. This would involve identifying common themes and patterns related to environmental impacts, such as resource extraction practices, battery disposal issues, and energy sourcing for EVs, to provide a more nuanced understanding of their impacts compared to gasoline vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive literature review of academic and industry research papers comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve summarizing findings on emissions, resource extraction, and lifecycle assessments from various studies to provide a well-rounded overview.", + "I can answer by performing a data-driven analysis using lifecycle assessment tools that model the emissions and resource usage of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve gathering data on manufacturing, operational, and disposal phases to quantitatively compare their overall environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by exploring expert opinions and interviews with environmental scientists and automotive industry specialists. This would involve collecting qualitative insights and perspectives on the long-term sustainability and potential environmental benefits or drawbacks of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by creating a case study comparison of specific regions or countries that have adopted electric vehicles widely. This approach would examine real-world impacts on air quality, energy consumption, and infrastructure development, contrasting these with regions that predominantly use gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive literature review of academic and industry research papers comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve summarizing findings on emissions, resource extraction, and lifecycle assessments from various studies to provide a well-rounded overview." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a meta-analysis of existing research papers that specifically aggregate data on the greenhouse gas emissions from the production and use phases of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve synthesizing quantitative data from multiple studies to present an averaged impact comparison.", + "I can answer by conducting a thematic analysis of qualitative research papers, industry reports, and case studies. This would involve identifying common themes and patterns related to environmental impacts, such as resource extraction practices, battery disposal issues, and energy sourcing for EVs, to provide a more nuanced understanding of their impacts compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by creating a comparative lifecycle assessment (LCA) synthesis that integrates findings from various LCA studies. This would involve detailing the environmental impacts associated with each stage of the vehicle's lifecycle, from raw material extraction to end-of-life disposal, and comparing these impacts across different vehicle types.", + "I can answer by conducting a critical review of policy-driven research papers and governmental reports that discuss the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would focus on how regulatory frameworks and incentives influence the environmental outcomes of vehicle use, and compare these impacts based on the policy context." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a thematic analysis of qualitative research papers, industry reports, and case studies. This would involve identifying common themes and patterns related to environmental impacts, such as resource extraction practices, battery disposal issues, and energy sourcing for EVs, to provide a more nuanced understanding of their impacts compared to gasoline vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:08:55.846540", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 38 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_39.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_39.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2ddd3ecae5f68520fddec0aef350be96580577e6 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_39.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "a5180bea-2397-4748-b2ce-44665f4db8bb", + "ibfs_id": "4c34ca44-58c0-44c1-90d7-e4d3b6e780ef", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and improve air quality but require resource-intensive battery production and raises recycling challenges.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles during their usage phase, we focus on fuel consumption, energy efficiency, and the resulting greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution.\n\n1. **Energy Efficiency**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. They convert over 77% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels. This high efficiency is due to the electric motor's ability to convert electrical energy into motion with minimal energy loss.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: In contrast, gasoline vehicles convert only about 12%\u201330% of the energy stored in gasoline to power at the wheels. The internal combustion engine (ICE) loses a significant amount of energy as heat.\n\n2. **Greenhouse Gas Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: During the usage phase, EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions. However, the overall greenhouse gas emissions depend on the electricity source. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources (such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power), the emissions are significantly lower. Conversely, if the electricity comes from fossil fuels (coal or natural gas), the emissions are higher, though still generally lower than those from gasoline vehicles.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), a major greenhouse gas, directly from the tailpipe as a result of burning gasoline. The emissions are consistent regardless of the fuel source, as they are inherent to the combustion process.\n\n3. **Air Pollution**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs do not emit pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) or particulate matter (PM) during operation. This leads to improved air quality, especially in urban areas. The only indirect emissions come from electricity generation, which can be mitigated by cleaner energy sources.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles emit significant amounts of NOx, hydrocarbons, and PM, contributing to air pollution and health issues like respiratory problems and smog formation. Catalytic converters reduce some of these emissions, but they do not eliminate them entirely.\n\nIn summary, during the usage phase, electric vehicles offer substantial environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles in terms of energy efficiency and reduced greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, particularly when powered by clean electricity sources. The transition to EVs can significantly improve air quality and reduce the carbon footprint of personal transportation, especially as the grid becomes greener.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from raw material extraction, through production, usage, and finally to disposal or recycling. This comprehensive approach considers all stages of the vehicle's life and can highlight differences in environmental impact, such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource usage.", + "I can answer by emphasizing the usage phase in the life cycle assessment, analyzing how differences in fuel consumption and energy efficiency impact the environment. This strategy would particularly assess greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution during the operational life of both electric and gasoline vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from raw material extraction, through production, usage, and finally to disposal or recycling. This comprehensive approach considers all stages of the vehicle's life and can highlight differences in environmental impact, such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource usage.", + "I can answer by focusing on the energy source and emissions during the usage phase. This involves comparing the emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during combustion with the emissions associated with electricity generation for electric vehicles. This approach takes into account the energy mix of the electricity grid, which can greatly influence the environmental impact of electric vehicles depending on whether it relies on renewable sources or fossil fuels.", + "I can answer by examining the supply chain and material sourcing for both types of vehicles. This approach would look at the environmental impact related to extracting and processing materials like lithium, cobalt, and copper for electric vehicles compared to the extraction and refinement of oil for gasoline vehicles. It would highlight the ecological and social considerations tied to material sourcing and the implications these have on the overall environmental impact.", + "I can answer by considering the end-of-life processing and recycling of both vehicle types. This strategy would explore how batteries in electric vehicles are recycled or disposed of compared to the scrapping and recycling processes for gasoline vehicles. It would assess the environmental impact of waste generation and resource recovery, considering how advancements in recycling technology could mitigate some of these impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison, which involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both electric and gasoline vehicles from raw material extraction, through production, usage, and finally to disposal or recycling. This comprehensive approach considers all stages of the vehicle's life and can highlight differences in environmental impact, such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource usage." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a cradle-to-gate life cycle assessment, which examines the environmental impacts from raw material extraction to the point where the vehicles leave the factory. This approach highlights differences in manufacturing processes and supply chain emissions for electric and gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by emphasizing the usage phase in the life cycle assessment, analyzing how differences in fuel consumption and energy efficiency impact the environment. This strategy would particularly assess greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution during the operational life of both electric and gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by conducting a cradle-to-grave life cycle assessment with a particular focus on end-of-life processes, comparing how recycling, waste management, and disposal affect the environmental footprint of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This approach could spotlight the benefits and challenges of battery recycling and the disposal of engine components.", + "I can answer by performing a geographic-specific life cycle assessment that considers regional variations in electricity generation and fuel production. This strategy would assess how the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles differ depending on the local energy grid's reliance on renewable versus fossil fuels, as well as regional manufacturing practices." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by emphasizing the usage phase in the life cycle assessment, analyzing how differences in fuel consumption and energy efficiency impact the environment. This strategy would particularly assess greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution during the operational life of both electric and gasoline vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:16.599251", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 39 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_4.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_4.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2968362023411812724036e3c85319c36065101c --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_4.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "e111650a-da51-4ab2-8237-d29e52bf64f2", + "ibfs_id": "d312e392-257c-4107-81ba-5bd440c80c12", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles generally have lower emissions and reduced environmental impact compared to gasoline vehicles, benefiting air quality and climate change.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, we need to examine two main aspects: emissions and energy efficiency.\n\n**1. Emissions:**\n\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:**\n - **Electric Vehicles (EVs):** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions during their operation. This means they do not emit pollutants such as carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), or particulate matter (PM) while being driven. This is a significant advantage over gasoline vehicles, especially in urban areas where air quality is a concern.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Gasoline vehicles emit various pollutants through their tailpipes, including CO2, NOx, carbon monoxide (CO), and hydrocarbons. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change.\n\n- **Source of Electricity:**\n - The environmental impact of EVs during their operational phase also depends on the source of the electricity used to charge them. If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the overall emissions associated with driving an EV are significantly reduced. However, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels such as coal or natural gas, the emissions associated with electricity production can offset some of the benefits of zero tailpipe emissions.\n - The energy mix varies by region, so the environmental impact of EVs can differ depending on where they are charged. In areas with a high percentage of renewable energy in the grid, EVs have a much lower overall environmental impact compared to regions that rely heavily on fossil fuels.\n\n**2. Energy Efficiency:**\n\n- **Electric Vehicles:**\n - EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 85-90% of electrical energy from the battery to power the wheels. This high efficiency means that a greater proportion of the energy stored in the battery is used for propulsion, resulting in less energy waste.\n \n- **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Internal combustion engines (ICEs) in gasoline vehicles are less efficient, typically converting only about 20-30% of the energy stored in gasoline into motion. The rest is lost as heat and through other inefficiencies in the engine and drivetrain.\n\nThe higher energy efficiency of EVs means that even when accounting for the emissions from electricity generation, they often have a lower overall environmental impact during their operational phase compared to gasoline vehicles. This efficiency advantage, combined with the potential for using renewable energy sources, makes EVs a more environmentally friendly option during their use phase.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, specifically analyzing their emissions and energy efficiency. This approach would delve into the differences in tailpipe emissions, where electric vehicles typically produce none, and the source of electricity for EVs, which can vary in its environmental impact depending on the energy mix (renewable vs. fossil fuels). Additionally, I would compare the energy efficiency of electric motors versus internal combustion engines, highlighting how these differences contribute to the overall environmental footprint during the vehicle's use phase." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, examining each stage from production to disposal. This would include the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage, such as greenhouse gas emissions, water usage, and resource depletion, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how the two types of vehicles differ environmentally.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, specifically analyzing their emissions and energy efficiency. This approach would delve into the differences in tailpipe emissions, where electric vehicles typically produce none, and the source of electricity for EVs, which can vary in its environmental impact depending on the energy mix (renewable vs. fossil fuels). Additionally, I would compare the energy efficiency of electric motors versus internal combustion engines, highlighting how these differences contribute to the overall environmental footprint during the vehicle's use phase." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, specifically analyzing their emissions and energy efficiency. This approach would delve into the differences in tailpipe emissions, where electric vehicles typically produce none, and the source of electricity for EVs, which can vary in its environmental impact depending on the energy mix (renewable vs. fossil fuels). Additionally, I would compare the energy efficiency of electric motors versus internal combustion engines, highlighting how these differences contribute to the overall environmental footprint during the vehicle's use phase." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:42.543692", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 4 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_40.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_40.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6eb4e03762d39fe01be7f2e982106966e0ce3e3c --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_40.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "66f96578-fc10-44fe-9c37-dcad43186d3f", + "ibfs_id": "1279850a-238c-43f8-8c24-ffb5c92dab1a", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce greenhouse emissions over time but pose challenges in battery production and disposal compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we can examine specific environmental factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource consumption. This involves looking at both the operational emissions and the lifecycle impacts of each type of vehicle.\n\n### Greenhouse Gas Emissions\n\n**Operational Emissions:**\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions during operation. However, the electricity used to charge EVs can result in greenhouse gas emissions, depending on the energy mix of the grid. In regions where electricity is primarily generated from renewable sources (e.g., wind, solar, hydroelectric), the emissions associated with EVs are significantly lower. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, emissions can be higher.\n - On average, EVs tend to have lower lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, especially as grids become greener.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2) and other greenhouse gases directly from the tailpipe as a result of burning fossil fuels. These emissions are a significant contributor to global warming.\n - The average gasoline vehicle emits about 4.6 metric tons of CO2 per year, assuming a fuel economy of about 22 miles per gallon and annual travel of 11,500 miles.\n\n### Air Pollution\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - EVs do not emit nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter (PM), or volatile organic compounds (VOCs) during operation, which are common pollutants from gasoline vehicles.\n - However, the production of electricity can contribute to air pollution, depending on the energy sources used. Coal-fired power plants, for instance, emit significant amounts of NOx and sulfur dioxide (SO2).\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Gasoline vehicles contribute to air pollution through the emission of NOx, CO, VOCs, and PM. These pollutants can lead to smog formation, respiratory problems, and other health issues.\n - Advances in emission control technologies (e.g., catalytic converters) have reduced the emissions from gasoline vehicles, but they still contribute significantly to urban air pollution.\n\n### Resource Consumption\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - EVs require batteries, typically lithium-ion, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other materials. Mining these resources can have significant environmental and social impacts, including habitat destruction and pollution.\n - Battery production is energy-intensive, but recycling programs are being developed to mitigate these impacts and recover valuable materials.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - The production and refining of gasoline involve the extraction of crude oil, which can lead to environmental degradation, oil spills, and habitat destruction.\n - Gasoline production is also energy-intensive and contributes to greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n### Disposal and End-of-Life Considerations\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - The disposal of EV batteries poses environmental challenges due to the hazardous materials they contain. However, battery recycling technologies are advancing, and second-life applications for EV batteries are being explored to extend their usefulness.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - The disposal of gasoline vehicles involves recycling metals and other materials, which is relatively well-established. However, the environmental impact of oil extraction and refining remains a concern throughout the vehicle's lifecycle.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, electric vehicles generally have a lower environmental impact compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly as the electricity grid becomes cleaner. While EVs have challenges related to battery production and disposal, their operational benefits in terms of reduced greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution make them a more sustainable option in the long term. As technology and infrastructure improve, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to increase further.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by examining specific environmental factors, such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource consumption. This approach focuses on comparing the operational emissions of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles, including the emissions from electricity generation for EVs and tailpipe emissions for gasoline vehicles. Additionally, I will consider the sourcing and disposal of materials like batteries in EVs and fossil fuels in gasoline vehicles to provide a detailed comparison of their environmental footprints." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle assessment of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal. By comparing these stages, I can provide a comprehensive view of how each vehicle type affects the environment throughout its entire lifecycle.", + "I can answer by examining specific environmental factors, such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource consumption. This approach focuses on comparing the operational emissions of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles, including the emissions from electricity generation for EVs and tailpipe emissions for gasoline vehicles. Additionally, I will consider the sourcing and disposal of materials like batteries in EVs and fossil fuels in gasoline vehicles to provide a detailed comparison of their environmental footprints." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by examining specific environmental factors, such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource consumption. This approach focuses on comparing the operational emissions of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles, including the emissions from electricity generation for EVs and tailpipe emissions for gasoline vehicles. Additionally, I will consider the sourcing and disposal of materials like batteries in EVs and fossil fuels in gasoline vehicles to provide a detailed comparison of their environmental footprints." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:00.032934", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 40 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_41.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_41.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..04cd8793150ee22dc7cbb6e4dbf3bc30967ce5f2 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_41.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "32902f78-c3b7-4c85-8179-a1d5d5dd0df0", + "ibfs_id": "49af31d3-ad06-4b28-9f94-ed75baa57a0a", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but battery production and disposal pose environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a lifecycle assessment (LCA) that examines each stage of a vehicle's life: production, usage, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. This comprehensive approach will help us understand the total environmental impact, including carbon emissions, pollution, and resource depletion.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction and Processing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Batteries:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve mining and processing of materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. These processes can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use aluminum and copper, which require energy-intensive extraction and processing.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuels:** The extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline production is energy-intensive and can lead to oil spills and habitat disruption.\n- **Materials:** Traditional vehicles primarily use steel and aluminum, which also involve energy-intensive extraction and processing, though typically less so than the materials for EV batteries.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Processes\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Use:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is generally more energy-intensive than that of gasoline vehicles. This is due to the complex processes involved in battery manufacturing.\n- **Emissions:** Manufacturing emissions for EVs are higher upfront due to the energy required for battery production.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Use:** Manufacturing processes for gasoline vehicles are less energy-intensive compared to EVs, primarily because they do not include battery production.\n- **Emissions:** While lower than EVs at the production stage, gasoline vehicles still contribute significant emissions from steel and aluminum production.\n\n### 3. Vehicle Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas. However, the overall emissions depend on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the emissions are minimal. If from coal or natural gas, emissions are higher.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Efficiency:** Internal combustion engines are less efficient than electric motors, losing more energy as heat.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries present challenges due to the complexity and toxicity of materials. However, advancements in recycling technologies are improving the recovery of valuable materials.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, the metal components of EVs can be recycled, reducing the need for new raw materials.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Traditional vehicles are generally easier to recycle, with established processes for recovering metals. However, they do not have the added complexity of battery disposal.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles have higher environmental impacts during the production phase, primarily due to battery manufacturing. However, they offer significant benefits during the usage phase by reducing emissions and improving energy efficiency, especially when powered by renewable energy. Gasoline vehicles, while having lower production impacts, contribute more to pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational life. End-of-life considerations are increasingly important for both vehicle types, with ongoing improvements in recycling technologies helping to mitigate some of the environmental impacts. Overall, the lifecycle assessment suggests that EVs have the potential for a lower total environmental impact, particularly as the energy grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies advance.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves evaluating the total environmental impact of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would look at the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle usage, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By examining each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental effects, including carbon emissions, pollution, and resource depletion associated with both vehicle types." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves evaluating the total environmental impact of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would look at the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle usage, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By examining each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental effects, including carbon emissions, pollution, and resource depletion associated with both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of the vehicles, comparing the emissions produced during the use of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles during operation and comparing them to the emissions from electricity generation used to power electric vehicles. Additionally, I would consider the impact of energy sources (renewable vs. fossil fuels) used in electricity production to evaluate how these factors influence the environmental footprint of electric vehicles during their operational life." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison, which involves evaluating the total environmental impact of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would look at the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle usage, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By examining each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental effects, including carbon emissions, pollution, and resource depletion associated with both vehicle types." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:03.854559", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 41 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_42.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_42.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e3dc5fb44ada5830a5c980522079718dda04a4cc --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_42.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "412a622a-1b1f-444b-b260-183cc56dc319", + "ibfs_id": "bb5f54cb-e163-45f4-8de8-fc3212e03029", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions, lower carbon footprints, and use renewable energy, outpacing gasoline cars in environmental benefits overall.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, we need to examine the emissions produced during vehicle use and consider the source of electricity for EVs.\n\n1. **Emissions During Vehicle Use:**\n\n - **Traditional Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles burn gasoline to power an internal combustion engine, directly emitting carbon dioxide (CO2) and other pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO), and particulate matter (PM) into the atmosphere. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change. The amount of CO2 emitted is directly related to the fuel efficiency of the vehicle and the carbon content of the gasoline.\n\n - **Electric Vehicles:** EVs do not have tailpipe emissions because they are powered by an electric motor rather than an internal combustion engine. This means that during their operation, they do not emit CO2, NOx, CO, or PM directly. This is a significant advantage in reducing urban air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions from the transportation sector.\n\n2. **Source of Electricity for EVs:**\n\n - The environmental impact of EVs during their operational phase is significantly influenced by the source of electricity used to charge them. The carbon footprint of an EV can vary depending on the energy mix of the local electricity grid.\n\n - **Fossil Fuel-Dominated Grids:** In regions where electricity is primarily generated from coal, natural gas, or oil, the indirect emissions associated with charging EVs can be relatively high. Coal-fired power plants, in particular, are a major source of CO2 and other pollutants. In such cases, the environmental benefits of EVs over gasoline vehicles may be reduced, though they still offer advantages in terms of local air quality.\n\n - **Renewable Energy-Dominated Grids:** In areas where the electricity grid relies heavily on renewable energy sources such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the emissions associated with charging EVs are much lower. This results in a significantly smaller carbon footprint for EVs compared to gasoline vehicles. As the share of renewables in the energy mix increases, the environmental benefits of EVs become more pronounced.\n\nIn summary, while electric vehicles offer clear advantages over traditional gasoline vehicles in terms of direct emissions during operation, the overall environmental impact of EVs is closely tied to the source of electricity used for charging. Regions with cleaner, renewable-based electricity grids will see greater environmental benefits from the adoption of EVs, while areas reliant on fossil fuels for electricity generation may experience less pronounced benefits. Nonetheless, the transition to EVs is generally considered a positive step towards reducing transportation-related emissions and improving air quality.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by exploring the specific environmental impacts associated with the operational phase of electric vehicles versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the emissions produced during vehicle use, including carbon dioxide and other pollutants. I would also consider the source of electricity used to power electric vehicles, as this can vary greatly in its environmental impact depending on the energy grid's reliance on fossil fuels versus renewable sources. This approach would highlight how the environmental benefits of EVs can differ based on regional electricity generation methods." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the entire lifecycle of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, operational emissions, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. For electric vehicles, I would focus on the impact of battery production and disposal, as well as the sourcing of electricity, while for gasoline vehicles, I would look at emissions from fuel combustion and oil extraction. This comprehensive lifecycle approach would provide a holistic view of the environmental impacts associated with both types of vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring the specific environmental impacts associated with the operational phase of electric vehicles versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the emissions produced during vehicle use, including carbon dioxide and other pollutants. I would also consider the source of electricity used to power electric vehicles, as this can vary greatly in its environmental impact depending on the energy grid's reliance on fossil fuels versus renewable sources. This approach would highlight how the environmental benefits of EVs can differ based on regional electricity generation methods." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by exploring the specific environmental impacts associated with the operational phase of electric vehicles versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the emissions produced during vehicle use, including carbon dioxide and other pollutants. I would also consider the source of electricity used to power electric vehicles, as this can vary greatly in its environmental impact depending on the energy grid's reliance on fossil fuels versus renewable sources. This approach would highlight how the environmental benefits of EVs can differ based on regional electricity generation methods." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:13.145733", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 42 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_43.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_43.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3e0e035aacafab894d159eeafaf49a1315ebdf58 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_43.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "d0d64e74-0705-44e2-8b1a-ba5aa372ccc1", + "ibfs_id": "b78fb0ef-92f7-41e1-94f0-12ec084c31f3", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles emit fewer greenhouse gases over their lifecycle but have environmental costs in battery production and resource extraction.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will examine the environmental impacts at each stage of their life cycles: raw material extraction, manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life disposal. This analysis will focus on key factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Materials:** EVs require lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other rare earth metals for their batteries. The extraction and processing of these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy use.\n- **Impact:** The mining of these materials often results in higher initial environmental impacts compared to gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of resource depletion and localized ecological damage.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Materials:** Gasoline vehicles primarily use steel, aluminum, and plastics. The extraction of these materials is less intensive in terms of rare earth metals but still involves significant energy use and emissions.\n- **Impact:** The environmental impact is generally lower than that of EVs at this stage, particularly regarding resource depletion.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Process:** The production of EVs, especially the battery, is energy-intensive. The manufacturing process results in higher greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Impact:** The carbon footprint during manufacturing is higher for EVs, primarily due to battery production.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Process:** The manufacturing process is well-established and less energy-intensive than that of EVs.\n- **Impact:** Lower greenhouse gas emissions during manufacturing compared to EVs.\n\n### 3. Operation\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy Source:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions. However, the environmental impact during operation depends on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources result in significantly lower emissions, while coal-based electricity can diminish the benefits.\n- **Impact:** Generally, EVs have a lower operational carbon footprint, especially in regions with a clean energy grid.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Source:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe.\n- **Impact:** Higher greenhouse gas emissions and air pollutants during operation compared to EVs.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Recycling and Disposal:** The disposal and recycling of batteries are complex and can pose environmental challenges. However, advancements in battery recycling are improving the sustainability of EVs.\n- **Impact:** Potential environmental risks if batteries are not properly recycled, but increasing recycling efforts mitigate these impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling and Disposal:** Established recycling processes exist for gasoline vehicles, with many components being recyclable.\n- **Impact:** Generally lower environmental impact at the end-of-life stage compared to EVs, due to established recycling practices.\n\n### Overall Environmental Footprint\n\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** Over their entire life cycle, EVs tend to have a lower overall carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles, especially when charged with renewable energy.\n- **Energy Consumption:** EVs are more energy-efficient during operation, but their manufacturing process is more energy-intensive.\n- **Resource Depletion:** EVs have higher initial resource depletion due to battery materials but can offset this with lower operational impacts.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles have higher environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages, their lower operational emissions and potential for cleaner energy sources contribute to a reduced overall environmental footprint compared to traditional gasoline vehicles. The benefits of EVs are maximized when they are powered by renewable energy and when battery recycling processes are effectively implemented.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both vehicle types from cradle to grave, including the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life disposal. By analyzing factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their overall environmental footprints." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both vehicle types from cradle to grave, including the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life disposal. By analyzing factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their overall environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles and examining their emissions during usage. This approach would involve analyzing the direct emissions produced by gasoline vehicle engines and comparing them to the emissions associated with electricity generation for EV charging, which varies based on the energy mix of the grid. Additionally, I would consider how advancements in renewable energy sources could influence the environmental benefits of EVs over time. This method allows for a specific comparison of the vehicles' impacts during their operational lifetime." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts of both vehicle types from cradle to grave, including the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life disposal. By analyzing factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their overall environmental footprints." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:18.471038", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 43 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_44.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_44.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..03cb4286b0172c3eb63ae0d09c026dfd4bd86f90 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_44.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "2eb305d4-f89e-4dce-92a8-7f79600fe851", + "ibfs_id": "f6e4a216-8547-4216-aa89-da3eed7abe8a", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and environmental damage compared to gasoline cars, though mining for batteries poses ecological challenges.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a comprehensive life cycle analysis (LCA) that examines each stage of a vehicle's life: raw material extraction, manufacturing, use, and disposal. This analysis helps to understand the total emissions, resource usage, and ecological footprint associated with each type of vehicle.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use copper and rare earth elements for electric motors and electronics, which have their own environmental extraction impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can cause oil spills, habitat disruption, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Material Use:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and plastics, similar to EVs, but generally in smaller quantities for components like engines.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and often results in higher initial emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Emissions:** Manufacturing emissions for EVs can be higher due to the complexity of battery production.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Conventional Manufacturing:** Gasoline vehicles have a more established manufacturing process with lower initial emissions compared to EVs.\n- **Engine Production:** The production of internal combustion engines is less energy-intensive than battery production.\n\n### 3. Use Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, reducing air pollution and greenhouse gases during operation.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during the use phase depends heavily on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources (solar, wind) significantly reduce emissions, while coal-based electricity increases them.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Combustion Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Advances in fuel efficiency can reduce emissions, but they remain higher than those of EVs powered by clean energy.\n\n### 4. Disposal and Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal of EV batteries poses challenges due to hazardous materials. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable metals.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, EVs can be recycled for metals and other materials, though the battery remains a significant concern.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **End-of-Life Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically recycled for metals and parts, with established processes in place.\n- **Environmental Impact:** The disposal of engine oils and fluids can pose environmental risks if not managed properly.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, while electric vehicles have higher environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages due to battery production, they offer significant advantages during the use phase by eliminating tailpipe emissions. The overall environmental benefits of EVs are maximized when they are powered by renewable energy sources. Gasoline vehicles, on the other hand, have lower initial manufacturing emissions but contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational life. As battery recycling technologies improve and the energy grid becomes cleaner, the life cycle environmental impact of EVs is expected to decrease further, enhancing their sustainability compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive life cycle analysis of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing through to use and disposal. By comparing the total emissions, resource usage, and ecological footprint of each type of vehicle, I can provide a detailed picture of their respective environmental impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive life cycle analysis of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing through to use and disposal. By comparing the total emissions, resource usage, and ecological footprint of each type of vehicle, I can provide a detailed picture of their respective environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles, examining emissions and energy consumption during their use. This approach would involve analyzing the differences in greenhouse gas emissions, energy efficiency, and pollution generated while the vehicles are in operation. Additionally, I can explore the impacts of electricity generation sources (renewable vs. fossil fuels) on the environmental benefits of operating EVs compared to gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive life cycle analysis of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing through to use and disposal. By comparing the total emissions, resource usage, and ecological footprint of each type of vehicle, I can provide a detailed picture of their respective environmental impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:18.853802", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 44 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_45.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_45.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8ac5777646f9ab4c88fc9bf51f33bc9bbefdbaf1 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_45.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "60e03179-6184-4fc4-af91-3ce2d4b647e7", + "ibfs_id": "39213203-221f-406a-9389-5760f3406587", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce fewer emissions, reduce fossil fuel reliance, but involve significant battery production impacts, compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will analyze the environmental impacts of each type of vehicle throughout their entire life cycle. This includes stages such as raw material extraction, manufacturing, use, and end-of-life disposal. The LCA will help us understand the differences in emissions, resource consumption, and overall environmental footprint of both vehicle types.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Materials:** EVs require lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other rare earth metals for their batteries. The extraction of these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Materials:** EVs also use aluminum, steel, and plastics, similar to gasoline vehicles, but the battery materials are a significant additional factor.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fossil Fuels:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline production involves drilling and refining processes that can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and significant greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Materials:** Like EVs, gasoline vehicles use steel, aluminum, and plastics, but they do not require the same rare metals as EVs.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive. This results in higher emissions during the manufacturing phase compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Emissions:** The emissions from manufacturing an EV can be higher due to the energy required to produce the battery, but this can vary depending on the energy mix of the manufacturing location.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Standard Manufacturing:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is less energy-intensive compared to EVs, primarily because they do not require large batteries.\n- **Emissions:** Emissions are generally lower during the manufacturing phase compared to EVs, but this advantage is often offset during the use phase.\n\n### 3. Use Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during the use phase depends on the electricity source. If the electricity comes from renewable sources, the emissions are minimal. However, if it comes from coal or other fossil fuels, the emissions can be higher.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Improvements in fuel efficiency have reduced emissions, but they are still higher than those of EVs, especially in terms of CO2 emissions per mile.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries are critical. Proper recycling can mitigate some environmental impacts, but current recycling rates and technologies are still developing.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, the metal and plastic components can be recycled, reducing the environmental impact.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** The recycling processes for gasoline vehicles are well-established, and most materials can be effectively recycled.\n- **Waste:** There is no battery disposal issue, but the emissions during the vehicle's life are a significant environmental concern.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases due to the production of batteries. However, they offer significant environmental benefits during the use phase, especially if powered by renewable energy, due to zero tailpipe emissions and higher energy efficiency. Gasoline vehicles have lower impacts during manufacturing but contribute significantly to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their use phase. The end-of-life disposal of both vehicle types involves recycling, but EVs face additional challenges with battery disposal. Overall, the life cycle assessment indicates that EVs can have a lower overall environmental impact, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the environmental impacts of each type of vehicle throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to end-of-life disposal. This method helps highlight the differences in emissions, resource consumption, and overall environmental footprint of both vehicle types." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the environmental impacts of each type of vehicle throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to end-of-life disposal. This method helps highlight the differences in emissions, resource consumption, and overall environmental footprint of both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by evaluating the direct emissions and energy efficiency during the usage phase of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This strategy focuses on comparing the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles with the zero emissions at the point of use for electric vehicles, while also considering the emissions related to electricity generation for EVs. By examining fuel efficiency and the sources of electricity, I can provide insights into how each vehicle type contributes to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the environmental impacts of each type of vehicle throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to end-of-life disposal. This method helps highlight the differences in emissions, resource consumption, and overall environmental footprint of both vehicle types." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:21.614755", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 45 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_46.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_46.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3c267ce4a065c3d468ab493df7ec41ecbf0a6e78 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_46.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c69c57d8-bbc4-42ea-b792-779ef04f2375", + "ibfs_id": "658f6166-b765-4cd0-a6ee-73f8db81b2ac", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions during operation but involve significant environmental impact during battery production and resource extraction.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we will conduct a life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines each stage of the vehicles' life cycles: raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal or recycling.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use materials like aluminum and copper, which have their own environmental extraction impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** Gasoline vehicles rely on crude oil extraction, which can result in oil spills, habitat disruption, and significant greenhouse gas emissions during extraction and refining.\n- **Material Use:** Traditional vehicles primarily use steel and aluminum, which also require energy-intensive extraction processes.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Higher Initial Emissions:** Manufacturing EVs, particularly the battery, generally results in higher initial emissions compared to gasoline vehicles due to the energy-intensive processes involved in battery production.\n- **Renewable Energy Potential:** The environmental impact can be mitigated if renewable energy sources are used in the manufacturing process.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Lower Initial Emissions:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles typically results in lower initial emissions compared to EVs, as they do not require large batteries.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces local air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation.\n- **Electricity Source Matters:** The environmental impact during the usage phase depends on the electricity source. If the grid relies on coal, the emissions can be higher; however, renewable energy sources drastically reduce the carbon footprint.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **High Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants directly into the atmosphere, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency Variability:** The environmental impact varies with fuel efficiency, with more efficient vehicles having a lower impact.\n\n### 4. Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling Challenges:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose significant challenges. While recycling technologies are improving, improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination.\n- **Potential for Reuse:** Batteries can be repurposed for secondary applications, such as energy storage, extending their life cycle.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Established Recycling Processes:** Traditional vehicles have well-established recycling processes for metals like steel and aluminum, reducing their end-of-life environmental impact.\n- **Oil Disposal:** Used oil and other fluids require careful disposal to prevent environmental contamination.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases, primarily due to battery production. However, they offer significant environmental benefits during the usage phase due to zero tailpipe emissions, especially when powered by renewable energy. Gasoline vehicles have lower initial manufacturing emissions but contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational life. The disposal phase presents challenges for both vehicle types, with EVs focusing on battery recycling and gasoline vehicles on fluid disposal. Overall, the life cycle assessment indicates that EVs have the potential for a lower overall environmental footprint, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies advance.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of both types of vehicles throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage to disposal or recycling. By examining factors such as emissions during manufacturing, energy consumption, and waste generation, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of both types of vehicles throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage to disposal or recycling. By examining factors such as emissions during manufacturing, energy consumption, and waste generation, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles to compare their environmental impacts. This approach will involve analyzing factors such as tailpipe emissions, fuel/energy efficiency, and the sources of electricity used for EVs. I will explore how these factors contribute to air pollution, greenhouse gas emissions, and overall energy consumption during the vehicle's usage phase, providing a clear picture of their impacts while they are in operation." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of both types of vehicles throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage to disposal or recycling. By examining factors such as emissions during manufacturing, energy consumption, and waste generation, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:24.244473", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 46 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_47.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_47.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3cd559d59fb720ddc62ccb8c866c86d7cbb4bbc5 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_47.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "3207a6ed-7190-4249-8024-b1d006f1f69d", + "ibfs_id": "e7d1cd17-380b-4ac0-ba0c-03c74ca5d627", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce fewer emissions, reduce dependence on fossil fuels, but battery production and disposal have environmental challenges.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will examine the environmental impacts at each stage of their life cycles: raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. This analysis will focus on energy consumption, emissions, and resource use.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, EVs require steel, aluminum, and plastics, but the battery production is the most resource-intensive part.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and significant energy use.\n- **Vehicle Components:** The materials used in gasoline vehicles (steel, aluminum, plastics) also require energy-intensive extraction processes.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Use:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive. However, advancements in battery technology and manufacturing efficiency are reducing this impact.\n- **Emissions:** Manufacturing EVs generally results in higher initial emissions compared to gasoline vehicles due to the battery production.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Use:** Manufacturing processes are well-established and less energy-intensive compared to EVs, primarily because they do not require large batteries.\n- **Emissions:** The emissions from manufacturing gasoline vehicles are generally lower initially, but this advantage decreases over the vehicle's lifetime.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Consumption:** EVs are more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. They convert a higher percentage of electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n- **Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions. However, the overall emissions depend on the electricity mix used for charging. Renewable energy sources significantly reduce the carbon footprint.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Consumption:** Gasoline engines are less efficient, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n- **Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, and particulate matter during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries are critical. Current technologies allow for the recycling of lithium, cobalt, and nickel, but the processes are still developing.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, the metal components can be recycled, reducing the need for new raw materials.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel System Disposal:** Components related to the fuel system can pose environmental hazards if not properly disposed of.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Established recycling processes exist for metals, but the environmental impact of disposing of used oil and other fluids remains a concern.\n\n### Overall Environmental Footprint\n\n- **Electric Vehicles:** While EVs have higher environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages, they offer significant benefits during the usage phase, especially when powered by renewable energy. Over their lifetime, they generally have a lower carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles.\n \n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles have lower initial manufacturing impacts but contribute more significantly to environmental degradation during the usage phase due to emissions and lower energy efficiency.\n\nIn conclusion, the life cycle assessment shows that electric vehicles have the potential to be more environmentally friendly than traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies improve. However, addressing the environmental impacts of battery production and disposal remains crucial for maximizing the benefits of EVs.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of each vehicle type throughout their entire life cycle\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. By examining factors such as energy consumption, emissions, and resource use at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive understanding of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of each vehicle type throughout their entire life cycle\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. By examining factors such as energy consumption, emissions, and resource use at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive understanding of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impacts related to the energy sources used by each vehicle type. This approach involves analyzing the emissions and environmental effects associated with the electricity generation that powers EVs, which can vary widely depending on the energy mix (e.g., coal, natural gas, renewables). For gasoline vehicles, I would assess the impacts of extracting, refining, and burning fossil fuels. By doing so, I can evaluate how the environmental effects of the energy supply chain differ between EVs and gasoline vehicles under different scenarios and energy policies." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of each vehicle type throughout their entire life cycle\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. By examining factors such as energy consumption, emissions, and resource use at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive understanding of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:24.136259", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 47 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_48.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_48.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c8d7eee44794697293caf90eea06c9cb6fddd6fb --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_48.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "1dd1c919-e76c-4310-a244-640de09ab375", + "ibfs_id": "9e5b551e-a546-46ea-b1b1-179271448acf", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, offering sustainable alternatives, while battery production poses environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a lifecycle assessment (LCA) that examines each stage of the vehicles' lifecycles: raw material extraction, manufacturing, use, and disposal or recycling. This approach allows us to evaluate the energy consumption, emissions, and resource use associated with each vehicle type.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to habitat destruction, soil and water pollution, and significant energy use.\n- **Other Components:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, EVs require steel, aluminum, and plastics, but the battery materials add additional environmental burdens.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can result in habitat disruption, oil spills, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Vehicle Materials:** Like EVs, gasoline vehicles also require steel, aluminum, and plastics, but they do not require the same battery materials as EVs.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy-Intensive Battery Manufacturing:** The production of EV batteries is energy-intensive, contributing to higher emissions during the manufacturing stage compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Overall Manufacturing:** The assembly of EVs is similar to gasoline vehicles, but the additional complexity and weight of the battery can increase energy use.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Standard Manufacturing:** The manufacturing process is well-established, with emissions primarily from steel and aluminum production and vehicle assembly.\n\n### 3. Use Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, reducing air pollution in urban areas.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during the use phase depends on the electricity mix. If the grid is powered by renewable energy, the emissions are significantly lower than those of gasoline vehicles. However, if coal or other fossil fuels dominate, the emissions can be higher.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid into vehicle movement.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** The efficiency varies by model, but gasoline engines typically convert less energy into movement compared to electric motors.\n\n### 4. Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries pose challenges due to the hazardous materials involved. However, advancements in battery recycling technologies are improving the recovery of valuable materials.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, the metal components can be recycled, reducing the need for new raw materials.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Standard Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle, with established processes for recovering metals and other materials.\n- **End-of-Life Emissions:** The disposal of gasoline vehicles involves fewer hazardous materials compared to EV batteries.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles offer significant environmental benefits during the use phase, particularly in regions with clean electricity grids, due to their zero tailpipe emissions and higher energy efficiency. However, they have higher environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages, primarily due to battery production. Gasoline vehicles have more established recycling processes and lower initial manufacturing emissions but contribute significantly to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their use phase. The overall environmental impact of each vehicle type depends heavily on factors such as the electricity mix for EVs and the fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing every stage of both types of vehicles' lifecycles, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling. By examining the energy consumption, emissions, and resource use at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts associated with each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing every stage of both types of vehicles' lifecycles, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling. By examining the energy consumption, emissions, and resource use at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts associated with each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy use during the operational phase of vehicles. This approach specifically compares the direct environmental impacts while the vehicles are in use, such as tailpipe emissions for gasoline vehicles and the source of electricity for EVs. I would also consider the carbon intensity of electricity grids in different regions to assess how the environmental benefits of EVs can vary geographically. This strategy provides insight into the immediate and visible environmental impacts associated with driving each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing every stage of both types of vehicles' lifecycles, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling. By examining the energy consumption, emissions, and resource use at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts associated with each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:30.768242", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 48 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_49.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_49.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8b0e89bda27869e7829fabbc57a7d34d54603e1c --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_49.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "276fb0e7-649d-4a62-83c5-fdb78c3ffdb0", + "ibfs_id": "2f6e051b-0e8f-47ea-ac62-c1975b559356", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce air pollution and emissions, but their battery production and disposal pose environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a lifecycle analysis that considers each stage of the vehicle's life: production, operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling.\n\n### 1. Extraction and Processing of Raw Materials\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other materials. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also require copper for wiring and rare earth elements for electric motors, which involve energy-intensive extraction processes.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction and refining of crude oil into gasoline is energy-intensive and can result in oil spills, habitat destruction, and water contamination.\n- **Vehicle Components:** Traditional vehicles require steel, aluminum, and other materials, which also involve energy-intensive extraction and processing.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Processes\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- The manufacturing of EVs, particularly the battery, is more energy-intensive compared to gasoline vehicles. This is due to the complex processes involved in battery cell production and assembly.\n- However, EVs generally have fewer moving parts, which can reduce the complexity and energy requirements of other manufacturing processes.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Manufacturing processes for gasoline vehicles are well-established but still energy-intensive, particularly for engine and transmission components.\n- The production of emissions control systems (like catalytic converters) also involves the use of precious metals.\n\n### 3. Operation and Maintenance\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Operation:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces air pollution in urban areas. However, the environmental impact depends on the electricity source; coal-based electricity increases emissions, while renewable energy reduces them.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n- **Maintenance:** EVs require less maintenance due to fewer moving parts and no need for oil changes.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Operation:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Efficiency:** Internal combustion engines are less efficient, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n- **Maintenance:** Regular maintenance is required, including oil changes, exhaust system repairs, and engine tune-ups.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The recycling of lithium-ion batteries is complex and not yet widespread, but it is crucial to prevent environmental contamination and recover valuable materials.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Other components of EVs can be recycled similarly to traditional vehicles, but the process can be more complex due to the presence of electronic components.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** The recycling process for gasoline vehicles is well-established, with many parts being recoverable, such as metals and plastics.\n- **Environmental Impact:** Disposal of fluids and emissions control components can pose environmental risks if not handled properly.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles have a different environmental impact profile compared to gasoline vehicles. While the production of EVs, particularly their batteries, is more resource and energy-intensive, their operation results in significantly lower emissions, especially when powered by renewable energy. Gasoline vehicles have a more established recycling process but contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational phase. The overall environmental benefit of EVs improves as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies advance.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include examining the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, operation and maintenance, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By assessing each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include examining the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, operation and maintenance, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By assessing each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of vehicles and comparing the emissions associated with using electric versus gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing the greenhouse gas emissions and air pollutants produced during the operation of each vehicle type. For electric vehicles, I would take into account the source of electricity generation (e.g., coal, natural gas, renewables) and for gasoline vehicles, I would consider the direct emissions from fuel combustion. This approach emphasizes the impacts associated with the use phase rather than the entire lifecycle." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that evaluates the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include examining the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, operation and maintenance, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. By assessing each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:38.212793", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 49 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_5.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_5.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..dfa5fa66ef82ec3af4d38a35e51f110f7284f45d --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_5.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "ab712ce7-f55d-4326-981b-0acb6540a7c4", + "ibfs_id": "5c22a326-8a7b-4c02-a647-efc6238ce84c", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles offer lower emissions, reduced air pollution, and decreased reliance on fossil fuels compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To address the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, I will review recent scientific studies and reports from credible sources, focusing on emissions, resource consumption, and potential benefits or drawbacks.\n\n1. **Emissions**:\n - A study published in *Nature Sustainability* (2020) analyzed the life cycle emissions of EVs and found that, on average, EVs produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles. This is primarily due to the higher efficiency of electric motors and the increasing share of renewable energy in electricity grids.\n - The International Energy Agency (IEA) in its 2021 Global EV Outlook report highlighted that EVs have the potential to significantly reduce CO2 emissions, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener. The report noted that in regions with a high share of coal in electricity generation, the emissions benefits are less pronounced but still positive.\n\n2. **Resource Consumption**:\n - A report by the European Environment Agency (EEA) in 2020 discussed the resource implications of EVs, noting that while EVs require critical raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for their batteries, advancements in battery technology and recycling processes are helping to mitigate these impacts. The shift towards less resource-intensive battery chemistries, such as lithium iron phosphate (LFP), is also reducing the environmental footprint.\n - The Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS) in a 2021 analysis emphasized that the extraction and processing of materials for EV batteries have environmental impacts, but these are offset by the lower emissions during the vehicle's operational phase.\n\n3. **Potential Benefits**:\n - EVs contribute to improved air quality in urban areas by eliminating tailpipe emissions of pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM). A study by the American Lung Association (2020) estimated that widespread adoption of EVs could prevent thousands of premature deaths and save billions in health costs annually in the United States alone.\n - According to a 2021 report by BloombergNEF, the total cost of ownership for EVs is becoming competitive with gasoline vehicles, which could accelerate their adoption and amplify environmental benefits.\n\n4. **Drawbacks and Challenges**:\n - The environmental impact of EVs is heavily dependent on the energy mix used for electricity generation. In regions where coal is a major energy source, the benefits are reduced. However, as renewable energy sources like wind and solar become more prevalent, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to increase.\n - The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose environmental challenges. Research from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) in 2021 highlighted the need for improved recycling technologies and policies to manage battery waste sustainably.\n\nIn conclusion, recent studies and reports indicate that electric vehicles generally offer significant environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of emissions and air quality. However, challenges related to resource consumption and battery disposal remain, necessitating continued advancements in technology and policy to maximize the environmental benefits of EVs.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by reviewing recent scientific studies and reports from credible sources like environmental agencies, universities, and research institutions. This would include summarizing findings on emissions, resource consumption, and potential benefits or drawbacks of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, taking into account advancements in technology and changes in energy production methods." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles, focusing on key stages such as production, operation, and disposal. This would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage, such as the extraction of raw materials, emissions during vehicle operation, and the handling of end-of-life components, to provide a comprehensive comparison.", + "I can answer by reviewing recent scientific studies and reports from credible sources like environmental agencies, universities, and research institutions. This would include summarizing findings on emissions, resource consumption, and potential benefits or drawbacks of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, taking into account advancements in technology and changes in energy production methods." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by reviewing recent scientific studies and reports from credible sources like environmental agencies, universities, and research institutions. This would include summarizing findings on emissions, resource consumption, and potential benefits or drawbacks of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, taking into account advancements in technology and changes in energy production methods." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:45.248199", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 5 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_50.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_50.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b8e6a4fe55e01669d03aedfb30916fc6d341ccf7 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_50.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "dacb02e6-bd8c-4d2f-9638-2c9c2bc4b35c", + "ibfs_id": "8a7af59c-63c5-4a51-b5d3-5d0e1ae1a36c", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but their battery production and disposal have environmental impacts compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles during the manufacturing phase, we can conduct a life cycle assessment (LCA) that focuses on energy consumption, raw material sourcing, and emissions associated with the production of each vehicle type.\n\n### Energy Consumption\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Battery Production:** The most energy-intensive component in EV manufacturing is the production of lithium-ion batteries. This process involves mining, refining, and processing raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. The energy required for these processes is significant, often relying on electricity that may be generated from fossil fuels, depending on the region.\n - **Vehicle Assembly:** The assembly of EVs is similar to that of traditional vehicles, but the integration of the battery system requires additional energy, particularly in the form of precision engineering and safety testing.\n\n2. **Traditional Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Engine Production:** The manufacturing of internal combustion engines (ICEs) involves casting, machining, and assembling numerous metal components. This process is energy-intensive due to the high temperatures required for metalworking and the complexity of engine design.\n - **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to EVs, the assembly process for gasoline vehicles involves significant energy use, though it does not require the additional steps associated with battery integration.\n\n### Raw Material Sourcing\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Battery Materials:** The sourcing of lithium, cobalt, and nickel is critical for EV batteries. Mining these materials can have substantial environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high carbon emissions. Cobalt mining, in particular, has raised ethical concerns due to labor practices in certain regions.\n - **Lightweight Materials:** EVs often use lightweight materials such as aluminum and advanced composites to offset the weight of the battery, which requires additional energy for extraction and processing.\n\n2. **Traditional Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Metals for Engine and Body:** The production of gasoline vehicles primarily involves steel and aluminum for the engine and body. The extraction and processing of these metals also have environmental impacts, though the processes are well-established and have seen efficiency improvements over time.\n - **Plastics and Other Materials:** Gasoline vehicles use a variety of materials, including plastics derived from petroleum, which have their own environmental footprint in terms of extraction and processing.\n\n### Emissions\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - **Battery Manufacturing Emissions:** The production of EV batteries is associated with higher greenhouse gas emissions compared to the manufacturing of ICEs. This is due to the energy-intensive processes involved in mining and refining battery materials.\n - **Overall Manufacturing Emissions:** While the initial emissions from manufacturing are higher for EVs, these are often offset over the vehicle's lifetime due to lower operational emissions.\n\n2. **Traditional Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - **Engine Manufacturing Emissions:** The production of ICEs involves emissions from metal processing and assembly. However, these emissions are generally lower than those associated with EV battery production.\n - **Overall Manufacturing Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles typically have lower manufacturing emissions compared to EVs, but this advantage diminishes when considering the entire life cycle, including fuel combustion during operation.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, the manufacturing phase of electric vehicles is characterized by higher energy consumption and emissions primarily due to battery production. The sourcing of raw materials for EV batteries also presents significant environmental challenges. In contrast, traditional gasoline vehicles have a more established manufacturing process with lower initial emissions, but they incur higher emissions during their operational phase. Understanding these differences is crucial for assessing the overall environmental impact of each vehicle type.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of both vehicle types throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. This method will provide a comprehensive view of the overall environmental footprint, including factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution.", + "I can answer by focusing the life cycle assessment (LCA) specifically on the manufacturing phase of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve a detailed analysis of the energy consumption, raw material sourcing, and emissions associated with the production of each vehicle type. By honing in on the manufacturing process, we can uncover specific environmental impacts related to the production of batteries for EVs compared to internal combustion engines for gasoline vehicles, providing insights into the most resource-intensive and environmentally impactful aspects of vehicle production." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of both vehicle types throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. This method will provide a comprehensive view of the overall environmental footprint, including factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution.", + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the differences in emissions during the usage phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during combustion and comparing them to the emissions generated by power plants that supply electricity for EVs, considering the energy mix of the grid. Additionally, this strategy would include an analysis of the impact of energy source variability on emissions, such as renewable energy versus fossil fuels, and how this affects the environmental benefits of electric vehicles over their operational life." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing and comparing the environmental impacts of both vehicle types throughout their entire life cycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. This method will provide a comprehensive view of the overall environmental footprint, including factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing the life cycle assessment (LCA) specifically on the manufacturing phase of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve a detailed analysis of the energy consumption, raw material sourcing, and emissions associated with the production of each vehicle type. By honing in on the manufacturing process, we can uncover specific environmental impacts related to the production of batteries for EVs compared to internal combustion engines for gasoline vehicles, providing insights into the most resource-intensive and environmentally impactful aspects of vehicle production.", + "I can answer by emphasizing the usage phase within the life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve a comparative analysis of the emissions and environmental impacts during the operational life of each vehicle type, taking into account factors such as fuel or electricity consumption, maintenance requirements, and regional variations in energy sources. By concentrating on the usage phase, we can evaluate the real-world environmental performance of each vehicle type over its operational life, which can vary significantly based on geographical location, driving habits, and the mix of energy sources used to generate electricity for EVs." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing the life cycle assessment (LCA) specifically on the manufacturing phase of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve a detailed analysis of the energy consumption, raw material sourcing, and emissions associated with the production of each vehicle type. By honing in on the manufacturing process, we can uncover specific environmental impacts related to the production of batteries for EVs compared to internal combustion engines for gasoline vehicles, providing insights into the most resource-intensive and environmentally impactful aspects of vehicle production." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:51.014972", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 50 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_51.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_51.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e0e2b0ff428d5a456cd09b3c516bc999ff27eb24 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_51.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "5613c61b-696e-4399-9a92-5ebd98280d9f", + "ibfs_id": "8cf951fd-c8ff-4c00-b6d0-a3209a1bc4ec", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions over their lifecycle, but battery production impacts, and resource extraction pose environmental challenges.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles during their operational lifetime, we need to focus on emissions and energy efficiency during the use phase.\n\n### Emissions from Gasoline Vehicles\n\nGasoline vehicles emit greenhouse gases (GHGs) and other pollutants directly from their tailpipes during operation. The primary emissions include:\n\n1. **Carbon Dioxide (CO2):** Gasoline combustion in internal combustion engines produces CO2, a major contributor to climate change.\n2. **Nitrogen Oxides (NOx):** These contribute to smog and acid rain and can cause respiratory problems.\n3. **Particulate Matter (PM):** Tiny particles that can penetrate the lungs and cause health issues.\n4. **Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs):** Contribute to ozone formation and smog.\n\nThe emissions from gasoline vehicles are directly proportional to fuel consumption, which is influenced by the vehicle's fuel efficiency.\n\n### Emissions from Electric Vehicles\n\nElectric vehicles do not produce tailpipe emissions during operation. However, the environmental impact during the use phase depends on the source of electricity used to charge them:\n\n1. **Renewable Energy Sources:** If the electricity comes from renewable sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the emissions associated with EV operation are minimal. This scenario represents the best-case environmental outcome for EVs.\n \n2. **Fossil Fuel-Based Electricity:** If the electricity is generated from coal, natural gas, or oil, there are upstream emissions associated with power generation. The impact varies based on the energy mix of the grid:\n - **Coal:** High CO2 emissions per unit of electricity generated.\n - **Natural Gas:** Lower CO2 emissions compared to coal but still significant.\n - **Oil:** Similar to natural gas but less common for electricity generation.\n\n### Energy Efficiency\n\nElectric vehicles are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. This efficiency is measured by how much of the energy from the fuel (or electricity) is converted into actual vehicle movement:\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles:** EVs typically convert over 60% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels. This high efficiency contributes to lower overall emissions, especially when powered by cleaner energy sources.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:** Internal combustion engines convert only about 20-30% of the energy stored in gasoline into power at the wheels, with the rest lost as heat and through other inefficiencies.\n\n### Long-Term Environmental Consequences\n\n- **Climate Impact:** EVs have the potential to significantly reduce GHG emissions during their use phase, especially as the electricity grid becomes cleaner with more renewable energy sources.\n- **Air Quality:** The absence of tailpipe emissions from EVs improves urban air quality by reducing pollutants like NOx and PM.\n- **Energy Transition:** As the energy grid transitions towards more renewable sources, the environmental benefits of EVs will continue to increase, making them a more sustainable choice in the long term.\n\nIn summary, during the operational lifetime, electric vehicles offer significant environmental advantages over gasoline vehicles, primarily due to their higher energy efficiency and the potential for low emissions when powered by renewable energy sources. However, the overall impact depends on the electricity generation mix used for charging. As the grid becomes greener, the benefits of EVs will become even more pronounced.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison. This approach involves analyzing the entire lifecycle of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to vehicle use and end-of-life disposal. By examining each stage, I can provide a comprehensive view of their respective environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion.", + "I can answer by concentrating on the vehicle use phase, examining the environmental impacts during the operational lifetime of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve assessing the emissions associated with driving, including the source of electricity for EVs (whether renewable or fossil fuel-based) and the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles. By focusing on the energy efficiency and emissions output during the use phase, I can shed light on the long-term environmental consequences of choosing one vehicle type over the other." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison. This approach involves analyzing the entire lifecycle of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to vehicle use and end-of-life disposal. By examining each stage, I can provide a comprehensive view of their respective environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion.", + "I can answer by focusing on the regional energy grid analysis. This involves assessing how the environmental impact of electric vehicles varies depending on the energy mix of the electricity grid in different regions. For example, the impact in regions relying heavily on coal might differ vastly from those using renewable energy sources. I would compare this with the emissions and environmental impact of gasoline vehicles, which remain relatively consistent regardless of location, to highlight the differences." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment comparison. This approach involves analyzing the entire lifecycle of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to vehicle use and end-of-life disposal. By examining each stage, I can provide a comprehensive view of their respective environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a detailed comparison of the manufacturing processes of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve analyzing the environmental impacts associated with the production phase, such as the energy use and emissions resulting from the mining of raw materials like lithium for batteries versus the extraction of crude oil for gasoline vehicles. By highlighting the distinct environmental footprints of manufacturing each type of vehicle, I can provide insights into the initial phase of their lifecycle assessment.", + "I can answer by concentrating on the vehicle use phase, examining the environmental impacts during the operational lifetime of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve assessing the emissions associated with driving, including the source of electricity for EVs (whether renewable or fossil fuel-based) and the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles. By focusing on the energy efficiency and emissions output during the use phase, I can shed light on the long-term environmental consequences of choosing one vehicle type over the other." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by concentrating on the vehicle use phase, examining the environmental impacts during the operational lifetime of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve assessing the emissions associated with driving, including the source of electricity for EVs (whether renewable or fossil fuel-based) and the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles. By focusing on the energy efficiency and emissions output during the use phase, I can shed light on the long-term environmental consequences of choosing one vehicle type over the other." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:46.371891", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 51 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_52.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_52.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..49af6f9a2599171a913366e8e9ee156c71cf2574 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_52.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c47ead2f-b47f-4cde-a9a2-b4ff91c4ab3a", + "ibfs_id": "89f6c8f8-4f40-4cda-85f2-f6ac20ebb5aa", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce greenhouse gases and pollution significantly, but their production and battery disposal present environmental challenges.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a component-focused lifecycle analysis. This involves examining the environmental impact of each major component involved in the lifecycle of both vehicle types, from production to disposal. Key components include the battery for EVs, the engine for gasoline vehicles, and other shared components like the body and tires. We'll assess these components based on energy consumption, emissions, and resource depletion.\n\n### 1. Battery Production (Electric Vehicles)\n\n**Energy Consumption and Emissions:**\n- **Production:** The production of lithium-ion batteries, which are commonly used in EVs, is energy-intensive. It involves mining and processing raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. This process emits significant greenhouse gases (GHGs) due to the energy required, often from fossil fuels.\n- **Resource Depletion:** Mining for battery materials can lead to habitat destruction and water pollution. Cobalt mining, in particular, has raised ethical concerns due to labor practices and environmental degradation.\n\n### 2. Engine Manufacturing (Gasoline Vehicles)\n\n**Energy Consumption and Emissions:**\n- **Production:** Manufacturing an internal combustion engine (ICE) involves casting, machining, and assembling various metal components. This process is less energy-intensive than battery production but still contributes to GHG emissions.\n- **Resource Depletion:** The production of ICEs requires steel and aluminum, which involve mining and processing that can lead to environmental degradation.\n\n### 3. Vehicle Assembly and Body Production (Both EVs and Gasoline Vehicles)\n\n**Energy Consumption and Emissions:**\n- **Production:** The assembly of both EVs and gasoline vehicles involves similar processes, such as stamping, welding, and painting. These processes consume energy and produce emissions, though the impact is relatively similar for both vehicle types.\n- **Resource Depletion:** The materials used, such as steel, aluminum, and plastics, require mining and processing, contributing to resource depletion and environmental impact.\n\n### 4. Fuel Production and Consumption (Gasoline Vehicles)\n\n**Energy Consumption and Emissions:**\n- **Fuel Production:** Extracting, refining, and transporting gasoline is energy-intensive and results in significant GHG emissions. Oil extraction can also lead to spills and habitat destruction.\n- **Consumption:** During operation, gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, and other pollutants, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n\n### 5. Electricity Generation and Consumption (Electric Vehicles)\n\n**Energy Consumption and Emissions:**\n- **Electricity Generation:** The environmental impact of EVs during operation depends on the energy mix used to generate electricity. Coal-based electricity results in higher emissions, whereas renewable sources like wind or solar have minimal emissions.\n- **Consumption:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, reducing local air pollution compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n### 6. End-of-Life and Recycling (Both EVs and Gasoline Vehicles)\n\n**Energy Consumption and Emissions:**\n- **Recycling:** Both vehicle types can be recycled, but the processes differ. EV batteries require specialized recycling to recover valuable materials, which is energy-intensive but reduces the need for new raw materials.\n- **Disposal:** Improper disposal of batteries can lead to environmental contamination, while gasoline vehicles primarily contribute to metal waste if not recycled.\n\n### Comparative Summary\n\n- **Production Phase:** EVs have a higher environmental impact during production due to battery manufacturing, but gasoline vehicles have a lower impact in this phase.\n- **Use Phase:** EVs generally have lower environmental impacts during use, especially if powered by renewable energy, due to zero tailpipe emissions. Gasoline vehicles have higher emissions due to fuel combustion.\n- **End-of-Life Phase:** Both vehicle types have opportunities for recycling, but EVs require more specialized processes for battery recycling.\n\nOverall, while EVs have a higher initial environmental impact during production, they tend to offer lower impacts during the use phase, especially when powered by clean energy. The end-of-life impacts can be mitigated through effective recycling strategies for both vehicle types.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves assessing the environmental impact from production to disposal, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling. By comparing the complete lifecycle emissions and resource use of electric vehicles (EVs) to that of traditional gasoline vehicles, I can provide a comprehensive understanding of their relative environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by conducting a component-focused lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This method would involve breaking down the lifecycle into specific components, such as the battery production for EVs and engine manufacturing for gasoline vehicles. By assessing the environmental impact of each component separately, such as energy consumption, emissions, and resource depletion, I can compare how individual parts contribute to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type, offering a detailed view of their comparative impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves assessing the environmental impact from production to disposal, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling. By comparing the complete lifecycle emissions and resource use of electric vehicles (EVs) to that of traditional gasoline vehicles, I can provide a comprehensive understanding of their relative environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by examining specific environmental factors separately, such as greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, and resource consumption. For instance, I can analyze the carbon emissions produced during the use phase of each vehicle type and compare them. Additionally, I can look at the impact on air quality due to tailpipe emissions from gasoline vehicles versus the emissions from electricity generation for EVs. By breaking down the environmental impacts into distinct categories, I can offer a detailed comparison that highlights the strengths and weaknesses of each vehicle type in each area." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves assessing the environmental impact from production to disposal, including raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life recycling. By comparing the complete lifecycle emissions and resource use of electric vehicles (EVs) to that of traditional gasoline vehicles, I can provide a comprehensive understanding of their relative environmental impacts." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a region-specific lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would consider the environmental impacts unique to different geographic areas, such as the source of electricity for EVs (renewable vs. non-renewable) and the local availability of recycling facilities. By analyzing how these regional variations affect the total lifecycle emissions and resource use, I can provide insights into the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles in specific contexts, leading to a more tailored understanding of their impacts.", + "I can answer by conducting a component-focused lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This method would involve breaking down the lifecycle into specific components, such as the battery production for EVs and engine manufacturing for gasoline vehicles. By assessing the environmental impact of each component separately, such as energy consumption, emissions, and resource depletion, I can compare how individual parts contribute to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type, offering a detailed view of their comparative impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a component-focused lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This method would involve breaking down the lifecycle into specific components, such as the battery production for EVs and engine manufacturing for gasoline vehicles. By assessing the environmental impact of each component separately, such as energy consumption, emissions, and resource depletion, I can compare how individual parts contribute to the overall environmental footprint of each vehicle type, offering a detailed view of their comparative impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:52.229869", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 52 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_53.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_53.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2cb6446cd4c295631985bd37cd591a0c5d5b8861 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_53.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c8f83bda-fb7f-420d-b698-26c889d50bce", + "ibfs_id": "fd057b24-490f-4f31-a2bc-05dabba9137c", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce zero tailpipe emissions and use renewable energy, reducing pollution compared to gasoline vehicles which emit pollutants.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a meta-analysis of the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, I will synthesize data from multiple peer-reviewed scientific studies that have quantitatively assessed these impacts. The focus will be on greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, and other relevant environmental metrics.\n\n### Greenhouse Gas Emissions\n\n1. **Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) Studies**: Numerous LCA studies have been conducted to compare the total greenhouse gas emissions of EVs and gasoline vehicles. A meta-analysis of these studies shows that, on average, EVs produce significantly lower greenhouse gas emissions over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles. For instance, a study by Hawkins et al. (2013) found that EVs can reduce emissions by approximately 20-30% in regions with average electricity grids, and up to 50% in regions with cleaner energy sources.\n\n2. **Electricity Source Dependency**: The environmental benefit of EVs is highly dependent on the electricity mix used for charging. A meta-analysis by Nordel\u00f6f et al. (2014) indicates that in areas with a high percentage of renewable energy, the reduction in emissions can be as high as 70% compared to gasoline vehicles. Conversely, in regions reliant on coal, the benefits are reduced but still present.\n\n### Air Quality\n\n1. **Tailpipe Emissions**: EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, which directly improves urban air quality by reducing pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM). A meta-analysis of urban air quality studies, such as those by Timmers and Achten (2016), shows a consistent reduction in NOx and PM levels in cities with higher EV adoption.\n\n2. **Upstream Emissions**: While EVs eliminate tailpipe emissions, the production of electricity and manufacturing of batteries contribute to upstream emissions. However, a synthesis of studies, including those by Notter et al. (2010), suggests that the overall impact on air quality is still positive, as the reduction in urban pollutants outweighs the emissions from electricity generation, especially as grids become greener.\n\n### Resource Use and Environmental Impact\n\n1. **Battery Production**: The production of lithium-ion batteries for EVs is resource-intensive, involving materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. A meta-analysis by Dunn et al. (2012) highlights that while battery production has a higher environmental impact than conventional vehicle manufacturing, advancements in recycling and battery technology are mitigating these effects.\n\n2. **End-of-Life Management**: Studies such as those by Gaines (2014) show that the environmental impact of EVs can be further reduced through effective recycling and reuse of battery materials, which is becoming more feasible with technological advancements.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe meta-analysis of peer-reviewed studies indicates that electric vehicles generally have a lower environmental impact than traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in terms of greenhouse gas emissions and urban air quality. The benefits are more pronounced in regions with cleaner electricity grids and are expected to increase as renewable energy adoption grows and battery technologies improve. While there are challenges related to battery production and resource use, ongoing advancements in these areas are likely to enhance the environmental benefits of EVs over time.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by reviewing existing scientific studies and reports from reputable organizations and research institutions. This approach entails summarizing key findings from these studies, focusing on various environmental factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, resource depletion, and ecological impacts related to electric and gasoline vehicles. By synthesizing the consensus and differing viewpoints in the literature, I can provide a comprehensive overview of their environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by conducting a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed scientific papers that have quantitatively assessed the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This involves statistically analyzing the data from multiple studies to identify general trends and patterns, such as the average reduction in greenhouse gas emissions or changes in air quality metrics. By presenting a statistically robust synthesis, I can provide insights into the overall environmental impact that combines various study results into a coherent conclusion." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining every stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage to disposal\u2014to assess their environmental impacts. I will gather data on emissions, energy consumption, and resource use for both types of vehicles during each stage and then compare the cumulative environmental footprint.", + "I can answer by reviewing existing scientific studies and reports from reputable organizations and research institutions. This approach entails summarizing key findings from these studies, focusing on various environmental factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, resource depletion, and ecological impacts related to electric and gasoline vehicles. By synthesizing the consensus and differing viewpoints in the literature, I can provide a comprehensive overview of their environmental impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by reviewing existing scientific studies and reports from reputable organizations and research institutions. This approach entails summarizing key findings from these studies, focusing on various environmental factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, resource depletion, and ecological impacts related to electric and gasoline vehicles. By synthesizing the consensus and differing viewpoints in the literature, I can provide a comprehensive overview of their environmental impacts." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed scientific papers that have quantitatively assessed the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This involves statistically analyzing the data from multiple studies to identify general trends and patterns, such as the average reduction in greenhouse gas emissions or changes in air quality metrics. By presenting a statistically robust synthesis, I can provide insights into the overall environmental impact that combines various study results into a coherent conclusion.", + "I can answer by creating a comparative case study analysis, where I select specific geographic regions or countries that have transitioned significantly to electric vehicles and compare them to regions still predominantly using gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining region-specific scientific studies and government reports to evaluate localized environmental impacts, such as improvements in urban air quality or changes in local ecosystems. By comparing these case studies, I can highlight how the environmental impacts of electric vehicles vary across different socio-economic and environmental contexts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed scientific papers that have quantitatively assessed the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This involves statistically analyzing the data from multiple studies to identify general trends and patterns, such as the average reduction in greenhouse gas emissions or changes in air quality metrics. By presenting a statistically robust synthesis, I can provide insights into the overall environmental impact that combines various study results into a coherent conclusion." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:57.431043", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 53 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_54.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_54.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..eccaa0aef00f1f26991447164d8a8fddb7249e88 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_54.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "08c7388e-9ab1-4ee5-a237-fe58f66ea3b9", + "ibfs_id": "8f12e43e-1ca6-46c3-bb57-873d51ce9208", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles offer reduced emissions and lower lifetime environmental impact, though battery production and disposal pose environmental challenges.", + "final_answer": "To understand the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through a regional lifecycle analysis, we must consider several key factors that vary by location: the composition of the electricity grid, regional manufacturing practices, and waste management infrastructure. These factors significantly influence the emissions, resource use, and sustainability of each vehicle type.\n\n### 1. Electricity Grid Composition\n\nThe environmental impact of EVs is heavily influenced by the source of electricity used for charging. Regions with cleaner energy sources, such as hydroelectric, wind, or solar power, will have lower associated emissions for EVs compared to regions reliant on coal or natural gas.\n\n- **Norway**: In Norway, where the electricity grid is predominantly powered by hydropower, EVs have a significantly lower carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. The lifecycle emissions from EVs in this region are much lower due to the clean energy used for charging.\n\n- **China**: In contrast, China\u2019s electricity grid is still heavily reliant on coal. As a result, the lifecycle emissions of EVs in China are higher than in Norway, though still generally lower than gasoline vehicles. However, the benefits of EVs in terms of emissions are less pronounced here compared to regions with cleaner grids.\n\n### 2. Regional Manufacturing Practices\n\nThe environmental impact of vehicle manufacturing also varies by region, influenced by local industrial practices and energy sources.\n\n- **Germany**: In Germany, where there is a strong emphasis on sustainable manufacturing and the use of renewable energy in industrial processes, the production of EVs tends to have a lower environmental impact compared to regions with less efficient manufacturing practices.\n\n- **United States**: In the U.S., the impact can vary significantly by state. States with more stringent environmental regulations and cleaner energy sources for manufacturing, like California, will have a lower impact compared to states with less focus on sustainable practices.\n\n### 3. Waste Management Infrastructure\n\nThe end-of-life phase of vehicles, including recycling and disposal, also contributes to their environmental impact. Effective recycling programs can mitigate the environmental footprint of both EVs and gasoline vehicles.\n\n- **European Union**: The EU has robust recycling regulations, which help reduce the environmental impact of EV batteries by recovering valuable materials and ensuring safe disposal. This makes EVs more sustainable in the EU compared to regions with less developed recycling infrastructure.\n\n- **India**: In India, where waste management infrastructure is less developed, the disposal of EV batteries poses significant environmental challenges. The lack of efficient recycling processes can lead to increased environmental harm from battery waste.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe regional lifecycle analysis reveals that the environmental benefits of electric vehicles over gasoline vehicles are highly dependent on geographic factors. In regions with clean energy grids, sustainable manufacturing practices, and efficient waste management systems, EVs offer substantial environmental advantages. However, in regions with coal-dependent grids, less efficient manufacturing, and inadequate recycling infrastructure, the benefits of EVs are reduced, though they often still outperform gasoline vehicles in terms of emissions. This analysis underscores the importance of regional context in assessing the environmental impacts of vehicle technologies.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which involves examining the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from raw material extraction through manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. This approach will cover factors such as resource consumption, emissions during production, energy efficiency, and recycling potential, providing a comprehensive overview of their environmental footprints throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by performing a regional lifecycle analysis to understand the geographic variations in environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This approach examines how factors such as local electricity grid composition, regional manufacturing practices, and waste management infrastructure influence the environmental footprint of each vehicle type. By focusing on specific regions, I can highlight variations in emissions, resource use, and overall sustainability due to differing regional conditions." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which involves examining the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from raw material extraction through manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. This approach will cover factors such as resource consumption, emissions during production, energy efficiency, and recycling potential, providing a comprehensive overview of their environmental footprints throughout their entire lifecycles.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase, specifically analyzing the emissions and energy consumption during the use of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach will highlight the differences in greenhouse gas emissions, air pollutants, and energy efficiency when the vehicles are driven, considering factors like electricity generation sources for EVs and fuel efficiency for gasoline vehicles. This will offer insights into the day-to-day environmental impacts of using each type of vehicle." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, which involves examining the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from raw material extraction through manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal. This approach will cover factors such as resource consumption, emissions during production, energy efficiency, and recycling potential, providing a comprehensive overview of their environmental footprints throughout their entire lifecycles." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a cradle-to-cradle lifecycle assessment that specifically focuses on the circularity of materials used in electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the potential for reusing and recycling materials at the end of each vehicle's life, assessing how the design of each vehicle type supports a circular economy, and comparing the environmental benefits of material recovery processes for both types of vehicles.", + "I can answer by performing a regional lifecycle analysis to understand the geographic variations in environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This approach examines how factors such as local electricity grid composition, regional manufacturing practices, and waste management infrastructure influence the environmental footprint of each vehicle type. By focusing on specific regions, I can highlight variations in emissions, resource use, and overall sustainability due to differing regional conditions." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by performing a regional lifecycle analysis to understand the geographic variations in environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This approach examines how factors such as local electricity grid composition, regional manufacturing practices, and waste management infrastructure influence the environmental footprint of each vehicle type. By focusing on specific regions, I can highlight variations in emissions, resource use, and overall sustainability due to differing regional conditions." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:09:49.425727", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 54 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_55.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_55.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a177a0dcce413b56ccf5cfaefbe212bd0de1fba9 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_55.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c968e9bf-0e3f-491a-8333-f74368dc8f61", + "ibfs_id": "29aa0f17-fafe-4b4a-a1eb-ed82b236b995", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles emit less CO2, reducing air pollution, but battery production impacts must be considered compared to gasoline vehicle emissions.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles using a gate-to-grave analysis, we focus on the latter stages of their lifecycle: operation, maintenance, and disposal.\n\n### Operation\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Emissions:** During operation, EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions. This means they do not emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), or particulate matter, which are common pollutants from gasoline vehicles. However, the overall emissions depend on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the emissions are minimal. Conversely, if the electricity comes from coal or other fossil fuels, indirect emissions can be significant.\n- **Energy Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles. They convert over 77% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, whereas gasoline vehicles convert only about 12%\u201330% of the energy stored in gasoline.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change. The amount of emissions depends on the vehicle's fuel efficiency and the type of fuel used.\n- **Energy Efficiency:** Gasoline vehicles are less efficient in converting fuel energy into movement, resulting in higher operational emissions per mile compared to EVs.\n\n### Maintenance\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Maintenance Needs:** EVs typically require less maintenance than gasoline vehicles. They have fewer moving parts, no oil changes, and less wear on brakes due to regenerative braking systems. This can lead to reduced environmental impact from maintenance activities.\n- **Battery Life:** The main maintenance concern is the battery, which can degrade over time. However, advancements in battery technology are improving longevity and performance.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Maintenance Needs:** These vehicles require regular oil changes, air filter replacements, and other maintenance activities that can have environmental impacts due to the disposal of used oil and parts.\n- **Engine Wear:** Internal combustion engines have more moving parts, which can lead to more frequent repairs and replacements, contributing to waste and resource use.\n\n### Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal of EV batteries is a significant environmental concern. Batteries contain valuable materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which can be recycled. However, the recycling process can be energy-intensive and may produce waste if not managed properly. Efforts are being made to improve battery recycling technologies and infrastructure to minimize environmental impacts.\n- **End-of-Life Management:** As EVs reach the end of their life, proper recycling and disposal of electronic components and batteries are crucial to minimize environmental harm.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **End-of-Life Management:** Traditional vehicles are typically dismantled, and materials like steel and aluminum are recycled. However, fluids and other hazardous materials must be carefully managed to prevent environmental contamination.\n- **Waste Generation:** The disposal of used oil, filters, and other components can pose environmental risks if not handled correctly.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, during the operation phase, EVs have a clear advantage over gasoline vehicles in terms of emissions and energy efficiency. Maintenance for EVs is generally less environmentally impactful due to fewer moving parts and no need for oil changes. However, the disposal phase presents challenges for both vehicle types. EVs require effective battery recycling processes to mitigate environmental impacts, while gasoline vehicles need careful management of hazardous materials. Overall, the long-term ecological implications favor EVs, particularly as renewable energy sources become more prevalent for electricity generation.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation, to disposal. This approach will help quantify and compare elements such as carbon emissions, resource depletion, and waste generation associated with each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by performing a gate-to-grave analysis, concentrating on the latter stages of the lifecycle for electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy emphasizes the environmental impacts during the operation, maintenance, and eventual disposal of the vehicles. By assessing aspects such as emissions during vehicle use, the sustainability of battery recycling processes, and waste management challenges, this approach aims to highlight the long-term ecological implications and end-of-life considerations for both vehicle types." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation, to disposal. This approach will help quantify and compare elements such as carbon emissions, resource depletion, and waste generation associated with each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of the vehicles. This strategy would involve analyzing the emissions produced during the use of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles, considering factors such as the source of electricity for EVs (renewable vs. non-renewable) and the fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles. This will provide insights into the immediate environmental impacts related to vehicle operation, such as greenhouse gas emissions and air quality effects." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation, to disposal. This approach will help quantify and compare elements such as carbon emissions, resource depletion, and waste generation associated with each type of vehicle." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a cradle-to-gate analysis focused on the initial stages of the lifecycle for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy involves a detailed examination of the environmental impacts from raw material extraction to the manufacturing process. By evaluating factors such as the energy consumption during battery production for electric vehicles and the environmental cost of refining oil for gasoline vehicles, this approach provides insights into the early-stage ecological footprints of each type.", + "I can answer by performing a gate-to-grave analysis, concentrating on the latter stages of the lifecycle for electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy emphasizes the environmental impacts during the operation, maintenance, and eventual disposal of the vehicles. By assessing aspects such as emissions during vehicle use, the sustainability of battery recycling processes, and waste management challenges, this approach aims to highlight the long-term ecological implications and end-of-life considerations for both vehicle types." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by performing a gate-to-grave analysis, concentrating on the latter stages of the lifecycle for electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy emphasizes the environmental impacts during the operation, maintenance, and eventual disposal of the vehicles. By assessing aspects such as emissions during vehicle use, the sustainability of battery recycling processes, and waste management challenges, this approach aims to highlight the long-term ecological implications and end-of-life considerations for both vehicle types." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:00.448298", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 55 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_56.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_56.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..512cd9ee6421b5a8111c7ae33781be49d28defea --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_56.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "62469360-a8b9-40c1-90c7-87ad4a3fc290", + "ibfs_id": "bc0abf6e-7a39-4dff-8fb0-f219d511bcca", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but battery production and disposal pose environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine the energy sources used throughout their life cycles. This involves analyzing the electricity generation mix for EVs and the extraction and refining processes of fossil fuels for gasoline vehicles.\n\n### Electric Vehicles (EVs)\n\n1. **Electricity Generation Mix:**\n - **Renewable Sources:** EVs can be powered by electricity generated from renewable sources such as wind, solar, hydroelectric, and geothermal energy. These sources are generally low in carbon emissions and have minimal environmental impact compared to fossil fuels. The more a region relies on renewables, the lower the carbon footprint of EVs.\n - **Non-Renewable Sources:** In many regions, electricity is still partially generated from non-renewable sources like coal, natural gas, and oil. Coal-fired power plants are particularly carbon-intensive, emitting significant amounts of CO2 and other pollutants. Natural gas is cleaner than coal but still contributes to greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n2. **Carbon Intensity and Pollution Levels:**\n - The carbon intensity of electricity varies widely depending on the energy mix. For example, regions with a high percentage of coal in their energy mix will have higher emissions associated with EV use compared to regions with a high percentage of renewables.\n - The overall environmental impact of EVs is reduced as the grid becomes greener, with more renewable energy sources being integrated.\n\n### Gasoline Vehicles\n\n1. **Fossil Fuel Extraction and Refining:**\n - **Extraction:** The extraction of crude oil involves drilling and pumping, which can lead to environmental degradation, habitat destruction, and oil spills. These activities also release methane, a potent greenhouse gas.\n - **Refining:** Crude oil must be refined into gasoline, a process that is energy-intensive and emits CO2 and other pollutants. Refineries also release volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and sulfur dioxide (SO2), contributing to air pollution and acid rain.\n\n2. **Carbon Intensity and Pollution Levels:**\n - Gasoline combustion in internal combustion engines produces CO2, nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter, and other pollutants. These emissions contribute to climate change, smog, and respiratory health issues.\n - The carbon intensity of gasoline vehicles is relatively fixed, as it primarily depends on the efficiency of the vehicle and the carbon content of the fuel.\n\n### Comparative Insights\n\n- **Life Cycle Emissions:** Over their entire life cycle, EVs tend to have lower greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline vehicles, especially as the electricity grid becomes cleaner. This is because the emissions from electricity generation can be significantly lower than those from fuel extraction, refining, and combustion.\n- **Pollution Levels:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which can lead to improved air quality in urban areas. However, the environmental benefits depend on the cleanliness of the electricity used to charge them.\n- **Energy Transition:** The environmental impact of EVs will continue to improve as the global energy transition progresses, with increased adoption of renewable energy sources and advancements in battery technology.\n\nIn conclusion, while both vehicle types have environmental impacts associated with their energy sources, EVs generally offer a pathway to reduced emissions and pollution, particularly as the energy sector shifts towards more sustainable practices.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling. By comparing the total environmental footprint, including carbon emissions, resource use, and pollution, I can provide a comprehensive comparison between the two vehicle types.", + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the energy sources used throughout the life cycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves a detailed assessment of the environmental impacts associated with the electricity generation mix for electric vehicles, including renewable and non-renewable sources, as well as the extraction and refining processes of fossil fuels for gasoline vehicles. By comparing the carbon intensity and pollution levels of these energy sources, I can provide insights into how energy production and consumption contribute to the overall environmental impact of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling. By comparing the total environmental footprint, including carbon emissions, resource use, and pollution, I can provide a comprehensive comparison between the two vehicle types.", + "I can answer by focusing on the energy source used during the operation phase of the vehicles. This strategy involves analyzing the emissions and environmental impact of generating electricity for electric vehicles versus the direct emissions from burning gasoline in traditional vehicles. This includes examining the carbon intensity of the electricity grid in different regions, as well as the potential for renewable energy integration to reduce the environmental impact of electric vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling. By comparing the total environmental footprint, including carbon emissions, resource use, and pollution, I can provide a comprehensive comparison between the two vehicle types." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the energy sources used throughout the life cycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves a detailed assessment of the environmental impacts associated with the electricity generation mix for electric vehicles, including renewable and non-renewable sources, as well as the extraction and refining processes of fossil fuels for gasoline vehicles. By comparing the carbon intensity and pollution levels of these energy sources, I can provide insights into how energy production and consumption contribute to the overall environmental impact of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by conducting a geographical life cycle assessment (LCA) that considers the regional variations in environmental impacts for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach evaluates how factors like local electricity grid compositions, transportation infrastructure, and recycling capabilities affect the life cycle impacts of vehicles in different regions. By analyzing these regional differences, I can provide a nuanced comparison that highlights how location-specific factors influence the overall environmental footprint of electric versus gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing specifically on the energy sources used throughout the life cycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves a detailed assessment of the environmental impacts associated with the electricity generation mix for electric vehicles, including renewable and non-renewable sources, as well as the extraction and refining processes of fossil fuels for gasoline vehicles. By comparing the carbon intensity and pollution levels of these energy sources, I can provide insights into how energy production and consumption contribute to the overall environmental impact of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:07.389583", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 56 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_57.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_57.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..58fa722acf850e2d88b59e32b6d7012876150b09 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_57.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "fd8b14a2-a88b-46cd-97b6-ed9392936394", + "ibfs_id": "2aed9d21-cb72-47ef-921c-d1b923e8676c", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce greenhouse emissions and air pollution but involve environmental costs through battery production and raw material mining.", + "final_answer": "To analyze the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we will conduct a comparative case study analysis focusing on three regions with distinct energy profiles: Norway, China, and the United States. Each region has varying levels of renewable energy integration and vehicle adoption rates, which affect the overall environmental impact of EVs.\n\n### Norway\n\n**Energy Profile and Vehicle Adoption:**\n- Norway is a leader in renewable energy, with approximately 98% of its electricity generated from hydropower.\n- The country has one of the highest per capita rates of EV adoption in the world, with EVs making up over 80% of new car sales as of 2023.\n\n**Environmental Impacts:**\n- **Emissions:** Due to the high share of renewable energy, the lifecycle emissions of EVs in Norway are significantly lower than those of gasoline vehicles. The carbon footprint of charging EVs is minimal, resulting in substantial reductions in greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Energy Source Dependency:** The reliance on hydropower means that EVs in Norway contribute minimally to fossil fuel dependency, enhancing energy security and reducing pollution.\n- **Recycling Practices:** Norway has established recycling systems for EV batteries, which further mitigates environmental impacts by reducing waste and recovering valuable materials.\n\n### China\n\n**Energy Profile and Vehicle Adoption:**\n- China has rapidly increased its EV adoption, with the government heavily promoting EVs as part of its strategy to reduce urban air pollution.\n- The country's energy mix is still heavily reliant on coal, although there is a growing investment in renewables like wind and solar.\n\n**Environmental Impacts:**\n- **Emissions:** While EVs help reduce urban air pollution, their lifecycle emissions in China are higher than in Norway due to the coal-dominated energy mix. However, they still offer a reduction in emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, particularly in urban areas where air quality is a significant concern.\n- **Energy Source Dependency:** The transition to EVs is part of China's strategy to reduce oil imports and increase energy independence. However, the coal-based electricity generation still poses environmental challenges.\n- **Recycling Practices:** China is developing battery recycling infrastructure, which is crucial given the scale of EV adoption. Effective recycling can mitigate some of the environmental impacts associated with battery production and disposal.\n\n### United States\n\n**Energy Profile and Vehicle Adoption:**\n- The U.S. has a diverse energy mix, with significant contributions from natural gas, coal, nuclear, and an increasing share of renewables.\n- EV adoption is growing, but gasoline vehicles still dominate the market.\n\n**Environmental Impacts:**\n- **Emissions:** The environmental impact of EVs in the U.S. varies by region, depending on the local energy mix. In states with higher renewable energy penetration, such as California, EVs have a lower carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. In regions reliant on coal, the benefits are less pronounced but still present.\n- **Energy Source Dependency:** EVs help reduce reliance on imported oil, contributing to energy security. The shift to renewables in the electricity sector further enhances the environmental benefits of EVs.\n- **Recycling Practices:** The U.S. is investing in battery recycling technologies, which is essential for minimizing the environmental impact of EVs and ensuring sustainable resource use.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles vary significantly across regions, influenced by the local energy mix, adoption rates, and recycling practices. In Norway, the high share of renewable energy makes EVs a clear environmental winner. In China, while coal reliance diminishes some benefits, EVs still contribute to reduced urban air pollution. In the U.S., regional differences in energy sources lead to varying impacts, with states investing in renewables seeing the most significant benefits. Effective battery recycling is a common challenge and opportunity across all regions, crucial for maximizing the environmental advantages of EVs.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by reviewing existing scientific studies and reports from authoritative sources such as government agencies, environmental organizations, and academic institutions. This approach will involve summarizing key findings from these studies regarding the environmental impacts of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles, focusing on factors like emissions during operation, energy sources for electricity production, and advances in battery technology and recycling.", + "I can answer by creating a comparative case study analysis using reports from specific regions or countries with different energy profiles. This approach will involve examining how the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles vary in places with different levels of renewable energy integration and vehicle adoption rates. The case studies will highlight differences in emissions, energy source dependencies, and recycling practices relevant to each region's unique context." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves examining each stage of a vehicle's life \u2014 from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal or recycling. I will evaluate the environmental impacts at each stage, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution, to provide a comprehensive comparison.", + "I can answer by reviewing existing scientific studies and reports from authoritative sources such as government agencies, environmental organizations, and academic institutions. This approach will involve summarizing key findings from these studies regarding the environmental impacts of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles, focusing on factors like emissions during operation, energy sources for electricity production, and advances in battery technology and recycling." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by reviewing existing scientific studies and reports from authoritative sources such as government agencies, environmental organizations, and academic institutions. This approach will involve summarizing key findings from these studies regarding the environmental impacts of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles, focusing on factors like emissions during operation, energy sources for electricity production, and advances in battery technology and recycling." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a meta-analysis of multiple scientific studies and reports from diverse authoritative sources. This approach will involve statistically synthesizing data from various studies to quantify the overall environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles. The analysis will focus on emissions during operation, lifecycle assessments, and the carbon footprint of manufacturing and recycling processes.", + "I can answer by creating a comparative case study analysis using reports from specific regions or countries with different energy profiles. This approach will involve examining how the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles vary in places with different levels of renewable energy integration and vehicle adoption rates. The case studies will highlight differences in emissions, energy source dependencies, and recycling practices relevant to each region's unique context." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by creating a comparative case study analysis using reports from specific regions or countries with different energy profiles. This approach will involve examining how the environmental impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles vary in places with different levels of renewable energy integration and vehicle adoption rates. The case studies will highlight differences in emissions, energy source dependencies, and recycling practices relevant to each region's unique context." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:11.661873", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 57 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_58.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_58.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..aed51ba72ec294de3430e5a819bdbb36dda529c8 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_58.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "02d3b124-76d0-49b4-92ae-d5ef194c14de", + "ibfs_id": "46652c31-b18e-42c5-82c5-d12a39375768", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles have lower emissions and energy efficiency advantages but involve resource-intensive battery production and recycling challenges.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a detailed toxicological assessment of the materials used in electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to evaluate the extraction and processing of raw materials, focusing on the environmental toxicity and human health risks associated with each.\n\n### Electric Vehicles (EVs)\n\n#### Key Materials:\n1. **Lithium**: \n - **Extraction**: Lithium is primarily extracted from brine pools and hard rock mining. The brine extraction process involves pumping groundwater to the surface and allowing it to evaporate, which can lead to significant water depletion in arid regions, impacting local ecosystems and communities.\n - **Toxicological Impacts**: The evaporation process can lead to soil and water contamination with heavy metals. Additionally, the mining process can disrupt local habitats and biodiversity.\n\n2. **Cobalt**:\n - **Extraction**: Cobalt is often mined as a byproduct of copper and nickel mining. Major sources are in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where mining practices can be environmentally damaging and socially problematic.\n - **Toxicological Impacts**: Cobalt mining can lead to soil and water pollution with heavy metals, posing risks to local communities' health. The mining process can also release particulate matter and other pollutants into the air, contributing to respiratory issues.\n\n3. **Nickel**:\n - **Extraction**: Nickel is extracted through sulfide or laterite mining. Both methods can have significant environmental impacts.\n - **Toxicological Impacts**: Sulfide mining can lead to acid mine drainage, which can severely impact water quality and aquatic life. Nickel mining and processing can release sulfur dioxide and other pollutants, contributing to air pollution and acid rain.\n\n### Gasoline Vehicles\n\n#### Key Materials:\n1. **Crude Oil**:\n - **Extraction**: Oil extraction involves drilling and can include methods like hydraulic fracturing (fracking). These processes can lead to habitat destruction, oil spills, and groundwater contamination.\n - **Toxicological Impacts**: Oil spills are catastrophic for marine and coastal ecosystems, leading to long-term ecological damage. Fracking fluids can contaminate groundwater with toxic chemicals, posing health risks to humans and wildlife.\n\n2. **Refining**:\n - **Process**: Crude oil refining involves separating hydrocarbons and converting them into usable fuels, which is energy-intensive and produces significant emissions.\n - **Toxicological Impacts**: Refining releases pollutants such as volatile organic compounds (VOCs), sulfur oxides, and nitrogen oxides, contributing to air pollution and respiratory health issues. The process also generates hazardous waste that can contaminate soil and water.\n\n### Comparative Analysis\n\n- **Environmental Toxicity**: Both EVs and gasoline vehicles have significant environmental impacts at different stages. EVs primarily impact the environment during the extraction and processing of battery materials, while gasoline vehicles have major impacts during oil extraction and refining.\n\n- **Human Health Risks**: The health risks associated with EVs are mostly related to the mining of materials like cobalt and nickel, which can lead to respiratory issues and heavy metal exposure. Gasoline vehicles pose health risks through air pollution from refining and combustion, leading to respiratory and cardiovascular diseases.\n\n- **Lifecycle Considerations**: While EVs have a higher environmental impact during the production phase due to battery materials, they generally have lower emissions during the use phase compared to gasoline vehicles. Gasoline vehicles, on the other hand, continue to emit pollutants throughout their lifecycle.\n\nIn conclusion, both electric and gasoline vehicles have distinct environmental and health impacts, with EVs being more impactful during the material extraction phase and gasoline vehicles during fuel extraction and use. Transitioning to EVs could reduce overall emissions, but it is crucial to address the environmental and social impacts of battery material extraction to ensure a sustainable transition.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include evaluating raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By comparing each stage of the vehicle lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive assessment of their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by conducting a detailed toxicological assessment of the materials used in both electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve evaluating the extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries, as well as the environmental and health impacts of oil extraction and refining for gasoline. By comparing the environmental toxicity and human health risks across both vehicle types, I can highlight specific stages where the impacts may be most significant." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include evaluating raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By comparing each stage of the vehicle lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive assessment of their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of vehicles and analyzing the emissions produced during their use. This approach would involve comparing tailpipe emissions from gasoline vehicles with the emissions generated by the electricity production needed to charge EVs. By considering different energy sources for electricity (e.g., coal, natural gas, renewable energy), I can evaluate how regional energy mixes influence the comparative environmental impacts of driving electric versus gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would include evaluating raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during operation, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. By comparing each stage of the vehicle lifecycle, I can provide a comprehensive assessment of their environmental footprints." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the energy sources used during the operation phase of electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve analyzing the environmental impacts of the electricity generation mix (e.g., coal, natural gas, renewables) for EVs in different regions compared to the emissions from gasoline combustion. By examining how the source of energy affects the lifecycle emissions, I can provide insights into regional variations in the environmental benefits of EVs.", + "I can answer by conducting a detailed toxicological assessment of the materials used in both electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve evaluating the extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries, as well as the environmental and health impacts of oil extraction and refining for gasoline. By comparing the environmental toxicity and human health risks across both vehicle types, I can highlight specific stages where the impacts may be most significant." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a detailed toxicological assessment of the materials used in both electric and gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would involve evaluating the extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries, as well as the environmental and health impacts of oil extraction and refining for gasoline. By comparing the environmental toxicity and human health risks across both vehicle types, I can highlight specific stages where the impacts may be most significant." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:17.057563", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 58 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_59.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_59.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6bdb911554a0117618035a2e27bf30528286c273 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_59.json @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "d5ecfeed-76be-46cd-bf3c-51e3120329c8", + "ibfs_id": "cb1c59e8-6595-4193-99ef-3570edf9af9d", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution overall, but concerns include battery production impacts and resource extraction environmental consequences.", + "final_answer": "To address the query regarding the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, I conducted a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed academic papers focusing on lifecycle assessments (LCAs) of these vehicle types. This approach allows us to systematically review and statistically combine results from multiple studies to identify common findings and variations.\n\n### Meta-Analysis of Lifecycle Assessments\n\n#### Production Phase\n\n1. **Material Extraction and Manufacturing**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is more resource-intensive than that of gasoline vehicles. Studies consistently show that battery manufacturing contributes significantly to the overall emissions of EVs. For instance, the production of lithium-ion batteries involves mining and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which are energy-intensive and have notable environmental impacts.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: The production emissions are generally lower than those of EVs due to the absence of large batteries. However, the manufacturing of internal combustion engines and associated components still contributes to emissions.\n\n2. **Common Findings**: Across multiple studies, the consensus is that EVs have higher production emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to battery manufacturing.\n\n#### Operational Phase\n\n1. **Energy Efficiency and Emissions**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: EVs are more energy-efficient and have zero tailpipe emissions. The environmental impact during the operational phase largely depends on the electricity mix used for charging. Studies indicate that in regions with a high share of renewable energy, EVs can significantly reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: These vehicles emit CO2 and other pollutants during operation. The efficiency of gasoline vehicles has improved over time, but they still contribute significantly to air pollution and GHG emissions.\n\n2. **Common Findings**: The operational phase is where EVs generally outperform gasoline vehicles, especially in regions with clean electricity grids. The reduction in emissions during this phase often offsets the higher production emissions of EVs over their lifecycle.\n\n#### End-of-Life Disposal\n\n1. **Recycling and Disposal**:\n - **Electric Vehicles**: The disposal and recycling of batteries pose environmental challenges. However, advancements in battery recycling technologies are improving the sustainability of EVs. Studies highlight the importance of developing efficient recycling processes to mitigate the environmental impact.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles**: End-of-life disposal is more straightforward, with established recycling processes for metals and other materials. However, the disposal of oil and other fluids can have environmental impacts.\n\n2. **Common Findings**: Both vehicle types face challenges at the end-of-life stage, but the potential for recycling EV batteries is a critical area for reducing their environmental impact.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe meta-analysis of lifecycle assessments reveals that while electric vehicles have higher emissions during the production phase, they offer significant environmental benefits during the operational phase, especially in regions with clean energy sources. Over the entire lifecycle, EVs tend to have a lower overall environmental impact compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to reduced operational emissions. However, the environmental benefits of EVs are contingent on advancements in battery technology, recycling processes, and the decarbonization of electricity grids.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by summarizing and synthesizing findings from existing research studies and reports that have analyzed the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach focuses on gathering data from authoritative sources such as government agencies, academic institutions, and environmental organizations. By comparing key metrics like emissions during operation, energy source sustainability, and battery production impacts, I can provide a balanced overview of the environmental benefits and drawbacks of each vehicle type based on established literature.", + "I can answer by conducting a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed academic papers that specifically focus on lifecycle assessments of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves systematically reviewing and statistically combining the results from multiple studies to identify common findings and variations in the data. By analyzing factors such as production emissions, operational efficiency, and end-of-life disposal, I can derive a comprehensive and statistically robust conclusion about the environmental impacts of the two vehicle types." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental impacts of each vehicle type throughout their entire lifecycle, from raw material extraction and manufacturing through operation and end-of-life disposal. By assessing factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution at each stage, we can gain a comprehensive understanding of the overall environmental footprint of each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by summarizing and synthesizing findings from existing research studies and reports that have analyzed the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach focuses on gathering data from authoritative sources such as government agencies, academic institutions, and environmental organizations. By comparing key metrics like emissions during operation, energy source sustainability, and battery production impacts, I can provide a balanced overview of the environmental benefits and drawbacks of each vehicle type based on established literature." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by summarizing and synthesizing findings from existing research studies and reports that have analyzed the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach focuses on gathering data from authoritative sources such as government agencies, academic institutions, and environmental organizations. By comparing key metrics like emissions during operation, energy source sustainability, and battery production impacts, I can provide a balanced overview of the environmental benefits and drawbacks of each vehicle type based on established literature." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed academic papers that specifically focus on lifecycle assessments of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves systematically reviewing and statistically combining the results from multiple studies to identify common findings and variations in the data. By analyzing factors such as production emissions, operational efficiency, and end-of-life disposal, I can derive a comprehensive and statistically robust conclusion about the environmental impacts of the two vehicle types.", + "I can answer by creating a comparative case study analysis that draws on specific research reports and data from different geographic regions. This involves selecting case studies that highlight the regional variability in environmental impacts due to factors like electricity grid composition, vehicle usage patterns, and local manufacturing practices. By examining these case studies, I can provide insights into how local conditions influence the environmental performance of electric versus gasoline vehicles, offering a nuanced understanding that goes beyond generalized findings." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a meta-analysis of peer-reviewed academic papers that specifically focus on lifecycle assessments of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves systematically reviewing and statistically combining the results from multiple studies to identify common findings and variations in the data. By analyzing factors such as production emissions, operational efficiency, and end-of-life disposal, I can derive a comprehensive and statistically robust conclusion about the environmental impacts of the two vehicle types." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:16.378474", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 59 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_6.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_6.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..405fc769b17872948b0175d418395dd92b1156ef --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_6.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "00ce6ed7-ce43-495f-891b-687f00418058", + "ibfs_id": "2372cec6-35e1-48a7-a2c6-66748e9d0c8e", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles generally produce fewer emissions over their lifecycle compared to gasoline vehicles, benefiting air quality and reducing greenhouse gases.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a lifecycle assessment (LCA) that encompasses the production, usage, and disposal stages of each vehicle type. This approach allows us to understand the comprehensive environmental footprint of both vehicle types.\n\n### 1. Production Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Raw Material Extraction:** EVs require significant amounts of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other rare earth metals for their batteries. The mining and processing of these materials can lead to habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Manufacturing:** The production of EVs, particularly their batteries, is energy-intensive. This stage often results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in battery technology and manufacturing efficiencies are gradually reducing these emissions.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Raw Material Extraction:** Gasoline vehicles primarily use steel, aluminum, and plastics. While these materials also require energy to extract and process, the environmental impact is generally lower than that of battery materials.\n- **Manufacturing:** The production process for gasoline vehicles is well-established and typically results in lower initial carbon emissions compared to EVs. However, the overall energy consumption is still significant.\n\n### 2. Usage Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Consumption:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions. Their environmental impact during the usage stage depends on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the impact is minimal. However, if it comes from fossil fuels, the emissions can be significant.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Consumption:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and other pollutants during operation. The combustion of gasoline is less efficient, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n- **Emissions:** The usage stage is where gasoline vehicles have the most significant environmental impact, contributing to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n### 3. Disposal Stage\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal of EVs poses challenges, particularly with battery recycling. While recycling technologies are improving, the process is complex and energy-intensive. Proper recycling can mitigate some environmental impacts by recovering valuable materials.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** The rest of the vehicle can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, with metals and plastics being reclaimed.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle, with established processes for reclaiming metals and other materials. However, the disposal of fluids and other hazardous materials remains a concern.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, the lifecycle assessment reveals that electric vehicles have a higher environmental impact during the production stage due to battery manufacturing. However, they offer significant benefits during the usage stage, especially when powered by renewable energy, due to their higher efficiency and zero tailpipe emissions. Gasoline vehicles, while having lower production emissions, contribute more significantly to environmental degradation during their operational life due to fossil fuel combustion. The disposal stage presents challenges for both vehicle types, particularly in battery recycling for EVs. Overall, the transition to electric vehicles can lead to reduced environmental impacts, especially as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery technologies advance.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by analyzing lifecycle assessments (LCAs) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts from production, usage, and disposal stages of each vehicle type. By breaking down these stages, I can highlight specific areas where EVs and gasoline vehicles differ in their environmental footprints, such as the sourcing of raw materials, energy consumption during operation, and end-of-life recycling processes." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comprehensive literature review of scientific studies and reports that compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve summarizing findings on various metrics such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource extraction impacts, and potential pollution from both vehicle types, providing a balanced view based on current research.", + "I can answer by analyzing lifecycle assessments (LCAs) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts from production, usage, and disposal stages of each vehicle type. By breaking down these stages, I can highlight specific areas where EVs and gasoline vehicles differ in their environmental footprints, such as the sourcing of raw materials, energy consumption during operation, and end-of-life recycling processes." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by analyzing lifecycle assessments (LCAs) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts from production, usage, and disposal stages of each vehicle type. By breaking down these stages, I can highlight specific areas where EVs and gasoline vehicles differ in their environmental footprints, such as the sourcing of raw materials, energy consumption during operation, and end-of-life recycling processes." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:59.518719", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 6 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_60.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_60.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..11820308cbd5340841f1632c742222a402745d5b --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_60.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "8b5c49b5-b5df-41b1-aab3-a72323f82f1a", + "ibfs_id": "bc1c121a-ef93-4be3-89d2-636c514f231c", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce fewer emissions, lower air pollution, and have a smaller carbon footprint compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, we will focus on the emissions and energy use associated with each type of vehicle.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n\n1. **Emissions During Operation:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit greenhouse gases (GHGs) directly from the tailpipe as a result of fuel combustion. The primary emissions include carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO), and particulate matter.\n - The amount of CO2 emitted is directly related to the fuel efficiency of the vehicle and the carbon content of the gasoline. On average, burning one gallon of gasoline produces about 8,887 grams of CO2.\n\n2. **Energy Use:**\n - Gasoline vehicles convert the chemical energy in gasoline into mechanical energy to power the vehicle. However, internal combustion engines are relatively inefficient, with only about 20-30% of the energy from gasoline being used to move the vehicle, while the rest is lost as heat.\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n\n1. **Emissions During Operation:**\n - EVs do not produce tailpipe emissions, as they rely on electric motors powered by batteries. However, the emissions associated with EVs depend on the source of the electricity used to charge them.\n - If the electricity comes from renewable sources such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the associated emissions are minimal. Conversely, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels like coal or natural gas, the emissions can be significant.\n\n2. **Energy Use:**\n - EVs are generally more efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 60% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels, compared to the much lower efficiency of internal combustion engines.\n - The efficiency of EVs can be influenced by factors such as driving conditions, temperature, and the efficiency of the battery and charging systems.\n\n**Comparison:**\n\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:**\n - Gasoline vehicles consistently emit GHGs during operation due to fuel combustion. In contrast, EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, but their overall emissions depend on the electricity mix.\n - In regions where electricity is predominantly generated from renewable sources, EVs have a significantly lower carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. However, in areas reliant on coal or other fossil fuels, the emissions from EVs can be higher, though still typically lower than those from gasoline vehicles.\n\n- **Energy Efficiency:**\n - EVs are more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, leading to lower energy consumption per mile traveled. This efficiency advantage contributes to reduced overall emissions, especially when powered by clean energy.\n\nIn summary, during the operational phase, electric vehicles generally have a lower environmental impact compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, primarily due to their higher efficiency and the potential for low emissions when powered by renewable energy sources. However, the exact environmental benefit of EVs depends significantly on the energy mix used for electricity generation in a given region.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy use during the operational phase of the vehicles. This approach would compare the greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion with the emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs. I would consider the sources of electricity (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and analyze how these contribute to the overall carbon footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the entire lifecycle of each type of vehicle, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal. By analyzing factors such as energy consumption, emissions, and resource depletion at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy use during the operational phase of the vehicles. This approach would compare the greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion with the emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs. I would consider the sources of electricity (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and analyze how these contribute to the overall carbon footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by exploring the implications of battery production and disposal for electric vehicles. This approach would specifically investigate the environmental impacts associated with the extraction and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which are critical for EV batteries. Additionally, I would examine the challenges and environmental consequences of battery recycling and disposal compared to the disposal of gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by evaluating the broader environmental and social impacts of infrastructure changes required for each vehicle type. This would include an analysis of the environmental footprint of developing charging infrastructure for EVs versus the impact of maintaining the existing network of gas stations for gasoline vehicles. I would also consider the potential for reduced air and noise pollution in urban areas due to increased EV adoption and the societal benefits of transitioning to cleaner transportation." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy use during the operational phase of the vehicles. This approach would compare the greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion with the emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs. I would consider the sources of electricity (renewable vs. fossil fuels) and analyze how these contribute to the overall carbon footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:22.457462", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 60 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_61.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_61.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..91bea148df128f37abe44a40c9c889f6aed9c47e --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_61.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "27b0ee75-2f05-4045-8f96-4c328d1a8ecd", + "ibfs_id": "8570b48e-ebc9-43cd-8d3e-a3e54915e27b", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles offer reduced emissions and decreased fossil fuel dependence, but require energy-intensive battery production and renewable energy sources.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a life cycle assessment (LCA) analysis. This involves examining each stage of the vehicle's life cycle: raw material extraction, manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life disposal.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve mining for lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, soil and water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use aluminum and copper more extensively than gasoline vehicles, contributing to additional mining impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fossil Fuels:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and pollution.\n- **Materials:** Gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and plastics, but generally in lesser quantities than the metals used in EV batteries.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** Manufacturing EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive, often resulting in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Material Processing:** The processing of battery materials also contributes to emissions and environmental impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Less Energy-Intensive:** The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles is typically less energy-intensive than for EVs, primarily due to the absence of large battery packs.\n- **Standard Components:** The production involves standard automotive components, which have established manufacturing processes with relatively lower emissions.\n\n### 3. Operation\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, reducing air pollution and greenhouse gases during operation.\n- **Electricity Source:** The environmental impact during operation depends on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources (solar, wind) significantly reduce emissions, while coal-based electricity increases them.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Advances in fuel efficiency have reduced emissions, but they remain higher than those from EVs powered by clean energy.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of lithium-ion batteries are challenging. Improper disposal can lead to toxic chemical leaching. However, advancements in recycling technology are improving the recovery of valuable materials.\n- **Recyclability:** Other components of EVs are similar to gasoline vehicles and can be recycled through existing processes.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Established Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles have established recycling processes for metals and other materials.\n- **Environmental Risks:** Disposal of engine oils and other fluids poses environmental risks if not managed properly.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, electric vehicles tend to have higher environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages due to battery production. However, they offer significant environmental benefits during the operation phase, especially when powered by renewable energy, due to zero tailpipe emissions. The end-of-life impacts of EVs are currently more challenging due to battery disposal, but improvements in recycling technologies are mitigating these issues.\n\nIn contrast, gasoline vehicles have lower initial manufacturing impacts but contribute more significantly to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational life. Their end-of-life disposal is generally well-managed but still poses environmental risks.\n\nThe net environmental impact of EVs versus gasoline vehicles largely depends on the electricity mix used to power EVs and advancements in battery technology and recycling.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) analysis for both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the entire life cycle of each type of vehicle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation to end-of-life disposal. By comparing the environmental impacts at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each vehicle type affects the environment throughout its life span." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) analysis for both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the entire life cycle of each type of vehicle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation to end-of-life disposal. By comparing the environmental impacts at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each vehicle type affects the environment throughout its life span.", + "I can answer by focusing on the carbon emissions associated with each vehicle type. This approach would specifically compare greenhouse gas emissions produced during the operation of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. I would also take into account the emissions from electricity generation for electric vehicles and the fuel production and combustion processes for gasoline vehicles, providing insights into their respective contributions to global warming.", + "I can answer by examining the resource and material usage of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This strategy involves analyzing the raw materials required for battery production in electric vehicles, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, and comparing them to the materials needed for gasoline vehicle production, like steel and aluminum. This would highlight issues such as resource depletion, mining impacts, and the sustainability of supply chains for both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by considering the impact on air quality and public health. This approach focuses on the pollutants emitted by gasoline vehicles, such as nitrogen oxides and particulate matter, compared to the localized emissions reductions from electric vehicles. I would also explore how the shift to electric vehicles can lead to improved air quality in urban areas and potentially reduce adverse health outcomes related to pollution." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) analysis for both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the entire life cycle of each type of vehicle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and operation to end-of-life disposal. By comparing the environmental impacts at each stage, I can provide a comprehensive overview of how each vehicle type affects the environment throughout its life span." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:21.672268", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 61 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_62.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_62.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8d2eb1c26e9edf71150326040f8e1ddbc5c477f1 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_62.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "3c46622b-6121-4766-895e-2b51b4c36fab", + "ibfs_id": "d7e8e463-68c2-429b-8612-5327ebb4dbfe", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce carbon emissions, offer cleaner energy options, but have battery production impacts compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles during their operation phase, we need to focus on the emissions produced while each type of vehicle is in use.\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n\n1. **Direct Emissions:**\n - Electric vehicles produce zero tailpipe emissions. This means they do not emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter (PM), or other pollutants directly from the vehicle itself during operation.\n\n2. **Indirect Emissions:**\n - The emissions associated with electric vehicles during their operation phase are primarily indirect, stemming from the electricity generation process used to charge the vehicle's battery.\n - The environmental impact of these emissions varies significantly depending on the energy mix of the electricity grid. In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources (such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power), the indirect emissions are very low. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, the emissions can be higher.\n - On average, even when accounting for electricity generation from fossil fuels, EVs typically result in lower overall greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles due to the higher efficiency of electric motors and the potential for cleaner energy sources.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n\n1. **Direct Emissions:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, NOx, carbon monoxide (CO), volatile organic compounds (VOCs), and particulate matter directly from the tailpipe as a result of burning fossil fuels.\n - These emissions contribute to air pollution and have significant impacts on human health and the environment, including contributing to smog formation and respiratory problems.\n\n2. **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:**\n - The operation of gasoline vehicles is a major source of CO2 emissions, a key greenhouse gas contributing to climate change. The amount of CO2 emitted is directly related to the fuel efficiency of the vehicle and the carbon content of the gasoline.\n\nIn summary, during the operation phase, electric vehicles have a clear advantage over gasoline vehicles in terms of direct emissions, as they produce none. However, the environmental impact of EVs is influenced by the source of electricity used for charging. Generally, even with a fossil-fuel-heavy electricity grid, EVs tend to have lower overall emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, especially as grids become cleaner over time with increased use of renewable energy sources.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the operation phase of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach will highlight the differences in greenhouse gas emissions and other pollutants released during the use of each type of vehicle, considering factors like electricity generation sources for electric vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles, which includes evaluating the environmental impact of production, usage, and disposal of each vehicle type. This approach will provide a comprehensive overview of the total environmental footprint of each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the operation phase of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach will highlight the differences in greenhouse gas emissions and other pollutants released during the use of each type of vehicle, considering factors like electricity generation sources for electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining the supply chain and resource extraction involved in the production of electric and gasoline vehicles. This includes looking at the mining of lithium, cobalt, and other materials for electric vehicle batteries compared to the extraction and refining of oil for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by evaluating the impact on energy infrastructure and resource consumption. This approach considers how the widespread adoption of electric vehicles might affect energy grid demands and the potential for renewable energy integration, versus the continued reliance on fossil fuels for gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the operation phase of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This approach will highlight the differences in greenhouse gas emissions and other pollutants released during the use of each type of vehicle, considering factors like electricity generation sources for electric vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:16.243256", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 62 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_63.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_63.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b6ee3d3985199f1f0a529c828767d9ccf7afe9ca --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_63.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "1a6446b8-0cf5-4e4e-afd7-5f06ff57add2", + "ibfs_id": "23e8bc43-c89f-44cf-a9cb-b2bb1ef03878", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles offer reduced emissions and lower pollution, but battery production impacts are significant compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we will conduct a life cycle assessment (LCA). This assessment considers the entire lifespan of the vehicles, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to use and disposal.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction and Manufacturing\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Production**: EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction and water pollution. The energy-intensive process of battery production also results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing**: The manufacturing process for EVs is similar to that of gasoline vehicles, but the additional complexity and weight of the battery can increase the energy and material inputs required.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Fuel System Components**: Gasoline vehicles require the extraction and refinement of crude oil, which has its own environmental impacts, including oil spills, habitat destruction, and significant carbon emissions.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing**: The manufacturing of gasoline vehicles involves the production of internal combustion engines and associated components, which generally have lower initial carbon emissions than EVs due to the absence of large batteries.\n\n### 2. Use Phase\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Energy Source**: The environmental impact during the use phase of EVs largely depends on the electricity mix used for charging. EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces local air pollution. However, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels, the overall carbon emissions can be substantial.\n- **Efficiency**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid into vehicle movement.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Fuel Consumption**: Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Efficiency**: Internal combustion engines are less efficient than electric motors, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n\n### 3. End-of-Life and Disposal\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Disposal and Recycling**: The disposal of EV batteries poses environmental challenges. While recycling technologies are improving, the process is still energy-intensive and not all materials can be fully recovered. Improper disposal can lead to soil and water contamination.\n- **Vehicle Recycling**: The rest of the EV can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, with metals and other materials being recovered and reused.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Vehicle Recycling**: Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle due to the absence of large battery systems. Metals and other materials can be efficiently recovered.\n- **Environmental Impact**: The disposal of gasoline vehicles does not involve the same level of hazardous waste as EVs, but the cumulative environmental impact of emissions during the use phase is significant.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, the life cycle assessment reveals that electric vehicles have higher environmental impacts during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases, primarily due to battery production. However, they offer significant benefits during the use phase, especially in regions with clean electricity grids, due to their higher efficiency and lack of tailpipe emissions. The end-of-life phase presents challenges for both vehicle types, but EVs face additional hurdles with battery disposal and recycling. Overall, the environmental impact of EVs can be lower than that of gasoline vehicles, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing through to use and disposal, to provide a comprehensive comparison." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing through to use and disposal, to provide a comprehensive comparison.", + "I can answer by focusing on the direct emissions produced by both types of vehicles during their operational phase. This would involve comparing the emissions from the tailpipes of gasoline vehicles with the emissions associated with electricity generation for electric vehicles, considering the energy mix of the grid.", + "I can answer by examining the broader ecological implications of resource extraction for both vehicle types. For electric vehicles, this would include the mining of lithium, cobalt, and other rare earth metals for batteries, whereas for gasoline vehicles, it would involve the extraction and refining of crude oil.", + "I can answer by exploring the potential for renewable energy integration with electric vehicles. This approach would assess how electric vehicles can be powered by renewable energy sources such as wind or solar, potentially reducing their environmental impact compared to gasoline vehicles that rely on fossil fuels." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing through to use and disposal, to provide a comprehensive comparison." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:28.592286", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 63 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_64.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_64.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..01c4e9cca5835fde7294422c99d2c0d8752d822a --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_64.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "cfc7346f-1f05-4036-8888-c165409cf3ae", + "ibfs_id": "15b1016a-a06d-4235-8a29-d1df906a632b", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles generally produce lower greenhouse gas emissions, reduce air pollution, and decrease dependence on fossil fuels compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can focus on the carbon footprint associated with both types of vehicles. This involves examining the greenhouse gas emissions produced during their production and operation phases, as well as the potential reductions in emissions when using renewable energy sources for charging EVs.\n\n### Production Phase\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - The production of EVs generally results in higher greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to the manufacturing of lithium-ion batteries. The extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel are energy-intensive and contribute significantly to the carbon footprint.\n - Studies estimate that the production emissions for EVs can be 30-40% higher than those for conventional vehicles. However, this varies based on the size of the battery and the energy mix used in the manufacturing process.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - The production of gasoline vehicles involves emissions from the extraction and refining of oil, as well as the manufacturing of the vehicle itself. These emissions are relatively lower compared to EVs, mainly because they do not require large batteries.\n\n### Operation Phase\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces their operational carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles. However, the overall emissions depend on the source of electricity used for charging.\n - If the electricity comes from fossil fuels, such as coal or natural gas, the emissions can be substantial. However, as the grid becomes greener with more renewable energy sources like wind, solar, and hydroelectric power, the operational emissions of EVs decrease significantly.\n - In regions with a high share of renewable energy, the carbon footprint of operating an EV can be reduced by up to 70-80% compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe. The average gasoline vehicle emits about 4.6 metric tons of carbon dioxide per year, assuming a fuel economy of about 22 miles per gallon and an annual mileage of 11,500 miles.\n - These emissions are a direct result of burning fossil fuels and are not offset by renewable energy sources.\n\n### Potential Reductions with Renewable Energy\n\n- The carbon footprint of EVs can be further reduced by charging them with electricity generated from renewable sources. This transition is crucial for maximizing the environmental benefits of EVs.\n- In scenarios where the electricity grid is predominantly powered by renewables, the lifecycle emissions of EVs can be reduced by up to 80% compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- As more countries and regions invest in renewable energy infrastructure, the environmental advantages of EVs over gasoline vehicles are expected to increase.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nWhile the production of EVs currently results in higher emissions due to battery manufacturing, their operational phase offers significant reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, especially when charged with renewable energy. In contrast, gasoline vehicles have lower production emissions but consistently high operational emissions due to fossil fuel combustion. As the energy grid becomes cleaner, the carbon footprint of EVs will continue to decrease, making them a more environmentally friendly option in the long run.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by evaluating the carbon footprint associated with both types of vehicles. This strategy would focus on quantifying the greenhouse gas emissions produced during the production and operation of EVs and gasoline vehicles, as well as the potential reductions in emissions when using renewable energy sources for charging EVs." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative life-cycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from manufacturing through disposal. This would include an examination of raw material extraction, production processes, energy consumption during vehicle usage, and end-of-life recycling or disposal processes.", + "I can answer by evaluating the carbon footprint associated with both types of vehicles. This strategy would focus on quantifying the greenhouse gas emissions produced during the production and operation of EVs and gasoline vehicles, as well as the potential reductions in emissions when using renewable energy sources for charging EVs.", + "I can answer by examining the supply chain and resource dependency of both vehicle types. This would include an analysis of the environmental impact of mining for materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries compared to oil drilling and refining processes for gasoline vehicles. This approach would also consider geopolitical and ecological impacts associated with resource extraction.", + "I can answer by exploring the policies and incentives that influence the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles. This would involve analyzing how government regulations, subsidies for clean energy, and emissions standards impact the adoption and development of each vehicle type, and how these policies affect their overall environmental footprint." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by evaluating the carbon footprint associated with both types of vehicles. This strategy would focus on quantifying the greenhouse gas emissions produced during the production and operation of EVs and gasoline vehicles, as well as the potential reductions in emissions when using renewable energy sources for charging EVs." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:31.349454", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 64 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_65.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_65.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d845c312b4027af75964025c81f90f9d8430a80c --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_65.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "1bd18304-4581-49eb-a9c0-075c4ad1867e", + "ibfs_id": "660f31e3-6961-4a07-883f-3885e3bf1fb7", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles offer reduced emissions and lower environmental impact over lifecycle compared to gasoline vehicles, despite battery production concerns.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a life-cycle assessment (LCA) that examines each stage of the vehicles' life cycle: raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal or recycling.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of materials like lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. Mining these materials can lead to significant environmental degradation, including habitat destruction, soil and water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also require copper and aluminum, which are less environmentally intensive than battery materials but still contribute to the overall impact.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline involve significant energy use and environmental risks, such as oil spills and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Vehicle Materials:** Gasoline vehicles primarily use steel and aluminum, which have a lower environmental impact compared to the materials used in EV batteries.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is energy-intensive and results in higher emissions compared to the manufacturing of gasoline vehicles. However, advancements in battery technology and manufacturing processes are gradually reducing these impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- Manufacturing emissions are generally lower than those of EVs, mainly due to the absence of large battery systems. However, the production of internal combustion engines and associated components still contributes to environmental impacts.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, significantly reducing air pollution in urban areas. However, the environmental impact during usage largely depends on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the impact is minimal. Conversely, if it comes from coal or other fossil fuels, the benefits are reduced.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and particulate matter, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** While improvements have been made, gasoline vehicles are less efficient than EVs, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose environmental challenges. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable materials and reducing the environmental footprint.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Like gasoline vehicles, EVs can be dismantled and recycled, with metals and other materials being reused.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle due to the absence of complex battery systems. Most of the vehicle's materials, such as steel and aluminum, can be efficiently recycled.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe life-cycle assessment reveals that while EVs have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages, they offer significant benefits during the usage phase, especially when powered by renewable energy. The end-of-life impacts are being mitigated by advancements in recycling technologies. In contrast, gasoline vehicles have lower initial manufacturing impacts but contribute more significantly to environmental degradation during their usage phase due to emissions. Overall, EVs present a more sustainable option in the long term, particularly as the energy grid becomes greener and battery technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life-cycle assessment (LCA) comparison of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the environmental impacts associated with each stage of the vehicles' life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. This method provides a comprehensive overview of the total environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life-cycle assessment (LCA) comparison of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the environmental impacts associated with each stage of the vehicles' life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. This method provides a comprehensive overview of the total environmental footprint of each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational emissions of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This strategy involves comparing the emissions produced during the use phase of both types of vehicles, including tailpipe emissions from gasoline vehicles and the emissions from electricity generation for charging EVs. This approach highlights the differences in air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during vehicle operation.", + "I can answer by examining the raw materials and resource consumption involved in the production of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would analyze the environmental impact of extracting and processing materials such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries, compared to the impacts of extracting crude oil and refining it into gasoline. It would also consider the sustainability and ethical concerns related to resource extraction.", + "I can answer by evaluating the potential for renewable energy integration with electric vehicles. This strategy involves discussing how the environmental impact of EVs can be mitigated by charging them using renewable energy sources like solar or wind power. This approach contrasts the possibilities of achieving a lower carbon footprint with EVs when compared to the fixed emissions profile of gasoline vehicles, which depend on fossil fuels." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life-cycle assessment (LCA) comparison of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves analyzing the environmental impacts associated with each stage of the vehicles' life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to end-of-life disposal or recycling. This method provides a comprehensive overview of the total environmental footprint of each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:37.276756", + "similarity_score": 0.7, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 65 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_66.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_66.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2243e19f1996b96732a90d96856d271d54cea77e --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_66.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "dc0d16b2-f461-43f5-b07e-838a51cd5630", + "ibfs_id": "156bf047-62e5-46d2-b085-cd2956f97223", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and air pollution but have challenges with battery production, resource extraction, and end-of-life disposal.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines each stage of the vehicles' life spans: raw material extraction, manufacturing, use phase, and end-of-life disposal. This comprehensive analysis will help us understand the carbon footprint and resource consumption associated with each type of vehicle.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Batteries:** EVs rely heavily on lithium-ion batteries, which require the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy use.\n- **Metals and Components:** EVs also use aluminum and copper, which require energy-intensive extraction processes.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fossil Fuels:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling and refining, which can lead to oil spills, habitat destruction, and significant greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Metals and Components:** Similar to EVs, gasoline vehicles require steel, aluminum, and other metals, though typically in different proportions.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** The production of batteries is energy-intensive, contributing to a higher initial carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** EV manufacturing processes are generally similar to those of gasoline vehicles but may involve additional energy for battery integration.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine Production:** Manufacturing internal combustion engines is complex and energy-intensive, but generally less so than battery production.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to EVs, with a focus on integrating the engine and fuel systems.\n\n### 3. Use Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy Source:** The environmental impact during the use phase largely depends on the electricity mix used for charging. Renewable energy sources (solar, wind) significantly reduce emissions, whereas coal-based electricity increases them.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Combustion:** Burning gasoline releases CO2 and other pollutants, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Efficiency:** Internal combustion engines are less efficient, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of batteries are critical. While recycling can recover valuable materials, improper disposal can lead to environmental contamination.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, with a focus on recovering metals and other materials.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Established processes exist for recycling metals and other components, though the disposal of oil and other fluids poses environmental risks.\n\n### Overall Environmental Impact\n\n- **Carbon Footprint:** EVs generally have a higher initial carbon footprint due to battery production but can offset this during the use phase, especially if powered by renewable energy. Over their lifetime, EVs typically produce fewer emissions than gasoline vehicles.\n- **Resource Consumption:** Both vehicle types require significant resources, but EVs depend more on critical minerals for batteries, which can have geopolitical and environmental implications.\n- **Pollution:** EVs have the potential to reduce air pollution in urban areas due to zero tailpipe emissions, while gasoline vehicles contribute to local air quality issues.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs have some environmental challenges, particularly in raw material extraction and battery production, they offer significant advantages in reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving air quality during the use phase. The overall environmental impact of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles is generally lower, especially when powered by clean energy sources.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the entire life span of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase, to end-of-life disposal. By comparing the carbon footprint and resource consumption at each stage, I would provide a comprehensive overview of their respective environmental impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the entire life span of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase, to end-of-life disposal. By comparing the carbon footprint and resource consumption at each stage, I would provide a comprehensive overview of their respective environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the operational phase of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This method would involve comparing the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles with the emissions from electricity generation for EVs, which vary depending on the energy mix of the grid. This approach highlights the differences in air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during the usage stage of the vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining regional differences in environmental impacts. This strategy involves exploring how the environmental benefits of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles can vary depending on the local energy infrastructure, government policies, availability of recycling facilities, and public transportation options. By providing specific examples from different regions, I would illustrate how these factors influence the overall environmental impact.", + "I can answer by assessing the broader ecological and societal impacts of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This approach would consider not only the direct environmental effects, such as emissions and resource depletion but also the indirect impacts, such as the mining of materials for batteries, potential shifts in employment due to changes in the automotive industry, and the implications for energy independence and security. This holistic analysis would provide a more context-driven understanding of the broader consequences of adopting electric vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the entire life span of both types of vehicles, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use phase, to end-of-life disposal. By comparing the carbon footprint and resource consumption at each stage, I would provide a comprehensive overview of their respective environmental impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:40.182004", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 66 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_67.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_67.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..af4db43ece5dbd5f7e26f509895a46ab77131554 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_67.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "d01ebeb8-5d1b-49f4-af4d-614ab4e23d8c", + "ibfs_id": "762c6ab6-42a3-497f-af5b-feb4164f5558", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce air pollution and reliance on fossil fuels but have significant battery production and disposal impacts.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative lifecycle analysis of the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to evaluate each stage of a vehicle's lifecycle: production, usage, and end-of-life management. This analysis will consider factors such as carbon footprint, resource extraction, manufacturing processes, and disposal.\n\n### 1. Production Phase\n\n#### Resource Extraction and Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other materials. Mining these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing:** The production of EVs generally requires more energy than gasoline vehicles, primarily due to the energy-intensive battery manufacturing process. However, advancements in technology and recycling are helping to mitigate these impacts.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Fuel System Production:** Gasoline vehicles require the extraction and processing of crude oil for fuel, which involves significant environmental risks, including oil spills and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Vehicle Manufacturing:** The production of gasoline vehicles is less energy-intensive compared to EVs, as they do not require large batteries. However, the manufacturing process still involves significant emissions and resource use.\n\n### 2. Usage Phase\n\n#### Carbon Footprint and Emissions\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Operation Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces local air pollution. However, the overall carbon footprint depends on the electricity source used for charging. Renewable energy sources result in a much lower carbon footprint compared to coal or natural gas.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Operation Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and other pollutants during operation, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** While improvements in fuel efficiency have been made, gasoline vehicles still convert less energy from fuel to power at the wheels compared to EVs.\n\n### 3. End-of-Life Management\n\n#### Disposal and Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Disposal:** The disposal and recycling of lithium-ion batteries are critical environmental concerns. Improper disposal can lead to soil and water contamination. However, recycling technologies are improving, allowing for the recovery of valuable materials.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** EVs can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, with metals and other materials being reused.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Vehicle Disposal:** Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle, as they do not contain large batteries. Metals and other components can be recovered and reused.\n- **Environmental Impact:** The disposal of gasoline vehicles still involves environmental impacts, particularly from fluids and other hazardous materials.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles offer significant environmental benefits during the usage phase due to their lack of tailpipe emissions and higher energy efficiency. However, the production phase of EVs, particularly battery manufacturing, has a higher environmental impact compared to gasoline vehicles. The end-of-life phase presents challenges for both vehicle types, with battery recycling being a key area for improvement in EVs. Overall, the environmental impact of EVs can be significantly reduced by using renewable energy sources for electricity and improving battery recycling technologies.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impact of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include assessing the carbon footprint, resource extraction, manufacturing processes, usage, and end-of-life management, providing a comprehensive overview of the entire lifecycle for each vehicle type." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impact of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include assessing the carbon footprint, resource extraction, manufacturing processes, usage, and end-of-life management, providing a comprehensive overview of the entire lifecycle for each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by analyzing the differences in emissions during the use phase of electric versus gasoline vehicles. This approach would focus on comparing the tailpipe emissions of traditional vehicles with the emissions generated from electricity production for electric vehicles, considering different energy sources like coal, natural gas, and renewables used in electricity generation.", + "I can answer by exploring the resource extraction and material use involved in both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would involve a detailed examination of the mining and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for electric vehicle batteries versus the extraction and refining of petroleum for gasoline vehicles, highlighting the environmental impacts associated with each process.", + "I can answer by reviewing and summarizing existing research studies and expert opinions on the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would involve gathering data from peer-reviewed articles, governmental reports, and industry analyses to provide a well-rounded perspective based on expert consensus and empirical evidence." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impact of both electric and gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This would include assessing the carbon footprint, resource extraction, manufacturing processes, usage, and end-of-life management, providing a comprehensive overview of the entire lifecycle for each vehicle type." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:41.960854", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 67 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_68.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_68.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4bd56c8a8f2d3e5651372cc962f0ff6c909d774d --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_68.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "12fe16e1-6cee-4953-b706-24eb2f99867c", + "ibfs_id": "f7d59b8a-739e-47e7-87ff-a9a918a66604", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles have a smaller carbon footprint, reduce air pollution, but battery production and disposal carry significant environmental concerns.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a life cycle assessment (LCA) that examines each stage of a vehicle's life: raw material extraction, manufacturing, usage, and disposal or recycling. This approach allows us to evaluate and compare the environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and energy consumption.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs require lithium-ion batteries, which involve the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. This process can be energy-intensive and environmentally damaging, particularly in terms of water usage and habitat disruption.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also use aluminum and copper, which have significant environmental footprints due to mining and refining processes.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fossil Fuels:** The extraction and refinement of crude oil for gasoline involve significant energy use and environmental risks, such as oil spills and habitat destruction.\n- **Metals and Materials:** Gasoline vehicles use steel, aluminum, and other materials, but typically in smaller quantities compared to the materials needed for EV batteries.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Energy-Intensive Production:** The production of EVs, particularly the battery, is more energy-intensive than that of gasoline vehicles. This results in higher initial greenhouse gas emissions during the manufacturing phase.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Less Energy-Intensive:** Manufacturing gasoline vehicles generally requires less energy compared to EVs, resulting in lower initial emissions.\n\n### 3. Usage\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs do not emit greenhouse gases during operation. However, the environmental impact depends on the electricity source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources, the emissions are minimal. If it's from fossil fuels, the emissions are higher.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and other pollutants during operation, contributing significantly to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Gasoline vehicles are less efficient, with a significant portion of energy lost as heat.\n\n### 4. Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal and recycling of lithium-ion batteries pose environmental challenges. However, recycling technologies are improving, which can mitigate some impacts.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Other components of EVs can be recycled similarly to those of gasoline vehicles.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **End-of-Life Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically easier to recycle, with established processes for metals and other materials. However, they do not have the added complexity of battery disposal.\n\n### Overall Comparison\n\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** Over their entire life cycle, EVs generally produce fewer greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline vehicles, especially if powered by renewable energy.\n- **Resource Depletion:** EVs have higher resource depletion impacts due to battery materials but can be mitigated through recycling and sustainable mining practices.\n- **Energy Consumption:** While EVs have higher energy consumption during manufacturing, their operational efficiency often offsets this over the vehicle's lifetime.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages, they offer significant benefits during the usage phase, particularly in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution. The overall environmental impact of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles depends heavily on the electricity source and advancements in battery recycling technologies.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at every stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal or recycling. Through this comprehensive analysis, I can compare factors like greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and energy consumption for both vehicle types." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at every stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal or recycling. Through this comprehensive analysis, I can compare factors like greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and energy consumption for both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by reviewing recent academic research and scientific studies that analyze the environmental benefits and drawbacks of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve summarizing findings from peer-reviewed journals and reports that focus on emissions, air quality, and overall ecological footprint, providing a detailed comparison based on up-to-date research.", + "I can answer by analyzing case studies of specific regions or countries that have adopted electric vehicles on a large scale. This would involve examining real-world data on how the shift to electric vehicles has affected environmental indicators such as air pollution levels, carbon emissions, and energy resource consumption, comparing these with areas reliant on traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring the technological and infrastructural aspects that influence the environmental impact of both vehicle types. This would include looking into the sources of electricity for EVs (renewable vs. non-renewable), the efficiency of battery recycling processes, and the impact of oil extraction and refinement for gasoline vehicles, providing a nuanced comparison based on these critical factors." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) of both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts at every stage of a vehicle's life, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal or recycling. Through this comprehensive analysis, I can compare factors like greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and energy consumption for both vehicle types." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:49.710069", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 68 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_69.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_69.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..83811d2f234d9e8b978e5f200baa1c907596860c --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_69.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "7e878f6e-258a-43ce-901a-4e78372a5b06", + "ibfs_id": "163d9949-98ac-4e4e-bc38-37cbf9ddc85c", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and energy consumption, but battery production and disposal present significant environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a lifecycle analysis that examines the entire lifecycle of both types of vehicles. This analysis includes the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Batteries:** EVs require large batteries, typically lithium-ion, which necessitate the extraction of lithium, cobalt, nickel, and other metals. Mining these materials can have significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction, soil and water pollution, and high energy consumption.\n- **Electric Motors:** Require rare earth elements like neodymium, which also have environmental and social impacts associated with their extraction.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling, which can lead to oil spills, habitat disruption, and greenhouse gas emissions.\n- **Vehicle Components:** Require steel, aluminum, and other materials, which also have environmental impacts from mining and refining processes.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Processes\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** Manufacturing batteries is energy-intensive and contributes significantly to the carbon footprint of EVs. However, advancements in technology and recycling can mitigate some impacts.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Generally similar to gasoline vehicles but may involve additional processes for integrating electric drivetrains.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine Production:** Manufacturing internal combustion engines involves complex processes that are energy-intensive and produce emissions.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to EVs, with established processes that have been optimized over decades.\n\n### 3. Vehicle Operation\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces urban air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during operation.\n- **Energy Source:** The environmental impact depends on the electricity source. Renewable energy sources (solar, wind, hydro) greatly reduce the carbon footprint, while coal or natural gas increase it.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Emissions:** Emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter, and other pollutants, contributing to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Varies by model, but generally less efficient than EVs in terms of energy conversion.\n\n### 4. End-of-Life Disposal or Recycling\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** Batteries can be recycled, but the process is complex and not yet fully efficient. Improper disposal can lead to environmental hazards.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, with metals and other materials being recycled.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Recycling:** Established processes exist for recycling metals and other components. However, the disposal of oil and other fluids poses environmental risks.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles generally have a higher environmental impact during the raw material extraction and manufacturing phases, primarily due to battery production. However, they offer significant environmental benefits during the operation phase, especially when powered by renewable energy sources, due to their zero tailpipe emissions and higher energy efficiency. Gasoline vehicles, while having a lower initial environmental impact in terms of raw material extraction and manufacturing, contribute more to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during their operational phase. End-of-life impacts for both vehicle types depend on the effectiveness of recycling processes and the management of hazardous materials. Overall, the lifecycle analysis suggests that EVs have the potential to be more environmentally friendly than gasoline vehicles, particularly as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, examining the entire lifecycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. This approach provides a comprehensive view of the environmental impacts associated with each type of vehicle." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, examining the entire lifecycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. This approach provides a comprehensive view of the environmental impacts associated with each type of vehicle.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of the vehicles, comparing the emissions produced during their use. This strategy would evaluate the greenhouse gas emissions and other pollutants emitted by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion against the emissions generated from electricity production for charging electric vehicles, considering different energy sources like coal, natural gas, and renewables.", + "I can answer by examining the resource and energy consumption involved in the production of electric vehicles, particularly focusing on the extraction and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel used in batteries. This approach would compare these impacts to the oil extraction and refining processes required for gasoline vehicles, highlighting the environmental costs of resource extraction for both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by analyzing the broader environmental and societal implications, such as the potential for reducing urban air pollution and noise with electric vehicles, versus the economic and environmental impacts of maintaining existing gasoline infrastructure. This would include considering the benefits of improved air quality and reduced noise pollution in urban areas and the challenges related to transitioning infrastructure and workforce from gasoline to electric vehicle support." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis, examining the entire lifecycle of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This would include the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, vehicle operation, and end-of-life disposal or recycling. This approach provides a comprehensive view of the environmental impacts associated with each type of vehicle." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:10:48.067835", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 69 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_7.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_7.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..35871c69fb23d77d8a09d4986e42299b0867be54 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_7.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "394e92d2-d34e-4cb1-861d-08bed5b5fb48", + "ibfs_id": "a0427723-887b-49c3-b7de-c44a23e8b29c", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce lower emissions, use sustainable energy, decrease air pollution but involve battery-related environmental challenges in mining and recycling.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine the emissions and energy sources associated with each during their operational phase.\n\n### Emissions from Gasoline Vehicles\n\nGasoline vehicles rely on internal combustion engines that burn fossil fuels, primarily gasoline, to operate. This combustion process directly emits several pollutants and greenhouse gases (GHGs) into the atmosphere, including:\n\n1. **Carbon Dioxide (CO2):** A significant greenhouse gas contributing to climate change. Gasoline vehicles emit CO2 as a byproduct of burning fossil fuels.\n2. **Nitrogen Oxides (NOx):** These contribute to smog and respiratory problems.\n3. **Particulate Matter (PM):** Tiny particles that can penetrate deep into the lungs and cause health issues.\n4. **Carbon Monoxide (CO):** A toxic gas that can be harmful in high concentrations.\n5. **Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs):** Contribute to the formation of ground-level ozone and smog.\n\nThe emissions from gasoline vehicles are directly released into the environment during operation, contributing significantly to air pollution and climate change.\n\n### Emissions from Electric Vehicles\n\nElectric vehicles, on the other hand, do not have tailpipe emissions. However, their environmental impact depends largely on the source of the electricity used to charge them:\n\n1. **Renewable Energy Sources (e.g., wind, solar, hydroelectric):** If the electricity used to charge EVs comes from renewable sources, the emissions associated with their operation are minimal. This scenario significantly reduces the carbon footprint of EVs compared to gasoline vehicles.\n \n2. **Fossil Fuel-Based Electricity (e.g., coal, natural gas):** If the electricity is generated from fossil fuels, EVs indirectly contribute to emissions. The extent of these emissions depends on the energy mix of the grid. For example, coal-fired power plants emit high levels of CO2, NOx, and other pollutants, whereas natural gas plants have a lower emissions profile.\n\n### Comparative Analysis\n\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** On average, EVs tend to have lower GHG emissions than gasoline vehicles, especially in regions where the electricity grid is cleaner or transitioning towards renewable energy. Even in areas with a significant portion of electricity from fossil fuels, EVs often still result in lower overall emissions due to the higher efficiency of electric motors compared to internal combustion engines.\n\n- **Air Pollutants:** EVs contribute to reduced air pollution in urban areas since they do not emit NOx, PM, or VOCs during operation. This can lead to improved air quality and public health benefits.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe environmental impact of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles is largely contingent upon the energy sources used for electricity generation. While EVs have the potential to significantly reduce emissions and improve air quality, maximizing these benefits requires a shift towards cleaner, renewable energy sources for electricity production. In contrast, gasoline vehicles consistently emit pollutants and GHGs directly during their operation, contributing to environmental degradation and climate change.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy source differences between electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would involve comparing the greenhouse gas emissions and air pollutants produced by each type of vehicle during operation. For electric vehicles, I would consider the source of the electricity, whether it's from renewable sources or fossil fuels, to evaluate their true emissions impact. For gasoline vehicles, I would analyze the direct emissions from combustion engines. This approach highlights the operational phase and energy sourcing as key factors in the environmental impact comparison." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle analysis for both electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach involves evaluating the environmental impacts of each type of vehicle from production to disposal. I would assess factors such as the extraction and processing of raw materials, manufacturing processes, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life recycling or disposal. This comprehensive analysis would provide a detailed comparison of the overall environmental footprint of electric versus gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy source differences between electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would involve comparing the greenhouse gas emissions and air pollutants produced by each type of vehicle during operation. For electric vehicles, I would consider the source of the electricity, whether it's from renewable sources or fossil fuels, to evaluate their true emissions impact. For gasoline vehicles, I would analyze the direct emissions from combustion engines. This approach highlights the operational phase and energy sourcing as key factors in the environmental impact comparison." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy source differences between electric and gasoline vehicles. This strategy would involve comparing the greenhouse gas emissions and air pollutants produced by each type of vehicle during operation. For electric vehicles, I would consider the source of the electricity, whether it's from renewable sources or fossil fuels, to evaluate their true emissions impact. For gasoline vehicles, I would analyze the direct emissions from combustion engines. This approach highlights the operational phase and energy sourcing as key factors in the environmental impact comparison." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:04.102044", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 7 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_70.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_70.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..66dc9f5664fc695432098899c2104949780f9003 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_70.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "b154e69a-205d-4619-aef8-3b32842c6544", + "ibfs_id": "b36dc164-729a-4369-b736-ee241067f93a", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles are more environmentally friendly, reducing emissions and pollution compared to gasoline vehicles, but mining impacts remain substantial.", + "final_answer": "A cradle-to-grave analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles involves examining the environmental impacts from the extraction of raw materials to the end of the vehicle's life. This analysis highlights significant differences in the material extraction processes for each type of vehicle, particularly focusing on the extraction of lithium and cobalt for EV batteries versus oil extraction for gasoline.\n\n**Material Extraction for Electric Vehicles:**\n\n1. **Lithium Mining:**\n - **Environmental Impact:** Lithium is primarily extracted from brine pools in regions like the Atacama Desert in Chile, or from hard rock mining in Australia. The extraction process involves pumping groundwater to the surface, where it evaporates, leaving lithium behind. This process can lead to significant water depletion in arid regions, affecting local ecosystems and communities.\n - **Ecological Footprint:** The evaporation process can take up to 500,000 gallons of water per ton of lithium extracted. This can disrupt local water supplies and harm biodiversity in these sensitive environments.\n\n2. **Cobalt Mining:**\n - **Environmental Impact:** Cobalt is often mined as a byproduct of nickel and copper mining, with significant production in the Democratic Republic of Congo. The mining process can lead to deforestation, soil erosion, and contamination of water sources with heavy metals.\n - **Ecological Footprint:** Cobalt mining is associated with both environmental and social issues, including habitat destruction and human rights concerns due to artisanal mining practices.\n\n**Material Extraction for Gasoline Vehicles:**\n\n1. **Oil Extraction:**\n - **Environmental Impact:** Oil extraction involves drilling into the earth to access crude oil reserves. This process can lead to oil spills, which have devastating effects on marine and terrestrial ecosystems. Additionally, the infrastructure required for extraction, such as drilling rigs and pipelines, can disrupt habitats.\n - **Ecological Footprint:** Oil extraction and refining are energy-intensive processes that contribute significantly to greenhouse gas emissions. The risk of spills and leaks poses a constant threat to the environment, with long-lasting impacts on wildlife and water quality.\n\n**Comparative Analysis:**\n\n- **Resource Intensity:** Both EVs and gasoline vehicles require significant resource extraction, but the types of resources and their associated impacts differ. EVs rely heavily on lithium and cobalt, which have localized environmental impacts, particularly concerning water use and pollution. Gasoline vehicles depend on oil, which has broader implications due to greenhouse gas emissions and the potential for catastrophic spills.\n\n- **Global Warming Potential:** Over their lifetime, EVs generally have a lower global warming potential compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to the reduced emissions during the use phase. However, the initial environmental cost of battery production can be higher due to the energy-intensive mining and processing of lithium and cobalt.\n\n- **End-of-Life Considerations:** EV batteries pose challenges for recycling and disposal, though advancements in battery recycling technologies aim to mitigate these impacts. In contrast, gasoline vehicles have a more established recycling process for their components.\n\nIn conclusion, while both electric and gasoline vehicles have environmental impacts associated with their material extraction processes, the nature and scale of these impacts differ. Electric vehicles present challenges related to water use and mining pollution, while gasoline vehicles contribute significantly to greenhouse gas emissions and pose risks of oil spills. Understanding these differences is crucial for developing strategies to minimize the ecological footprint of both vehicle types.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining all stages of each vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling\u2014and comparing their total environmental impacts in terms of greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution.", + "I can answer by focusing on a comparative cradle-to-grave analysis for both electric and gasoline vehicles, emphasizing the differences in material extraction processes. This sub-strategy would delve deeper into the specific environmental impacts associated with mining for lithium and cobalt for EV batteries versus oil extraction for gasoline, providing insights into their respective ecological footprints." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining all stages of each vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling\u2014and comparing their total environmental impacts in terms of greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution.", + "I can answer by analyzing the energy sources used for electricity generation in different regions, as the environmental impact of electric vehicles largely depends on whether the electricity comes from renewable sources (like wind and solar) or non-renewable sources (like coal and natural gas). In contrast, gasoline vehicles' impact is more consistent as it primarily depends on fossil fuel combustion. This approach would provide insights into regional differences in EV impacts.", + "I can answer by examining and comparing the raw materials used in the production of electric and gasoline vehicles, focusing specifically on the extraction and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel for EV batteries versus the materials needed for internal combustion engines. This approach would highlight the environmental and social implications of mining and resource depletion.", + "I can answer by considering the long-term environmental benefits and drawbacks, including the potential for electric vehicles to contribute to urban air quality improvement and noise reduction, while also assessing the challenges related to battery recycling and disposal. This approach would provide a broader perspective on how these vehicles could shape future environmental conditions." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining all stages of each vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and use, to disposal or recycling\u2014and comparing their total environmental impacts in terms of greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and pollution." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a comparative cradle-to-grave analysis for both electric and gasoline vehicles, emphasizing the differences in material extraction processes. This sub-strategy would delve deeper into the specific environmental impacts associated with mining for lithium and cobalt for EV batteries versus oil extraction for gasoline, providing insights into their respective ecological footprints.", + "I can answer by performing a detailed usage phase comparison within the life cycle assessment, concentrating on energy consumption and emissions during the operational life of the vehicles. This approach would highlight how the source of electricity (renewable vs. non-renewable) for EVs and the efficiency of gasoline engines affect overall greenhouse gas emissions and air quality.", + "I can answer by emphasizing the end-of-life phase in the life cycle assessment, exploring the recycling and disposal processes of EV batteries versus gasoline vehicles. This sub-strategy would assess the environmental benefits and challenges of recycling battery materials and the potential pollution from landfilling or incinerating vehicle components.", + "I can answer by broadening the life cycle assessment to include the infrastructure needed for both vehicle types, such as the environmental impact of building and maintaining charging stations for EVs versus refineries and gas stations for gasoline vehicles. This approach would consider the long-term environmental implications of supporting infrastructure and its role in the overall environmental impact of each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on a comparative cradle-to-grave analysis for both electric and gasoline vehicles, emphasizing the differences in material extraction processes. This sub-strategy would delve deeper into the specific environmental impacts associated with mining for lithium and cobalt for EV batteries versus oil extraction for gasoline, providing insights into their respective ecological footprints." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:08.767145", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 70 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_71.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_71.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..05a7ad724838e2accc19ac1e3db1bdebc94d2b3a --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_71.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "b4c778c7-9960-4d02-8584-d720dad666eb", + "ibfs_id": "4775b8f4-c425-4ba8-a40a-6a9e7d50c3eb", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions significantly, minimize air pollution, and lower carbon footprint compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, we can focus on tailpipe emissions, particularly carbon dioxide (CO\u2082) and other pollutants.\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Electric vehicles do not produce tailpipe emissions during their operation. This means they do not emit carbon dioxide (CO\u2082), nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter (PM), or other harmful pollutants directly from the vehicle itself. This is a significant environmental advantage, especially in urban areas where air quality is a concern.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n\n- **Tailpipe Emissions:** Traditional gasoline vehicles emit a variety of pollutants during their operation. The primary emissions include:\n - **Carbon Dioxide (CO\u2082):** Gasoline vehicles emit CO\u2082 as a byproduct of burning fossil fuels. The amount of CO\u2082 emitted depends on the fuel efficiency of the vehicle and the carbon content of the gasoline.\n - **Nitrogen Oxides (NOx):** These are significant contributors to smog and respiratory problems. Gasoline engines produce NOx during combustion.\n - **Particulate Matter (PM):** Gasoline vehicles can emit particulate matter, which contributes to air pollution and can have adverse health effects.\n - **Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs):** These contribute to the formation of ground-level ozone and smog.\n\nIn summary, during their operational phase, electric vehicles have a clear advantage over gasoline vehicles in terms of tailpipe emissions. EVs produce no direct emissions, which helps reduce local air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions associated with vehicle operation. In contrast, gasoline vehicles emit several pollutants, including CO\u2082, which contribute to climate change and air quality issues.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of the vehicles, specifically looking at the emissions produced during their use. This would involve comparing the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles, such as CO", + "I can answer by examining the tailpipe emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, focusing on pollutants like carbon dioxide (CO" + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and traditional gasoline vehicles. This method involves evaluating the total environmental impact of each vehicle type from production through operation to disposal. By examining factors such as resource extraction, manufacturing emissions, energy consumption during use, and end-of-life processing, I can provide a comprehensive comparison of their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of the vehicles, specifically looking at the emissions produced during their use. This would involve comparing the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles, such as CO", + "I can answer by examining the broader ecological and societal impacts of adopting electric vehicles over traditional gasoline vehicles. This would include factors such as the reduction in urban air pollution and its health benefits, the potential changes in infrastructure requirements (like charging stations vs. fuel stations), and the impact on oil dependency and energy security. By taking a holistic view, I can evaluate how a shift to electric vehicles might influence environmental sustainability on a broader scale.", + "I can answer by analyzing recent research studies and reports from credible environmental organizations and academic institutions. By summarizing findings from multiple sources, including data on emissions, resource use, and environmental policies, I can present an evidence-based overview that reflects the current scientific consensus on the comparative environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach ensures that the answer is grounded in up-to-date and reliable information." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of the vehicles, specifically looking at the emissions produced during their use. This would involve comparing the direct emissions from gasoline vehicles, such as CO" + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by examining the tailpipe emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, focusing on pollutants like carbon dioxide (CO", + "I can answer by analyzing the emissions produced indirectly from the energy sources used to power electric and gasoline vehicles. For electric vehicles, this means looking at the emissions from electricity generation based on the energy mix of the grid, while for gasoline vehicles, it involves calculating the emissions from refining and transporting gasoline.", + "I can answer by considering the lifecycle emissions during the operational phase, which includes not only direct emissions but also the emissions associated with vehicle maintenance and parts replacement. This would involve assessing the environmental impact of maintaining electric vehicle batteries versus internal combustion engine components over the vehicle's lifespan.", + "I can answer by investigating regional variations in emissions during the operational phase, comparing areas with different electricity generation profiles and fuel standards. This would involve analyzing how the environmental impact of electric vehicles changes in regions with renewable-heavy grids versus those reliant on fossil fuels, compared to gasoline vehicles operating under varying fuel quality regulations." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by examining the tailpipe emissions of both electric and gasoline vehicles during their operational phase, focusing on pollutants like carbon dioxide (CO" + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:02.837377", + "similarity_score": 0.8, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 71 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_72.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_72.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..21fbfa478f5609ffe9301335cc8fb8fe6c889cd1 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_72.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "3cf69da0-f1f8-49eb-9151-71ad9eff95b0", + "ibfs_id": "ed1296a7-8ab8-4a30-8738-5022449b3285", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and air pollution but involve mining impacts; still generally less harmful than gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To evaluate the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can focus on the lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions, which encompass the carbon footprint from raw material extraction, production, operation, and disposal.\n\n1. **Raw Material Extraction:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The production of EVs involves significant emissions during the extraction and processing of raw materials, particularly for lithium-ion batteries. Mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel is energy-intensive and contributes to higher initial emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** The extraction of raw materials for gasoline vehicles primarily involves steel, aluminum, and other metals, which also have associated emissions. However, these are generally lower than those for EV battery materials.\n\n2. **Production:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** Manufacturing EVs, especially the battery, results in higher emissions compared to gasoline vehicles. The energy required to produce batteries is substantial, contributing to a larger carbon footprint at this stage.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** The production emissions for gasoline vehicles are lower than for EVs, as they do not require the complex battery systems that EVs do.\n\n3. **Operation (Fuel/Electricity Consumption):**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** During operation, EVs typically have lower emissions than gasoline vehicles, as they do not burn fossil fuels directly. The carbon footprint depends on the electricity source; renewable energy sources (like wind or solar) significantly reduce emissions, whereas coal-based electricity increases them.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases directly from the tailpipe during operation. The emissions are consistent and directly tied to fuel consumption, with no variation based on energy source.\n\n4. **Disposal:**\n - **Electric Vehicles:** The disposal and recycling of EV batteries pose environmental challenges. However, advancements in recycling technologies are reducing the emissions associated with this stage. Proper recycling can mitigate some of the initial emissions from battery production.\n - **Gasoline Vehicles:** Disposal emissions are generally lower than for EVs, as traditional vehicles do not have large battery systems. However, the recycling of metals and other components still contributes to emissions.\n\n**Overall Lifecycle Emissions:**\n- **Electric Vehicles:** Despite higher emissions during production, EVs typically have a lower overall carbon footprint over their lifespan, especially when powered by clean electricity. As the grid becomes greener, the operational emissions of EVs continue to decrease.\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:** These vehicles have higher operational emissions, which accumulate over time, leading to a larger carbon footprint compared to EVs, especially as the vehicle ages.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs start with a higher carbon footprint due to battery production, their lower operational emissions often result in a smaller overall carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles, particularly when charged with renewable energy. The lifecycle emissions advantage of EVs becomes more pronounced as the electricity grid becomes less reliant on fossil fuels.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's lifecycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal and recycling. I would compare factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and waste generation at each stage.", + "I can answer by evaluating the lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions specifically, focusing on the carbon footprint aspect of EVs and gasoline vehicles across their lifespan. This approach would involve comparing emissions from raw material extraction, production, operation (fuel/electricity consumption), and disposal, providing a focused perspective on the climate impact." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's lifecycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal and recycling. I would compare factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and waste generation at each stage.", + "I can answer by focusing on the energy source used for electric vehicles. This approach would analyze the environmental impacts based on the electricity generation mix in different regions (e.g., coal, natural gas, renewable sources). I would compare this with the emissions from gasoline vehicles to assess how the source of electricity influences the overall environmental impact of EVs.", + "I can answer by investigating the impact of electric and gasoline vehicles on specific environmental factors, such as air quality and noise pollution. This would involve looking at data and studies that measure emissions of pollutants like nitrogen oxides and particulates, as well as the noise levels produced by each vehicle type, and their effects on urban environments.", + "I can answer by considering the broader economic and social implications that influence environmental outcomes. This strategy would evaluate how the adoption of electric vehicles affects infrastructure development, changes in energy policies, and shifts in consumer behavior, and how these factors contribute to overall environmental impacts compared to traditional gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis of electric vehicles (EVs) and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's lifecycle, from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal and recycling. I would compare factors such as greenhouse gas emissions, resource consumption, and waste generation at each stage." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the manufacturing stage of EVs and gasoline vehicles. This involves analyzing the environmental impacts associated with the production processes, energy consumption during manufacturing, and emissions generated from factories. By isolating this stage, I can identify key differences in environmental footprints related to vehicle assembly and production.", + "I can answer by conducting a regional lifecycle analysis, which examines how the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles vary based on location. This would consider factors such as the electricity grid's energy mix, local resource availability, and regional recycling capabilities, providing insights into how geography influences the overall environmental impact.", + "I can answer by performing a comparative analysis of the recycling and disposal phases of EVs and gasoline vehicles. This entails evaluating the end-of-life processes, including recycling efficiency of batteries, disposal of hazardous materials, and waste management practices, to determine which vehicle type has a more sustainable end-of-life impact.", + "I can answer by evaluating the lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions specifically, focusing on the carbon footprint aspect of EVs and gasoline vehicles across their lifespan. This approach would involve comparing emissions from raw material extraction, production, operation (fuel/electricity consumption), and disposal, providing a focused perspective on the climate impact." + ], + "choice_idx": 3, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by evaluating the lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions specifically, focusing on the carbon footprint aspect of EVs and gasoline vehicles across their lifespan. This approach would involve comparing emissions from raw material extraction, production, operation (fuel/electricity consumption), and disposal, providing a focused perspective on the climate impact." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:10.953507", + "similarity_score": 0.7, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 72 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_73.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_73.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e1fa088cc1447f3ac4c4e4bd912708f6edd24c05 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_73.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "6361c264-28b6-4f3e-a2f5-d6b1d68618a1", + "ibfs_id": "9fe712f7-6213-431b-a77b-688025c1a97f", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions overall, but battery production impacts resources; they're still environmentally preferable to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative lifecycle analysis focused on the carbon footprint of electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to evaluate the greenhouse gas emissions associated with each phase of the vehicles' lifecycle: manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life.\n\n### 1. Manufacturing Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Production:** The production of lithium-ion batteries, which are essential for EVs, is energy-intensive and contributes significantly to the carbon footprint. The extraction and processing of raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel are major contributors to emissions.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to traditional vehicles, the assembly of EVs involves emissions from the production of steel, aluminum, and other materials. However, the battery production adds a substantial additional carbon footprint.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Transmission Production:** The manufacturing of internal combustion engines and transmissions is less carbon-intensive than battery production but still contributes significantly to emissions.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to EVs, emissions result from the production of materials like steel and aluminum.\n\n**Comparison:** Overall, the manufacturing phase of EVs generally results in higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to battery production.\n\n### 2. Operation Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Electricity Use:** The carbon footprint during the operation of EVs depends on the electricity mix used to charge them. If the electricity comes from renewable sources, the emissions are minimal. However, if the grid relies heavily on coal or natural gas, emissions can be higher.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Combustion:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases directly through the combustion of fossil fuels. The emissions are consistent and significant over the vehicle's lifespan.\n\n**Comparison:** In the operation phase, EVs typically have a lower carbon footprint than gasoline vehicles, especially in regions with cleaner electricity grids. The efficiency of electric motors and the potential for renewable energy charging contribute to this advantage.\n\n### 3. End-of-Life Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The recycling of EV batteries can mitigate some of the emissions from the manufacturing phase. However, the recycling process itself can be energy-intensive and may contribute to emissions if not managed sustainably.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** Similar to gasoline vehicles, the recycling of materials like steel and aluminum can reduce the overall carbon footprint.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** The recycling of materials is comparable to that of EVs, with emissions associated with the recycling process.\n\n**Comparison:** The end-of-life phase for both types of vehicles involves emissions from recycling processes. However, the potential for battery recycling in EVs can help offset some of the initial manufacturing emissions.\n\n### Overall Lifecycle Analysis\n\nWhen considering the entire lifecycle, EVs generally have a lower carbon footprint than gasoline vehicles, despite the higher emissions during manufacturing. The key factors are the reduced emissions during the operation phase and the potential for using renewable energy for charging. Over time, as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery production and recycling processes improve, the carbon footprint of EVs is expected to decrease further, enhancing their environmental benefits compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would detail emissions and resource use at each stage: manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life management, providing a holistic view of each vehicle type's environmental footprint.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis focused specifically on the carbon footprint of electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve calculating and comparing the total greenhouse gas emissions generated during the manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life phases for each vehicle type, thus providing a clear picture of their respective contributions to climate change." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would detail emissions and resource use at each stage: manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life management, providing a holistic view of each vehicle type's environmental footprint.", + "I can answer by focusing on the operational phase of both vehicle types, specifically analyzing the emissions associated with the operation of EVs versus gasoline vehicles. This approach would evaluate emissions reductions from EVs when powered by different energy sources, such as coal-based electricity versus renewable energy, and compare them to the emissions from burning gasoline.", + "I can answer by examining the resource extraction and material sourcing needed for both types of vehicles. This strategy would involve assessing the environmental impacts of mining for lithium, cobalt, and other materials used in EV batteries compared to the extraction and refining of oil for gasoline, highlighting differences in land use, water consumption, and habitat disruption.", + "I can answer by investigating the regional variations in environmental impacts due to differences in energy grids and infrastructure. This approach would consider how the environmental benefits of EVs might vary in regions with cleaner electricity grids compared to those reliant on fossil fuels, and how local policies and infrastructure can influence these impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis that examines the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles from production to disposal. This approach would detail emissions and resource use at each stage: manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life management, providing a holistic view of each vehicle type's environmental footprint." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis focused specifically on the carbon footprint of electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve calculating and comparing the total greenhouse gas emissions generated during the manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life phases for each vehicle type, thus providing a clear picture of their respective contributions to climate change.", + "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis that emphasizes the resource consumption differences between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would detail the extraction and use of raw materials, such as lithium for batteries in EVs and crude oil for gasoline vehicles, to understand how each type impacts natural resource depletion and ecosystem disruption.", + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis that hones in on the water usage involved in the production and operation of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining water use in the manufacturing of components, such as batteries, and the refining processes for gasoline, providing insights into each vehicle type's impact on water resources.", + "I can answer by performing a lifecycle analysis with a focus on the air quality impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would assess the pollutants released at each stage of the vehicle lifecycle, particularly during operation, and evaluate how each vehicle type contributes to air pollution and related health effects, offering a comprehensive view of their environmental implications." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative lifecycle analysis focused specifically on the carbon footprint of electric vehicles (EVs) versus traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve calculating and comparing the total greenhouse gas emissions generated during the manufacturing, operation, and end-of-life phases for each vehicle type, thus providing a clear picture of their respective contributions to climate change." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:12.598843", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 73 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_74.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_74.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..03918c2e62e5cbe95149916d6a18de029721d600 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_74.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "764b651f-9b5c-4979-ae87-c2c6b58feace", + "ibfs_id": "6881a9e0-80bf-4cc0-a85c-e23a35c85696", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce lower emissions and less pollution but require resource-intensive battery production, impacting the environment differently than gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a lifecycle analysis that examines emissions from the production, operation, and disposal phases of both types of vehicles.\n\n### 1. Production Phase\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Manufacturing**: The production of EVs, particularly the lithium-ion batteries, is energy-intensive. Mining for raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel involves significant environmental impacts, including habitat destruction and pollution. The manufacturing process itself requires substantial energy, often from non-renewable sources, leading to higher initial carbon emissions compared to gasoline vehicles.\n- **Vehicle Assembly**: Apart from the battery, the rest of the EV's manufacturing process is similar to that of gasoline vehicles, involving emissions from steel, aluminum, and plastic production.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Oil Refining and Vehicle Manufacturing**: The production of gasoline vehicles involves emissions from extracting and refining oil into gasoline. The vehicle assembly process is similar to that of EVs, with emissions from steel, aluminum, and plastic production. However, gasoline vehicles do not require the energy-intensive battery manufacturing process.\n\n### 2. Operation Phase\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Electricity Generation**: The operation of EVs involves electricity consumption, which can vary in environmental impact depending on the energy source. If the electricity is generated from renewable sources (e.g., wind, solar), the emissions are minimal. However, if the electricity comes from coal or natural gas, the emissions are higher.\n- **Efficiency**: EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **Fuel Combustion**: Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe during operation. These emissions contribute to air pollution and climate change.\n- **Fuel Efficiency**: Gasoline vehicles are less efficient than EVs, as a significant portion of the energy in gasoline is lost as heat.\n\n### 3. Disposal Phase\n\n#### Electric Vehicles:\n- **Battery Recycling**: The disposal of EVs involves challenges related to battery recycling. While recycling technologies are improving, the process can be energy-intensive and may release pollutants if not managed properly. However, recycling can recover valuable materials, reducing the need for new mining.\n- **Vehicle Disposal**: The rest of the vehicle can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, involving emissions from the recycling process.\n\n#### Gasoline Vehicles:\n- **End-of-Life Recycling**: Gasoline vehicles are typically dismantled, and materials like steel and aluminum are recycled. This process also involves emissions but is generally well-established and less complex than battery recycling.\n\n### Overall Comparison\n\n- **Initial Emissions**: EVs tend to have higher emissions during the production phase due to battery manufacturing. However, this is often offset by lower emissions during the operation phase, especially if the electricity comes from low-carbon sources.\n- **Operational Emissions**: EVs generally produce fewer emissions during operation compared to gasoline vehicles, particularly if powered by renewable energy.\n- **End-of-Life**: Both types of vehicles have environmental impacts during disposal, but EVs face additional challenges with battery recycling.\n\nIn conclusion, while electric vehicles have higher initial emissions due to battery production, they typically result in lower overall emissions over their lifecycle compared to gasoline vehicles, especially when powered by clean electricity. The environmental benefits of EVs increase as the electricity grid becomes greener and battery recycling technologies improve.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions aspect, comparing the greenhouse gases and pollutants emitted during the operation of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This would include examining tailpipe emissions for gasoline cars and the emissions from electricity production for electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis, which includes a detailed comparison of emissions from the production, operation, and disposal phases of both electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This approach would consider the emissions from manufacturing batteries for electric cars and refining oil for gasoline cars, providing a comprehensive view of their environmental impact." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves assessing the environmental impacts at every stage from raw material extraction, manufacturing, and usage, to disposal or recycling, providing a comprehensive overview of their environmental footprints.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions aspect, comparing the greenhouse gases and pollutants emitted during the operation of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This would include examining tailpipe emissions for gasoline cars and the emissions from electricity production for electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by reviewing existing scientific studies and reports that compare the environmental impacts of electric and gasoline vehicles. By summarizing the findings and conclusions from these authoritative sources, I can provide an evidence-based perspective on the topic.", + "I can answer by evaluating the resource extraction and supply chain impacts associated with each vehicle type. This includes analyzing the mining of lithium, cobalt, and other materials for electric vehicle batteries compared to the oil extraction and refining processes needed for gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions aspect, comparing the greenhouse gases and pollutants emitted during the operation of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This would include examining tailpipe emissions for gasoline cars and the emissions from electricity production for electric vehicles." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis, which includes a detailed comparison of emissions from the production, operation, and disposal phases of both electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This approach would consider the emissions from manufacturing batteries for electric cars and refining oil for gasoline cars, providing a comprehensive view of their environmental impact.", + "I can answer by analyzing regional variations in emissions, focusing on how the source of electricity affects the emissions of electric vehicles in different areas. This would involve comparing emissions in regions that rely heavily on coal for electricity versus those using renewable energy sources, alongside the uniform emissions profile of gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by exploring the emissions related to the supply chain and infrastructure required for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the emissions from building and maintaining charging stations versus gas stations, as well as the transportation and refining of oil compared to the extraction and processing of materials for batteries.", + "I can answer by evaluating the potential for emissions reduction through future technological advancements and policy changes. This would include examining how improvements in battery technology, grid decarbonization, and fuel efficiency standards could alter the emissions profiles of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles over time." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis, which includes a detailed comparison of emissions from the production, operation, and disposal phases of both electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This approach would consider the emissions from manufacturing batteries for electric cars and refining oil for gasoline cars, providing a comprehensive view of their environmental impact." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:12.911532", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 74 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_75.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_75.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b773df1f542347cf9034f43f17bbbddcc1364613 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_75.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "698a708b-17dc-482d-b33e-69557704b174", + "ibfs_id": "bc55417b-8d7b-415e-b96c-75b72f0f97e9", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, but battery production impacts and resource extraction need sustainable solutions.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles during the raw material extraction phase, we need to consider the different materials and processes involved in each type of vehicle.\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n\n1. **Lithium Extraction:**\n - Lithium is a critical component of lithium-ion batteries used in EVs. It is primarily extracted from brine pools in South America (Chile, Argentina, Bolivia) and from hard rock mining in Australia.\n - The extraction from brine involves pumping lithium-rich brine to the surface and allowing it to evaporate, which can lead to significant water depletion in arid regions, affecting local water supplies and ecosystems.\n - Hard rock mining for lithium is energy-intensive and can result in habitat destruction and soil erosion.\n\n2. **Cobalt Mining:**\n - Cobalt is another essential material for EV batteries, with a significant portion sourced from the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC).\n - The mining process often involves artisanal and small-scale mining, which can lead to unsafe working conditions and child labor.\n - Environmental impacts include habitat destruction, soil and water contamination from mining waste, and significant carbon emissions from the energy-intensive extraction process.\n\n3. **Nickel Extraction:**\n - Nickel is used in many EV battery chemistries, and its extraction involves both open-pit and underground mining.\n - The process can lead to deforestation, soil erosion, and contamination of water bodies with heavy metals and sulfuric acid from tailings.\n - Nickel mining is energy-intensive, contributing to greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n\n1. **Crude Oil Extraction:**\n - The extraction of crude oil for gasoline involves drilling and pumping oil from underground reserves, often located in sensitive environments such as the Arctic, deep-sea regions, and rainforests.\n - Oil extraction can lead to habitat destruction, oil spills, and water contamination, significantly impacting marine and terrestrial ecosystems.\n - The process is energy-intensive, contributing to greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution.\n\n2. **Oil Refining:**\n - Once extracted, crude oil is refined into gasoline, a process that involves significant energy use and emissions of pollutants such as sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and volatile organic compounds.\n - Refineries can also contribute to localized air and water pollution, impacting human health and the environment.\n\n**Comparative Analysis:**\n\n- **Resource Intensity:** EVs require more diverse and often more environmentally impactful materials (lithium, cobalt, nickel) compared to the relatively straightforward extraction of crude oil for gasoline.\n- **Water Use:** Lithium extraction from brine is particularly water-intensive, impacting local water availability, whereas oil extraction can lead to water contamination.\n- **Carbon Emissions:** Both processes are energy-intensive, but the specific emissions depend on the energy sources used (e.g., fossil fuels vs. renewable energy).\n- **Social and Environmental Justice:** Cobalt mining raises significant ethical concerns due to labor practices and environmental degradation in the DRC, while oil extraction often affects indigenous and local communities.\n\nIn conclusion, the raw material extraction phase for EVs and gasoline vehicles presents distinct environmental challenges. EVs involve complex supply chains with significant impacts from mining critical battery materials, while gasoline vehicles primarily impact the environment through oil extraction and refining. Both require careful management to mitigate their environmental footprints.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the entire life cycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction to manufacturing, usage, and disposal, to evaluate their overall environmental impacts, including greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion.", + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the raw material extraction phase of the life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach delves into the environmental impacts associated with mining and processing the materials needed for batteries in EVs, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, compared to the extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the entire life cycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction to manufacturing, usage, and disposal, to evaluate their overall environmental impacts, including greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion.", + "I can answer by focusing on the specific environmental impact of emissions during the use phase of both vehicle types. This would involve comparing the tailpipe emissions of gasoline vehicles with the emissions associated with electricity generation for EVs, taking into account the energy sources that power the electric grid in different regions.", + "I can answer by exploring the environmental implications of the supply chain for both EVs and gasoline vehicles. This includes analyzing the mining and processing of materials like lithium and cobalt for electric vehicle batteries, as well as the extraction and refinement of oil for gasoline production, to assess their respective ecological footprints.", + "I can answer by reviewing scientific literature and case studies on the topic. This approach would involve summarizing findings from existing research papers and reports that compare the environmental impacts of EVs and gasoline vehicles, highlighting key insights and conclusions drawn by experts in the field." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the entire life cycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction to manufacturing, usage, and disposal, to evaluate their overall environmental impacts, including greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, and resource depletion." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing specifically on the raw material extraction phase of the life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach delves into the environmental impacts associated with mining and processing the materials needed for batteries in EVs, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, compared to the extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by concentrating on the manufacturing phase of the life cycle assessment, comparing the environmental impacts of producing electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This involves analyzing the energy consumption and emissions related to the production processes of electric motors and batteries, as well as traditional internal combustion engines and fuel systems.", + "I can answer by examining the usage phase of the life cycle assessment for both vehicle types. This approach emphasizes the differences in emissions and energy efficiency during the operational life of the vehicles, taking into account factors like the electricity grid's energy mix for EVs and fuel consumption rates for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by investigating the end-of-life and disposal phase of the life cycle assessment, evaluating the environmental impacts associated with recycling and disposing of electric vehicle batteries and gasoline vehicle components. This includes assessing the potential for resource recovery and the risks of environmental contamination from waste products." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing specifically on the raw material extraction phase of the life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach delves into the environmental impacts associated with mining and processing the materials needed for batteries in EVs, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, compared to the extraction and refining of crude oil for gasoline vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:17.584138", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 75 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_76.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_76.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..35d211e6cde313fa2f9ce3e37edfa27d8e3278b1 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_76.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "3f1b7fd2-16ba-49fd-9774-765234f4e39a", + "ibfs_id": "45b4c407-7558-4c9d-8b46-e2e3acab2456", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and noise pollution, but battery production and disposal pose environmental challenges compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a well-to-wheel life cycle assessment (LCA). This approach evaluates the entire energy supply chain from the production of energy sources to their consumption in vehicles, providing a comprehensive view of emissions and resource use.\n\n### Well-to-Wheel LCA Comparison\n\n#### 1. Energy Production\n\n**Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n\n- **Electricity Generation:** The environmental impact of EVs largely depends on how the electricity used to charge them is generated. In regions where electricity comes from renewable sources (e.g., wind, solar, hydro), the emissions associated with EVs are significantly lower. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, the emissions can be higher.\n- **Grid Mix Variability:** The carbon intensity of the grid varies by location and time. For example, countries with a high percentage of renewables or nuclear energy have a lower carbon footprint for EVs.\n- **Transmission and Distribution Losses:** Approximately 5-10% of electricity is lost during transmission and distribution, which slightly increases the overall energy demand for EVs.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n\n- **Fuel Extraction and Refining:** The production of gasoline involves extracting crude oil, transporting it, and refining it into gasoline. This process is energy-intensive and results in significant greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.\n- **Distribution:** Transporting gasoline to fueling stations also contributes to emissions, though these are relatively minor compared to extraction and refining.\n\n#### 2. Vehicle Operation\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more efficient than gasoline vehicles. Electric motors convert over 85% of electrical energy into motion, compared to about 20-30% for internal combustion engines (ICEs).\n- **Zero Tailpipe Emissions:** EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, which reduces local air pollution and improves urban air quality.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n\n- **Combustion Emissions:** Gasoline vehicles emit CO2, nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter, and other pollutants during operation. These emissions contribute to climate change and air quality issues.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** The fuel efficiency of gasoline vehicles varies widely, but even the most efficient models produce more emissions per mile than EVs powered by a clean grid.\n\n#### 3. Overall Emissions and Resource Use\n\n- **Greenhouse Gas Emissions:** On average, EVs have lower lifecycle GHG emissions than gasoline vehicles, especially when charged on a low-carbon grid. However, in areas with a coal-heavy grid, the benefits are reduced but still generally favorable.\n- **Resource Depletion:** The production of EV batteries requires significant amounts of materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. While this raises concerns about resource depletion and mining impacts, advancements in battery recycling and alternative chemistries are addressing these issues.\n- **Lifecycle Impact:** Over their lifetime, EVs tend to have a smaller environmental footprint compared to gasoline vehicles, considering both direct emissions and the broader impacts of energy production.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nThe well-to-wheel LCA comparison shows that electric vehicles generally have a lower environmental impact than traditional gasoline vehicles, primarily due to their higher efficiency and the potential for low-emission electricity generation. The extent of these benefits depends on the energy mix used for electricity generation and ongoing improvements in battery technology and recycling. As the grid becomes cleaner and battery technologies advance, the environmental advantages of EVs are expected to increase further.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to use and end-of-life. By analyzing factors such as emissions, resource consumption, and waste generation, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts of both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by conducting a well-to-wheel LCA comparison of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would emphasize the energy production and consumption aspects, examining how electricity generation for EVs and fuel production for gasoline vehicles contribute to overall emissions and resource depletion. This method would provide insight into the environmental impacts associated with powering each type of vehicle during their operational life." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to use and end-of-life. By analyzing factors such as emissions, resource consumption, and waste generation, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts of both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions produced during the use phase of the vehicles. This approach would compare the greenhouse gas emissions from the tailpipes of gasoline vehicles with the indirect emissions associated with the electricity generation required to power EVs. I can also explore how the grid's energy mix (renewable vs. fossil fuels) affects the environmental impact of EVs.", + "I can answer by examining the impact of resource extraction and battery production for electric vehicles. This would involve investigating the environmental consequences of mining for materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which are crucial for EV batteries, and comparing these impacts with those associated with oil extraction and refining for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by evaluating the potential for reducing environmental impacts through technological advancements and policy measures. This would include looking at improvements in EV battery technology, such as increased efficiency and recyclability, as well as the role of government incentives and regulations aimed at reducing emissions from both vehicle types. This strategy would help highlight future trends and possibilities for minimizing environmental impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison between electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of the vehicle's life, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to use and end-of-life. By analyzing factors such as emissions, resource consumption, and waste generation, I can provide a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts of both vehicle types." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by focusing on a cradle-to-gate life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would concentrate specifically on the environmental impacts associated with the raw material extraction, transportation, and manufacturing processes up to the point when the vehicle is ready to be distributed. By comparing these initial stages, I can highlight the differences in resource use and emissions before the vehicles even hit the road.", + "I can answer by conducting a well-to-wheel LCA comparison of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would emphasize the energy production and consumption aspects, examining how electricity generation for EVs and fuel production for gasoline vehicles contribute to overall emissions and resource depletion. This method would provide insight into the environmental impacts associated with powering each type of vehicle during their operational life.", + "I can answer by performing an end-of-life LCA comparison, which would examine the processes involved in the disposal and recycling of electric vehicles and gasoline vehicles. This approach would analyze the environmental impacts of vehicle dismantling, material recovery, and waste management, highlighting the sustainability and potential benefits of recycling practices for both types of vehicles.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative LCA with a regional focus, analyzing how the environmental impacts of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles differ based on geographical location. This approach would consider variations in electricity grid composition, fuel sourcing, and regulatory frameworks to provide a region-specific assessment of environmental impacts, offering insights into how local conditions influence the sustainability of each vehicle type." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a well-to-wheel LCA comparison of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would emphasize the energy production and consumption aspects, examining how electricity generation for EVs and fuel production for gasoline vehicles contribute to overall emissions and resource depletion. This method would provide insight into the environmental impacts associated with powering each type of vehicle during their operational life." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:22.681974", + "similarity_score": 0.4, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 76 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_77.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_77.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..910caf1453dc083643e8993419f3c017d2746d7d --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_77.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "b229da37-7972-4c02-9842-5906d50b9708", + "ibfs_id": "b663e8fe-8208-4915-ae77-758ac86835a2", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions, improve air quality, and have a smaller carbon footprint than gasoline vehicles, despite battery production concerns.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles, we can conduct a life-cycle assessment (LCA) that considers emissions and energy consumption across several stages: manufacturing, operational use, and disposal.\n\n### 1. Manufacturing Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** The production of EV batteries, particularly lithium-ion batteries, is energy-intensive and results in significant emissions. Mining and processing raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel contribute to environmental degradation and carbon emissions.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** The assembly of EVs generally requires less energy than gasoline vehicles, as electric drivetrains are simpler. However, the overall manufacturing emissions are higher due to the battery.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Transmission Production:** Manufacturing internal combustion engines and transmissions involves complex processes and materials, leading to substantial energy use and emissions.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** Similar to EVs, the assembly of gasoline vehicles contributes to emissions, but the absence of large battery packs results in lower manufacturing emissions compared to EVs.\n\n### 2. Operational Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Energy Source:** The environmental impact during the operational phase largely depends on the electricity source. EVs charged with renewable energy (solar, wind) have minimal emissions, while those charged with coal-based electricity have higher emissions.\n- **Efficiency:** EVs are generally more energy-efficient than gasoline vehicles, converting a higher percentage of energy from the grid to power at the wheels.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Combustion:** Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and other pollutants directly through the combustion of fossil fuels.\n- **Fuel Efficiency:** Although improvements in fuel efficiency have been made, gasoline vehicles still emit significant greenhouse gases over their lifetime.\n\n### 3. Disposal Phase\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Recycling:** The disposal phase involves recycling or disposing of batteries, which can be environmentally challenging. Advances in recycling technologies are improving the recovery of valuable materials, but the process still has environmental impacts.\n- **Vehicle Recycling:** The rest of the vehicle can be recycled similarly to gasoline vehicles, with metals and other materials being reused.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **End-of-Life Recycling:** Gasoline vehicles are typically dismantled, and materials such as steel, aluminum, and plastics are recycled. The absence of large batteries simplifies the recycling process compared to EVs.\n\n### Overall Environmental Impact\n\n- **Carbon Footprint:** Over their entire life cycle, EVs generally have a lower carbon footprint than gasoline vehicles, especially when charged with low-carbon electricity. The higher emissions from manufacturing are offset by lower operational emissions.\n- **Pollutants:** EVs produce fewer air pollutants during operation, contributing to better air quality, particularly in urban areas.\n- **Resource Use:** EVs require specific minerals for batteries, which can lead to environmental and social issues related to mining. However, ongoing improvements in battery technology and recycling can mitigate these impacts.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs have higher emissions during the manufacturing phase due to battery production, they offer significant environmental benefits during the operational phase, particularly when powered by renewable energy. The disposal phase presents challenges for both vehicle types, but advancements in recycling are helping to reduce impacts. Overall, EVs tend to have a more favorable environmental profile over their entire life cycle compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy consumption during the operational phase of each vehicle type. This would involve comparing the carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion versus the emissions from electricity generation required to charge electric vehicles, accounting for the energy mix of the grid.", + "I can answer by conducting a life-cycle assessment that examines emissions and energy consumption not only during the operational phase but also during the manufacturing and disposal phases of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This holistic approach would provide a more comprehensive understanding of overall environmental impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) for both electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves evaluating the environmental impacts during the entire lifespan of the vehicles, from manufacturing and operation to disposal. The LCA would consider factors such as raw material extraction, energy consumption, emissions during production, and end-of-life recycling.", + "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy consumption during the operational phase of each vehicle type. This would involve comparing the carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion versus the emissions from electricity generation required to charge electric vehicles, accounting for the energy mix of the grid.", + "I can answer by examining the resource and material extraction impacts associated with each vehicle type. This would look into the mining and processing of materials like lithium, cobalt, and rare earth elements for electric vehicle batteries, compared to the oil extraction, refining, and transportation processes needed for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by evaluating the broader ecological and health impacts using a systems thinking approach. This includes not only direct emissions and resource use but also secondary effects such as habitat destruction from mining, pollution from manufacturing plants, and the impact of battery disposal. Additionally, I would consider the public health benefits from reduced air pollution in urban areas due to the use of electric vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by focusing on the emissions and energy consumption during the operational phase of each vehicle type. This would involve comparing the carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gas emissions produced by gasoline vehicles during fuel combustion versus the emissions from electricity generation required to charge electric vehicles, accounting for the energy mix of the grid." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a life-cycle assessment that examines emissions and energy consumption not only during the operational phase but also during the manufacturing and disposal phases of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This holistic approach would provide a more comprehensive understanding of overall environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by comparing the energy efficiency of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles during their operational phase. This would involve analyzing how much energy each vehicle type consumes to travel a certain distance and the associated emissions from this energy consumption, particularly focusing on the energy mix used in different regions.", + "I can answer by focusing on regional variations in the emissions and energy consumption of electric vehicles. This would involve evaluating how the local energy grid's composition (coal, nuclear, renewables, etc.) affects the emissions profile of electric vehicles compared to gasoline vehicles in different geographic areas.", + "I can answer by examining the impact of technological advancements on emissions and energy consumption during the operational phase. This would involve analyzing how improvements in battery technology and fuel efficiency affect the environmental performance of electric versus gasoline vehicles over time, including potential future scenarios." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a life-cycle assessment that examines emissions and energy consumption not only during the operational phase but also during the manufacturing and disposal phases of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This holistic approach would provide a more comprehensive understanding of overall environmental impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:25.060696", + "similarity_score": 0.6, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 77 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_78.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_78.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4dbf7f76f70df17af26af46bc9f9bb293ad130d1 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_78.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "c0ec38cd-64d2-4d5b-9bbe-b07d7ecf7117", + "ibfs_id": "8ee85a92-4e7b-4e57-877c-0472cd70d4e2", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution, are energy-efficient, but battery production impacts remain concerning compared to gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To assess the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) compared to traditional gasoline vehicles through the lens of electric vehicle infrastructure, we need to focus on how the increased demand for electricity from EV charging stations affects energy grids and local ecosystems.\n\n**Impact on Energy Grids:**\n\n1. **Increased Demand for Electricity:**\n - As the number of EVs increases, so does the demand for electricity to power these vehicles. This can lead to a significant rise in overall electricity consumption.\n - If the charging demand peaks at certain times, such as during the evening when people return home from work, it can strain the existing grid infrastructure. This may necessitate upgrades to transmission lines, transformers, and other grid components to handle the increased load.\n\n2. **Changes in Energy Production Methods:**\n - To meet the increased electricity demand from EVs, utilities may need to adjust their energy production strategies. This could involve ramping up production from existing power plants or investing in new capacity.\n - If the additional electricity demand is met by fossil fuel-based power plants, such as coal or natural gas, it could negate some of the emissions benefits of switching from gasoline to electric vehicles. However, if the demand is met by renewable energy sources like wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the environmental impact is significantly reduced.\n\n3. **Grid Modernization and Smart Grids:**\n - The integration of smart grid technologies can help manage the increased demand more efficiently. Smart grids can optimize electricity distribution and reduce peak loads through demand response programs, where EV charging is scheduled during off-peak hours.\n - Investment in energy storage solutions, such as batteries, can also help balance supply and demand, storing excess renewable energy generated during low-demand periods for use during high-demand times.\n\n**Impact on Local Ecosystems:**\n\n1. **Construction of Charging Infrastructure:**\n - The development of EV charging stations requires land and resources, which can impact local ecosystems. This includes the physical footprint of charging stations and any associated infrastructure, such as roads or parking lots.\n - Careful planning and site selection can mitigate these impacts by avoiding ecologically sensitive areas and minimizing habitat disruption.\n\n2. **Potential for Renewable Energy Integration:**\n - Charging stations powered by renewable energy sources, such as solar panels, can reduce the ecological footprint of EV infrastructure. This integration can help preserve local ecosystems by reducing reliance on fossil fuels and lowering emissions.\n\n3. **Localized Environmental Effects:**\n - In areas where the grid is heavily reliant on fossil fuels, increased electricity demand from EVs could lead to more localized pollution from power plants, affecting air quality and local ecosystems.\n - Conversely, in regions with a high penetration of renewables, the shift to EVs can lead to cleaner air and reduced ecological disturbance.\n\nIn summary, while the transition to electric vehicles presents challenges in terms of increased electricity demand and potential impacts on local ecosystems, it also offers opportunities for cleaner energy production and infrastructure development. The environmental impact largely depends on how the electricity is generated and the strategies employed to integrate EV infrastructure into the existing grid. By prioritizing renewable energy sources and smart grid technologies, the negative impacts can be minimized, leading to a more sustainable transportation system.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by exploring the impact on infrastructure and ecosystems. I would analyze how the shift to electric vehicles affects the development of charging infrastructure, changes in land use, and potential effects on ecosystems compared to the infrastructure needed for gasoline vehicles, such as gas stations and oil refineries.", + "I can answer by assessing the impact of electric vehicle infrastructure on energy grids and local ecosystems, specifically examining how increased demand for electricity from charging stations might lead to changes in energy production methods and potential effects on nearby natural habitats." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle analysis of both electric and gasoline vehicles, which would involve examining the environmental impacts at each stage of a vehicle's life\u2014from raw material extraction, through manufacturing and use, to disposal. This comprehensive approach would highlight differences in resource use, emissions, and waste generation.", + "I can answer by focusing on emissions and air quality impact specifically. I would compare the greenhouse gas emissions and pollutants released during the operation of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles. This would include an assessment of emissions from electricity generation for EVs and tailpipe emissions from gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by considering the broader energy and resource consumption implications. This would involve evaluating the demand on natural resources such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel for electric vehicle batteries, compared to the petroleum consumption for gasoline vehicles. This approach would discuss the sustainability and geopolitical implications of resource extraction and use.", + "I can answer by exploring the impact on infrastructure and ecosystems. I would analyze how the shift to electric vehicles affects the development of charging infrastructure, changes in land use, and potential effects on ecosystems compared to the infrastructure needed for gasoline vehicles, such as gas stations and oil refineries." + ], + "choice_idx": 3, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by exploring the impact on infrastructure and ecosystems. I would analyze how the shift to electric vehicles affects the development of charging infrastructure, changes in land use, and potential effects on ecosystems compared to the infrastructure needed for gasoline vehicles, such as gas stations and oil refineries." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the spatial footprint required for electric vehicle charging stations versus traditional gasoline stations, including the land and resources needed for construction and maintenance, and examining how these differences might affect local ecosystems and urban development.", + "I can answer by investigating the environmental impact of the supply chain for electric vehicle infrastructure, focusing on the production, transportation, and disposal of materials used in electric charging stations compared to those used in gasoline station construction and maintenance.", + "I can answer by assessing the impact of electric vehicle infrastructure on energy grids and local ecosystems, specifically examining how increased demand for electricity from charging stations might lead to changes in energy production methods and potential effects on nearby natural habitats.", + "I can answer by exploring the long-term ecological benefits and challenges associated with the decommissioning of gasoline-related infrastructure versus the establishment of electric vehicle infrastructure, looking at changes in land restoration opportunities, pollution reduction, and biodiversity recovery." + ], + "choice_idx": 2, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by assessing the impact of electric vehicle infrastructure on energy grids and local ecosystems, specifically examining how increased demand for electricity from charging stations might lead to changes in energy production methods and potential effects on nearby natural habitats." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:45.241706", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 78 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_79.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_79.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..15a6fa32bc797cfaac5e31f111d6fa039d1d1cc5 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_79.json @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "1c535ea5-74fc-4285-ab1e-968f56bebe56", + "ibfs_id": "35b3eda4-b177-4866-8021-399c305cd3dd", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce emissions and pollution but entail mining impacts; gasoline vehicles generate more CO2 and air pollution.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative analysis of the carbon footprints associated with the supply chains of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we need to examine several stages: raw material extraction, manufacturing processes, and transportation logistics. Each stage contributes differently to the overall carbon footprint of the vehicles.\n\n### 1. Raw Material Extraction\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Production:** EVs primarily rely on lithium-ion batteries, which require mining and refining of materials such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and graphite. The extraction and processing of these materials are energy-intensive and often involve significant greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. For instance, cobalt mining, primarily in the Democratic Republic of Congo, involves substantial energy use and environmental degradation.\n- **Other Components:** EVs also require copper for wiring and other components, which involves additional mining and refining activities.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Production:** The extraction and refining of crude oil into gasoline is a major source of emissions. Oil drilling, transportation, and refining are energy-intensive processes that release significant amounts of CO2 and other pollutants.\n- **Vehicle Components:** Traditional vehicles require steel and aluminum for construction, which also involve mining and refining. However, the absence of large batteries reduces the need for certain minerals like lithium and cobalt.\n\n### 2. Manufacturing Processes\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Manufacturing:** The production of lithium-ion batteries is one of the most carbon-intensive parts of EV manufacturing. It involves high energy consumption, often from fossil fuel sources, especially in regions where renewable energy is less prevalent.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** EVs generally have fewer moving parts than gasoline vehicles, which can reduce emissions during assembly. However, the energy used in battery production often offsets these savings.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Engine and Transmission Manufacturing:** The production of internal combustion engines and complex transmissions involves significant energy use and emissions. These components are more complex than electric drivetrains, leading to higher emissions during manufacturing.\n- **Vehicle Assembly:** The overall assembly process for gasoline vehicles is similar in energy use to that of EVs, excluding the battery production.\n\n### 3. Transportation Logistics\n\n**Electric Vehicles:**\n- **Battery Transport:** The transportation of batteries, often across continents, adds to the carbon footprint. Batteries are heavy and require specialized handling, which can increase emissions.\n- **Vehicle Distribution:** The logistics of distributing EVs are similar to gasoline vehicles, though the weight of batteries can increase emissions during transportation.\n\n**Gasoline Vehicles:**\n- **Fuel Supply Chain:** The transportation of crude oil and refined gasoline involves a complex global supply chain, contributing to emissions. Tanker ships, pipelines, and trucks all play a role in delivering fuel to end-users.\n- **Vehicle Distribution:** Similar to EVs, the distribution of gasoline vehicles involves emissions from logistics operations.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nIn summary, electric vehicles tend to have a higher carbon footprint during the raw material extraction and manufacturing stages, primarily due to battery production. However, they benefit from lower emissions during the vehicle's operational phase due to the absence of tailpipe emissions. Gasoline vehicles, on the other hand, have a more balanced distribution of emissions across their lifecycle, with significant contributions from fuel production and consumption.\n\nOverall, while EVs may start with a higher carbon footprint due to their supply chain, they can offset this through cleaner operation, especially when charged with renewable energy. The net environmental impact depends on various factors, including the energy mix used in battery production and vehicle operation.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by comparing the lifecycle emissions of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles, which involves analyzing the environmental impact from manufacturing to disposal. This would include the extraction of raw materials, production processes, the electricity generation for EVs, and the fuel production and consumption for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the carbon footprints associated with the supply chains of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the emissions from the mining and refining of raw materials, manufacturing processes, and transportation logistics for both vehicle types." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by comparing the lifecycle emissions of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles, which involves analyzing the environmental impact from manufacturing to disposal. This would include the extraction of raw materials, production processes, the electricity generation for EVs, and the fuel production and consumption for gasoline vehicles.", + "I can answer by examining the differences in air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions during the operation of both types of vehicles. This approach focuses on tailpipe emissions for gasoline vehicles versus the emissions from power plants that generate electricity for charging electric vehicles.", + "I can answer by investigating the impact of battery production and disposal in electric vehicles compared to the environmental costs associated with oil extraction and refinement for gasoline vehicles. This strategy will explore the resource extraction and waste management challenges unique to each vehicle type.", + "I can answer by evaluating the potential for renewable energy integration with electric vehicles versus improvements in fuel efficiency and alternative fuels for gasoline vehicles. This involves exploring future scenarios where EVs are charged using renewable energy sources and comparing that to advancements in gasoline vehicle technology that aim to reduce environmental impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by comparing the lifecycle emissions of electric vehicles and traditional gasoline vehicles, which involves analyzing the environmental impact from manufacturing to disposal. This would include the extraction of raw materials, production processes, the electricity generation for EVs, and the fuel production and consumption for gasoline vehicles." + }, + { + "depth": 1, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the carbon footprints associated with the supply chains of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the emissions from the mining and refining of raw materials, manufacturing processes, and transportation logistics for both vehicle types.", + "I can answer by performing a regional case study analysis, comparing the lifecycle emissions of electric and gasoline vehicles in different geographical locations. This would consider regional variations in electricity generation sources for EVs, local emissions standards, and the availability of raw materials.", + "I can answer by evaluating the end-of-life disposal and recycling processes for electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would focus on the environmental impacts of recycling batteries in EVs versus the disposal of traditional vehicle components, assessing how these processes contribute to overall emissions.", + "I can answer by modeling the potential emissions reduction scenarios over the lifespan of electric and gasoline vehicles. This would involve simulating different scenarios of vehicle usage patterns, including urban versus rural driving, varying electricity grid mixes, and advancements in battery technology to predict future environmental impacts." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the carbon footprints associated with the supply chains of electric and gasoline vehicles. This involves examining the emissions from the mining and refining of raw materials, manufacturing processes, and transportation logistics for both vehicle types." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "medium", + "branching_factor": 4, + "max_depth": 2 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:11:38.310506", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 79 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_8.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_8.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f4670a7584de6f20056ee2f6f864cac624b4746a --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_8.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "de405556-9935-4e7b-9761-2a2d1f6d3e31", + "ibfs_id": "1dccd8e5-c222-45d1-833a-e02ba7fb3ccc", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles produce fewer emissions, reduce dependency on fossil fuels, and contribute less pollution compared to traditional gasoline vehicles.", + "final_answer": "To conduct a comparative analysis of the lifecycle emissions of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we will examine the emissions produced during the manufacturing, operation, and disposal phases of each vehicle type. This analysis draws from various studies and reports that provide insights into the carbon footprint and energy consumption associated with both types of vehicles.\n\n### Manufacturing Phase\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - The manufacturing of EVs generally results in higher emissions compared to gasoline vehicles, primarily due to the production of lithium-ion batteries. The extraction and processing of raw materials such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel are energy-intensive and contribute significantly to the carbon footprint.\n - According to a study by the Union of Concerned Scientists, the production emissions of an EV can be about 15% to 68% higher than those of a gasoline vehicle, depending on the size of the battery.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - The manufacturing process for gasoline vehicles involves emissions from the production of steel, aluminum, and other materials, but these are typically lower than the emissions associated with EV battery production.\n - Overall, the manufacturing emissions for gasoline vehicles are relatively lower compared to EVs, but this advantage diminishes over the vehicle's lifecycle.\n\n### Operation Phase\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, which significantly reduces their operational carbon footprint. However, the total emissions depend on the electricity source used for charging.\n - In regions where electricity is generated from renewable sources, the operational emissions of EVs are minimal. Conversely, in areas reliant on coal or natural gas, the emissions can be higher.\n - The International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT) reports that even in regions with a high percentage of fossil fuel-based electricity, EVs still have lower operational emissions than gasoline vehicles.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Gasoline vehicles emit carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and other pollutants directly from the tailpipe during operation.\n - The operational emissions are consistent and depend on fuel efficiency and driving habits. On average, gasoline vehicles emit about 4.6 metric tons of CO2 per year, according to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).\n\n### Disposal Phase\n\n1. **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - The disposal phase of EVs involves recycling or disposing of batteries, which can be environmentally challenging. However, advancements in battery recycling technologies are reducing the environmental impact.\n - Proper recycling can recover valuable materials and reduce the need for new raw material extraction, thus lowering the lifecycle emissions.\n\n2. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - The disposal of gasoline vehicles involves recycling metals and other materials, which is a well-established process with a relatively lower environmental impact compared to battery disposal.\n - However, the end-of-life emissions are generally lower than those of EVs due to the absence of large batteries.\n\n### Overall Lifecycle Emissions\n\n- **Electric Vehicles (EVs):**\n - Despite higher manufacturing emissions, EVs tend to have lower overall lifecycle emissions due to their cleaner operation phase. The reduction in emissions is more pronounced over time as the electricity grid becomes greener.\n - Studies, such as those by the European Environment Agency, indicate that EVs can reduce lifecycle emissions by about 30% to 50% compared to gasoline vehicles, depending on the electricity mix.\n\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Gasoline vehicles have lower manufacturing emissions but higher operational emissions, leading to a higher overall carbon footprint over their lifecycle.\n - The lack of tailpipe emissions reduction technology means that gasoline vehicles will continue to have a significant environmental impact unless offset by other means.\n\nIn conclusion, while EVs have higher emissions during the manufacturing phase, their overall lifecycle emissions are generally lower than those of traditional gasoline vehicles, especially as the energy grid becomes more reliant on renewable sources. This makes EVs a more environmentally friendly option in the long term.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the lifecycle emissions of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the emissions produced during the manufacturing, operation, and disposal phases of each vehicle type. I would gather data from studies and reports that provide insights into the carbon footprint and energy consumption associated with both EVs and gasoline vehicles, highlighting key differences and similarities in their environmental impacts." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the lifecycle emissions of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the emissions produced during the manufacturing, operation, and disposal phases of each vehicle type. I would gather data from studies and reports that provide insights into the carbon footprint and energy consumption associated with both EVs and gasoline vehicles, highlighting key differences and similarities in their environmental impacts.", + "I can answer by evaluating the broader ecological effects of electric vehicles versus gasoline vehicles beyond just emissions. This strategy would look at factors such as the environmental impact of raw material extraction (like lithium for EV batteries), the energy sources used for electricity generation, and the potential for pollution from battery disposal. Additionally, I would consider the impacts on ecosystems, such as habitat disruption from mining activities, and compare these to the effects of oil extraction and refining for gasoline vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 0, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by conducting a comparative analysis of the lifecycle emissions of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve examining the emissions produced during the manufacturing, operation, and disposal phases of each vehicle type. I would gather data from studies and reports that provide insights into the carbon footprint and energy consumption associated with both EVs and gasoline vehicles, highlighting key differences and similarities in their environmental impacts." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:07:10.805611", + "similarity_score": 0.3, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 8 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_9.json b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_9.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..704e1f04084f0f014aa5cd1df5b38da2f85ea649 --- /dev/null +++ b/experiment_results/exp_20250319_160627_sim_9.json @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{ + "query": "What are the environmental impacts of electric vehicles compared to traditional gasoline vehicles?", + "user_id": "86eb172c-f1f6-469b-a9b1-1c9d38e657b3", + "ibfs_id": "d0a18dcd-b9e3-46ac-ba7e-a95b5f32d4b5", + "user_preferred_answer": "Electric vehicles reduce greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, but concern remains about battery production and electricity sourcing impact.", + "final_answer": "To compare the environmental impacts of electric vehicles (EVs) and traditional gasoline vehicles, we can examine specific environmental metrics such as tailpipe emissions and the energy sources used to power EVs.\n\n### Tailpipe Emissions\n\n1. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Traditional gasoline vehicles emit pollutants directly from their tailpipes. These emissions include carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO), particulate matter (PM), and hydrocarbons (HC). CO2 is a significant greenhouse gas contributing to global warming, while NOx and PM contribute to air pollution and have adverse health effects.\n\n2. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - EVs have zero tailpipe emissions since they do not burn fuel. This means they do not emit CO2, NOx, CO, PM, or HC during operation. This is a significant advantage in terms of reducing urban air pollution and improving air quality.\n\n### Energy Sources\n\n1. **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - The environmental impact of gasoline vehicles is primarily linked to the combustion of fossil fuels (gasoline or diesel) derived from crude oil. The extraction, refining, and transportation of these fuels also contribute to environmental degradation and greenhouse gas emissions.\n\n2. **Electric Vehicles:**\n - The environmental impact of EVs depends significantly on the energy mix used to generate electricity. If the electricity comes from renewable sources such as wind, solar, or hydroelectric power, the overall emissions associated with EVs are much lower. However, if the electricity is generated from fossil fuels like coal or natural gas, the emissions can be higher.\n - The global energy mix is gradually shifting towards more renewable sources, which enhances the environmental benefits of EVs over time. In regions where the grid is predominantly powered by renewables, EVs have a much smaller carbon footprint compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n### Contribution to Air Pollution and Global Warming\n\n- **Gasoline Vehicles:**\n - Directly contribute to air pollution through tailpipe emissions. They are a significant source of urban air pollution and greenhouse gases, contributing to global warming.\n\n- **Electric Vehicles:**\n - Indirectly contribute to emissions based on the electricity generation mix. In areas with a high percentage of renewable energy, EVs contribute minimally to air pollution and global warming. In contrast, in regions reliant on coal or natural gas, the benefits are reduced but still generally favorable compared to gasoline vehicles.\n\n### Conclusion\n\nOverall, electric vehicles offer substantial environmental benefits over traditional gasoline vehicles, particularly in reducing tailpipe emissions and improving air quality. The extent of their advantage in terms of global warming potential depends on the energy sources used to generate electricity. As the energy grid becomes greener with more renewable energy integration, the environmental footprint of electric vehicles will continue to decrease, enhancing their role in mitigating climate change.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by comparing specific environmental metrics such as tailpipe emissions and energy sources. This approach would focus on direct emissions during the operation of both vehicle types and consider the energy mix used to power electric vehicles. By contrasting these factors, we can determine their contribution to air pollution and global warming, and assess how the energy grid's reliance on renewable versus fossil fuels impacts the overall environmental footprint of electric vehicles." + ], + "history": [ + { + "depth": 0, + "strategies": [ + "I can answer by conducting a lifecycle assessment of both electric and gasoline vehicles. This approach would involve analyzing the entire lifecycle of each vehicle type, from raw material extraction and manufacturing to usage and end-of-life disposal. This would provide a comprehensive view of the environmental impacts associated with each stage, including greenhouse gas emissions, resource depletion, and pollution.", + "I can answer by comparing specific environmental metrics such as tailpipe emissions and energy sources. This approach would focus on direct emissions during the operation of both vehicle types and consider the energy mix used to power electric vehicles. By contrasting these factors, we can determine their contribution to air pollution and global warming, and assess how the energy grid's reliance on renewable versus fossil fuels impacts the overall environmental footprint of electric vehicles." + ], + "choice_idx": 1, + "chosen_strategy": "I can answer by comparing specific environmental metrics such as tailpipe emissions and energy sources. This approach would focus on direct emissions during the operation of both vehicle types and consider the energy mix used to power electric vehicles. By contrasting these factors, we can determine their contribution to air pollution and global warming, and assess how the energy grid's reliance on renewable versus fossil fuels impacts the overall environmental footprint of electric vehicles." + } + ], + "ibfs_config": { + "diversity_level": "low", + "branching_factor": 2, + "max_depth": 1 + }, + "user_config": { + "epsilon": 0.2 + }, + "timestamp": "2025-03-19T16:06:59.120475", + "similarity_score": 0.5, + "experiment_id": "exp_20250319_160627", + "simulation_id": 9 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ibfs.py b/ibfs.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..94f4b1b1bb7ec87135eb313624d4dfbcf8aeff4c --- /dev/null +++ b/ibfs.py @@ -0,0 +1,335 @@ +import re +import litellm +from typing import List, Dict, Any, Optional + +# Import the necessary functions +from prompts import PROMPTS, format_prompt +from utils import save_results, generate_user_id + + +def generate_strategies(query: str, selected_strategy: Optional[str], k: int) -> List[str]: + """ + Generate k strategy options using the LLM. + + Args: + query: The original user query + selected_strategy: Previously selected strategy (if any) + k: Number of strategies to generate + + Returns: + List of strategy options + """ + # Choose the appropriate prompt template + if selected_strategy: + prompt_key = "continuation_strategies" + format_args = { + "query": query, + "selected_strategy": selected_strategy, + "k": k + } + else: + prompt_key = "initial_strategies" + format_args = { + "query": query, + "k": k + } + + # Format the prompts + system_template = PROMPTS["ibfs"][prompt_key]["system"] + user_template = PROMPTS["ibfs"][prompt_key]["user"] + + system_message = format_prompt(system_template, **format_args) + user_message = format_prompt(user_template, **format_args) + + messages = [ + {"role": "system", "content": system_message}, + {"role": "user", "content": user_message} + ] + + # Get response from LLM + response = litellm.completion( + model="gpt-4o", + messages=messages, + temperature=0.7, + max_tokens=1000 + ) + + content = response.choices[0].message.content + + # Parse strategies using regex (simplified) + strategies = re.findall(r'\d+\.\s*(.+?)(?=\n\d+\.|\Z)', content, re.DOTALL) + + # Ensure we have exactly k strategies + strategies = [s.strip() for s in strategies[:k]] + + # Fill in missing strategies if needed + while len(strategies) < k: + strategies.append(f"Strategy option #{len(strategies) + 1}") + + return strategies + + +def answer_query(query: str, final_strategy: str) -> str: + """ + Generate the final answer based on the selected strategy. + + Args: + query: The original user query + final_strategy: The final selected strategy + + Returns: + The final answer + """ + # Get prompt templates + system_template = PROMPTS["ibfs"]["final_answer"]["system"] + user_template = PROMPTS["ibfs"]["final_answer"]["user"] + + # Format the prompts + format_args = { + "query": query, + "final_strategy": final_strategy + } + + system_message = format_prompt(system_template, **format_args) + user_message = format_prompt(user_template, **format_args) + + messages = [ + {"role": "system", "content": system_message}, + {"role": "user", "content": user_message} + ] + + response = litellm.completion( + model="gpt-4o", + messages=messages, + temperature=0.3, + max_tokens=2000 + ) + + return response.choices[0].message.content + + +def start_ibfs(query: str, k: int, m: int) -> tuple: + """ + Start the IBFS process with a new query. + + Args: + query: User's query + k: Branching factor + m: Depth + + Returns: + Initial state and chat history + """ + if not query or not query.strip(): + return None, [{"role": "assistant", "content": "Please enter a query."}] + + # Generate a unique user ID + user_id = generate_user_id() + + # Initialize chat history + chat_history = [] + + # Add the original query to chat history + chat_history.append({"role": "user", "content": f"Query: {query}"}) + + # Welcome message + welcome_msg = format_prompt( + PROMPTS["ibfs"]["ui_messages"]["welcome"], + m=m, + k=k + ) + chat_history.append({"role": "assistant", "content": welcome_msg}) + + # Generating message + generating_msg = PROMPTS["ibfs"]["ui_messages"]["generating"] + chat_history.append({"role": "assistant", "content": generating_msg}) + + try: + # Generate initial strategies + strategies = generate_strategies(query, None, k) + + # Format strategies for display + valid_options = ", ".join(map(str, range(1, len(strategies) + 1))) + select_msg = format_prompt( + PROMPTS["ibfs"]["ui_messages"]["select_strategy"], + current_step=1, + max_steps=m, + valid_options=valid_options + ) + + options_text = f"{select_msg}\n\n" + for idx, strategy in enumerate(strategies): + options_text += f"{idx + 1}. {strategy}\n\n" + + chat_history.append({"role": "assistant", "content": options_text}) + + # Create state + state = { + "user_id": user_id, + "query": query, + "k": k, + "m": m, + "current_step": 0, + "strategy_path": [], + "chat_history": chat_history, + "strategies": strategies, + } + + return state, chat_history + + except Exception as e: + error_msg = format_prompt( + PROMPTS["ibfs"]["ui_messages"]["error_general"], + error_message=str(e) + ) + print(error_msg) + return None, [ + {"role": "user", "content": f"Query: {query}"}, + {"role": "assistant", "content": "I encountered an error while starting the IBFS process."}, + {"role": "system", "content": error_msg} + ] + + +def handle_choice(state: Dict[str, Any], choice: str) -> tuple: + """ + Handle the user's choice of strategy. + + Args: + state: Current state + choice: The user's selected option (1-based index as string) + + Returns: + Updated state and chat history + """ + if not state: + return state, [] + + chat_history = state.get("chat_history", []) + + # Validate choice input + if not choice or not choice.strip(): + chat_history.append({"role": "system", "content": PROMPTS["ibfs"]["ui_messages"]["error_missing_choice"]}) + return state, chat_history + + try: + choice_idx = int(choice.strip()) - 1 # Convert to 0-based index + strategies = state.get("strategies", []) + + # Check if we have strategies and if choice is valid + if not strategies: + chat_history.append({"role": "system", "content": PROMPTS["ibfs"]["ui_messages"]["error_no_strategies"]}) + return state, chat_history + + if choice_idx < 0 or choice_idx >= len(strategies): + error_msg = format_prompt( + PROMPTS["ibfs"]["ui_messages"]["error_invalid_choice"], + max_option=len(strategies) + ) + chat_history.append({"role": "system", "content": error_msg}) + return state, chat_history + + # Get the selected strategy and update path + selected_strategy = strategies[choice_idx] + strategy_path = state.get("strategy_path", []) + strategy_path.append(selected_strategy) + + # Record user's choice + chat_history.append({"role": "user", "content": f"I choose option {choice_idx + 1}: {selected_strategy}"}) + + # Update current step + current_step = state.get("current_step", 0) + 1 + m = state.get("m", 2) + + # Check if we've reached the final step + if current_step >= m: + # Generate final answer + final_processing_msg = PROMPTS["ibfs"]["ui_messages"]["final_processing"] + chat_history.append({"role": "assistant", "content": final_processing_msg}) + + query = state.get("query", "") + final_answer = answer_query(query, selected_strategy) + + # Format final result + result_msg = format_prompt( + PROMPTS["ibfs"]["ui_messages"]["final_result"], + final_strategy=selected_strategy, + final_answer=final_answer + ) + chat_history.append({"role": "assistant", "content": result_msg}) + + # Save results + user_id = state.get("user_id", "") + save_path = save_results( + user_id=user_id, + query=query, + final_answer=final_answer, + method="ibfs", + strategy_path=strategy_path + ) + + saved_msg = format_prompt( + PROMPTS["ibfs"]["ui_messages"]["saved_result"], + save_path=save_path, + user_id=user_id + ) + chat_history.append({"role": "system", "content": saved_msg}) + + # Reset state for a new query + state = { + "user_id": user_id, + "current_step": 0, + "strategy_path": [], + "strategies": [], + "chat_history": chat_history, + } + + return state, chat_history + + # If we're not at the final step, generate new strategies + k = state.get("k", 3) + query = state.get("query", "") + + # Generate sub-strategies for next step + sub_strategies = generate_strategies(query, selected_strategy, k) + + # Format strategies for display + valid_options = ", ".join(map(str, range(1, len(sub_strategies) + 1))) + select_msg = format_prompt( + PROMPTS["ibfs"]["ui_messages"]["select_strategy"], + current_step=current_step + 1, + max_steps=m, + valid_options=valid_options + ) + + options_text = f"{select_msg}\n\n" + for idx, strategy in enumerate(sub_strategies): + options_text += f"{idx + 1}. {strategy}\n\n" + + chat_history.append({"role": "assistant", "content": options_text}) + + # Update state + state.update({ + "current_step": current_step, + "strategy_path": strategy_path, + "chat_history": chat_history, + "strategies": sub_strategies, + }) + + return state, chat_history + + except ValueError: + error_msg = format_prompt( + PROMPTS["ibfs"]["ui_messages"]["error_invalid_number"], + choice=choice + ) + chat_history.append({"role": "system", "content": error_msg}) + return state, chat_history + + except Exception as e: + error_msg = format_prompt( + PROMPTS["ibfs"]["ui_messages"]["error_general"], + error_message=str(e) + ) + print(error_msg) + chat_history.append({"role": "system", "content": error_msg}) + return state, chat_history \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ibfs_results/1d83bf84-172c-4757-801f-736b683e53a5_ibfs_20250319_135421.json b/ibfs_results/1d83bf84-172c-4757-801f-736b683e53a5_ibfs_20250319_135421.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..89777be54a6cd967004e80c7b9a31d9e4968c119 --- /dev/null +++ b/ibfs_results/1d83bf84-172c-4757-801f-736b683e53a5_ibfs_20250319_135421.json @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +{ + "user_id": "1d83bf84-172c-4757-801f-736b683e53a5", + "timestamp": "20250319_135421", + "method": "ibfs", + "query": "whats the meaning of life", + "final_answer": "Existentialist philosophers like Jean-Paul Sartre and Simone de Beauvoir offer a unique perspective on the meaning of life, emphasizing that life has no inherent or predetermined meaning. According to existentialism, the universe is indifferent, and it is up to each individual to create their own purpose through their choices and actions.\n\nJean-Paul Sartre famously declared that \"existence precedes essence,\" meaning that humans first exist without any predefined purpose or essence. It is through living and making choices that individuals define who they are. Sartre emphasized personal freedom and the responsibility that comes with it. Since there is no inherent meaning to life, individuals are free to choose their own paths, but this freedom also brings with it a profound responsibility for one's actions and their consequences.\n\nSimone de Beauvoir, another prominent existentialist, also explored these themes. She argued that individuals must confront the \"ambiguity\" of existence and embrace the freedom to define themselves. De Beauvoir highlighted the importance of authenticity and the need to live in accordance with one's own values and beliefs, rather than conforming to societal expectations or external pressures.\n\nBoth philosophers acknowledged the existential angst or anxiety that arises from the realization that life lacks inherent meaning. This angst stems from the burden of freedom and the awareness of one's ultimate responsibility for creating meaning in a seemingly indifferent universe. However, they also saw this as an opportunity for empowerment, as it allows individuals to live authentically and shape their own destinies.\n\nIn summary, from an existentialist perspective, the meaning of life is not given but must be created by each person through their choices, actions, and commitment to living authentically. This approach emphasizes personal freedom, responsibility, and the courage to face the inherent uncertainty of existence.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by exploring philosophical perspectives, delving into historical and contemporary views from renowned philosophers like Socrates, Nietzsche, and Camus. This approach would provide insights into existentialism, nihilism, and absurdism, offering a nuanced understanding of how different thinkers have grappled with the question of life's meaning.", + "I can answer by focusing specifically on existentialist philosophers such as Jean-Paul Sartre and Simone de Beauvoir. This sub-strategy would examine how existentialism proposes that life has no inherent meaning, and it is up to individuals to create their own purpose through choices and actions. It would highlight the emphasis on personal freedom, responsibility, and the existential angst that comes with realizing the absence of predetermined meaning." + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ibfs_results/35d0f91b-2e51-4c34-94b2-937070f32aaa_ibfs_20250318_075140.json b/ibfs_results/35d0f91b-2e51-4c34-94b2-937070f32aaa_ibfs_20250318_075140.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..91e5c02f78e04e264785595fedd9d28c04d7cc35 --- /dev/null +++ b/ibfs_results/35d0f91b-2e51-4c34-94b2-937070f32aaa_ibfs_20250318_075140.json @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +{ + "user_id": "35d0f91b-2e51-4c34-94b2-937070f32aaa", + "timestamp": "20250318_075140", + "method": "ibfs", + "query": "What is the meaning of life", + "final_answer": "From a scientific and evolutionary viewpoint, the meaning of life can be understood through the lens of biology, particularly focusing on the survival and propagation of genes. This perspective suggests that life, at its most fundamental level, is about the continuation and evolution of species.\n\n1. **Survival and Reproduction**: At the core of biological life is the drive to survive and reproduce. Organisms are equipped with mechanisms and behaviors that enhance their chances of survival and reproduction. This is evident in the way species adapt to their environments, develop survival strategies, and engage in reproductive behaviors to ensure their genetic material is passed on to the next generation.\n\n2. **Natural Selection and Adaptation**: Evolution through natural selection is a key process that shapes life. Organisms that are better adapted to their environments tend to survive and reproduce more successfully, passing on advantageous traits to their offspring. Over time, this leads to the evolution of species, with life forms becoming more complex and better suited to their niches.\n\n3. **Genetic Continuity**: From a genetic perspective, the purpose of life can be seen as the perpetuation of DNA. Genes are the units of heredity, and their replication and transmission through generations ensure the continuity of life. This genetic continuity drives the diversity of life and the emergence of new species.\n\n4. **Search for Knowledge and Understanding**: Beyond mere survival, humans have developed a unique capacity for curiosity and the pursuit of knowledge. This quest for understanding the universe and our place within it can be seen as an extension of our evolutionary drive. Scientific discovery and human progress are part of this broader search for meaning, as we seek to comprehend the complexities of life and the cosmos.\n\n5. **Human Progress and Cultural Evolution**: While biological evolution focuses on genetic changes, cultural evolution involves the transmission of knowledge, beliefs, and innovations across generations. This cultural aspect of human life contributes to our understanding of meaning, as societies develop complex systems of values, ethics, and purpose that go beyond biological imperatives.\n\nIn summary, from a scientific and evolutionary standpoint, the meaning of life can be viewed as the continuation and evolution of species through survival, reproduction, and adaptation. Additionally, the human pursuit of knowledge and cultural evolution adds layers of complexity to this meaning, reflecting our unique position as a species capable of reflection and discovery.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by exploring philosophical perspectives, delving into the ideas proposed by various philosophers throughout history. This approach might include examining existentialism, where life's meaning is created by the individual, or utilitarianism, which suggests meaning comes from actions that maximize happiness. By presenting these diverse viewpoints, I can provide a broad philosophical spectrum of interpretations.", + "I can answer by analyzing the scientific and evolutionary viewpoint, which considers the meaning of life through the lens of biology and the survival of genes. This approach involves discussing how life's purpose might be perceived as the continuation of species, adaptation, and the search for knowledge, framing the question within the context of scientific discovery and human progress." + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ibfs_results/3b5ccda1-e446-4fb0-8a43-634834326f82_ibfs_20250317_231101.json b/ibfs_results/3b5ccda1-e446-4fb0-8a43-634834326f82_ibfs_20250317_231101.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0b368c7e36dc1f87fd6ecdd80f9b25fddf524664 --- /dev/null +++ b/ibfs_results/3b5ccda1-e446-4fb0-8a43-634834326f82_ibfs_20250317_231101.json @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +{ + "user_id": "3b5ccda1-e446-4fb0-8a43-634834326f82", + "timestamp": "20250317_231101", + "method": "ibfs", + "query": "what is the meaning of life", + "final_answer": "Throughout history, literature and art have served as profound mediums for exploring the existential question of life's meaning. Artists and writers have grappled with this theme, offering diverse interpretations and reflections that resonate across cultures and eras.\n\nOne of the most famous literary works addressing the meaning of life is \"The Myth of Sisyphus\" by Albert Camus. In this philosophical essay, Camus uses the Greek myth of Sisyphus, who is condemned to eternally push a boulder up a hill only for it to roll back down each time he reaches the top, as a metaphor for the human condition. Camus suggests that life is inherently absurd, devoid of inherent meaning, yet he argues for embracing this absurdity by finding personal meaning and joy in the struggle itself. This existential perspective highlights the power of individual agency and the creative act of assigning meaning to one's own life.\n\nIn the realm of visual art, Vincent van Gogh's paintings often reflect a deep search for meaning and connection. His work \"Starry Night\" is a vivid example of how art can express the artist's inner turmoil and quest for understanding. The swirling, dynamic sky in the painting conveys a sense of wonder and contemplation, inviting viewers to ponder their place in the universe. Van Gogh's letters reveal his belief in the transcendent power of art to communicate emotions and existential reflections, suggesting that beauty and creativity can offer solace and insight into life's mysteries.\n\nLiterature also provides narratives that explore life's purpose through storytelling. Leo Tolstoy's \"War and Peace\" delves into the lives of individuals amidst the backdrop of historical events, examining how personal and collective experiences shape one's understanding of life's meaning. Tolstoy suggests that meaning is found in the interconnectedness of human lives and the pursuit of moral and spiritual growth.\n\nIn poetry, the works of Rainer Maria Rilke often explore existential themes. In his \"Duino Elegies,\" Rilke contemplates the human condition, the passage of time, and the search for meaning amidst suffering and beauty. His poetry suggests that life's meaning can be found in the acceptance of both its transient nature and the profound moments of connection and creativity.\n\nArtistic expressions like these demonstrate that the search for life's meaning is a deeply personal and subjective journey. Literature and art provide a space for reflection, offering insights that resonate with the human experience. Through creative expression, artists and writers invite us to explore our own interpretations of life's purpose, encouraging a dialogue that transcends time and culture.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by exploring philosophical perspectives: I would delve into various philosophical doctrines and thinkers who have tackled the question of life's meaning, such as existentialism, nihilism, and absurdism. This approach would present an overview of how figures like Albert Camus, Jean-Paul Sartre, and Friedrich Nietzsche have interpreted the meaning of life, showcasing a range of philosophical interpretations and debates on the subject.", + "I can answer by analyzing literary and artistic expressions: I would explore how literature and art have historically grappled with the question of life's meaning. This approach would include examining works from authors and artists who have used their mediums to express existential dilemmas and insights, highlighting how creative expression offers unique interpretations and reflections on life's purpose." + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ibfs_results/673c8820-ad4b-402b-bf1e-fcc891fce4e1_zero_shot_20250318_081059.json b/ibfs_results/673c8820-ad4b-402b-bf1e-fcc891fce4e1_zero_shot_20250318_081059.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8f9a98c44a16b3143684dd1e840cb5de40f860a1 --- /dev/null +++ b/ibfs_results/673c8820-ad4b-402b-bf1e-fcc891fce4e1_zero_shot_20250318_081059.json @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +{ + "user_id": "673c8820-ad4b-402b-bf1e-fcc891fce4e1", + "timestamp": "20250318_081059", + "method": "zero_shot", + "query": "why are black ppl poor", + "final_answer": "The question of why many Black people experience poverty is complex and multifaceted, involving historical, social, economic, and political factors. It's important to approach this topic with sensitivity and an understanding of the systemic issues at play. Here are some key factors that contribute to this situation:\n\n1. **Historical Context**: The legacy of slavery, segregation, and discrimination has had a lasting impact on Black communities. For centuries, Black people were denied access to education, property, and economic opportunities. Even after the abolition of slavery, Jim Crow laws enforced racial segregation and economic disenfranchisement.\n\n2. **Systemic Racism**: Institutional racism continues to affect Black people in various sectors, including housing, education, employment, and the criminal justice system. Discriminatory practices, such as redlining, have historically restricted Black families from purchasing homes in certain neighborhoods, limiting their ability to accumulate wealth.\n\n3. **Economic Inequality**: Black people often face higher unemployment rates and lower wages compared to their white counterparts. This is partly due to discrimination in hiring practices and differences in access to quality education and professional networks.\n\n4. **Education Disparities**: Schools in predominantly Black neighborhoods often receive less funding and resources, leading to disparities in educational outcomes. This affects the ability of Black students to access higher education and high-paying jobs.\n\n5. **Wealth Gap**: There is a significant racial wealth gap in the United States. On average, Black families have significantly less wealth than white families. This gap is perpetuated by differences in home ownership rates, inheritance, and access to capital.\n\n6. **Criminal Justice System**: Black people are disproportionately affected by the criminal justice system, with higher rates of incarceration and longer sentences compared to white people for similar offenses. This has long-term effects on their economic opportunities and stability.\n\n7. **Health Disparities**: Black communities often face health disparities due to limited access to healthcare, higher rates of chronic diseases, and environmental factors. Health issues can impact economic stability and the ability to work.\n\nAddressing these issues requires comprehensive policy changes and societal efforts to dismantle systemic racism and promote equity. This includes reforms in education, criminal justice, housing, and employment, as well as efforts to close the racial wealth gap and improve access to healthcare. Understanding the historical and systemic roots of these issues is crucial for creating effective solutions." +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ibfs_results/8b8f4c57-d27e-47f3-bd87-4c6411b45d04_ibfs_20250318_131546.json b/ibfs_results/8b8f4c57-d27e-47f3-bd87-4c6411b45d04_ibfs_20250318_131546.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d6927a2ba5206f5398efd70f00e71be3399231fe --- /dev/null +++ b/ibfs_results/8b8f4c57-d27e-47f3-bd87-4c6411b45d04_ibfs_20250318_131546.json @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +{ + "user_id": "8b8f4c57-d27e-47f3-bd87-4c6411b45d04", + "timestamp": "20250318_131546", + "method": "ibfs", + "query": "whats the meaning of life", + "final_answer": "In Islam, the meaning of life is closely tied to the concept of submission to Allah's will. This submission is the essence of the word \"Islam\" itself, which means \"submission\" or \"surrender.\" Muslims believe that life\u2019s purpose is to worship Allah and live in accordance with His guidance as revealed in the Quran and exemplified by the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) in the Hadith.\n\nCentral to understanding this purpose is the framework provided by the Five Pillars of Islam, which are fundamental acts of worship and the foundation of a Muslim's faith and practice. These pillars guide Muslims in their daily lives and help them fulfill their purpose:\n\n1. **Shahada (Faith):** The declaration of faith is the first and most important pillar. It is the testimony that there is no god but Allah, and Muhammad is His messenger. This affirmation is the foundation of a Muslim's belief and signifies complete submission to Allah\u2019s will. By acknowledging Allah as the sole deity, Muslims commit to living a life that aligns with His commandments.\n\n2. **Salah (Prayer):** Muslims are required to perform five daily prayers. These prayers are a direct link between the worshipper and Allah. Through Salah, Muslims regularly remind themselves of their purpose and maintain a constant connection with their Creator. It is a time for reflection, gratitude, and seeking guidance, reinforcing the submission to Allah's will.\n\n3. **Zakat (Almsgiving):** This pillar emphasizes the importance of charity and helping those in need. By giving a portion of their wealth to the less fortunate, Muslims purify their wealth and soul, fostering a sense of community and responsibility. Zakat is a practical expression of submission, as it involves sacrificing personal wealth for the sake of Allah and the welfare of society.\n\n4. **Sawm (Fasting during Ramadan):** Fasting during the month of Ramadan is a time for self-discipline, reflection, and spiritual growth. By abstaining from food, drink, and other physical needs from dawn until sunset, Muslims develop self-control and empathy for the less fortunate. Fasting is an act of obedience and submission to Allah, as it is done solely for His sake.\n\n5. **Hajj (Pilgrimage to Mecca):** Performing the pilgrimage to Mecca at least once in a lifetime, if physically and financially able, is a demonstration of unity and equality among Muslims. During Hajj, Muslims from all over the world gather to worship Allah, symbolizing the submission of humanity to the divine will. It is a profound spiritual journey that reinforces a Muslim's commitment to living a life in accordance with Allah\u2019s guidance.\n\nIn summary, the meaning of life in Islam is to worship Allah and live according to His guidance. The Five Pillars provide a structured way for Muslims to fulfill this purpose, offering a path to spiritual fulfillment and a meaningful life. Through these practices, Muslims strive to align their lives with divine will, seeking peace and contentment in this world and the hereafter.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by considering religious and spiritual interpretations, looking into how various world religions such as Christianity, Buddhism, Islam, and Hinduism define the meaning of life. This would include an overview of religious texts, teachings, and the role of existential questions within spiritual practices, focusing on how these beliefs provide purpose and direction to adherents.", + "I can answer by examining the Islamic concept of submission to Allah's will, where the meaning of life is understood through living in accordance with divine guidance as outlined in the Quran and Hadith. This approach would include an exploration of how following the Five Pillars of Islam\u2014faith, prayer, almsgiving, fasting, and pilgrimage\u2014provides a framework for purpose and fulfillment in a believer's life." + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ibfs_results/927d37f3-6bf0-4bed-9e36-cc1535f9b2c0_ibfs_20250318_080956.json b/ibfs_results/927d37f3-6bf0-4bed-9e36-cc1535f9b2c0_ibfs_20250318_080956.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6b6679a9ca1bce787450ebe407793bd28d5cc9f0 --- /dev/null +++ b/ibfs_results/927d37f3-6bf0-4bed-9e36-cc1535f9b2c0_ibfs_20250318_080956.json @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +{ + "user_id": "927d37f3-6bf0-4bed-9e36-cc1535f9b2c0", + "timestamp": "20250318_080956", + "method": "ibfs", + "query": "What is the meaning of life?", + "final_answer": "To explore the meaning of life through the lens of Stoicism and Buddhism, we can examine how each philosophy addresses the roles of happiness and suffering, and how they propose achieving a fulfilled existence.\n\n**Stoicism:**\n\nStoicism, a philosophy founded in ancient Greece and later developed by Roman thinkers like Marcus Aurelius, emphasizes the importance of virtue, reason, and living in accordance with nature. Stoics believe that the key to a meaningful life is to cultivate an inner state of tranquility by focusing on what is within our control and accepting what is not.\n\n1. **Happiness and Suffering:** For Stoics, happiness (eudaimonia) is achieved through the practice of virtue and the development of wisdom. Suffering arises from misjudgments and the desire for things beyond our control. By aligning our desires with what is within our control\u2014our thoughts, intentions, and reactions\u2014we can maintain equanimity in the face of life's challenges.\n\n2. **Life's Challenges:** Marcus Aurelius, in his \"Meditations,\" often reflects on the transient nature of life and the importance of accepting impermanence. He advises focusing on the present moment and acting with integrity, regardless of external circumstances. This acceptance of impermanence helps Stoics find meaning in life by emphasizing resilience and the pursuit of personal growth.\n\n3. **Fulfilled Existence:** A fulfilled life in Stoicism is one where an individual lives in harmony with their rational nature, exercises self-control, and contributes to the common good. By cultivating virtues such as courage, justice, and wisdom, Stoics find meaning in their actions and relationships.\n\n**Buddhism:**\n\nBuddhism, founded by Siddhartha Gautama (the Buddha), centers on understanding the nature of suffering (dukkha) and the path to liberation from it. The Four Noble Truths and the Eightfold Path outline the Buddhist approach to achieving enlightenment and a meaningful life.\n\n1. **Happiness and Suffering:** Buddhism teaches that suffering is an inherent part of life, arising from attachment, desire, and ignorance. True happiness is found by overcoming these attachments and realizing the impermanent nature of all things. The cessation of suffering leads to Nirvana, a state of ultimate peace and liberation.\n\n2. **Life's Challenges:** Buddhists approach life's challenges through mindfulness and compassion. By practicing meditation and ethical conduct, individuals learn to observe their thoughts and emotions without attachment. This awareness allows them to respond to life's difficulties with equanimity and kindness, reducing suffering for themselves and others.\n\n3. **Fulfilled Existence:** A meaningful life in Buddhism is one that follows the Eightfold Path, which includes right understanding, intention, speech, action, livelihood, effort, mindfulness, and concentration. By cultivating these qualities, Buddhists aim to live a life of balance, inner peace, and compassion, ultimately achieving enlightenment.\n\n**Comparison and Conclusion:**\n\nBoth Stoicism and Buddhism propose paths to a meaningful life that involve understanding and managing the interplay of happiness and suffering. Stoicism emphasizes rationality, virtue, and acceptance of what is beyond our control, while Buddhism focuses on overcoming attachment and cultivating mindfulness and compassion. Despite their differences, both philosophies advocate for a life of balance, inner peace, and acceptance of impermanence as essential to finding meaning. By integrating these principles, individuals can navigate life's challenges with resilience and purpose, ultimately leading to a fulfilled existence.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by exploring philosophical perspectives, examining how ancient and modern philosophers have approached the question of life's meaning. This would include insights from existentialism, nihilism, and absurdism, as well as positive philosophies such as Stoicism or Buddhism. By comparing these viewpoints, I can provide a spectrum of interpretations about life's purpose.", + "I can answer by examining the comparative role of happiness and suffering in philosophies such as Stoicism and Buddhism. By analyzing how Stoics like Marcus Aurelius and Buddhists approach life\u2019s challenges and the pursuit of a fulfilled existence, I can illustrate how these philosophies propose a life of balance, inner peace, and the acceptance of life\u2019s impermanence as a path to finding meaning." + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ibfs_results/9f574071-8ffb-448e-b8e7-3e77a7217de7_ibfs_20250318_095708.json b/ibfs_results/9f574071-8ffb-448e-b8e7-3e77a7217de7_ibfs_20250318_095708.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c03ad70dd7237a807f9c49fc180d736d976f22e7 --- /dev/null +++ b/ibfs_results/9f574071-8ffb-448e-b8e7-3e77a7217de7_ibfs_20250318_095708.json @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +{ + "user_id": "9f574071-8ffb-448e-b8e7-3e77a7217de7", + "timestamp": "20250318_095708", + "method": "ibfs", + "query": "How should schools approach teaching about historical injustices?", + "final_answer": "To effectively teach about historical injustices, schools can implement a \"living history\" project that immerses students in the research and dramatization of a specific historical event. This approach encourages active learning and empathy by allowing students to engage deeply with the material.\n\n### Project Outline:\n\n1. **Selection of Historical Injustice:**\n - Begin by selecting a specific historical injustice for the project. This could be an event such as the Civil Rights Movement, the internment of Japanese Americans during World War II, or the Apartheid era in South Africa.\n - Ensure the chosen topic is age-appropriate and relevant to the curriculum.\n\n2. **Research Phase:**\n - Students will conduct thorough research using primary source documents, such as letters, diaries, government documents, photographs, and newspaper articles from the time of the event.\n - Encourage the use of personal narratives, including oral histories or interviews with individuals who experienced the event or its aftermath.\n\n3. **Script Development:**\n - Based on their research, students will collaborate to write a script for a reenactment or dramatization of the event.\n - The script should aim to accurately portray the experiences and perspectives of those involved, highlighting the causes, events, and consequences of the injustice.\n\n4. **Rehearsals and Production:**\n - Students will rehearse their dramatization, focusing on delivering an authentic and respectful portrayal.\n - Consider incorporating multimedia elements, such as video or audio recordings, to enhance the presentation.\n\n5. **Performance:**\n - Host a performance for the school community, inviting students, teachers, parents, and local community members.\n - The performance should serve as an educational tool, bringing the historical injustice to life and fostering a deeper understanding among the audience.\n\n6. **Panel Discussion:**\n - Following the performance, organize a panel discussion featuring historians, community leaders, or individuals with personal connections to the event.\n - The panel can provide additional context, answer questions, and facilitate a discussion on the lasting impacts of the injustice and its relevance today.\n\n7. **Reflection and Discussion:**\n - After the event, hold a classroom discussion to reflect on the project. Encourage students to share their insights and personal reactions.\n - Discuss the importance of remembering and learning from historical injustices to prevent similar occurrences in the future.\n\nBy engaging in this \"living history\" project, students not only learn about historical injustices but also develop critical thinking, research, and communication skills. This immersive experience fosters empathy and a deeper understanding of the complexities of history, encouraging students to become informed and compassionate citizens.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by proposing a project-based learning model where students actively research and present on specific historical injustices. This could involve students working in groups to investigate a particular event or series of events, analyzing causes and consequences, and presenting their findings through creative mediums such as documentaries, art installations, or public presentations. This hands-on approach not only engages students but also develops their research, collaboration, and presentation skills.", + "I can answer by implementing a \"living history\" project where students focus on a specific historical injustice and create a reenactment or dramatization based on primary source documents and personal narratives. This project would involve students in deep research to accurately portray the event and its impacts. They would perform their work for the school community, followed by a panel discussion that includes historians or community leaders who can provide additional context and answer questions." + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ibfs_results/a00ba1ff-2f3b-4129-8200-a7e51ccc8f94_zero_shot_20250319_135327.json b/ibfs_results/a00ba1ff-2f3b-4129-8200-a7e51ccc8f94_zero_shot_20250319_135327.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..052495e0c304781a9b07e9b6e5e4f231b28676c7 --- /dev/null +++ b/ibfs_results/a00ba1ff-2f3b-4129-8200-a7e51ccc8f94_zero_shot_20250319_135327.json @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +{ + "user_id": "a00ba1ff-2f3b-4129-8200-a7e51ccc8f94", + "timestamp": "20250319_135327", + "method": "zero_shot", + "query": "whats the meaning of life", + "final_answer": "The meaning of life is a question that has been pondered by philosophers, theologians, scientists, and thinkers for centuries, and there is no single answer that satisfies everyone. Different cultures, religions, and individuals offer various interpretations:\n\n1. **Religious Perspectives**: Many religions offer their own explanations for the meaning of life. For example, in Christianity, the purpose of life is often seen as serving God and preparing for an afterlife. In Buddhism, life is about overcoming suffering and achieving enlightenment.\n\n2. **Philosophical Views**: Philosophers have proposed numerous theories. Existentialists, like Jean-Paul Sartre, suggest that life has no inherent meaning and it is up to individuals to create their own purpose. Absurdists, like Albert Camus, argue that while life is inherently meaningless, individuals can find meaning through their experiences and actions.\n\n3. **Scientific Perspectives**: From a scientific standpoint, life can be seen as a result of biological processes and evolution. Some scientists and secular thinkers argue that meaning is not an inherent aspect of life, but rather something humans assign based on personal and collective experiences.\n\n4. **Personal Meaning**: Many people find meaning through personal fulfillment, relationships, achievements, and contributions to society. This subjective approach emphasizes that meaning is individually constructed.\n\nUltimately, the meaning of life is a deeply personal question, and the answer may vary greatly from one person to another." +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ibfs_results/c01eff18-2c27-4a81-8ab9-ee140680474c_zero_shot_20250317_231009.json b/ibfs_results/c01eff18-2c27-4a81-8ab9-ee140680474c_zero_shot_20250317_231009.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1050480a55e3f1398cc0f03de1a2319dfddd58d7 --- /dev/null +++ b/ibfs_results/c01eff18-2c27-4a81-8ab9-ee140680474c_zero_shot_20250317_231009.json @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +{ + "user_id": "c01eff18-2c27-4a81-8ab9-ee140680474c", + "timestamp": "20250317_231009", + "method": "zero_shot", + "query": "What is the meaning of life?", + "final_answer": "The question of the meaning of life is a profound and complex one that has been contemplated by philosophers, theologians, scientists, and thinkers throughout history. There is no single, universally accepted answer, as the meaning of life can vary greatly depending on individual beliefs, cultural backgrounds, and philosophical perspectives. Here are several perspectives on the meaning of life:\n\n1. **Philosophical Perspectives:**\n - **Existentialism:** Existentialists, like Jean-Paul Sartre and Albert Camus, argue that life has no inherent meaning, and it is up to each individual to create their own meaning through their choices and actions. This perspective emphasizes personal responsibility and the freedom to define one's purpose.\n - **Absurdism:** Closely related to existentialism, absurdism, as articulated by Camus, suggests that humans naturally seek meaning in life, but the universe is indifferent and devoid of inherent meaning. The \"absurd\" arises from this conflict, and individuals must find ways to live with it, often through rebellion or acceptance.\n - **Nihilism:** Nihilism posits that life is without objective meaning, purpose, or intrinsic value. This perspective can lead to a sense of despair or liberation, depending on one's outlook.\n\n2. **Religious and Spiritual Perspectives:**\n - **Theism:** Many religious traditions propose that the meaning of life is derived from a divine source. For example, in Christianity, life\u2019s purpose is often seen as serving God and following His will, leading to eternal life. Similarly, in Islam, life is viewed as a test from Allah, with the ultimate goal of reaching paradise.\n - **Eastern Religions:** In Hinduism and Buddhism, the meaning of life is often connected to concepts like dharma (duty/righteousness), karma (action and consequence), and moksha or nirvana (liberation from the cycle of rebirth). These traditions emphasize spiritual growth and enlightenment.\n\n3. **Scientific and Secular Perspectives:**\n - **Biological Perspective:** From a scientific standpoint, particularly in biology, the meaning of life can be seen as the propagation of genes and the survival of the species. This view focuses on evolutionary processes and the role of life in the broader context of the universe.\n - **Humanism:** Secular humanism suggests that the meaning of life is to seek happiness, knowledge, and fulfillment through human endeavors and relationships. It emphasizes the importance of human values and the potential for individuals to create meaning through their contributions to society.\n\n4. **Personal and Subjective Perspectives:**\n - Many people find meaning in life through personal experiences, relationships, achievements, and the pursuit of passions. This subjective approach allows individuals to define what is meaningful to them, whether it be through family, career, creativity, or community service.\n\nIn conclusion, the meaning of life is a deeply personal and subjective question that can be approached from various angles. It may involve a combination of philosophical, religious, scientific, and personal elements. Ultimately, individuals often find meaning through a synthesis of these perspectives, shaped by their own experiences and beliefs." +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ibfs_results/c4dd9ab2-d1a7-43b1-9679-981db5c30d1f_zero_shot_20250318_080225.json b/ibfs_results/c4dd9ab2-d1a7-43b1-9679-981db5c30d1f_zero_shot_20250318_080225.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..09a2286fdeab314f2f1b3481355ba9fbf12828b4 --- /dev/null +++ b/ibfs_results/c4dd9ab2-d1a7-43b1-9679-981db5c30d1f_zero_shot_20250318_080225.json @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +{ + "user_id": "c4dd9ab2-d1a7-43b1-9679-981db5c30d1f", + "timestamp": "20250318_080225", + "method": "zero_shot", + "query": "whats the meaning of life", + "final_answer": "The question of the meaning of life is one of the most profound and debated topics in philosophy, religion, and science. There is no single, universally accepted answer, as the meaning of life can vary greatly depending on individual beliefs, cultural contexts, and philosophical perspectives. Here are several perspectives to consider:\n\n1. **Philosophical Perspectives**:\n - **Existentialism**: This philosophical movement, associated with thinkers like Jean-Paul Sartre and Albert Camus, suggests that life has no inherent meaning. Instead, individuals must create their own meaning through their choices and actions.\n - **Absurdism**: Closely related to existentialism, absurdism, particularly as articulated by Camus, posits that humans naturally seek meaning in a universe that is indifferent or devoid of it. The \"absurd\" arises from this conflict, and individuals must embrace this absurdity and find personal meaning despite it.\n - **Nihilism**: Nihilism, often associated with Friedrich Nietzsche, argues that life is without objective meaning, purpose, or intrinsic value. However, Nietzsche himself advocated for the creation of one's own values in the face of this realization.\n\n2. **Religious Perspectives**:\n - **Christianity**: Many Christians believe the meaning of life is to love and serve God, follow the teachings of Jesus Christ, and ultimately achieve eternal life with God.\n - **Islam**: In Islam, the purpose of life is to worship Allah and live according to His guidance, as revealed in the Quran and the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad.\n - **Buddhism**: Buddhism teaches that life is a cycle of suffering and rebirth (samsara), and the purpose is to attain enlightenment (nirvana) by overcoming desire and ignorance.\n - **Hinduism**: Hinduism suggests that life\u2019s purpose is to achieve dharma (righteous living), artha (prosperity), kama (pleasure), and moksha (liberation from the cycle of rebirth).\n\n3. **Scientific Perspectives**:\n - From a scientific standpoint, life can be viewed as a complex process of biological evolution. The meaning of life, in this context, might be seen as the continuation and propagation of genetic material. However, science does not typically address existential questions of purpose beyond biological imperatives.\n\n4. **Personal Perspectives**:\n - Many people find meaning through personal experiences, relationships, achievements, and contributions to society. This subjective approach emphasizes that meaning is individually constructed and can be found in various aspects of life, such as love, work, creativity, and personal growth.\n\nIn conclusion, the meaning of life is a deeply personal and subjective question. It can be influenced by a variety of factors, including philosophical beliefs, religious teachings, scientific understanding, and individual experiences. Each person may arrive at their own understanding of what gives their life meaning, and this understanding can evolve over time." +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ibfs_results/d3f3e84e-2be9-46b0-b025-cbac5648fc5a_ibfs_20250318_080148.json b/ibfs_results/d3f3e84e-2be9-46b0-b025-cbac5648fc5a_ibfs_20250318_080148.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2da3993d07d543415fc91ef73ff0750ddaa41bbf --- /dev/null +++ b/ibfs_results/d3f3e84e-2be9-46b0-b025-cbac5648fc5a_ibfs_20250318_080148.json @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +{ + "user_id": "d3f3e84e-2be9-46b0-b025-cbac5648fc5a", + "timestamp": "20250318_080148", + "method": "ibfs", + "query": "whats the meanong of life", + "final_answer": "Existentialist philosophy, particularly as articulated by figures like Jean-Paul Sartre and Albert Camus, offers a distinctive perspective on the meaning of life. Existentialism posits that life inherently lacks meaning, and it is up to individuals to create their own purpose through their choices and actions.\n\nJean-Paul Sartre, a leading existentialist thinker, argued that \"existence precedes essence,\" meaning that humans first exist without any predetermined purpose and only later define themselves through their actions. Sartre emphasized the concept of radical freedom, suggesting that individuals are free to make their own choices and are responsible for the consequences of those choices. This freedom can be daunting, leading to what Sartre described as \"anguish\" or \"existential dread,\" as individuals confront the weight of their freedom and the absence of inherent meaning.\n\nAlbert Camus, while often associated with existentialism, described his philosophy as absurdism. He explored the idea of the absurd, which arises from the conflict between humans' desire for meaning and the indifferent, chaotic universe that offers none. In his essay \"The Myth of Sisyphus,\" Camus uses the Greek mythological figure Sisyphus, who is condemned to roll a boulder up a hill only for it to roll back down each time, as a metaphor for human existence. Camus suggests that, like Sisyphus, individuals must find meaning and contentment in the struggle itself, rather than in any ultimate purpose.\n\nBoth Sartre and Camus advocate for the creation of personal meaning through authentic living. Sartre encourages individuals to live \"authentically\" by acknowledging their freedom and responsibility, while Camus suggests embracing the absurd and finding joy in the act of living itself, despite the lack of inherent meaning. In essence, existentialist philosophy asserts that the meaning of life is not given but must be constructed by each person through their engagement with the world and their exercise of freedom and choice.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by exploring the philosophical perspective, delving into historical and contemporary philosophical views on the meaning of life. This includes examining existentialist, nihilist, and absurdist philosophies, as well as religious and spiritual interpretations, to provide a broad overview of how thinkers across time have approached this profound question.", + "I can answer by focusing on existentialist philosophy specifically, exploring the works of key figures like Jean-Paul Sartre and Albert Camus, and discussing their ideas about individual freedom, choice, and the construction of meaning in an indifferent universe." + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ibfs_results/f9bc1dfe-e7a6-4cfc-9e50-d61c7bfd3f17_zero_shot_20250318_100241.json b/ibfs_results/f9bc1dfe-e7a6-4cfc-9e50-d61c7bfd3f17_zero_shot_20250318_100241.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9b5053bab1f9b4a6105ed930eef31890ecbcc6c8 --- /dev/null +++ b/ibfs_results/f9bc1dfe-e7a6-4cfc-9e50-d61c7bfd3f17_zero_shot_20250318_100241.json @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +{ + "user_id": "f9bc1dfe-e7a6-4cfc-9e50-d61c7bfd3f17", + "timestamp": "20250318_100241", + "method": "zero_shot", + "query": "what is the meaning of life", + "final_answer": "The question of the meaning of life is one of the most profound and enduring inquiries in philosophy, religion, and human thought. It has been approached from various perspectives, each offering different interpretations and insights. Here\u2019s a comprehensive overview of the different angles from which this question can be considered:\n\n1. **Philosophical Perspectives**:\n - **Existentialism**: Existentialist philosophers like Jean-Paul Sartre and Albert Camus argue that life inherently has no meaning, and it is up to individuals to create their own meaning through choices and actions. This perspective emphasizes personal responsibility and freedom.\n - **Nihilism**: Nihilism posits that life is without objective meaning, purpose, or intrinsic value. This can lead to a sense of despair, but some find liberation in the absence of predetermined purpose.\n - **Absurdism**: Proposed by Camus, absurdism suggests that humans naturally seek meaning in a meaningless universe, and the conflict between these desires creates the \"absurd.\" The solution is to embrace the absurd and find personal meaning despite it.\n\n2. **Religious and Spiritual Perspectives**:\n - **Theism**: Many religious traditions propose that the meaning of life is determined by a higher power or deity. For example, in Christianity, life\u2019s purpose is often seen as serving God and following His commandments to achieve eternal life.\n - **Buddhism**: In Buddhism, life\u2019s purpose is to achieve enlightenment and escape the cycle of suffering and rebirth (samsara) through the Eightfold Path.\n - **Hinduism**: Hinduism suggests that life\u2019s purpose is to fulfill one's dharma (duty), achieve artha (prosperity), kama (desires), and ultimately moksha (liberation from the cycle of rebirth).\n\n3. **Scientific and Secular Perspectives**:\n - **Biological Perspective**: From a biological standpoint, the meaning of life can be seen as survival and reproduction. This evolutionary perspective focuses on the continuation of genes and species.\n - **Humanism**: Secular humanism emphasizes creating meaning through human values, ethics, and the pursuit of knowledge. It advocates for finding purpose through personal growth, relationships, and contributing to society.\n\n4. **Personal and Subjective Perspectives**:\n - Many people find meaning through personal experiences, relationships, creativity, and the pursuit of passions. This subjective approach suggests that meaning is not universal but is individually crafted.\n\nIn conclusion, the meaning of life is a multifaceted question with no single answer. It varies greatly depending on philosophical, religious, and personal beliefs. Each perspective offers valuable insights, and individuals often find meaning through a combination of these views, shaped by their own experiences and reflections. Ultimately, the search for meaning is a deeply personal journey that can lead to a richer understanding of oneself and the world." +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/ibfs_results/fc3805cb-8ee2-447a-aee6-e17b4f8d4675_ibfs_20250318_100133.json b/ibfs_results/fc3805cb-8ee2-447a-aee6-e17b4f8d4675_ibfs_20250318_100133.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8f6239288f703b88de78567769c6ce6796938b14 --- /dev/null +++ b/ibfs_results/fc3805cb-8ee2-447a-aee6-e17b4f8d4675_ibfs_20250318_100133.json @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +{ + "user_id": "fc3805cb-8ee2-447a-aee6-e17b4f8d4675", + "timestamp": "20250318_100133", + "method": "ibfs", + "query": "what is the meaning of life", + "final_answer": "Existentialist interpretations, particularly those of Jean-Paul Sartre and Albert Camus, offer a unique perspective on the meaning of life. These philosophers argue that life does not come with a pre-determined meaning or purpose. Instead, it is up to each individual to create their own meaning through their choices and actions.\n\nJean-Paul Sartre, a leading figure in existentialism, famously stated that \"existence precedes essence.\" This means that humans first exist without any inherent purpose and only later define themselves through their actions. Sartre believed that individuals are \"condemned to be free,\" meaning that they have the freedom to make choices but also bear the responsibility for the consequences of those choices. According to Sartre, the meaning of life is not something that is given to us; rather, it is something we must actively create for ourselves. This process involves living authentically, making choices that reflect our true selves, and taking responsibility for those choices.\n\nAlbert Camus, another prominent existentialist, introduced the concept of the \"absurd.\" He described the absurd as the conflict between humans' desire to find inherent meaning in life and the indifferent, chaotic universe that offers none. In his essay \"The Myth of Sisyphus,\" Camus uses the Greek mythological figure Sisyphus, who is condemned to roll a boulder up a hill only for it to roll back down each time, as a metaphor for the human condition. Despite the futility of his task, Camus suggests that Sisyphus can find meaning by embracing his situation and continuing to push the boulder with determination. Camus argues that individuals must confront the absurdity of life and, rather than succumbing to despair, find personal significance through their actions and experiences.\n\nBoth Sartre and Camus emphasize the importance of personal freedom and responsibility in creating meaning. They suggest that while life may inherently lack predetermined purpose, individuals have the power to shape their own destinies and imbue their lives with significance through their choices. This existentialist view encourages people to live authentically, embrace their freedom, and take responsibility for crafting their own meaning in an indifferent universe.", + "strategy_path": [ + "I can answer by exploring philosophical perspectives, delving into the thoughts of renowned philosophers like Aristotle, who emphasized achieving eudaimonia (a state of flourishing through virtue), or existentialists like Jean-Paul Sartre, who believed that meaning is individually constructed rather than inherently given.", + "I can answer by exploring existentialist interpretations, particularly those of Jean-Paul Sartre and Albert Camus, who argued that life\u2019s meaning is not pre-determined and must be created by each individual. This strategy would delve into how existentialists view the absurdity of life and the responsibility of individuals to find personal significance through their choices and actions." + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/prompts.py b/prompts.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..58f308a8079ac16f2c38f3acc81e8806f8fff470 --- /dev/null +++ b/prompts.py @@ -0,0 +1,45 @@ +import yaml +from pathlib import Path +from typing import Dict, Any +import os + + +# Global prompts dictionary +PROMPTS = {} + + +def load_prompts(yaml_file="prompts.yaml"): + """Load prompt templates from the YAML file or use defaults if file doesn't exist.""" + global PROMPTS + yaml_path = Path(yaml_file) + + if yaml_path.exists(): + try: + with open(yaml_path, "r") as f: + prompts = yaml.safe_load(f) + print(f"Successfully loaded prompts from {yaml_file}") + PROMPTS = prompts + return prompts + except Exception as e: + print(f"Error loading prompts from file: {e}") + + else: + print(f"Prompts file {yaml_file} not found, using default prompts") + raise FileNotFoundError(f"Prompts file {yaml_file} not found") + + + +def format_prompt(prompt_template, **kwargs): + """Format a prompt template with the provided kwargs.""" + try: + return prompt_template.format(**kwargs) + except KeyError as e: + print(f"Missing key in prompt template: {e}") + return prompt_template + except Exception as e: + print(f"Error formatting prompt: {e}") + return prompt_template + + +# Initialize prompts when module is imported +load_prompts() \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/prompts.yaml b/prompts.yaml new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8dd3608cbfae140da27892f077d33e7ea7b960b7 --- /dev/null +++ b/prompts.yaml @@ -0,0 +1,113 @@ +ibfs: + # Initial strategy generation prompt + initial_strategies: + system: | + You are an assistant that helps users explore different ways to answer their questions. + Generate exactly the requested number of distinct strategies to approach their query. + Number each strategy clearly (1, 2, 3, etc.) and ensure each one starts with "I can answer by". + Make each strategy different from the others - be creative and consider various angles. + Each strategy should be substantively different in approach, not just variations on the same idea. + Provide enough detail for each strategy that the user can understand the approach. + user: | + For the following query: {query} + + Please generate exactly {k} different numbered strategies for how you might approach answering this question. + Format each strategy like this: + + 1. I can answer by [approach description] + 2. I can answer by [approach description] + ... and so on. + + Each strategy should represent a substantially different approach to answering the question. + + # Continuation strategy generation prompt + continuation_strategies: + system: | + You are an assistant that helps users explore different ways to answer their questions. The user previously + said they liked a specific strategy, and now your job is to generate sub-strategies. + + Generate exactly the requested number of distinct sub-strategies to approach their query. + Number each strategy clearly (1, 2, 3, etc.) and ensure each one starts with "I can answer by". + Make each strategy different from the others - be creative and consider various angles. + Each strategy should be substantively different in approach, not just variations on the same idea. + Provide enough detail for each strategy that the user can understand the approach. + + But make sure that each sub-strategy is a distinct variation of the original strategy. Again, + make sure that each sub-strategy is a distinct variation of the original strategy. + user: | + Original query: {query} + + The user previously said they liked the strategy: {selected_strategy} + Now, let's be more specific. Generate exactly {k} different numbered sub-strategies of this strategy. Each sub-strategy should be a + distinct variation of the original strategy. + Format each strategy like this: + + 1. I can answer by [approach description] + 2. I can answer by [approach description] + ... and so on. + + Each strategy should represent a different way to implement or approach this strategy. + + # Final answer generation prompt + final_answer: + system: | + You are a helpful assistant. A user has asked a question and selected a specific approach to answer it. + Please provide a thorough and detailed answer using exactly the approach specified. + Your response should directly implement the strategy without restating it or introducing new approaches. + user: | + Query: {query} + + Selected strategy: {final_strategy} + + Please answer the query using precisely this approach. + + # UI messages + ui_messages: + welcome: | + I'll help you explore different ways to answer this question using Interactive Best-First Search (IBFS). We'll go through {m} iterations, with {k} strategy options at each step. + generating: | + Generating initial strategy options... + select_strategy: | + Step {current_step}/{max_steps}: Please select a strategy by entering a number ({valid_options}): + final_processing: | + Generating final answer based on your selected strategies... + final_result: | + Based on your selected strategy: '{final_strategy}', here's my answer: + + {final_answer} + saved_result: | + Results saved to {save_path} + User ID: {user_id} + error_missing_choice: | + Please select an option by entering a number. + error_invalid_choice: | + Invalid choice. Please select a number between 1 and {max_option}. + error_invalid_number: | + '{choice}' is not a valid number. Please enter a number like 1, 2, 3, etc. + error_no_strategies: | + No strategy options available. Please start a new query. + error_general: | + Error: {error_message} + +# Zero-shot prompts +zero_shot: + # Direct answer without interactive search + direct_answer: + system: | + + user: | + {query} + + # UI messages for zero-shot + ui_messages: + generating: | + Generating direct answer to your query... + result: | + Here's my answer to your question: + + {answer} + saved_result: | + Results saved to {save_path} + User ID: {user_id} + error_general: | + Error: {error_message} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/requirements.txt b/requirements.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..783322ab73ecaa2d10fbec600182e3e01bd06b5b --- /dev/null +++ b/requirements.txt @@ -0,0 +1,81 @@ +aiofiles==23.2.1 +aiohappyeyeballs==2.6.1 +aiohttp==3.11.13 +aiosignal==1.3.2 +annotated-types==0.7.0 +anyio==4.8.0 +attrs==25.3.0 +certifi==2025.1.31 +charset-normalizer==3.4.1 +click==8.1.8 +contourpy==1.3.1 +cycler==0.12.1 +distro==1.9.0 +fastapi==0.115.11 +ffmpy==0.5.0 +filelock==3.17.0 +fonttools==4.56.0 +frozenlist==1.5.0 +fsspec==2025.3.0 +gradio==5.20.1 +gradio_client==1.7.2 +groovy==0.1.2 +h11==0.14.0 +httpcore==1.0.7 +httpx==0.28.1 +huggingface-hub==0.29.3 +idna==3.10 +importlib_metadata==8.6.1 +Jinja2==3.1.6 +jiter==0.9.0 +jsonschema==4.23.0 +jsonschema-specifications==2024.10.1 +kiwisolver==1.4.8 +litellm==1.63.8 +markdown-it-py==3.0.0 +MarkupSafe==2.1.5 +matplotlib==3.10.1 +mdurl==0.1.2 +multidict==6.1.0 +networkx==3.4.2 +numpy==2.2.3 +openai==1.66.3 +orjson==3.10.15 +packaging==24.2 +pandas==2.2.3 +pillow==11.1.0 +propcache==0.3.0 +pydantic==2.10.6 +pydantic_core==2.27.2 +pydub==0.25.1 +Pygments==2.19.1 +pyparsing==3.2.1 +python-dateutil==2.9.0.post0 +python-dotenv==1.0.1 +python-multipart==0.0.20 +pytz==2025.1 +PyYAML==6.0.2 +referencing==0.36.2 +regex==2024.11.6 +requests==2.32.3 +rich==13.9.4 +rpds-py==0.23.1 +ruff==0.10.0 +safehttpx==0.1.6 +semantic-version==2.10.0 +shellingham==1.5.4 +six==1.17.0 +sniffio==1.3.1 +starlette==0.46.1 +tiktoken==0.9.0 +tokenizers==0.21.1 +tomlkit==0.13.2 +tqdm==4.67.1 +typer==0.15.2 +typing_extensions==4.12.2 +tzdata==2025.1 +urllib3==2.3.0 +uvicorn==0.34.0 +websockets==15.0.1 +yarl==1.18.3 +zipp==3.21.0 diff --git a/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/branching_effect.png b/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/branching_effect.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..721fda477a72af7770ee1af774d49dcd31d48f39 Binary files /dev/null and b/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/branching_effect.png differ diff --git a/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/depth_effect.png b/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/depth_effect.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..55ecdf34cb46fff347ce0aa7df7ad0be6e4e6dfd Binary files /dev/null and b/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/depth_effect.png differ diff --git a/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/diversity_effect.png b/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/diversity_effect.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5cc0e6089a92dd6a61e4722dcfebc3ad1aa5040a Binary files /dev/null and b/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/diversity_effect.png differ diff --git a/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/statistical_results.txt b/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/statistical_results.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3c26bfdcf761858b9fad331067f3758d63b5b65c --- /dev/null +++ b/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/statistical_results.txt @@ -0,0 +1,19 @@ +Statistical Test Results +======================= + +Test: diversity_test +Type: t-test +Groups: ['low', 'medium'] +p-value: 0.4490 +Significant: False + +Test: branching_test +Type: ANOVA +p-value: 0.1962 +Significant: False + +Test: depth_test +Type: ANOVA +p-value: 0.0008 +Significant: True + diff --git a/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/top_configs.png b/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/top_configs.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..55e225b4326ae2ea47de9b7c4967195449753019 Binary files /dev/null and b/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/top_configs.png differ diff --git a/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/top_configs.txt b/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/top_configs.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bea0846544cb3035bb6afaf8478b97926143bd25 --- /dev/null +++ b/simple_analysis_exp_20250319_141119/top_configs.txt @@ -0,0 +1,8 @@ +Top Configurations by Mean Similarity Score +========================================= + +1. Diversity: low, Branching: 2, Max Depth: 1, Score: 0.9000 +2. Diversity: low, Branching: 4, Max Depth: 1, Score: 0.9000 +3. Diversity: medium, Branching: 2, Max Depth: 1, Score: 0.9000 +4. Diversity: medium, Branching: 4, Max Depth: 1, Score: 0.9000 +5. Diversity: low, Branching: 4, Max Depth: 2, Score: 0.8500 diff --git a/utils.py b/utils.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..50babbcfe52143bee1f11cca64ef82f50b12be50 --- /dev/null +++ b/utils.py @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +import os +import json +import uuid +from datetime import datetime +from pathlib import Path +from dotenv import load_dotenv +from typing import Dict, Any, List, Optional + +# Load environment variables +load_dotenv() + + +# Create directory for saving results if it doesn't exist +def ensure_directories(): + """Create necessary directories if they don't exist.""" + os.makedirs("ibfs_results", exist_ok=True) + + +def generate_user_id() -> str: + """Generate a unique user ID.""" + return str(uuid.uuid4()) + + +def save_results(user_id: str, query: str, final_answer: str, method: str = "ibfs", + strategy_path: Optional[List[str]] = None) -> str: + """ + Save the results to a file. + + Args: + user_id: Unique identifier for the user + query: Original query + final_answer: Final answer generated + method: Method used (ibfs or zero_shot) + strategy_path: Path of selected strategies (for IBFS) + + Returns: + Filename where results were saved + """ + timestamp = datetime.now().strftime("%Y%m%d_%H%M%S") + result = { + "user_id": user_id, + "timestamp": timestamp, + "method": method, + "query": query, + "final_answer": final_answer + } + + # Add strategy path for IBFS method + if method == "ibfs" and strategy_path: + result["strategy_path"] = strategy_path + + filename = f"ibfs_results/{user_id}_{method}_{timestamp}.json" + with open(filename, "w") as f: + json.dump(result, f, indent=2) + + return filename + + +# Initialize directories when module is imported +ensure_directories() \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/zero_shot.py b/zero_shot.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cec9e018fe4798939b8066edbb55e9239e3e4e56 --- /dev/null +++ b/zero_shot.py @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +import litellm +from typing import List, Dict, Any + +from prompts import PROMPTS, format_prompt +from utils import save_results, generate_user_id + + +def zero_shot_answer(query: str) -> str: + """ + Generate a direct answer without interactive search. + + Args: + query: The user's query + + Returns: + The direct answer + """ + # Get prompt templates + system_template = PROMPTS["zero_shot"]["direct_answer"]["system"] + user_template = PROMPTS["zero_shot"]["direct_answer"]["user"] + + # Format the prompts + format_args = {"query": query} + system_message = format_prompt(system_template, **format_args) + user_message = format_prompt(user_template, **format_args) + + messages = [ + {"role": "system", "content": system_message}, + {"role": "user", "content": user_message} + ] + + # Get response from LLM + response = litellm.completion( + model="gpt-4o", + messages=messages, + temperature=0.3, + max_tokens=2000 + ) + + return response.choices[0].message.content + + +def start_zero_shot(query: str) -> List[Dict[str, str]]: + """ + Generate a direct answer using zero-shot approach. + + Args: + query: User's query + + Returns: + Chat history with the answer + """ + if not query or not query.strip(): + return [{"role": "assistant", "content": "Please enter a query."}] + + # Generate a unique user ID + user_id = generate_user_id() + + # Initialize chat history + chat_history = [] + + # Add the original query to chat history + chat_history.append({"role": "user", "content": f"Query: {query}"}) + + try: + # Use generating message template from YAML + generating_msg = PROMPTS["zero_shot"]["ui_messages"]["generating"] + chat_history.append({"role": "assistant", "content": generating_msg}) + + # Generate direct answer + answer = zero_shot_answer(query) + + # Format result message + result_msg = format_prompt( + PROMPTS["zero_shot"]["ui_messages"]["result"], + answer=answer + ) + chat_history.append({"role": "assistant", "content": result_msg}) + + # Save the results + save_path = save_results( + user_id=user_id, + query=query, + final_answer=answer, + method="zero_shot" + ) + + saved_msg = format_prompt( + PROMPTS["zero_shot"]["ui_messages"]["saved_result"], + save_path=save_path, + user_id=user_id + ) + chat_history.append({"role": "system", "content": saved_msg}) + + return chat_history + except Exception as e: + error_msg = format_prompt( + PROMPTS["zero_shot"]["ui_messages"]["error_general"], + error_message=str(e) + ) + print(error_msg) + return [ + {"role": "user", "content": f"Query: {query}"}, + {"role": "assistant", "content": "I encountered an error while generating a direct answer."}, + {"role": "system", "content": error_msg} + ] \ No newline at end of file