""" Phase 5: End-to-End System Testing for GAIA Agent Comprehensive test suite to validate the complete GAIA Agent system and ensure 90%+ accuracy. This test suite validates: 1. Complete workflow: Question โ†’ Processing โ†’ Tool Usage โ†’ Answer Extraction โ†’ Final Output 2. GAIA-style questions similar to evaluation scenarios 3. Performance benchmarking and reliability 4. Integration validation across all components 5. Edge case handling and error conditions Test Categories: - Mathematical Questions (Calculator and Python tools) - Knowledge Questions (Wikipedia and ArXiv tools) - Multimodal Questions (Image, audio, document processing) - Web Research Questions (Firecrawl and Exa tools) - File-Based Questions (Questions with attachments) - Complex Multi-Step Questions (Multiple tool usage) """ import pytest import sys import os import time import json import tempfile import logging from pathlib import Path from typing import Dict, List, Any, Optional from unittest.mock import Mock, patch # Add the deployment-ready directory to the path sys.path.insert(0, os.path.join(os.path.dirname(__file__), '..')) # Import the fixed enhanced agent from agents.fixed_enhanced_unified_agno_agent import FixedGAIAAgent # Set up logging for tests logging.basicConfig(level=logging.INFO) logger = logging.getLogger(__name__) class TestEndToEndComprehensive: """Comprehensive end-to-end test suite for the complete GAIA Agent system.""" @pytest.fixture(autouse=True) def setup_method(self): """Set up test fixtures before each test method.""" # Initialize the agent self.agent = FixedGAIAAgent() # Track test metrics self.test_metrics = { 'total_tests': 0, 'passed_tests': 0, 'failed_tests': 0, 'response_times': [], 'accuracy_scores': [], 'tool_usage_stats': {}, 'error_types': [] } # Performance thresholds self.max_response_time = 30.0 # 30 seconds max self.target_accuracy = 0.9 # 90% accuracy target logger.info("๐Ÿงช End-to-end test setup completed") def _measure_performance(self, test_func, *args, **kwargs): """Measure performance of a test function.""" start_time = time.time() try: result = test_func(*args, **kwargs) success = True error = None except Exception as e: result = None success = False error = str(e) end_time = time.time() response_time = end_time - start_time # Update metrics self.test_metrics['total_tests'] += 1 if success: self.test_metrics['passed_tests'] += 1 else: self.test_metrics['failed_tests'] += 1 self.test_metrics['error_types'].append(error) self.test_metrics['response_times'].append(response_time) return { 'result': result, 'success': success, 'response_time': response_time, 'error': error } def _validate_answer_format(self, answer: str, expected_type: str = None) -> bool: """Validate that the answer is properly formatted.""" if not answer or answer == "unknown": return False # Check for common formatting issues if answer.startswith("FINAL ANSWER:"): return False # Should be extracted, not raw format if len(answer.strip()) == 0: return False # Type-specific validation if expected_type == "numeric": try: # Should be a valid number without commas float(answer.replace(',', '')) return ',' not in answer # No commas in final answer except ValueError: return False return True def test_agent_initialization(self): """Test that the agent initializes correctly with all required components.""" # RED: Write failing test first assert self.agent is not None, "Agent should be initialized" assert self.agent.available, "Agent should be available" assert hasattr(self.agent, 'tools'), "Agent should have tools" assert hasattr(self.agent, 'response_processor'), "Agent should have response processor" assert hasattr(self.agent, 'file_handler'), "Agent should have file handler" # Verify minimum required tools assert len(self.agent.tools) >= 2, "Agent should have at least core tools (calculator, python)" logger.info(f"โœ… Agent initialized with {len(self.agent.tools)} tools") def test_mathematical_questions_basic(self): """Test basic mathematical questions using calculator tool.""" test_cases = [ { 'question': 'What is 25 * 17?', 'expected': '425', 'type': 'numeric' }, { 'question': 'What is 144 / 12?', 'expected': '12', 'type': 'numeric' }, { 'question': 'What is 2^8?', 'expected': '256', 'type': 'numeric' } ] for case in test_cases: performance = self._measure_performance( self._test_single_question, case['question'], case['expected'], case['type'] ) assert performance['success'], f"Mathematical test failed: {performance['error']}" assert performance['response_time'] < self.max_response_time, "Response too slow" logger.info(f"โœ… Math test passed: {case['question']} โ†’ {performance['result']}") def test_mathematical_questions_complex(self): """Test complex mathematical questions requiring Python tool.""" test_cases = [ { 'question': 'Calculate the factorial of 5', 'expected': '120', 'type': 'numeric' }, { 'question': 'What is the square root of 144?', 'expected': '12', 'type': 'numeric' }, { 'question': 'Calculate 15! / 13!', 'expected': '210', 'type': 'numeric' } ] for case in test_cases: performance = self._measure_performance( self._test_single_question, case['question'], case['expected'], case['type'] ) # Allow for some flexibility in complex math if performance['success']: logger.info(f"โœ… Complex math test passed: {case['question']} โ†’ {performance['result']}") else: logger.warning(f"โš ๏ธ Complex math test failed: {case['question']} - {performance['error']}") def test_knowledge_questions_wikipedia(self): """Test knowledge questions that should use Wikipedia tool.""" test_cases = [ { 'question': 'What is the capital of France?', 'expected': 'Paris', 'type': 'text' }, { 'question': 'In what year was the Eiffel Tower completed?', 'expected': '1889', 'type': 'numeric' } ] for case in test_cases: performance = self._measure_performance( self._test_single_question, case['question'], case['expected'], case['type'] ) if performance['success']: logger.info(f"โœ… Knowledge test passed: {case['question']} โ†’ {performance['result']}") else: logger.warning(f"โš ๏ธ Knowledge test failed: {case['question']} - {performance['error']}") def test_file_based_questions(self): """Test questions with file attachments.""" # Create test files test_files = self._create_test_files() test_cases = [ { 'question': 'What is the final numeric output from the attached Python code?', 'files': [test_files['python_code']], 'expected_type': 'numeric' }, { 'question': 'What is the sum of all numbers in the attached CSV file?', 'files': [test_files['csv_data']], 'expected_type': 'numeric' }, { 'question': 'What is the value of "result" in the attached JSON file?', 'files': [test_files['json_data']], 'expected_type': 'numeric' } ] for case in test_cases: performance = self._measure_performance( self._test_question_with_files, case['question'], case['files'], case['expected_type'] ) if performance['success']: logger.info(f"โœ… File-based test passed: {case['question']}") else: logger.warning(f"โš ๏ธ File-based test failed: {case['question']} - {performance['error']}") # Cleanup test files self._cleanup_test_files(test_files) def test_multimodal_questions(self): """Test multimodal questions (images, audio, documents).""" # Create test multimodal files test_files = self._create_multimodal_test_files() test_cases = [ { 'question': 'How many objects are in this image?', 'files': [test_files['test_image']], 'expected_type': 'numeric' }, { 'question': 'What is the main content of this document?', 'files': [test_files['test_document']], 'expected_type': 'text' } ] for case in test_cases: performance = self._measure_performance( self._test_question_with_files, case['question'], case['files'], case['expected_type'] ) if performance['success']: logger.info(f"โœ… Multimodal test passed: {case['question']}") else: logger.warning(f"โš ๏ธ Multimodal test failed: {case['question']} - {performance['error']}") # Cleanup test files self._cleanup_test_files(test_files) def test_web_research_questions(self): """Test web research questions using Firecrawl and Exa tools.""" test_cases = [ { 'question': 'What is the current population of Tokyo?', 'expected_type': 'numeric' }, { 'question': 'Who is the current CEO of Microsoft?', 'expected_type': 'text' } ] for case in test_cases: performance = self._measure_performance( self._test_single_question, case['question'], None, # No expected answer for web research case['expected_type'] ) if performance['success']: logger.info(f"โœ… Web research test passed: {case['question']}") else: logger.warning(f"โš ๏ธ Web research test failed: {case['question']} - {performance['error']}") def test_complex_multistep_questions(self): """Test complex questions requiring multiple tools.""" test_cases = [ { 'question': 'Calculate the square root of 144, then find information about that number in mathematics', 'expected_type': 'text' }, { 'question': 'What is 25 * 17, and what is the significance of that number?', 'expected_type': 'text' } ] for case in test_cases: performance = self._measure_performance( self._test_single_question, case['question'], None, # Complex questions may have varied answers case['expected_type'] ) if performance['success']: logger.info(f"โœ… Complex test passed: {case['question']}") else: logger.warning(f"โš ๏ธ Complex test failed: {case['question']} - {performance['error']}") def test_edge_cases_and_error_handling(self): """Test edge cases and error handling.""" edge_cases = [ { 'question': '', # Empty question 'should_handle_gracefully': True }, { 'question': 'What is the answer to a question that makes no sense?', 'should_handle_gracefully': True }, { 'question': 'Calculate the square root of -1', # Mathematical impossibility 'should_handle_gracefully': True } ] for case in edge_cases: performance = self._measure_performance( self._test_edge_case, case['question'] ) # Edge cases should be handled gracefully, not crash if case['should_handle_gracefully']: assert performance['result'] is not None, "Edge case should return some result" logger.info(f"โœ… Edge case handled: {case['question']}") def test_gaia_style_evaluation_questions(self): """Test questions similar to GAIA evaluation scenarios.""" gaia_style_questions = [ { 'question': 'How many studio albums were published by Mercedes Sosa between 2000 and 2009?', 'expected_type': 'numeric', 'requires_tools': ['wikipedia'] }, { 'question': 'What is the highest number of bird species to be on camera simultaneously?', 'expected_type': 'numeric', 'requires_tools': ['web_search'] }, { 'question': 'In chess, what is the minimum number of moves required for checkmate?', 'expected_type': 'numeric', 'requires_tools': ['wikipedia'] } ] for case in gaia_style_questions: performance = self._measure_performance( self._test_single_question, case['question'], None, # GAIA questions have specific answers we'd need to verify case['expected_type'] ) if performance['success']: logger.info(f"โœ… GAIA-style test passed: {case['question']}") self.test_metrics['accuracy_scores'].append(1.0) else: logger.warning(f"โš ๏ธ GAIA-style test failed: {case['question']} - {performance['error']}") self.test_metrics['accuracy_scores'].append(0.0) def test_performance_benchmarks(self): """Test performance benchmarks and system reliability.""" # Test response time consistency question = "What is 100 * 50?" response_times = [] for i in range(5): performance = self._measure_performance( self._test_single_question, question, "5000", "numeric" ) response_times.append(performance['response_time']) # Check response time consistency avg_response_time = sum(response_times) / len(response_times) max_response_time = max(response_times) assert avg_response_time < self.max_response_time, f"Average response time too high: {avg_response_time}" assert max_response_time < self.max_response_time * 1.5, f"Max response time too high: {max_response_time}" logger.info(f"โœ… Performance benchmark passed - Avg: {avg_response_time:.2f}s, Max: {max_response_time:.2f}s") def test_system_integration_validation(self): """Test that all system components work together seamlessly.""" # Test processor statistics stats = self.agent.get_processor_statistics() assert isinstance(stats, dict), "Processor should return statistics" # Test tool status tool_status = self.agent.get_tool_status() assert isinstance(tool_status, dict), "Agent should return tool status" # Test file handler capabilities file_formats = self.agent.file_handler.get_supported_formats() assert len(file_formats) > 0, "File handler should support some formats" logger.info("โœ… System integration validation passed") def _test_single_question(self, question: str, expected: str = None, expected_type: str = None) -> str: """Test a single question and return the result.""" if not self.agent.available: pytest.skip("Agent not available for testing") result = self.agent(question) # Validate answer format assert self._validate_answer_format(result, expected_type), f"Invalid answer format: '{result}'" # If expected answer provided, check for exact match or reasonable similarity if expected: if expected_type == "numeric": # For numeric answers, allow for minor variations try: result_num = float(result.replace(',', '')) expected_num = float(expected.replace(',', '')) assert abs(result_num - expected_num) < 0.01, f"Expected {expected}, got {result}" except ValueError: assert result.lower() == expected.lower(), f"Expected {expected}, got {result}" else: # For text answers, allow case-insensitive comparison assert result.lower() == expected.lower(), f"Expected {expected}, got {result}" return result def _test_question_with_files(self, question: str, files: List[str], expected_type: str = None) -> str: """Test a question with file attachments.""" if not self.agent.available: pytest.skip("Agent not available for testing") result = self.agent(question, files) # Validate answer format assert self._validate_answer_format(result, expected_type), f"Invalid answer format: '{result}'" return result def _test_edge_case(self, question: str) -> str: """Test an edge case question.""" if not self.agent.available: pytest.skip("Agent not available for testing") # Edge cases should not crash try: result = self.agent(question) return result except Exception as e: # Log the error but don't fail the test - edge cases should be handled gracefully logger.warning(f"Edge case caused exception: {e}") return "unknown" def _create_test_files(self) -> Dict[str, str]: """Create test files for file-based questions.""" test_files = {} # Create Python code file python_code = """ # Test Python code def calculate(): result = 25 * 17 return result if __name__ == "__main__": answer = calculate() print(f"The result is: {answer}") """ python_file = tempfile.NamedTemporaryFile(mode='w', suffix='.py', delete=False) python_file.write(python_code) python_file.close() test_files['python_code'] = python_file.name # Create CSV data file csv_data = """name,value,category item1,10,A item2,20,B item3,30,A item4,40,B """ csv_file = tempfile.NamedTemporaryFile(mode='w', suffix='.csv', delete=False) csv_file.write(csv_data) csv_file.close() test_files['csv_data'] = csv_file.name # Create JSON data file json_data = { "result": 425, "calculation": "25 * 17", "metadata": { "timestamp": "2024-01-01", "version": "1.0" } } json_file = tempfile.NamedTemporaryFile(mode='w', suffix='.json', delete=False) json.dump(json_data, json_file) json_file.close() test_files['json_data'] = json_file.name return test_files def _create_multimodal_test_files(self) -> Dict[str, str]: """Create test files for multimodal questions.""" test_files = {} # Create a simple text file representing an image description image_desc = "This is a test image description file representing an image with 3 objects: a cat, a dog, and a bird." image_file = tempfile.NamedTemporaryFile(mode='w', suffix='.txt', delete=False) image_file.write(image_desc) image_file.close() test_files['test_image'] = image_file.name # Create a document file document_content = """ Test Document This is a test document for multimodal processing. The main content discusses artificial intelligence and machine learning. Key points: 1. AI is transforming industries 2. Machine learning enables automation 3. Natural language processing improves communication Conclusion: Technology continues to advance rapidly. """ doc_file = tempfile.NamedTemporaryFile(mode='w', suffix='.txt', delete=False) doc_file.write(document_content) doc_file.close() test_files['test_document'] = doc_file.name return test_files def _cleanup_test_files(self, test_files: Dict[str, str]): """Clean up test files.""" for file_path in test_files.values(): try: os.unlink(file_path) except OSError: pass # File already deleted or doesn't exist def test_final_system_validation(self): """Final validation test to ensure system meets all requirements.""" # Calculate overall metrics total_tests = self.test_metrics['total_tests'] passed_tests = self.test_metrics['passed_tests'] if total_tests > 0: accuracy = passed_tests / total_tests avg_response_time = sum(self.test_metrics['response_times']) / len(self.test_metrics['response_times']) logger.info(f"๐Ÿ“Š Final System Metrics:") logger.info(f" Total Tests: {total_tests}") logger.info(f" Passed Tests: {passed_tests}") logger.info(f" Accuracy: {accuracy:.2%}") logger.info(f" Average Response Time: {avg_response_time:.2f}s") # Validate against success criteria assert accuracy >= self.target_accuracy, f"Accuracy {accuracy:.2%} below target {self.target_accuracy:.2%}" assert avg_response_time < self.max_response_time, f"Average response time {avg_response_time:.2f}s above limit" logger.info("โœ… System validation passed - Ready for GAIA evaluation!") else: logger.warning("โš ๏ธ No tests were executed for final validation") if __name__ == "__main__": # Run the comprehensive test suite pytest.main([__file__, "-v", "--tb=short"])